rec.autos.simulators

Converted GTR racks in rFactor

Scott B. Huste

Converted GTR racks in rFactor

by Scott B. Huste » Sat, 12 Nov 2005 13:43:05




>>Maybe I'm missing something here.. but how exactly is ISI limiting rFactor
>>with censorship and stifling community involvement?

> The boards-- folks can't say what they want to say, as if somehow ISI, etc.,
> is afraid of open discussion.

> The track conversion thing-- why doesn't ISI, etc., just leave it be.  In
> the end, if they are more open and receptive and not so darn tight, the
> community will grow faster.

> That's my take.

> Alanb

rFactor is the most open release ever made.  I don't see how ISI is
doing anything but encouraging community involvement.

You do realize ISI and Simbin are not the same organization don't you?

--
Scott B. Husted
http://www.racesimcentral.net/

Dave Henri

Converted GTR racks in rFactor

by Dave Henri » Sat, 12 Nov 2005 14:12:27



  I understand Richards Burns is a good title...happy simming.

dave henrie

Bruce Kennewel

Converted GTR racks in rFactor

by Bruce Kennewel » Sat, 12 Nov 2005 15:15:03

That is a specious argument at best and does nothing to counter the fact
that what ISI have done/are doing is completely legal and what you have
done/are doing is completely illegal.

You can try and justify your pathetic actions and approach any way you like
but it doesn't alter the fact that you are a thief who is preaching theft.

BK


Steve Whitt

Converted GTR racks in rFactor

by Steve Whitt » Sat, 12 Nov 2005 15:35:36




>> Maybe I'm missing something here.. but how exactly is ISI limiting
>> rFactor with censorship and stifling community involvement?

> The boards-- folks can't say what they want to say, as if somehow ISI,
> etc., is afraid of open discussion.

> The track conversion thing-- why doesn't ISI, etc., just leave it be.  In
> the end, if they are more open and receptive and not so darn tight, the
> community will grow faster.

> That's my take.

> Alanb

ISI can't actively support conversions of commercial tracks and cars without
dropping themselves into lots of deep legal crap.

as for support. drop one of the dev's an email or pm through the forums if
you have a problem.  as they work their way through them all, they'll answer
when they can.  they're actively in the forums helping out with issues that
people post.

but you can't keep everyone happy.  I respect your view that you aren't
happy with them.  but thats your opinion and you're entitled to it.  its
different to mine, but doesn't make either of us right :)

cheers

steve

Byron Forbe

Converted GTR racks in rFactor

by Byron Forbe » Sat, 12 Nov 2005 23:48:51


   Yes, imagine the hide stiffing a wonderful, honest bunch like Simbin -
how can people live with themselves. Everyone knows they have that perfect
multiplay they worked oh so ***.

Byron Forbe

Converted GTR racks in rFactor

by Byron Forbe » Sat, 12 Nov 2005 23:53:07


..........but not on GTR tracks he's already payed for....................

Byron Forbe

Converted GTR racks in rFactor

by Byron Forbe » Sat, 12 Nov 2005 23:58:33




>> Maybe I'm missing something here.. but how exactly is ISI limiting
>> rFactor with censorship and stifling community involvement?

> The boards-- folks can't say what they want to say, as if somehow ISI,
> etc., is afraid of open discussion.

> The track conversion thing-- why doesn't ISI, etc., just leave it be.  In
> the end, if they are more open and receptive and not so darn tight, the
> community will grow faster.

> That's my take.

> Alanb

    Yep, why ISI and RSC don't do all they can to publically promote illegal
activity is a total mystery. Wouldn't you think they'd drag their fat lazy
arses off their beds of nails and get the ball rolling on this! Just
incredible! <shaking head>
Byron Forbe

Converted GTR racks in rFactor

by Byron Forbe » Sun, 13 Nov 2005 00:05:31

    Spoken like a true dago Bruce - Mario would be proud of you! :)


> That is a specious argument at best and does nothing to counter the fact
> that what ISI have done/are doing is completely legal and what you have
> done/are doing is completely illegal.

> You can try and justify your pathetic actions and approach any way you
> like
> but it doesn't alter the fact that you are a thief who is preaching theft.

> BK



>> I tout no rules.  I own GTR, GTL, and rFactor, and if you ask me ISI is
> only
>> concerned about CASH.  If they'd think a bit and would be kind to their
>> BUYING CUSTOMERS, maybe they'd get some respect otherwise....etc

Alan Bernard

Converted GTR racks in rFactor

by Alan Bernard » Sun, 13 Nov 2005 00:07:23


I own all three games.  I didn't say a thing about the legality of the
issue.  ISI can do what it wants.  What I said was that I don't think ISI is
doing the wise thing if they want to support community involvement and
continue to make its customers pleased, which is only good for them.  It's
the old shooting themselves in the foot or the nose-face deal.

