Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

N3 does suck!

26 posts by 20 people · 27 Oct 1999 - 03 Nov 1999

Troll post claiming NASCAR Racing 3 sucks

A poster attacked N3's old engine and claimed NASCAR Revolution looked better, which drew a Troll-O-Meter reply and many rebuttals. The discussion moved to whether the GPL engine would make stock cars feel like 1967 F1 cars, and posters explained that the engine models whatever car parameters it is given.

game comparisonphysics/realism debatehumourNASCAR Racing 3Grand Prix Legends

Automated summary.

<rmol.. 27 Oct 1999#499668
I'm fed up with papy's tire old engine that couldn't! Shit, the only improvement is the sound! The cars still drive like every track is a newly paved asphalt parking lot, the cars still don't look anywhere near the quality of Nascar Revolution...Nor do the tracks and racing surface even compare...As a matter of fact the AI is a joke compared to NASREV...I know, I know, all you mindless numbnuts out there that have listened to your "*** sim" buddies are outraged that I should compare the 2 but try opening your narrow little minds a bit...Racing Darlington in NASREV beats the living hell out of N3...If only those idiots at EA would've allowed true pitting and car adjustments that mattered and no computer control of your car I guarantee we would be sitting around laughing at Papy's latest money grab...I challenge you to pull out your old NASREV, run 100 laps at Darlington, then run 100 laps at Darlington with N3 and you decide which seemed more realistic and intense as far as the actual hot laps and racing against AI goes...there's little comparison! And another thing, why all the ***ing on the EA board about "jitterbug" cars and none about the very same "jitterbug" cars in N3...surely you've seen it, especially at Tally...The papy reply to this thouroughly un-simlike we could combine NASREV's engine with papy's physics we'd finally have the best NASCAR sim out there...Right now we have nothing...And you can forget about Papy basing n4 or whatever on GPL...shit even the GPL engine is old and tired! And how about the size of those spoilers! Anyone out there ever seen something like this on a real cup car? The AI in N3 still does stupid shit like stopping during a yellow, coming down on you in a turn, drastically slowing down for a car on the apron, blablabla...I'm getting sick of this shit... Later
> the cars still don't look anywhere near the quality of Nascar > Revolution... OK.. Either you have NEVER run N3 or you are in serious need of glasses. NASCAR Revoltings graphics are junk compared to N3 at 800X600 or above. Again, you have either never run N3 or your preferences are for an arcade game. If you want an arcade game, then NASCAR Revolting is probably your better choice. Better yet, buy a console if you dont already own one and buy NASCAR 2000. You are right, no comparison. NASCAR Revolution is not worth the CD its burned on. If I dive into the corner against a car in NASCAR Revolting... the AI instantaneously move out of the way and gives you the position. The N3 AI at least race you and dont just pull over like they use to in N2/N99. Comparing NR to N3 is like comparing a Chevy Cavalier to a Chevy Corvette. Yeah, they are both cars (debatable <G>) but that is about where the comparison ends. And this just proved that you have flawed knowledge about sim racing. Then I suggest you go back to NR and play with the unrealistic arcade game and pass on racing the best NASCAR Simulation available, N3. Scott PA-Scott -- Scott B. Husted ICQ# 4395450
Troll-O-Meter 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 ___________________________________________________ | | | | | | | | | | | --------------------------------------------------- ^ | Amateur....
Quoted text (34 lines)>I'm fed up with papy's tire old engine that couldn't! Shit, the only >improvement is the sound! >The cars still drive like every track is a newly paved asphalt parking lot, >the cars still don't look anywhere near the quality of Nascar >Revolution...Nor do the tracks and racing surface even compare...As a matter >of fact the AI is a joke compared to NASREV...I know, I know, all you >mindless numbnuts out there that have listened to your "*** sim" >buddies are outraged that I should compare the 2 but try opening your narrow >little minds a bit...Racing Darlington in NASREV beats the living hell out >of N3...If only those idiots at EA would've allowed true pitting and car >adjustments that mattered and no computer control of your car I guarantee we >would be sitting around laughing at Papy's latest money grab...I challenge >you to pull out your old NASREV, run 100 laps at Darlington, then run 100 >laps at Darlington with N3 and you decide which seemed more realistic and >intense as far as the actual hot laps and racing against AI goes...there's >little comparison! >And another thing, why all the ***ing on the EA board about "jitterbug" >cars and none about the very same "jitterbug" cars in N3...surely you've >seen it, especially at Tally...The papy reply to this thouroughly un-simlike >we could combine NASREV's engine with papy's physics we'd finally have the >best NASCAR sim out there...Right now we have nothing...And you can forget >about Papy basing n4 or whatever on GPL...shit even the GPL engine is old >and tired! >And how about the size of those spoilers! Anyone out there ever seen >something like this on a real cup car? The AI in N3 still does stupid shit >like stopping during a yellow, coming down on you in a turn, drastically >slowing down for a car on the apron, blablabla...I'm getting sick of this >shit... >Later
/
Philster 27 Oct 1999#499671
Quoted text (10 lines)> Troll-O-Meter > 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 > ___________________________________________________ > | | | | | | | | | | | > --------------------------------------------------- > ^ > | > Amateur....
ROTFL!!! Now that was funny! That made my day. This could become a standard in this newsgroup. Philster
Marty U'Ren 27 Oct 1999#499672
< Snipped > You are right N3 is the best Nascar sim, but how pitiful it is still second rate to the best sim, GPL, published by the same company, Sierra. Marty.
You suck! Nothing makes me madder than when some dumb idiot gets on here and says something with absolutley no basis for their argument. The game is completely different imho. Run it with a PII-450 with a Voodoo2 and an A3d card and you will see how much better it is than any other NASCAR game out there. All the tracks are at current specs, the AI is a lot better than before, the way the car drives is more realistic when not handling up to par, it has force feedback support, it has a lot better graphics including higher resolutions, a truly win 95 native program with win95 multiplayer, support for 43 cars at tracks that have enough space, updated paint schemes on the cars, more customizable season options, more customizable AI with short track and speedway settings, better menu and overall game interfacing with GPL-like browsing, Indy Motor Speedway, digital joystick support, better groove definition, a WHOLE lot better sound with an A3D 2.0 card and stereo headphones. 100% improvement imho. It literally kicks the ***out of any other NASCAR game available for ANY port, including that total POS game, Nasrev, that wont even let you pit. I love how in NasRev when you hit the wall, bounce off, and then hit the gas to drive off, it's like you hit the brakes. Hell, you've already hit the wall and started to speed off. It doesnt slow you down when you hit the wall, just when you start to drive away. LOL! I love the***pit view. Technology from 1993 in Bill Elliott's Nascar Challenge, which was great at the time and I loved it then, but I expect more than that. What an immersive driving experience! LMBO! I also love how the game seems like it "speeds up" 100 mph when coming off the 2nd turn, then exiting 4, it crawls. What a POS game. Nice drink coaster though. When the best feature of the game is the uninstall feature, the game pretty much sucks. NasRev is to realism as OJ is to innocent. Come on! I feel better now! Have a nice day, Phillip
ymenard 28 Oct 1999#499925
It's a standard on many newsgroup Philippe ;) I think I used that once here around a year ago. Just make a search for "troll ASCII Usenet", and you'll find a couple of stuff there I think. Well I had found them. -- -- Fran?ois Mnard <ymenard> -- May the Downforce be with you... "People think it must be fun to be a super genius, but they don't realise how hard it is to put up with all the idiots in the world."
Ken Beard 28 Oct 1999#499927
One of my faves is the Standard Reply Form, where you check the boxes that apply..... Dear: [x] Clueless newbie ..... :-) -- Ken's Sig 3.01 "Who is the more foolish? The fool, or the fool who follows him?" - Obi-Wan Kenobi Go #43 and #44! volksy (at) yahoo (dot) com > > ROTFL!!! Now that was funny! That made my day. This could become a > > standard in this newsgroup. > It's a standard on many newsgroup Philippe ;) I think I used that once here > around a year ago. > Just make a search for "troll ASCII Usenet", and you'll find a couple of > stuff there I think. Well I had found them. > -- > -- Fran?ois Mnard <ymenard> > -- May the Downforce be with you... > "People think it must be fun to be a super genius, but they don't realise > how hard it is to put up with all the idiots in the world."
>>second rate to >>the best sim, GPL >Yeah, but it's 2 totally different things. '67 GP cars and '99 WC cars. You're >comparing apples to oranges. Err ... not really. Both GPL and N3 are racing sims developed by the same company, published by the same publisher. It doesn't matter what series or year they are simulating ... N3 engine just plain sucks compared to GPL engine. I don't. Hena
George Fase 28 Oct 1999#499929
How reassuring to discover that cool, rational analysis combined with rhetorical elegance hasn't deserted this newsgroup.
Quoted text (34 lines)> I'm fed up with papy's tire old engine that couldn't! Shit, the only > improvement is the sound! > The cars still drive like every track is a newly paved asphalt parking lot, > the cars still don't look anywhere near the quality of Nascar > Revolution...Nor do the tracks and racing surface even compare...As a matter > of fact the AI is a joke compared to NASREV...I know, I know, all you > mindless numbnuts out there that have listened to your "*** sim" > buddies are outraged that I should compare the 2 but try opening your narrow > little minds a bit...Racing Darlington in NASREV beats the living hell out > of N3...If only those idiots at EA would've allowed true pitting and car > adjustments that mattered and no computer control of your car I guarantee we > would be sitting around laughing at Papy's latest money grab...I challenge > you to pull out your old NASREV, run 100 laps at Darlington, then run 100 > laps at Darlington with N3 and you decide which seemed more realistic and > intense as far as the actual hot laps and racing against AI goes...there's > little comparison! > And another thing, why all the ***ing on the EA board about "jitterbug" > cars and none about the very same "jitterbug" cars in N3...surely you've > seen it, especially at Tally...The papy reply to this thouroughly un-simlike > we could combine NASREV's engine with papy's physics we'd finally have the > best NASCAR sim out there...Right now we have nothing...And you can forget > about Papy basing n4 or whatever on GPL...shit even the GPL engine is old > and tired! > And how about the size of those spoilers! Anyone out there ever seen > something like this on a real cup car? The AI in N3 still does stupid shit > like stopping during a yellow, coming down on you in a turn, drastically > slowing down for a car on the apron, blablabla...I'm getting sick of this > shit... > Later
Alan Orton 28 Oct 1999#499930
The gpl engine will fall behind shortly, other driving models coming out model the real world just like gpl does plus it also models brake fade/heat/ failure, Tire wear/failure, real time weather affecting performance and track temps, Different adhesion levels on certain parts or track(so when outside the line it gets greasy also. Modeling of marbles or loose ***, etc.. I'm sure the gpl engine could up grade itself but it won't be king of sims if it doesn't. The gpl engine is awesome but there are going to be others that are even better not too far down the road, nothing wrong with that. Year 2000 is going to be a fun year :)
Quoted text (40 lines)> How reassuring to discover that cool, rational analysis combined with > rhetorical elegance hasn't deserted this newsgroup. > > I'm fed up with papy's tire old engine that couldn't! Shit, the only > > improvement is the sound! > > The cars still drive like every track is a newly paved asphalt parking lot, > > the cars still don't look anywhere near the quality of Nascar > > Revolution...Nor do the tracks and racing surface even compare...As a matter > > of fact the AI is a joke compared to NASREV...I know, I know, all you > > mindless numbnuts out there that have listened to your "*** sim" > > buddies are outraged that I should compare the 2 but try opening your narrow > > little minds a bit...Racing Darlington in NASREV beats the living hell out > > of N3...If only those idiots at EA would've allowed true pitting and car > > adjustments that mattered and no computer control of your car I guarantee we > > would be sitting around laughing at Papy's latest money grab...I challenge > > you to pull out your old NASREV, run 100 laps at Darlington, then run 100 > > laps at Darlington with N3 and you decide which seemed more realistic and > > intense as far as the actual hot laps and racing against AI goes...there's > > little comparison! > > And another thing, why all the ***ing on the EA board about "jitterbug" > > cars and none about the very same "jitterbug" cars in N3...surely you've > > seen it, especially at Tally...The papy reply to this thouroughly un-simlike > > we could combine NASREV's engine with papy's physics we'd finally have the > > best NASCAR sim out there...Right now we have nothing...And you can forget > > about Papy basing n4 or whatever on GPL...shit even the GPL engine is old > > and tired! > > And how about the size of those spoilers! Anyone out there ever seen > > something like this on a real cup car? The AI in N3 still does stupid shit > > like stopping during a yellow, coming down on you in a turn, drastically > > slowing down for a car on the apron, blablabla...I'm getting sick of this > > shit... > > Later
Hena, I think many people have a false notion to what the GPL engine in N4 will do. Yes, the current N3 engine is NOT as advanced as the GPL engine. That is a given. However, people who think that implementing the GPL engine into NASCAR Racing is going to have the same effects as GPL are severely mistaken. Sure, you get flipping, etc. The point being that once you take the GPL engine and adjust for weight, aerodynamics, tire width, tire grip, weight distribution, and chassis setup... you won't recognize the GPL engine! The GPL cars are hard to drive because those cars in 1967 WERE hard to drive. The same engine in N4 will not dramatically change the driving characteristics of a NASCAR. Yes, it will be improved but the vast changes that some expect are not going to appear due to the physics and nature of NASCAR racing itself. Scott PA-Scott -- Scott B. Husted ICQ# 4395450
Arghhhhhhh! No-one's ever said all cars handle the same, but if you apply the same modelling rigour as displayed in GPL you *will* get a similarly involving drive. *That's* what the GPL engine's about. Andrew McP
Alan Orton schrieb: Are you just dreaming (we all share the same dream then), or do you have any facts about a company producing a *** sim (strange name for a piece of software, actually ;^) like GPL? l8er ronny -- The box said "Windows 95 or better", so I installed LINUX! |\ _,,,---,,_ I want to die like my Grandfather, ZZZzz /,`.-'`' -. ;-;;,_ in his sleep. |,4- ) )-,_. ,\ ( `'-' Not like the people in his car, '---''(_/--' `-'\_) screaming their heads off!
Kenny L. 28 Oct 1999#499935
Yeah, and my setup would mask the rest of all those physic goodies.
Greg Cisko 28 Oct 1999#499936
> I'm fed up with papy's tire old engine that couldn't! Shit, the only > improvement is the sound! I guess we can stop right here. Um... Try Force Feedback. Dork. You have to be trolling the NG by comparing N3 to NASREV. -- Header address intentionally scrambled to ward off the spamming hordes. cisko [AT] ix [DOT] netcom [DOT] com
MAC 29 Oct 1999#500133
On Wed, 27 Oct 1999 14:54:21 -0400, The GPL engine may be a year "old", but then some games and physics engines get old quickly, whereas the GPL engine is ageing in style. Its like Tina Turner, 60yrs old and still alive and kickin butt, the N3 engine is more like Frank Sinatra <G>
Alan Orton 29 Oct 1999#500134
Well One of the games that comes to mind is World Sports Cars. You can see about it here. [link lost in import] There are a couple of other sim as well but We'll Probably find out alot more by Christmas. Cya on the *** Tracks in year 2000 and beyond.
Quoted text (27 lines)> Alan Orton schrieb: > > The gpl engine will fall behind shortly, other driving models coming out > > model the real world just like gpl does plus it also models brake > > fade/heat/ failure, Tire wear/failure, real time weather affecting > > performance and track temps, Different adhesion levels on certain parts > > or track(so when outside the line it gets greasy also. Modeling of > > marbles or loose ***, etc.. I'm sure the gpl engine could up grade > > itself but it won't be king of sims if it doesn't. The gpl engine is > > awesome but there are going to be others that are even better not too > > far down the road, nothing wrong with that. Year 2000 is going to be a > > fun year :) > Are you just dreaming (we all share the same dream then), or do you > have any facts about a company producing a *** sim (strange name > for a piece of software, actually ;^) like GPL? > l8er > ronny > -- > The box said "Windows 95 or better", so I installed LINUX! > |\ _,,,---,,_ I want to die like my Grandfather, > ZZZzz /,`.-'`' -. ;-;;,_ in his sleep. > |,4- ) )-,_. ,\ ( `'-' Not like the people in his car, > '---''(_/--' `-'\_) screaming their heads off!
Quoted text (8 lines)>> The point being that once you take the GPL engine and adjust >> for weight, aerodynamics, tire width, tire grip, weight >> distribution, and chassis setup... you won't recognize the >> GPL engine! >Arghhhhhhh! >No-one's ever said all cars handle the same, but if you apply the same
Where have you been? There've been A LOT of people saying just (or thinking) just that. That if N4 incorporates the GPL physics engine the stock cars would handle like '67 GP cars. And this is wrong. The beauty of GPL engine lies in its scalability. You can enter whichever car's parameters including tyre dynamics, engine specs, suspension values etc. into it, and you'd get realistic handling of that vechile. Be it a school bus or a go-kart. That's what the GPL engine is about. Huh?!? Hena
Please, have some respect for Frank...
Quoted text (8 lines)>On Wed, 27 Oct 1999 14:54:21 -0400, >The GPL engine may be a year "old", but then some games and physics engines >get old quickly, whereas the GPL engine is ageing in style. Its like Tina >Turner, 60yrs old and still alive and kickin butt, the N3 engine is more >like Frank Sinatra <G>
You mean the "next Nascar 2"? or should I say 1.... Target 12 kirjoitti viestiss?
Quoted text (8 lines)>On Wed, 27 Oct 1999 14:54:21 -0400, >>And you can forget about Papy basing n4 or whatever on GPL... >>shit even the GPL engine is old and tired! >Uhh.. the GPL 'engine' is old in what way, exactly?
For God's sake! It's 1967!!! Frank Francois Dubuc, Simulator ***world, [link lost in import: /***world/]
You are only repeating what many people here have. You just dropped to a lower lever of how to say it. I too would like a better engine. I disagree with your comment about the GPL engine. It is the only SIM where I REALLY feel like I'm driving a car. It would be nice if we could just get a few things: - Punch the throttle of a 700hp car and you should have no control. Especially if the car is loose coming off the corners. - Slamming on the brakes at 150mph should lock up the tires and you should not be able to hold onto the car. Your challenge intrigues me. If I had NASREV I'd take the challenge. >I'm fed up with papy's tire old engine that couldn't! Shit, the only >improvement is the sound!

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy