I was in Vancouver recently and had a chance to play a near-Gold
version of SuperBikes. I promised not to reveal anymore detail than
that about the where/who/how, so don't bother asking.
Now I know you're already skeptical seeing the words "EA" and "you'll
like it" in a thread title in an autosim group. But this may finally
be the game that brakes EA out of their arcade-only mold.
Now I'm no motorcycle expert, so I'm not tossing around any proven
conclusions or comparisons to other sims. But to me the physics
modeling seemed pretty damn good (in simulation mode). I'm not going
to talk much about the graphics, you've seen how great the demo looks.
If you start up too fast, especially sitting up, the bike will flip
from under you. Slow down to fast it will wobble and, under extreme
braking, the back will rise and flip. The turning and control seems
realistic, and it's very possible to lose the bike in a variety of
interesting (and painful looking!) ways that are indicative, to me, of
a fairly advanced physics model. It doesn't seem canned in any way.
Two examples. One, I'm off on the grass trying to get to the road,
tires spinning. I spin out a bit, just a I catch the concrete while
sliding sideways - and the bike flips over me when the wheels get
purchase. Two, even more interesting, I was heavily braking going
downhill (at the A1-Ring track I think it was called), braking way too
hard. I started to wobble and my back wheel lifted, I was going to
flip. But just in time I eased up on the brakes to let the front wheel
run, and the back wheel dropped again! I was too late for the corner
of course but was able to slide into the sand (i.e., instead of
flipping on concrete). The replay showed an awesome image of the bike
up on it's front wheel, the ass-end wobbling as it rose higher and
higher, and finally dropping before the slide. There's no way they
canned that.
Speaking of hills, they are done very nicely on the tracks that have
them. There's a real good feeling of elevation change.
The***pit mode is well done. (The F2 one - not the one where your
head moves independently of the bike.) I used the F4 (arcade) view for
a while, but found the***pit mode more immersive and with a better
sense of speed, once I got used to it. Once I knew the track I was
able to drive better with in***pit mode too. It has good visual
feedback such as handle bar shakes (for wobble when breaking too hard)
and you can see the chassis rising and falling when under
acceleration/decelleration. The***pit reminds me of GPL's, in that
it very much feels like a dynamic, moving object, not a static bitmap.
There are a whole host of bike setup options which I am not qualified
to review. Seemed to be a lot of choices (e.g., many adjustable parts
to the front and rear suspension).
I couldn't find any menus to enable bike damage. This seems like an
odd omission. The engine will blow out if you rev too high (or
downshift too fast) but crashes don't seem to damage the bike.
There is a weather option (sunny/cloudy/wet) but I didn't have time to
try it.
Anyway, in conclusion I'm buying this one as soon as it comes out. For
those still skeptical, I can only assume EA will release an updated
demo closer to the release date. The sim mode is too good to kept
secret.
Joe
Hands-on impressions of EA's Superbike World Championship
A poster who had played a near-final version of Superbike World Championship reported that its simulation mode was a genuine sim with options to help newcomers. A real rider questioned how well it modelled front-end tucks and crashes, while other players offered control tips and LAN impressions. Posters noted it was developed by Milestone in Italy, not by EA itself.
Automated summary.
Joe wrote
It's a great title. I got reports by everybody that it's a true simulation
(unfortunately it's available on the warez scene).
I hope they rethink their approach to the market, because many people now
have a really bad name of Electronic Arts with their racing title. But we
need to understand that EA is only producing both Superbike SBK and Sports
Car GT.
-= Fran?ois Mnard <ymenard/Nas-Frank>
-= NROS Nascar sanctioned Guide http://www.nros.com/
-= SimRacing Online http://www.simracing.com/
-= Official mentally retarded guy of r.a.s.
-= May the Downforce be with you...
"People think it must be fun to be a super genius, but they don't realise
how hard it is to put up with all the idiots in the world."
I am also impressed with the demo, although it is in arcade mode.
I really hope that the future formule 1 games from EA sports will be as
realistic.
Remco
<snip>
> If you start up too fast, especially sitting up, the bike will flip
> from under you. Slow down to fast it will wobble and, under extreme
> braking, the back will rise and flip. The turning and control seems
> realistic, and it's very possible to lose the bike in a variety of
> interesting (and painful looking!) ways that are indicative, to me, of
> a fairly advanced physics model. It doesn't seem canned in any way. <snip>
> Joe
Thanks for your report Joe, I've been waiting for something like this,
but I'm always wondering: How do we control a superbike-sim thru our
well-known interfaces? Mouse? GamePad? Wheel/Pedal-combo? Joystick?
Keyboard? Even those Pinball controllers :-)?
I can't see how I can get close to control my real life motorcycle thru
our pc-interfaces...
It has to be an "analogue" device, and Motocross Madness was into
something, where we controlled the weight on top of the bike when
turning the joystick forward and back, but then the power and braking
was on/off. Maybe we have to use our flight-controllers?
Joystick/pedal-combo comes to mind, which works great in my opinion also
in GPL.
The input devices in a SuperBike-sim _has_ to work, or else it won't be
any fun at all...
Any ideas welcome,
JoHS, Norway
>I was in Vancouver recently and had a chance to play a near-Gold
>version of SuperBikes. I promised not to reveal anymore detail than
>that about the where/who/how, so don't bother asking.
One thing I forgot to mention. For a sim the game has a lot of
features to make it more approachable for non-experts. The practice
mode includes markers for optimum braking points for each turn, and
best line markers. You can select the skill/speed level of computer
drivers, and at the lowest level it takes only a little practive to
become competitive.
Oh yeah, and the setup/sim crowd will LOVE the "telemetry" feature.
You can practice a bunch of laps, adjusting setups, and then compare
any two laps you choose on a graph. You can graph all sorts of
variables - speed, acceleration, and about six or seven others. Youy
can even zoom in on the graph to study the data in detail for a
particular part of the track. IMO this is a huge leap over trying to
setup a vehicle just by feel and lap times, and once seen should
become a standard feature in all serious sims.
Joe
>Well I base my idea of what EA are going to do with F1 on this game
Why do you say that? Is it being programmed by the same company?
Remember EA is just the producer of Superbikes.
I did but just one lap, near the beginning of me session. I was still
getting a handle on sim-mode control at that point, so it's hard to
say how fun that track is. I spent most of my time at A1-Ring (a
totally awesome track) and a bit at Hockenhiem and one other I can't
recall the name of.
Joe
Well I base my idea of what EA are going to do with F1 on this game so I
hope its as good as it sounds. Pity you didn't have time to try out the
rain, I can imagine balancing a superbike in the wet would be pretty darn
hairy!!! Also did you give it a go at laguna seca? One of my favorite tracks
and I bet its interesting on a bike.
-Berno
I have no idea what company is going to develop the F1 game for EA is. But I
hope with a licence that im sure Mr Ecclestone made them dig deep for theyre
not going to hand it to a bunch of baffoons. EA still does some dev in house
and there are varying contracts the company has with developers so they dont
always just produce and publish. Who is making superbikes? Is it inhouse at
EA sports? Either way at least it shows that they can publish a simulation.
-Berno
> >Well I base my idea of what EA are going to do with F1 on this game
> Why do you say that? Is it being programmed by the same company?
> Remember EA is just the producer of Superbikes.
Don't forget also that EA picked this title up almost complete when they
bought Westwood and their choice of the ex-*** titles. Virtually all
the development was done under *** Europe in London, and the team was
the same one that did Screamer 2 - they're based in Italy.
They'd probably be a good choice for the F1 game though.
- Michael
tatus: N
it is very good, but really needs to be played in isolation... it's quite a
jump from sim mode to back to 4 wheels. ;)
Z.
Please remove NOSPAM from my email address when replying.
Quoted text (13 lines)
>> >Well I base my idea of what EA are going to do with F1 on this game >> Why do you say that? Is it being programmed by the same company? >> Remember EA is just the producer of Superbikes. >Don't forget also that EA picked this title up almost complete when they >bought Westwood and their choice of the ex-*** titles. Virtually all >the development was done under *** Europe in London, and the team was >the same one that did Screamer 2 - they're based in Italy. >They'd probably be a good choice for the F1 game though. >- Michael% >Why do you say that? Is it being programmed by the same company?
% >Remember EA is just the producer of Superbikes.
% I have no idea what company is going to develop the F1 game for EA is. But I
% hope with a licence that im sure Mr Ecclestone made them dig deep for theyre
% not going to hand it to a bunch of baffoons. EA still does some dev in house
% and there are varying contracts the company has with developers so they dont
% always just produce and publish. Who is making superbikes? Is it inhouse at
% EA sports? Either way at least it shows that they can publish a simulation.
Sorry to say, but if the baffoons have deep pockets and those pockets
are lined with big bucks, Bernie will sell his mother's grave.
--
**************************** Michael E. Carver *************************
Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town.
=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
Superbike makers are Italians.
Rafael
Quoted text (11 lines)
> >Why do you say that? Is it being programmed by the same company? > >Remember EA is just the producer of Superbikes. > I have no idea what company is going to develop the F1 game for EA is. But I > hope with a licence that im sure Mr Ecclestone made them dig deep for theyre > not going to hand it to a bunch of baffoons. EA still does some dev in house > and there are varying contracts the company has with developers so they dont > always just produce and publish. Who is making superbikes? Is it inhouse at > EA sports? Either way at least it shows that they can publish a simulation. > -BernoJoe, can you answer these simple questions?
All in sim mode
When going straight and very fast and you instantly hit the brakes on full
max, what happens? The front should tuck immediately and send you and the
bike on a long easy slide.
When entering a turn too hot, can you throw the bike in the turn and loose
the front end before getting to the apex?
Can you do powerslides exiting corners?
What happens when you go in the grass or gravel at a medium speed and try
to turn a bit?
thanks
Destroy
Quoted text (64 lines)
> I was in Vancouver recently and had a chance to play a near-Gold > version of SuperBikes. I promised not to reveal anymore detail than > that about the where/who/how, so don't bother asking. > Now I know you're already skeptical seeing the words "EA" and "you'll > like it" in a thread title in an autosim group. But this may finally > be the game that brakes EA out of their arcade-only mold. > Now I'm no motorcycle expert, so I'm not tossing around any proven > conclusions or comparisons to other sims. But to me the physics > modeling seemed pretty damn good (in simulation mode). I'm not going > to talk much about the graphics, you've seen how great the demo looks. > If you start up too fast, especially sitting up, the bike will flip > from under you. Slow down to fast it will wobble and, under extreme > braking, the back will rise and flip. The turning and control seems > realistic, and it's very possible to lose the bike in a variety of > interesting (and painful looking!) ways that are indicative, to me, of > a fairly advanced physics model. It doesn't seem canned in any way. > Two examples. One, I'm off on the grass trying to get to the road, > tires spinning. I spin out a bit, just a I catch the concrete while > sliding sideways - and the bike flips over me when the wheels get > purchase. Two, even more interesting, I was heavily braking going > downhill (at the A1-Ring track I think it was called), braking way too > hard. I started to wobble and my back wheel lifted, I was going to > flip. But just in time I eased up on the brakes to let the front wheel > run, and the back wheel dropped again! I was too late for the corner > of course but was able to slide into the sand (i.e., instead of > flipping on concrete). The replay showed an awesome image of the bike > up on it's front wheel, the ass-end wobbling as it rose higher and > higher, and finally dropping before the slide. There's no way they > canned that. > Speaking of hills, they are done very nicely on the tracks that have > them. There's a real good feeling of elevation change. > The***pit mode is well done. (The F2 one - not the one where your > head moves independently of the bike.) I used the F4 (arcade) view for > a while, but found the***pit mode more immersive and with a better > sense of speed, once I got used to it. Once I knew the track I was > able to drive better with in***pit mode too. It has good visual > feedback such as handle bar shakes (for wobble when breaking too hard) > and you can see the chassis rising and falling when under > acceleration/decelleration. The***pit reminds me of GPL's, in that > it very much feels like a dynamic, moving object, not a static bitmap. > There are a whole host of bike setup options which I am not qualified > to review. Seemed to be a lot of choices (e.g., many adjustable parts > to the front and rear suspension). > I couldn't find any menus to enable bike damage. This seems like an > odd omission. The engine will blow out if you rev too high (or > downshift too fast) but crashes don't seem to damage the bike. > There is a weather option (sunny/cloudy/wet) but I didn't have time to > try it. > Anyway, in conclusion I'm buying this one as soon as it comes out. For > those still skeptical, I can only assume EA will release an updated > demo closer to the release date. The sim mode is too good to kept > secret. > Joe>When going straight and very fast and you instantly hit the brakes on full
>max, what happens? The front should tuck immediately and send you and the
>bike on a long easy slide.
That can happen. If you manage to keep your balance the rear end can
also rise up into the air and flip you.
I'm not quit sure what you mean by this. I found the best way to turn
(for me) was to follow a clean line, gradually increasing your lean
and throttle as you approach the apex.
Not as far as I can tell.
You can turn a very little bit, very gently. But anything more than
that and you will slide into a spill. It's like driving on slick ice
(with an over-powered bike). The gravel may be slightly less slippery
than the grass, but still easy to spin out on.
Joe
Er..not cool.
I basicly want to know if you can throw the bike into a turn too fast and tuck
the front end.
Lame. Again, not cool.
At least the game got one thing right.
Looks like this game isnt much of a true sim. Thanks for the input Joe, this
game just doesnt seem to do it right yet. Oh well, here's hoping for AMA
Superbike Racing. Wish I could go to Daytona to check out there computer lan
setup.
Agreed, very wrong. (Hi Revv, you here too?! :^)
To answer the original questions:
Slamming the brakes at full throttle and high speed does unsettle the bike,
but because you're using the same joystick axis for brake and throttle
you're already off the gas before you brake. It doesn't loose as much front
grip as I think it should, i.e. I don't think it's possible to lock the
wheel at any speed or upset it enough to get it to tuck in unless you're
leaning a little. It does send the back end light though, which can cause
you problems if the suspension hasn't settled before you want to turn.
You can certainly loose the front entering a corner, and I have many times.
Quite often I wonder why as of course you don't get the physical feedback
you would on the road before it lets go.
Yes you can powerslide exiting corners, though I haven't decided whether my
game playing technique benefits from doing it or just being easier on the
gas. It often throws me way off-line if I'm not careful.
When you hit the gravel and try and turn (about say 20 mph) you're VERY
likely to loose it. You should see just what happens when you land, it's
awesome, you flip and the bike will tumble and catch, bounce and go
careering into the wall. Not all the time, obviously. My point is that is
behaves VERY realistically within the expected limits of a simulation.
If you ride a sportbike then I'm sure you'll love the game to the point of
abandoning everything else for the time-being, including your beloved
flightsims (eh, Revved?) :^)
The different bikes behave as I'd imagine they would: the Suzuki is fast but
flighty, the Kawa is stable, the Duke is hard to turn but great out of
corners and the Honda is... well a Honda!!
Go buy it!!
--
Si. (owner of CBR400RR and GSX-R600, soon to be the proud owner of a Ducati
748 bip)
>On Thu, 04 Mar 1999 08:04:32 -0600,
>>Looks like this game isnt much of a true sim.
>Wrong.
>--
>// rrevved posts from mindspring dot com
Prove me otherwise then. Dont just say wrong. Tell me what the game does
to prove it is a true roadracing sim.
Ah, now this is a better post with some feedback. Thanks for the reply. I think
I'll get this game at a store where I can return it. It still sounds not totally
accurate for a motorcycle race sim but I'll have to play it to find out.
Quoted text (52 lines)
> Agreed, very wrong. (Hi Revv, you here too?! :^) > To answer the original questions: > Slamming the brakes at full throttle and high speed does unsettle the bike, > but because you're using the same joystick axis for brake and throttle > you're already off the gas before you brake. It doesn't loose as much front > grip as I think it should, i.e. I don't think it's possible to lock the > wheel at any speed or upset it enough to get it to tuck in unless you're > leaning a little. It does send the back end light though, which can cause > you problems if the suspension hasn't settled before you want to turn. > You can certainly loose the front entering a corner, and I have many times. > Quite often I wonder why as of course you don't get the physical feedback > you would on the road before it lets go. > Yes you can powerslide exiting corners, though I haven't decided whether my > game playing technique benefits from doing it or just being easier on the > gas. It often throws me way off-line if I'm not careful. > When you hit the gravel and try and turn (about say 20 mph) you're VERY > likely to loose it. You should see just what happens when you land, it's > awesome, you flip and the bike will tumble and catch, bounce and go > careering into the wall. Not all the time, obviously. My point is that is > behaves VERY realistically within the expected limits of a simulation. > If you ride a sportbike then I'm sure you'll love the game to the point of > abandoning everything else for the time-being, including your beloved > flightsims (eh, Revved?) :^) > The different bikes behave as I'd imagine they would: the Suzuki is fast but > flighty, the Kawa is stable, the Duke is hard to turn but great out of > corners and the Honda is... well a Honda!! > Go buy it!! > -- > Si. (owner of CBR400RR and GSX-R600, soon to be the proud owner of a Ducati > 748 bip) > >On Thu, 04 Mar 1999 08:04:32 -0600, > >>Looks like this game isnt much of a true sim. > >Wrong. > >-- > >// rrevved posts from mindspring dot comBTW, I got a chance to try it out on a LAN over the weekend. Lan racing is
real good fun but it's a shame the single-player detail is missing when in
multiplayer mode. i.e. you can't do a full simulation race weekend (with
qualifying and practice sessions) multiplayer, it just allows you to do the
last race at each track. That's a pity. It would be awesome to have a PC
just serving the track and for players to adjust their setups and jump in
and out of the practice and qualifying session independently. As it is, LAN
simulation is just like arcade LAN with the simulation difficulty settings.
It also locked up occasionally, usually at about the 7th ot 8th race of the
season, and as you can't save a multiplayer season all was lost. (At least I
was kicking my buddy's ass by 40 championship points at the time!) I
occasionally get Direct 3D errors and kick-outs to the desktop when it jumps
from the menus into demo mode.
I've also come to the conclusion that the game is far too easy. In arcade
mode I can win a 5 lap race on most of of the courses up to 30 seconds
before the second place computer controlled rider, with settings on "REAL".
In simulation mode I can lap as quick as the computer riders in "REAL" mode
on most of the tracks. Whether I win or not usually depends on if I***up
and over-cook a corner. I doubt it will be long before the full championship
at full simulation realism will seem easy.
Si.
>Ah, now this is a better post with some feedback. Thanks for the reply. I think
>I'll get this game at a store where I can return it. It still sounds not totally
bike,
>> but because you're using the same joystick axis for brake and throttle
>> you're already off the gas before you brake. It doesn't loose as much front
>> grip as I think it should, i.e. I don't think it's possible to lock the
>> wheel at any speed or upset it enough to get it to tuck in unless you're
>> leaning a little. It does send the back end light though, which can cause
>> you problems if the suspension hasn't settled before you want to turn.
>> You can certainly loose the front entering a corner, and I have many times.
>> Quite often I wonder why as of course you don't get the physical feedback
>> you would on the road before it lets go.
>> Yes you can powerslide exiting corners, though I haven't decided whether my
of
>> abandoning everything else for the time-being, including your beloved
>> flightsims (eh, Revved?) :^)
>> The different bikes behave as I'd imagine they would: the Suzuki is fast but
Ducati
Quoted text (10 lines)
>accurate for a motorcycle race sim but I'll have to play it to find out. >> Agreed, very wrong. (Hi Revv, you here too?! :^) >> To answer the original questions: >> Slamming the brakes at full throttle and high speed does unsettle theQuoted text (10 lines)
>> game playing technique benefits from doing it or just being easier on the >> gas. It often throws me way off-line if I'm not careful. >> When you hit the gravel and try and turn (about say 20 mph) you're VERY >> likely to loose it. You should see just what happens when you land, it's >> awesome, you flip and the bike will tumble and catch, bounce and go >> careering into the wall. Not all the time, obviously. My point is that is >> behaves VERY realistically within the expected limits of a simulation. >> If you ride a sportbike then I'm sure you'll love the game to the pointQuoted text (7 lines)
>> flighty, the Kawa is stable, the Duke is hard to turn but great out of >> corners and the Honda is... well a Honda!! >> Go buy it!! >> -- >> Si. (owner of CBR400RR and GSX-R600, soon to be the proud owner of aQuoted text (14 lines)
>> 748 bip) >> >On Thu, 04 Mar 1999 08:04:32 -0600, >> >>Looks like this game isnt much of a true sim. >> >Wrong. >> >-- >> >// rrevved posts from mindspring dot comWhat's your controller setup?
Tom
>I can't imagine anyone thinking that Superbikes is 'easy'.
>Maybe those who have a knack for racing it could post some replays
>in the binaries newsgroup to let the 'rest of us' know how its done...
Rrevved,
I find it a lot easier if you tilt your head while you "ride". This
may sound really stupid but it works. I use the "first person" view
where the bike is fixed and lean with it. Give it a try.
Whixh newsgroup is that. I will quite happily post some 3 lap replays.
Quoted text (23 lines)
> On 9 Mar 1999 02:46:18 GMT, > >>I've also come to the conclusion that the game is far too easy. > >What's your controller setup? > >Tom > Really.. hehe. > I can't imagine anyone thinking that Superbikes is 'easy'. > Maybe those who have a knack for racing it could post some replays > in the binaries newsgroup to let the 'rest of us' know how its done... > 8-) > -- > // rrevved posts from mindspring dot com>Great! Post them to alt.binaries.simulators.autos , alt.binaries.misc .
>I think most people could get them there.
If you want to learn something *other* than how to go fast, see my
"How to Wipe Out in EA Superbikes" replay in
alt.binaries.simulators.autos.
Joe
Great IDEA.....really good.
I'm really impressed with this sim and think it's a classic....
Thanks for the tip.....the lean is so radical your solution is probably the
one to use...
JEB "OZ"
Quoted text (9 lines)
>>I can't imagine anyone thinking that Superbikes is 'easy'. >>Maybe those who have a knack for racing it could post some replays >>in the binaries newsgroup to let the 'rest of us' know how its done... >Rrevved, >I find it a lot easier if you tilt your head while you "ride". This >may sound really stupid but it works. I use the "first person" view >where the bike is fixed and lean with it. Give it a try.I use the for/back axis for accel and brake, steer with left and right. I
only hold the joystick with my thumb and forfinger at it's base though as
it's much too sensitive.
My key to getting competitive is lengthening tyre life (press F8 in the sim
game to get a picture of the wear/temperature) by good tyre choice and
smooth power transitions.
--
Si.
Get the most from Jane's F-15 at http://home.vest.net/flight
>>I've also come to the conclusion that the game is far too easy.
>What's your controller setup?
>Tom
I just reinstalled and lost my most precious replay of me winning Donnington
(at full realism settings) by 20 seconds. (Largely due to the fact that I
wiped out the entire field by diving for first place through the chicane and
hitting the 1st place guy.)
--
Si.
Get the most from Jane's F-15 at http://home.vest.net/flight
>On Tue, 09 Mar 1999 23:52:16 +1000,
>>Whixh newsgroup is that. I will quite happily post some 3 lap replays.
>Great! Post them to alt.binaries.simulators.autos , alt.binaries.misc .
>I think most people could get them there.
>Thanks!
>>> On 9 Mar 1999 02:46:18 GMT,
>>> >>I've also come to the conclusion that the game is far too easy.
>>> >What's your controller setup?
>>> >Tom
>>> Really.. hehe.
>>> I can't imagine anyone thinking that Superbikes is 'easy'.
>>> Maybe those who have a knack for racing it could post some replays
>>> in the binaries newsgroup to let the 'rest of us' know how its done...
>>> 8-)
>>> --
>>> // rrevved posts from mindspring dot com
>--
>// rrevved posts from mindspring dot com
If you see Foggy lying on the ground, run him over for me!


































