rec.autos.simulators

VROC Disappointments

Jeff Vince

VROC Disappointments

by Jeff Vince » Sat, 20 Feb 1999 04:00:00


>On Thu, 18 Feb 1999 08:03:49 GMT, "Michael E. Carver"


>>% 12) show who is hosting a particular race- everyone always ends up
>>% asking after the race.

>>This is always the "first" name listed when you turn the page on the
>>Event info....

>Great! That is a big help- now I won't have to say "Who's the host?
>... Uh, thanks!"

   The host also always gets car number 4.

   Do *not* run into car number 4.  :)

"But in a way, fear is a big part of racing, because if there was
nothing to be frightened of, and no limit, any fool could get into
a motor car and racing would not exist as a sport." -- Jim Clark

Maps

VROC Disappointments

by Maps » Wed, 24 Feb 1999 04:00:00

I thought of another thing I think is important to add to the list of
future upgrades- having a server option to *not* refuel after a
SHIFT-R. The refueling SHIFT-R has some downsides- for one, on a long
race, some people can go out on very light loads then SHIFT-R
occasionally in hairpins. Secondly, if you do get wiped out by a
backmarker or such 3/4ths of the way through the race, it is simply a
terrible drag to go back not only to cold tires, but also a full fuel
tank.

For that matter, how about an option to leave tires as they were
(temperature and wear). Of course, if you blow a tire, that's a
problem!

If these sound like details, take a look at the Quake2 server
options... there's at least 100 of them. Not to mention 30 different
mods to start with!


>Here are some ideas for VROC or GPL (depending on who's job it would
>be to implement them). I haven't thought these through terribly
>carefully, but perhap we can toss them around:
>1) a way for people to allow their machines to host while they aren't
>there (Please please!). This would mean cycling through tracks
>automatically after each race.

This would mean many more people just leaving their machines running
GPL server for us while they are off doing something else :-)

Or when you discover that you are 3 seconds a lap faster than anyone
else on the server, and feel it might be a good time to try a new
car... last night this happened twice. Instead I just waited for
everyone to catch up a few times... but it was still beat.

I now know, thanks to you guys, that this is presently possible-
thanks.

IOW, do a "GameSpy" sort of thing.

Thanks- I also now realize that the host is always #4. And as pointed
out, *don't* hit #4 ;) Nothing worse than hearing the host complain
after a bad start that he's going to start having password only
races...

Maps

VROC Disappointments

by Maps » Fri, 26 Feb 1999 04:00:00

Well, since I'm on a roll, here's another thing I've thought of- an
optional sound "alarm" of some sort when the race is counting down to
start. ANybody else ever been caught in the garage not realizing the
race has suddenly (after 5 minutes in "ending practice session")
discovered the race was counting down?!? Or, worse, caught similarly
on a quick trip to the bathroom?!

>I thought of another thing I think is important to add to the list of
>future upgrades- having a server option to *not* refuel after a
>SHIFT-R. The refueling SHIFT-R has some downsides- for one, on a long
>race, some people can go out on very light loads then SHIFT-R
>occasionally in hairpins. Secondly, if you do get wiped out by a
>backmarker or such 3/4ths of the way through the race, it is simply a
>terrible drag to go back not only to cold tires, but also a full fuel
>tank.

>For that matter, how about an option to leave tires as they were
>(temperature and wear). Of course, if you blow a tire, that's a
>problem!

>If these sound like details, take a look at the Quake2 server
>options... there's at least 100 of them. Not to mention 30 different
>mods to start with!


>>Here are some ideas for VROC or GPL (depending on who's job it would
>>be to implement them). I haven't thought these through terribly
>>carefully, but perhap we can toss them around:

>>1) a way for people to allow their machines to host while they aren't
>>there (Please please!). This would mean cycling through tracks
>>automatically after each race.

>This would mean many more people just leaving their machines running
>GPL server for us while they are off doing something else :-)

>>2) some simple way to change cars without disconnecting (for all those
>>"BRM only" servers you discover only after loggin on)

>Or when you discover that you are 3 seconds a lap faster than anyone
>else on the server, and feel it might be a good time to try a new
>car... last night this happened twice. Instead I just waited for
>everyone to catch up a few times... but it was still beat.

>>3)a way to use key-combo stock phrases in chat without typing
>>("sorry", "NP", "please move over- I'm lapping you", etc.). Perhaps
>>that is too un-simmlike, but it sure is irritating having backrunners
>>race you and eventually put you in the dirt...

>>4)see latency without going on to pit lane.

>I now know, thanks to you guys, that this is presently possible-
>thanks.

>>5)go back to having VROC chat at the bottom of the Netscape page- I
>>think that was a great place to go when nothing was happening, and you
>>wanted to set up another race. Or vent about just gettting discoed!

>>6) a way to see who is practicing (and times) at a particular server
>>before going to it. Maybe a way to check race standings at a given
>>server- but maybe that is too taxing during the race for the server

>IOW, do a "GameSpy" sort of thing.

>>7)a way to save lap info and garage info before getting tossed to the
>>"newspaper"

>>8) have a way for server to restrict access from specific people (of
>>course, they can always change their names).

>>9) the choice for the server to allow people to connect when practice
>>is over but race hasn't started yet. Perhaps even the choice for a
>>server to let people connect during a race- boon to discoed drivers,
>>or people who just want to watch a good race.

>>10) show records of top speeds for server or most wins per individual,
>>etc.

>>11) provide a way to know how many people are still racing with you
>>(sucks not realizing until end that everyone else left).

>>12) show who is hosting a particular race- everyone always ends up
>>asking after the race.

>Thanks- I also now realize that the host is always #4. And as pointed
>out, *don't* hit #4 ;) Nothing worse than hearing the host complain
>after a bad start that he's going to start having password only
>races...

Jason Mond

VROC Disappointments

by Jason Mond » Fri, 26 Feb 1999 04:00:00


> I thought of another thing I think is important to add to the list of
> future upgrades- having a server option to *not* refuel after a
> SHIFT-R. The refueling SHIFT-R has some downsides- for one, on a long
> race, some people can go out on very light loads then SHIFT-R
> occasionally in hairpins. Secondly, if you do get wiped out by a
> backmarker or such 3/4ths of the way through the race, it is simply a
> terrible drag to go back not only to cold tires, but also a full fuel
> tank.

I like the cold tires and original fuel load -- it makes you choose between

running the last few laps with bad toe-in or press SHIFT-R and suffer
from the cold tires and fuel load.

I think I was one of these hosts.  If I wanted a full race, the open
server was the way to go.  However, after having 10 drivers and 2 finishers

after 2 PRO races (Monaco and Nurburgring) I decided it was better to
start with 5 PRC drivers and finish with 5 PRC drivers.  I thought the
difficulty
and selection of track would scare the rookies away, but it didn't work.

On a good note, I will be hosting PRC recruiting race(s) Thursday 10pm EST
on VROC in the Open2 room to try and minimize the number of rookies that
join.

--
--------
Jason Monds
"My other car is a Ferrari"
http://members.home.net/gpl.mondsj/gpl - For my combined gas/brake setups
(Please remove 'no extra spork' when replying)

Maps

VROC Disappointments

by Maps » Fri, 26 Feb 1999 04:00:00

On Thu, 25 Feb 1999 10:53:35 -0700, Jason Monds



>> I thought of another thing I think is important to add to the list of
>> future upgrades- having a server option to *not* refuel after a
>> SHIFT-R. The refueling SHIFT-R has some downsides- for one, on a long
>> race, some people can go out on very light loads then SHIFT-R
>> occasionally in hairpins. Secondly, if you do get wiped out by a
>> backmarker or such 3/4ths of the way through the race, it is simply a
>> terrible drag to go back not only to cold tires, but also a full fuel
>> tank.

>I like the cold tires and original fuel load -- it makes you choose between

>running the last few laps with bad toe-in or press SHIFT-R and suffer
>from the cold tires and fuel load.

Well, I mean having an option to keep or omit shift-r refueling,
depending on the server owner's choice.

I must admit, there have been races where I was so sure that I would
get knocked off at least once in the race by an over-eager lapped car
(you can judge those races in the practice!) that I considered the
light fuel load. I don't like that we can do that. But I also have
been in one too many races where the last 5 laps of a 27 lapper I've
had to do on a full tank because someone got sloppy- no fun. At least
for me.

Since I'm throwing future upgrade ideas lately, here's another option-
make a limit to how much fuel or mileage cars can go out on a given
race- force there to be at least on pit stop. Even in a 14 lap race,
that could be interesting.

Just a thought.

- Show quoted text -

How do we get the password? ;-)
Jason Mond

VROC Disappointments

by Jason Mond » Fri, 26 Feb 1999 04:00:00

Hi Mapson,

You don't need a password for the recruiting races.  That's why I hold them
in the Open rooms :-)   If you are interested in attending, just tell me that
you like to 'try out' (during practice) and make sure I have your email address.

I figure there are 3 kinds of drivers in GPL.  Those who are members of
PRC (Pro Racing Club) and those who are not members are the bad
drivers we are trying to keep out of our races :)  The other group are
rookies that need more practice to stay on the road, but would make
fine members one day.

To be a member you not have to be fast, just clean.  Latency is important
as well because we race mainly PRO races.  The recruiting race is a
chance for me to see you in action and check latency.

Once your accepted into the group you get our passwords :-)

That should cover it.

Jason.


> On Thu, 25 Feb 1999 10:53:35 -0700, Jason Monds

> >On a good note, I will be hosting PRC recruiting race(s) Thursday 10pm EST
> >on VROC in the Open2 room to try and minimize the number of rookies that
> >join.

> How do we get the password? ;-)

--
--------
Jason Monds
"My other car is a Ferrari"
http://members.home.net/gpl.mondsj/gpl - For my combined gas/brake setups
(Please remove 'no extra spork' when replying)
Ron Ayto

VROC Disappointments

by Ron Ayto » Fri, 26 Feb 1999 04:00:00

Hi Jason, i find your comments in this post a bit on the offensive side
to say the least.
In other words, everyone who is not a member of the mighty PRC in your
opinion, is either a rookie who can't stay on the road, or a bad driver
who doesn't deserve the honour of racing with the PRC members.    
Sheesh, talk about arrogant.
I hope you made a mistake in your wording of this post, or my opinion
of you has just took a rather large down turn.
I feel you should have added a 4th group of racers to your comments,
like:  "The rest of the sim world that are good clean racers and just
do not want, or wish to part of the PRC."
I run in a league called the GMSS, and i know i have never raced
against a cleaner or better class of driver than is presently located
in our league.
There are plenty of other leagues that are not part of the PRC as well,
and i am sure they are just as clean and capable of good racing as ANY
member of the PRC, so how do you get off on saying if your not a member
of the PRC you are either a "Rookie who can't stay on the road", or a
"Bad Driver" .. ?
There is more to sim racing life than the PRC.
I wonder if you could clarify this post or reword it a bit better, as
the way you have stated it, simply sucks!
Cheers, and have a nice day, from a bad rookie driver.
Ron

ps..  if you did make a mistake in the wording of this post, then i
apologise for my outburst, but if what you said is in your opinion
true, then i stand by this post...



> Hi Mapson,

> You don't need a password for the recruiting races.  That's why I
hold them
> in the Open rooms :-)   If you are interested in attending, just tell
me that
> you like to 'try out' (during practice) and make sure I have your
email address.

> I figure there are 3 kinds of drivers in GPL.  Those who are members
of
> PRC (Pro Racing Club) and those who are not members are the bad
> drivers we are trying to keep out of our races :)  The other group
are
> rookies that need more practice to stay on the road, but would make
> fine members one day.

> To be a member you not have to be fast, just clean.  Latency is
important
> as well because we race mainly PRO races.  The recruiting race is a
> chance for me to see you in action and check latency.

> Once your accepted into the group you get our passwords :-)

> That should cover it.

> Jason.


> > On Thu, 25 Feb 1999 10:53:35 -0700, Jason Monds

> > >On a good note, I will be hosting PRC recruiting race(s) Thursday
10pm EST
> > >on VROC in the Open2 room to try and minimize the number of
rookies that
> > >join.

> > How do we get the password? ;-)

> --
> --------
> Jason Monds
> "My other car is a Ferrari"
> http://members.home.net/gpl.mondsj/gpl - For my combined gas/brake
setups
> (Please remove 'no extra spork' when replying)

Jason Mond

VROC Disappointments

by Jason Mond » Fri, 26 Feb 1999 04:00:00

Hi Ron,


> Hi Jason, i find your comments in this post a bit on the offensive side
> to say the least.

> In other words, everyone who is not a member of the mighty PRC in your
> opinion, is either a rookie who can't stay on the road, or a bad driver
> who doesn't deserve the honour of racing with the PRC members.
> Sheesh, talk about arrogant.

Chill.

I meant, the Open VROC races are not fun with all the crashes at the
start.

Anyone who wants to enjoy GPL (without the crashing) has to join
a special league (or group).  The PRC is just a group of like minded
drivers -- we don't like people who try to come from last place on the
grid and crash everyone out.  We stress clean driving and passing.

As for the rookies.  I'm sure they don't want to crash people out, but
just haven't developed the skill to be consistant yet.

Ok not being a part of the PRC is fine.  But those people must be searching

for other 'leagues' I'm sure.

See.  You found open races to be horrible and had to search for a
group of clean drivers.  The GMSS does that for you.

I believe Micheal Carver is a member of the GMSS group and PRC,
and allows both racers into his Monday race.

I should have made that clearer.  PRC means you want to drive clean, but of

course that can be found in ANY other league or group.

I mostly post while at work and may not always get my ideas across
perfectly.  Like right now, I should be leaving -- its after 5pm and
I need to get home to support another client by phone at 6pm :-)

Would you be in the GMSS if you were a bad driver?  Probably not.

I hope I cleared this up.  It was a partial misunderstanding.

The PRC is a group of over 100 drivers who like to race clean.
That is all.  I'm sure you like to race clean, that would put you
in the 'PRC' group even though you are in the GMSS.  Wouldn't
the GMSS kick out drivers who were careless and crashed
people out every race?



> > Hi Mapson,

> > You don't need a password for the recruiting races.  That's why I
> hold them
> > in the Open rooms :-)   If you are interested in attending, just tell
> me that
> > you like to 'try out' (during practice) and make sure I have your
> email address.

> > I figure there are 3 kinds of drivers in GPL.  Those who are members
> of
> > PRC (Pro Racing Club) and those who are not members are the bad
> > drivers we are trying to keep out of our races :)  The other group
> are
> > rookies that need more practice to stay on the road, but would make
> > fine members one day.

> > To be a member you not have to be fast, just clean.  Latency is
> important
> > as well because we race mainly PRO races.  The recruiting race is a
> > chance for me to see you in action and check latency.

> > Once your accepted into the group you get our passwords :-)

> > That should cover it.

> > Jason.


> > > On Thu, 25 Feb 1999 10:53:35 -0700, Jason Monds

> > > >On a good note, I will be hosting PRC recruiting race(s) Thursday
> 10pm EST
> > > >on VROC in the Open2 room to try and minimize the number of
> rookies that
> > > >join.

> > > How do we get the password? ;-)

> > --
> > --------
> > Jason Monds
> > "My other car is a Ferrari"
> > http://members.home.net/gpl.mondsj/gpl - For my combined gas/brake
> setups
> > (Please remove 'no extra spork' when replying)

Is this my first flame?  If not, it must be the 2nd on the same topic too.

--
--------
Jason Monds
"My other car is a Ferrari"
http://members.home.net/gpl.mondsj/gpl - For my combined gas/brake setups
(Please remove 'no extra spork' when replying)

Ron Ayto

VROC Disappointments

by Ron Ayto » Sat, 27 Feb 1999 04:00:00

Hi again Jason,
I understand what you are talking about in your post, but i felt the
way you said it was not the best way of approaching this problem.
There certainly are more classes of sim drivers than you have given
credit to.
I know quite a few rookie/new drivers to GPL that can stay on the
track, they are not fast, but are clean, and i would take a slow clean
driver over a fast, shift-r mentality driver anyday.  :-)
That is why pro racing is the best way to go in a on-line race.   It
won't stop them all, but will deter a few of the worst offenders.

I suppose i just get a bit dissapointed in the way that a lot of the
hosts on VROC are starting to password their races.   I understand why,
but i still think that is the wrong approach to introduce the new  sim
racers of the world to the fun of our on-line racing community.
One reason for that is that the new driver to GPL is not going to have
the confidence to apply for a password and join a race, knowing full
well he may botch it, and they will be totally put off racing on-line
if all they can join is a shift-r, go like hell and win at all costs,
type of a race.

A better way, IMO, would be to be able to have a kill list enabled from
within the hosts' computer in GPL to prevent the, "win at all costs",
mentality racer from entering a GPL race.    If a driver ends up on
that list, it is because he deserves to be there.
I just get a bit cheesed off at times i suppose, about all the holier
than thou attitude that abounds in the sim racing community, and i
would prefer to let the sim community sort it self out with who can be
trusted, and who can't, not make them join a special club or group just
to be able to have good clean races on-line.
I can understand the need for passwords in league races, but for the
rest, it does more harm than good to the racing community as a whole.  
It always tends to create divisions within groups, about who is good &
clean and who is, (in the host's opinion) a schmuck.
The idiots will soon learn to curb their eagerness at the line etc. or
they won't be welcomed for very long.
As you say, you can't win a race in the first lap, when everyone
realises that, things will start to improve.
I just hope the current trend to password races is a dying fad, because
the on-line sim racing community doesn't need those sort of politics to
be successfull...
If cable ever becomes available in Australia cheap enough, i will not
be passwording any races except for the points races for our league.
No hard feelings Jason, hopefully i will see you on-line in an open
event sometime, if i can still find one....    <G>
Cheers,
Ron

DAVI

VROC Disappointments

by DAVI » Sat, 27 Feb 1999 04:00:00

Well Jason I can assure you that I will not be a member of the PRC, due to
your preconcieved notion of that there are three kinds of drivers.  If you
want a demonstration of my driving why don't you arrange to come out and
drive my real race car.  I get really tired and bored with individuals who
make sweeping statments   like that.  I play this game for fun not to be
bothered by guys who cannot accept that some people have poor judgement in
the heat of the moment especailly when they do have to pay the consequences
a driver in a real race car would have too.

--
David Robinson

Egan's Law  

The Pace car will always go 2 MPH slower then your race car idles in first
gear.

Jason Mond

VROC Disappointments

by Jason Mond » Sat, 27 Feb 1999 04:00:00

Hello again Ron :-)

I checked out the replay of the Monday Mexico race that Micheal Carver
held.  You were the Brahbam behind me in T1 :-), but slid to the inside
:-(.  As a client I only get to see 6 cars, that was all I noticed.  I made
a great pass on Alison in the closing laps -- great fun overall.  I like
the idea Micheal has.  Give the password to any 'clean' drivers: GMSS, PRC,
whatever.


> Hi again Jason,
> I know quite a few rookie/new drivers to GPL that can stay on the
> track, they are not fast, but are clean, and i would take a slow clean
> driver over a fast, shift-r mentality driver anyday.  :-)

Rookie may have been a poor choice of words too.  We have 'slow' but clean
drivers in the PRC -- the Pro stands more for Pro mentality (clean) as you
say.

Just gets frustrating when your the host and get knocked out of the only 2
races that you can host.  I think I'll mainly stick to INT on open VROC
races and PRO to passworded races.

This should change with the GPL 1.1 patch.  I think they are putting in a
automatic server mode.  We should see a lot more races available 24hrs a
day.

And those players will not be allowed back into your races unless your
remove them from the list?  Sounds good to me :-)

Nope.

If you don't see me in open events, I'll see you in Micheal's Monday races
:-)

--
Jason Monds
theCLAPPER  in Kali
"My other car is a Ferrari"
http://members.home.net/gpl.mondsj/gpl/ - My combined gas/brake setups
(Remove 'no spork' when replying)

Mike Buckle

VROC Disappointments

by Mike Buckle » Sat, 27 Feb 1999 04:00:00

:(

I'd just like to say that after lurking here for a month or two before
trying VROC I was most surprised at the standard of driving I
encountered. The only serious start line crash I've been involved in was
a 15 strong grid at the Glen and that seemed to be because half the grid
were merely trying to keep position and one little touch set off a major
incident.
I've yet to see someone from the back try to make a stupid move into the
first corner, if accidents have happened then apologies have been quick
to follow. Indeed, I'm starting to feel I'm overcautious and too
gentlemanly as I've been rammed from behind surprising people because of
my cautious nature into turn 1. I think the number of startline
incidents is a fair reflection of the number that happen in real life
current F1 (although I've no idea what it was like in 67). I have no
problem with open VROC racing and can see no need to join the PRC, for
the sake the future of VROC I hope people agree with me.
--
Mike Buckley    
Cotswold Pig Development Co Ltd
Tel: 44 (0)1472 371591  Fax: 44 (0)1472 371208

WWW:    www.toastyhamster.freeserve.co.uk

Jason Mond

VROC Disappointments

by Jason Mond » Tue, 02 Mar 1999 04:00:00

Hi David,


> > I figure there are 3 kinds of drivers in GPL.  Those who are members of
> > PRC (Pro Racing Club) and those who are not members are the bad
> > drivers we are trying to keep out of our races :)  The other group are
> > rookies that need more practice to stay on the road, but would make
> > fine members one day.

> Well Jason I can assure you that I will not be a member of the PRC, due to
> your preconcieved notion of that there are three kinds of drivers.

No problem.   Just remember I am not the 'leader' of the PRC, just the most
outspoken member.

Now your talking!   I would like to race one day, but the expenses get in the
way ;)  I'll have to wait until I retire -- I work enough to retire at 40 ;)
At least I'll have the house paid for.  That will make way for many
opportunities :-)

No comment.

I do too.  When I only host 6-8 races a week I want to race, not sit around
watching.  I never restart the race due to an accident.  If I'm out on the
start, I don't reset the server.  I just prefer if my opponents wait for me to
crash myself out ;-)

I put the word [not] in there -- I believe thats what you meant to say.

Racing incidents do occur in the PRC (just not as often as open races).  It's
just that members of the PRC have proven themselves to be clean-minded
drivers.  What more can we ask for?  Everyone has their bad days and incidents.

--------
Jason Monds
"My other car is a Ferrari"
http://members.home.net/gpl.mondsj/gpl - For my combined gas/brake setups
(Please remove 'no extra spork' when replying)

Mike Rodrigue

VROC Disappointments

by Mike Rodrigue » Tue, 02 Mar 1999 04:00:00

Does the PRC host password-required races? I'm interested in joining up, but
have not had the dubious priviledge of racing in VROC. Don't want to use
netscape unless I HAVE to.

I am also hugely disappointed in on-line open play in general. I made it to
44th spot on Case's Ladder in Jedi Knight (quite some time ago), but was
amazed at the... er... "attitude" of many of the on-line players.

I'd rather not waste my time wading through that sort of thing again if I
can help it.

I am almost ready to move to the Ferrari, but am still getting "stick-time"
with the Cooper. Anybody got some good suggestions? Bear in mind that the
peurile ones will be ignored.

Mike


rec.autos.simulators is a usenet newsgroup formed in December, 1993. As this group was always unmoderated there may be some spam or off topic articles included. Some links do point back to racesimcentral.net as we could not validate the original address. Please report any pages that you believe warrant deletion from this archive (include the link in your email). RaceSimCentral.net is in no way responsible and does not endorse any of the content herein.