why bernie doesn't want a direct comparison taken from autosport
website
first want to say I enjoy your work, both past and present. Now my
question is this: a raging debate I have with friends concerns CART
and F1.
I am a fan of both series, however, I tell my CART friends that if an
F1 car and CART car were to lap the same track, say, Circuit Gilles
Villeneuve (because of the impending CART race rumoured to be held
there in 2002 at the expense of Vancouver), the F1 car would be at
least five seconds faster. I would also say that Montoya in the
Ganassi would not outqualify Mazzacane in the Minardi. Could you
perhaps shed an adventurous opinion?
Dino Giorgio, Ottawa, Canada
Dear Dino,
First of all, like you I am a fan of both F1 and CART. If indeed CART
does go to Montreal, to the Circuit Gilles Villeneuve, it will be
fascinating, because it's a very long time since both types of car
have run at the same track in the same year.
Would the F1 cars be "at least five seconds faster", as you suggest?
Until the CART cars have run there, that must remain in the realms of
conjecture. Logically, given that the CART cars are very much heavier,
and do not have carbon brakes, they would be at a severe disadvantage
at a track like Montreal, which puts a premium on braking - but still
I find it hard to imagine Mazzacane's Minardi being quicker than
Montoya in one of Ganassi's Reynards...
It's a very long time now, and the regulations in both series were
different from now, but back in 1978 the Indycars, then competing for
the USAC Championship (the year before CART was launched), came to
England for a couple of races, at Silverstone and Brands Hatch.
This was the beginning of the 'ground effect' era in F1, the year of
domination by the Lotus 79s of Mario Andretti and Ronnie Peterson. At
the USAC race at Silverstone, though, I have never forgotten the sight
of Danny Ongais's Parnelli on its pole lap. This car emphatically did
not have any ground effect technology, but Ongais lapped in 1m16.25s.
At the time, the F1 lap record was 1m 19.60s...
On Sun, 21 Jan 2001 16:55:26 -0500, "Wayne Hutchison"
>You're correct. The dotted lines are the current F1 circuit.
>Wayne
>> Correction, please.
>> *remove* two chicanes. Now *that's* more like it...but won't Bernie be
>> p*ssed if the loathesome Indy cars are faster?
>> --Steve
>> > Michael, et al.,
>> > CART intends to add two chicanes (why?); details here:
>> > http://www.racesimcentral.net/
>> > --Steve Smith
>> > > > Check www.cart.com for details.
>> > > On AtlasF1.com and Autosport.com the articles they have up each state
>> > > that the FIA is expected to demand layout changes to the track. I.e. -
>> > > one layout for F1 and then a different variation for CART.
>> > > Man, I am going to have to save up cash one day to buy an F1 car, a
>CART
>> > > car, and a well known track and figure this ***out all on my own....
>> ;)
>> > > MRSisson
>> > > --
>> > > LOAD "GPL",8,1
>> > > RUN