rec.autos.simulators

iRacing: The race that changed my mind!

Asgeir Nesoe

iRacing: The race that changed my mind!

by Asgeir Nesoe » Wed, 27 Aug 2008 17:30:05

A pass, for position or lapping, should always be performed on the
inside, and never on the outside. Outside passing will cause accidents
all the time, and this will make everyone frustrated.

The faster drivers always claim that the slower should give way, because
they, due to their superior speed, have a god-given right of way.

This is untrue in RL racing, and it is untrue in Sim racing. Everyone
with a car on a track on equal terms has a right to be there, and a
faster driver becoming stuck behind a slow driver is the faster drivers
problem.

When that is said, the slower driver should never try to block the
faster driver unless fighting for position. You're allowed to block when
you're fighting for position, but blocking takes time, and will cause
accidents, so you'll have to make up your mind if blocking gets you that
podium finish or not. Most of the time it doesn't, IMO. The best racing
results when you leave room for the passing driver, so that both drivers
can race very hard without risking being pushed off track.

When I approach slower drivers, I just *hate* it when they move over
when I approach them. I may even hate that more than the slower driver
being mindless of what happens behind him, because moving over upsets
everyones rythms, and it's accident prone.

The correct way of letting by a faster driver at the end of a straight
is holding your line, all the way to the outside, braking a bit early so
that you don't run off, and just wait for the faster driver to pass on
the inside. This is the way it is done in RL, and this is the way it
should be done in sim racing.

---A---


Gary

iRacing: The race that changed my mind!

by Gary » Wed, 27 Aug 2008 23:35:33

While I agree with the part about the slower driver no altering his
driving line I don't agree about the ouside pass. A faster driver will
plan and execute a safe pass using the information gathered while
following the driver in front of him. What messes this up is the
slower driver changeing his/her behavior at the last minute. Inside,
outside, is of no consequence in sims, just as in RL racing. I
currently RL race more than I sim race (almost never during the
summer) so maybe in sims you should act differently?

>A pass, for position or lapping, should always be performed on the
>inside, and never on the outside. Outside passing will cause accidents
>all the time, and this will make everyone frustrated.
>---A---

David Fisher's Left Testicl

iRacing: The race that changed my mind!

by David Fisher's Left Testicl » Thu, 28 Aug 2008 00:28:33




>>Complete with beginning ,
>> middle and hopefully a happy end.

> Ah, another Disney fan, I see. Unfortunately, Disney is not reality.

He said 'hopefully' not 'definitely'!
Rob

iRacing: The race that changed my mind!

by Rob » Thu, 28 Aug 2008 00:58:52


> A pass, for position or lapping, should always be performed on the inside,
> and never on the outside. Outside passing will cause accidents all the
> time, and this will make everyone frustrated.

> The faster drivers always claim that the slower should give way, because
> they, due to their superior speed, have a god-given right of way.

> This is untrue in RL racing, and it is untrue in Sim racing. Everyone with
> a car on a track on equal terms has a right to be there, and a faster
> driver becoming stuck behind a slow driver is the faster drivers problem.

> When that is said, the slower driver should never try to block the faster
> driver unless fighting for position. You're allowed to block when you're
> fighting for position, but blocking takes time, and will cause accidents,
> so you'll have to make up your mind if blocking gets you that podium
> finish or not. Most of the time it doesn't, IMO. The best racing results
> when you leave room for the passing driver, so that both drivers can race
> very hard without risking being pushed off track.

> When I approach slower drivers, I just *hate* it when they move over when
> I approach them. I may even hate that more than the slower driver being
> mindless of what happens behind him, because moving over upsets everyones
> rythms, and it's accident prone.

> The correct way of letting by a faster driver at the end of a straight is
> holding your line, all the way to the outside, braking a bit early so that
> you don't run off, and just wait for the faster driver to pass on the
> inside. This is the way it is done in RL, and this is the way it should be
> done in sim racing.

> ---A---



This seems like good advice. On the current track of Laguna I don't get
lapped, I guess I'm just fast enough to stop this. At Lime Rock I will put
this into practice. On the straight I will hold my line, but brake a little
earlier so that I can take the whole bend on the outside line (the left). I
will need to practice this first as I don't know what the camber does there
at the mo and I wouldn't want to upset the car and send it off the track.

I wish iRacing would publish a newbie guide of race craft with info such as
this. Otherwise we all develop our own means of dealing with fast cars,
which as you rightly point out isn't optimal.

RobP

Larr

iRacing: The race that changed my mind!

by Larr » Thu, 28 Aug 2008 02:19:12

No one expects anyone to pass on the outside at a RC.  Does it happen?
Sure.  But the odds against it going well are FAR worse than a normal,
expected inside pass.

The odds just are not with you.

Generally speaking, of course.

-Larry


> While I agree with the part about the slower driver no altering his
> driving line I don't agree about the ouside pass. A faster driver will
> plan and execute a safe pass using the information gathered while
> following the driver in front of him. What messes this up is the
> slower driver changeing his/her behavior at the last minute. Inside,
> outside, is of no consequence in sims, just as in RL racing. I
> currently RL race more than I sim race (almost never during the
> summer) so maybe in sims you should act differently?

>>On Tue, 26 Aug 2008 10:30:05 +0200, Asgeir Nesoen

>>A pass, for position or lapping, should always be performed on the
>>inside, and never on the outside. Outside passing will cause accidents
>>all the time, and this will make everyone frustrated.
>>---A---

Larr

iRacing: The race that changed my mind!

by Larr » Thu, 28 Aug 2008 02:24:40

I actually have no issues whatsoever about getting lapped.  Really, it
doesn't bug me in the least.  As long as the guy lapping me is paying
attention and doesn't punt/bully me out of the way.

When it comes to RC's right now, for me, I'm racing myself and the track.
Everything else is just a required distraction :)

Road racing is new to me.  With the exception of a few Cup RC's in Rascar, I
never ran them.  Not until about 4 years ago when I came aboard iRacing.
I've considerably behind everyone else in this regard.

At least I don't HATE them any more :)

-Larry


Asgeir Nesoe

iRacing: The race that changed my mind!

by Asgeir Nesoe » Fri, 29 Aug 2008 18:08:18

The braking early bit is only approprioate when the lapper moves to your
inside before approaching the braking zone; this way he'll pass you well
before turn-in, and you'll make the turn with full control, nice line,
and therefore you'll get the maximum exit speed despite being overtaking
previously...

If he stays on your line as you approach the braking zone, you should
NOT brake early, as this will surely set up things nicely for a possibly
race-ruining event...

The main thing is to get the lapper past you as quickly as possible
without upsetting his or your line. If you let him by during braking,
you'll be ready for the turn just like on any lap, and he'll make his
turn-in without worrying about what takes place on the outside.

---A---




>> A pass, for position or lapping, should always be performed on the
>> inside, and never on the outside. Outside passing will cause accidents
>> all the time, and this will make everyone frustrated.

>> The faster drivers always claim that the slower should give way,
>> because they, due to their superior speed, have a god-given right of way.

>> This is untrue in RL racing, and it is untrue in Sim racing. Everyone
>> with a car on a track on equal terms has a right to be there, and a
>> faster driver becoming stuck behind a slow driver is the faster
>> drivers problem.

>> When that is said, the slower driver should never try to block the
>> faster driver unless fighting for position. You're allowed to block
>> when you're fighting for position, but blocking takes time, and will
>> cause accidents, so you'll have to make up your mind if blocking gets
>> you that podium finish or not. Most of the time it doesn't, IMO. The
>> best racing results when you leave room for the passing driver, so
>> that both drivers can race very hard without risking being pushed off
>> track.

>> When I approach slower drivers, I just *hate* it when they move over
>> when I approach them. I may even hate that more than the slower driver
>> being mindless of what happens behind him, because moving over upsets
>> everyones rythms, and it's accident prone.

>> The correct way of letting by a faster driver at the end of a straight
>> is holding your line, all the way to the outside, braking a bit early
>> so that you don't run off, and just wait for the faster driver to pass
>> on the inside. This is the way it is done in RL, and this is the way
>> it should be done in sim racing.

>> ---A---


> This seems like good advice. On the current track of Laguna I don't get
> lapped, I guess I'm just fast enough to stop this. At Lime Rock I will
> put this into practice. On the straight I will hold my line, but brake a
> little earlier so that I can take the whole bend on the outside line
> (the left). I will need to practice this first as I don't know what the
> camber does there at the mo and I wouldn't want to upset the car and
> send it off the track.

> I wish iRacing would publish a newbie guide of race craft with info such
> as this. Otherwise we all develop our own means of dealing with fast
> cars, which as you rightly point out isn't optimal.

