Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

GLP is OVERRATED!

73 posts by 29 people · 15 Jan 1999 - 15 Feb 1999

Debate over whether GPL is overrated

A thread titled GPL is overrated saw some posters list GPL's flaws, including frame rate collapse with full fields on older PCs, the lack of a clutch with auto-shifting, and no force feedback. Others defended its physics and said slower hardware was the issue, and the argument drifted into British versus American humour and Voodoo2 technicalities.

review/impressionshardware: PC/graphicsGrand Prix LegendsMonaco Grand Prix Racing Simulation 2

Automated summary.

Schlomo4 15 Jan 1999#445488
Shoot im havin a blast and my FPS never gets above 15. Its just a matter of perspective. GPL is for the diehard sim racers, guys like me that love that era of Grand Prix racing, and some guys that just love racing. If you sit down and just give it some time im sure you will see just how much fun it is. I will soon be getting a 3dfx card and im sure i will enjoy it even more at 36 FPS. As for D3d...yes it is the wave of the future and i have it on my comp. But really its ahead of its time. Wait for GPL2 (if there is one) and im sure it will support D3d.
NanaKofi 16 Jan 1999#445646
Rendition/Hercules/Voodoo 2 ONLY, ONLY, ONLY way to speed up frame rate.
DBran 16 Jan 1999#445647
Quoted text (18 lines)>First before I start with my system specs >Dell XP450 >128MEG SDRAM >1- 16MEG Riva TNT >17Gig HD >I bought GPL about 2 weeks ago. I installed it....argh!!!!. Sierra has the >absolute worst installer! I usually install my games to C:\Games\<GAME> but >not here. Then I run the game and go for a quick lap. 12 stunning FPS! Come >on SIERRA!! D3D is the way of the future!!!!! Then I got the OpenGL Driver >and the 0.48 nVidia drivers. Okay, 30 fps, not great but not bad. Then i >tried with some Ai cars. 8 FPS in the lowest res (514 X whatever). Plus the >game is way to hard. Tracks are nice. Interface is typical Papy poor. >Sounds blah. I don't see why this game is so damn great. >I'll be playin Viper and Burnout. >Tyler
Obviously you know very little about car physics or driving techniques.
Brian Short 16 Jan 1999#445648
Quoted text (21 lines)> >First before I start with my system specs > >Dell XP450 > >128MEG SDRAM > >1- 16MEG Riva TNT > >17Gig HD > >I bought GPL about 2 weeks ago. I installed it....argh!!!!. Sierra has the > >absolute worst installer! I usually install my games to C:\Games\<GAME> but > >not here. Then I run the game and go for a quick lap. 12 stunning FPS! Come > >on SIERRA!! D3D is the way of the future!!!!! Then I got the OpenGL Driver > >and the 0.48 nVidia drivers. Okay, 30 fps, not great but not bad. Then i > >tried with some Ai cars. 8 FPS in the lowest res (514 X whatever). Plus the > >game is way to hard. Tracks are nice. Interface is typical Papy poor. > >Sounds blah. I don't see why this game is so damn great. > >I'll be playin Viper and Burnout. > >Tyler > Obviously you know very little about car physics or driving > techniques.
So? That still doesnt change the fact that the game is probably WAY to hard for most people, takes a LONG time and a LOT of patience to get any good at it so it's finally fun to play (FUN?! What's that?), and doesnt indicate that it is such a difficult game on the box, and that the average consumer, and those without endless amounts of patience, should stay away from it. I dont mind it being extremely realistic, but they really should have put in some better difficulty settings... how hard would it have been to put in a really dumbed down physics model, or a method of manually slowing the AI (other than editing an .ini file), or the ability to race the slower cars (other than editing an .ini file).... I'll agree with the common thought on this though, if you arent a *** simmer, stay away :-) Brian Short
NORDICSK 16 Jan 1999#445649
Ah!. I didn't know that Graham Hill incarnate subscribed to this newsgroup! It is truly amazing how many people out there seem to have had experience driving a 1967 vintage F1 car! It must be so, since they keep telling us neophytes how little we understand about racecar driving techniques and physics! The truth is that this that no "simulation" including GPL is really very accurate since the G-forces and seat of the pants feel that a driver feels when driving a car are not represented here. By the way, who can really quantify that the physiscs model is all that accurate? Certainly the crash model is highly unrealistic. I've numerous times ( more than I can count!) crashed my car in ways that would have positively destroyed a real vehicle. However, the GPL car will fly upside down and do spectacular spins and loops but remain essentially intact (yes, I'm on realistic damage!) I also happen to run through the "ghost" spectators seemingly with no problem either. Also, while we're on the subject of realism, since when has a race at Spa been held where some wet weather hasn't occurred? Why no rain effects? While I'm nitpicking here, I might as well touch a little on the manual: in a word, mediocre at best. There are glaring omissions in this thing that are frankly quite hard to believe. How can the writers leave out references to the Ferrari?- licencing problems?; how is in the game then? Poor references to the use of the gauges; unclear and confusing references to how to tune the car ( you should not have to be a race car mechanic to understand this aspect). All in all, I'm not confinced that this supposed state-of -the -art realism exists or is really all that necessary to create an enjoyable and rewarding race simulation, certainly not at the price that seems necessary in terms of hardware and time that GPL requires.
For me that is the quantum leap represented by GPL - the feel it generates. I do not know if the physics model is accurate - just that it provides far & away the best sensation of driving on & over the edge than any other simulation I have tried. Graphics, sounds & AI will always improve as programmers learn new techniques & hardware progresses. Getting the feel of driving through a computer simulation without access to mechanical devices (like a full blown hydraulically operated simulator) to my mind is far more difficult to create. Papyrus deserve the credit for GPL. IMHO GPL is truly a milestone in auto sim history. Tony
Not when it was launched!!! We didn't have PIIs in summer '96 Tony
DAVID 16 Jan 1999#445652
Well I am driving GPL with a P1 233mhz with no L2 cache. Greame can be thanked for the help getting the computer to where it will run good FPS. I have evev won races online with this PC at IP addresses. So you can drive GPL without have a P2 with over 400mhz. Also I am running 128.24 personal best at Monza and 105.45 at Watkins, so I am a bit slower hten the really fast guys but the dog will hunt. I am running a little 50 dollar T2 I bought last year and have resprung a milloin times already. So you can drive GPL with a low cost set of pedals well you know what htey say about opinions every has one and they all ____ IMHO, mine does too Dave
sbarbou 16 Jan 1999#445653
I gotta admit, I was geeked when GPL first hit the shelves. I was watching this group everyday waiting for it to come out. When it did I even crossed the border to Detroit because Canada always gets it a little later than the States. But today, 3 months after I got it, I deleted it from my system. Why? Frustration factor. GPL is not a game one can just "jump into" and race. Like many have said it takes time and patience. I really don't have the time, working 40 hours a week. I do like to spend some time AWAY from the computer. Plus the cars are just TOO damn hard to control. And guys, come on now. This game may have awesome physics and be super realistic but it is a game played on a computer sitting on a desk. The art of racing is mostly from "feel". You can feel a car starting to slip under you. You can't do that in a game. It's like "BOOM" the car starts to spin, you try to correct it, the wheel turns a tad too much, and you're on the grass, in the wall, unable to race anymore. FUN!! Sorry, I'll wait for Nascar3 where the cars give a bit more and bide my time with NR1999 meanwhile!
Dean 16 Jan 1999#445654
Firstly I think GPL is great but I have to say the religious following is a little dodgy to say the least. We ought to compile a list of whats wrong with it just to address balance. 1) Opponents hit on framerate is unacceptable. Running on a 200mmx with a Voodoo2 should be good enough (5 FPS with a full field is just bad programming). The Voodoo2 should take all the graphic duties and the AI should have no effect on the graphics. Name one other game that does this. If a 12 meg Voodoo2 can't move the fairly simple graphics around then Papy have done a terrible job as far as 3d acceleration goes. 2) Crashing and getting stuck in a wall is just stupid. Advanced 3D engine? I don't think so. I remember getting locked together with other cars in Indycar 2 so maybe Papy just can't get collision detection sorted. 3) Accelerated time in menus going in to the race. Pop to the loo while accelerated time is on and you return to a race in action. 4) No clutch control on auto gearbox. Why? 5) Why when you crash badly do you get the TV snow effect? Ruins any immersion I feel. 6) No Force Feedback. I notice the manual sarcastically dismisses current feedback technology but even with this you can tell when the front end has begun to slide in MGPRS2 which would be a big addition to GPL. 7) It is said GPL models air over the engine. Shame they never model a car with grass on its tyres. Go on the grass and it has no effect once your back on the track. Also I'm sure you wouldn't get the amount of grip on the grass as you get. You can go wide on to the grass at 130mph (not that you can tell your speed in the***pit - what use are those guages?) and still find enough grip to get back on. Surely not right. 8) Its difficult to tell what gear your in as the stick graphic is terrible. I don't have time while hurtling in to a corner to look at this as I downshift (a real driver would know as he would feel the position) so often downshift too much and lock the rear. I'm sure practice will get rid of this but Papy should have used another method to provide feedback (even if it's unrealistic -after all its unrealistic to not know what gear your in without looking - real Indycars didn't have the gear as a digit right in the field of view but it made Indycar 2 easier). 9) The accuracy of the physics simulation is great but why ignore the fact your on a computer without the feedback of a real car. Surely you need to get creative with using other sources to give you feedback about what the car is doing. I remember GP2 sound allowing me to know exactly what the car was doing. I could tell the revs, speed and grip level just from the noise (I'm not blaming GPL as no other race game has had the accurate audio feedback that GP2 had). There are loads of other things but I'll give someone else a chance. All that said it's still the most advanced race game but it's not perfect by any stetch of the imagination. Dean
Scott Moore 16 Jan 1999#445655
Quoted text (11 lines)>Firstly I think GPL is great but I have to say the religious following is a >little dodgy to say the least. >We ought to compile a list of whats wrong with it just to address balance. >1) Opponents hit on framerate is unacceptable. Running on a 200mmx with a >Voodoo2 should be good enough (5 FPS with a full field is just bad >programming). The Voodoo2 should take all the graphic duties and the AI >should have no effect on the graphics. Name one other game that does this. >If a 12 meg Voodoo2 can't move the fairly simple graphics around then Papy >have done a terrible job as far as 3d acceleration goes.