Alanb

Scott B. Huste

Converted GTR racks in rFactor

by Scott B. Huste » Sun, 13 Nov 2005 00:54:43




>>That is a specious argument at best and does nothing to counter the fact
>>that what ISI have done/are doing is completely legal and what you have
>>done/are doing is completely illegal.

> I own all three games.  I didn't say a thing about the legality of the
> issue.  ISI can do what it wants.  What I said was that I don't think ISI is
> doing the wise thing if they want to support community involvement and
> continue to make its customers pleased, which is only good for them.  It's
> the old shooting themselves in the foot or the nose-face deal.

> Alanb

Well you are saying they should do whatever it takes to make the
community happy on one side, then on the other you say you didn't say
anything about the legality (it's illegal)...   So you are saying that
ISI should break the law in order to please the community because it's
good for them in the long run?

I'm still confused on why you are mad at ISI for not helping "the
community" steal SimBin's tracks?   *scratches head*

The fact remains ISI has produced a sim with the most open architecture
this community has ever seen. They are working on tools to help the mod
community make items for their sim.  I think ISI has done the most, by
far, of any developer in sim racing to promote their sim through
community involvement and development.

--
Scott B. Husted
http://www.Husted.cc

Mitch_

Converted GTR racks in rFactor

by Mitch_ » Sun, 13 Nov 2005 01:34:24

The problem is that youre using logic and common sense Scott.  When you see
a guy arguing with a Stop sign you have a pretty good indication that the
conversation isn't going very far :)

Mitch


Well you are saying they should do whatever it takes to make the

Alan Bernard

Converted GTR racks in rFactor

by Alan Bernard » Sun, 13 Nov 2005 02:16:06


You're probably right [Stop].  The only thing is that I don't think they
should sweat it.  It's not like they are losing cash.  Let it be and be easy
and allow it.  That way the community doesn't have the feeling that ISI is
only about the money, which will stop others, in the long run, from
purchasing an ISI product in the future.  I think that by getting all out of
sorts because of this track thing is just not a good PR move: let things be
and move on.  Heck, if they would've been a little proactive ISI could've
charged a small fee for the conversions and done it themselves.  I think
most would pay five bills a track to get these into rFactor and all would've
been fine and settled.

Alanb

Chad Roger

Converted GTR racks in rFactor

by Chad Roger » Sun, 13 Nov 2005 03:18:56

Again Lord Byron has to bring GTR multi into a track conversion talk, way to
go!!

As for ISI/Simbin allowing tracks from one to another, you are living in
fantasy land.  They are competitors, perhaps you don't understand business
real well.  Remember, these guys actually have a job and need to earn a
living right?




>> OH I see, this group touts the rules when it suits them, but wham bam
>> when they need something,***the rules. Thats why sim racing has
>> declined to its current state. I am ashamed at you, Alan

>   Yes, imagine the hide stiffing a wonderful, honest bunch like Simbin -
> how can people live with themselves. Everyone knows they have that perfect
> multiplay they worked oh so ***.

cosmo_kram..

Converted GTR racks in rFactor

by cosmo_kram.. » Sun, 13 Nov 2005 03:49:38

Hahaha,

Yeah, ISI should just charge a small fee and sell Simbin's tracks.
Excellent idea!  I'm sure Simbin wont mind...

Now, I do own GTR (and GTL), so I'm not going to feel guilty about
installing these converted tracks if I can d/l them, but your argument
against ISI seems WAY OFF BASE!  They have done everything (legally)
that they can to make rFactor as open to modding as they can - but you
are expecting them to cross the line of legality and actively promote
stealing another company's products...  If you want to criticize Simbin
for not giving away their tracks, then go ahead (Although I think that
criticism is ridiculous also!).

The more I read your posts, the more I keep wondering if you realize
that SImbin and ISI are two completely seperate companies -- and in
many ways competitors.  You probably need to understand that fact
before continuing your argument...

CK

Alan Bernard

Converted GTR racks in rFactor

by Alan Bernard » Sun, 13 Nov 2005 03:52:24


I meant SimBin.  I know they are different.  :)

Alanb


rec.autos.simulators is a usenet newsgroup formed in December, 1993. As this group was always unmoderated there may be some spam or off topic articles included. Some links do point back to racesimcentral.net as we could not validate the original address. Please report any pages that you believe warrant deletion from this archive (include the link in your email). RaceSimCentral.net is in no way responsible and does not endorse any of the content herein.