rec.autos.simulators

Your thoughts on Motor City Online?

andre

Your thoughts on Motor City Online?

by andre » Wed, 04 Apr 2001 22:52:44

Mine -

1) Graphics look great.

2) How much will it cost?

3) Will it simply be added to ***edcompany.com because it's
subscription?

himrli..

Your thoughts on Motor City Online?

by himrli.. » Thu, 05 Apr 2001 05:57:33

1) Yes

2) No clue

3) Probably

On Tue, 03 Apr 2001 13:52:44 GMT, andrew


>Mine -

>1) Graphics look great.

>2) How much will it cost?

>3) Will it simply be added to ***edcompany.com because it's
>subscription?

Remove "hi" from address or it will bounce....
andre

Your thoughts on Motor City Online?

by andre » Thu, 05 Apr 2001 22:46:10

Yeah, and I think the response to this post shows the direction in which
the sim will go....

> 1) Yes

> 2) No clue

> 3) Probably

> On Tue, 03 Apr 2001 13:52:44 GMT, andrew

> >Mine -

> >1) Graphics look great.

> >2) How much will it cost?

> >3) Will it simply be added to ***edcompany.com because it's
> >subscription?

> Remove "hi" from address or it will bounce....

himrli..

Your thoughts on Motor City Online?

by himrli.. » Thu, 05 Apr 2001 23:06:19

Seems like it, doesn't it.

My guess is that Motor City Online will --
depending on the rate at which EA continues to
lose money -- either be patched by EA to offer
singleplayer offline play, repackaged as a
singleplayer offline game by EA or cracked by some
clever programmer to enable singleplayer offline
play.  Given how rapidly the economy is cooling,
it's hard to imagine a subscription service based
on fixing up and racing virtual cars making a go
of it.

On Wed, 04 Apr 2001 13:46:10 GMT, andrew


>Yeah, and I think the response to this post shows the direction in which
>the sim will go....


>> 1) Yes

>> 2) No clue

>> 3) Probably

>> On Tue, 03 Apr 2001 13:52:44 GMT, andrew

>> >Mine -

>> >1) Graphics look great.

>> >2) How much will it cost?

>> >3) Will it simply be added to ***edcompany.com because it's
>> >subscription?

>> Remove "hi" from address or it will bounce....

Remove "hi" from address or it will bounce....
andre

Your thoughts on Motor City Online?

by andre » Thu, 05 Apr 2001 23:44:45

Definitely.

Hell, I probably wouldn't even consider buying it even if it *had*
single-player mode just because of the subscription service needed to play
online. That's just lame!

If EA was smart, their little virtual town would have contracts with
manufacturers for name-brand parts, such as Firestone, Fram, Snap-On, and
Craftsman, and places like McDonald's, Sears, Pep Boys and Safeway, it would
eliminate the need for subscriptions because of all the advertising money...

Ah, if only I could make money on ideas...

But, maybe that's crazy talk. It's the marketing profession coming out in
me...

Sheesh...


> Seems like it, doesn't it.

> My guess is that Motor City Online will --
> depending on the rate at which EA continues to
> lose money -- either be patched by EA to offer
> singleplayer offline play, repackaged as a
> singleplayer offline game by EA or cracked by some
> clever programmer to enable singleplayer offline
> play.  Given how rapidly the economy is cooling,
> it's hard to imagine a subscription service based
> on fixing up and racing virtual cars making a go
> of it.

> On Wed, 04 Apr 2001 13:46:10 GMT, andrew

> >Yeah, and I think the response to this post shows the direction in which
> >the sim will go....


> >> 1) Yes

> >> 2) No clue

> >> 3) Probably

> >> On Tue, 03 Apr 2001 13:52:44 GMT, andrew

> >> >Mine -

> >> >1) Graphics look great.

> >> >2) How much will it cost?

> >> >3) Will it simply be added to ***edcompany.com because it's
> >> >subscription?

> >> Remove "hi" from address or it will bounce....

> Remove "hi" from address or it will bounce....

andre

Your thoughts on Motor City Online?

by andre » Fri, 06 Apr 2001 02:50:38

Hi Todd -

I agree, to some extent. Don't forget, however, that is is also possible to
(in other games, anyway) to set up "passworded" games where only select people
could get in.

I want to like it too, I'm just afraid I'll never get the chance...


> I can see where you guys are coming from, and maybe my response stems
> from the fact that I REALLY want to like MC when it comes out. But,
> think of it this way -- if it is a pay service then chances are you
> won't get a lot of people in there just screwing around and messing up
> those of us who really want to play seriously. That is one problem
> that I have experienced with online racing and many others have
> mentioned here. And from what I have read about how MC is going to
> work, it would really suck to build up your car through hours of
> gameplay and then lose it because some jackass 12 year old has nothing
> better to do than jump on a server and see how many people he can
>***up.

> Having said that, if I am going to pay a monthly fee, it better be a
> damn excellent online environment. If I don't feel like I am actually
> living in 1969 I ain't gonna keep paying! :-)

> Todd Walker
> twalker at jam dot rr dot com
> http://www.racesimcentral.net/


> >Definitely.

> >Hell, I probably wouldn't even consider buying it even if it *had*
> >single-player mode just because of the subscription service needed to play
> >online. That's just lame!

Groo the Wandere

Your thoughts on Motor City Online?

by Groo the Wandere » Fri, 06 Apr 2001 05:45:47


> Seems like it, doesn't it.

> My guess is that Motor City Online will --
> depending on the rate at which EA continues to
> lose money -- either be patched by EA to offer
> singleplayer offline play, repackaged as a
> singleplayer offline game by EA or cracked by some
> clever programmer to enable singleplayer offline
> play.  Given how rapidly the economy is cooling,
> it's hard to imagine a subscription service based
> on fixing up and racing virtual cars making a go
> of it.

You'd be surprised how many people are playing Everquest, Asheron's call
and Ultima Online. They all pay ten dollars a month. I like the concept
but not the car selection. I would have preferred a selection like in
Gran Turismo.

  .-~~-.____          
 / |  '     \
(  )         O       _
 \_/-, ,----'       //
    ====        ___//  
    /  \-'~;   /~~~(O)------------------------------------------
   /  __/~| __/      |"Beauty is in the eyes of the beer holder"
==(______| (_________|

himrli..

Your thoughts on Motor City Online?

by himrli.. » Fri, 06 Apr 2001 05:55:56

While it's true that there are other successful
online games, I would suggest that they offer
something very different from what MCO is
offering.  I am not sure how many fans of sim
racing are eager to pay to race online when they
can race online and offline for free.  Or are
eager to pay to be part of an online community
when they can be part of an online community for
free.  And then there is the matter of the car
selection.  I love it, but I would not pay to play
anymore than I would pay to play Porsche
Unleashed.  And I LOVE Porsche Unleashed.  Then
there is the matter of bandwidth.  I could be
wrong on this point, but I suspect online racing
might not be so impressive with a dial-up modem.
And that is all I and a number of other sim fans
have access to.  (The future is never available as
shown where I wind up living.)

We'll just have to see whether motorheads flock to
MCO or not.  Meanwhile, I am waiting for Rally
Trophy from Bugbear.  THAT looks like HUGE fun.
:)

On Wed, 04 Apr 2001 16:45:47 -0400, Groo the



>> Seems like it, doesn't it.

>> My guess is that Motor City Online will --
>> depending on the rate at which EA continues to
>> lose money -- either be patched by EA to offer
>> singleplayer offline play, repackaged as a
>> singleplayer offline game by EA or cracked by some
>> clever programmer to enable singleplayer offline
>> play.  Given how rapidly the economy is cooling,
>> it's hard to imagine a subscription service based
>> on fixing up and racing virtual cars making a go
>> of it.

>You'd be surprised how many people are playing Everquest, Asheron's call
>and Ultima Online. They all pay ten dollars a month. I like the concept
>but not the car selection. I would have preferred a selection like in
>Gran Turismo.

>  .-~~-.____          
> / |  '     \
>(  )         O       _
> \_/-, ,----'       //
>    ====        ___//  
>    /  \-'~;   /~~~(O)------------------------------------------
>   /  __/~| __/      |"Beauty is in the eyes of the beer holder"
>==(______| (_________|

Remove "hi" from address or it will bounce....
Roger Squire

Your thoughts on Motor City Online?

by Roger Squire » Fri, 06 Apr 2001 06:48:55

    I raced NFS5 online for several months on a 33k modem, and the
performance was generally excellent.  And those servers were just the betas
for MCO.

    As for MCO itself I think you'd be surprised how attractive a persistant
game-world could be to racing fans.

rms

The Enigmatic O

Your thoughts on Motor City Online?

by The Enigmatic O » Fri, 06 Apr 2001 07:40:13


says...

        I rather agree.  I think this one will grab some types that don't
generally go for most racing sims or online games.

        My prediction is that this one hits it _really_ big.  Ultima Online
big.

                                        -Tim

himrli..

Your thoughts on Motor City Online?

by himrli.. » Fri, 06 Apr 2001 08:00:50

As I said, we'll just have to see whether
motorheads flock to it or not.  Ladies and
gentlemen, place your bets....

On Wed, 04 Apr 2001 22:40:13 GMT,


>says...

>>    As for MCO itself I think you'd be surprised how attractive a persistant
>>game-world could be to racing fans.

>    I rather agree.  I think this one will grab some types that don't
>generally go for most racing sims or online games.

>    My prediction is that this one hits it _really_ big.  Ultima Online
>big.

>                                    -Tim

Remove "hi" from address or it will bounce....
John Bod

Your thoughts on Motor City Online?

by John Bod » Sat, 07 Apr 2001 04:38:35

My guess is it won't be the motorheads and sim racing fans that make
or break this one -- it will be whether or not it appeals to the
general *** public.  If it succeeds with the general *** public,
then it will be interesting to see what affect that will have on sim
racing in general (and it may not necessarily be a good impact).

-- JB


>As I said, we'll just have to see whether
>motorheads flock to it or not.  Ladies and
>gentlemen, place your bets....

>On Wed, 04 Apr 2001 22:40:13 GMT,


>>says...

>>>    As for MCO itself I think you'd be surprised how attractive a persistant
>>>game-world could be to racing fans.

>>        I rather agree.  I think this one will grab some types that don't
>>generally go for most racing sims or online games.

>>        My prediction is that this one hits it _really_ big.  Ultima Online
>>big.

>>                                        -Tim

>Remove "hi" from address or it will bounce....

andre

Your thoughts on Motor City Online?

by andre » Sat, 07 Apr 2001 08:27:43

If it's subscription only for online multiplayer, I'm not buying it.

If it's free, I'm buying it.

Simple decision for me, really. I hope it's free, because it looks really
promising.


> My guess is it won't be the motorheads and sim racing fans that make
> or break this one -- it will be whether or not it appeals to the
> general *** public.  If it succeeds with the general *** public,
> then it will be interesting to see what affect that will have on sim
> racing in general (and it may not necessarily be a good impact).

> -- JB


> >As I said, we'll just have to see whether
> >motorheads flock to it or not.  Ladies and
> >gentlemen, place your bets....

> >On Wed, 04 Apr 2001 22:40:13 GMT,


> >>says...

> >>>    As for MCO itself I think you'd be surprised how attractive a persistant
> >>>game-world could be to racing fans.

> >>      I rather agree.  I think this one will grab some types that don't
> >>generally go for most racing sims or online games.

> >>      My prediction is that this one hits it _really_ big.  Ultima Online
> >>big.

> >>                                      -Tim

> >Remove "hi" from address or it will bounce....

jalo

Your thoughts on Motor City Online?

by jalo » Tue, 10 Apr 2001 15:01:52


I'll be suprised if it actually even comes out. This will be the biggest
flop
that EA has ever seen. I'm all into online games, I have played Everquest
for over a year. MC doesn't appeal to me at all. Nothing about it appeals
to me. I don't like the primative cars, I don't like the idea of the 60's
interface.
Like I said, I don't think it will ever get released.
After all who's going to play it? Most of the people here will say it's ***
because
it is not up to GPL standards (and we all know it wont be). And the casual
gamer
doesn't care about upgrading his or her car, they just want to pop the cd in
and race.
And the few casual gamers that do play it, will get wasted by the few
*** drivers
that do play it. In my opinion, bad idea. Any way you look at it.


rec.autos.simulators is a usenet newsgroup formed in December, 1993. As this group was always unmoderated there may be some spam or off topic articles included. Some links do point back to racesimcentral.net as we could not validate the original address. Please report any pages that you believe warrant deletion from this archive (include the link in your email). RaceSimCentral.net is in no way responsible and does not endorse any of the content herein.