Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

Best F1 simulator ?

23 posts by 12 people · 14 Apr 1999 - 19 Apr 1999

Flame warBest F1 sim: GPL, GP2, F1RS or MGPRS2

A GP2 owner asked about the best F1 sims, and most replies told him to buy Grand Prix Legends. For modern F1, posters argued over whether GP2, F1 Racing Simulation or its update Monaco Grand Prix Racing Simulation 2 was better, and the debate turned to crude insults between a few regulars.

game comparisonGrand Prix LegendsGrand Prix 2F1 Racing SimulationMonaco Grand Prix Racing Simulation 2

Automated summary.

GandAlf 14 Apr 1999#461926
Hi I was wondering what top, awesome F1 sims are on the market ? How do they compare etc I already have GP2. Regards Gandalf
no 5 words : Buy Grand Prix Legends NOW
Quoted text (16 lines)>On 14 Apr 1999 14:33:19 GMT, >>Hi >>I was wondering what top, awesome F1 sims are on the market ? >>How do they compare etc >>I already have GP2. >>Regards >>Gandalf >4 words: Buy Grand Prix Legends. >-- >// rrevved posts from mindspring dot com
Modern era with real teams: - Formula One Racing Sim (F1RS) Modern era with fake teams but updatable: - Monaco Grand Prix Racing Sim (MGPRS) 60's historical Formula One: - Grand Prix Legends (GPL) - Grand Prix Legends (GPL) - Grand Prix Legends (GPL) - Grand Prix Legends (GPL) - Grand Prix Legends (GPL) - Grand Prix Legends (GPL) - Grand Prix Legends (GPL) - Grand Prix Legends (GPL) - Grand Prix Legends (GPL) Do I make myself clear?-)
Don't buy F1RS as MGPRS2 is vastly superior in every way, including the AI, graphics, etc.etc. Iain
Graeme Nash 14 Apr 1999#461930
Well, if you already have GP2 you're sorted for modern F1 (IMHO) so the only one left is Grand Prix Legends. The finest sim yet. Get it yesterday! -- Cheers! Graeme Nash http://www.karisma1.demon.co.uk ICQ# 11257824 ________________________________________________________________________________ "I liked things better when I didn't understand them" (Calvin & Hobbes)
GP2 is the best for contemporary cars by far. But you really should go out and get GPL...It offers racing exhilaration that can only be experienced by those fortunate enough to do it for real... Matthew.
Greg Cisko 14 Apr 1999#461932
Bullshit. Perhaps they released a patch for MGPRS2 which has drastically improved the game since Dec98? If not I simply don't believe it. The framerate was certainly worse at Monaco in MGPRS2 than it is in F1RS. (I have a P2-450 with 128MB of RAM and a 12MB Voodoo2). Are the Force Feedback effects also improved in MGPRS2? The last I heard it was not. The sound also was certainly *NOT* improved. In fact the sound was quite a bit worse. The 3D sound also sucked. This is quite surprising since the 3D sound in F1RS is awesome. MGPRS2 is more like F1RS 1.5 than it is a new version of the game. -- Header address intentionally scrambled to ward off the spamming hordes. cisko [AT] ix [DOT] netcom [DOT] com
Greg Cisko 14 Apr 1999#461933
>GP2 is the best for contemporary cars by far. But you really should go out What? GP2 better than F1RS? Are you people totally mental or something? Holy shit... -- Header address intentionally scrambled to ward off the spamming hordes. cisko [AT] ix [DOT] netcom [DOT] com >and get GPL...It offers racing exhilaration that can only be experienced by >those fortunate enough to do it for real... >Matthew. >> Hi >> I was wondering what top, awesome F1 sims are on the market ? >> How do they compare etc >> I already have GP2. >> Regards >> Gandalf
ymenard 14 Apr 1999#461934
Nice way to make friend Greg <g> IMHO Gp2.. updated with 1996tracks, 1996 performances, 1996 carshape and carset is as good as F1RS. It excels it in some domains (game engine, sound, depth of the options) but fails to F1RS in others (graphic engine, tyre temps ! heh). I even consider the GP2 AI better than in F1RS. -- -- Fran?ois Mnard <ymenard/Nas-Frank> -- NROS Nascar sanctioned Guide http://www.nros.com/ -- SimRacing Online http://www.simracing.com/ -- Official mentally retarded guy of r.a.s. -- May the Downforce be with you... "People think it must be fun to be a super genius, but they don't realise how hard it is to put up with all the idiots in the world."
Te 15 Apr 1999#462135
On Wed, 14 Apr 1999 21:53:36 -0500, "Greg Cisko" >MGPRS2 is more like F1RS 1.5 than it is a new version of the game. Just to get back to the facts... - Improved ingame graphics and FX (i.e. more and more detailed objects, reflections, additional texturing, mip mapping) - support for higher resolutions - new ingame perspectives - brake ratio, ARB, fuel strategy can be changed on the fly during the race - more realistic wheather changes - 2 new tracks - the ability to change team & driver info, editors for graphics and sound - a vastly modified driving model - much more aggressive AI - blue flag and additional black flag situations - extended setup and telemetry - spare car & 107 % rule option - the careermode - the scenariomode - the Gameservice (Multiplayer via Internet, up to 8 players) So, in any case it *is* a lot better than F1RS, I cannot see a single reason why anyone should still buy the older, less advanced of the two (money issue aside). As you can see there's quite a number of changes/additions, a bit the opposite to another company who just released basically the same game for the third time - and people are still happily buying and playing it... ? PS: you really need to check your system, there must be a serious problem if you cannot manage to get a fluid framerate on a PII450. I know people are running it successfully on an ordinary P200 without any hickups (low res of course) --Tel
P Gagg 15 Apr 1999#462136
> >I already have GP2. > Well, if you already have GP2 you're sorted for modern F1 (IMHO) so > the > only one left is Grand Prix Legends. The finest sim yet. Get it > yesterday! Wot Graeme said. 8-) Except.....FIRS or MGPS2 (which is the newer version of F1RS) have better graphics than GP2 (3Dfx). I hated F1RS when it first came out, as I was a die hard GP2 fan, and F1RS just didn't feel right? However, after lots of practicing, it does grow on you, and gets to be very enjoyable. I still think GP2 feels better to drive though? So if you want looks, F1RS or MGPR2 is your choice, if you want driving feel, stick with GP2? The best F1 sim, EVER, though, has to be GRAND PRIX LEGENDS, no doubt, buy it. You will regret it if you miss out on what is, a sim racing experience that should not be missed! It sounds great, it looks great, it drives great. Go get it............Well! what are you waiting for? 8-) *Peter* #:-)
Jay Wolf 15 Apr 1999#462137
>>GP2 is the best for contemporary cars by far. But you really should go out >What? GP2 better than F1RS? Are you people totally mental or >something? Holy shit... yeah, greggy, it is so good that i will give my copy (including the box and manual) of that piece o'***to the first person that sends me enough postage to send it to them. every time i see that box, it makes me mad. that sorry program lasted less than 10 minutes on my system. i don't have to smell a fart for 3 days to know it stinks. GP2 kicks its ass in every way, if you care about modern stuff. but, since GPL has been out... p.s. - hey, ymenard - i saw a screening of that new SW flick. it blows.
Quoted text (8 lines)> >Don't buy F1RS as MGPRS2 is vastly superior in every way, including the AI, > >graphics, etc.etc. > Bullshit. Perhaps they released a patch for MGPRS2 which has > drastically improved the game since Dec98? If not I simply don't > believe it. The framerate was certainly worse at Monaco in > MGPRS2 than it is in F1RS. (I have a P2-450 with 128MB of > RAM and a 12MB Voodoo2).
You obviously have some problems, it's really fast in 1152x864 and I am on a P2 300 and a G200...F1RS was limited to 640x480 and was definitely slower. Absolutely not. I have a Logitech Formula Force, and the feedback is quite awesome. You should check your sound card...it's really better than in F1RS...the pitch is far more detailed. I wouldn't go that far, there was a lot of new features like Tel described. Although it wasn't a brand new game, it's a good evolution. Cheers! -- Jean-Francois Lepage Web designer & 3D Artist/Animator ICQ#5404541 __________________________________________ The Web's World http://www.supernet.ca/~stealth/index.html Includes: -Inspire 3D & LightWave Resources -The AirSpace -The Unofficial Fly! Web Site
> IMHO Gp2.. updated with 1996tracks, 1996 performances, 1996 carshape and > carset is as good as F1RS. It excels it in some domains (game engine, > sound, depth of the options) but fails to F1RS in others (graphic engine, > tyre temps ! heh). I even consider the GP2 AI better than in F1RS. IMHO, as a veteran of all the named F1 sims, I like MGPRS2 the best...although I miss the old Imola track. :+) The AI is really improved in MGPRS2, it's better than GP2 and F1RS; the adversaries can dodge if you tend to be agressive. They also let you overtake them, and sometimes gives you hard time. Cheers! -- Jean-Francois Lepage Web designer & 3D Artist/Animator ICQ#5404541 __________________________________________ The Web's World http://www.supernet.ca/~stealth/index.html Includes: -Inspire 3D & LightWave Resources -The AirSpace -The Unofficial Fly! Web Site
ymenard 15 Apr 1999#462140
Ewwwww.. Im sure people use them "all" the time <g> 1 track lost <g> Rename this to "We lost our FIA license" vastly ? Still the old and canned Pod game engine. And the title they are presently doing is STILL using the old game engine. LOL can we say dumb AI ? (somebody has damage... a lapper pass him.. the lapper receives a blue flag.. lets the driver with damage pass... loop this until the damaged car goes into the pits). It's not really good. I finished a season with 10wins and the Championship at my first season with a Tyrell, and I still only got a wheel for a Benneton.. not for a top team. It's one of the worse online experience I ever saw. the NROS.. Hawaii.. VROC.. it's years ahead of a 2-3car racing with extreme latency (cars stopping on a straight all the time and reaccelerating from 0 to 200 in 0.5seconds. Nice game engine <g>). They still never fixed the no sound in replay after what 6patches now ? They are a incredible company <g>. Maybe I shoudl post my URL about the Union that the UBisoft employees want to form because they are threated like meat and have severe m***and abuse problems at work? -- Fran?ois Mnard <ymenard/Nas-Frank> -- NROS Nascar sanctioned Guide http://www.nros.com/ -- SimRacing Online http://www.simracing.com/ -- Official mentally retarded guy of r.a.s. -- May the Downforce be with you... "People think it must be fun to be a super genius, but they don't realise how hard it is to put up with all the idiots in the world."
>>that sorry program lasted less than 10 minutes on my system. << A really informed opinion given there! Like you really were able to evaluate a very complex sim in that time! Iain
Te 16 Apr 1999#462316
Look, it's actually rather simple. I didn't say anything about the quality of these games (nor the lame company producing them) but was just listing features which made it to MGPRS but not into F1RS. Whether these *additional* features are well implemented in your opinion or not is irrelevant, fact is they are there. They are however significant enough to give one game a clear advantage over the other and thus make the decision which one to take an easy one. Also I'd like to point out that I too would have liked to see something else than a rehash using the old POD engine (and I hope what you say about upcoming games is not true) but then again, Papyrus in example recycled their 5 years old indycar engine for lord knows how often... --Tel
Greg Cisko 18 Apr 1999#462629
>> Are the Force Feedback effects also improved in MGPRS2? The >> last I heard it was not. >Absolutely not. I have a Logitech Formula Force, and the feedback is quite >awesome. Thanks for the tip! I was thinking about getting the Logitech FF today :-) Nothing wrong with the soundcard. The sound is at least the same in MGPRS2. I was quite disappointed that they never fixed the high speed downshift sound (flam16.wav). -- Header address intentionally scrambled to ward off the spamming hordes. cisko [AT] ix [DOT] netcom [DOT] com
Greg Cisko 18 Apr 1999#462630
>yeah, greggy, it is so good that i will give my copy (including the box and Hey ***. *** you. If you want to start some shit, fine with me. that Wow. If you say so. Let me see... F1RS (and MGPRS2) have a have a better framerate and better graphics, force feedback and 3D positional sound. Even though the AI is stupid you can still drive around them and win (or do very well) in races. F1RS and MGPRS2 has changing weather conditions, but I imagine you wouldn't know shit about that. Or are you good enough to win rain races? Heck even a win against Amateur AI would be somewhat impressive... But no forget all that stuff... GP2 is *WAY* better because it is not Made by Ubisoft (or something) I guess. Is that your point. -- Header address intentionally scrambled to ward off the spamming hordes. cisko [AT] ix [DOT] netcom [DOT] com
ymenard 18 Apr 1999#462631
No that would be my point.. Muahahahahahaha <Machiavellian laugh> -- It's a joke ! -- Fran?ois Mnard <ymenard/Nas-Frank> -- NROS Nascar sanctioned Guide http://www.nros.com/ -- SimRacing Online http://www.simracing.com/ -- Official mentally retarded guy of r.a.s. -- May the Downforce be with you... "People think it must be fun to be a super genius, but they don't realise how hard it is to put up with all the idiots in the world."
Greg Cisko 18 Apr 1999#462632
>> But no forget all that stuff... GP2 is *WAY* better because it is not >> Made by Ubisoft (or something) I guess. Is that your point. >No that would be my point.. In that case you are the NG's mental guy *AND* full of ***to boot. -- Header address intentionally scrambled to ward off the spamming hordes. cisko [AT] ix [DOT] netcom [DOT] com
Jay Wolf 19 Apr 1999#462781
>>yeah, greggy, it is so good that i will give my copy (including the box and
Quoted text (7 lines)>Hey ***. *** you. If you want to start some shit, fine with me. >>manual) of that piece o'***to the first person that sends me enough >>postage to send it to them. every time i see that box, it makes me mad. >that >Wow.
first off, porkchop, i am an ***, but for different reasons than you have stated, so***off. socondly, i have stuck by my bashing of the crappy f1rs by offering my copy of the scummy program to any takers for free. you know what? zip. nadda. nobody wants that piece of crap, and i don't blame them. here is the score, amigo: GP2 = very good GPL = great F1RS (and that monaco crap, too) = bad a piece of dog ***in 3D is still a piece of dog crap. it's just in 3D. you bring nothing to the fight.
Greg Cisko 19 Apr 1999#462782
>GP2 = very good >GPL = great >F1RS (and that monaco crap, too) = bad >a piece of dog ***in 3D is still a piece of dog crap. it's just in 3D. >you bring nothing to the fight. Sure, anything you say... -- Header address intentionally scrambled to ward off the spamming hordes. cisko [AT] ix [DOT] netcom [DOT] com

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy