rec.autos.simulators

N4 AI

BCla

N4 AI

by BCla » Sat, 28 Apr 2001 20:51:40

I'm sure that if N4 was meant to be an online game only, then there wouldn't
be any AI at all. So, if it's broke then they should listen and fix it. It's
sad to pay the money we did for half a game.


BCla

N4 AI

by BCla » Sat, 28 Apr 2001 21:12:55

God forbid I say this... Nascar Heat has a helluva lot better AI. If N4 had
NH's AI, it would be great. (People do buy the sim with intentions of racing
OFFLINE.) The online community is not the majority here, as some would like
to believe, it's just that the majority that buy the game don't know of
r.a.s. or other newsgroups to voice thier concerns. There probably has been
a few hundred thousand N4 games sold already. Hmmm, I don't see that many
online or in the newsgroups. I guess it's the old saying coming to
mind..."The squeeky wheel gets the grease." I say this because most of the
people here that look for a honest answer get barraged by the Papy loyalists
for even asking for fixes or adding things like a savegame feature. Their
past products had it, why not this one? I think that N4 is a great sim but
it still has bugs that need to be fixed. Even after this latest patch it
still does have some issues, but the majority of the bugs were squashed. If
they fix these remaining issues the game will be better for most but not
all. Remember that there are others that feel that the sim should have had
more and others that would have been happy with just online racing and no
AI. But the fact is, it does have offline racing and should be enjoyable for
those that choose to have it their way.


Larr

N4 AI

by Larr » Sat, 28 Apr 2001 22:30:54

Wouldn't it be cool if they programmed it th LEARN from what WE do on the
track ?

I realize that this would be a handicap for some online racers  :)

-Larry


> Yeah, they can be a little wimpy at times. But hey, I don't think the day
> will ever come anyone can program an ai to replicate actual human
behaviour.
> Until they can, then we'll always find weaknesses in the ai. That's why I
> love online racing.

> --
> Don Burnette
> D Burnette in N4

> Some people do nothing wrong.
> The problem is, they do nothing.
> And THAT is wrong.



> > Its ok but it seems like the AI let you away with way too much stuff,
they
> > try way too much to get outta your way. :(



> > > I have to disagree, imho. I have had hours of great fun with N4, both
> > online
> > > and offline. The key to online is finding good races, making friends,
> > > joining a league, etc. Offline is learning the ai behaviour and
dealing
> > with
> > > it. And now that the patch has been released, it is much better.

> > > --
> > > Don Burnette
> > > D Burnette in N4

> > > Some people do nothing wrong.
> > > The problem is, they do nothing.
> > > And THAT is wrong.



> > > > Horrible, worthless, waste of time.

> > > > Plus there is no save race feature, meaning you can't run a complete
> > race
> > > > unless you have 3 hours to sit in front of your PC - and even then
> there
> > > is
> > > > no way to save your place before the AI decides to kamikaze you into
> the
> > > > wall. Hell, you can't even pause and alt-tab back to the desktop for
a
> > > > moment without the screen freaking out.

> > > > Unless you plan on racing multiplayer, there is no racing in N4. And
> the
> > > > multiplayer is almost as bad as the AI in most cases. Occasionally
you
> > can
> > > > find a good race (no morons) on a good server, but rarely.

> > > > Like GPL, N4 is fun to drive, but that's about it. I think of it
more
> as
> > a
> > > > driving simulator than a racing simulator, and driving around in
> circles
> > > > gets old quick. If theuspits (Noonan) can do a 'Ring conversion then
> it
> > > > might be worth the space on the hard drive.



> > > > > In reading the user reviews from a few websites about the game, a
> > > > > complaint I see a lot is of horrible AI.  The demo doesn't let you
> > race
> > > > > against other cars, so I can't attest to this myself.  For those
of
> > you
> > > > > who have it, how good/bad is it?
> > > > > --
> > > > > Scott Lyman
> > > > > ICQ 88979227

Andre Warrin

N4 AI

by Andre Warrin » Sat, 28 Apr 2001 22:46:08


<snip>

Are you talking about the N4 AI -after- the patch? I must admit it's
been a while since I played NH and I can't really remember what the AI
was like, but the N4 patch improved the AI a LOT!

I did a 100-lap race at Bristol last night against 43 AI, imho the
ultimate AI test with all that close racing :)
During that race I causes one collision and the AI caused two
collisions, in a realistic way that is.
Unpatched N4's AI would ram me off the road, but yesterday they were
very carefull, maintaining their line when I was passing them.
I agree that the AI is now a tad too polite, but a 'perfect' AI has
yet to be made for a racing sim and so far I'm having a very good time
racing against N4's AI.

Ofcourse there will be lots of situations where the AI reacts stupid,
it will never be perfect, but the patch improved the AI (and lots of
other things too!) more than I ever expected!

Andre

BCla

N4 AI

by BCla » Sun, 29 Apr 2001 05:46:07

Post patch, the AI are much better but still have some bugs. Try a green
flag start at Daytona or California, the only two super speedways I tried so
far, and see what happens. I had 3 cars at both tracks dive down to the
grass at Cal. and the same for Daytona.

Why don't the AI try to stay in your draft or try to follow you to stay in
the draft? I understand if you are out in front and have to drive with the
mirror to stay there, but if I change my line, why don't the AI follow that
line? Nascar Heat already does this. If this is possible in N4, I wish there
would be a way to turn it on.

Don't get me wrong. I'd rather race N4 than Heat, but the AI in Heat is
still better.

Don Burnett

N4 AI

by Don Burnett » Sun, 29 Apr 2001 07:56:45

I didn't fine Heat's ai very realistic at all. I got nailed by them during
yellows and going down pit road, almost every time. When they didn't fix
that problem with the first patch was when I uninstalled it. I also found it
pretty unrealistic that I could plow through the ai and none of us wreck.
For instance, squeeze between two cars where there isn't room, and shove
them both aside.
No matter, it appears that programming the ai with the 6dof physics is
pretty complicated as both Heat and N4 have had problems with it. For me
personally, I preferred N4's over Heat.

--
Don Burnette
D Burnette in N4

Some people do nothing wrong.
The problem is, they do nothing.
And THAT is wrong.


> God forbid I say this... Nascar Heat has a helluva lot better AI. If N4
had
> NH's AI, it would be great. (People do buy the sim with intentions of
racing
> OFFLINE.) The online community is not the majority here, as some would
like
> to believe, it's just that the majority that buy the game don't know of
> r.a.s. or other newsgroups to voice thier concerns. There probably has
been
> a few hundred thousand N4 games sold already. Hmmm, I don't see that many
> online or in the newsgroups. I guess it's the old saying coming to
> mind..."The squeeky wheel gets the grease." I say this because most of the
> people here that look for a honest answer get barraged by the Papy
loyalists
> for even asking for fixes or adding things like a savegame feature. Their
> past products had it, why not this one? I think that N4 is a great sim but
> it still has bugs that need to be fixed. Even after this latest patch it
> still does have some issues, but the majority of the bugs were squashed.
If
> they fix these remaining issues the game will be better for most but not
> all. Remember that there are others that feel that the sim should have had
> more and others that would have been happy with just online racing and no
> AI. But the fact is, it does have offline racing and should be enjoyable
for
> those that choose to have it their way.



> > Yeah, they can be a little wimpy at times. But hey, I don't think the
day
> > will ever come anyone can program an ai to replicate actual human
> behaviour.
> > Until they can, then we'll always find weaknesses in the ai. That's why
I
> > love online racing.

boredU

N4 AI

by boredU » Sun, 29 Apr 2001 08:10:38

Did you try the second patch? I dont remember where I got it.


> I didn't fine Heat's ai very realistic at all. I got nailed by them during
> yellows and going down pit road, almost every time. When they didn't fix
> that problem with the first patch was when I uninstalled it. I also found
it
> pretty unrealistic that I could plow through the ai and none of us wreck.
> For instance, squeeze between two cars where there isn't room, and shove
> them both aside.
> No matter, it appears that programming the ai with the 6dof physics is
> pretty complicated as both Heat and N4 have had problems with it. For me
> personally, I preferred N4's over Heat.

> --
> Don Burnette
> D Burnette in N4

> Some people do nothing wrong.
> The problem is, they do nothing.
> And THAT is wrong.



> > God forbid I say this... Nascar Heat has a helluva lot better AI. If N4
> had
> > NH's AI, it would be great. (People do buy the sim with intentions of
> racing
> > OFFLINE.) The online community is not the majority here, as some would
> like
> > to believe, it's just that the majority that buy the game don't know of
> > r.a.s. or other newsgroups to voice thier concerns. There probably has
> been
> > a few hundred thousand N4 games sold already. Hmmm, I don't see that
many
> > online or in the newsgroups. I guess it's the old saying coming to
> > mind..."The squeeky wheel gets the grease." I say this because most of
the
> > people here that look for a honest answer get barraged by the Papy
> loyalists
> > for even asking for fixes or adding things like a savegame feature.
Their
> > past products had it, why not this one? I think that N4 is a great sim
but
> > it still has bugs that need to be fixed. Even after this latest patch it
> > still does have some issues, but the majority of the bugs were squashed.
> If
> > they fix these remaining issues the game will be better for most but not
> > all. Remember that there are others that feel that the sim should have
had
> > more and others that would have been happy with just online racing and
no
> > AI. But the fact is, it does have offline racing and should be enjoyable
> for
> > those that choose to have it their way.



> > > Yeah, they can be a little wimpy at times. But hey, I don't think the
> day
> > > will ever come anyone can program an ai to replicate actual human
> > behaviour.
> > > Until they can, then we'll always find weaknesses in the ai. That's
why
> I
> > > love online racing.

Don Burnett

N4 AI

by Don Burnett » Sun, 29 Apr 2001 08:19:14

Thought the supposed 2nd patch wasn't out yet?

--
Don Burnette
D Burnette in N4

Some people do nothing wrong.
The problem is, they do nothing.
And THAT is wrong.


> Did you try the second patch? I dont remember where I got it.



> > I didn't fine Heat's ai very realistic at all. I got nailed by them
during
> > yellows and going down pit road, almost every time. When they didn't fix
> > that problem with the first patch was when I uninstalled it. I also
found
> it
> > pretty unrealistic that I could plow through the ai and none of us
wreck.
> > For instance, squeeze between two cars where there isn't room, and shove
> > them both aside.
> > No matter, it appears that programming the ai with the 6dof physics is
> > pretty complicated as both Heat and N4 have had problems with it. For me
> > personally, I preferred N4's over Heat.

> > --
> > Don Burnette
> > D Burnette in N4

> > Some people do nothing wrong.
> > The problem is, they do nothing.
> > And THAT is wrong.



> > > God forbid I say this... Nascar Heat has a helluva lot better AI. If
N4
> > had
> > > NH's AI, it would be great. (People do buy the sim with intentions of
> > racing
> > > OFFLINE.) The online community is not the majority here, as some would
> > like
> > > to believe, it's just that the majority that buy the game don't know
of
> > > r.a.s. or other newsgroups to voice thier concerns. There probably has
> > been
> > > a few hundred thousand N4 games sold already. Hmmm, I don't see that
> many
> > > online or in the newsgroups. I guess it's the old saying coming to
> > > mind..."The squeeky wheel gets the grease." I say this because most of
> the
> > > people here that look for a honest answer get barraged by the Papy
> > loyalists
> > > for even asking for fixes or adding things like a savegame feature.
> Their
> > > past products had it, why not this one? I think that N4 is a great sim
> but
> > > it still has bugs that need to be fixed. Even after this latest patch
it
> > > still does have some issues, but the majority of the bugs were
squashed.

> > If
> > > they fix these remaining issues the game will be better for most but
not
> > > all. Remember that there are others that feel that the sim should have
> had
> > > more and others that would have been happy with just online racing and
> no
> > > AI. But the fact is, it does have offline racing and should be
enjoyable
> > for
> > > those that choose to have it their way.



> > > > Yeah, they can be a little wimpy at times. But hey, I don't think
the
> > day
> > > > will ever come anyone can program an ai to replicate actual human
> > > behaviour.
> > > > Until they can, then we'll always find weaknesses in the ai. That's
> why
> > I
> > > > love online racing.

BCla

N4 AI

by BCla » Sun, 29 Apr 2001 09:13:07

I hope you really don't race like that. :-) I agree that you could do this
in normal mode. Did you ever try the *** mode?
Don Burnett

N4 AI

by Don Burnett » Sun, 29 Apr 2001 09:21:56

No, I really don't race like that , especially online :)
Yes, I could do that in *** mode, which I thought was very unrealistic.

--
Don Burnette
D Burnette in N4

Some people do nothing wrong.
The problem is, they do nothing.
And THAT is wrong.


Dave Henri

N4 AI

by Dave Henri » Sun, 29 Apr 2001 09:25:12

  It's been out in beta form for about a MONTH!!!  where have you been
Donnie boy?
:)
  actually the AI behave MUCH better now in NH.  What they are working on is
still some
improvements AND they are adding menu items that allow patches to seemlessly
be swapped or chosen
from within the game, like it's done on Half-life.
dave henrie


> Thought the supposed 2nd patch wasn't out yet?

> --
> Don Burnette
> D Burnette in N4

> Some people do nothing wrong.
> The problem is, they do nothing.
> And THAT is wrong.



> > Did you try the second patch? I dont remember where I got it.



> > > I didn't fine Heat's ai very realistic at all. I got nailed by them
> during
> > > yellows and going down pit road, almost every time. When they didn't
fix
> > > that problem with the first patch was when I uninstalled it. I also
> found
> > it
> > > pretty unrealistic that I could plow through the ai and none of us
> wreck.
> > > For instance, squeeze between two cars where there isn't room, and
shove
> > > them both aside.
> > > No matter, it appears that programming the ai with the 6dof physics is
> > > pretty complicated as both Heat and N4 have had problems with it. For
me
> > > personally, I preferred N4's over Heat.

> > > --
> > > Don Burnette
> > > D Burnette in N4

> > > Some people do nothing wrong.
> > > The problem is, they do nothing.
> > > And THAT is wrong.



> > > > God forbid I say this... Nascar Heat has a helluva lot better AI. If
> N4
> > > had
> > > > NH's AI, it would be great. (People do buy the sim with intentions
of
> > > racing
> > > > OFFLINE.) The online community is not the majority here, as some
would
> > > like
> > > > to believe, it's just that the majority that buy the game don't know
> of
> > > > r.a.s. or other newsgroups to voice thier concerns. There probably
has
> > > been
> > > > a few hundred thousand N4 games sold already. Hmmm, I don't see that
> > many
> > > > online or in the newsgroups. I guess it's the old saying coming to
> > > > mind..."The squeeky wheel gets the grease." I say this because most
of
> > the
> > > > people here that look for a honest answer get barraged by the Papy
> > > loyalists
> > > > for even asking for fixes or adding things like a savegame feature.
> > Their
> > > > past products had it, why not this one? I think that N4 is a great
sim
> > but
> > > > it still has bugs that need to be fixed. Even after this latest
patch
> it
> > > > still does have some issues, but the majority of the bugs were
> squashed.

> > > If
> > > > they fix these remaining issues the game will be better for most but
> not
> > > > all. Remember that there are others that feel that the sim should
have
> > had
> > > > more and others that would have been happy with just online racing
and
> > no
> > > > AI. But the fact is, it does have offline racing and should be
> enjoyable
> > > for
> > > > those that choose to have it their way.



> > > > > Yeah, they can be a little wimpy at times. But hey, I don't think
> the
> > > day
> > > > > will ever come anyone can program an ai to replicate actual human
> > > > behaviour.
> > > > > Until they can, then we'll always find weaknesses in the ai.
That's
> > why
> > > I
> > > > > love online racing.

Don Burnett

N4 AI

by Don Burnett » Sun, 29 Apr 2001 09:31:01

Ahhh, I was waiting for the official patch. Still, I might try reinstalling
it and applying the beta patch to compare again. If I recall I also had a
lot of crash to desktops in Heat also, maybe that will be better also.

--
Don Burnette
D Burnette in N4

Some people do nothing wrong.
The problem is, they do nothing.
And THAT is wrong.


>   It's been out in beta form for about a MONTH!!!  where have you been
> Donnie boy?
> :)
>   actually the AI behave MUCH better now in NH.  What they are working on
is
> still some
> improvements AND they are adding menu items that allow patches to
seemlessly
> be swapped or chosen
> from within the game, like it's done on Half-life.
> dave henrie



> > Thought the supposed 2nd patch wasn't out yet?

> > --
> > Don Burnette
> > D Burnette in N4

> > Some people do nothing wrong.
> > The problem is, they do nothing.
> > And THAT is wrong.



> > > Did you try the second patch? I dont remember where I got it.



> > > > I didn't fine Heat's ai very realistic at all. I got nailed by them
> > during
> > > > yellows and going down pit road, almost every time. When they didn't
> fix
> > > > that problem with the first patch was when I uninstalled it. I also
> > found
> > > it
> > > > pretty unrealistic that I could plow through the ai and none of us
> > wreck.
> > > > For instance, squeeze between two cars where there isn't room, and
> shove
> > > > them both aside.
> > > > No matter, it appears that programming the ai with the 6dof physics
is
> > > > pretty complicated as both Heat and N4 have had problems with it.
For
> me
> > > > personally, I preferred N4's over Heat.

> > > > --
> > > > Don Burnette
> > > > D Burnette in N4

> > > > Some people do nothing wrong.
> > > > The problem is, they do nothing.
> > > > And THAT is wrong.



> > > > > God forbid I say this... Nascar Heat has a helluva lot better AI.
If
> > N4
> > > > had
> > > > > NH's AI, it would be great. (People do buy the sim with intentions
> of
> > > > racing
> > > > > OFFLINE.) The online community is not the majority here, as some
> would
> > > > like
> > > > > to believe, it's just that the majority that buy the game don't
know
> > of
> > > > > r.a.s. or other newsgroups to voice thier concerns. There probably
> has
> > > > been
> > > > > a few hundred thousand N4 games sold already. Hmmm, I don't see
that
> > > many
> > > > > online or in the newsgroups. I guess it's the old saying coming to
> > > > > mind..."The squeeky wheel gets the grease." I say this because
most
> of
> > > the
> > > > > people here that look for a honest answer get barraged by the Papy
> > > > loyalists
> > > > > for even asking for fixes or adding things like a savegame
feature.
> > > Their
> > > > > past products had it, why not this one? I think that N4 is a great
> sim
> > > but
> > > > > it still has bugs that need to be fixed. Even after this latest
> patch
> > it
> > > > > still does have some issues, but the majority of the bugs were
> > squashed.

> > > > If
> > > > > they fix these remaining issues the game will be better for most
but
> > not
> > > > > all. Remember that there are others that feel that the sim should
> have
> > > had
> > > > > more and others that would have been happy with just online racing
> and
> > > no
> > > > > AI. But the fact is, it does have offline racing and should be
> > enjoyable
> > > > for
> > > > > those that choose to have it their way.



> > > > > > Yeah, they can be a little wimpy at times. But hey, I don't
think
> > the
> > > > day
> > > > > > will ever come anyone can program an ai to replicate actual
human
> > > > > behaviour.
> > > > > > Until they can, then we'll always find weaknesses in the ai.
> That's
> > > why
> > > > I
> > > > > > love online racing.

Eldre

N4 AI

by Eldre » Mon, 30 Apr 2001 06:32:56



>Wouldn't it be cool if they programmed it th LEARN from what WE do on the
>track ?

There's no 'global_hype' variable...?  Good.

Eldred
--
Dale Earnhardt, Sr. R.I.P. 1951-2001
Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett
F1 hcp. +28.67...F2 +151.26...

Never argue with an idiot.  He brings you down to his level, then beats you
with experience...
Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.

Tim Mise

N4 AI

by Tim Mise » Wed, 02 May 2001 09:47:10

It worked with my V5 but now with the patch, Alt-Tab no longer works!!  :(


> What video card? With my V5 in D3D the screen gets trashed so bad it's
> hard to find the exit.



> > Alt-tab works for me.

Dave Henri

N4 AI

by Dave Henri » Wed, 02 May 2001 10:22:12

  are you still using d3d or did you perhaps change it to opengl while/or
after patching?
dave henrie

> It worked with my V5 but now with the patch, Alt-Tab no longer works!!  :(



> > What video card? With my V5 in D3D the screen gets trashed so bad it's
> > hard to find the exit.



> > > Alt-tab works for me.


rec.autos.simulators is a usenet newsgroup formed in December, 1993. As this group was always unmoderated there may be some spam or off topic articles included. Some links do point back to racesimcentral.net as we could not validate the original address. Please report any pages that you believe warrant deletion from this archive (include the link in your email). RaceSimCentral.net is in no way responsible and does not endorse any of the content herein.