rec.autos.simulators

Braking Too Easy?

Damien Smit

Braking Too Easy?

by Damien Smit » Sun, 10 Feb 2002 22:02:13

That's a fair point.  It's as if 'low' anti-lock braking is enabled at all
times.  I'm not aware of real F1 cars having any form of 'intelligent'
brakes.

--
Damien Smith

ICQ: 77028579
F1 2001 rank: +27.680

Haqsa

Braking Too Easy?

by Haqsa » Mon, 11 Feb 2002 02:01:41

Good questions.  I haven't tried some of the things you have, and I
don't know of any good article on F1 braking performance, so I can't
answer most of them.  Most of what I said is based on what I have heard
from people more familiar with F1 than I.  However here are a couple of
things to think about.

First, the brake pressure in the setups is arbitrarily low, and you
can't adjust it from the standard F1 2001 menus.  If you get Turner's
setup tool from http://members.rogers.com/nwalkz or the advanced options
menu from http://www.rsdg.net/ you can raise the brake pressure quite a
bit, and they do seem to lock a bit earlier if you do that.

Secondly F1 2001 attributes a substantial amount of downforce to the
diffuser, so even if you knock both wings off you are still being glued
to the road pretty hard.  The diffuser's downforce is height sensitive,
however even raising the car to the max ride height is not sufficient to
remove all the downforce.  At the base ride height of the Williams, for
example, the diffuser alone has a lift coefficient of -0.932.  I'm not
sure what the frontal area of an F1 car is, but making some rough
estimates the diffuser alone should be capable of around 100 lbs of
downforce at 50 mph, more if you have it running at the nose down
attitude typical of most setups.

I will admit however, after doing some rough calculations, that it seems
like if you knock the front wing off you ought to be able to lock the
fronts at any speed.  The diffuser force is primarily on the rear
wheels, meaning you still should not be able to lock the rears at any
significant speed, only the fronts.

The only other explanation I have for this is brake heat.  F1 2001 does
appear to model brake heat, and defaults the brake ducts to a relatively
high setting.  You can change the brake duct setting with the tools
mentioned above.  Brakes have an optimum operating temperature, so maybe
with good brake ducts you might not be able to get them hot enough at
high speeds.  Just a guess, really.

One thing I just tried to test what I just said was to run the Williams
with maximum brake pressure and minimum brake duct settings.  I should
have messed with the wings too, but I didn't.  Anyway I was able to get
front wheel lock up at 120 kph, which I think is about 75 mph.  So
basically I think F1 2001's physics model is working right, but there
are some parameters that you should be able to adjust that you can't,
unless you get one of the setup tools listed above; and the downforce is
more effective than you might expect.



Eldre

Braking Too Easy?

by Eldre » Tue, 12 Feb 2002 10:54:47



>Incidentally have you come to any conclusions with the controller
>settings for F1-2001.

>I have yet to find that magic "feel" setting - but judging from
>other posts others I feel I am missing something - any further
>thoughts?

Yes - they SUCK...  F1 2001(and other EA products) don't seem to have settings
that are very 'intuitive'.  David has given me suggestions that should help,
but I haven't had time to experiment yet.  Since when should it be this
difficult to tweak a NON-ff wheel?  <sigh>
There's a lot more 'feel' out there, we just have to work harder for it. :(

Eldred
--
Dale Earnhardt, Sr. R.I.P. 1951-2001
Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett
GPLRank - under construction...

Never argue with an idiot.  He brings you down to his level, then beats you
with experience...
Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.

Dave Henri

Braking Too Easy?

by Dave Henri » Tue, 12 Feb 2002 12:18:23

"EldredP">
(snip)
 Since when should it be this
   I spent tons of time getting my f1 CS 2001 brakes to NOT lockup, then I
see threads here that complain cuz they CAN'T lockup the brakes.  I'm
thinking this was an EA feature fix due to customer input.(just a guess
about that tho..)
dave henrie

Damien Smi

Braking Too Easy?

by Damien Smi » Tue, 12 Feb 2002 15:16:05

I seem to be able to lock the brakes at 200kph+ speeds in the GT mod.
I guess the F1 brake performance could only be commmented on by
someone 'in the know'


rec.autos.simulators is a usenet newsgroup formed in December, 1993. As this group was always unmoderated there may be some spam or off topic articles included. Some links do point back to racesimcentral.net as we could not validate the original address. Please report any pages that you believe warrant deletion from this archive (include the link in your email). RaceSimCentral.net is in no way responsible and does not endorse any of the content herein.