Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

Nascar 3 vs GPL

34 posts by 21 people · 22 Sep 1999 - 13 Oct 1999 20:41 UTC

NASCAR Racing 3 versus Grand Prix Legends physics

Posters debated whether GPL fans were unfairly trashing N3, pointing out that the physics are the same even though a 1967 F1 car and a 1999 stock car handle very differently. Some wanted an IndyCar Racing II update or a sim built on the GPL engine. Others speculated about Papyrus's next projects, such as the GPL 1.2 patch and NASCAR 4, and N3's improved online collision handling was praised.

game comparisonphysics/realism debaterumour/speculationNASCAR Racing 3Grand Prix Legends

Automated summary.

dbon.. 22 Sep 1999#494295
Did anyone actually think that the multitudes of diehard GPL fans that populate this newsgroup wouldn't ***all over N3 once it was released? As far as physics go, lets be "realistic", isn't there supposed to be a huge difference in physics between a '67 F1 car with no downforce, and a '99 stock car??
Not in the world in which I inhabit. F=ma no matter what type of car, vehicle or object you drive, ride or what not. However, yes there is a huge difference in how a 67 F1 car handles in comparison to how a 99 stock car handles and a lot of that has to do with tire compounds, aerodynamics, weight, etc.
Dan Belcher 22 Sep 1999#494297
Well, I personally LOVE Grand Prix Legends, but I'm not crapping all over NASCAR3. It's a pretty good sim IMHO. Now only if Papy would do this kind of upgrade to IndyCar 2... Dan Belcher Team Racing Unlimited
NO!!! I don't want ICR2 with ICR2 physics/driving model and 1024x768 resolution graphics. I want ICR2 with GPL physics engine.
Physics is Physics......Handling is Handling... of course there is a huge difference between 1967 and modern cars in terms of handling...but the physics remain the same. GPL has real world physics all other don't. > Did anyone actually think that the multitudes of diehard GPL fans > that populate this newsgroup wouldn't ***all over N3 once it was > released? As far as physics go, lets be "realistic", isn't there > supposed to be a huge difference in physics between a '67 F1 car with > no downforce, and a '99 stock car??
Maybe it would be better to say that GPL's physics are closer to real world than anyone elses. I doubt even Papy would say that the physics are 100% accurate. Wayne Hutchison > Physics is Physics......Handling is Handling... > of course there is a huge difference between 1967 and modern cars in terms > of handling...but the physics remain the same. > GPL has real world physics all other don't.
Now there's a nice surprise. :o)
Quoted text (22 lines)> Maybe it would be better to say that GPL's physics are closer to real world > than anyone elses. I doubt even Papy would say that the physics are 100% > accurate. > Wayne Hutchison > > Physics is Physics......Handling is Handling... > > of course there is a huge difference between 1967 and modern cars in terms > > of handling...but the physics remain the same. > > GPL has real world physics all other don't. > > > Did anyone actually think that the multitudes of diehard GPL fans > > > that populate this newsgroup wouldn't ***all over N3 once it was > > > released? As far as physics go, lets be "realistic", isn't there > > > supposed to be a huge difference in physics between a '67 F1 car with > > > no downforce, and a '99 stock car??
-- Rob Swindells 3rd equal in Goldline Bearings FFord Championship (29 Points); ONE point behind Championship Leader (as of round 5 of 6) "If you're a great driver, you will get through. It's not harder than any time before." ~Martin Brundle "Winning, that you can't know, 'fighting' ...that I know..." ~Jacques Villeneuve pre'96
Brian 23 Sep 1999#494611
While I've been eagerly awaiting N3 here in Ottawa, Canada, I went back to N1999 and raced at Loudon. I haven't had that many hours with N2/N1999 and was pretty lapping slowly,but consistently at around 31.5 seconds. Then for comparison, I went into GPL and ran 30 laps at Loudon (converted from N1999) - I had a fastest lap of about 31.2 secs. I found it interesting that my times were very close in a '67 F1 sim and a '99 stock car sim - the BIG difference to me was the amount of concentration required with GPL. My lap times varied more in GPL (31.2 to 33.1 secs) than in N1999 (31.3 to 32 secs). The pure driving experience was much more rewarding with GPL at Loudon than N1999 - the overall racing experience was not so good, GPL AI are pretty bad for the converted ovals (leaders can't seem to pass backmarkers). The interesting thing to ME (someone who's never driven a stockcar, 60's F1, nor any racing car for that matter) is that GPL's handling feel at Loudon felt really good and could easily pass as a stockcar sim's handling. If I tried it without a visible***pit and someone told me that it was the beta for N4/2000, I would have believed it (except for the 5th gear of course). Soo ... here's hoping Dave Noonan comes out with a full ICR2/N1999->GPL converter and someone like Paul Hoad (or someone using his 3D editor) develops a stockcar body for GPL. Of course, a lot will still be missing (yellow flag/pace laps, pit stops, grill tape ...). However, I'm not sure how many others would be interested - how many oval races have there been recently on VROC? Don't get me wrong, I will still get N3 and enjoy the 3D sound, force feedback, 1024x768 resolution, ... Brian > Physics is Physics......Handling is Handling... > of course there is a huge difference between 1967 and modern cars in terms > of handling...but the physics remain the same. > GPL has real world physics all other don't.
Dan Belcher 23 Sep 1999#494612
It'll be awhile before Papy could ever make that. I just need an improved ICR2 to hold me over till they finish that. ;) Dan Belcher Team Racing Unlimited
back to What are you waiting for? EB has had it for a week now. Got mine at EB at Carlingwood Sept. 16. The FFB & built in multiplayer are worth the price of admission alone (IMHO - of course). Considering the only "new" game I've gotten since GPL is "The Patch For GPL", I think it's worth the $70 (CAN). Randy Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ Share what you know. Learn what you don't.
Rexv 23 Sep 1999#494614
What? You'd like to pay another $50 for IC2's "Eye candy and still buggy' edition? Hey, you are on your own there. ____________________ Hydrogen and Stupidity.. The two most universal elements
Rexv 23 Sep 1999#494615
>Did anyone actually think that the multitudes of diehard GPL fans >that populate this newsgroup wouldn't ***all over N3 once it was >released? As far as physics go, lets be "realistic", isn't there >supposed to be a huge difference in physics between a '67 F1 car with >no downforce, and a '99 stock car?? There is indeed supposed to be a huge difference, just as there is to be a difference between a game marketted as a simulation and a game marketted as an arcade style. N3 is definitely under the Arcade group. I've played arcade games that let you upgrade the suspensions before and some of those work better than N3! ____________________ Hydrogen and Stupidity.. The two most universal elements
Goy Larsen 23 Sep 1999#494616
Quoted text (8 lines)> Now there's a nice surprise. :o) > > Maybe it would be better to say that GPL's physics are closer to real world > > than anyone elses. I doubt even Papy would say that the physics are 100% > > accurate.
Ok, I'll show my ignorance, or lack of long term memory (whichever makes me look less stupid :-), but who's Wayne ? -- Beers and cheers (uncle) Goy "Team Mirage" http://www.teammirage.com/ "The Pits" http://www.theuspits.com/
On Wed, 22 Sep 1999 19:18:02 -0400, "Wayne Hutchison" No one currently working for Papy at least. I've still got some messages posted by Mike L. on CSi ;-) Cheers, Richard
Goy Larsen 23 Sep 1999#494619
> >Ok, I'll show my ignorance, or lack of long term memory (whichever makes > >me look less stupid :-), but who's Wayne ? > Always the outsider, eh Goy? <g> Uh yeah, and the strange thing is that the more I think about it, the more I feel I *ought* to know this, oh well, some kind soul will someday tell me......:-) -- Beers and cheers (uncle) Goy "Team Mirage" http://www.teammirage.com/ "The Pits" http://www.theuspits.com/
Anyone care to guess what Papyrus is now working on since Nascar3 is finished. They originally stated that they put ICR3(?) on hold till they finished Nascar3. We know that Sierra won't allow them to make GPL2 since GPL was a money loser. Joel Willstein
Blackra 23 Sep 1999#494621
Quoted text (8 lines)>> >Ok, I'll show my ignorance, or lack of long term memory (whichever makes >> >me look less stupid :-), but who's Wayne ? >> Always the outsider, eh Goy? <g> >Uh yeah, and the strange thing is that the more I think about it, the >more I feel I *ought* to know this, oh well, some kind soul will someday >tell me......:-)
Hi Goy, Hmmm, you might just find Wayne in the below web page ;-)) I don't get any kinder than that <G> Cheers Mark Fisher aka Blackrat Brain Fade Racing http://website.lineone.net/~black_rat/legends.htm
Quoted text (29 lines)> While I've been eagerly awaiting N3 here in Ottawa, Canada, I went back to > N1999 and raced at Loudon. I haven't had that many hours with N2/N1999 and > was pretty lapping slowly,but consistently at around 31.5 seconds. Then for > comparison, I went into GPL and ran 30 laps at Loudon (converted from > N1999) - I had a fastest lap of about 31.2 secs. > I found it interesting that my times were very close in a '67 F1 sim and a > '99 stock car sim - the BIG difference to me was the amount of concentration > required with GPL. My lap times varied more in GPL (31.2 to 33.1 secs) > than in N1999 (31.3 to 32 secs). > The pure driving experience was much more rewarding with GPL at Loudon than > N1999 - the overall racing experience was not so good, GPL AI are pretty bad > for the converted ovals (leaders can't seem to pass backmarkers). The > interesting thing to ME (someone who's never driven a stockcar, 60's F1, nor > any racing car for that matter) is that GPL's handling feel at Loudon felt > really good and could easily pass as a stockcar sim's handling. If I tried > it without a visible***pit and someone told me that it was the beta for > N4/2000, I would have believed it (except for the 5th gear of course). > Soo ... here's hoping Dave Noonan comes out with a full ICR2/N1999->GPL > converter and someone like Paul Hoad (or someone using his 3D editor) > develops a stockcar body for GPL. Of course, a lot will still be missing > (yellow flag/pace laps, pit stops, grill tape ...). However, I'm not sure > how many others would be interested - how many oval races have there been > recently on VROC? > Don't get me wrong, I will still get N3 and enjoy the 3D sound, force > feedback, 1024x768 resolution, ...
I can't wait for the N3 to GPL converter either :-) I've been practicing drafting with my F3 car for some time but can only draft the length of a strait. In the corners we are too slow for any drafting to occur, but are still nose cone to tail pipe. So, When N3 to GPL comes out, I can't wait to be able to win races on *PURE* drafting abilities on Taladega in F3 ;-) I'd assume that the F1's would be equivalent to stock cars at the same track in speed(?) Then to get into the track with the smaller radius turns to start learning more and more about car handling, braking, excel oration.. then to jump into the original GPL track, I'd assume with the knowledge gained from above would give me faster and more stable laps. Basically, I can easily see where oval tracks can give us a teaching tool for the real racing of the road courses. ;-) ========================================= Mike Barlow of Barlow Racing? ========================================= Racing online with the help of...... Race Communications Association http://members.xoom.com/RCA/toc.html Holodyne Engineering Mystic Music (have Your !!Name/Address!! placed here)
Goy Larsen 23 Sep 1999#494623
> Hi Goy, > Hmmm, you might just find Wayne in the below web page ;-)) > I don't get any kinder than that <G> You're a kind rat Mark :-) So, you getting ready to go online in N3 soon ? No way I'm getting near a GPL track with you guys any more, not that I mind getting beaten, but getting humiliated is not much fun :-)) -- Beers and cheers (uncle) Goy "Team Mirage" http://www.teammirage.com/ "The Pits" http://www.theuspits.com/
Blackra 23 Sep 1999#494624
Quoted text (12 lines)>> Hi Goy, >> Hmmm, you might just find Wayne in the below web page ;-)) >> I don't get any kinder than that <G> >You're a kind rat Mark :-) >So, you getting ready to go online in N3 soon ? >No way I'm getting near a GPL track with you guys any more, not that I >mind getting beaten, but getting humiliated is not much fun :-))
Hi Goy, Well we are a few secs a lap faster now <G>, but that is all relevent to the guys you race with and we have all improved at similar rates ;-) As for on-line N3, I would like to think so, I should have the box in my grubby mitts by Monday :-) I don't think it will be realistic for me to actually join a league due to work, but I would sure like some decent door to door racing again. Rik and I have had a little trial H2H just to see how rubbin' is handled :-)) Cheers Mark Fisher aka Blackrat Brain Fade Racing http://website.lineone.net/~black_rat/legends.htm
>Did anyone actually think that the multitudes of diehard GPL fans >that populate this newsgroup wouldn't ***all over N3 once it was >released? As far as physics go, lets be "realistic", isn't there >supposed to be a huge difference in physics between a '67 F1 car with >no downforce, and a '99 stock car?? No - not on this planet. Physical laws are physical laws. Cheers! John
ymenard 24 Sep 1999#494992
Well I figure there is probably minimum 3teams working on those projects : 1) the GPL 1.2 patch. I hope it will ever be released, but I consider the fact that it's probably a very small team that also works on other projects at the same time. 2) Nascar Racing 4. It was never cancelled but only "postponed". It is already in development since more than a year now, and it continues to do so. 3) Nascar Racing 3 patch. There will be one, Im absolutely, positively sure. So there must be a team working on this, since there is many issues, especially on the multiplayer side of the game, that needs to be patched, fixed or added. No Papyrus title had no patch (except SODA, but that's another thing), so there will be one for N3, 100% sure. As for other development teams, I have seriously no idea, I speculate and I know rumors but that's all. -- -- Fran?ois Mnard <ymenard> -- May the Downforce be with you... "People think it must be fun to be a super genius, but they don't realise how hard it is to put up with all the idiots in the world."
Goy Larsen 24 Sep 1999#494993
> Hi Goy, > Well we are a few secs a lap faster now <G>, but that is all relevent > to the guys you race with and we have all improved at similar rates > ;-) Well, I haven't, so there you have it :-) I have a feeling that the collition detection is much improved, I've raced side by side with a few people, much closer than you ever could on TEN, Stu and I was racing at Sears the other day (now there's a surprise :-) and for a little while I was ahead (now that WAS a surprise :-) and down through the esses Stu gave a couple of friendly nudges, got me a tad out of shape, but nothing like N2 on TEN ever was, so on a fast stable host, this can be a lot of fun -- Beers and cheers (uncle) Goy "Team Mirage" http://www.teammirage.com/ "The Pits" http://www.theuspits.com/
Blackra 24 Sep 1999#494994
Quoted text (7 lines)>I have a feeling that the collition detection is much improved, I've >raced side by side with a few people, much closer than you ever could on >TEN, Stu and I was racing at Sears the other day (now there's a surprise >:-) and for a little while I was ahead (now that WAS a surprise :-) and >down through the esses Stu gave a couple of friendly nudges, got me a >tad out of shape, but nothing like N2 on TEN ever was, so on a fast >stable host, this can be a lot of fun
Yes Sears was a surprise, a third of it has disappeared <GG>, I ran around it and the next thing I know I am at ten last turn. As to ten collision detection, yes it does appear to have improved and it does make it more fun on-line as Rik and I found out. You can get ten car sideways and back again where as before that was it, you were history. However we did question, or rather Rik did <G>, whether the cars should be as stable as they are now, whether realism has been sacrificed for more fun. I'm not complaining, it just makes ten racing that much closer. Cheers Mark Fisher aka Blackrat Brain Fade Racing http://website.lineone.net/~black_rat/legends.htm
Goy Larsen 24 Sep 1999#494995
> Yes Sears was a surprise, a third of it has disappeared <GG>, I ran > around it and the next thing I know I am at ten last turn. LOL, yeah, that came with N99, too bad, they (NASCAR ?) ruined a good track.. Uhm, not sure I agree with Rik here, running on my own at Wg I don't think my car is easier to drive as such, I just feel they have improved on the things that happen when 2 cars touch, on TEN you were history unless you hit them square in the back, now you have a chance to catch it, much better for online anyway Oh, never realised before that you have a typing disorder, ten instead of the ? Or is that a result a few beers already :-) -- Beers and cheers (uncle) Goy "Team Mirage" http://www.teammirage.com/ "The Pits" http://www.theuspits.com/
Blackra 24 Sep 1999#494996
Quoted text (10 lines)>Uhm, not sure I agree with Rik here, running on my own at Wg I don't >think my car is easier to drive as such, I just feel they have improved >on the things that happen when 2 cars touch, on TEN you were history >unless you hit them square in the back, now you have a chance to catch >it, much better for online anyway >Oh, never realised before that you have a typing disorder, ten instead >of the ? >Or is that a result a few beers already :-)
Instead of the what? ;-) Hehe, no beers this weeks, a long week of nights, it looks more like I can't operate the speel chicker properly <G>. I must say I like the way you can take a different line at a reasonable speed and not hit the wall. But not enough time to race N3 and GPL ATM ;-). Cheers Mark Fisher aka Blackrat Brain Fade Racing http://website.lineone.net/~black_rat/legends.htm
I sort of think it's better for online racing although I'm not 100% convinced. It is certainly a good thing when we are driving round Dega swapping the lead twice every lap and knowing that a minor mistake won't end the race for either of us. But in pick ups at least, people will drive to the limits of what is available. So I fully expect to see just as many pointless "accidents" in N3 as there ever were with N2. And given that league racing has just taken a huge step back.... :(( I do find that the overall feel of the car has been reduced somewhat which is disappointing. N2 never had a great deal of finesse in the driving model and, if anything, I find that N3 has less. Maybe when I've driven it more I'll change my mind but so far, I find that if I just stomp on the brake into a turn and feed the power back in any way at all, the car will get through the turn just fine. You need to ask? <g> Cheers, Richard
Mapson 26 Sep 1999#495518
>Did anyone actually think that the multitudes of diehard GPL fans >that populate this newsgroup wouldn't ***all over N3 once it was >released? I only thought they'd *** about the newsgroup overpopulation. They probably have a lot more in common than a '99 stock car and a '99 CART car.
Goy Larsen 27 Sep 1999#495611
Quoted text (7 lines)> I sort of think it's better for online racing although I'm not 100% > convinced. It is certainly a good thing when we are driving round Dega > swapping the lead twice every lap and knowing that a minor mistake won't > end the race for either of us. But in pick ups at least, people will drive > to the limits of what is available. So I fully expect to see just as many > pointless "accidents" in N3 as there ever were with N2. And given that > league racing has just taken a huge step back.... :((
True, I haven't ran any PU races as of yet, but the few races I've run with people I know and trust has been very good, passed a guy on the OUTSIDE at Homestead yeasterday, and ran several laps side by side at Martinsville, think he took about 5 laps to pass me, so once we gat the hosting/server thing sorted, I think this is a great step forward for MP As it did in N2 with the proper setup, if I understood you right, I happen to think that the cars now "feel" heavier and the line is wider, in N2 there was ONE line through the corner, now you can run the high line and still keep it off the wall and maintain a decent speed, love it, once I get to the end of my TPTCC season, I'll probably never fire up N2/N99 again, I've even zipped up my TEN/N2 folder and are going to archive it on a CD-r for future reference :-) Uh, no, not really .............. -- Beers and cheers (uncle) Goy "Team Mirage" http://www.teammirage.com/ "The Pits" http://www.theuspits.com/
% 2) Nascar Racing 4. It was never cancelled but only "postponed". It is % already in development since more than a year now, and it continues to do % so. NASCAR Racing 4 based on a beefed up N1/N2/N3 engine I would hazard to guess. -- **************************** Michael E. Carver ************************* Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town. =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
Thom j. 13 Oct 1999 10:47 UTC#292730
'Ditto' on a new IndyCar 2 & I'd even take a carset that could be put in N3 that were Cart or IRL cars of season99. N3 also is alot of fun. It ain't GPL but it is fun.. So Papy please read & take heed guys!!! Cheers Thom_j.
Quoted text (13 lines)>Dan Belcher wrote in message ><[email hidden]>... >>Well, I personally LOVE Grand Prix Legends, but I'm not crapping all over >>NASCAR3. It's a pretty good sim IMHO. Now only if Papy would do this >>kind of upgrade to IndyCar 2... > >> > >> > >>Dan Belcher > >>Team Racing Unlimited > > > > Anyone care to guess what Papyrus is now working on since Nascar3 is > >finished. They originally stated that they put ICR3(?) on hold till they > >finished Nascar3. We know that Sierra won't allow them to make GPL2
since > >GPL was a money loser. > > > >Joel Willstein > >[email hidden]
Daniel 13 Oct 1999 17:58 UTC#292781
But would'nt an Indycar sim regardless of physics sell extremely well especially in US. I think the average simmer really wants modern simulations IMO. Daniel. Joel Willstein wrote in message <7sde35$bfe$[email hidden]>... > >Dan Belcher wrote in message ><[email hidden]>... >>Well, I personally LOVE Grand Prix Legends, but I'm not crapping all over >>NASCAR3. It's a pretty good sim IMHO. Now only if Papy would do thiskind
Quoted text (15 lines)>of >>upgrade to IndyCar 2... >> >> >>Dan Belcher >>Team Racing Unlimited > > Anyone care to guess what Papyrus is now working on since Nascar3 is >finished. They originally stated that they put ICR3(?) on hold till they >finished Nascar3. We know that Sierra won't allow them to make GPL2 since >GPL was a money loser. > >Joel Willstein >[email hidden] >
WarriorSpirit 13 Oct 1999 20:41 UTC#292627
So, you broke down and bought it huh? Just couldn't wait to see if Santa would bring it to you. Oh well, I think 'fun' is the whole idea! In article <6rZM3.806$[email hidden]>, "Thom j." <[email hidden]> wrote: > >'Ditto' on a new IndyCar 2 & I'd even take a carset that could >be put in N3 that were Cart or IRL cars of season99. N3 also >is alot of fun. It ain't GPL but it is fun.. So Papy please read & >take heed guys!!! Cheers Thom_j. WarriorSpirit

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy