Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

AMA Superbike Open Beta - UI & Problems

42 posts by 18 people · 04 Oct 1999 - 08 Oct 1999 03:15 UTC

AMA Superbike open beta user interface complaints

DjFIL attacked the AMA Superbike user interface as slow and confusing and reported lockups, which drew rebukes about tone and a long argument with poster MaX. Motorsims's Mark S. Miller explained why the UI was not built as a linear menu and said its texture load would be reduced. Miguel Parra and Matthew Jessick of Motorsims answered questions about track accuracy, red flags and penalties.

With Mark S. Miller (Motorsims); Miguel Parra (Motorsims); Matthew Jessick (Motorsims)

tech supportreview/impressionsAMA Superbike

Automated summary.

DjFIL 04 Oct 1999#497274
Where the hell did Motorsims think up this ***ass maze of a user interface. This truly is the slowest and most annoying ui I have ever seen in any game. And the controller setup area is detailed, but very poorly planned. But now about my problems. I am over the requirements but it still locks up everytime in the ui. Any clue? I'm at... Pentium Celeron 300mhz 98mb RAM Monster Fusion (video, 2d & 3d in one, 16 mb total) And whatever else is neccary. thanks, DjFIL
It does help when you have a question about a certain game, not to be an ass when expressing opinions about that game [not to mention grammar and spelling]. However, yes I would concur that going between the various screens of the UI is a bit slow, but then so can doing the same thing in GPL. Haven't found the advanced setup to be all that poorly planned or all that hard to navigate. As to the problem, try grabbing the latest drivers from Diamond for the Fusion. If that doesn't work, then try the reference drivers from 3dfx for the Banshee (unless I miss my guess, the Monster Fusion is a Banshee card, no?). And make sure you are running DirectX6.1 and not just DirectX6.0. Might even try upgrading to DirectX7.0
Quoted text (13 lines)> Where the hell did Motorsims think up this ***ass maze of a user > interface. This truly is the slowest and most annoying ui I have ever > seen in any game. And the controller setup area is detailed, but very > poorly planned. But now about my problems. I am over the requirements > but it still locks up everytime in the ui. Any clue? I'm at... > Pentium Celeron 300mhz > 98mb RAM > Monster Fusion (video, 2d & 3d in one, 16 mb total) > And whatever else is neccary. > thanks, > DjFIL
Philster 04 Oct 1999#497276
I guess Chris point was that if you're going to say something bad about a game, don't expect to get help after. It's going to someone and telling him he has an ugly car say: "BTW, how can you fix a carburator?" It might be a valid opinion, but do agree that he would probably not help you out. Philster
I too get some lockups in the UI during online play. But no problems so far offline. Have you downloaded the v1.02 update? BTW, I find the riders view for riding much better than SBK's. At least I don't get seasick in AMA <G> Wayne Hutchison
Quoted text (13 lines)> Where the hell did Motorsims think up this ***ass maze of a user > interface. This truly is the slowest and most annoying ui I have ever > seen in any game. And the controller setup area is detailed, but very > poorly planned. But now about my problems. I am over the requirements > but it still locks up everytime in the ui. Any clue? I'm at... > Pentium Celeron 300mhz > 98mb RAM > Monster Fusion (video, 2d & 3d in one, 16 mb total) > And whatever else is neccary. > thanks, > DjFIL
AndrewS 04 Oct 1999#497278
I thought I was the only one who had those opinions of the UI. I was a beta tester, but quickly gave up on the game because of the awful UI. The UI is not just bad, but perhaps the worst I've ever seen in a game.
