Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

NASCAR - VGA vs SVGA

59 posts by 34 people · 20 Jul 1997 - 08 Aug 1997

Does a faster PC or VGA mode make you faster?

Don Wilsher claimed that running NASCAR in VGA instead of SVGA was a speed secret and demanded that Papyrus level the playing field between fast and slow PCs. Jim Sokoloff explained that higher frame rates let a good driver go faster and that the field cannot be perfectly levelled, and Eric Busch and many others agreed that frame rate, not resolution, was what mattered. Most posters rejected the idea of slowing down fast machines.

With Jim Sokoloff; Steven Travers (Papyrus)

hardware: PC/graphicsonline racing/leaguesNASCAR Racing 2NASCAR Racing

Automated summary.

Don Wilshe 20 Jul 1997#373671
Drivers: A couple of days ago I posted a note about a SPEED SECRET. That was running in VGA vs SVGA. Well I went to HAWAII - PAPYRUS last night and I tested it. I tested on MICHIGAN and I was able in PRACTICE to run 194's at 89. Did do so well in the race, but that was for other reasons. The thing I noticed right off was: SVGA vs VGA Comparison 1). SVGA setup I ran a 3.70 gear and I could run laps in the 192/193.3 and my corner speed was about 180 with tire squel.. 2). VGA setup was a whole new deal and I was able to drop my gear to 3.50 and I could run laps in the 194's, but the most significant thing was I could run 183's in the corners with no tire squal.. I am sure that I could tweak the setup and get more speed with the new found traction and gearing, but I cant see the DAM SCREEN. Lets hope this is one PAPYRUS can fix for NASCAR 3 or NRO... Otherwise the boys with 486-66's in VGA are gonna SMOKE us.. Don Wilshe, IVGA GRAPHICS RATE and TRACTION and GEARING are all connected. PS. Maybe Jim Sokoloff can explain why this is happening..
BGrauss9 21 Jul 1997#373763
Good info Don, thanks! VGA vs. SVGA is one issue, computer (cpu) speed also has got to have a big effect on lap times. While I have practiced a lot since I had my 486-66, my laptimes are far better on my 166mmx. Hopefully since N2 runs in SVGA this will not be a factor. But what are the effects when someone rusn in 320 graphics mode? If you have any info on this, please post it. Thanks Bryan
Ed Benson 22 Jul 1997#373836
Quoted text (35 lines)> Drivers: > A couple of days ago I posted a note about > a SPEED SECRET. That was running in VGA vs > SVGA. Well I went to HAWAII - PAPYRUS last > night and I tested it. > I tested on MICHIGAN and I was able in PRACTICE > to run 194's at 89. Did do so well in the race, but > that was for other reasons. The thing I noticed > right off was: > SVGA vs VGA Comparison > 1). SVGA setup I ran a 3.70 gear and I could > run laps in the 192/193.3 and my corner > speed was about 180 with tire squel.. > 2). VGA setup was a whole new deal and I was > able to drop my gear to 3.50 and I could > run laps in the 194's, but the most significant > thing was I could run 183's in the corners > with no tire squal.. > I am sure that I could tweak the setup and get more > speed with the new found traction and gearing, but > I cant see the DAM SCREEN. Lets hope this is one > PAPYRUS can fix for NASCAR 3 or NRO... Otherwise > the boys with 486-66's in VGA are gonna SMOKE us.. > Don Wilshe, IVGA > GRAPHICS RATE and TRACTION and GEARING are all connected. > PS. Maybe Jim Sokoloff can explain why this is happening..
The only way to get a true result is to use the scientific method, ie. use the same setup for VGA and SVGA. Then try both modes in practice (off-line), run a lot of laps with each and average you times. You could try it on Hawaii too, but with other traffic you could never get really accurate, isolated information. -- Ed DO NOT SEND JUNK E-MAIL: "By US Code Title 47, Sec.227(a)(2)(B), a computer/modem/printer meets the definition of a telephone fax machine. By Sec.227(b)(1)(C), it is unlawful to send any unsolicited adverti***t to such equipment. By Sec.227(b)(3)(C), a violation of the aforementioned Section is punishable by action to recover actual monetary loss, or $500, whichever is greater, for each violation."
Jim Sokolo 22 Jul 1997#373837
> <Long post about VGA being faster than SVGA snipped> > GRAPHICS RATE and TRACTION and GEARING are all connected. Same as ever: If you get a higher frame rate, a good driver will be able to drive the car faster. Period. On a high end machine, which can run SVGA at a constant 30 fps, there should be no difference between VGA and SVGA. If SVGA yields 20 fps and VGA yields 30fps, VGA will probably be faster due to the higher frame rate. The gearing change you mentioned was either a secondary effect of carrying higher speeds, or you should have been using that gear all along. ---Jim Sokoloff
Don Wilshe 22 Jul 1997#373838
Quoted text (17 lines)> > <Long post about VGA being faster than SVGA snipped> > > GRAPHICS RATE and TRACTION and GEARING are all connected. > Same as ever: If you get a higher frame rate, a good driver will be able > to drive the car faster. Period. > On a high end machine, which can run SVGA at a constant 30 fps, there > should be no difference between VGA and SVGA. If SVGA yields 20 fps and > VGA yields 30fps, VGA will probably be faster due to the higher frame > rate. > The gearing change you mentioned was either a secondary effect of > carrying higher speeds, or you should have been using that gear all > along. > ---Jim Sokoloff
Jim: I really am alittle shocked by your candid answer. For Years Papyrus has been trying to convince us that all DRIVING SYSTEMS were created equal. Now we you have said what we have all know. The NASCAR software doesnt run equally on all systems.. Don Wilshe, IVGA
One question on this matter thats say I have a 166 MMX system with 32 meg of EDO Ram and just a 2 meg tridant pci interlaced video card,which does a great job I must say I run all my games in 640x480 and with the highest graphic settings and in SVGA mode without any choppiness or delay and all my games look awesome(not like a 3d or rendition card) I the max frame rate set at 30 fps and the min set at 30 fps in both Nascar1 and N2 and both games run great no choppines at all and all graphics are turn on except for asphalt and grass texture in N1 because they mess with my eyes,but they are turned on in N2.I get no slow down or choppiness at all.But anyway my question is if I ran in VGA mode with or with out the graphics turned on should I get faster times or will it not make a difference?.Because I also did some testing on Hawaii one night I had all the graphics but Asphalt and grass turned but ran th egame on hawaii in VGA mode.I didnot see any differnce in my laptimes,or did I see where I needed to change my setups for running in VGA instead of SVGA.The only track I did run a faster laptimes at was Bristol I did a couple 135's in prac. but that could have just been that I was just on and ran a couple of almost perfect laps because I do run mid to high 134's anyway.But for the other tarcks I seen no differnce except for one thing if anything it slowed me down because I could tell when to cut for the turns until I was right at where I needed to turn,I couldn't see anything until I was right on top of it:).So will it make a differnce on my system or not? GT86 Robert Platts PS I am just wondering I doubt I will ever run in VGA again because I have always run in SVGA even with my old P 100 16 meg ram 1 meg video card system :),plus like I said I couldn't see ***:) > > > <Long post about VGA being faster than SVGA snipped> > > > GRAPHICS RATE and TRACTION and GEARING are all connected. > > Same as ever: If you get a higher frame rate, a good driver will be able
Quoted text (21 lines)> > to drive the car faster. Period. > > On a high end machine, which can run SVGA at a constant 30 fps, there > > should be no difference between VGA and SVGA. If SVGA yields 20 fps and > > VGA yields 30fps, VGA will probably be faster due to the higher frame > > rate. > > The gearing change you mentioned was either a secondary effect of > > carrying higher speeds, or you should have been using that gear all > > along. > > ---Jim Sokoloff > Jim: > I really am alittle shocked by your candid answer. For Years Papyrus > has been trying to convince us that all DRIVING SYSTEMS were created > equal. Now we you have said what we have all know. The NASCAR > software doesnt run equally on all systems.. > Don Wilshe, IVGA
Eric Busch 23 Jul 1997#373927
Don, quit trying to look for *** theories here. No one has ever denied that a faster machine (one with a higher framerate) will allow for higher speeds. It's really a simple fact that on such a machine the driver will be able to drive a much smoother line. Why is this such a surprise to you? --
Mike 23 Jul 1997#373928
Quoted text (18 lines)>> > > <Long post about VGA being faster than SVGA snipped> >> > > GRAPHICS RATE and TRACTION and GEARING are all connected. >> > Same as ever: If you get a higher frame rate, a good driver will be >able >> > to drive the car faster. Period. >> > On a high end machine, which can run SVGA at a constant 30 fps, there >> > should be no difference between VGA and SVGA. If SVGA yields 20 fps and >> > VGA yields 30fps, VGA will probably be faster due to the higher frame >> > rate. >> > The gearing change you mentioned was either a secondary effect of >> > carrying higher speeds, or you should have been using that gear all >> > along. >> > ---Jim Sokoloff
The records stand for themselves,.....look at the Fastlaps for Nascar1. When they first started, I ran a 486 DX 66, 8megs, and a joystick. At the time, I ran in SVGA, FM sound, and barely anything on but the pavement. I was ranked in the top 25 on the speedways for a long time. Then came the Pentiums (that we all could afford), the wheel/pedal combos, and 2meg and up video cards. My ranking went down quick, there was no way to keep up with my machine at the time. So I upgraded a bit. Threw in a 586 133 cpu, a 16meg stick, and a 2 meg video card. I managed to move up again. But technology upped the ante again. What I'm getting to is this, take the same racer, with the same setup, run a set of consistent laps, on different machines with different controllers, and you'll get drastically different results. My argument with Don last year was about starting a "joystick" league because the T2 guys we're sweeping most of the series. The response was that there were a few guys that held Fastlap records with a stick, therefore no need for a new series. Anyway,......I'm ranting on now, sorry. Point is,.....setups, gearing and THE MACHINE = speed. Papyrus can't seriuosly belive otherwise. Mike Lapsley IVGA #2198 Lifes too short,....don't fold your underwear!
Tony Joh 23 Jul 1997#373930
Quoted text (24 lines)>> > <Long post about VGA being faster than SVGA snipped> >> > GRAPHICS RATE and TRACTION and GEARING are all connected. >> Same as ever: If you get a higher frame rate, a good driver will be able >> to drive the car faster. Period. >> On a high end machine, which can run SVGA at a constant 30 fps, there >> should be no difference between VGA and SVGA. If SVGA yields 20 fps and >> VGA yields 30fps, VGA will probably be faster due to the higher frame >> rate. >> The gearing change you mentioned was either a secondary effect of >> carrying higher speeds, or you should have been using that gear all >> along. >> ---Jim Sokoloff >Jim: >I really am alittle shocked by your candid answer. For Years Papyrus >has been trying to convince us that all DRIVING SYSTEMS were created >equal. Now we you have said what we have all know. The NASCAR >software doesnt run equally on all systems..
Whoa now, Hoss... that's not what Jim was saying at all. Read through it again and this time pay close attention to the first paragraph. "A good driver will be able to drive the car faster." That doesn't mean the SOFTWARE gives him an advantage -- it means that thanks to the faster frame rate, smoother transitions between car states, etc., that a driver can be more consistent, more smooth, and more fluid in his driving than a person whose display is more choppy and there is more gap time between frames. -- Papyrus Design Group, Inc. The views expressed in this message are mine entirely and do not represent Papyrus or Sierra in any official capacity.
Don Wilshe 23 Jul 1997#373931
Quoted text (16 lines)> Don, quit trying to look for *** theories here. No one has ever > denied that a faster machine (one with a higher framerate) will allow for > higher speeds. It's really a simple fact that on such a machine the driver > will be able to drive a much smoother line. Why is this such a surprise to > you? > -- > >I really am alittle shocked by your candid answer. For Years Papyrus > >has been trying to convince us that all DRIVING SYSTEMS were created > >equal. Now we you have said what we have all know. The NASCAR > >software doesnt run equally on all systems..
Eric: Dont try and twist this into some sort of a *** thoery. Let me make it simple. Since Day 1 Papyrus has stated to all of us that had different hardware configurations that we would all be equal and have a LEVEL PLAYING FIELD. It is quite clear now based on Jim Sokoloff statement and even yours that the person with the BEST HARDWARE COMBINATION could be the fastest. I think we need more explanation so we know what is the best hardware to buy. What CPU, Graphics Card, Control Devices and GAMECARD yeild the fastest results. I would like to know for once if I get smoked: 1). Was it the driver 2). Was it the hardware 3). Or Both And more importantly what I can do to improve my speed. At Least now we are seeing it said that FRAME RATES and faster computers can be the FASTEST. Does that mean that the people with all the MONEY are going to win the RACES.. Why Cant this game LEVEL THE PLAYING FIELD Don Wilshe
Don Wilshe 23 Jul 1997#373932
Quoted text (38 lines)> >> > <Long post about VGA being faster than SVGA snipped> > >> > GRAPHICS RATE and TRACTION and GEARING are all connected. > >> Same as ever: If you get a higher frame rate, a good driver will be able > >> to drive the car faster. Period. > >> On a high end machine, which can run SVGA at a constant 30 fps, there > >> should be no difference between VGA and SVGA. If SVGA yields 20 fps and > >> VGA yields 30fps, VGA will probably be faster due to the higher frame > >> rate. > >> The gearing change you mentioned was either a secondary effect of > >> carrying higher speeds, or you should have been using that gear all > >> along. > >> ---Jim Sokoloff > >Jim: > >I really am alittle shocked by your candid answer. For Years Papyrus > >has been trying to convince us that all DRIVING SYSTEMS were created > >equal. Now we you have said what we have all know. The NASCAR > >software doesnt run equally on all systems.. > Whoa now, Hoss... that's not what Jim was saying at all. Read through > it again and this time pay close attention to the first paragraph. "A > good driver will be able to drive the car faster." That doesn't mean > the SOFTWARE gives him an advantage -- it means that thanks to the > faster frame rate, smoother transitions between car states, etc., that > a driver can be more consistent, more smooth, and more fluid in his > driving than a person whose display is more choppy and there is more > gap time between frames. > -- > Papyrus Design Group, Inc. > The views expressed in this message are mine entirely > and do not represent Papyrus or Sierra in any official capacity.
Tony: I standby what I said. Better Hardware gives you a faster car. Why Cant you just say it. Why cant you just say that PENTIUMS are FASTER than 486's. Why cant you say that VGA is faster than SVGA.. Why cant you say that JOYSTICKS are faster than WHEELS. All we want to do is compete against each other fairly.. Lets keep it simple.. Don Wilshe, IVGA
Don Wilshe 23 Jul 1997#373933
Quoted text (33 lines)> >> > <Long post about VGA being faster than SVGA snipped> > >> > GRAPHICS RATE and TRACTION and GEARING are all connected. > >> Same as ever: If you get a higher frame rate, a good driver will be able > >> to drive the car faster. Period. > >> On a high end machine, which can run SVGA at a constant 30 fps, there > >> should be no difference between VGA and SVGA. If SVGA yields 20 fps and > >> VGA yields 30fps, VGA will probably be faster due to the higher frame > >> rate. > >> The gearing change you mentioned was either a secondary effect of > >> carrying higher speeds, or you should have been using that gear all > >> along. > >> ---Jim Sokoloff > >Jim: > >I really am alittle shocked by your candid answer. For Years Papyrus > >has been trying to convince us that all DRIVING SYSTEMS were created > >equal. Now we you have said what we have all know. The NASCAR > >software doesnt run equally on all systems.. > Whoa now, Hoss... that's not what Jim was saying at all. Read through > it again and this time pay close attention to the first paragraph. "A > good driver will be able to drive the car faster." That doesn't mean > the SOFTWARE gives him an advantage -- it means that thanks to the > faster frame rate, smoother transitions between car states, etc., that > a driver can be more consistent, more smooth, and more fluid in his > driving than a person whose display is more choppy and there is more > gap time between frames.
Tony: You couldnt of said it better. Better HARDWARE is FASTER TIMES. But its still the softwares responsibility to even the field. Let me explain. When your software starts up its synchronizes the GRAPHICS RATE and the CONTROL DEVICE you have to make the FRAME RATES the same and you cant give some people advanatages. It is the responsibility of PAPYRUS to slow down the FASTER machines and FRAME RATES to be the same for all of us. Whether as advertised on your SOFTWARE BOXES you have a 486-66 or a Pentium 300.. Don Wilshe Nice Try.... > Papyrus Design Group, Inc. > The views expressed in this message are mine entirely > and do not represent Papyrus or Sierra in any official capacity.
Nice Pant 23 Jul 1997#373934
> At Least now we are seeing it said that FRAME RATES and > faster computers can be the FASTEST. Does that mean > that the people with all the MONEY are going to win > the RACES.. Why Cant this game LEVEL THE PLAYING FIELD Welcome to the world of auto racing, Don. Of course, I've seen plenty of high-dollar real-life racing teams with drivers who couldn't drive worth a***, and guys who hardly had two nickels to rub together run fantastically in equipment that in lesser hands would be laps down. Good drivers can overcome less-than-optimal equipment. Of course if everyone knew and accepted this, the IVGA would be out of business. Then what would you do with all your CAPITAL LETTERS? Smileys for the humor-impaired: ;) ;) -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=- Alan J. Claffie PARSIMONIOUS Internet Grand National aclaffie 'at' bgnn.com RACING #93 Buick Riviera Southern New England Correspondent for "The Racin' Paper" WWW.BGNN.COM - NASCAR's Busch North Series on the Internet --- SPAMbot bait below:
Eric Busch 23 Jul 1997#373935
For two drivers of exactly equal skill the one with the faster system will most likely be able to run faster laps... BIG DEAL. If you don't like this, then turn down your detail levels or, God forbid, run in VGA. There is nothing that can be done on Papyrus' part to make up for those people with lesser systems. The same holds true with just about every game I've ever played, framerate > smooth graphics > more easy to control > more precise movements > faster speeds. --
Eric Busch 23 Jul 1997#373936
Because it's not that easy. That 486 could have some incredible pimp-daddy video card and be able to run the game at a very fast framerate (albeit probably in VGA). The Pentium could have some leftover 4 year old ISA card with an owner who insists on running SVGA with full details even though it looks like a slideshow. In a drastic case like this, the 486 driver would the advantage. If you can show that at the same framerate VGA is faster than then SVGA on the same system, then we could have a potential problem. I'm not sure you could test it since a: Nascar2 doesnt have a reliable way to determine frame rates and b: I don't know if you could get SVGA to run at VGA speeds (perhaps will a lot of details turned off you could run at similar speeds). --
Don Wilshe 23 Jul 1997#373937
Quoted text (23 lines)> Because it's not that easy. That 486 could have some incredible pimp-daddy > video card and be able to run the game at a very fast framerate (albeit > probably in VGA). The Pentium could have some leftover 4 year old ISA card > with an owner who insists on running SVGA with full details even though it > looks like a slideshow. In a drastic case like this, the 486 driver would > the advantage. > If you can show that at the same framerate VGA is faster than then SVGA on > the same system, then we could have a potential problem. I'm not sure you > could test it since a: Nascar2 doesnt have a reliable way to determine frame > rates and b: I don't know if you could get SVGA to run at VGA speeds > (perhaps will a lot of details turned off you could run at similar speeds). > -- > >I standby what I said. Better Hardware gives you a faster car. > >Why Cant you just say it. Why cant you just say that PENTIUMS > >are FASTER than 486's. Why cant you say that VGA is faster > >than SVGA..
Eric: Thanks for input.. BottomLine... SPEED COST!!!! Don
MCritche 23 Jul 1997#373938
With all due respect, I think the suggestion that " it is the responsibility of PAPYRUS to slow down the FASTER machines and FRAME RATES to be the same for all of us" is rediculous. How would you like it if your brand new Pentium II machine w/Rendtion card, capable of 40 fps, was "forced" to run at at a 15 fps because you're driving against someone on a 486 with a 1 meg video card? How could you effectively create setups knowing that every race you'll be running at a different frame rate determined by the least common denominator of the machines your running against? The playing field in NASCAR is not fair... just look at the real teams whining about Ford giving support to only a few teams, or the constant compaints about rule changes. Why should we expect the simulation to be any different? Real NASCAR teams with money have better cars, and teams in the NROS with better equipment have an advantage. It is a fact of racing. If you race for fun like I do, I accept the fact that others who invest the money in faster systems will have an advantage. More power to them. If you take your racing seriously, then you have to pay the price. It's not unlike any other hobby... the more serious you are, the more money you have to spend to be "elite". I play golf, but I dont force the guys I play with to use the same set of crappy clubs that I have. Getting PAPYRUS to change the software is not the answer. Well, enough of my rambling....
ccorpor 23 Jul 1997#373939
Well I have it***ed. I use the same hardware and every body has to use Rendition version -4. If someboy else brings their hardware then they have to still use SVGA min. if no Rendition. Nobody can use vga advantage or not. I won't allow looking at such a pitiful picture at my place! Maybe for NRO they should make you have to race in a specific video mode. That should clear up this crazy matter. Q.B.M.
Jody Huggin 23 Jul 1997#373940
Quoted text (12 lines)> 1). Was it the driver > 2). Was it the hardware > 3). Or Both > And more importantly what I can do to improve my speed. > At Least now we are seeing it said that FRAME RATES and > faster computers can be the FASTEST. Does that mean > that the people with all the MONEY are going to win > the RACES.. Why Cant this game LEVEL THE PLAYING FIELD > Don Wilshe
Hey Don, why don't you just buy a faster computer if it bothers you that mutch? I started out on a 486/33 with N1, upgraded to a 486/100, then a 486/pentium83 overdrive chip, Then along came N2 and I stopped eating and paying the bills for a while so I could get a P166 with a Rendition card. Don't whine, either buy the hardware to run the game, or turn your detail down to match your system. If you can maintain 30fps then you should not be at a disadvantage. Computer *** is an inherantly expensive hobby. All my comments should be taken in fun! -Jody- http:\\www.geocities.com\~jodys_pit_stop\
myke 23 Jul 1997#373941
Quoted text (26 lines)> > > <Long post about VGA being faster than SVGA snipped> > > > GRAPHICS RATE and TRACTION and GEARING are all connected. > > Same as ever: If you get a higher frame rate, a good driver will be able > > to drive the car faster. Period. > > On a high end machine, which can run SVGA at a constant 30 fps, there > > should be no difference between VGA and SVGA. If SVGA yields 20 fps and > > VGA yields 30fps, VGA will probably be faster due to the higher frame > > rate. > > The gearing change you mentioned was either a secondary effect of > > carrying higher speeds, or you should have been using that gear all > > along. > > ---Jim Sokoloff > Jim: > I really am alittle shocked by your candid answer. For Years Papyrus > has been trying to convince us that all DRIVING SYSTEMS were created > equal. Now we you have said what we have all know. The NASCAR > software doesnt run equally on all systems.. > Don Wilshe, IVGA
Don, Come on you know better than that. Put the program on a 386/40. It's a slide show. However, it is theoriticaly possible to still obtain the same speeds. I make this comment with a couple assumptions. The sampling/computation (reading joystick/calculating car positions) is at a fixed rate which requires only a small amount of processing power. The display rate is unrelated to the computation rate other than it should have the same maximum. If a 486/66 can sample and compute at fixed rate, but only display 10 frames per second, the driver will be slower because they can't react to things they can't see. Not because the computations are slower but the frame rate is slower. I doubt there is any difference between your speeds if you change from a P166 with rendition to a P200 with rendition leaving EVERYTHING else the same. Your Visual Frame Rate is EVERYTHING until you can obtain the maximum. Then you should be on even ground. (In that department) More expensive wheels may have a higher degree of stability, and consitantcy. (I.E. turning the wheel 45 degrees left always gives you the same reading with lower tolerances) This could effect your speed. You need to consider EVERY part of the system before assigning blame on any one part. I however keep getting stuck on one part (the driver). mykey
Mike 23 Jul 1997#373942
Joysticks faster than wheels? Maybe if the joystick user has pedals too. My biggest problem has always been gas/brake factor on sticks,.....it's either all on or all off, no increments. Mike Lifes too short,....don't fold your underwear!
Jim Sokolo 23 Jul 1997#373943
> Nobody can use vga advantage or not. I won't allow looking at such a pitiful > picture at my place! Maybe for NRO they should make you have to race in a > specific video mode. That should clear up this crazy matter. It won't clear anything up. It's not VGA vs SVGA that changes the theoretical performance of an optimal human, but rather higher frame rate vs lower frame rate... ---Jim
Goy Larsen 23 Jul 1997#373944
lot`s of stuff snipped Don I don`t know if what you said about Papyrus stating from day one.... and so on, is true, I`ll take your word for it, but what I read into Jim Sokoloffs statement, if you don`t read his answer word for word but sum it up instead is; if you turn down the detail so you get a smooth framerate it doesn`t matter what kind of machine you have. As for the controls, of course you can drive better with a steering wheel than with a keyboard, thats why Opel/GM in all their wisdom put one in my car, because you get more feel and precission (is that the correct way to spell that), and you can drive more smoothly (there`s that word again). Gamecard, if you are among those that have problems with drifting contols, of course you are going to benefit from a gamecard, you can`t drive smoothly (again :-)) unless you have precise control of your car. In my case I know it`s the driver, and I can live with that as long as he/she is not cheating. It sure looks as if you`re holding a grudge against Papyrus, because you jump at every little chance you get to pick on them, and this from a guy who had, in my (not humble at all) opinion, very vage opinons about cheating some time ago. I can`t quote them because I don`know how to do a search for those things, so this is from memory, but I sure got the impression that you ment it was only cheating if you got caught, so where is the LEVEL PLAYING FIELD then. As a member of IVGA, 3126 in case you were wondering, I would rather you spend the time you are using hacking at Papyrus to do something constructive, because as president of IVGA, you represent over 2800 members, as it says on the IVGA homepage, whether you like it or not. The above statement is not meant as a flame or personal attack, even if it may look like it :-) And this is where I step down from my soapbox Beers and cheers Goy
Jim Sokolo 23 Jul 1997#373945
> You couldnt of said it better. Better HARDWARE is FASTER TIMES. No. It's the software's responsibility to not tilt the playing field, but it's an impossibility to completely level the field as you desire (read on). I'm listening, but disagreeing Presumably it does this by limiting the speed of all machines but the slowest. That sounds fair to me (sarcasm). Ever played multiplayer descent or other turn-based MP games? They suck when a slow machine joins in... So, they're to synchronize the CONTROL DEVICE? Suddenly my T2 will morph into a Gravis GamePad, because that's the best someone else has? This logic amounts to: let's degrade the performance of all but the slowest computer so that everyone gets the same frame rate... While the socialistic aspect of it might appeal to some, it seems obviously inefficient for my P5-90 (that's the fastest machine I personally own) to sit busy-looping just because someone in my race is running an old 486-33 with an ISA video card. Similarly, if I were to join a race with someone with a modern machine, their machine would suddenly have to slow down to allow me to keep up. That amounts to a needless wastage of resources in my book. You can't make the playing field perfectly level in every respect. Some people have bigger monitors, better speakers, wheels, pedals, less fingerprints/glare on their screen, no SO, pets, kids at home to interrupt them, more time in their life to practice, etc. Should Papyrus attempt to simulate all of these differences and somehow degrade everyone's game so that no one has a theoretical advantage? No. The differences in lap time are all about fine car control. If you've set up a machine that gets 1 frame every 10 seconds, how fast do you think you could drive? Then double it, and keep doubling it. You'll get faster each time, up to a point, then the improvements will really drop off. Fact is: Papyrus is developing a multiplayer SIMULATION of driving a Winston Cup stockcar in a race. This simulation is best acheived with the highest framerate possible. Degrading the performance of someone's P-2-200 just because someone else in the race has a 486-66 is the antithesis of that goal. I don't think Papyrus has ever claimed that a higher frame rate doesn't give better car control, which can lead to a better lap time. What they've claimed, which is 100% true, is that a better lap time is a result of better driving, not of faster hardware. (Doubling the CPU power will not halve the lap time. In fact, if a driver sucks, it probably won't change the lap time at all...) ---Jim Sokoloff Speed costs money; how fast do you want to go?
Joe McGinn 23 Jul 1997#373946
>people advanatages. It is the responsibility of PAPYRUS to slow down >the FASTER machines and FRAME RATES to be the same for all of us. ROF,L! I've seen some true gems on these forums but I think the above may actually be the stupidest statement I have ever read on the net. And that's saying a lot, there's a lot of competition on the net, you should be proud of yourself! Joe
> Tony: > You couldnt of said it better. Better HARDWARE is FASTER TIMES. But > its No Don...Faster Framerates mean better Response Time. Hey, it's up to the individual to get the most out of their hardware configuration. Just because someone owns a fast Pentium doesn't mean they know diddly about maximizing it's performance. This from the self proclaimed "President" of the IVGA? What does that say about the credibility of your organization? It seems like you're on another one of your witch hunts to me...could it be due to the fact that you're trying to release your own racing game, so you feel obligated to do a little Papyrus bashing? -- God Bless, Steve (remove the <remove this> from my address when replying via e-mail)
Dana Baile 23 Jul 1997#373948
Quoted text (16 lines)> Tony: > You couldnt of said it better. Better HARDWARE is FASTER TIMES. But > its > still the softwares responsibility to even the field. Let me explain. > When > your software starts up its synchronizes the GRAPHICS RATE and the > CONTROL > DEVICE you have to make the FRAME RATES the same and you cant give some > people advanatages. It is the responsibility of PAPYRUS to slow down > the FASTER machines and FRAME RATES to be the same for all of us. > Whether > as advertised on your SOFTWARE BOXES you have a 486-66 or a Pentium > 300.. > Don Wilshe
By limiting the frame-rate in software to a maximum of 30fps Papy has in fact capped the maximum available performance. You can race on a 486 if you want to in VGA but I will stick with my P166MMX/Rendition system which runs 30fps in all but heavy traffic. The minute advantages provided by the faster systems are only meaningful for qualifying times and so called lap records. All that goes out the window when the real racing begins. Since the P166MMX is effectively the entry level system today and a Rendition card is available for $150 from two different companies it is my opinion that a competitive system is available to everyone. I don't care about the 486 owners anymore and if Papyrus doesn't then that is fine with me. I think this discussion would be more productive if everyone gave insight on what they believe is the best hardware for racing so others don't go wasting their hard earned money. I will start the ball rolling. I use P166MMX on Supermicro P5MMA TX based motherboard. This board only supports a maximum 75mhz system bus which I use to overclock the processor to 187mhz. I feel the ultimate situation would be a P233MMX on a 83mhz system bus and 250mhz processor speed. I'm not even sure that the P233MMX will work at that speed, input would be appreciated. Since the faster system bus improves memory performance and video performance this is IMO the best way to go. PPro systems that I have seen have lousy DMA performance and few options for bus overclocking. Though I haven't tested any P2 systems I assume they have the same DMA problems because they currently use the same PPro chipset(Natoma/440FX). I'm sure you could add much in regards to PPro/P2 performance here Don. I use SDRAM mainly because of its ability to run the higher system bus speeds reliably. As far as video goes a Rendition based card is a given. The Canopus Total3D and the new Miro card both use a slightly overclocked version of the Verite chip so they should give a marginally better performance. I have read that the Sierra card is now using the same chip, but I haven't been able to verify this. A new Rendition card should be available within the next 2 months or so which may greatly improve the graphics potential. It is not known at this time how this new chipset will effect existing software so this may or may not be an improvement for Nascar2. I'm keeping my fingers crossed on that. I use a Soundblaster AWE64 which I replaced an old AWE32 with. I was pleasantly surprised to find it all but eliminated the stutter which I sometimes got when driving by a pit full of rumbling cars. Even though the card is plug and play it was easy to disable the game port so I could use a Thrustmaster ACM gamecard. Others may disagree but I find the controller input is more precise and stable with the ACM gamecard. I try to adjust the card so the max calibration numbers are in the 200-250 range. I believe that this makes the car more stable. My wheel setup is a Thrustmaster GP1 with T2 pedals which are modified so that the two pedals work on separate axis on joystick 2. I feel that this helps to keep me from overshooting turns while driving two footed. It takes some getting used to but it may keep you from running people over on the short tracks. Unfortunately N1/N2 doesn't properly model brake/throttle input or this could be a tremendous advantage. I should have probably kept it to myself but what the hell. I don't think a SCSI subsystem would make a difference because you don't really access any drives during gameplay. I would recommend more memory before trying SCSI, at least the menus run faster with 64meg. The only other thing I would recommend is that you eliminate anything running in the background that you can when running under windows. I also recommend running in dos when practicing to eliminate overhead from windows. We can now entertain offerings from the peanut gallery. Dana Bailes
Quoted text (18 lines)>For two drivers of exactly equal skill the one with the faster system will >most likely be able to run faster laps... BIG DEAL. If you don't like this, >then turn down your detail levels or, God forbid, run in VGA. There is >nothing that can be done on Papyrus' part to make up for those people with >lesser systems. The same holds true with just about every game I've ever >played, framerate > smooth graphics > more easy to control > more precise >movements > faster speeds. >-- >>At Least now we are seeing it said that FRAME RATES and >>faster computers can be the FASTEST. Does that mean >>that the people with all the MONEY are going to win >>the RACES.. Why Cant this game LEVEL THE PLAYING FIELD
Thank you, Eric. Steve
maxwel 24 Jul 1997#374025
> > > <Long post about VGA being faster than SVGA snipped> > > > GRAPHICS RATE and TRACTION and GEARING are all connected. > > Same as ever: If you get a higher frame rate, a good driver will be able
Quoted text (21 lines)> > to drive the car faster. Period. > > On a high end machine, which can run SVGA at a constant 30 fps, there > > should be no difference between VGA and SVGA. If SVGA yields 20 fps and > > VGA yields 30fps, VGA will probably be faster due to the higher frame > > rate. > > The gearing change you mentioned was either a secondary effect of > > carrying higher speeds, or you should have been using that gear all > > along. > > ---Jim Sokoloff > Jim: > I really am alittle shocked by your candid answer. For Years Papyrus > has been trying to convince us that all DRIVING SYSTEMS were created > equal. Now we you have said what we have all know. The NASCAR > software doesnt run equally on all systems.. > Don Wilshe, IVGA
don do me a favor. take your car out on to the local highway, get it up to about 70 in rush hour traffic. then blink your eyes repeatedly. this is what it feals like to drive N1 on a slower mach. its pretty tough to keep the car going straight. the slower the mach the slower your eyes open and close. its that simple. the car in fact is still going 70 but you just cant control it because your eyes are closed to much. much like the frame rate on a slower mach. maxwell
Amen! Slightly off topic (but germane nonetheless), this is one of the problems that crippled Apple for so long -- writing OSs and forcing developers to write software for "legacy" systems. It's pretty hard to write a good (sophisticated and fast) program when you have to make it run on a Mac Classic. Same deal with PCs -- I'm sure there are people around trying to squeeze the last 2 cents worth out of their investment in a 286 10 years ago. It may be made to sound elitist, but if your hardware isn't up to current minimal standards -- which in the PC world means a Pentium 166, 32 Mb RAM, and a decent graphics card at the least -- then why should you expect to be able to run the latest software? In this context it's like complaining that you're not competitive in Indy Cars when you're driving a Watson roadster and the rest of the pack is in the latest Reynard. Bart Brown
Mike 24 Jul 1997#374027
> Maybe they (Whoever actually runs the multiplayer Nascar system) >should introduce a class-system based on computer performance. They >could break it down into 486's, "artificial" Pentiums, Pentium MMX's, >etc. My thoughts exactly! Set up leagues by CPU speed,.....evryone will have a more level playing field, not totally level but close enough. You can still take an Overdrive/Enhanced 486 x100+ and run with the low end Pentiums, I do it! As I remember,.....there was a flight/war sim online for awhile in beta test called Air Warrior. When they went into league format, they set up an evaluation prog that would tell them what you were running, and if it was fast enough for their sim. I don't think that would be too much of a hassle for Papyrus. It would keep the fast "frameraters" from totally dominating a one league system as they do now on Hawaii. And it would cut down on the complaints,....are ya listening Papy?? Ya can't say it's gonna cost ya money, cause what brings more returns, a full league with happy comoetitors that want to STAY; or a one leauge system with a large turnover ratio? Do the math Papyrus! (soap box mode off,...flame retardent gear on) Mike Lifes too short,....don't fold your underwear!
Don, When Ayrton Senna driving a McLaren-Honda smoked past the other F1 drivers, don't you think they'd like to know was it his chassis, was it the Honda power or was he actually better? Sorry to say, but that's life. If you enter NASCAR with a Chevy Nova and $100 you'd better believe you're gonna be last - why is Hawaii any different? If you're the man with the answers perhaps you'd like to suggest what Papyrus could do about that? Limit the software so that it only does 12fps whether it's run on a PII or a 386? No-one with higher than a 486 can enter? While you're at it, remember to describe how this would be policed since that is your main area of concern. I'm looking forward to your suggestions. If you can't come up with any suggestions from the IVGA's membership how are poor old Papyrus gonna do it with the few folks that they have? Cheers! John
Maybe they (Whoever actually runs the multiplayer Nascar system) should introduce a class-system based on computer performance. They could break it down into 486's, "artificial" Pentiums, Pentium MMX's, etc. As far as frame rates slwoing down someone's reaction time, I guess that's why I average about one wreck per every 15 laps! Every damn time I get into a pack, my computer (486-33 ISA) starts skipping frames. I should ask though, is the T2 really that superior to even the Grand Prix 1? I would think the GP1 should definitely hold its weight. I realize this post my seem incongruent, but I really didn't want to post everyone else's post AGAIN. Wading through pages of repeated text is almost hypnotic. Jp
Quoted text (16 lines)>You couldnt of said it better. Better HARDWARE is FASTER TIMES. But >its >still the softwares responsibility to even the field. Let me explain. >When >your software starts up its synchronizes the GRAPHICS RATE and the >CONTROL >DEVICE you have to make the FRAME RATES the same and you cant give some >people advanatages. It is the responsibility of PAPYRUS to slow down >the FASTER machines and FRAME RATES to be the same for all of us. >Whether >as advertised on your SOFTWARE BOXES you have a 486-66 or a Pentium >300.. >Don Wilshe >Nice Try....
Don, if you want a "level playing field" with equal frame rates, get into a locked system, like a Playstation. One of the great things about Papyrus and Nascar Racing is the fact that they built into it room for growth. When I first got NASCAR Racing, I had a 486 DX2-66, now I have a Pentium. I drive basically the same laptimes (given room for improvement due to experience). What's most important is that Papyrus even *supports* a 486! In other words, count your blessings. They could just check for non-pentium and run an exit() routine on you :)
Quoted text (88 lines)> > Tony: > > You couldnt of said it better. Better HARDWARE is FASTER TIMES. But > > its > > still the softwares responsibility to even the field. Let me explain. > > When > > your software starts up its synchronizes the GRAPHICS RATE and the > > CONTROL > > DEVICE you have to make the FRAME RATES the same and you cant give some > > people advanatages. It is the responsibility of PAPYRUS to slow down > > the FASTER machines and FRAME RATES to be the same for all of us. > > Whether > > as advertised on your SOFTWARE BOXES you have a 486-66 or a Pentium > > 300.. > > Don Wilshe > By limiting the frame-rate in software to a maximum of 30fps Papy has in > fact capped the maximum available performance. You can race on a 486 if > you want to in VGA but I will stick with my P166MMX/Rendition system > which runs 30fps in all but heavy traffic. The minute advantages > provided by the faster systems are only meaningful for qualifying times > and so called lap records. All that goes out the window when the real > racing begins. Since the P166MMX is effectively the entry level system > today and a Rendition card is available for $150 from two different > companies it is my opinion that a competitive system is available to > everyone. I don't care about the 486 owners anymore and if Papyrus > doesn't then that is fine with me. > I think this discussion would be more productive if everyone gave > insight on what they believe is the best hardware for racing so others > don't go wasting their hard earned money. I will start the ball > rolling. > I use P166MMX on Supermicro P5MMA TX based motherboard. This board only > supports a maximum 75mhz system bus which I use to overclock the > processor to 187mhz. I feel the ultimate situation would be a P233MMX > on a 83mhz system bus and 250mhz processor speed. I'm not even sure > that the P233MMX will work at that speed, input would be appreciated. > Since the faster system bus improves memory performance and video > performance this is IMO the best way to go. PPro systems that I have > seen have lousy DMA performance and few options for bus overclocking. > Though I haven't tested any P2 systems I assume they have the same DMA > problems because they currently use the same PPro > chipset(Natoma/440FX). I'm sure you could add much in regards to > PPro/P2 performance here Don. I use SDRAM mainly because of its ability > to run the higher system bus speeds reliably. > As far as video goes a Rendition based card is a given. The Canopus > Total3D and the new Miro card both use a slightly overclocked version of > the Verite chip so they should give a marginally better performance. I > have read that the Sierra card is now using the same chip, but I haven't > been able to verify this. A new Rendition card should be available > within the next 2 months or so which may greatly improve the graphics > potential. It is not known at this time how this new chipset will > effect existing software so this may or may not be an improvement for > Nascar2. I'm keeping my fingers crossed on that. > I use a Soundblaster AWE64 which I replaced an old AWE32 with. I was > pleasantly surprised to find it all but eliminated the stutter which I > sometimes got when driving by a pit full of rumbling cars. Even though > the card is plug and play it was easy to disable the game port so I > could use a Thrustmaster ACM gamecard. > Others may disagree but I find the controller input is more precise and > stable with the ACM gamecard. I try to adjust the card so the max > calibration numbers are in the 200-250 range. I believe that this makes > the car more stable. > My wheel setup is a Thrustmaster GP1 with T2 pedals which are modified > so that the two pedals work on separate axis on joystick 2. I feel that > this helps to keep me from overshooting turns while driving two footed. > It takes some getting used to but it may keep you from running people > over on the short tracks. Unfortunately N1/N2 doesn't properly model > brake/throttle input or this could be a tremendous advantage. I should > have probably kept it to myself but what the hell. > I don't think a SCSI subsystem would make a difference because you don't > really access any drives during gameplay. I would recommend more memory > before trying SCSI, at least the menus run faster with 64meg. The only > other thing I would recommend is that you eliminate anything running in > the background that you can when running under windows. I also > recommend running in dos when practicing to eliminate overhead from > windows. > We can now entertain offerings from the peanut gallery. > Dana Bailes
Dana , Hay man how are u doing ?? Do you still run on hawaii ?? Mike Blackstock Mike12 = Hawaii
Neil Yeatma 24 Jul 1997#374033
Quoted text (22 lines)> > Maybe they (Whoever actually runs the multiplayer Nascar system) > >should introduce a class-system based on computer performance. They > >could break it down into 486's, "artificial" Pentiums, Pentium MMX's, > >etc. > My thoughts exactly! Set up leagues by CPU speed,.....evryone will > have a more level playing field, not totally level but close enough. > You can still take an Overdrive/Enhanced 486 x100+ and run with the > low end Pentiums, I do it! > As I remember,.....there was a flight/war sim online for awhile in > beta test called Air Warrior. When they went into league format, they > set up an evaluation prog that would tell them what you were running, > and if it was fast enough for their sim. I don't think that would be > too much of a hassle for Papyrus. It would keep the fast "frameraters" > from totally dominating a one league system as they do now on Hawaii. > And it would cut down on the complaints,....are ya listening Papy?? Ya > can't say it's gonna cost ya money, cause what brings more returns, a > full league with happy comoetitors that want to STAY; or a one leauge > system with a large turnover ratio? Do the math Papyrus! > (soap box mode off,...flame retardent gear on)
What Don brought up is not really much different than what happens in Quake...those in the know are aware that framerate is everything, and they either run GLQuake or turn down the resolution to get more speed. For league play, rather than fragment your players by CPU, I think you'd be better off just advertising the fact that framerate is king, and if you're not getting 20+ fps (or insert what you consider to be a minimum fps), then turn down the detail until you do. And Don was nice enough to point out what we already know: That throwing a lot of money into a PC will enhance your *** experience. Neil -- Neil Yeatman Ajax, Ontario, CANADA My REAL email address is: ICQ# 1315725
Quoted text (25 lines)> > Maybe they (Whoever actually runs the multiplayer Nascar system) > >should introduce a class-system based on computer performance. They > >could break it down into 486's, "artificial" Pentiums, Pentium MMX's, > >etc. > My thoughts exactly! Set up leagues by CPU speed,.....evryone will > have a more level playing field, not totally level but close enough. > You can still take an Overdrive/Enhanced 486 x100+ and run with the > low end Pentiums, I do it! > As I remember,.....there was a flight/war sim online for awhile in > beta test called Air Warrior. When they went into league format, they > set up an evaluation prog that would tell them what you were running, > and if it was fast enough for their sim. I don't think that would be > too much of a hassle for Papyrus. It would keep the fast "frameraters" > from totally dominating a one league system as they do now on Hawaii. > And it would cut down on the complaints,....are ya listening Papy?? Ya > can't say it's gonna cost ya money, cause what brings more returns, a > full league with happy comoetitors that want to STAY; or a one leauge > system with a large turnover ratio? Do the math Papyrus! > (soap box mode off,...flame retardent gear on) > Mike > Lifes too short,....don't fold your underwear!
Hey man , I think this issue is nothing but blowing smoke !! I had a 486-66 last year and was just as fast as i am this year with a pent 200mmx !! Mike12= Hawaii Mike Blackstock
>> Maybe they (Whoever actually runs the multiplayer Nascar system) >>should introduce a class-system based on computer performance. They >>could break it down into 486's, "artificial" Pentiums, Pentium MMX's, >>etc. How about this, people with slow systems run in vga or turn off some graphics. People with fast systems turn all the graphics on? Is that too simple??? Sager
Mopars 25 Jul 1997#374098
well people i will try to be your test bed on this subject call me stupid or an amature but i knew nothing about the frame rates recently i upgraded to a pentium166 system with 32 megs of ram 2 meg trident video and a yamaha wave table sound with joystick port w/a grand prix 1 wheel the first thing i noticed was the calibration in nascar 2 the thing lock to lock is now off the scale maybe this new card has the same effect as a game card the frame rates are set at the default nascar2 settings which i believe are 23 and 13 i have run consistent 195.5s with a top of 196.033 without the draft in a pontiac body. contrary to popular belief guys the pontiac is the fastest in this game i picked up at 3 100ths of a second just by changing to the pontiac i am now going to go and adjust the frame rates and see if i pick up any more speed this may also explain how a friend of mine with a pentium133 and a game card maybe using the max frame rates is able to run upper 196s and a fastest lap of 197.5 with no draft i have been chasing him for too long now>Same as ever: If you get a higher frame rate, a good driver will be i will let you know the results asap
Quoted text (52 lines)> > >> > <Long post about VGA being faster than SVGA snipped> > > >> > GRAPHICS RATE and TRACTION and GEARING are all connected. > > >> Same as ever: If you get a higher frame rate, a good driver will be able > > >> to drive the car faster. Period. > > >> On a high end machine, which can run SVGA at a constant 30 fps, there > > >> should be no difference between VGA and SVGA. If SVGA yields 20 fps and > > >> VGA yields 30fps, VGA will probably be faster due to the higher frame > > >> rate. > > >> The gearing change you mentioned was either a secondary effect of > > >> carrying higher speeds, or you should have been using that gear all > > >> along. > > >> ---Jim Sokoloff > > >Jim: > > >I really am alittle shocked by your candid answer. For Years Papyrus > > >has been trying to convince us that all DRIVING SYSTEMS were created > > >equal. Now we you have said what we have all know. The NASCAR > > >software doesnt run equally on all systems.. > > Whoa now, Hoss... that's not what Jim was saying at all. Read through > > it again and this time pay close attention to the first paragraph. "A > > good driver will be able to drive the car faster." That doesn't mean > > the SOFTWARE gives him an advantage -- it means that thanks to the > > faster frame rate, smoother transitions between car states, etc., that > > a driver can be more consistent, more smooth, and more fluid in his > > driving than a person whose display is more choppy and there is more > > gap time between frames. > > -- > > Papyrus Design Group, Inc. > > The views expressed in this message are mine entirely > > and do not represent Papyrus or Sierra in any official capacity. > Tony: > I standby what I said. Better Hardware gives you a faster car. > Why Cant you just say it. Why cant you just say that PENTIUMS > are FASTER than 486's. Why cant you say that VGA is faster > than SVGA.. Why cant you say that JOYSTICKS are faster than > WHEELS. > All we want to do is compete against each other fairly.. > Lets keep it simple.. > Don Wilshe, IVGA
Don shut up already!!!!!!!!!!!!!You have always known this its nothing new .You are the most egotistacle clown I have seen.You act like this is a conspirocy and you are out to save the world of Auto racing simulation from a dasterdly dead.You look for every little problem or discrepency with papy and Make big deals about it.You talk out of both sides of your mouth ..doesnt that get old??? Reading these stupid posts by you does!! -- Paul Carillon
Quoted text (58 lines)> > >> > <Long post about VGA being faster than SVGA snipped> > > >> > GRAPHICS RATE and TRACTION and GEARING are all connected. > > >> Same as ever: If you get a higher frame rate, a good driver will be able > > >> to drive the car faster. Period. > > >> On a high end machine, which can run SVGA at a constant 30 fps, there > > >> should be no difference between VGA and SVGA. If SVGA yields 20 fps and > > >> VGA yields 30fps, VGA will probably be faster due to the higher frame > > >> rate. > > >> The gearing change you mentioned was either a secondary effect of > > >> carrying higher speeds, or you should have been using that gear all > > >> along. > > >> ---Jim Sokoloff > > >Jim: > > >I really am alittle shocked by your candid answer. For Years Papyrus > > >has been trying to convince us that all DRIVING SYSTEMS were created > > >equal. Now we you have said what we have all know. The NASCAR > > >software doesnt run equally on all systems.. > > Whoa now, Hoss... that's not what Jim was saying at all. Read through > > it again and this time pay close attention to the first paragraph. "A > > good driver will be able to drive the car faster." That doesn't mean > > the SOFTWARE gives him an advantage -- it means that thanks to the > > faster frame rate, smoother transitions between car states, etc., that > > a driver can be more consistent, more smooth, and more fluid in his > > driving than a person whose display is more choppy and there is more > > gap time between frames. > Tony: > You couldnt of said it better. Better HARDWARE is FASTER TIMES. But > its > still the softwares responsibility to even the field. Let me explain. > When > your software starts up its synchronizes the GRAPHICS RATE and the > CONTROL > DEVICE you have to make the FRAME RATES the same and you cant give some > people advanatages. It is the responsibility of PAPYRUS to slow down > the FASTER machines and FRAME RATES to be the same for all of us. > Whether > as advertised on your SOFTWARE BOXES you have a 486-66 or a Pentium > 300.. > Don Wilshe > Nice Try.... > > -- > > Papyrus Design Group, Inc. > > The views expressed in this message are mine entirely > > and do not represent Papyrus or Sierra in any official capacity.
Don maybe you could right since you seem to know a lot about it??? -- Paul Carillon http://members.aol.com/sschevy454 http://www.oilout.com/nros/hts/ http://www2.netwide.net/n2ros/midwest/default.asp
Quoted text (9 lines)> >people advanatages. It is the responsibility of PAPYRUS to slow down > >the FASTER machines and FRAME RATES to be the same for all of us. > ROF,L! I've seen some true gems on these forums but I think the above > may actually be the stupidest statement I have ever read on the net. > And that's saying a lot, there's a lot of competition on the net, you > should be proud of yourself! > Joe
ROFLMAO!!!!!!!!!!! -- Paul Carillon http://members.aol.com/sschevy454 http://www.oilout.com/nros/hts/ http://www2.netwide.net/n2ros/midwest/default.asp
> Well said Bart. > Marc Uh...THANK yuh...thank yuh verrah much... BB
Quoted text (25 lines)> > Maybe they (Whoever actually runs the multiplayer Nascar system) > >should introduce a class-system based on computer performance. They > >could break it down into 486's, "artificial" Pentiums, Pentium MMX's, > >etc. > My thoughts exactly! Set up leagues by CPU speed,.....evryone will > have a more level playing field, not totally level but close enough. > You can still take an Overdrive/Enhanced 486 x100+ and run with the > low end Pentiums, I do it! > As I remember,.....there was a flight/war sim online for awhile in > beta test called Air Warrior. When they went into league format, they > set up an evaluation prog that would tell them what you were running, > and if it was fast enough for their sim. I don't think that would be > too much of a hassle for Papyrus. It would keep the fast "frameraters" > from totally dominating a one league system as they do now on Hawaii. > And it would cut down on the complaints,....are ya listening Papy?? Ya > can't say it's gonna cost ya money, cause what brings more returns, a > full league with happy comoetitors that want to STAY; or a one leauge > system with a large turnover ratio? Do the math Papyrus! > (soap box mode off,...flame retardent gear on) > Mike > Lifes too short,....don't fold your underwear!
Ya who will policwe it to keep the faster Machines out?? Thats what Don wants another way to Cheat !!!!!LOL just kidding couldnt resist -- Paul Carillon http://members.aol.com/sschevy454 http://www.oilout.com/nros/hts/ http://www2.netwide.net/n2ros/midwest/default.asp
Mike 25 Jul 1997#374104
Lemme see here,....those who have the fast systems get to go fast and see pretty pictures. And those who can't afford them get to look at fuzz and run into the walls? Gee,.....I guess I should just quit my ***in and be happy that I get to race at all,....huh? Must be why Papy advertises that minimum requirements are just a 486 dx66,......we must all be equal after all! So this means that after two years with Nascar1, and a month w/ Nas2, I'm just a lousy driver that can't put a setup together to keep up with the rest of you Einsteins! Damn,....glad you put me straight on this issue. Mike Lifes too short,....don't fold your underwear!
SimRaci 25 Jul 1997#374105
Elvis is here!!...Elvis is here!!...Elvis is here!! ;) Marc
Don Wilshe 25 Jul 1997#374106
P Paul: What kind of non-sense is this. All I have ever tried to do is LEVEL the playing field. I bring up these issues so people that cant quite cut the mustard have some ideas why. Don
Mw421 27 Jul 1997#374225
This is the most insane "thought" I've ever seen on a computer screen. "let's make sure the 486-33s and P-60s can keep up, mustn't damage their self-esteem". If you can't drive with the frame rate you have, then GET A FASTER MACHINE!!! Don't even think about dragging the rest of the world down to your pathetic level. Are you this half-assed in the rest of your life?
TOlson94 27 Jul 1997#374226
No, it is the responsibility of the person with the slower machine to adjust the graphic options to get a better frame rate...or get a fast computer, but not everyone can do that.
Don Wilshe 27 Jul 1997#374227
Quoted text (34 lines)> >It is quite clear now > >based on Jim Sokoloff statement and even yours that the person > >with the BEST HARDWARE COMBINATION could be the fastest. I think > >we need more explanation so we know what is the best hardware > >to buy. What CPU, Graphics Card, Control Devices and GAMECARD > >yeild the fastest results. I would like to know for once if > >I get smoked: > > 1). Was it the driver > > 2). Was it the hardware > > 3). Or Both > Don, > When Ayrton Senna driving a McLaren-Honda smoked past the other F1 > drivers, don't you think they'd like to know was it his chassis, was > it the Honda power or was he actually better? > Sorry to say, but that's life. If you enter NASCAR with a Chevy Nova > and $100 you'd better believe you're gonna be last - why is Hawaii any > different? If you're the man with the answers perhaps you'd like to > suggest what Papyrus could do about that? Limit the software so that > it only does 12fps whether it's run on a PII or a 386? No-one with > higher than a 486 can enter? While you're at it, remember to describe > how this would be policed since that is your main area of concern. > I'm looking forward to your suggestions. If you can't come up with any > suggestions from the IVGA's membership how are poor old Papyrus gonna > do it with the few folks that they have? > Cheers! > John
John: You are 100% right. This whole question was about a level playing field. STUPID QUESTION as it AINT possible and I was glad to see that so many of the USENET people were up to speed on this issue. I have a Pentium II 266 and I have achieved some success on HAWAII with wins and fast times. I have worked extensively with Driving Lines and Setups and I am always surprised that a simple little hardware change can make me a ROCKET. I ran 181 at ATLANTA for 2 years and than a simple hardware upgrade and I was 188's and some 189's. My point all along was exactly what most of you told me. There is nothing level about this game or life. If you want to go fast just write a BIG CHECK to the MECHANIC or the computer store. That has always been the fastest way around the track. Don Wilshe, IVGA PS. Personally I am very glad that PAPRYUS gave us NASCAR and I am behind PAPYRUS 100%. I always look forward to the next version of the software and frankly they are the best. PSS. I thank all the drivers for thier replys !!!!!!!!! LETS CLOSE THIS THREAD!!!!!!!
Man ive got a pentium 100 16megs ram and 188s are are no problem. of course I have to turn off most of the graphics though.Better hardware might help but not much unless your old machine was really crap.
Im far from being the greatest racer in the world but Ill be damned if im gonna whine and say someone beat me because of their hardware,Id like to think I have more character than that!!!
Handy^Ma 28 Jul 1997#374314
> Im far from being the greatest racer in the world but Ill be damned if > im gonna whine and say someone beat me because of their hardware,Id like > to think I have more character than that!!! gotta agree with ya on this one, If I'm slow at some of the tracks, I feel it's because of my lack of practice there,,,I just have an old amd486 dx 133mhz I threw together a couple of years ago,,,24 megs ram,,,, Generic video and yamaha sound, and I just broke into the low 195's during a Tally race....With a JOYSTICK, and still tweaking setups. when I get beat, I think I'll just say good race,,, I'll afford my turn at the top someday, til then, I have a GOAL :) -- Sit down,,Strap in,,Shut up,,Hang on,,Go fast,,Turn left,,Kiss Trophy Girl GGGGGGgoooo #3,,,31,,,28,,,94,,,6,,,5,,,18,,,8,,, Handy^man
Bob Thurman 03 Aug 1997#374770
> >people advanatages. It is the responsibility of PAPYRUS to slow down > >the FASTER machines and FRAME RATES to be the same for all of us. It's oblious this guy has NEVER palyed Quake on the net! buzard
>Point is,.....setups, gearing and THE MACHINE = speed. Papyrus can't >seriuosly belive otherwise. They don't - the only people that seem to be surprised by this "revelation" are you and Don. Cheers! John
I for one have never seen anyone from Papyrus claim that all "driving systems" (whatever a driving system is) were equal in terms of performance (they can't be "created equal" since that would require they all comprised identical hardware). Had anyone from Papyrus said that they would certainly have been taken to task by the people here, as _everyone_ knows that any system which can delivery sharper and/or faster images to your eye will give you more scope for car control. This is not only in terms of the amount of information you get about what the car is doing, but faster confirmation that your corrections are acting as you expected - this is 100% common sense. Just look at the Quake community's obsession with ping times for a graphic example - the high ping guy will almost certainly lose since he cannot follow the action as readily. There are no rules for internet Quake and yet everyone manages to fit in just fine. I'm playing with a 35ms ping on a P-Pro 200, and people can choose to either live with that and play me or go elsewhere and look for someone with an equivalent system and connection. The on-line system _will_ be regulated, and surely that gives more chance that everything will be handled to make things fair? Even if the rules fail, at the end of the day everyone can still choose to race against those with equal equipment or even not to race at all. In fact it's somewhat akin to real life - a talented driver in a Minardi might be able to look good, but if you want to be World Champ you have to spend money. As an aside, isn't it interesting how everyone is whinging about how long it is taking Papyrus to get this up and running, and yet at the same time those same people are posting messages pointing out loopholes and issues with the rules that need clarified and defined BEFORE the system goes live? A quick scan of this group will show exactly how much work Papyrus have. Cheers! John

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy