rec.autos.simulators

N4 - Chassis'... Difference?

James Pickar

N4 - Chassis'... Difference?

by James Pickar » Thu, 07 Jun 2001 21:30:44

Just wondering, is there any difference between the different chassis in
N4???

Is there any different in handling between them..?

James

Cliff Roma

N4 - Chassis'... Difference?

by Cliff Roma » Thu, 07 Jun 2001 21:38:32

No, they are all identical


Andre Warrin

N4 - Chassis'... Difference?

by Andre Warrin » Thu, 07 Jun 2001 22:37:05



Stupid question, but is that also the case in real life?
In GPL each car feels totally different, why not in N4 I wonder..

Andre



>> Just wondering, is there any difference between the different chassis in
>> N4???

>> Is there any different in handling between them..?

>> James

Cliff Roma

N4 - Chassis'... Difference?

by Cliff Roma » Thu, 07 Jun 2001 23:00:39

In real life there are DEFINITELY differences between the different car
makes.  In fact, they even have different rules they have to follow.

In N3 they had Chassis 1, 2 and 3 (which were assumed to mean the different
makes) and they did have differences in the game.

In N4 they paid for the license to use the actual design and names of the
car makes. Chevy, Ford, Pontiac and Dodge.   My guess would be that they are
not actually different in the game as far as performance goes for a few
reasons.

The main one is that I imagine that the actual manufacturers wanted them to
all be the same.   Imagine if they were different and the Ford chassis in
the game was known to be the best and Pontiac was known to be the worst by
the avid gamers.   I do not think that Pontiac would like that.  So to avoid
all of that, they probably just made them the same.

Another reason would be that the car makes are constantly changing.  Chevy
gets a change here and Ford gets a change there... rules are changed which
causes performance to change, etc...   No way to keep up with that.  Another
reason to just make them all the same.




> >No, they are all identical

> Stupid question, but is that also the case in real life?
> In GPL each car feels totally different, why not in N4 I wonder..

> Andre



> >> Just wondering, is there any difference between the different chassis
in
> >> N4???

> >> Is there any different in handling between them..?

> >> James

Marc Fraio

N4 - Chassis'... Difference?

by Marc Fraio » Fri, 08 Jun 2001 03:58:36





>>No, they are all identical

> Stupid question, but is that also the case in real life?
> In GPL each car feels totally different, why not in N4 I wonder..

A little while back I saw some NASCAR crew chief being interviewed on TV.
His team had just announced that it was switching manufacturers, Pontiac
to Ford, or Chevy to Dodge, or some such thing, I don't remember.  Anyway,
the reporter asked him when he expected to take delivery of the new cars.
The crew chief looked surprised and then explained that there were no
new cars; they were just going to keep using the same cars they had used
before, but with new body panels.  They're all the same.

Oh, and the headlights and radiator grilles are stickers.

        Marc

Jonny Hodgso

N4 - Chassis'... Difference?

by Jonny Hodgso » Fri, 08 Jun 2001 07:56:17


Sounds exactly like R/C touring cars... ;-)

Seriously though, the body is a major aero tuning aid.  /All/ the top
guys seem to run an Andy's (a bodyshell manufacturer) Dodge Stratus.

Jonny

Dave Henri

N4 - Chassis'... Difference?

by Dave Henri » Fri, 08 Jun 2001 11:17:01

  Got any pictures?  I love the Super Touring Stratus!
ok...here is a slightly different explanation.
  The chassis are generic.   The same chassis could be under a Dodge skin,
or a Chevy etc...  But the body shapes DO make a difference in the
aerodynamics.   And to try and equalize them, Nascar has made each
manufacturer use slightly different pieces...the Ford & Dodge have the same
rear spoiler and front splitter but the Dodge has a slightly draggier hood
flap.  The chev's and pontiacs each get some bonus' concerning how high or
low the front splitter and rear spoiler are.   The reason is to try and make
the windtunnel numbers equal so no one car make has an advantage.  So YES
the cars are different, but Nascar tries to legislate them back to equality.
If your making a sim...save yourself some time and make the cars all the
same.
  Back to the chassis.  Some teams build thier own, some buy them, many of
the Dodges are running on top of chassis that ran Pontiac's last year.
Depending on the type of track they run at, alot of teams will have several
different brands of chassis' to run better on short tracks or
superspeedways.  Just because Jeff Gordon's car has the same paint job week
to week, doesn't mean you are seeing the same car at each event.
  That is one big difference from say Touring Cars.  If I gather correctly,
you submit a car at the start of the year and you must run that car/chassis
etc for the whole season.(barring catatrophic wrecks of course)
  Does that help?  Or have I just muddled things up more (as usual)
dave henrie



> > A little while back I saw some NASCAR crew chief being interviewed
> on TV.
> > His team had just announced that it was switching manufacturers,
> Pontiac
> > to Ford, or Chevy to Dodge, or some such thing, I don't remember.
> Anyway,
> > the reporter asked him when he expected to take delivery of the new
> cars.
> > The crew chief looked surprised and then explained that there were
> no
> > new cars; they were just going to keep using the same cars they had
> used
> > before, but with new body panels.  They're all the same.

> > Oh, and the headlights and radiator grilles are stickers.

> Sounds exactly like R/C touring cars... ;-)

> Seriously though, the body is a major aero tuning aid.  /All/ the top
> guys seem to run an Andy's (a bodyshell manufacturer) Dodge Stratus.

> Jonny

Eldre

N4 - Chassis'... Difference?

by Eldre » Fri, 08 Jun 2001 13:02:57



>>A little while back I saw some NASCAR crew chief being interviewed on =
>TV.
>>His team had just announced that it was switching manufacturers, Pontiac
>>to Ford, or Chevy to Dodge, or some such thing, I don't remember.  =
>Anyway,
>>the reporter asked him when he expected to take delivery of the new =
>cars.
>>The crew chief looked surprised and then explained that there were no
>>new cars; they were just going to keep using the same cars they had used
>>before, but with new body panels.  They're all the same.

>LOL!.
>You know nothing about NASCAR.
>They are NOT the same.

Well, he said he SAW it in tv, from a source that you'd *think* should know - a
NASCAR crew chief.  

The Chevy/Ford/whatever aren't THAT different, come on now...<g>

Eldred
--
Dale Earnhardt, Sr. R.I.P. 1951-2001
Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett
F1 hcp. +20.90...F2 +151.26...

Never argue with an idiot.  He brings you down to his level, then beats you
with experience...
Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.

Michael Basde

N4 - Chassis'... Difference?

by Michael Basde » Fri, 08 Jun 2001 11:52:36

Now who is showing their ignorance?

Each series, whether it be NASCAR Winston Cup, Busch or even ARCA or ASA can
all use the same "CHASSIS" between manufacturers!  (This is what helps to
make racing more affordable.)  By manufacturers I mean their engine/body
manufacturer (i.e Dodge , GM, Ford, Pontiac) The differences come with the
body and engine regulations/designs.  This is what affects the aerodynamics
packages and power/torque.  The chassis themselves are fabricated pieces
that don't give a rats-ass who's manufacturers nameplate is on them.  So in
the context of the interview Andre was referring to, he is absolutely RIGHT
and you are absolutely WRONG!!

Having said that, there are different manufacturers for chassis' as well.
Many teams build their own in-house, others choose to purchase them.
Hopkins, and Laughlin are two of the most popular 'brands' of chassis' in
WC, Busch, and ARCA.  Someone buying a chassis can specify what kind of
chassis they want (Superspeedway, Speedway, Short track or Road Course) and
even make more specific requirements for it (i.e drop snout with a lowered
left rail etc...).  So while the chassis may not be identical between
competitors on any given Sunday, they are interchangeable )and for all
intensive purposes identical) between engine manufacturers.

I hope this helps clear the mud some people caused.

Regards,
Mike Basden
(Former ARCA Crew Chief and Craftsman Truck crew member)








>>>No, they are all identical

>> Stupid question, but is that also the case in real life?
>> In GPL each car feels totally different, why not in N4 I wonder..

>A little while back I saw some NASCAR crew chief being interviewed on TV.
>His team had just announced that it was switching manufacturers, Pontiac
>to Ford, or Chevy to Dodge, or some such thing, I don't remember.  Anyway,
>the reporter asked him when he expected to take delivery of the new cars.
>The crew chief looked surprised and then explained that there were no
>new cars; they were just going to keep using the same cars they had used
>before, but with new body panels.  They're all the same.

LOL!.
You know nothing about NASCAR.
They are NOT the same.

Take a Square body stlye and race it verse a car with an arrow body
style.
Which one do u think will win?

Marc Fraio

N4 - Chassis'... Difference?

by Marc Fraio » Sat, 09 Jun 2001 03:27:13









>>>=20
>>>>No, they are all identical
>>>=20
>>> Stupid question, but is that also the case in real life?
>>> In GPL each car feels totally different, why not in N4 I wonder..

>>A little while back I saw some NASCAR crew chief being interviewed on =
> TV.
>>His team had just announced that it was switching manufacturers, Pontiac
>>to Ford, or Chevy to Dodge, or some such thing, I don't remember.  =
> Anyway,
>>the reporter asked him when he expected to take delivery of the new =
> cars.
>>The crew chief looked surprised and then explained that there were no
>>new cars; they were just going to keep using the same cars they had used
>>before, but with new body panels.  They're all the same.

> LOL!.
> You know nothing about NASCAR.
> They are NOT the same.

> Take a Square body stlye and race it verse a car with an arrow body
> style.
> Which one do u think will win?

Ok, I guess others have already responded to this pretty well, but basically
the points as I see them are:

1) True, I don't know much about NASCAR, although I wouldn't say it's nothing.
2) In this context, it doesn't matter what *I* know, because I'm just reporting
   what someone who does know said.
3) A body is not a chassis.  When I said "car" I suppose I should have said
   "chassis", but the crew chief on TV said "car" so I stayed with his usage.
   He's the one who knows about NASCAR after all, right?

And the headlights and radiator grilles are still stickers.

        Marc

Aitc

N4 - Chassis'... Difference?

by Aitc » Sat, 09 Jun 2001 05:57:26


: Ok, I guess others have already responded to this pretty well, but
basically
: the points as I see them are:

: 1) True, I don't know much about NASCAR, although I wouldn't say it's
nothing.

You made a discovery!

: 3) A body is not a chassis.  When I said "car" I suppose I should have
said
:    "chassis", but the crew chief on TV said "car" so I stayed with his
usage.
:    He's the one who knows about NASCAR after all, right?

For those of us who know. We know what you mean.

 Everyone having the same chassis style, that's Nascar's decision for parity
between the makes. It is cheaper, and it makes it more controllable and
easier for them to police.

: And the headlights and radiator grilles are still stickers.

Actually, the radiator grilles are real. They use a fine mesh for the brake
ducts and radiator grilles.
The headlights and tail-lights are stickers though.

Jonny Hodgso

N4 - Chassis'... Difference?

by Jonny Hodgso » Sat, 09 Jun 2001 02:49:08


Some general TC pictures are on www.brca.org

HPI, including bodyshells (190mm are the usual ones):
www.hpiracing.com

You can probably find some pics of "readers' rides" by lurking on
rec.models.rc.land and following homepage links, too...

Jonny


rec.autos.simulators is a usenet newsgroup formed in December, 1993. As this group was always unmoderated there may be some spam or off topic articles included. Some links do point back to racesimcentral.net as we could not validate the original address. Please report any pages that you believe warrant deletion from this archive (include the link in your email). RaceSimCentral.net is in no way responsible and does not endorse any of the content herein.