rec.autos.simulators

Logitech Driving Force Pro -What WERE they thinking?

Tim Epstei

Logitech Driving Force Pro -What WERE they thinking?

by Tim Epstei » Fri, 26 Aug 2005 01:36:29




>> "Larry" wrote...
>>> What WERE they thinking?  Their top of the line wheel doesn't have
>>> a proper clamping system?

>> Quite aside from it appearing and feeling like a piece of cheap,
>> plastic tat you mean?

>> Having owned a succession of underengineered mass market wheel pedal
>> combo's, starting from a TM1 to the 4-times patched up MOMO Force I
>> use now (original pedals, sorry Jore), I've now basically had it with
>> the mass market solutions. Come September I'll be ordering a BRD
>> Speed7 with matching pedals and finally own simracing gear which won't
>> self-destruct through nomal use.

> How much will that cost?

> Just found it, retailing at 399! I think most people will have to stick
> with the mass market wheel

I think you found an old ad (2001) for the non FF wheel and pedal combo. The
new Speed 7 wheel (much delayed) with FF will be 750 for the standard
version and 1000 for the LCD version. Pedals are extra.

Tim

FooAtar

Logitech Driving Force Pro -What WERE they thinking?

by FooAtar » Fri, 26 Aug 2005 02:12:49







>>> "Larry" wrote...
>>>> What WERE they thinking?  Their top of the line wheel doesn't have
>>>> a proper clamping system?

>>> Quite aside from it appearing and feeling like a piece of cheap,
>>> plastic tat you mean?

>>> Having owned a succession of underengineered mass market wheel pedal
>>> combo's, starting from a TM1 to the 4-times patched up MOMO Force I
>>> use now (original pedals, sorry Jore), I've now basically had it
>>> with the mass market solutions. Come September I'll be ordering a
>>> BRD Speed7 with matching pedals and finally own simracing gear which
>>> won't self-destruct through nomal use.

>> How much will that cost?

>> Just found it, retailing at 399! I think most people will have to
>> stick with the mass market wheel

> I think you found an old ad (2001) for the non FF wheel and pedal
> combo. The new Speed 7 wheel (much delayed) with FF will be 750 for
> the standard version and 1000 for the LCD version. Pedals are extra.

> Tim

Sweet jesus...

--
Transplants save lives! - Have you signed up to be a donor?  
http://www.racesimcentral.net/

Do something amazing today. Save a life, give ***.
http://www.***.co.uk/

My games collection and Live games:
http://www.racesimcentral.net/

Jan Verschuere

Logitech Driving Force Pro -What WERE they thinking?

by Jan Verschuere » Fri, 26 Aug 2005 10:39:52

It's actually more like <cough>750 quid</cough>, with the pedals coming in
at an extra 150.

Serious money, for sure, but let me put that into perspective: having raced
sims since 1994 I've already binned 250 Pounds worth of wheel/pedal combos
(TM1+TM2+LWFF).
The MOMO Force cost and additional 180 pounds to buy and, in total, I guess
I must calculate well over a 1000 pounds in man-hours repairing/modding my
wheels over the years just to keep them going and/or improving their feel.

As with any worthwhile hobby one takes seriously and intends to pursue (just
with GPL, NR2003, GTR and LFS I can't see myself ever growing tired of
"driving"), the tools of the trade don't come cheap. E.g. I also like to
design, build and repair a variety of electronic circuits. To this end I own
an entry level rework station (soldering/desoldering) at a cool 1500 pounds,
a CAE (computer aided engineering) design suite (Proteus) at 175 pounds and
a digital storage oscilloscope worth 2200 pounds.

All of which pales in comparison to actually competing in any competitive
real life racing series, where you'd be lucky to spend less than 7500 pounds
a year and still be ahead of the also rans.

The problem with racing sims (and the hardware used to *play* them) has been
the fact they've been viewed as part of a toy/entertainment market, which
has led to a lowest bidder mentality and, consequently, dropping quality
accross the board. If any good is to come from the failure of the various
"true sims" to compete with yer Counter Strikes and Everquests it's through
its limited customers willing to pay a valid price for a valid product.

Jan.
=---

FooAtar

Logitech Driving Force Pro -What WERE they thinking?

by FooAtar » Fri, 26 Aug 2005 15:44:06

I have had many wheels, but only one FFB wheel, the MS Sidewinder.  It
may not be the best wheel in the market, but I found it to be pretty
sturdy and with a good feels and has last a good 4 or 5 years now.

Sim racing is a niche market.  And will never compete with games like CS
and everquest.  You have to invest alot of time just to get good at
racing sims, and really need a lot of real life car knowledge to get the
best of them.  Most people are not willing to put that time in, CS is
realtivly easy to play, its just a mulit-player FPS.

If you can afford a quality product to go along with your hobby then go
ahead, but even for poeople that enjoy the hobby, the better end of a
grand is hard to justify for one product consisting of only a wheel and
pedals which you can pick fairly decent FFB wheels for 50.  Then again
if I could afford to spend that much on a wheel my opinion might be
different :-)

--
Transplants save lives! - Have you signed up to be a donor?  
http://www.racesimcentral.net/

Do something amazing today. Save a life, give ***.
http://www.***.co.uk/

My games collection and Live games:
http://www.racesimcentral.net/

Larr

Logitech Driving Force Pro -What WERE they thinking?

by Larr » Fri, 26 Aug 2005 23:08:14

Um, Holy Shit.

-Larry

found it, retailing at 399! I think most people will have to stick

alex

Logitech Driving Force Pro -What WERE they thinking?

by alex » Sun, 28 Aug 2005 11:38:29


Curious... I had similar problem with MSFFW when comparing it with
Guillemot Ferrari FF that I had before. I've solved the problem by opening
MSFF and bolting it to the desk (with real bolts going through the bottom
of the wheel and through the desk). That works amazingly well, the wheel is
not going anywhere anytime soon :) Should work with any wheel... I wonder
why no genius has come out with such a simple idea ;)

Alex.

Larr

Logitech Driving Force Pro -What WERE they thinking?

by Larr » Mon, 29 Aug 2005 13:32:42

Never had a problem with my MSFFW's.  The clamps reach deep to the back of
the wheel assembly, and it can't rotate down over the curved edge of the
desk, like the DFP did.

-Larry

Curious... I had similar problem with MSFFW when comparing it with

alex

Logitech Driving Force Pro -What WERE they thinking?

by alex » Wed, 31 Aug 2005 10:08:49


With MSFFW problem is in up-down direction. There's nothing that holds the
front of the wheel from going up.


rec.autos.simulators is a usenet newsgroup formed in December, 1993. As this group was always unmoderated there may be some spam or off topic articles included. Some links do point back to racesimcentral.net as we could not validate the original address. Please report any pages that you believe warrant deletion from this archive (include the link in your email). RaceSimCentral.net is in no way responsible and does not endorse any of the content herein.