rec.autos.simulators

OT: TFT Monitor advice?

Rick Catto

OT: TFT Monitor advice?

by Rick Catto » Thu, 23 Feb 2006 08:11:41

Hi - we're looking to upgrade the old faithful CRT for something that takes
up a bit less room on the desktop following a PC relocation. I'd like to buy
a decent TFT monitor and have been reading lots of stuff about various
manufacturers and specs. However, there is one question bothering me that's
not been answered elsewhere and I'm sure people in here will be able to
answer it for me.

'Widescreen' versus 4:3. What do I really want if I'm running desktop app's
and plenty of GTL, GPL, rFactor etc, and can my system handle the 1440 x 900
required to run a w/screen unit? (P4 3.0 with 2gb RAM & GeForce 6800XT.)

Virtually every site I've seen says that it's pretty much essential to run
these monitors at their native resolution...are these resolutions supported
in the titles above (and others generally) or can the card/monitor reach a
compromise?

Finally, any recommendations for kit in the UK? Viewsonic seem to be
well-respected, and Dell - budget of between 200-300.

Thanks in advance for any advice, and apologies if it seems a bit simple - I
just like to get it right when I'm spending!

Regards

Rick.

test

OT: TFT Monitor advice?

by test » Thu, 23 Feb 2006 09:01:29

I was worried about making the switch from CRT, I was using a Sony 21"
Trintion and went to the Dell 24' Widescreen and could not be happer, This
monitor is awesome, It has to run at 1900x1200 but, so far have not found
anything that did not run and look great.

John Smit

OT: TFT Monitor advice?

by John Smit » Thu, 23 Feb 2006 11:08:20

I have a 15.4 on my laptop that runs a 1920 x 1200 native res. and it has a
ati 9200 gc that will automatically adjust the screen to fit. I don't race
on it, but everything else works fine. That 24" dell is going to be my next
monitor, unless something else better and cheaper comes along. Go for the
widescreen..
Andi Col

OT: TFT Monitor advice?

by Andi Col » Fri, 24 Feb 2006 02:32:17

Widescreen under 300 in the UK may be pushing things a bit. I have a
Viewsonic VX924 - the worlds fastest TFT (or so they claim). I'm waiting for
a 'fast' widescreen to be made available and by that I mean a pixel response
time of around 4ms.

http://www.viewsoniceurope.com/UK/Products/LCDX/VX2025wm.htm is pretty close
but response times look like they could be 16ms.

Or this
http://www.savastore.com/productinfo/product.aspx?catalog_name=Savast...

I've seen good reports of the Dell monitor already mentioned but it's only
16ms and 700 in the UK. Dells 20" wide screen is 500.

Andi.


Larr

OT: TFT Monitor advice?

by Larr » Fri, 24 Feb 2006 03:13:33

I use both an Hyundai L90D+ (4:3) and now a Gateway 21" Widescreen (16:10)
and both have been fine for ***.

NR2003 works perfectly for me at 1680X1050 (on an nVidia 7800GTX).  Only the
menu's remain in 4:3.  Once in-car, it's widescreen.

-Larry


Larr

OT: TFT Monitor advice?

by Larr » Fri, 24 Feb 2006 03:14:22

Man, dat there is some dense pixels :)

-Larry


Rick Catto

OT: TFT Monitor advice?

by Rick Catto » Fri, 24 Feb 2006 04:27:39

Interesting! The second Viewsonic, the VA1912W, is one that's already on my
list. I've heard good things about the brand, and it seems to tick all the
right boxes for me at the moment -price included.

Couple of questions, of course!

Is 8ms sufficiently fast for ***?
Has anyone had experience of this model or anything similar that could
persuade/dissuade me?

Thanks to all who have replied so far - v. helpful.

Can anyone clarify what actually happens when a piece of software doesn't
support a particular resolution...does the monitor attempt to replicate the
resolution the game can handle (and therefore lose image quality) or does it
ignore extra pixels and display the given resolution 'in the middle' of the
screen, leaving vertical black bands on either side?

Many thanks again,

Regards,

Rick.

Mika Takal

OT: TFT Monitor advice?

by Mika Takal » Fri, 24 Feb 2006 04:35:55

Hi

I got a Vp191b during the summer, just before it got replaced by almost the
same monitor called Vp930. I'm totally happy with this device, although it
is not widescreen.

I did not get a widescreen monitor just because 5:4 19" is bigger than a
widescreen 20" monitor in terms of display area - and widescreen support is,
in my opinion, still in developtment in *** use.

8ms is enough for your typical racing sims and I couldn't see any
dragging/lag even in HL2.

--
Mika Takala

scot

OT: TFT Monitor advice?

by scot » Fri, 24 Feb 2006 06:29:13


Should be fine, mine is 16ms and I don't notice any problems at all with
racing sims.  Beware though, that time is not always a good comparison
figure, especially between different brands.  Best to go and actually try it
with a game if you can.  Reason being is that time is only to switch from
black to white and back to black again.  In reality most switches are
between different grey levels and these can be waaaay longer depending on
the LC technology used.

Most monitors and GFX cards will have options to determine what to do in
these situations.  And as with most things, the quality of the resolution
resampling varies, some monitors do it quite well (using some sort of
interpolation I guess) and it's fine for playing games.  I often use my
monitor at lower than native because my PC isn't powerful enough to get good
frame-rates at native.

scot

OT: TFT Monitor advice?

by scot » Fri, 24 Feb 2006 06:34:06


Not when you compare it to PDAs and cellphones :-)

> -Larry



>> I have a 15.4 on my laptop that runs a 1920 x 1200 native res. and
>> it has a ati 9200 gc that will automatically adjust the screen to
>> fit. I don't race on it, but everything else works fine. That 24"
>> dell is going to be my next monitor, unless something else better
>> and cheaper comes along. Go for the widescreen..

Larr

OT: TFT Monitor advice?

by Larr » Sat, 25 Feb 2006 02:40:24

I don't let mine resample.  I have it set to use the games resolution at the
monitors proper resolution.

If that sounds confusing, keep this in mind.  It results in black borders,
which I find far more acceptable than LCD interpolation.

-Larry




>>> http://www.racesimcentral.net/
>>> pretty close
>>> but response times look like they could be 16ms.

>>> Or this
>>> http://www.racesimcentral.net/

>> Interesting! The second Viewsonic, the VA1912W, is one that's
>> already on my list. I've heard good things about the brand, and it
>> seems to tick all the right boxes for me at the moment -price
>> included.
>> Couple of questions, of course!

>> Is 8ms sufficiently fast for ***?

> Should be fine, mine is 16ms and I don't notice any problems at all with
> racing sims.  Beware though, that time is not always a good comparison
> figure, especially between different brands.  Best to go and actually try
> it with a game if you can.  Reason being is that time is only to switch
> from black to white and back to black again.  In reality most switches are
> between different grey levels and these can be waaaay longer depending on
> the LC technology used.

>> Can anyone clarify what actually happens when a piece of software
>> doesn't support a particular resolution...does the monitor attempt
>> to replicate the resolution the game can handle (and therefore lose
>> image quality) or does it ignore extra pixels and display the given
>> resolution 'in the middle' of the screen, leaving vertical black
>> bands on either side?

> Most monitors and GFX cards will have options to determine what to do in
> these situations.  And as with most things, the quality of the resolution
> resampling varies, some monitors do it quite well (using some sort of
> interpolation I guess) and it's fine for playing games.  I often use my
> monitor at lower than native because my PC isn't powerful enough to get
> good frame-rates at native.

scot

OT: TFT Monitor advice?

by scot » Sun, 26 Feb 2006 06:55:59


Yes I know what you mean :-)  Of course it varies from monitor to monitor
how good the resampling will be (my work LCD has 4 different settings for
different resampling methods, the best ones makes even the windows desktop
look ok), and how far you sit from the screen, and how big the pixels are.

Peasan

OT: TFT Monitor advice?

by Peasan » Mon, 27 Feb 2006 07:11:21


> Yes I know what you mean :-)  Of course it varies from monitor to monitor
> how good the resampling will be (my work LCD has 4 different settings for
> different resampling methods, the best ones makes even the windows desktop
> look ok), and how far you sit from the screen, and how big the pixels are.

What LCD unit that has those settings? The reason I refuse to use LCD
for my main *** computer is because many games don't support the
LCD's native res. I don't want black borders around my games either.
I have an LCD but it is hooked to a non-*** computer, although; I do
have a few games installed on it but they all support 1280x1024.
Larr

OT: TFT Monitor advice?

by Larr » Wed, 01 Mar 2006 01:54:26

You have to choose one or the other.  Nature of the beast.

-Larry



> What LCD unit that has those settings? The reason I refuse to use LCD for
> my main *** computer is because many games don't support the LCD's
> native res. I don't want black borders around my games either.
> I have an LCD but it is hooked to a non-*** computer, although; I do
> have a few games installed on it but they all support 1280x1024.


rec.autos.simulators is a usenet newsgroup formed in December, 1993. As this group was always unmoderated there may be some spam or off topic articles included. Some links do point back to racesimcentral.net as we could not validate the original address. Please report any pages that you believe warrant deletion from this archive (include the link in your email). RaceSimCentral.net is in no way responsible and does not endorse any of the content herein.