A 200MMX is not even a bottom of the line system at this date. There are many programs that won't run acceptably on the system you describe. As for the AI hit, the AI in GPL is so much more complex than most other titles, thus the hit. Get ready to see a lot more of this. I'm yet to find any racing sim with perfect collision detection. Simple--turn off accelerated time before relieving yourself. Why even have an auto gearbox? The real cars didn't. Just consider it the fog of unconciousness. Programmer's perogitive--I tend to agree with them, as the few FF titles I have tried are utter crap, and FF adds nothing. Maybe someday it'll be viable, but I don't think it's a must have. Noone who hasn't driven one of these cars can say for sure, but remember that they used treaded tires. And the gauges are accurate. I don't believe they had speedos in them, and most racing cars don't have today. I've never had this problem--the shifter is pretty easy to see, IMHO. That's purely your opinion. As everything I've written is mine. These are not problems for most people, and the sim remains true to the programmer's intent. Nothing is perfect, but this comes closer than anyhting else out there. Scott Moore Team Tachyon [link lost in import] Sports *** Network [link lost in import: /***.com] Vintage Internet Racing Club [link lost in import] ICQ 13433409 Responsible Online Racers [link lost in import: /~marknjess/nonflame.html]
NanaKofi 16 Jan 1999#445656
If you read the manual, you will see that Sierra did NOT design the game to be a mass seller like NASCAR games. Instead they designed the game for the racing purist. They knew it would not sell much HOWEVER, they knew the PURE RACER would totally enjoy it. -I hope this clears things up -Nana
>Firstly I think GPL is great but I have to say the religious following is a >little dodgy to say the least. >We ought to compile a list of whats wrong with it just to address balance. Since everyone else is opining, I guess I will, too! A 200MMX is significantly less than half the speed of currently available processors. Don't be suprised to get significantly less than half of what is available. I have a fast computer and I don't want a lesser game because you don't feel like staying current with technology. Yeah..this is pretty annoying. Duh. Shut it off before you go to the 'loo'. Or, realize that real race drivers can't go to the bathroom that close to the start of a race and consider it part of the realism to be prevented from doing so. I have to admit this baffles me. Not so much that the cars had no auto gearboxes, but how are you going to know when to use the clutch if the computer is deciding on its own when it is going to shift? Are you going to guess? What happens if you push in the clutch to upshift while the computer thinks it should be accelerating a bit more? Is it OK that you blow the motor to bits? That is pretty goofy. Being a Force Feedback user, I agree. When implemented well, as in Viper racing, Force Feedback is very useful and enjoyable. That said, in GPL I am so involved in the driving that I don't notice the lack of FF. The forced centering of my MSFF wheel feels much nicer than springs, though. Springs only return the energy you put into them, electric motors push back. Some ability to display the speed would be nice. The appearance on the screen of the illusion of speed is pretty good, but not precise enough to accurately gauge the speed. Yeah, the real cars had no speedos, but you could read the tach a little more clearly, too. terrible. Yes!!! Put a gear indicator right next to the speed indicator, sort of like "S" in NASCAR 2/99 While we are at it, how about a wheel/pedal/shifter that uses a gated shifter. I know thats not GPLs problem, but it would be nice. I didn't like GP2, but then again I am having no trouble with the sounds in GPL. SBLive! with surround is terrific. My dogs hide under the furniture when I drive the Ferarri. I wanna put in my own whine about the crashing. I was pulling into the pits at the end of a race a couple days ago and bumped the tire of another car at about 5 mph. The car flew about 6 feet in the air and flipped over. Yea..that's realistic... ~daxe "religion is remedial spirituality" -----------== Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News ==---------- http://www.newsfeeds.com The Largest Usenet Servers in the World! -----------== Over 66,000 Groups, Plus a Dedicated Binaries Server ==----------
Dean 16 Jan 1999#445658
Agreed, but 5-10 FPS is hardly half is it. I can run Half-Life, Unreal and anything else at a playable level. GPL is not playable with a full field. With 8 cars I get 15-30 FPS in 1024 so the AI is the culprit. I don't accept that they couldn't have a less consuming system for working out where the other cars are. Have you ever had a problem with your opponents taking all your resources when you can'teven see them in any other race game. Maybe but it's still real quick and once its ended it goes through the race build up in a millisecond whether you pop to the loo or not. The excellent illusion is a real plus but that can't give you the speed within a few MPH which I feel is needed to balance the car going in to a bend. Consistent lap times becoms dificult. I know they didn't have speedos but then the real life feel would compensate a lot. Dean
>Agreed, but 5-10 FPS is hardly half is it. I can run Half-Life, Unreal and >anything else at a playable level. GPL is not playable with a full field. It is for me. It isn't for you. The reason for that is that your computer is old, slow and outdated. My SPARE computer (my previous main computer) is a P2/266 with 128 MEG! You can spin the idea any way you want, but the plain fact is that the sim runs fine on modern hardware. Your computer isn't up to the task, and if you aren't willing to update it, don't blame the sim! No, but I don't try to run stuff that is too advanced for my computer. As for the AI, when would you like them to be aware of your presence? I like the fact that the AI isn't as 'stupid' as in games past. I could usually figure out ways to dupe the AI before in other sims. Now they act more like real drivers. Should they start reacting to you when they are in view? When they are 100 yards away? When? The problem is that you can't have the AI switching on and off during the sim. At the risk of sounding redundant, my computer has no trouble with it. Any new computer is not going to have a problem with it. The computers coming out 6 months and a year from now aren't going to have a problem with it. If Papyrus should have dumbed down the game to run on your 200MMX, why shouldn't they have made it run on a P133 or 486dx100? Where do you get the completely arbitrary notion that your outdated computer is less outdated than other outdated computers? I'm sorry, I can't find any sympathy here, either. There is a clock ticking in front of you and you are complaining that you have trouble sensing the time. Why don't you pee before the practice session starts? I can see you in a real race, raising your hand and asking the race officials to hold up the start of the race because you have to go to the bathroom. It's a RACE, it's not supposed to be leisurely! I agree. It sure would. You eventually develop the speed sense in any game, though. I find looking at the road surface to help me in GPL. There is alot of stuff on the road (skid marks, brake zones, the groove) and it goes by at a more rapid pace than anything else you are looking at, so in effect it is the most accurate way to judge the speed. Being a musician, I might also be able to gain a really good sense of the speed in any given gear based on the pitch of the engine sound. Maybe I'm just full of ***and I should shut up. ~daxe -----------== Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News ==---------- http://www.newsfeeds.com The Largest Usenet Servers in the World! -----------== Over 66,000 Groups, Plus a Dedicated Binaries Server ==----------
>Listen carefully! A 12 meg Voodoo2 should chuck as many poly's and textures >around as GPL needs it to at a frightening rate regardless of processor. In >GPL it doesn't because Papy have chosen to do it a different way. Actually, I have heard the 12 MEG VooDoo II (which I also have) needs a faster processor to perform its best. Though two texture processors and a geometry processor are toiling away, there is more to do regarding graphics that is obviously CPU-dependant. Or uses more of it than any other game. Things have to move forward at some point and you've found that point. Why would the speed of your processor have an effect on how the VooDoo performs in ANY game if it was doing all the work? I don't either, but when they are ON screen, your computer is going to have to start working harder. I'd rather the load remain consistent. That's relative to how much money you have to spend. I don't have a fast computer to run GPL, I have it because I do a lot of 3d modelling and rendering and animation, so the speed was already there. Now YOU listen carefully. Papyrus is going to sell a lot more copies of GPL in the FUTURE than it is going to sell in the PAST. In the FUTURE, most computers will not have a problem with the game, so they aren't doing anything wrong and aren't being lazy, they are designing a game that will run just fine on the computers available during its life span on the shelf. I wouldn't buy a whole new computer for a game, but rest assured that I am never more than 6 months off the hardware pace because I can afford it and I enjoy it. I don't want my processor load switching in and out when the other drivers show up. I would rather it be consistent. The erratic performance of the sim if the additional AI was suddenly cut in or out would be very irritating to me. We are back to the same point. It works fine on my computer, but not on yours. I don't want the game to be one iota less comprehensive just so you can run it. Because it's more advanced and better. I don't use it, then again, I wasn't the one complaining about it. :o) And it's hard to tell the lighthearted stuff from the real stuff when the real stuff is stupid enough to be a joke, like someone complaining that their ancient P200MMX can't run a cutting edge sim as well as a cutting edge computer. ;-) I agree here, too. I noticed the odd letterbox concept. People have ragged Papyrus sims for awhile for using creative ways to reduce the amount of screen that needs to be drawn. How about N2/99? You actually have a pretty small percentage of the screen showing you what's outside the vehicle. Very true. It also depends on how often you visit the loo. ~daxe -----------== Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News ==---------- http://www.newsfeeds.com/ The Largest Usenet Servers in the World! -----------== Over 66,000 Groups, Plus a Dedicated Binaries Server ==----------
Dean 17 Jan 1999#445812
Listen carefully! A 12 meg Voodoo2 should chuck as many poly's and textures around as GPL needs it to at a frightening rate regardless of processor. In GPL it doesn't because Papy have chosen to do it a different way. I don't have a problem with a 200mmx being old hat but I resent it when I don't see an effective use of the fastest 3D hardware available for games. Bottom line is that GPL is the only game I can't get 20-30 FPS in (including Falcon 4 in 800x600). I've been meaning to upgrade for a while but everything I've bought this year (Unreal, Need for Speed 3-was a present, honest, F22 ADF, Falcon 4, MGPRS2, Half Life, Colin McRae, TOCA, European air War) run smoothly in 800x600 so I've held off. Then GPL comes along and positively wastes processor power. I just think that Papy have been lazy. Why would the processor slow down the frame rate so drastically anyway when the Voodoo2 is moving everything around. I don't care if the opponents physics are simplified or AI routines follow a more predictable path when they are off screen. My hardware can run the sim fine with 8 opponents. Are you telling me it's worth 350 to add 12 drivers to the field that I won't see for 95% of a race. Mmm. I don't think so. I will be going for a PII 450 in the next 2 weeks but people like you making excuses for software houses that have already used up all the power a 450 can muster are doing the industry no use. I can see you getting a PII 900 with a Voodoo3 just to have a full field for GPL 2 because they decide to model how the opponents moustaches blow in the wind on the other side of the track. Not when they are on the other side of a 9 minute track. I think that's fair to say don't you? Be realistic for god's sake. How often are you within sight of more than 5 cars? Not for long after the start, yet you are content for your processor cycles to be working out all that they are doing on the other side of the track. The problem is that you can't have the Fine but I'll say it again the Voodoo2 should be in control of the framerate not the processor. NO other game suffers from this. Why GPL? Are you an idiot? This was a lighthearted comment at best to show some imperfections in what's obviously an excellent but imperfect game. Get a grip. Every other game would stop accelerated time after the practice. Why would you want to leave it on anyway? A feature with no use. Oh finally. The sound in GPL almost allows me to get it mostly right, I just think as I try to get faster and the feedback need to be more accurate it will become a major problem. BTW why is the speedo available in the outside view only. There's an awful lot of black screen in the game that could be used for other bits. (widescreen was a stupid choice as well when you can run smooth in 1024x768 - why not use that resolution to fill the screen) Were all full of crap. It's just a question of how much on any given day.
P Gagg 17 Jan 1999#445813
> Firstly I think GPL is great but I have to say the religious > following is a > little dodgy to say the least. I personally cannot understand why there are so many negative posts about GPL at the moment? There are lots of driving games/sims that I don't use, don't like, or I am simply ***at. But I don't spend all my spare time writing posts slagging them off!!!! I concentrate on driving the games/sims that I *DO* enjoy. As far as I can see, GPL is the best *overall* racing sim so far, just IMHO, it is not perfect, it has flaws, but it is *still* the best so far. The perfect program has not been written yet, and probably never will be. So lets give credit where credit it due? I am a huge GPL fan. It is very hard to get to grips with (and I'm an *experienced* sim racer, note that I said experienced, and not fast or very good!) But thats half the thrill for me, mastering (even if its only slightly mastering!) the handling of these cars. I knew it would be hard before I got it, and I am quite prepared to give up hours every week to continue the steep learning curve it takes to master these cars. Thats my choice, no-one is making me do it? It also seems to me that most of the people ranting about GPL also think GPL is hard, often they think it is *too* hard? I feel obliged to comment to some people who have, IMHO, posted unfair comments with regards to GPL, when it appears plain to me that they simply do not like GPL, or find it too hard to drive. If you don't like it, don't drive it, simple? No-one is forcing you to buy it/drive it. If its too hard, don't drive it, simple? plenty of people *can* drive the cars ok, and get decent times (I hasten to add I am not one of them, I'm still learning and not very good?) If the above comments constitute religious rantings from a religious follower, then so be it...... As I've said, GPL is not perfect, but neither is *any* other sim? GPL comes a lot closer to perfection to most (if not all?) though. And its remarkably bug free, compared to most other sims. I have a K6 200, and with the pc optimised for games, some detail turned down, and with some AI running, I get decent enough fps. Certainly acceptible to me? I also have a Celery 333, and GPL flies along nicely. Virtually all games from now on will push hardware further and further. GPL pushes hardware quite a bit, thats technology for you? Unfortunately a 200mmx pc is just not cutting edge hardware anymore? Its a fact, get used to it, cos less and less games are gonna run on that 200mmx....... Gee, name a game that slows down, or suffers a performance hit when lots of things are happening in the game? Where do I start? Thats such a ***e? Try virtually every game you (or I) have ever played? If you think GPL's graphics are fairly simple, then tell me what game has complex graphics? IMHO the graphics are pretty good, maybe not the best ever, but they certainly do the job. Oh, and my 12Mb V2 card seems to move the graphics ok? Do you have your's set-up correctly? Can you name me a game with *perfect* collision detection? I cannot think of any? GP2? No, fraid not. F1RS? no, not here either! You let me know if you think of one.....Once again I think GPL does just fine here, you smack a car at high speed into a fence/wall and see what happens, the car normally gets pretty mangled? Do you expect the car to just bounce off so you can carry on? GPL is definitely not an *arcade* game where you might see this happen. Why do you put the game in accelerated time, (speeded up) then leave the room for a while? Why not just pause the sim? or leave it in *normal* speed? Would you "pop to the loo" if you were really just about to race? The real cars didn't have auto gears, the auto option is a driving aid for those not so gifted drivers? Do you have a clutch on a real auto gearbox? Why not try using manual? If you crashed badly in real life, you would probably die? I know which I'de prefer.......It is actually meant to indicate a tv camera view, when you crash badly, the tv camera no longer works, simple. IMHO, Sierra did the right thing by not including FF with GPL. I do not think it adds a great deal in its present form, and can actually detract from the feel of serious racing sims. Hmmm, feels pretty good to me on grass, normally if I've crashed or spun and am on the grass, I have little or no grip, and find it very slow to get back on the track, I have to tip-toe carefully or the car spins or slides all over the place? And gauges, they are actually fairly accurate. Most cars did not (and still do not) have speedo's? And the gauges do actually model engine temp, oil pressure, etc, so they do provide a purpose too. I thought you were using auto gears, so why worry what gear you are in? And any decent driver should automatically know which gear he is in at any point on the circuit (after some practice of course) and generally doesn't need to look at the gear lever? But if I *do* look at my gear lever, I can tell what gear I'm in, maybe its your graphics card? It will, keep trying.....(still wondering how you are down shifting too much if using auto gears?) I agree GP2 had great sound, but GPL's sound is good too? Not a problem for me? (You can hear the opposition in GPL too, but couldn't in GP2?) ok..... Agreed, so why are you giving it so much grief? Why not pick on one of the other (even less perfect) games/sims....... And can you name me a *perfect* game/sim? Like I said, don't like GPL? Find it too hard? simple....Don't drive it. It's *YOUR* choice....... 8-) *Peter* #:-)
snip
Quoted text (11 lines)> Listen carefully! A 12 meg Voodoo2 should chuck as many poly's and textures > around as GPL needs it to at a frightening rate regardless of processor. In > GPL it doesn't because Papy have chosen to do it a different way. I don't > have a problem with a 200mmx being old hat but I resent it when I don't see > an effective use of the fastest 3D hardware available for games. Bottom line > is that GPL is the only game I can't get 20-30 FPS in (including Falcon 4 in > 800x600). I've been meaning to upgrade for a while but everything I've > bought this year (Unreal, Need for Speed 3-was a present, honest, F22 ADF, > Falcon 4, MGPRS2, Half Life, Colin McRae, TOCA, European air War) run > smoothly in 800x600 so I've held off. Then GPL comes along and positively > wastes processor power.