Quoted text (13 lines)> Where the hell did Motorsims think up this ***ass maze of a user > interface. This truly is the slowest and most annoying ui I have ever > seen in any game. And the controller setup area is detailed, but very > poorly planned. But now about my problems. I am over the requirements > but it still locks up everytime in the ui. Any clue? I'm at... > Pentium Celeron 300mhz > 98mb RAM > Monster Fusion (video, 2d & 3d in one, 16 mb total) > And whatever else is neccary. > thanks, > DjFIL
DjFIL 05 Oct 1999#497496
That was not being an ass, that was expressing my opinion. But.... Whats grammar and spellin gotta do with it? Is this an english essay? Its not like I'm already failing English 12 any way... Thanks tho for ideas on how to try and get this beta working. I think they tried to be all fancy pantsed about it. Out of all racing games I have 2 UI's which I like. SBK and GP500, GP500 being the better of the 2. They looked nice, they were easy to navigate, and they were fast to navigate around. The papy ui's are ok, but not on the top of my list. Any way, back later to post my comments about the gameplay once I get it running. DjFIL
Quoted text (28 lines)> It does help when you have a question about a certain game, not to be an ass > when expressing opinions about that game [not to mention grammar and > spelling]. However, yes I would concur that going between the various > screens of the UI is a bit slow, but then so can doing the same thing in > GPL. Haven't found the advanced setup to be all that poorly planned or all > that hard to navigate. > As to the problem, try grabbing the latest drivers from Diamond for the > Fusion. If that doesn't work, then try the reference drivers from 3dfx for > the Banshee (unless I miss my guess, the Monster Fusion is a Banshee card, > no?). And make sure you are running DirectX6.1 and not just DirectX6.0. > Might even try upgrading to DirectX7.0 > > Where the hell did Motorsims think up this ***ass maze of a user > > interface. This truly is the slowest and most annoying ui I have ever > > seen in any game. And the controller setup area is detailed, but very > > poorly planned. But now about my problems. I am over the requirements > > but it still locks up everytime in the ui. Any clue? I'm at... > > Pentium Celeron 300mhz > > 98mb RAM > > Monster Fusion (video, 2d & 3d in one, 16 mb total) > > And whatever else is neccary. > > thanks, > > DjFIL
Ma 05 Oct 1999#497497
Yeah, I love how the rider's point of view bobs up and down even with the slightest press of the throttle or brake... AMA = A Motorsims' *** !
Quoted text (23 lines)>I too get some lockups in the UI during online play. But no problems so far >offline. Have you downloaded the v1.02 update? >BTW, I find the riders view for riding much better than SBK's. At least I >don't get seasick in AMA <G> >Wayne Hutchison >> Where the hell did Motorsims think up this ***ass maze of a user >> interface. This truly is the slowest and most annoying ui I have ever >> seen in any game. And the controller setup area is detailed, but very >> poorly planned. But now about my problems. I am over the requirements >> but it still locks up everytime in the ui. Any clue? I'm at... >> Pentium Celeron 300mhz >> 98mb RAM >> Monster Fusion (video, 2d & 3d in one, 16 mb total) >> And whatever else is neccary. >> thanks, >> DjFIL
DjFIL 05 Oct 1999#497498
andrew: Hmm, thanks for being behind me. I knew I wasnt the only one. I'm gonna send in my bug report to MotorSims than I'm deleting this game for good. wayne: 1st person view didn't get you sick? oh my god, I was about to puke. But thats not saying its a bad on board view, I just find it hard to stomache. But personaly I think it seams over done. But [this is a general insult to AMA] the AMA courses are not very well kept and rather bumpy as it is. any hoo. no long comments towards the game, but if the full version is anything like this, you wont see the $45 us, which it costs, on my credit card. Nor will you see me wasting my time downloading a full cracked copy either. end of subject, DjFIL
Quoted text (19 lines)> I thought I was the only one who had those opinions of the UI. I was a beta > tester, but quickly gave up on the game because of the awful UI. The UI is > not just bad, but perhaps the worst I've ever seen in a game. > > Where the hell did Motorsims think up this ***ass maze of a user > > interface. This truly is the slowest and most annoying ui I have ever > > seen in any game. And the controller setup area is detailed, but very > > poorly planned. But now about my problems. I am over the requirements > > but it still locks up everytime in the ui. Any clue? I'm at... > > Pentium Celeron 300mhz > > 98mb RAM > > Monster Fusion (video, 2d & 3d in one, 16 mb total) > > And whatever else is neccary. > > thanks, > > DjFIL
Mike 05 Oct 1999#497499
Hmmm that about sums it up eh? BTW where did you buy your copy of GP500? Thought so Funny Mike
Joe McGinn 05 Oct 1999#497500
>I guess Chris point was that if you're going to say something bad about >a game, don't expect to get help after. I disagree, not if the criticism is stated reasonable. But you're right too (in this case) the "xxx is CRAP" kind of statements are hardly going to be received kindly by anyone. Joe McGinn ========================================== Staff Writer for the Sports *** Network [link lost in import: /***.com/] ==========================================
Chris 05 Oct 1999#497501
I agree with Joe. Its one thing to have critism. Its another to present it as constructive critism as opposed to "This SUCKS", etc. mentality.