> RobP

pdot..

iRacing: The race that changed my mind!

by pdot.. » Fri, 29 Aug 2008 22:59:24


That's ridiculous.  Look here:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nl3yP7JeAZI

--
Pat Dotson

Gary

iRacing: The race that changed my mind!

by Gary » Sat, 30 Aug 2008 01:26:16

I agree. They got the track down well but they must have scanned it
when it was smooth, as this is what it was like two weeks ago..
http://www.vimeo.com/1551363

GR



>> A pass, for position or lapping, should always be performed on the
>> inside, and never on the outside. Outside passing will cause accidents
>> all the time, and this will make everyone frustrated.

>That's ridiculous.  Look here:

>http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nl3yP7JeAZI

Asgeir Nesoe

iRacing: The race that changed my mind!

by Asgeir Nesoe » Sat, 30 Aug 2008 17:25:23

I never said outside passing cannot be done, I just said that passes
should be performed on the inside, as a general rule.

In addition the inside/outside pass was discussed here in context of
being lapped. You should try to pass a backmarker when he tries to get
you around him on the outside. If there is at all doubts about inside or
outside pass when passing a backmarker, accidents will occur. All the time.

If a racer consistently tries to pass on the outside, he'll see plenty
of accidents, that is what I meant.

Safe outside passing takes place from time to time, but safe inside
passing takes place *all* the time...

---A---



>> A pass, for position or lapping, should always be performed on the
>> inside, and never on the outside. Outside passing will cause accidents
>> all the time, and this will make everyone frustrated.

> That's ridiculous.  Look here:

> http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nl3yP7JeAZI

> --
> Pat Dotson

Byron Forbe

iRacing: The race that changed my mind!

by Byron Forbe » Sat, 30 Aug 2008 18:34:28

    You can stick that in the software you're working on -

IF pass outside attempted

THEN GOTO JAIL, do not pass start/finish line, do not collect winners
pearse.

ELSE continue

STOP

END


>I never said outside passing cannot be done, I just said that passes should
>be performed on the inside, as a general rule.

> In addition the inside/outside pass was discussed here in context of being
> lapped. You should try to pass a backmarker when he tries to get you
> around him on the outside. If there is at all doubts about inside or
> outside pass when passing a backmarker, accidents will occur. All the
> time.

> If a racer consistently tries to pass on the outside, he'll see plenty of
> accidents, that is what I meant.

> Safe outside passing takes place from time to time, but safe inside
> passing takes place *all* the time...

> ---A---



>>> A pass, for position or lapping, should always be performed on the
>>> inside, and never on the outside. Outside passing will cause accidents
>>> all the time, and this will make everyone frustrated.

>> That's ridiculous.  Look here:

>> http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nl3yP7JeAZI

>> --
>> Pat Dotson

Larr

iRacing: The race that changed my mind!

by Larr » Sat, 30 Aug 2008 22:29:27

In GENERAL terms, passing on the inside IS historically safer, and generally
the more-expected method of passing.  This doesn't mean that outside passing
doesn't work, but it isn't going to be expected by the majority.  Just look
at the mess that F1 drivers get themselves into when they try it :)

-Larry



That's ridiculous.  Look here:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nl3yP7JeAZI

--
Pat Dotson

Byron Forbe

iRacing: The race that changed my mind!

by Byron Forbe » Sun, 31 Aug 2008 08:25:11

    If the lead driver is blocking the inside line then, especially in real
life due to dust, etc, he needs to brake earlier. Even without the dust
factor, the geometry of the situation demands this as well, especially if he
is considerate enough (yes, a BIG if) to make sure he will not end up on the
outside line due to braking too late. Point is, if the lead car makes his
intentions to block the inside clear then an attempted pass on the outside
is completely legitimate and actually common sense.

    And really, the main point here is not situation, but the discipline of
the drivers in play. Remember Montoya pulling that move off on, of all
people, Michael Schumacher?


> In GENERAL terms, passing on the inside IS historically safer, and
> generally the more-expected method of passing.  This doesn't mean that
> outside passing doesn't work, but it isn't going to be expected by the
> majority.  Just look at the mess that F1 drivers get themselves into when
> they try it :)

> -Larry




>> A pass, for position or lapping, should always be performed on the
>> inside, and never on the outside. Outside passing will cause accidents
>> all the time, and this will make everyone frustrated.

> That's ridiculous.  Look here:

> http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nl3yP7JeAZI

> --
> Pat Dotson


rec.autos.simulators is a usenet newsgroup formed in December, 1993. As this group was always unmoderated there may be some spam or off topic articles included. Some links do point back to racesimcentral.net as we could not validate the original address. Please report any pages that you believe warrant deletion from this archive (include the link in your email). RaceSimCentral.net is in no way responsible and does not endorse any of the content herein.