GT Interactive has obtained exclusive rights for the "Indy 500, Indy Racing
League, Indianapolis Motor Speedway, Indy Racing League teams and drivers,
for all PC and console platforms." So basically if it's got the Indy label
on it, it has to have come from GT. The license is a multiyear deal.
Maybe we will get Daytona!!!
John McClaren
GT Interactive's Indy licence and fears of simplified NASCAR 3
News that GT Interactive had obtained exclusive Indy 500 and IRL rights meant NASCAR Racing 3 could not include Indianapolis. The thread became a debate over whether Sierra would make Papyrus simplify the NASCAR 3 physics after GPL's weak sales; most wanted optional difficulty levels rather than a simplified physics model, and oval and road racers argued over whether setup or driving skill matters more.
Automated summary.
John McClaren wrote
You sure it's exclusive right for the name and likeness ? If not why is Sega
launching their new Indianapolis arcade-style game for both the arcade and
DreamCast this year ?
Any source better than what you said ? You don't say much thing about the
title. Press release ?
Still, we won't die from not having the Brickyard in Nascar Racing 3 (no big
deal, I doubt it will get profit from the money they spent, even if it helps
on the customer satisfaction).
p.s. : To anybody at Papyrus. I got some words from XYZ beta tester who
said you were under pressure from Sierra to "detune" your game engine for
Nascar Racing 3. Do this and it's the start of your death.
-= Fran?ois Mnard <ymenard/Nas-Frank>
-= NROS Nascar sanctioned Guide http://www.nros.com/
-= SimRacing Online http://www.simracing.com/
-= Official mentally retarded guy of r.a.s.
-= May the Downforce be with you...
"People think it must be fun to be a super genius, but they don't realise
how hard it is to put up with all the idiots in the world."
I believe it is Cart2000. I would expect it a little after N3, maybe 2000
summer or Xmas of 99, i would bet summer though, or end of it.
Jesse
>> p.s. : To anybody at Papyrus. I got some words from XYZ beta tester who
>> said you were under pressure from Sierra to "detune" your game engine for
>> Nascar Racing 3. Do this and it's the start of your death.
>Not to be rude, but what do you mean by "detune"? Are you insinuating they'll
>dummy-down the physics because it's too hard?
>And if you could, ask your source to inquire about CART3 - it's long overdue,
Quoted text (9 lines)
>damnit! >Sorry - had to ask. > Andy Backa The only skills I have the patience to learn are > - Calvin and Hobbes > Chewey Pages: http://home.istar.ca/~cheweyHmm...I say every simmer sends angry e-mails to Sierra. If Sierra forces Papyrus
to throw the physics out the window, then I'm no longer buying from
Sierra/Papyrus.
> p.s. : To anybody at Papyrus. I got some words from XYZ beta tester who
> said you were under pressure from Sierra to "detune" your game engine for
> Nascar Racing 3. Do this and it's the start of your death.
Not to be rude, but what do you mean by "detune"? Are you insinuating they'll
dummy-down the physics because it's too hard?
And if you could, ask your source to inquire about CART3 - it's long overdue,
damnit!
Sorry - had to ask.
Andy Backa The only skills I have the patience to learn are
- Calvin and Hobbes
Chewey Pages: http://home.istar.ca/~chewey
> Hmm...I say every simmer sends angry e-mails to Sierra. If Sierra forces Papyrus
> to throw the physics out the window, then I'm no longer buying from
> Sierra/Papyrus.
Heheheh, go ahead because the other million+ people that will be buying the game
will be laughing. If the game is as difficult as GPL then you might as well just
forget seeing a Nascar Sim from Papy again. Sales as poor as GPL will not cut it
for Nascar.
Heck, some of you guys act as if Nascar2 is easy LOL.
Bill / Amish on TEN
Bill Bollinger wrote
You don't see the point here Bill. Im not saying to not include an arcade
mode for the arcade-people (I want one for better sales, more money to
Papyrus). Im saying that they might detune the whole game engine, no
exceptions. If they decide to do this, it's the death of Papyrus. The game
engine is _THERE_. We have the perfect tool for a realistic racing
simulator, but the market is too brain-washed by all the NFS and cie stuff
on the market.