Quoted text (12 lines)> >I guess Chris point was that if you're going to say something bad about > >a game, don't expect to get help after. > I disagree, not if the criticism is stated reasonable. But you're > right too (in this case) the "xxx is CRAP" kind of statements are > hardly going to be received kindly by anyone. > Joe McGinn > ========================================== > Staff Writer for the Sports *** Network > [link lost in import: /***.com/] > ==========================================
Chris 05 Oct 1999#497502
Opinions are one thing. Learning to express them in a somewhat constructive manner will always generate you more help than not. And people generally may actually take what you say to heart. If you are an ass about it, people will more often than not just ignore it. On the other hand, SBK and GP500 have good interfaces? Personally, I thought that SBK's was poorly planned. Point in case, you could not get to the options screen until several levels down into the interface. Not to mention there were too many clicks to reach any given area. GP500s is ok, but its very lightweight in terms of features it allows you to change and customize, especially in the controller area. > That was not being an ass, that was expressing my opinion. But.... Whats > grammar and spellin gotta do with it? Is this an english essay? Its not like > I'm already failing English 12 any way... Thanks tho for ideas on how to try > and get this beta working. I think they tried to be all fancy pantsed about > it. Out of all racing games I have 2 UI's which I like. SBK and GP500, GP500 > being the better of the 2. They looked nice, they were easy to navigate, and > they were fast to navigate around. The papy ui's are ok, but not on the top of > my list. Any way, back later to post my comments about the gameplay once I get
Quoted text (8 lines)> it running. > DjFIL > > It does help when you have a question about a certain game, not to be an
ass > > when expressing opinions about that game [not to mention grammar and > > spelling]. However, yes I would concur that going between the various > > screens of the UI is a bit slow, but then so can doing the same thing in > > GPL. Haven't found the advanced setup to be all that poorly planned or all > > that hard to navigate. > > As to the problem, try grabbing the latest drivers from Diamond for the > > Fusion. If that doesn't work, then try the reference drivers from 3dfx for > > the Banshee (unless I miss my guess, the Monster Fusion is a Banshee card, > > no?). And make sure you are running DirectX6.1 and not just DirectX6.0. > > Might even try upgrading to DirectX7.0
Chris 05 Oct 1999#497503
Odd, but a) Road America, b) Laguna Seca, c) Mid-Ohio, d) Road Atlanta are all first class tracks and are not unkept. Road courses, heck even oval tracks, are not flat glasslike surfaces with that are utterly smooth. Why in the world would you want to download a full cracked copy, other than it being illegal, when you can download the entire game, minus the offline AI scripts, for FREE directly from Motorsims?
Ma 05 Oct 1999#497504
The bottom line is GP500's menus get you on the track with the least effort, quick and simple. AMA's is a maze of confusion. MaX (AMA=A Motorsims' ***)
Bob 05 Oct 1999#497505
Did Motorsims *piss* in your Wheaties or something. You have yet to say anything worth reading. I'd hate to put you in the kill file, some of your post regarding other sims are somewhat informative. You aren't disgruntled still because they didn't select you to be on the original beta team, are you?? Get over it!! Good day
Chris 05 Oct 1999#497506
So, MaX. Just how long have you been working for the GP500 development team? Hmmmm? Jesus, you're a walking, talking billboard for them.
Quoted text (9 lines)> The bottom line is GP500's menus get you on the track with the least > effort, quick and simple. AMA's is a maze of confusion. > MaX > (AMA=A Motorsims' ***) > >GP500s is ok, but its > >very lightweight in terms of features it allows you to change > >and customize, especially in the controller area.
Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ Before you buy.
Chris 05 Oct 1999#497507
You can change this behavior in the controller setup menu. When set to auto, the rider pitch will sit the rider up on the bike when you brake. I've got the rider pitch coupled to my braking input. The rider is tucked all the time unless I'm on the brakes. I've got it set so that the rider goes from 100% tuck linearly to 50% tuck as I go from 0% to 100% braking input. The linear progression really smooths out the dynamic view. I agree that it bobs a bit when set to auto. I'm guessing it's because the auto setting sends the rider from 100% tuck to 0% tuck the instant you hit the brakes. BTW, MaX. It would be nice if you'd loose the combative attitude towards Motorsims. You may not like the AMA game, but the Motorsims folks are real people with real jobs doing their best to make a good game. They don't deserve all the ***you've been dishing out lately. A little courtesy mixed in with your criticisms would go a long way to giving you some small margin of credibility. > Yeah, I love how the rider's point of view bobs up and down even > with the slightest press of the throttle or brake... > AMA = A Motorsims' *** ! > >BTW, I find the riders view for riding much better than SBK's. > >At least I don't get seasick in AMA <G> Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ Before you buy.
Bob 05 Oct 1999#497508
Just to be *somewhat* informative myself, the rider pov bobbing up and down can be controlled in the *terrible* UI you are talking about. Its called rider pitch. If you leave it on the throttle/brake axis at the default setting, this is what you will get. It, like anything else in the control UI, can be adjusted. I'm sure it can be adjusted to suit *almost* anyones tastes. Good day. > > Yeah, I love how the rider's point of view bobs up and down even with > > the slightest press of the throttle or brake... > > AMA = A Motorsims' *** !
Terry Welch 05 Oct 1999#497509
Thank goodness you're outta here! We can finally get beyond simple- minded flaming and self-serving anger and work on constructive criticism! > andrew: Hmm, thanks for being behind me. I knew I wasnt the only one. I'm > gonna send in my bug report to MotorSims than I'm deleting this game for good. > wayne: 1st person view didn't get you sick? oh my god, I was about to puke. > But thats not saying its a bad on board view, I just find it hard to stomache. > But personaly I think it seams over done. But [this is a general insult to AMA] > the AMA courses are not very well kept and rather bumpy as it is. > any hoo. no long comments towards the game, but if the full version is anything > like this, you wont see the $45 us, which it costs, on my credit card. Nor will
Quoted text (9 lines)> you see me wasting my time downloading a full cracked copy either. > end of subject, > DjFIL > > I thought I was the only one who had those opinions of the UI. I
was a beta > > tester, but quickly gave up on the game because of the awful UI. The UI is > > not just bad, but perhaps the worst I've ever seen in a game. Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ Before you buy.
Ma 05 Oct 1999#497511
I would be less combative if Motorsims admitted AMA needs some serious work to reach a completed state. What truly upsets me about this company is how they've put this early beta in stores and suckered people into paying $50. That's inexcusable.
DjFIL 05 Oct 1999#497512
Dear confused, I don't have a copy of GP500. At all. But once it's in North America or I find a place to buy it online It will be on its way here. DjFIL
Quoted text (11 lines)> > Nor will > > you see me wasting my time downloading a full cracked copy either. > > end of subject, > > DjFIL > Hmmm that about sums it up eh? > BTW where did you buy your copy of GP500? > Thought so > Funny > Mike
DjFIL 05 Oct 1999#497513
the bit about ama courses sucking, its just my critism and sarcasm acting in. I dislike AMA as a whole. DjFIL
Quoted text (21 lines)> > wayne: 1st person view didn't get you sick? oh my god, I was about to > puke. > > But thats not saying its a bad on board view, I just find it hard to > stomache. > > But personaly I think it seams over done. But [this is a general insult > to AMA] > > the AMA courses are not very well kept and rather bumpy as it is. > Odd, but a) Road America, b) Laguna Seca, c) Mid-Ohio, d) Road Atlanta are > all first class tracks and are not unkept. Road courses, heck even oval > tracks, are not flat glasslike surfaces with that are utterly smooth. > > any hoo. no long comments towards the game, but if the full version is > anything > > like this, you wont see the $45 us, which it costs, on my credit card. > Nor will > > you see me wasting my time downloading a full cracked copy either. > Why in the world would you want to download a full cracked copy, other than > it being illegal, when you can download the entire game, minus the offline > AI scripts, for FREE directly from Motorsims?
DjFIL 05 Oct 1999#497514
Perfectly said max. I applaud Geoff Crammond for pushing the release of GP3 back because it wasnt to his standards. I also admit it is getting kinda anoying watching GP3 release date getting pushed back as much as it does, but atleast he's not gonna put something out that could have easily have been done a whole lot better. DjFIL
Quoted text (12 lines)> I would be less combative if Motorsims admitted AMA needs some serious > work to reach a completed state. What truly upsets me about this > company is how they've put this early beta in stores and suckered > people into paying $50. That's inexcusable. > >BTW, MaX. It would be nice if you'd loose the combative > >attitude towards Motorsims. You may not like the AMA game, > >but the Motorsims folks are real people with real jobs doing > >their best to make a good game. They don't deserve all the > >***you've been dishing out lately. A little courtesy mixed in > >with your criticisms would go a long way to giving you some > >small margin of credibility.
DjFIL 05 Oct 1999#497515
this is not MaX replying but... personaly I did not apply for the beta team, but I have friends that did apply and were choosen. And the they even had major complaints right from the start.
Quoted text (15 lines)> Did Motorsims *piss* in your Wheaties or something. You have yet to say > anything worth reading. I'd hate to put you in the kill file, some of your > post regarding other sims are somewhat informative. You aren't disgruntled > still because they didn't select you to be on the original beta team, are > you?? > Get over it!! > Good day > > Yeah, I love how the rider's point of view bobs up and down even with > > the slightest press of the throttle or brake... > > AMA = A Motorsims' *** !
Chris 06 Oct 1999#497733
OK, you've got a point. It does need some work. But, how many games ever released *DIDN'T* need a bit of work? Not too many. Also, I don't remember Motorsims ever being less than honest about the game and the fact that updates will be following. Take the fact that they've already released an update as partial proof. And the game's only been in stores, what, two weeks? Three weeks? Sounds to me like they're beginning to make good on the things they've said. If you still don't like the game after they've released a couple of updates, fine. But at least acknowledge the fact that they're following through with their statements so far. -Chris-
Quoted text (13 lines)> I would be less combative if Motorsims admitted AMA needs > some serious work to reach a completed state. What truly > upsets me about this company is how they've put this early > beta in stores and suckered people into paying $50. > That's inexcusable. > >BTW, MaX. It would be nice if you'd loose the combative > >attitude towards Motorsims. You may not like the AMA game, > >but the Motorsims folks are real people with real jobs doing > >their best to make a good game. They don't deserve all the > >***you've been dishing out lately. A little courtesy mixed in > >with your criticisms would go a long way to giving you some > >small margin of credibility.
Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ Before you buy.
Joe McGinn 06 Oct 1999#497734
>I would be less combative if Motorsims admitted AMA needs some serious >work to reach a completed state. Oh please. I've NEVER seen a more responsive company, more willing to put continual effort into improving the product over time. They are here in the newsgroups fielding questions (even rude ones), they've paid big bucks for the technology and infrastructure to deliver continuous enhancements, and they've ALREADY got one patch out (in record time) addressing several of the issues raised here on this very group. Your comment is ridiculous. Joe McGinn ========================================== Staff Writer for the Sports *** Network [link lost in import: /***.com/] ==========================================
> Where the hell did Motorsims think up this ***ass maze of a user > interface. This truly is the slowest and most annoying ui I have ever > seen in any game. [...] First of all ... we are planning some rework to reduce the texture budget on the UI. That's why it's slow loading a screen the first time - it's a LOT of texture getting loaded. Next, the UI was built that way for a very good reason. Most racing games are "tunnel" interfaces. That is you go through a very rigid sequence each time you want to get on the track: pick a bike, pick a track, tune the bike, tune the settings, now I can drive. Or something similar. I agree, there ain't much room for confusion there. But ... For a game which will also support serious online play, having to do that much work everytime you want to change races does not work well. It becomes a royal pain real quick. It's just a different flow than you're used to. You seem to have already made up your mind about us ... but I figure you at least deserved an explanation of what we were trying to do. -MSM -- __________________________________________________________________________ Mark S. Miller "Be regular and orderly in your life, Director of Design that you may be *** and original Motorsport Simulations in your work." [link lost in import]
> they've ALREADY got one patch out (in record time) addressing > several of the issues raised here on this very group. Actually the patch addresses multiplayer issues only, something that wasn't touched upon by anyone on this newsgroup as far as I know (at least not until after it was released). Indeed I would call it more of an upgrade than a patch. Not really making a 'point' here, just clarifying. - George
Joe McGinn 06 Oct 1999#497737
The physics model was affected too (specifically wheelies). Joe McGinn ========================================== Staff Writer for the Sports *** Network [link lost in import: /***.com/] ==========================================
> The physics model was affected too (specifically wheelies). Not according to Motorsims and the testing I have done. See Miguel V. Parra's comment below: "The focus in the latest version had to do with online fixes since we had promised the open beta by Sept 30th, and yup we were one day late." - George
Miguel 07 Oct 1999#293497
I guess we have to wait for some unbiased person that has actually been at Laguna Seca to set the matter straight. If you care to tell me one of the parts that the track is not accurate, I'll go through the videos and the hundreds of reference pictures we have to see if you are correct or not, I wont post in here since this group is not a binary posting group, but I could scan it and send it to you via e-mail. Miguel Parra Motorsims MaX wrote in message <[email hidden]>... >I gaurantee you the track owners are not avid pc simulation players. >I'm sure the have little or no time with any car or motorcycle sim on >the pc. Sure they've given you visual approval, they probably don't >know any better. But I can tell you this. If they saw your Laguna >Seca and EA SBK's Laguna Seca in a side-by-side comparison, your >version would lose miserably.
Miguel 07 Oct 1999#293566
LOL Max, Give it a break already Our Laguna Seca has even visual approval from the track owners, need I say more :) And not just because of the track surface itself, it has way more details as well I'm not going to get tangled in a flame war with you, which is what it seems you want, instead I'll bite my tongue and let you be. I know better than that ;) Miguel Parra Motorsims MaX wrote in message <[email hidden]>... >Motorsims' version of Laguna Seca is the exact opposite of how good it >looks in EA Sports SBK. > >>PS: One thing I still wanna check out in your game is Laguna Seca. Ican't >>think of one perfect version of the track designed yet. My personal faveis >>from EA Sports SBK (pretty damn close and looked really wicked), and 2ndis one >>in CART Precision Racing (really good lay out, looked kinda blah comparedto >>SBK). Any hoo. Later. >> >
DjFIL 07 Oct 1999#497951
note to mark: this did go to newsgroups and you. just incase you care. I dunno why you would tho. any way... note to readers: i am still not a fan of this game, but I've settled down. also thanks for gigantic amout of replies to my message and the others. First and formost thank you for coming out and puting up your opinions on my opinions and actualy taking them as well as you have. Atleast you are working on it. One thing I didn't mention since I was on a "rampage" is the great job you've done on the advanced settings. Allows for you to get any type of controller working the way you want it to. But don't forget, dont need too much eye candy in a basic thing like the UI. Think of it this way, get it in between your UI (fancy pants, and huge on gfx and animations) and on the UI from CARTpr (kinda like your idea in some sence but really blah on looks). Otherwise good luck on this release, but my mind has been made. And I'm one to stick with first impressions. As I said earlier tho Mr. Crammond had many dates set for release of GP3. We may complain about this date being pushed back, but I am glad that he is trying to set high standards for his game before a retail copy is released. DjFIL PS: One thing I still wanna check out in your game is Laguna Seca. I can't think of one perfect version of the track designed yet. My personal fave is from EA Sports SBK (pretty damn close and looked really wicked), and 2nd is one in CART Precision Racing (really good lay out, looked kinda blah compared to SBK). Any hoo. Later.
Quoted text (31 lines)> > Where the hell did Motorsims think up this ***ass maze of a user > > interface. This truly is the slowest and most annoying ui I have ever > > seen in any game. [...] > First of all ... we are planning some rework to reduce the texture budget on > the UI. That's why it's slow loading a screen the first time - it's a LOT of > texture getting loaded. > Next, the UI was built that way for a very good reason. Most racing games > are "tunnel" interfaces. That is you go through a very rigid sequence each > time you want to get on the track: pick a bike, pick a track, tune the bike, > tune the settings, now I can drive. Or something similar. I agree, there > ain't much room for confusion there. > But ... For a game which will also support serious online play, having to do > that much work everytime you want to change races does not work well. It > becomes a royal pain real quick. It's just a different flow than you're used > to. > You seem to have already made up your mind about us ... but I figure you at > least deserved an explanation of what we were trying to do. > -MSM > -- > __________________________________________________________________________ > Mark S. Miller "Be regular and orderly in your life, > Director of Design that you may be *** and original > Motorsport Simulations in your work." > [link lost in import]
Ma 07 Oct 1999#497952
Motorsims' version of Laguna Seca is the exact opposite of how good it looks in EA Sports SBK.
Mark S. Miller 07 Oct 1999 15:50 UTC#293564
DjFIL <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > First and formost thank you for coming out and puting up your opinionson my > opinions and actualy taking them as well as you have. Atleast you areworking > on it. Constantly. > One thing I didn't mention since I was on a "rampage" is the great job > you've done on the advanced settings. Allows for you to get any type of > controller working the way you want it to. Thanks. That flexability also allows us to handle the fancier controllers. > But don't forget, dont need too much > eye candy in a basic thing like the UI. Yes. We did. You don't know our artists. <g> > Think of it this way, get it in between > your UI (fancy pants, and huge on gfx and animations) and on the UI fromCARTpr > (kinda like your idea in some sence but really blah on looks). Hey ... I admit we did get a bunch of WTF's about the UI. Once we explained why it was designed that way, a lot of people just go: "Oh ... I see ... makes sense." Another f'rinstance, there's a lot of repetetive work in sim racing. Tuning the vehicle being the biggest, but also tuning the controllers, tweeking custom skins, etc. Back and forth to the track. The way our UI works, you can get back to the track from almost every screen in the game. The downside is that there isn't one known path to go racing. It's a trade-off. > Otherwise good luck on this release, but my mind has been made. AndI'm one > to stick with first impressions. Never say never ... we'll get you yet <g>. > As I said earlier tho Mr. Crammond had many > dates set for release of GP3. We may complain about this date beingpushed > back, but I am glad that he is trying to set high standards for his gamebefore > a retail copy is released. As a company, we were not in a position to delay shipment any longer than we did. We ain't Sierra or Microsoft or EA. It's that simple. And, FWIW, I do *not* hold with the theory that "games are always late in releasing." Hell, look at Ensemble Studios ... they released Age of Kings weeks before they said they would (OK ... they have bazillions of MS dollars to use ... but anyway ...). All I can say is that we're fixing what's broken. > PS: One thing I still wanna check out in your game is Laguna Seca. [...] Seca asked to review the track model before signing their contract with us (we have contracts with every track) and were very, very pleased. -MSM -- __________________________________________________________________________ Mark S. Miller "Be regular and orderly in your life, Director of Design that you may be violent and original Motorsport Simulations in your work." [email hidden] -- Clive Barker ("Jihad") http://www.motorsims.com
Dave Henrie 07 Oct 1999 17:20 UTC#293582
DjFIL wrote: > > > PS: One thing I still wanna check out in your game is Laguna Seca. I can't think of one perfect version of the track designed yet. My personal fave is from EA Sports SBK (pretty damn close and looked really wicked), and 2nd is one > in CART Precision Racing (really good lay out, looked kinda blah compared to > SBK). Any hoo. Later. > I'm looking for the sarcasm warning sign. You thought CPR's Laguna was good? I only ran the demo...(famous last words) but where was the hill, I made the left turn, expecting to go up...I never got the sense that the run 'UP' to the corkscrew was UP at all. SCGT was different enough from the Papyrus ICR2 track that I took several laps before I came close to nailing the corkscrew. Just curious. dave henrie
MaX 07 Oct 1999 21:24 UTC#293477
I gaurantee you the track owners are not avid pc simulation players. I'm sure the have little or no time with any car or motorcycle sim on the pc. Sure they've given you visual approval, they probably don't know any better. But I can tell you this. If they saw your Laguna Seca and EA SBK's Laguna Seca in a side-by-side comparison, your version would lose miserably.
Quoted text (35 lines)>LOL Max, > >Give it a break already > >Our Laguna Seca has even visual approval from the track owners, need I say >more :) > >And not just because of the track surface itself, it has way more details as >well > >I'm not going to get tangled in a flame war with you, which is what it seems >you want, instead I'll bite my tongue and let you be. > > I know better than that ;) > >Miguel Parra >Motorsims > >MaX wrote in message <[email hidden]>... >>Motorsims' version of Laguna Seca is the exact opposite of how good it >>looks in EA Sports SBK. >> >>>PS: One thing I still wanna check out in your game is Laguna Seca. I >can't >>>think of one perfect version of the track designed yet. My personal fave >is >>>from EA Sports SBK (pretty damn close and looked really wicked), and 2nd >is one >>>in CART Precision Racing (really good lay out, looked kinda blah compared >to >>>SBK). Any hoo. Later. >>> >> > >
George M. Smiley 08 Oct 1999 01:22 UTC#293525
Miguel <[email hidden]> wrote: > I guess we have to wait for some unbiased person that has > actually been at Laguna Seca to set the matter straight. Myself and one of the other gamespot beta testers had a discussion about this a few weeks ago. In his opinion the tracks he has first hand knowledge of (Willow Springs, Sears Point, and Laguna Seca) are not entirely done justice by AMA Superbike. He did praise the CHS 2000 version of Laguna Seca (although the game itself wasn't much to write home about). His opinion, not mine, unfortunately he doesn't read newsgroups so he isn't here to share it (smart guy, eh?). The only track I have first hand experience with is Mid-Ohio and it seems reasonably close for a game. Camber is off in some of the corners and a few of the elevation changes seem a bit too 'pointy'. The other AMA track I have ridden got cut (Las Vegas) but there really isn't much to screw up there. I'm curious, how did you go about constructing the tracks? - George
Matthew V. Jessick 08 Oct 1999 02:45 UTC#293390
Dave Henrie wrote: > I'm looking for the sarcasm warning sign. You thought CPR's Laguna > was good? I only ran the demo...(famous last words) but where was the > hill, I made the left turn, expecting to go up...I never got the sense > that the run 'UP' to the corkscrew was UP at all. AMA Superbike's LSR was "up" enough that we had to increase the maximum altitude used on some of our aerial debugging views after the first time we used them... The corkscrew isn't as impressive from underground ;) -- Matthew V. Jessick Motorsims [email hidden] http://www.motorsims.com Vehicle Dynamics Engineer (972)910-8866 Ext.125, Fax: (972)910-8216
Dave Henrie 08 Oct 1999 02:49 UTC#293391
"Matthew V. Jessick" wrote:
Quoted text (17 lines)> > Dave Henrie wrote: > > > I'm looking for the sarcasm warning sign. You thought CPR's Laguna > > was good? I only ran the demo...(famous last words) but where was the > > hill, I made the left turn, expecting to go up...I never got the sense > > that the run 'UP' to the corkscrew was UP at all. > > AMA Superbike's LSR was "up" enough that we > had to increase the maximum altitude used on some of > our aerial debugging views after the first time we used them... > The corkscrew isn't as impressive from underground ;) > > -- > Matthew V. Jessick Motorsims > [email hidden] http://www.motorsims.com > Vehicle Dynamics Engineer (972)910-8866 Ext.125, Fax: (972)910-8216
good way to study tire contact patches?? I have a couple of questions. Online race, I got a penalty for an off course excursion. How do I serve that? Just wait til the last flagman grabs my over and holds me for a short time? and I had one race red flagged after a bozo went backwards. What do we do when the course marshalls are waving the red flag? Gotta work on that warping! dave henrie
Matthew V. Jessick 08 Oct 1999 03:15 UTC#293396
Dave Henrie wrote: > "Matthew V. Jessick" wrote: > good way to study tire contact patches?? ;) > I have a couple of questions. > Online race, I got a penalty for an off course excursion. How do I > serve that? Just wait til the last flagman grabs my over and holds me > for a short time? and I had one race red flagged after a bozo went > backwards. Actually, the online red flags come from multiple simultaneous wrecks on or near the course. We may have to increase the threshold until the local motorcycle shops run out of stock ;) As for the penalty system, I really don't want to talk about it. ;) We just couldn't get a proper stop and go penalty system in for this version. ;( It requires the option of grabbing a "jerk" and forcing him into the pit lane to handle his "time out" and that is a bit complicated. A similar system is needed our first SCCA game for several uses so as soon as it's developed for that one I expect we'll get it into AMA Superbike also. (We thought of just teleporting miscreants to a corner of a garage for awhile, but that was vetoed as possibly encouraging a tantrum ;) > What do we do when the course marshalls are waving the red > flag? No comment. (We were intending to restart the race, but haven't coded that process yet! :):) -- Matthew V. Jessick Motorsims [email hidden] http://www.motorsims.com Vehicle Dynamics Engineer (972)910-8866 Ext.125, Fax: (972)910-8216

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy