rec.autos.simulators

Incredibly basic wheel question ... take pity on me !

Mike Roja

Incredibly basic wheel question ... take pity on me !

by Mike Roja » Fri, 12 Jun 1998 04:00:00


> Hi folks,

> This is my first visit to this newsgroup, as I am fairly new to
> driving sims.  I have been persevering with the keyboard when playing
> my assorted games, and thinking about the idea of buying a wheel for
> ages.  My question ........ you know how when using a keyboard, you
> simply have the option of left, right, or straight ahead.  Well, does
> a wheel do the same, or is the steering input actually proportional to
> the amount you turn the wheel.  If so, does this apply to ALL wheels,
> including the el-cheapos?  Lastly, does anyone have specific
> recommendations for an inexpensive but decent quality wheel?  I only
> play games at a fairly basic level, and basically am pretty hopeless,
> so have little need for anything highly customisable or our of the
> ordinary - just a basic wheel so I don't need to use the keyboard any
> more.  Suggestions?

> Cheers,
> Peter.

> To email me, change .com in my address to .au

  Peter,
You will notice a BIG difference with a wheel, even over a joystick Yes
the input is proportional.
My recomendation for a wheel/pedal is either the Thrustmaster T-2 or
Formula Pro (called the NASCAR Pro here in the U.S.) Basicly they are the
same, the Formula Pro being a newer design. Here in the U.S. the T-2 is
about $100 and the FP $125.
There are better, but this one is the biggest bang for the buck!

Mike Rojas

Jeff Morri

Incredibly basic wheel question ... take pity on me !

by Jeff Morri » Fri, 12 Jun 1998 04:00:00

Steering wheels are analogue devices and yes the more you turn the wheel,
the more your computer car turns.  Likewise, the gas/brake are analogue,
so you can apply 1/2 gas or brakes and  it gives you a lot better control
over your computer car.

A very good basic wheel that is relatively inexpensive is the Thrustmaster
Grand Prix 1.  It is a good quality wheel that has a street price of about
$50 US.  I have seen them for as low as $30 with rebates and sales, so if
you look around you can get quite a good deal.  The Grand Prix 1 is only a
wheel and doesn't come with foot pedals, instead it uses hand paddels on
the wheel that actually work quite well.  It also has four buttons, two on
the wheel and two on the base of the unit.  I used a TM:GP1 for about 6
months and really liked it, before upgrading to a higher priced wheel
(TSW).  Thrustmaster also has steering wheels that come with foot pedals,
but they are more expensive (about $100).  So if you can live without foot
pedals, I would suggest the TM:GP1.

Jeff


> Hi folks,

> This is my first visit to this newsgroup, as I am fairly new to
> driving sims.  I have been persevering with the keyboard when playing
> my assorted games, and thinking about the idea of buying a wheel for
> ages.  My question ........ you know how when using a keyboard, you
> simply have the option of left, right, or straight ahead.  Well, does
> a wheel do the same, or is the steering input actually proportional to
> the amount you turn the wheel.  If so, does this apply to ALL wheels,
> including the el-cheapos?  Lastly, does anyone have specific
> recommendations for an inexpensive but decent quality wheel?  I only
> play games at a fairly basic level, and basically am pretty hopeless,
> so have little need for anything highly customisable or our of the
> ordinary - just a basic wheel so I don't need to use the keyboard any
> more.  Suggestions?

> Cheers,
> Peter.

> To email me, change .com in my address to .au

Peter McMill

Incredibly basic wheel question ... take pity on me !

by Peter McMill » Sat, 13 Jun 1998 04:00:00

Hi folks,

This is my first visit to this newsgroup, as I am fairly new to
driving sims.  I have been persevering with the keyboard when playing
my assorted games, and thinking about the idea of buying a wheel for
ages.  My question ........ you know how when using a keyboard, you
simply have the option of left, right, or straight ahead.  Well, does
a wheel do the same, or is the steering input actually proportional to
the amount you turn the wheel.  If so, does this apply to ALL wheels,
including the el-cheapos?  Lastly, does anyone have specific
recommendations for an inexpensive but decent quality wheel?  I only
play games at a fairly basic level, and basically am pretty hopeless,
so have little need for anything highly customisable or our of the
ordinary - just a basic wheel so I don't need to use the keyboard any
more.  Suggestions?

Cheers,
Peter.

To email me, change .com in my address to .au

Andy Jone

Incredibly basic wheel question ... take pity on me !

by Andy Jone » Sat, 13 Jun 1998 04:00:00

Hi Jeff,

Yeah, I'd agree, the Gp1 works pretty well. I've had some trouble with
pots going bad but when its working its fine.

What do you think of the TSW ?

Andy


> Steering wheels are analogue devices and yes the more you turn the wheel,
> the more your computer car turns.  Likewise, the gas/brake are analogue,
> so you can apply 1/2 gas or brakes and  it gives you a lot better control
> over your computer car.

> A very good basic wheel that is relatively inexpensive is the Thrustmaster
> Grand Prix 1.  It is a good quality wheel that has a street price of about
> $50 US.  I have seen them for as low as $30 with rebates and sales, so if
> you look around you can get quite a good deal.  The Grand Prix 1 is only a
> wheel and doesn't come with foot pedals, instead it uses hand paddels on
> the wheel that actually work quite well.  It also has four buttons, two on
> the wheel and two on the base of the unit.  I used a TM:GP1 for about 6
> months and really liked it, before upgrading to a higher priced wheel
> (TSW).  Thrustmaster also has steering wheels that come with foot pedals,
> but they are more expensive (about $100).  So if you can live without foot
> pedals, I would suggest the TM:GP1.

> Jeff


> > Hi folks,

> > This is my first visit to this newsgroup, as I am fairly new to
> > driving sims.  I have been persevering with the keyboard when playing
> > my assorted games, and thinking about the idea of buying a wheel for
> > ages.  My question ........ you know how when using a keyboard, you
> > simply have the option of left, right, or straight ahead.  Well, does
> > a wheel do the same, or is the steering input actually proportional to
> > the amount you turn the wheel.  If so, does this apply to ALL wheels,
> > including the el-cheapos?  Lastly, does anyone have specific
> > recommendations for an inexpensive but decent quality wheel?  I only
> > play games at a fairly basic level, and basically am pretty hopeless,
> > so have little need for anything highly customisable or our of the
> > ordinary - just a basic wheel so I don't need to use the keyboard any
> > more.  Suggestions?

> > Cheers,
> > Peter.

> > To email me, change .com in my address to .au

Paul Jone

Incredibly basic wheel question ... take pity on me !

by Paul Jone » Sat, 13 Jun 1998 04:00:00

Andy - you can't really drive any of racing sims without a wheel.
My Thrustmaster Formula 1 over-twisted in its mountings last night (sob sob) -
the problem with it is that the metal shaft is mounted in plastic and after
throwing it hard through too many corners the plastic mountings wear and the
shaft slips round. (Apologies for the lack of technical nomneclature). The
brake-accelerator microswitch on my old thrustmaster Grand Prix 1 went so now I
sometimes find the brakes stay on. Thrustmaster wheels are great until they go
wrong - the build quality is just not up to it.
What is and where can I buy I sturdy wheel?


> Hi Jeff,

> Yeah, I'd agree, the Gp1 works pretty well. I've had some trouble with
> pots going bad but when its working its fine.

> What do you think of the TSW ?

> Andy


> > Steering wheels are analogue devices and yes the more you turn the wheel,
> > the more your computer car turns.  Likewise, the gas/brake are analogue,
> > so you can apply 1/2 gas or brakes and  it gives you a lot better control
> > over your computer car.

> > A very good basic wheel that is relatively inexpensive is the Thrustmaster
> > Grand Prix 1.  It is a good quality wheel that has a street price of about
> > $50 US.  I have seen them for as low as $30 with rebates and sales, so if
> > you look around you can get quite a good deal.  The Grand Prix 1 is only a
> > wheel and doesn't come with foot pedals, instead it uses hand paddels on
> > the wheel that actually work quite well.  It also has four buttons, two on
> > the wheel and two on the base of the unit.  I used a TM:GP1 for about 6
> > months and really liked it, before upgrading to a higher priced wheel
> > (TSW).  Thrustmaster also has steering wheels that come with foot pedals,
> > but they are more expensive (about $100).  So if you can live without foot
> > pedals, I would suggest the TM:GP1.

> > Jeff


> > > Hi folks,

> > > This is my first visit to this newsgroup, as I am fairly new to
> > > driving sims.  I have been persevering with the keyboard when playing
> > > my assorted games, and thinking about the idea of buying a wheel for
> > > ages.  My question ........ you know how when using a keyboard, you
> > > simply have the option of left, right, or straight ahead.  Well, does
> > > a wheel do the same, or is the steering input actually proportional to
> > > the amount you turn the wheel.  If so, does this apply to ALL wheels,
> > > including the el-cheapos?  Lastly, does anyone have specific
> > > recommendations for an inexpensive but decent quality wheel?  I only
> > > play games at a fairly basic level, and basically am pretty hopeless,
> > > so have little need for anything highly customisable or our of the
> > > ordinary - just a basic wheel so I don't need to use the keyboard any
> > > more.  Suggestions?

> > > Cheers,
> > > Peter.

> > > To email me, change .com in my address to .au

Bruce Kennewel

Incredibly basic wheel question ... take pity on me !

by Bruce Kennewel » Sat, 13 Jun 1998 04:00:00

Wrong!
GPL drives beautifully with a joystick/pedal combo.

One of the very few that do, but there you go!


> Andy - you can't really drive any of racing sims without a wheel.

--
Regards,
Bruce.
----------
The GP Legends Historic Motor Racing Club  is located at:-
http://www.netspeed.com.au/brucek/legends/
Richard Hassel

Incredibly basic wheel question ... take pity on me !

by Richard Hassel » Sat, 13 Jun 1998 04:00:00

Paul Jones schreef:

Yep last night while racing the gaspedal of my T2 broke what a bummer ;-((((

Richard Hasselt

"A lot of people think racing is about going fast. But it's not. It's about
going just slow enough to stay on the track."
===================================================

 My Homepage : http://over.to/rhasselt
 F1 Connections : http://over.to/f1connections
 Team Jordan Grandprix 2  Homepage :
 http://home.worldonline.nl/~barhorst/jordangp2.htm
 Jordan Grandprix 2 is looking for new drivers !!
===================================================

Peter Gag

Incredibly basic wheel question ... take pity on me !

by Peter Gag » Sat, 13 Jun 1998 04:00:00



> Well, does
> >a wheel do the same, or is the steering input actually proportional t
> o
> >the amount you turn the wheel.  

Yes, provided you have an *analogue* device and not a *digital* one?

Analogue = progressive response (the more you turn the wheel, the more
the car turns)

Digital = switched response (only full on or off, nothing in between)

No,  there are some cheap devices that are digital, and this will not
give you the response you are looking for? (eg:- G-Force wheel)

8-)

*Peter*    8-)
(NB: remove asterix to e-mail)

Jeff Morri

Incredibly basic wheel question ... take pity on me !

by Jeff Morri » Sat, 13 Jun 1998 04:00:00

Well, I got the TSW stock and  I am happy with my toy.  I paid $300+ after
shipping, so it isn't cheap, but I think it was worth it.  The TSW stock
consists of a steering wheel with a sequential shifter on the side and floor
pedals.  The unit is hand made out of mostly steel components and mechanically
looks like it should last forever. Instead of a bungee cord, the TSW has two
steel springs for steering wheel tension. The only parts that will go bad over
time are the potentiometers and Thomas Enterprise will send you new ones for
free when you need them.  I  have had my TSW for almost 6 months and it works as
good as day one. I have heard other people on the internet say that they have
been using their unit for x number of months/years and it is still as good as
new (with maybe the exception of putting in new potentiometers). There is a new
version of the TSW called the TSW2 that sells for about $200 and I have heard
good things about it as well, but don't have any first hand experience with it.

Jeff


> Hi Jeff,

> Yeah, I'd agree, the Gp1 works pretty well. I've had some trouble with
> pots going bad but when its working its fine.

> What do you think of the TSW ?

> Andy

David G Fishe

Incredibly basic wheel question ... take pity on me !

by David G Fishe » Sun, 14 Jun 1998 04:00:00

The T2 was being sold for 45.00 after a rebate for awhile. If you can find
that deal again, that would almost definitely be the best way to go.

Dave
(DmndDave)

Jason Mond

Incredibly basic wheel question ... take pity on me !

by Jason Mond » Sun, 14 Jun 1998 04:00:00

I attached my T2 to a TV tray.  Ok. Ok.  It's not as sturdy as a desk, but it
prevents ripping the steering wheel out of the socket :-) Besides, I can quickly
change from steering controller to whatever I'm using next.

My T2 is 2 years old and might need a new steering pot (spraying with cleaner makes

it as good as new, but gets tiresome)  The pedal springs have been changed once.
I bolted a 1 1/4" board behind the pedals to reduce the travel/pressure on the
springs and haven't had any problems since.

A satisfied TM customer.


> My Thrustmaster Formula 1 over-twisted in its mountings last night (sob sob) -
> the problem with it is that the metal shaft is mounted in plastic and after
> throwing it hard through too many corners the plastic mountings wear and the
> shaft slips round. (Apologies for the lack of technical nomneclature). The
> brake-accelerator microswitch on my old thrustmaster Grand Prix 1 went so now I
> sometimes find the brakes stay on. Thrustmaster wheels are great until they go
> wrong - the build quality is just not up to it.

--
-----------------------
Jason Monds
(Remove 'no extra spork' when replying)
stevende

Incredibly basic wheel question ... take pity on me !

by stevende » Fri, 19 Jun 1998 04:00:00

I wasn't sure what to get when I went shopping, but opted
out for inexpensive.  I've never seen anyone else ever
mention this brand, but I  passed on the Nascar and
Thrustmaster for a V3 Interact wheel w/ gas/brake pedals.
It comes with all the joystick buttons on the wheel, and
works better than a joystick I think.  Cost was about $50.
Bonus was free full copy of Need for Speed II (for something
different, and the kids like it better).  I have the wheel
for a year with no problems; steering is a bit sensitive,
but I have nothing to compare it too.  Guess its more not
feeling the torque of real driving.

Steve B.


> Andy - you can't really drive any of racing sims without a wheel.
> My Thrustmaster Formula 1 over-twisted in its mountings last night (sob sob) -
> the problem with it is that the metal shaft is mounted in plastic and after
> throwing it hard through too many corners the plastic mountings wear and the
> shaft slips round. (Apologies for the lack of technical nomneclature). The
> brake-accelerator microswitch on my old thrustmaster Grand Prix 1 went so now I
> sometimes find the brakes stay on. Thrustmaster wheels are great until they go
> wrong - the build quality is just not up to it.
> What is and where can I buy I sturdy wheel?


> > Hi Jeff,

> > Yeah, I'd agree, the Gp1 works pretty well. I've had some trouble with
> > pots going bad but when its working its fine.

> > What do you think of the TSW ?

> > Andy


> > > Steering wheels are analogue devices and yes the more you turn the wheel,
> > > the more your computer car turns.  Likewise, the gas/brake are analogue,
> > > so you can apply 1/2 gas or brakes and  it gives you a lot better control
> > > over your computer car.

> > > A very good basic wheel that is relatively inexpensive is the Thrustmaster
> > > Grand Prix 1.  It is a good quality wheel that has a street price of about
> > > $50 US.  I have seen them for as low as $30 with rebates and sales, so if
> > > you look around you can get quite a good deal.  The Grand Prix 1 is only a
> > > wheel and doesn't come with foot pedals, instead it uses hand paddels on
> > > the wheel that actually work quite well.  It also has four buttons, two on
> > > the wheel and two on the base of the unit.  I used a TM:GP1 for about 6
> > > months and really liked it, before upgrading to a higher priced wheel
> > > (TSW).  Thrustmaster also has steering wheels that come with foot pedals,
> > > but they are more expensive (about $100).  So if you can live without foot
> > > pedals, I would suggest the TM:GP1.

> > > Jeff


> > > > Hi folks,

> > > > This is my first visit to this newsgroup, as I am fairly new to
> > > > driving sims.  I have been persevering with the keyboard when playing
> > > > my assorted games, and thinking about the idea of buying a wheel for
> > > > ages.  My question ........ you know how when using a keyboard, you
> > > > simply have the option of left, right, or straight ahead.  Well, does
> > > > a wheel do the same, or is the steering input actually proportional to
> > > > the amount you turn the wheel.  If so, does this apply to ALL wheels,
> > > > including the el-cheapos?  Lastly, does anyone have specific
> > > > recommendations for an inexpensive but decent quality wheel?  I only
> > > > play games at a fairly basic level, and basically am pretty hopeless,
> > > > so have little need for anything highly customisable or our of the
> > > > ordinary - just a basic wheel so I don't need to use the keyboard any
> > > > more.  Suggestions?

> > > > Cheers,
> > > > Peter.

> > > > To email me, change .com in my address to .au

--
===============
Steve and Deb
Smokin_

Incredibly basic wheel question ... take pity on me !

by Smokin_ » Fri, 19 Jun 1998 04:00:00

I was using a Madcatz wheel/pedal combo (~$50) which is very similar to the
V3, which worked pretty well.  I have since purchased a TM Nascar Pro wheel
which I like better mainly because of the higher effort required to turn the
wheel and better feel of the gas & brake pedal.  The Madcatz works just as
well as the TM, but the steering after a few 1000 or so laps has gotten a
little rough.  I guess whatever kind of bushing (if any ;) isn't of very
good quality in it.

I hope the TM fairs better, only time & laps will tell.

Dan.

|I wasn't sure what to get when I went shopping, but opted
|out for inexpensive.  I've never seen anyone else ever
|mention this brand, but I  passed on the Nascar and
|Thrustmaster for a V3 Interact wheel w/ gas/brake pedals.
|It comes with all the joystick buttons on the wheel, and
|works better than a joystick I think.  Cost was about $50.
|Bonus was free full copy of Need for Speed II (for something
|different, and the kids like it better).  I have the wheel
|for a year with no problems; steering is a bit sensitive,
|but I have nothing to compare it too.  Guess its more not
|feeling the torque of real driving.
|
|Steve B.
|

Erni

Incredibly basic wheel question ... take pity on me !

by Erni » Sat, 20 Jun 1998 04:00:00

We are also using the V3 and it meets our needs.  If you don't use your 3" disk to
configure the wheel, brake and gas setup, the steering isn't as sensitive and drives more
realistically.


>I was using a Madcatz wheel/pedal combo (~$50) which is very similar to the
>V3, which worked pretty well.  I have since purchased a TM Nascar Pro wheel
>which I like better mainly because of the higher effort required to turn the
>wheel and better feel of the gas & brake pedal.  The Madcatz works just as
>well as the TM, but the steering after a few 1000 or so laps has gotten a
>little rough.  I guess whatever kind of bushing (if any ;) isn't of very
>good quality in it.

>I hope the TM fairs better, only time & laps will tell.

>Dan.


>|I wasn't sure what to get when I went shopping, but opted
>|out for inexpensive.  I've never seen anyone else ever
>|mention this brand, but I  passed on the Nascar and
>|Thrustmaster for a V3 Interact wheel w/ gas/brake pedals.
>|It comes with all the joystick buttons on the wheel, and
>|works better than a joystick I think.  Cost was about $50.
>|Bonus was free full copy of Need for Speed II (for something
>|different, and the kids like it better).  I have the wheel
>|for a year with no problems; steering is a bit sensitive,
>|but I have nothing to compare it too.  Guess its more not
>|feeling the torque of real driving.
>|
>|Steve B.
>|


Ernie

rec.autos.simulators is a usenet newsgroup formed in December, 1993. As this group was always unmoderated there may be some spam or off topic articles included. Some links do point back to racesimcentral.net as we could not validate the original address. Please report any pages that you believe warrant deletion from this archive (include the link in your email). RaceSimCentral.net is in no way responsible and does not endorse any of the content herein.