Well, I don't know that I'd necessarily say a bad thing, but certainly
entirely unnecessary. One thing they do that can be considered bad is
allowing much higher speeds at the most dangerous part of the racetrack, the
corners. It's a paradox, but racing would actually be much safer with LESS
cornering grip.
To support this argument I'd note that fewer fatalities happen in the rain
than in the dry. A lot MORE accidents, but fewer fatalities.
Grooving the tires is a lousy way to achieve lower cornering speeds. Ripping
the wings off works great.
If so, I would agree. I think that, in F1
Here I'd actually disagree with you. The rise of the driver in F1 is a
fairly recent phenomenon. F1 was always an engineering first form of racing.
It's raison d'etre was the ultimate machine.
We don't have that anymore. Now it's a star based, soak the fan for money,
media event. As an engineer I look at F1 and see sterility. The cars are so
rigidly defined by the rules that the "designer" is reduced to diddling with
minor details in order to garner some 1/10 of 1% advantage. It is far LESS
of an engineer's formula as a result. It's engineering for the brain dead,
***retentive fussbudget.
The Tyrrell six wheeler may have been no great success but at least they
were allowed to apply creativity to an engineering problem and stick their
necks out to see if their solution worked!
That sort of thing can't be allowed today. If one competitor were allowed a
new idea that actually gave them a distinct advantage over the others it
would be bad for the sport, i.e. *The Gate.*
Money talks, the lawyers have taken control of the 'show.'
Here's my solution. Seperate the driver's championship and the
manufacturer's championship.
The driver's championship would be run with a spec chassis, spec motor, and
spec tires. All of these would be defined on a cost/benifit basis in order
to keep the overall cost of operation low. So low that the upper middle
class could, at least in theory, finance their own championship team out of
pocket. NO WINGS.
Basically I'm talking a beefed up, de-aeroed Formula Mazda here.
F1 would be a manufacturer's championship only. The rules would be fairly
simple. Your car can only be so big. It has to have these driver safety
items. It has to breath through this little tube.
That's IT!
Ok, I've stuck my neck out. Let the chopping begin.
> John
> > Kevin,
> > What do you mean? Umm...surely they create downforce in
order
> > for the car to stick to the road?
> > Ash
> > |
> > | I'll say this though, for purely sporting purposes wings on a car
serve
> no
> > | purpose whatsoever.
> > |
> > |