I just hate this we are going in a dead-end here. Hard-core simmers want
more realism, but it doesn't sell well. The gamers can't appreciate taking
their time to learn the techniques of racing a a car.
N2 is easy, sorry. Especially the arcade mode.
-= Fran?ois Mnard <ymenard/Nas-Frank>
-= NROS Nascar sanctioned Guide http://www.nros.com/
-= SimRacing Online http://www.simracing.com/
-= Official mentally retarded guy of r.a.s.
-= May the Downforce be with you...
"People think it must be fun to be a super genius, but they don't realise
how hard it is to put up with all the idiots in the world."
Quoted text (7 lines)
>On Wed, 03 Mar 1999 00:06:21 -0600, >> If the game is as difficult as GPL then you might as well just >>forget seeing a Nascar Sim from Papy again. Sales as poor as GPL will not cut it >>for Nascar.That's very true - a typical NASCAR race is far more about strategy and
tactics than pure driver skill.
- Michael
Quoted text (10 lines)
>On Wed, 03 Mar 1999 07:07:40 GMT, >>Add the arcade model but dont dumb down >>the physics. >I agree with a **choice** of ultra-realism (GPL, etc.) and more relaxed >realism (Viper Racing). I just think it would be a mistake to put 'physics' >in the Nascar sim that would make it difficult to drive in a straight line.Thankfully no NASCAR sim should be as difficult as GPL since stock
cars are so much heavier.
-
"If the meaning of life was printed in a book, someone
would use it to keep the window open."
Yeah, if anything, they should just raise the grip levels a little bit
to make it "easier"... DONT***WITH PERFECTION!!!
-_Dave
> Hmm...I say every simmer sends angry e-mails to Sierra. If Sierra forces Papyrus
> to throw the physics out the window, then I'm no longer buying from
> Sierra/Papyrus.
--
Dave Schwabe
The Aussie Toad -- Grand Prix Legends & Brabham site
http://users.wi.net/~schwabe
says...
I think you guys are missing the big picture. Papy can make the sim as
easy as Sierra wants it to be without sacrificing the realism that we
hard-core simmers want simply by making the level of "realism"
and "damage model" completely configurable by the user.
A group of three radio buttons labelled as follows would allow the user
to select the realism of the physics model
Realism
() Minimum (Arcade)
() Medium
() Maximum (Simulation)
Notice that I avoided the use of the words "Easy" and "Hard". This radio
button group could be followed by another group that allows the user to
specify the damage modem independantly of the "Realism" setting
(something I wish GPL already did).
Damage model
() Off
() Amateur
() Pro
() Realistic
And finally, a way to select the length of the race (again, something
more than what GPL provides):
Race length ___ laps
If they do this, *everyone* will be happy.
=================================================
I think Papy kinda sorta blew it (or at least didn't go far enough) in
the race configuration part of GPL.
1) They didn't (as far as I know) give a way for people
to hold online races using the trainer cars.
2) The race length setting would have been better served
if it simply allowed us to specify the number of laps
we want to run.
3) We can't select a lower damage model for longer races.
Along with this would go another damage model that
only allowed the use of Shift-R from your pit stall
(something in between "intermediate" and "pro").
I honestly hope that these issues have been addressed in the upcoming
patch. It would make the sim mmore enjoyable for a broader group of
people. Afterall, that's what Sierra, Papy, and the existing users want.
--
=========================================================
John Simmons - Redneck Techno-Biker (Zerex12)
http://www.members.home.net/jms1/index.html
John Simmons - Barbarian Diecast Collector
http://members.home.net/jsimm/diecast_index.html
IGPS Director
http://www.paddedwall.org/igps/igps.html
If you want to send me email, go to either of the URL's
shown above & click "Send Me Mail" in the contents frame.
=========================================================
Quoted text (9 lines)
>On Wed, 03 Mar 1999 00:06:21 -0600, >>If the game is as difficult as GPL then you might as well just >>forget seeing a Nascar Sim from Papy again. Sales as poor as >>GPL will not cut it for Nascar. >My thoughts exactly.Compared to GPL it is VERY easy.
I completely disagree. In fact, most likely the ONLY reason that Tony
George went into a fairly exclusive contract for Indy/IRL is because the IRL
is so poorly received. Nascar has the luxury of allowing non-exclusive
liscenses because it can make more money from having multiple licenses, not
to mention by having many game licenses it doesn't tie itself to a potential
flop. Imagine if NASCAR had made an exclusive agreement with EA and
therefore Nascar Revolution was the only Nascar racing game available.
NASCAR fans would scream ***y *** and not to mention NASCAR gets more
from the licenses when it has tons of games out there to license: N1, N2,
NR99, NascarREvolution, Nascar98, Nascar3/2000, etc.
So no, I do NOT think that even if N3/2000 is as hard as GPL (and it won't
be simply because stock cars are NOT the 1967 GP beasts and are easier to
drive - its all relative..I'd imagine that current F1 or CART cars are
easier to drive than the 67 GP cars) it will sale as few copies as GPL did
simply because of the fanatical fan base that must have seemingly EVER piece
of Nascar merchandise. As for GPL, its a niche game..and I would assume
that both Papyrus and Sierra went into it knowing full well it was NOT going
to top the charts in sales.
Compared to GPL it is VERY easy. Comparing physics engines solely: GPL is
harder. Comparing cars solely: 1967 GP cars are much harder to drive than a
1999 stockcar. Comparing tracks solely: No competition here....GPL's tracks
are orders of maginitude more difficult and challenging than 1999 Nascar,
CART or F1 tracks.
N2 may not be easy per say, but in comparison to GPL it is a much easier
racing game to get a handle on.
Yes, and on slicks, and with slow steering ratios... a lower
power/weight ratio... etc.
--Dave
PS -- Toni, great quote! :-)
cut it
--
Dave Schwabe
The Aussie Toad -- Grand Prix Legends & Brabham site
http://users.wi.net/~schwabe
I have to concur, Chris... I jumped in at Bristol with 105% just for
grins, started at the rear and DEMOLISHED the (AI) field in a short
race. The car is so easy to throw around... I think GPL is great
sensitivity training for N2, not the reverse.
The GPL car feels ALIVE, while the N2 car feels very PLASTIC...
N2 is still BIG FUN, but the driving model feels like, well, it's a
generation behind GPL! ;-)
-_dave
> >Heck, some of you guys act as if Nascar2 is easy LOL.
> Compared to GPL it is VERY easy.
--
Dave Schwabe
The Aussie Toad -- Grand Prix Legends & Brabham site
http://users.wi.net/~schwabe
>will be laughing. If the game is as difficult as GPL then you might as well just
>forget seeing a Nascar Sim from Papy again. Sales as poor as GPL will not cut it
>for Nascar.
Don't forget one BIG difference: there are a LOT more fans of Nascar
than there are of 1967 "Indy" cars. Nascar's a lot more flexible to addon
to than GPL. As we all know there are THREE different series included (not
just one), there are a LOT more tracks (tho' most ARE oval), a LOT more
carset/truckset patches, etc.
It's MY belief that if Sierra learns how to market it to INCLUDE all the
stuff on the 'net that can be (or will be) "added" to it to expand it, I
think it'll do better. As it is, if Sierra promoted more of the GPL sites
that're out there (or at least mentioned them on the packaging) I think
sales could go up exponentially. I think most people that HAVEN'T bought it
aren't aware of the full capabilities of the game. If Sierra makes a big
production about all the different carsets, utilities, etc. I think it'll
prove to be a BIG seller.
They should also make more of a production out of the "arcade"
capabilities of NR99 (and NR3). Certainly most reviewers (at least for the
N2 series) rave on and on about the "sim" capabilities of it with only
brushing mention of being able to "dumb down" the AI and crank up braking
and steering help for those that are more interested in a NasRev sort of
game.
I believe that MARKETING will either sell it, or kill it.
"Gunner"
ORSA #78 Navy Dodge truck
> N2 is easy, sorry. Especially the arcade mode.
Heheheh you don't want to go there with me :)
In regards to the arcade mode, it probably isn't too "Easy" for the
first time user which is what market IMHO will be purchasing this
product over the next 5 years.
The KEY will be the success of having those first time users take the
game and continue to use it. Sell add ons, more tracks etc....Get
online, use NROS etc...
But if N2 is easy, then why do we still see sooo many people on NROS
that struggle at some tracks 3-5 years after the original physics engine
was created? I would assume that if the physics engine was that easy we
would see people running the same speeds as you. OH, I forgot they
already are ROFLMAO.... Teasing BTW :)
Bill / Amish on TEN
Quoted text (8 lines)
> > the physics.I dont think that N3 will be as hard as GPL anyway since > > the racing in 67 was much harder in real life then Nascar is...track > > and car wise.Just look at Rouen and you can tell that no Nascar track > That's very true - a typical NASCAR race is far more about strategy and > tactics than pure driver skill. > - MichaelQuoted text (51 lines)
> I think you guys are missing the big picture. Papy can make the sim as > easy as Sierra wants it to be without sacrificing the realism that we > hard-core simmers want simply by making the level of "realism" > and "damage model" completely configurable by the user. > A group of three radio buttons labelled as follows would allow the user > to select the realism of the physics model > Realism > () Minimum (Arcade) > () Medium > () Maximum (Simulation) > Notice that I avoided the use of the words "Easy" and "Hard". This radio > button group could be followed by another group that allows the user to > specify the damage modem independantly of the "Realism" setting > (something I wish GPL already did). > Damage model > () Off > () Amateur > () Pro > () Realistic > And finally, a way to select the length of the race (again, something > more than what GPL provides): > Race length ___ laps > If they do this, *everyone* will be happy. > ================================================= > I think Papy kinda sorta blew it (or at least didn't go far enough) in > the race configuration part of GPL. > 1) They didn't (as far as I know) give a way for people > to hold online races using the trainer cars. > 2) The race length setting would have been better served > if it simply allowed us to specify the number of laps > we want to run. > 3) We can't select a lower damage model for longer races. > Along with this would go another damage model that > only allowed the use of Shift-R from your pit stall > (something in between "intermediate" and "pro"). > I honestly hope that these issues have been addressed in the upcoming > patch. It would make the sim mmore enjoyable for a broader group of > people. Afterall, that's what Sierra, Papy, and the existing users want.Quoted text (11 lines)
> I have to concur, Chris... I jumped in at Bristol with 105% just for > grins, started at the rear and DEMOLISHED the (AI) field in a short > race. The car is so easy to throw around... I think GPL is great > sensitivity training for N2, not the reverse. > The GPL car feels ALIVE, while the N2 car feels very PLASTIC... > N2 is still BIG FUN, but the driving model feels like, well, it's a > generation behind GPL! ;-) > -_dave> >Heck, some of you guys act as if Nascar2 is easy LOL.
> Compared to GPL it is VERY easy.
Heheheh, you wouldn't want to go there Chris with me... You know better
:)
You probably would whip me as bad at GPL in those yuckie roadies as I
would whip you in the "Easy" version of N2 :)
Bill / Amish on TEN
Bill Bollinger wrote
So your saying that having good laptimes on road course on the NROS is more
pure skill and less setup ? That people can't do 124's at the Glen, 93's at
Sears Point and 130's at Bull Run without the driving techniques and
abilities ?
Thanks Bill, I always knew you understood my NROS road course talents and
driving skills (heh getting back on you) ;-)
-= Fran?ois Mnard <ymenard/Nas-Frank>
-= NROS Nascar sanctioned Guide http://www.nros.com/
-= SimRacing Online http://www.simracing.com/
-= Official mentally retarded guy of r.a.s.
-= May the Downforce be with you...
"People think it must be fun to be a super genius, but they don't realise
how hard it is to put up with all the idiots in the world."
schwabe wrote
Im challenging you to get on the NROS schwabe ;-)
Nascar Stock-car racing needs technical racing skills but alot of
preparation before and after the race. Both for setup and pit strategy/tyre
wear. I was teasing Bill when I said N2 is easy, because there is subtle
physics in it that is very had to master and takes thousands of laps to
learn it. Controlling a drift slide at Darlington doing 170mph laps or
powersliding off Turn2 at Nazareth and doing a 125mph lap is as difficult
and challenging as anything else. the NROS is a complete new ballpark.
Nobody can say they have mastered N2 until they reach the top10 on the NROS.
It's easy to be good, but difficult to be great.
-= Fran?ois Mnard <ymenard/Nas-Frank>
-= NROS Nascar sanctioned Guide http://www.nros.com/
-= SimRacing Online http://www.simracing.com/
-= Official mentally retarded guy of r.a.s.
-= May the Downforce be with you...
"People think it must be fun to be a super genius, but they don't realise
how hard it is to put up with all the idiots in the world."
Hi Frank... (sorry for the english translation :-) but it's easier for
my feeble mind to spell...)
Well, NROS would be fun to try... I love VROC to death, so it could be
great. But I have to admit I'm spoiled by GPL and it's lovely physics
engine... plus VROC is free! :-)
I guess I wasn't clear enough on my reply... sorry. When I said easy, I
mean "easy," as in "I can floor it in any gear and keep the back end in
check." I was referring to the simple act of keeping the car under
control, as compared to GPL. I may catch flak for this, but IMHO, the
GPL physics model is just unparalleled in terms of realism.
But like you allude to, going fast over a long distance and at an
ultra-competitive pace, well, that's the same probably for any sim. It's
tough at the top! ;-)
I do love N2... especially the TPTCC patch. Cutting a TOP lap is not
ultra easy... but controlling the car feels much easier after mastering
GPL... that's all my point was.... :-)
-_Dave
--
Dave Schwabe
The Aussie Toad -- Grand Prix Legends & Brabham site
http://users.wi.net/~schwabe
Quoted text (27 lines)
> schwabe wrote > >I have to concur, Chris... I jumped in at Bristol with 105% just for > >grins, started at the rear and DEMOLISHED the (AI) field in a short > >race. The car is so easy to throw around... I think GPL is great > >sensitivity training for N2, not the reverse. > Im challenging you to get on the NROS schwabe ;-) > Nascar Stock-car racing needs technical racing skills but alot of > preparation before and after the race. Both for setup and pit strategy/tyre > wear. I was teasing Bill when I said N2 is easy, because there is subtle > physics in it that is very had to master and takes thousands of laps to > learn it. Controlling a drift slide at Darlington doing 170mph laps or > powersliding off Turn2 at Nazareth and doing a 125mph lap is as difficult > and challenging as anything else. the NROS is a complete new ballpark. > Nobody can say they have mastered N2 until they reach the top10 on the NROS. > It's easy to be good, but difficult to be great. > -= Fran?ois Mnard <ymenard/Nas-Frank> > -= NROS Nascar sanctioned Guide http://www.nros.com/ > -= SimRacing Online http://www.simracing.com/ > -= Official mentally retarded guy of r.a.s. > -= May the Downforce be with you... > "People think it must be fun to be a super genius, but they don't realise > how hard it is to put up with all the idiots in the world."Quoted text (12 lines)
> Bill Bollinger wrote > >TRUE TRUE, Oval racing is more SETUP vs. Driving Skill. > >Road Racing is more Driver Skill vs. Setup. > So your saying that having good laptimes on road course on the NROS is more > pure skill and less setup ? That people can't do 124's at the Glen, 93's at > Sears Point and 130's at Bull Run without the driving techniques and > abilities ? > Thanks Bill, I always knew you understood my NROS road course talents and > driving skills (heh getting back on you) ;-)>If they do this, *everyone* will be happy.
The skill/speed level of computer drivers also needs to be in-game
adjustable. But I'm sure Papy has laearned that since every GPL review
(even the glowing ones) mentioned it.
Joe
Heheheheh, I will have to CONCEDE to you and schletter that ROAD RACING
Wooohoo. :) There are lots of carry over in both...both require some
modicrum of skill to race at high levels and both require being able to
understand what the car is doing at any particular time and how setups can
change that.
I wonder. I think that they will definetly be as important in N3 as N2. N3
will be much easier to drive (relatively) than GPL just due to the cars
themselves...I don't know that it will be even more important.
Actually they are very realistic....within the framework of the GPL physics
universe. :) Since GPL or any other racing game can not hope to model every
physical law that is at work on a real racing car, they only model a subset
of our real physical laws. And even the model of that subset may not be
100% correct either. :)
> Actually they are very realistic....within the framework of the GPL physics
> universe. :) Since GPL or any other racing game can not hope to model every
> physical law that is at work on a real racing car, they only model a subset
> of our real physical laws. And even the model of that subset may not be
> 100% correct either. :)
Hehehehhe, that is exactly what I say to people that complain about the
"realism" of the n2 physics engine. From what I have gathered over time
in N2 is that the Front to Rear, Cross and Camber is about the only
things that are fairly accurate. Havn't spent enough time with the GPL
physics engine to say what things are being modeled properly and what
things are not.
Bill / Amish on TEN
I think that what is the thing is that it is an easy game to drive around
in, you can jump in and easily turn laps, but people struggle with getting
that last seconds to be competetive with the hotlappers.
Jesse
Quoted text (19 lines)
>> N2 is easy, sorry. Especially the arcade mode. >Heheheh you don't want to go there with me :) >In regards to the arcade mode, it probably isn't too "Easy" for the >first time user which is what market IMHO will be purchasing this >product over the next 5 years. >The KEY will be the success of having those first time users take the >game and continue to use it. Sell add ons, more tracks etc....Get >online, use NROS etc... >But if N2 is easy, then why do we still see sooo many people on NROS >that struggle at some tracks 3-5 years after the original physics engine >was created? I would assume that if the physics engine was that easy we >would see people running the same speeds as you. OH, I forgot they >already are ROFLMAO.... Teasing BTW :) >Bill / Amish on TEN> I think that what is the thing is that it is an easy game to drive around
> in, you can jump in and easily turn laps, but people struggle with getting
> that last seconds to be competetive with the hotlappers.
> Jesse
That is exactly what I want to continue. I feel that if the game is too
difficult to even drive arround then that will cause problems in the long run.
Bill / Amish on TEN
This is true, but then again, GPL isn't for the masses. Honestly, how many
people here could actually name some drivers from '67 besides Clark,
Brabham, and Hulme before they got GPL? I guarantee you that most of the
people out there buying sims today aren't even old enough to remember or
even know of them (I'm one...my dad was my age the year Clark died, and I'm
15)
Besides, there are a lot of people (myself included) coming out of the
arcades from playing Indy 500, Ridge Racer, Crusin' USA and the like and are
looking for the same action to take home. Most can't tell you what in the
world a tie rod is or what gear ratios do. So, of course, GPL isn't for
them. N3 hopefully will be.
--
Kirk Lane
ICQ: 28171652
>On Wed, 03 Mar 1999 00:06:21 -0600,
>> If the game is as difficult as GPL then you might as well just
>>forget seeing a Nascar Sim from Papy again. Sales as poor as GPL will not
cut it
>>for Nascar.
>My thoughts exactly.
>--
>// rrevved posts from mindspring dot com
Quoted text (12 lines)
> > Hmm...I say every simmer sends angry e-mails to Sierra. If Sierra forces Papyrus > > to throw the physics out the window, then I'm no longer buying from > > Sierra/Papyrus. > Heheheh, go ahead because the other million+ people that will be buying the game > will be laughing. If the game is as difficult as GPL then you might as well just > forget seeing a Nascar Sim from Papy again. Sales as poor as GPL will not cut it > for Nascar. > Heck, some of you guys act as if Nascar2 is easy LOL. > Bill / Amish on TEN> >Heck, some of you guys act as if Nascar2 is easy LOL.
> Compared to GPL it is VERY easy.
I've been following this thread,and for an older driver (51),NAS2 is
a lot easier than gpl. But then agian,it's two completely different
forms of racing. It's was much harder to drive a 1967 F1 than driving a
WC stockcar. There are air dams and rear spoilers to help keep your car
on the track,and you just can't compare a oval to the difficulty of the
courses they drove in 67.
Joel Willstein
>> > Hmm...I say every simmer sends angry e-mails to Sierra. If Sierra forces Papyrus
>> > to throw the physics out the window, then I'm no longer buying from
>> > Sierra/Papyrus.
I very much doubt Papyrus will be throwing their physics model out the
window, regardless of the opinion of anyone. If Sierra don't like it, I
guess you might find a 2nd easy/arcade physics model as a subset of the
current one, or alternatively, there might be a market for professional
racing simulators - the kind that few if any here could even begin to
afford.
Mike.
It is :)
-Larry
> N2 is still BIG FUN, but the driving model feels like, well, it's a
> generation behind GPL! ;-)
Or a new marketer...
Personally, I'd rather give my money directly to Papyrus anyway...
-Larry
-Larry


