If you think, Half-Life, Unreal and Falcon4 run SMOOTHLY on your 200MMX, you should get dizzy by looking at screenshots. It MUST be a freaking slideshow, even to you... The graphics are the smallest part of the work in GPL. And as the V2 is not doing the triangle setup, it's only doing the rendering, but a big part of the graphics setup is done by your lowly CPU. Live with it or upgrade... l8er ronny -- How to get rid of censorship in German game releases <http://www.gamesmania.com/german/maniac/freedom/freedom.htm> |\ _,,,---,,_ I want to die like my Grandfather, ZZZzz /,`.-'`' -. ;-;;,_ in his sleep. |,4- ) )-,_. ,\ ( `'-' Not like the people in his car, '---''(_/--' `-'\_) screaming their heads off!
Dean 17 Jan 1999#445815
I'm a designer and use G3 Macs so the PC is for games, web and spreadsheets etc. At the moment the only real use for extra horsepower is more drivers in GPL. I'm no tightwad just not a waster. No problem here at all but they will lose thousands of sales for people not wanting to upgrade yet. Not everyone is ready to dump a 200 - 300mhz machine for one game. Your suggesting I should. That's like Unreal processing every creature just so it doesn't slow down when they arrive. Maybe others will start doing that but I doubt it. In reality the game needs to be MORE comprehensive not less. You don't question scalable graphic options to allow for diferent machines so why is scalable AI such a terrible idea? In your opinion. I see lots of things that don't seem that advanced. re: post concerning grass, collision detection etc. The only game in existence that you can run in 1024x768 at 25fps but drops to 5fps if you add opponents and you think I'm stupid for questioning it. Can you imagine getting Half Life home to discover it ran perfect while you ran around on your own but if you added enemies it was reduced to a crawl. There would be a riot. The box says 166 min spec and anyone would assume that it's graphics that would suffer to up the framerate, not that you will have to drive alone in order to make it playable. No where does it say 450 needed to have a race. Dean
Dean 17 Jan 1999#445816
Quoted text (9 lines)>> Firstly I think GPL is great but I have to say the religious >> following is a >> little dodgy to say the least. >I personally cannot understand why there are so many negative posts >about GPL at the moment? There are lots of driving games/sims that I >don't use, don't like, or I am simply ***at. But I don't spend all >my spare time writing posts slagging them off!!!! I concentrate on >driving the games/sims that I *DO* enjoy.
It's just become a bit of a joke having 50-70% of all the posts praising GPL for the last 2 months or so. MGPRS2 exists as well you know. Sure but Papy will think that they can retire now having reached sim perfection. They haven't, that's all I'm saying. No way. GPL's difficulty is its best feature I'm not talking about bouncing. I'm talking about becoming entwined half way in to a wall. GP2 and F1RS may not be perfect but they are a lot better. I do use manual but if you were to use auto you lose the gear changing speed (very slow) and have to start with no revs. That's not an aid, it's just a stupid disadvantage. GPL is one game where it's easier to race WITH manual IMO. I expect an aid to bring me up to the level of manual control while I get better not punish me. Sorry but this is rubbish. In MGPRS2 you can feel the front go light as you overbrake or push too hard in to a corner as well as feel more resistance as you go around a corner which help you determine your speed. More resistance = more speed = more G's. Papy probably didn't have enough performance left to calculate it. Roll on PII 900's. If you drive ANY car with 2 wheels on the grass the car would pull to the direction of the grass due to the extra resistance (MGPRS2 does this beautifully and provides FFeffects to pull the steering that way). In GPL you can put a wheel or 2 on the grass and not really notice. Other Papy sims were the same. As I've said I don't use auto gears but that doesn't make them any less usable. Yeah my graphics card doesn't show the gears properly. Yeah that's the problem. God forbid Papy could ever produce a feature less than perfect. This is a ***y religion. Deny any critisism at all costs or we'll all go to hell. The gear lever concept is ***in a sim. Areal driver doesn't have to take their eyes off the road to check the gears (as he obviously feels them). We can't yet Papy force us to take our eyes off the road in a fast corner because they couldn't think of a better way. GPL's sound is unbelievable but as yet I haven't been able to trust it for really accurate feedback. Maybe more practice will help. As I said initially it's just balance. If there's nothing wrong with GPL then what are Papy going to improve? GPL is the best, it's is not the Holy Grail of sims. That's the best bit. Dean
Dean 17 Jan 1999#445817
Seriously they look fine. I thought they would run like a bag of $%^& but they don't. When I got Falcon 4 at Xmas I thought, mmm upgrade time then after installing it thought wow, I'll leave it a while. Dean
>I'm a designer and use G3 Macs so the PC is for games, web and spreadsheets >etc. At the moment the only real use for extra horsepower is more drivers in >GPL. I'm no tightwad just not a waster. Neither am I. At least I don't have to own TWO computers to do everything I want :) I think that, like many others in this group have pointed out, you will start seeing fewer and fewer games that will run acceptably on your older computer. Eventually you WILL upgrade. When you have the faster computer, probably in the next year or two, you will still be within GPLs product life and others who may have held off will buy it. Presto! No lost sales. I don't suggest anyone do anything based on what I say unless they ask for my advice. I was arguing with your contention that the program is flawed because you don't have a good enough computer to run it fully. In my opinion, the AI behaviour is what defines the game, along with the physics model. The way you are describing it, you want a game that LOOKS the same on every computer, but plays differently. While I understand your viewpoint, I think that is a kind of inconsistency that wouldn't be beneficial to the game's reputation. Yes, it is my opinion. It also seems to be the opinion of 95% of the rest of the people in here. And better does not mean perfect, nor does 'more advanced'. I think your *question* was stupid. You really need to read what is written and stop projecting things into it. I think it's a stupid question because expecting backwards compatability forever is short-sighted. Arguing vociferously on behalf of retarding the progress of game development is stupid when your problem with the game is based on YOUR SLOW COMPUTER and nothing else. I know I sound like a broken record, but lots of people with up-to-date computers have no trouble with the program; the problem is not with the program!!!! I can't imagine running/flying around and shooting monsters/people as entertainment. That whole genre of games alternates between horrifying me for its mindless 'killing-is-fun' mentality and boring me to tears. Yes, the minimum is absurdly low. I would NOT expect the framerate to be perfect with a computer close to the minimum requirement. I have used too much software to give any creedence to minimum requirements. If you recall, Windows 95 was touted as runnable on a 386DX with 4 meg of memory. Maybe a few morons tried to do that and are STILL waiting around for it to finish loading. Yes, it ran on that machine, but so poorly as to be unusable. This is not a new concept, and Papyrus/GPL are not alone in doing things that way. Anyone with half a brain and no axe to grind would realize the program would run like ***on a system near the bottom of the hardware requirement barrel. What are the minimum requirements for the other games you mentioned as running perfectly well? Are they also P166MMX? (asking because I don't know, not to be a smartass) ~daxe "beating a dead horse into hamburger" -----------== Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News ==---------- http://www.newsfeeds.com The Largest Usenet Servers in the World! -----------== Over 66,000 Groups, Plus a Dedicated Binaries Server ==----------
rob 17 Jan 1999#445819
Seems like the fans and detractor(s) of gpl are talking about different things. If you are talking about installing the program, checking out the menus, driving through spectators, and crashing the car, then I'll admit GPL isn't much. Even the graphics aren't that wonderful, I'll admit. But it's the _driving_, the _racing_ that's great - all the other stuff like crappy spectator graphics don't matter that much when you're into the feel of it trying to cut tenths off you best time. I'll agree GPL isn't well rounded in the way that a big budget or Nintendo game is (I'm not being sarcastic here, either, those Nintendo games are super professional in all ways, for what they are). GPL really just does one little trick really well - racing. <snip> You are right about that. A 166 will not cut it... 166 is a lie. rob.
Dean 18 Jan 1999#445983
That has got to be the worst point I've ever seen. I will not justify it with a reply. Remember the Min spec was for software only. I would expect given a slightly faster processor, mmx plus a Voodoo2 to be more than a little better than minimum spec. Does it actually run on a 166 in software. I can't see it somehow. Oh well. Dean
snip > As to whether the game is overrated: I do think it is a bit overrated. The > first few times you see the cars fly in the air and crash it is exciting bu > this wears thin very rapidly. Even with this, the crashes aren't all that hmm, you don't like the crashes? How long would you look at REALLY GOOD crashes? 10 minutes? An hour? I'd rather drive the sim and try to master the car... In arcade racers, I NEED to get first place, in GPL I'm very satisfied to drive somewhere in the middle and SURVIVE the race... ;^) l8er ronny -- Your mouse has moved. Windows must be restarted for the change to take effect. Reboot now? |\ _,,,---,,_ I want to die like my Grandfather, ZZZzz /,`.-'`' -. ;-;;,_ in his sleep. |,4- ) )-,_. ,\ ( `'-' Not like the people in his car, '---''(_/--' `-'\_) screaming their heads off!
Tadej Krev 18 Jan 1999#445986
It sounds like you need a good setup. And IMO from all simulations GPL gives the best feedback to the driver. Yes, it's hard, but eventually, after few weeks you'll be racing like crazy, not to mention the fun you can have if you go racing online... :o) Tadej Krevh // and take it easy at 1st, because many drivers jump into Lotus and then get very frustrated // take BRM or Coventry at first and then try out the upper class cars...
Quoted text (17 lines)> I gotta admit, I was geeked when GPL first hit the shelves. I was > watching this group everyday waiting for it to come out. When it did I even > crossed the border to Detroit because Canada always gets it a little later > than the States. But today, 3 months after I got it, I deleted it from my > system. Why? Frustration factor. GPL is not a game one can just "jump into" > and race. Like many have said it takes time and patience. I really don't > have the time, working 40 hours a week. I do like to spend some time AWAY > from the computer. Plus the cars are just TOO damn hard to control. And > guys, come on now. This game may have awesome physics and be super realistic > but it is a game played on a computer sitting on a desk. > The art of racing is mostly from "feel". You can feel a car starting to > slip under you. You can't do that in a game. It's like "BOOM" the car starts > to spin, you try to correct it, the wheel turns a tad too much, and you're > on the grass, in the wall, unable to race anymore. FUN!! Sorry, I'll wait > for Nascar3 where the cars give a bit more and bide my time with NR1999 > meanwhile!
P Gagg 18 Jan 1999#445987
> It's just become a bit of a joke having 50-70% of all the posts > praising GPL > for the last 2 months or so. MGPRS2 exists as well you know. If it upsets you so much, filter out the GPL posts? And yes, I know MGPRS exits, I have F1RS (the first version) and it too is a great sim, but it too, is not perfect, and IMHO GPL takes sims to a higher plane and is quite simply the best there is.....at present. I have no doubt that some time soon, an even better sim will appear. Thats life.... What! where do you get this from? Are you not aware that Papy are already working on their next sims? Have you ever watched *real* F1 races? ever noticed how, on quite a few tracks, they are able to put two wheels quite a bit off the track on the kerbs, on the dirt, and even (gasp!) on the grass!!!!) No! perhaps you should watch and see. Granted, its not recommended driving, but it *does* happen, and they *do* get away with it? Amen Brother, (Thats called Irony?) Constructive critisism is one thing, unfounded allegations, uninformed comment, and plain stupid remarks are another. And you can hear the revs, and you can remember what gear you just put the car in, and you can glance at the rev counter, etc, etc, yeah, yeah, ok, so what are you getting at..... Hmmm, Papy "force us" do they? Do you always let people force you to do things you don't want to do? If you don't want to look at the gear lever, then don't. It really is that simple? No-one is forcing you to look at it. And what would be a better way? I'de be very interested to hear. I think most decent drivers, after a bit of practice, rarely have to look at the gear lever while driving. I'm not particulally good at GPL, but I've already learnt to change gear without looking at the lever, but it is handy to have if you crash, or spin, and want to glance down to check which gear you are in after quickly dropping up or down the gears pretty fast.Perhaps you need a bit more practice? The choice is yours, you can look if you want, or not, no-one is forcing you to do anything. I never said it was (has anybody?) so why are you arguing? Jeez, get a life and complain about something thats really bothering you. *Peter* #:-)
ymenard 18 Jan 1999#445988
Dean wrote Well there must be a reason, no ? It's easy... GPL makes MGPRS2 look like a video arcade game. No but it's the most perfect hard-core simracing title that was ever produced. And it's a BIG step in front of the second most.. Is this hard to understand ? It's funny any hard-core simracer knows that. And anybody that raced in real life knows that. LOL yes it's based on the POD game engine. The real physics are about non-existant in MGPRS2, it's all made of canned routines and so. Per example, did you know that the tracks are flat ? They don't have any camber and banking. That means that the track will go up and down in Z axis, and that's mostly all. It won't roll on it's axis. You don't have camber that means that the track itself is flat.. not shapen like an arc as in real life. same goes for the banking. The carrousell at the Ring is VERY banked.. not in the title. Oh and for the bumps... it's precalculated XYZ positions in the track files... all canned not real physics compared to GPL. Just memorize your gear. Like in real life. You need to learn how to do that. In real life CART since they have sequential gears they need to memorize for all the race what gear they are... -= Fran?ois Mnard <ymenard/Nas-Frank> -= NROS Nascar sanctioned Guide http://www.nros.com/ -= SimRacing Online http://www.simracing.com/ -= Official mentally retarded guy of r.a.s. -= May the Downforce be with you... "People think it must be fun to be a super genius, but they don't realise how hard it is to put up with all the idiots in the world."
% > Firstly I think GPL is great but I have to say the religious % > following is a % > little dodgy to say the least. % I personally cannot understand why there are so many negative posts % about GPL at the moment? There are lots of driving games/sims that I % don't use, don't like, or I am simply ***at. But I don't spend all % my spare time writing posts slagging them off!!!! I concentrate on % driving the games/sims that I *DO* enjoy. Frustration at not being able to "enjoy" the best racing simulation to date for the home PC. That and trolling. -- **************************** Michael E. Carver ************************* Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town. =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
% 4) No clutch control on auto gearbox. Why? Because automatic transmissions don't have a manual clutch? % 6) No Force Feedback. I notice the manual sarcastically dismisses current % feedback technology but even with this you can tell when the front end has % begun to slide in MGPRS2 which would be a big addition to GPL. There is also a big latency issue with Force Feedback. One hears enough complaints about the frame rate hit with AI cars. Why bog down the performance even more for a bit of hand-candy? -- **************************** Michael E. Carver ************************* Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town. =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
Dean 18 Jan 1999#445991
It was meant as a joke. Your American right? It's not racist before you start, it's just that a lot of English humour and subtle sarcasm does seem to get lost in this NG. We are talking about the best 20 drivers in the world. Not me and you for pity's sake. Shuey can do it, I wager you and I should not without any practice as is quite possible in GPL. Sometimes you barely notice putting a wheel on the grass let alone get punished for it. Irony. Good at least your aware of the concept. Now go away and practice it a little more then you won't have to be so obvious about it. When you knock the gears down quickly at the end of the straight it's easy to miss-count and end up losing the back end in first. Hmmm. End of stupid conversation I think. You can't see the point I'm not going to waste my time explaining something that's this simple. This started out (I didn't start it) as a lighthearted balance to all the GPL is wonderful posts. Idiots like you have turned it in to vitriolic mess. Maybe I was right about the religious angle. You can't suggest alternative options to them either whether it's lighthearted or not. Dean
Dean 18 Jan 1999#445992
I wager you've not played it. I have both and love both. Your probaly in America and haven't had MGPRS2 yet. I'm waiting for all the posts on MGPRS2 to increase dramatically once you get the official release. Agreed it is the best, just not by as large a margin as is suggested by people who haven't got MGPRS2. And that affects the good use of FF in what way? Yes I'm well aware of that. In Europe we watch F1 with a passion so you'd have to be blind not to know. The game itself however is the best of it's kind so we have to live with it. BTW did you ever critisise GP2 for it's awfully flat inaccurate tracks or is it just a MGPRS2 slagging session. GPL isn't real life and you don't have the feedback to tell you what gear your in. Have you ecer (be honest) looked at your gear leve in your real car since you took your driving test. Of course not you don't need to. You shouldn't in GPL. As I've said elsewhere I'm sure practice will make me better but in the meantime it's annoying. Dean
Dean 18 Jan 1999#445993
It's not really an auto gearbox more an aid. All I'm saying is that without a clutch it's less an aid and more of a restriction. Dean
Pat Dotson 18 Jan 1999#445994
> % 6) No Force Feedback. I notice the manual sarcastically dismisses current > There is also a big latency issue with Force Feedback. There was a latency issue with earlier FF devices. With serial port input, and especially with USB, I don't think latency is an issue at all. If done right, it shouldn't cause a performance hit. -- ------------------------------------------------------ IMPACT Motorsports http://www.impactmotorsports.com/pd.html ------------------------------------------------------
ymenard 18 Jan 1999#445995
Dean wrote OF COURSE. I probably haven't tried it <g>. I just have two version of it on my PC, including an early beta. You know.. Ubisoft did MGPRS2 in Montreal, and I live in Montreal. Ubisoft had only about 3guys working on the project that ever raced a real racecar in real life... Oh and should I repost the URL about the website about the bad working conditions at Ubisoft ? Of course... crappy replays.. AI who is flawled IMHO, bad physics.. canned reactions.. fake weather conditions.. track accuracy is very bad (still a tiny better than F1RS), bad sound.. no license, retro crappy and boring racing, still slow menues.. and the list goes on and on... It's still fun, but too flawed. Like I said they will never make a good title because of Ubisoft's mentality. I bet you 5$ that the next title will STILL use the old POD game engine. Err.. even Psygnosis F1 has more accurate tracks than what Ubisoft did. Oh and PLEASE.. Gp2 was out 3years ago, with the limitation of the era. But Ubisoft didn't increased it's track accuracy in TWO titles... And you just said it. When you compare a 3year old software to a new release.. it's because it's flawed. Think about this.. THREE years and a half almost.. that's BIG in the *** industry. What major problem does Gp2 have in track accuracy ? The Montreal track is IMHO the best (in it's 1994 form), and at least they have Suzuka accurate (oops I forgot Ubisoft's game engine can't model banking and camber). How is this possible in 1999 ? Errr.. Im a Touring car driver and let me tell you that if you can't remember what gear your in there's a problem since you will need to look at the gear configuration. That means you don't pay attention to the track. That's the same in whatever series... Heck it's difficult... 1-2-3-4-5 I don't see why you have problems with GPL and what gear your in. There's no more feedback in a car that would tell you what gear your in more than in GPL. I can understand that.. GPL has a steep curve and probably no other sims on the market needs more time to master it. Thus being like in real life. Even after 2full years of Touring car I wasn't able to master my Volvo 850T. -= Fran?ois Mnard <ymenard/Nas-Frank> -= NROS Nascar sanctioned Guide http://www.nros.com/ -= SimRacing Online http://www.simracing.com/ -= Official mentally retarded guy of r.a.s. -= May the Downforce be with you... "People think it must be fun to be a super genius, but they don't realise how hard it is to put up with all the idiots in the world."
ymenard 18 Jan 1999#445996
Dean wrote LOL Cmon Dean.. So clutching it into first gear should be impossible because only the 20 best drivers in the world can. Anybody can drive a F1.. but it's not everybody who can push it to the limit. Easy reasoning. Putting a wheel or 2 in the grass is like the Chaos theory. It's soo unpredictable (mostly because of the weight transfer at the moment and also how the grass is actually..). That's easy physics. Another time.. Cmon ! It's like that in ANY racing simulator or in ANY real-racing type. Heck if you can't remember what gear your in... <vbg> "Because it's too fast". I think it's more you. You didn't answer him. Let's try another time. What do you want them to make better so you can remember what gear your in ? That's a great point and you don't want to answer him. Why ? Err... you want a voice to tell you what gear your in ? <g> Nope, we are all doing normal threading here. No flames, no bashing fest.. nothing at all. But from this post it seems you just want to evade from the reality. That's how your shown to us. Heck we are a group of hard-core simracer. You come here and tell US how GPL is ***(even if it's not true). Heck at least do you have any real-life racing experience ? If we wanted to flame you, we would had flamed you. -= Fran?ois Mnard <ymenard/Nas-Frank> -= NROS Nascar sanctioned Guide http://www.nros.com/ -= SimRacing Online http://www.simracing.com/ -= Official mentally retarded guy of r.a.s. -= May the Downforce be with you... "People think it must be fun to be a super genius, but they don't realise how hard it is to put up with all the idiots in the world."
Pat Dotson 18 Jan 1999#445997
> >Because automatic transmissions don't have a manual clutch? > It's not really an auto gearbox more an aid. All I'm saying is that without > a clutch it's less an aid and more of a restriction. It's supposed to be a restriction. -- ------------------------------------------------------ IMPACT Motorsports http://www.impactmotorsports.com/pd.html ------------------------------------------------------
Te 18 Jan 1999#445998
LOL, what kind of touring car is that? A triycle contest? I never have to *look* at the 'gear configuration' to figure out what gear I'm in...In no car on this planet. Sorry, couldn't resist... As it is just as limited as any computergame the indicators are probably just about right. Maybe a few working gauges as well as a simple gear display would certainly have done a better job. But that's of course not realistic...ho hum. --Tel
ymenard 18 Jan 1999#445999
Tel wrote That's exactly what I said, that in no car in the entire world (normal life or racecar) you should look at what gear your in ;) Maybe you mis-understood me ;-) Exactly ;-) and we all understand that the goal with GPL wasn't to make it accessible to the mass, but to a more strict group of hard-core fans who want realism ;). But all the gauges work btw, there's a website (sorry can't remember the URL) about how each of them work (they are different for each GPL car). And to anybody who tells me they are impossible to read, they aren't more easy to read if you would be in the real car. It's shaking and rattling up/down/left/right, so you obviously wouldn't have enough focus to be able to see the numbers on the tach ;-) -= Fran?ois Mnard <ymenard/Nas-Frank> -= NROS Nascar sanctioned Guide http://www.nros.com/ -= SimRacing Online http://www.simracing.com/ -= Official mentally retarded guy of r.a.s. -= May the Downforce be with you... "People think it must be fun to be a super genius, but they don't realise how hard it is to put up with all the idiots in the world."
Dean 18 Jan 1999#446000
>> >Because automatic transmissions don't have a manual clutch? >> It's not really an auto gearbox more an aid. All I'm saying is that without >> a clutch it's less an aid and more of a restriction. >It's supposed to be a restriction. Why? It's an aid to help you achieve good times until your good enough to turn it off. Sitting on the start without a clutch is ridiculous. GP2 had a clutch in auto so it's not an alien concept. I just thought aids were 'aids'. The definition of an aid is that it HELPS you. No clutch gives you a big disadvantage. I started using a manual box the first day I got GPL because of this and that's not good to be forced to turn aids off otherwise you'll be miles behind at the start by the time engines got around to the power band. Dean
Dean 18 Jan 1999#446001
>Dean wrote >>We are talking about the best 20 drivers in the world. Not me and you for >>pity's sake. Shuey can do it, I wager you and I should not without any >>practice as is quite possible in GPL. Sometimes you barely notice putting a
Quoted text (10 lines)>>wheel on the grass let alone get punished for it. >LOL Cmon Dean.. >So clutching it into first gear should be impossible because only the 20 >best drivers in the world can. Anybody can drive a F1.. but it's not >everybody who can push it to the limit. Easy reasoning. Putting a wheel or >2 in the grass is like the Chaos theory. It's soo unpredictable (mostly >because of the weight transfer at the moment and also how the grass is >actually..). That's easy physics.
I saw Winfield's 2 rally drivers fail to get around the first corner in a promotional Williams event. Both gassed it and crashed it, so I wouldn't say anyone can drive an F1 car. As far as the grass is concerned I still think GPL's grass is a bit grippy. Just my opinion but when I go on the grass in a fast corner I get the feeling, given the forces pushing the car wide, that with the sudden lack of grip there ought to be more of a slide. GPL is the only sim where I don't worry about going wide as I know I can get it back. I suppose the tyres and track could have been so poor that grass doesn't lose you that much grip but I'm not sure. It's not about remembering but at the end of a straight you go from 5th to 2nd in a blink and I find it easy to go from 5th to 1st. As I've said a million times I may improve on this but at the moment, with everything else going on, it's quite hard. I would prefer a clutched auto gearbox then I could get used to the braking points and grip levels without having to worry about the gears as well. Ok. When I say 'force' I meant if you need to know what gear your in. I'm not saying they come to your house and smash your head in if you don't but then I didn't think anyone stupid enough to think beyond what I meant. As far as a better way, an optional gear digit at the top of the dash would be nice while your learning. Don't say they didn't have them because drivers didn't see TV snow when they crashed or have auto gears anyway so every aid would compromise reality. Wow. This gets worse. I might post some controversial stuff in the Nazi newsgroups just to get more level headed replies. I didn't say GPL was crap!!!! What planet are you on? I started my first post saying I thought it was great sim that I loved but that it had a few flaws IMHO. That's all. I'm one of those *** simmers that you go on about. I've been with this NG since Nascar through Indycar II, GP2 and now GPL. OK. GPL is absolutely perfect. No flaws, problems or anything negative to be said about it. Papy are god's and deserve my full and committed loyalty for ever and ever amen. Happy? Dean
>OK. GPL is absolutely perfect. No flaws, problems or anything negative to be >said about it. Papy are god's and deserve my full and committed loyalty for >ever and ever amen. Happy? No. There's no apostrophe in gods. That's *American* humor, Dean. ;-) Thanks for arguing. ~daxe -----------== Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News ==---------- http://www.newsfeeds.com/ The Largest Usenet Servers in the World! -----------== Over 66,000 Groups, Plus a Dedicated Binaries Server ==----------
>That's a great point and you don't want to answer him. Why ? That's why I stopped arguing with him. He didn't address any of the points I made, just kept saying the same thing different ways. ~daxe -----------== Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News ==---------- http://www.newsfeeds.com/ The Largest Usenet Servers in the World! -----------== Over 66,000 Groups, Plus a Dedicated Binaries Server ==----------
Pat Dotson 19 Jan 1999#446173
> >> It's not really an auto gearbox more an aid. All I'm saying is that > without a clutch it's less an aid and more of a restriction. > >It's supposed to be a restriction. > Why? It's an aid to help you achieve good times until your good enough to See below. You answered your own question. It is a big encouragement to use manual shifting. I don't know if Papy really planned it that way or not, but using the aids in any other papy sim was a serious handicap. They have never helped to get _good_ lap times - you have to drive without aids to do that. On this point, I think Papy probably just wanted to maintain some degree of realism. Think about a real car with an auto transmission. It has no clutch. If you wanted to, you could rev it up and drop it into gear. You can do the same thing in GPL. In fact, I use manual shifting but don't use the clutch on the start - just slam it into gear. -- ------------------------------------------------------ IMPACT Motorsports http://www.impactmotorsports.com/pd.html ------------------------------------------------------
[long volley deleted] Dean, you gotta realize the sheer number of Papy fanatics that live in r.a.s.. It's a lost cause trying to point out any percieved shortcomings with Papy products, because there are many here that will jump to Papy's defense no matter what the argument. Personally, I don't buy anything from them because I don't think they are capable of producing an acceptable game graphically. I bought one of their off-road titles and it made me laugh. Running Voodoo1 at like 10-15 fps and rediculously sparse environment. Additionally, their allegance to Rendition cards is confusing. Seems to me that they better watch out-- if a start-up w/ lots of domain experience gets ahold of Ratbag's Difference Engine (sustained 60 fps), Papy's toast. They better pay their developers good... --mountain k
% >Because automatic transmissions don't have a manual clutch? % It's not really an auto gearbox more an aid. All I'm saying is that without % a clutch it's less an aid and more of a restriction. Which, (you may agree or disagree with the merits) was the designers' intention. Driving with aids are a double-edged sword. They are crutches and in such should be a restriction. I take it that you disagree with this philosophy, so be it. . . -- **************************** Michael E. Carver ************************* Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town. =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
<snip> % Personally, I don't buy anything from them because I don't think they % are capable of producing an acceptable game graphically. I bought one % of their off-road titles and it made me laugh. Running Voodoo1 at % like 10-15 fps and rediculously sparse environment. Additionally, % their allegance to Rendition cards is confusing. Sounds like you are talking about SODA which was not a Papyrus designed program. The "produced" it, but was coded by another design group all together. -- **************************** Michael E. Carver ************************* Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town. =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
David Ewing 19 Jan 1999#446177
> We are talking about the best 20 drivers in the world. Not me and you for > pity's sake. Shuey can do it, I wager you and I should not without any > practice as is quite possible in GPL. Sometimes you barely notice putting a > wheel on the grass let alone get punished for it. Are we playing the same game? I find that there are places where I always spin if I put a wheel off - for example, turn 2 at Mosport (downhill left hander). I suspect it has to do with lots of factors (orientation of car, which wheels are loaded, how fast the wheel is spinning, whether or not it is a front wheel or a rear wheel, etc.). Dave Ewing
Pat Dotson 19 Jan 1999#446178
Quoted text (8 lines)> > practice as is quite possible in GPL. Sometimes you barely notice putting a > > wheel on the grass let alone get punished for it. > Are we playing the same game? I find that there are places where I > always spin if I put a wheel off - for example, turn 2 at Mosport > (downhill left hander). I suspect it has to do with lots of factors > (orientation of car, which wheels are loaded, how fast the wheel is > spinning, whether or not it is a front wheel or a rear wheel, etc.).
I can often save putting a wheel off in that turn at Mosport. It is about the toughest one in all of GPL, and just about the only place I have a lot of trouble with putting a wheel off. The key to saving it in that situation is to immediately balance the throttle. If you apply too much gas, not enough gas, or touch the brakes, you will spin. I can save it with this technique just about every time I put a wheel off. This is different from most other sims where all you have to do is let completely off the gas, and steer back onto the track. -- ------------------------------------------------------ IMPACT Motorsports http://www.impactmotorsports.com/pd.html ------------------------------------------------------
>I saw Winfield's 2 rally drivers fail to get around the first corner in a >promotional Williams event. Both gassed it and crashed it, so I wouldn't say >anyone can drive an F1 car. That's overconfidence, not lack of ability. Jean Alesi and Gerhard Berger crashed a Fiat, does that mean they can't drive? As it's been said, anyone who can drive a road car can drive an F1 car, it's how quickly and consistently you can do it that's the difficult part. Don't you have this in GPL? You need to change gear at the start but that's it, after that it changes for you. Now you're just being silly. No, not about GPL perfection or Papy being gods, but in assuming that anyone on this newsgroup could ever be happy about something posted here - you've just upset the GPL bashers...! :-) Cheers! John
Dean 19 Jan 1999#446180
I've been playing Silverstone a lot. The second corner (very fast lefthander) is the main corner for this. I very rarely lose it if I go on the grass here and you take it almost flat out. Maybe other tracks are less forgiving. Dean
Dean 19 Jan 1999#446181
Yes but the change is very slow. I improved my best auto time on my second lap with the manual. The performace gain is massive. My kingdom for some balance! Happy racing. Dean
David Ewing 19 Jan 1999#446182
Ah, that explains it. You're right about Silverstone. Going wide there is much more forgiving than the other tracks. Don't know why. Dave Ewing
Quoted text (12 lines)> >Are we playing the same game? I find that there are places where I > >always spin if I put a wheel off - for example, turn 2 at Mosport > >(downhill left hander). I suspect it has to do with lots of factors > >(orientation of car, which wheels are loaded, how fast the wheel is > >spinning, whether or not it is a front wheel or a rear wheel, etc.). > I've been playing Silverstone a lot. The second corner (very fast > lefthander) is the main corner for this. I very rarely lose it if I go on > the grass here and you take it almost flat out. Maybe other tracks are less > forgiving. > Dean
ymenard 19 Jan 1999#446183
Dean wrote Good point.. actually there is an easy (let's keep it simple) solution to this. Take the two situations. Turn two at Silverstone and turn two at Mosport. Grass physics are mathematically calculated I would speculate with an easy friction calculation between the tyre and the grass. There is some numbers that exist about adherence coefficiant between the tyre and the road. They are used for braking distance, but can be also applied to the traction. Taking 1 as a base number we have... Tarmac : 0.8 Asphalt : 0.7 Wood : 0.55 Snow : Between 0.2 and 0.15 Short grass : 0.4 Long grass : 0.35 Those coefficient are approximate of 10%, and can change because of the quality of the surface, the design of the tyre and also the adherence of the tyre gum (it's not that big as we think, since if the tyre is hyper-sticky the coefficient will stay the same... it's just an X number that needs to be multiplied as the definition of the word "coefficient"). Ok... Now what does this add ? Im about sure (but still speculate) that there is some difference within each track of the grass, as it is with the asphalt also. Kyalami is IMHO less forgiving, probably because of the nature of the grass there (very short). When your going into turn2 at Silverstone, the car weights are different when you touch the grass than when it's exiting turn2 at Mosport. At Mosport all the weight are transferred on the right side of the car, since it's turning left. This is basic racing physics. The lateral force are much bigger than at Silverstone so the right tyres have much more weight on them. It really destabilize the car and that's why spins are common in that corner. Oh and another thing.. IIRC it's not grass there but a mixture of mud/grass exiting Turn2. Now to Silverstone. When you go into turn2, the weights affect much less the drivability of the car than at Mosport. The lateral forces are less, since the corner is wider. Thus needing less turning inputs, and that makes the weight more equally on both sides of the car. When your left tyres touch the grass, the weight is much less than at Mosport when you touch it. As a final point...there is a great URL about a website that explains the basic physics of racing. Everybody should read this and try to understand this website. the URL is : http://members.home.net/rck/phor/ Oh and if anybody see something wrong in my reasoning.. please reply ;) -= Fran?ois Mnard <ymenard/Nas-Frank> -= NROS Nascar sanctioned Guide http://www.nros.com/ -= SimRacing Online http://www.simracing.com/ -= Official mentally retarded guy of r.a.s. -= May the Downforce be with you... "People think it must be fun to be a super genius, but they don't realise how hard it is to put up with all the idiots in the world."
>>Err... you want a voice to tell you what gear your in ? <g> >Wow. This gets worse. I might post some controversial stuff in the Nazi >newsgroups just to get more level headed replies. What was the bit about Americans not understanding humor? I believe you have to work on that concept yourself a bit. "Paging Mr. Godwin! - Sir, may I inform you that you were right, again." -- Wolfgang Preiss \ E-mail copies of replies to this posting are welcome.
Dean 20 Jan 1999#446328
Quoted text (7 lines)>>>Err... you want a voice to tell you what gear your in ? <g> >>Wow. This gets worse. I might post some controversial stuff in the Nazi >>newsgroups just to get more level headed replies. >What was the bit about Americans not understanding humor? I believe >you have to work on that concept yourself a bit.
Err. Hence the reply being humourous. Mmmm. Americans and the the England. Two countries divided by a common language. Dean
>Err. Hence the reply being humourous. Mmmm. Americans and the the England. >Two countries divided by a common language. I heard today a story (true or apocryphal, I don't know) about Juhn Cleese bein interviewed recently on U.S. TV. When asked what was the difference between Americans and British he considered for a moment and answered that there were three. Firstly we speak English and American don't, secondly that when we have a world championship in any given sport we actually invite the rest of the world to participate, and finally when you meet the head of state in the UK you only need to go down....on one knee....! Cheers! John
David Ewing 20 Jan 1999#446330
Quoted text (8 lines)> I heard today a story (true or apocryphal, I don't know) about Juhn > Cleese bein interviewed recently on U.S. TV. When asked what was the > difference between Americans and British he considered for a moment > and answered that there were three. Firstly we speak English and > American don't, secondly that when we have a world championship in any > given sport we actually invite the rest of the world to participate, > and finally when you meet the head of state in the UK you only need to > go down....on one knee....!
Eh? I don't get it. But after all we're just a bunch of dumb hillbillies over here in the States. John, I think it was inevitable that a post mentioning American's lack of English skills would contain three typos. ;-) I even included a dreaded smiley so that any other Americans reading this would know that I'm just pulling your chain. Actually, I can't speak for the rest of my fellow Americans, but I love British humor (Monty Python, P.G. Wodehouse, Fawlty Towers, ...). Not to mention Richard Thompson - the world's greatest guitar player whose between song banter is hilarious. But I'm still trying to figure out something I saw on the Benny Hill show. When the director said "Zoom in on those trophies", why did the cameraman get a tight shot of the woman's ***s? Dave Ewing
Ford Prefe 20 Jan 1999#446331
Took a look there after a recommendation on rasf1. Certainly worth printing off and studying.
P Gagg 22 Jan 1999#446578
Quoted text (12 lines)> >>> The perfect program has not been written yet, and probably never > >>> will be. So lets give credit where credit it due? > >>Sure but Papy will think that they can retire now having reached > sim > >>perfection. They haven't, that's all I'm saying. > >What! where do you get this from? Are you not aware that Papy are > >already working on their next sims? > It was meant as a joke. Your American right? It's not racist before > you > start, it's just that a lot of English humour and subtle sarcasm > does seem > to get lost in this NG.
Jeez, can't you even read a message properly? I wrote the first paragraph above, but I didn't write the second paragraph. Get a newsreader that threads properly and maybe you won't get so confused. And, No, I am not American, I'm English, and happen to know a little bit about English humour myself.....I'm not gonna waste it on a wingnut like you though pal. We are also talking about a *SIMULATION*, not real life here! GPL is the best *SIM* to date, but its still *ONLY* a sim. I was pointing out that GPL does indeed model accurately real world car physics (within the confines of a pc sim anyway?) Yawn....... Is it? I've driven GPL since its first demo release, and cannot remember ever doing this, If I have, it must have only been once or twice? I also don't remember anyone else moaning about it? You harp on about it like you are doing it every five minutes, sounds to me like you need to stop whining and start practicing. Yep, thats right, you've got no point to make, or are incapable of explaining it, so don't waste yours (and everyone elses) time. This started out with some *** spouting inane drivel, as an attempt at trolling, and just kept on trolling......and on......and on....... Nuff said, large portion, YES, larging it plenty, SORTED. (Got it?) NB: Americans, please don't ask me to explain the above sentance, its' an English thang......(But the plank I'm replying to will/should/ought to understand!) 8-) *Peter* #:-)
Dean 23 Jan 1999#446703
I didn't say you did which was why I knew 'that' reply was from an American and not yourself. Mmmm. If your that bored why bother even typing Yawn.....? Good for you. Glad it's not a problem. I suppose you never blew the engine in ICR2 doing the same thing? You don't have to read the threads, especially as it developed if you didn't care for the content surely. I actually didn't start the thread if you care to check. I just posted after it had started. It was someone else who said GPL was overrated. Take it up with them. Anyway it's not like an Englishman to lose his head like this. Chill out, it's not to be taken nearly as seriously as some seem to have taken it. If you read the posts properly you would see that I offered 6 things 'I' thought could be improved in GPL and everybody else had a heart attack at the thought. How it got to people like you calling me a *** and all the other ***you've come out with is beyond me. You could do to spell sentence correctly BTW. Still what would you expect from someone who would use profanities in a normally well behaved NG. Dean
YUBS 24 Jan 1999#446894
>1) Opponents hit on framerate is unacceptable. Running on a 200mmx with >a Voodoo2 should be good enough (5 FPS with a full field is just bad fairly simple graphics around >then Papy have done a terrible job as far as 3d acceleration goes. Ok, it seems that you just don't understand how 3D accelerators work. The voodoo 2 doesn't take over all the graphic duties. It just renders the scene the actual transformations of the vertices have to be done by the cpu... think about it... you wouldn't be able to just plug a 3d accelerator into the the mother board without a processor and have it display graphics. Also, in another one of your post you say "a pentium 200, with mmx, should be enough" well, I guess you got caught up in the mmx marketing hype because A) To get any benifits from MMX you have to write specific code for it (code that uses the special instructions intel added) and B)even when written for MMX, you wouldn't see more than approx. %5-%15 increase in performance and last but not least C) MMX is a HUGE flop because it doesn't have ANY instructions that speed up 3D calculations... that's right, NONE, ZERO NADA, ZILCH.... not to mention that you can't switch between MMX registers and regular register without suffering a performance hit. So basically the fact that you have MMX doesn't mean anything. And if you read any (good)reviews of ANY V2 you would notice that they state that the V2 is cpu limited, not fill rate limited meaning that the V2 is waiting around for the vertex information so that it can render the frame... it's done rendering the scene before the processor can deliver the next frame's info. that's why you don't really notice a difference between a V1 and a V2 on anything less then a PII (you get about 5-10 fps more with a V2 than a V1)... once you hit the PII range, the V2 is highly scalable... then there is the fact that the cpu still has to do sound, AI, poll the interupts and get any user input( i.e. steering). plus in windows you have numerous things going on behind the scenes. so basically, your idea that the V2 frees up the cpu of graphic processing is wrong. True the cpu has to do signifigantly less work than without a 3d accelerator but it still is a major part of rendering each frame. How the heck would this work?... you'd have to guess when the computer was going to shift. Besides if you're using the auto gear box, you're probably not ready to use the clutch. Did you mean something else because frankly this doesn't make any sense... -Josh de Bever
Dean 24 Jan 1999#446895
Snipped lots of good tech info on Voodoo2: I agree. I was meaning the hit on framerate with opponents on suggesting that the processor is so busy with AI it doesn't seem to have time for much else, lowering the framerate as a result. I'm well aware that a 200mmx is out of date but having searched Deja News I'm not convinced that even a 450 PII with Twin 12 Voodoo2's is capable of a constant 37 FPS with a full field. Some seem to be ok but a lot still drop frames. I can actually run MGPRS2 in 1024x768 smooth as anything (no frame counter so I'm not sure exactly) and I wouldn't call the AI bad. In fact I think the AI is better than any other race game I've played except GPL. I must say the in MGPRS2 if you spin and sit in the middle of the track the cars will avoid you. In GPL I have been hit a few times when they had a good view of me. The question is I suppose is GPL's AI worth a new computer. I can get 37 FPS with 3 other cars on the track so I know my 200mmx can at least handle the physics on my car comfortably. For starts only and when you spin off and need to accelerate form standstill. Currently you just get bogged down in 1st at the start because you can't rev the engine without a clutch. GP2 had this and it was great for starts. Incidentally MGPRS2 doesn't either (on manual as well) and it's quite annoying not being able to rev the engine at the start. Dean
P Gagg 29 Jan 1999#447794
Quoted text (8 lines)>Is it? I've driven GPL since its first demo release, and cannot >remember ever doing this, If I have, it must have only been once or > >twice? I also don't remember anyone else moaning about it? You harp on > >about it like you are doing it every five minutes, sounds to me like > >you need to stop whining and start practicing. > Good for you. Glad it's not a problem. I suppose you never blew the engine > in ICR2 doing the same thing?
I've never driven ICR2, so No, I didn't!!! I'm not calling *you* a ***, I'm calling the *original* poster/troller a ***, although...... Pardon? do you mean "you would do better spelling sentences correctly" and your grammar is perfect is it? Hmmm, *** is a profanity is it? I could do a lot worse if I *really* tried I assure you. I thought I was being very restrained and well behaved? (under the circumstances....) Never mind, you'll get over it. Now lets get back to sim related stuff shall we? Peter G (Smiley not missed out unintentionally)
Larry 12 Feb 1999#449830
The Viper 550 (Riva TNT) board I installed last night is faster than the Diamond VooDoo II in Viper, and it also provides a 1024X768 mode that the VooDoo II didn't. VooDoo II - 50fps Viper 550 - 55fps both at 800X600 Viper 550 at 1024 - 51fps BTW... DirectX 6.1 actually killed off about 2fps on my system. -Larry > Rendition/Hercules/Voodoo 2 ONLY, ONLY, ONLY way to speed up frame rate.
Larry 12 Feb 1999#449831
Doh! -Larry > 4) No clutch control on auto gearbox. Why?
Larry 12 Feb 1999#449832
You ARE dead! I suspect that would ruin _anyone's_ immersion :) -Larry > 5) Why when you crash badly do you get the TV snow effect? Ruins any > immersion I feel.
Larry 12 Feb 1999#449833
Agreed (mostly). -Larry > 6) No Force Feedback. I notice the manual sarcastically dismisses current > feedback technology but even with this you can tell when the front end has > begun to slide in MGPRS2 which would be a big addition to GPL.
Phil Hobb 13 Feb 1999#449953
I don't think of it that way....I like to think I've just broken my camera. |o) -- #33 Zandvoort 1.28.56 >You ARE dead! I suspect that would ruin _anyone's_ immersion :) >-Larry >> 5) Why when you crash badly do you get the TV snow effect? Ruins any >> immersion I feel.
Ron Kell 14 Feb 1999#450105
What are you doing here?!!? Somebody back at alt.games.gplegends needs initiation. Now shoo back to your niche! |o) /Ron
Quoted text (7 lines)>I don't think of it that way....I like to think I've just broken my >camera. |o) >-- >#33 >Zandvoort >1.28.56
Phil Hobb 15 Feb 1999#450290
gone.....cya.... ;o) -- #33 Zandvoort 1.28.56 >What are you doing here?!!? >Somebody back at alt.games.gplegends needs initiation. >Now shoo back to your niche! |o)

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy