Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

Why can't we race 3-4 wide at Mich?

41 posts by 14 people · 20 Jun 2004 19:43 UTC - 01 Jul 2004 12:32 UTC

Why NR2003 allows only one racing groove

Mitch_A asked why Papyrus sims could not reproduce three- and four-wide racing at Michigan. Suggested causes included uniform track grip with no dynamic groove or rubber build-up, AI limited to one line, too little downforce or drag, and fixed setups that favour the bottom line. Posters noted GTR's planned dynamic track grip and debated whether more sim racers race online or offline.

physics/realism debateonline racing/leaguesNASCAR Racing 2003 Season

Automated summary.

Mitch_A 20 Jun 2004 19:43 UTC#35751
First off this isn't a Papy bashing post. That company did more for Simracing than any other period, and I for one do appreciate what they've done that has given me many many thousands of hours of enjoyment (all the way back to Indy 500 and every single title since). That being said I wonder why or what prevented Papy from giving us a more accurate experience. As I sit and watch the Michigan race I clearly see that Papy's efforts have a weakness that they NEVER over came. Each successive title improved (or hid) the weakness but it has always been their since N1. The BR tracks again seem to just "hide" the issue not overcome it. My question (more for fun than anything) is what do you all think this inherent weakness is and why do you think Papy was never able to solve it? Mitch
What do you mean by the BR tracks "hiding" the issue? Up until the latest aero and tire rules in NASCAR there was no 2-3 wide racing at most tracks, only recent changes have improved this. Remember NR2003 is based on what they were trying to model from at least 2002. "Mitch_A" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:wNlBc.2598$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (9 lines)> First off this isn't a Papy bashing post. That company did more for > Simracing than any other period, and I for one do appreciate what they've > done that has given me many many thousands of hours of enjoyment (all the > way back to Indy 500 and every single title since). > > That being said I wonder why or what prevented Papy from giving us a more > accurate experience. As I sit and watch the Michigan race I clearly see > that Papy's efforts have a weakness that they NEVER over came. Each > successive title improved (or hid) the weakness but it has always been
their
Quoted text (9 lines)> since N1. The BR tracks again seem to just "hide" the issue not overcome > it. > > My question (more for fun than anything) is what do you all think this > inherent weakness is and why do you think Papy was never able to solve it? > > Mitch > >
JP 20 Jun 2004 21:55 UTC↳ reply to Schooner#35755
Schooner <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:ganBc.7822$[email hidden]... > What do you mean by the BR tracks "hiding" the issue? > > Up until the latest aero and tire rules in NASCAR there was no 2-3 wide > racing at most tracks, only recent changes have improved this. Remember > NR2003 is based on what they were trying to model from at least 2002. lol, huh ? 2-3 wide racing has been at Michigan since it was built. Nothing to do with new aero or tire rules.
JP 20 Jun 2004 22:11 UTC↳ reply to Mitch_A#35756
Mitch_A <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:wNlBc.2598$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (9 lines)> First off this isn't a Papy bashing post. That company did more for > Simracing than any other period, and I for one do appreciate what they've > done that has given me many many thousands of hours of enjoyment (all the > way back to Indy 500 and every single title since). > > That being said I wonder why or what prevented Papy from giving us a more > accurate experience. As I sit and watch the Michigan race I clearly see > that Papy's efforts have a weakness that they NEVER over came. Each > successive title improved (or hid) the weakness but it has always been
their
Quoted text (8 lines)> since N1. The BR tracks again seem to just "hide" the issue not overcome > it. > > My question (more for fun than anything) is what do you all think this > inherent weakness is and why do you think Papy was never able to solve it? > > Mitch >
1. Weakness is Papy tracks have always been one groove(or line, or whatever term you want) tracks. Don't know why exactly. Track modeling hasn't been the best in terms of relationship to actual track, but its more involved than just that I think. 2. Who knows. Didn't want to or maybe see the need to change maybe. >
variable track grip. talent of drivers. those are the 2 biggies, if you could rubber up parts of the track, have marbles form elsewhere, have track grip alter constantly then youd get more 'lines' opening up. my concern with GTR is that it will be harder to pass people due to the variable track grip option theyre going to have. itll be just like in real life, impossible to pass in most places because it gets dirty offline. pez "Mitch_A" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:wNlBc.2598$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (9 lines)> First off this isn't a Papy bashing post. That company did more for > Simracing than any other period, and I for one do appreciate what they've > done that has given me many many thousands of hours of enjoyment (all the > way back to Indy 500 and every single title since). > > That being said I wonder why or what prevented Papy from giving us a more > accurate experience. As I sit and watch the Michigan race I clearly see > that Papy's efforts have a weakness that they NEVER over came. Each > successive title improved (or hid) the weakness but it has always been
their
Quoted text (9 lines)> since N1. The BR tracks again seem to just "hide" the issue not overcome > it. > > My question (more for fun than anything) is what do you all think this > inherent weakness is and why do you think Papy was never able to solve it? > > Mitch > >
You may be on to something Pez. A dynamic groove/grooves may have been the main contributor. The key is, we as drivers need to be able to identify the change and till this point we haven't had the level of detail needed to identify the change. Very well could be hardware related then, no? Mitch "Pez" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:Y3oBc.17742$[email hidden]... > variable track grip. talent of drivers. > > those are the 2 biggies, if you could rubber up parts of the track, have > marbles form elsewhere, have track grip alter constantly then youd getmore
Quoted text (8 lines)> 'lines' opening up. > > my concern with GTR is that it will be harder to pass people due to the > variable track grip option theyre going to have. itll be just like in real > life, impossible to pass in most places because it gets dirty offline. > > pez >
Haqsau 20 Jun 2004 22:43 UTC↳ reply to Mitch_A#35759
I think more downforce would allow people to run the outside groove. Downforce is proportional to speed squared, so the more you have, the more important it becomes to keep your speed up, thus making the outside line preferable. Then increase the drag so that the increased downforce doesn't allow unrealistic speeds overall. That is essentially what Papy did from NR2002 to NR2003, and it did improve things, but it appears they didn't go quite far enough. I know they were working with one of the teams but it is likely that team didn't want to show the other teams how good they thought they were, so they probably dumbed down the data they gave Papy. "Mitch_A" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:wNlBc.2598$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (9 lines)> First off this isn't a Papy bashing post. That company did more for > Simracing than any other period, and I for one do appreciate what they've > done that has given me many many thousands of hours of enjoyment (all the > way back to Indy 500 and every single title since). > > That being said I wonder why or what prevented Papy from giving us a more > accurate experience. As I sit and watch the Michigan race I clearly see > that Papy's efforts have a weakness that they NEVER over came. Each > successive title improved (or hid) the weakness but it has always been
their
Quoted text (9 lines)> since N1. The BR tracks again seem to just "hide" the issue not overcome > it. > > My question (more for fun than anything) is what do you all think this > inherent weakness is and why do you think Papy was never able to solve it? > > Mitch > >
JP 20 Jun 2004 23:10 UTC↳ reply to Haqsau#35761
I don't think the team, Jasper Motorsports, had anything to hide from any of the others.......they're a backmarkers backmarker, always have been. Its safe to say, not many other teams are concerned with how good they are. Haqsau <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > I think more downforce would allow people to run the outside groove. > Downforce is proportional to speed squared, so the more you have, the more > important it becomes to keep your speed up, thus making the outside line > preferable. Then increase the drag so that the increased downforcedoesn't > allow unrealistic speeds overall. That is essentially what Papy did from > NR2002 to NR2003, and it did improve things, but it appears they didn't go > quite far enough. I know they were working with one of the teams but itis
Quoted text (8 lines)> likely that team didn't want to show the other teams how good they thought > they were, so they probably dumbed down the data they gave Papy. > > > "Mitch_A" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:wNlBc.2598$[email hidden]... > > First off this isn't a Papy bashing post. That company did more for > > Simracing than any other period, and I for one do appreciate what
they've > > done that has given me many many thousands of hours of enjoyment (allthe > > way back to Indy 500 and every single title since). > > > > That being said I wonder why or what prevented Papy from giving us amore > > accurate experience. As I sit and watch the Michigan race I clearly see > > that Papy's efforts have a weakness that they NEVER over came. Each > > successive title improved (or hid) the weakness but it has always been > their > > since N1. The BR tracks again seem to just "hide" the issue notovercome > > it. > > > > My question (more for fun than anything) is what do you all think this > > inherent weakness is and why do you think Papy was never able to solveit? > > > > Mitch > > > > > >
JP 20 Jun 2004 23:11 UTC↳ reply to Mitch_A#35762
Not reall Mitch_A <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:tioBc.6292$[email hidden]... > You may be on to something Pez. A dynamic groove/grooves may have beenthe > main contributor. The key is, we as drivers need to be able to identifythe > change and till this point we haven't had the level of detail needed to > identify the change. Very well could be hardware related then, no? > > Mitch Not really. Take Michigan, Rock, whatever. Real race, they can run the same as they do later in the race. iow, they're not waiting for a groove to be laid down.
In article <wNlBc.2598$[email hidden]>, Mitch_A <[email hidden]> writes
Quoted text (15 lines)>First off this isn't a Papy bashing post. That company did more for >Simracing than any other period, and I for one do appreciate what they've >done that has given me many many thousands of hours of enjoyment (all the >way back to Indy 500 and every single title since). > >That being said I wonder why or what prevented Papy from giving us a more >accurate experience. As I sit and watch the Michigan race I clearly see >that Papy's efforts have a weakness that they NEVER over came. Each >successive title improved (or hid) the weakness but it has always been their >since N1. The BR tracks again seem to just "hide" the issue not overcome >it. > >My question (more for fun than anything) is what do you all think this >inherent weakness is and why do you think Papy was never able to solve it? >
Because we would have been able to kick the AI's butt, big time. The Papy AI has no means by which it is capable of running more than one line. What's the point of putting in multiple lines when the only driver using those lines is going to be you, whilst all the AI drivers use the same line as each other. -- Peter Ives (AKA Pete Ivington) Remove ALL_STRESS before replying via email If you know what's good for you, don't listen to me :) GPLRank Joystick -50.63 Wheel -25.01
Did a race yesterday at Michigan and was 2 and 3 wide all race. Must be your drivers. EL "Mitch_A" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:wNlBc.2598$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (9 lines)> First off this isn't a Papy bashing post. That company did more for > Simracing than any other period, and I for one do appreciate what they've > done that has given me many many thousands of hours of enjoyment (all the > way back to Indy 500 and every single title since). > > That being said I wonder why or what prevented Papy from giving us a more > accurate experience. As I sit and watch the Michigan race I clearly see > that Papy's efforts have a weakness that they NEVER over came. Each > successive title improved (or hid) the weakness but it has always been
their
Quoted text (9 lines)> since N1. The BR tracks again seem to just "hide" the issue not overcome > it. > > My question (more for fun than anything) is what do you all think this > inherent weakness is and why do you think Papy was never able to solve it? > > Mitch > >
variable track grip. talent of drivers. those are the 2 biggies, if you could rubber up parts of the track, have marbles form elsewhere, have track grip alter constantly then youd get more 'lines' opening up. my concern with GTR is that it will be harder to pass people due to the variable track grip option theyre going to have. itll be just like in real life, impossible to pass in most places because it gets dirty offline. pez "Mitch_A" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:wNlBc.2598$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (9 lines)> First off this isn't a Papy bashing post. That company did more for > Simracing than any other period, and I for one do appreciate what they've > done that has given me many many thousands of hours of enjoyment (all the > way back to Indy 500 and every single title since). > > That being said I wonder why or what prevented Papy from giving us a more > accurate experience. As I sit and watch the Michigan race I clearly see > that Papy's efforts have a weakness that they NEVER over came. Each > successive title improved (or hid) the weakness but it has always been
their
Quoted text (9 lines)> since N1. The BR tracks again seem to just "hide" the issue not overcome > it. > > My question (more for fun than anything) is what do you all think this > inherent weakness is and why do you think Papy was never able to solve it? > > Mitch > >
"Peter Ives" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > In article <wNlBc.2598$[email hidden]>, Mitch_A > <[email hidden]> writes >What's the point of putting in multiple lines when the only > driver using those lines is going to be you, whilst all the AI drivers > use the same line as each other. Online racing, no? -jde
Haqsau 21 Jun 2004 01:17 UTC↳ reply to JP#35770
Perhaps, but the crew chief involved made the statement that he did not give Papy the exact data. "JP" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:jOoBc.381$%[email hidden]... > I don't think the team, Jasper Motorsports, had anything to hide fromany > of the others.......they're a backmarkers backmarker, always have been. > > Its safe to say, not many other teams are concerned with how good they > are. >
Why are you concerned that GTR is going to be more realistic? -- Mike Beauchamp http://www.therevox.com - custom electro-theremins and stuff. http://www.mikebeauchamp.com - mike's personal site. "Pez" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:Y3oBc.17742$[email hidden]... > variable track grip. talent of drivers. > > those are the 2 biggies, if you could rubber up parts of the track, have > marbles form elsewhere, have track grip alter constantly then youd get more > 'lines' opening up. > > my concern with GTR is that it will be harder to pass people due to the > variable track grip option theyre going to have. itll be just like in real > life, impossible to pass in most places because it gets dirty offline. > > pez > > "Mitch_A" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:wNlBc.2598$[email hidden]... > > First off this isn't a Papy bashing post. That company did more for > > Simracing than any other period, and I for one do appreciate what they've > > done that has given me many many thousands of hours of enjoyment (all the > > way back to Indy 500 and every single title since). > > > > That being said I wonder why or what prevented Papy from giving us a more > > accurate experience. As I sit and watch the Michigan race I clearly see > > that Papy's efforts have a weakness that they NEVER over came. Each > > successive title improved (or hid) the weakness but it has always been > their > > since N1. The BR tracks again seem to just "hide" the issue not overcome > > it. > > > > My question (more for fun than anything) is what do you all think this > > inherent weakness is and why do you think Papy was never able to solve it? > > > > Mitch > > > > > >
Mitch_A 21 Jun 2004 04:46 UTC↳ reply to JP#35775
I was thinking more along the lines of a larger static groove which has dynamic elements on the edges. "JP" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:gPoBc.382$%[email hidden]... > > Not really. Take Michigan, Rock, whatever. Real race, they can run the > same as they do later in the race. iow, they're not waiting for a grooveto > be laid down. > >
Dont kid yourself. There is only one way to go fast. "EL" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:ERoBc.25958$[email hidden]... > Did a race yesterday at Michigan and was 2 and 3 wide all race. Must beyour
Quoted text (9 lines)> drivers. > > EL > > > "Mitch_A" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:wNlBc.2598$[email hidden]... > > First off this isn't a Papy bashing post. That company did more for > > Simracing than any other period, and I for one do appreciate what
they've > > done that has given me many many thousands of hours of enjoyment (allthe > > way back to Indy 500 and every single title since). > > > > That being said I wonder why or what prevented Papy from giving us amore > > accurate experience. As I sit and watch the Michigan race I clearly see > > that Papy's efforts have a weakness that they NEVER over came. Each > > successive title improved (or hid) the weakness but it has always been > their > > since N1. The BR tracks again seem to just "hide" the issue notovercome > > it. > > > > My question (more for fun than anything) is what do you all think this > > inherent weakness is and why do you think Papy was never able to solveit? > > > > Mitch > > > > > >
but then they wouldve been running on it all weekend long. track grip varies depending on many things. papyrus tracks have uniform grip, which creates ONE distinct 'best line' around any track. hardware speed and time to implement are the reasons for not having dynamic track grip. pez "JP" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:gPoBc.382$%[email hidden]...
Quoted text (15 lines)> Not reall > Mitch_A <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:tioBc.6292$[email hidden]... > > You may be on to something Pez. A dynamic groove/grooves may have been > the > > main contributor. The key is, we as drivers need to be able to identify > the > > change and till this point we haven't had the level of detail needed to > > identify the change. Very well could be hardware related then, no? > > > > Mitch > > > Not really. Take Michigan, Rock, whatever. Real race, they can run the > same as they do later in the race. iow, they're not waiting for a groove
to > be laid down. > >
theyve announced that it is going to have dynamic track grip, so that offline will be covered in marbles and hence slippery, online will be tacky and grippy. = no overtaking, just like the real thing! pez "Mike Beauchamp" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]...
Quoted text (19 lines)> Why are you concerned that GTR is going to be more realistic? > > -- > Mike Beauchamp > http://www.therevox.com - custom electro-theremins and stuff. > http://www.mikebeauchamp.com - mike's personal site. > > > "Pez" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:Y3oBc.17742$[email hidden]... > > variable track grip. talent of drivers. > > > > those are the 2 biggies, if you could rubber up parts of the track, have > > marbles form elsewhere, have track grip alter constantly then youd get > more > > 'lines' opening up. > > > > my concern with GTR is that it will be harder to pass people due to the > > variable track grip option theyre going to have. itll be just like in
real
Quoted text (16 lines)> > life, impossible to pass in most places because it gets dirty offline. > > > > pez > > > > "Mitch_A" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > news:wNlBc.2598$[email hidden]... > > > First off this isn't a Papy bashing post. That company did more for > > > Simracing than any other period, and I for one do appreciate what > they've > > > done that has given me many many thousands of hours of enjoyment (all > the > > > way back to Indy 500 and every single title since). > > > > > > That being said I wonder why or what prevented Papy from giving us a > more > > > accurate experience. As I sit and watch the Michigan race I clearly
see
Quoted text (18 lines)> > > that Papy's efforts have a weakness that they NEVER over came. Each > > > successive title improved (or hid) the weakness but it has always been > > their > > > since N1. The BR tracks again seem to just "hide" the issue not > overcome > > > it. > > > > > > My question (more for fun than anything) is what do you all think this > > > inherent weakness is and why do you think Papy was never able to solve > it? > > > > > > Mitch > > > > > > > > > > > >
In article <KsqBc.5435$[email hidden]>, J.D. Ellis <[email hidden]> writes
Quoted text (13 lines)> >"Peter Ives" <[email hidden]> wrote in >message >news:[email hidden]... >> In article <wNlBc.2598$[email hidden]>, >Mitch_A >> <[email hidden]> writes >>What's the point of putting in multiple lines when the only >> driver using those lines is going to be you, whilst all the AI drivers >> use the same line as each other. > >Online racing, no? >
Well they could do that for online racers, but seeing as I would estimate that there are a great deal more offline racers than online ones, they are sure going to piss off more people than they are going to please. -- Peter Ives (AKA Pete Ivington) Remove ALL_STRESS before replying via email If you know what's good for you, don't listen to me :) GPLRank Joystick -50.63 Wheel -25.01
"Pez" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:HTEBc.18266$[email hidden]... > theyve announced that it is going to have dynamic track grip, so that > offline will be covered in marbles and hence slippery, online will betacky > and grippy. > > = no overtaking, just like the real thing! Correct for the intended application. However, in the context of oval racing which was the original gist of this thread, if enough drivers were using the high line and laid down some "virtual rubber" and "swept" it free of marbles, then you should be able to develop a viable high line under dynamic grip. If enough drivers used it, it could even be conceivably faster than the "ideal" line. But as in real life, it would be unpredictable and would vary from race to race on a given track. Nice... ;-)
On Sun, 20 Jun 2004 18:43:08 -0400, "Haqsau" <[email hidden]> wrote:
Quoted text (9 lines)>I think more downforce would allow people to run the outside groove. >Downforce is proportional to speed squared, so the more you have, the more >important it becomes to keep your speed up, thus making the outside line >preferable. Then increase the drag so that the increased downforce doesn't >allow unrealistic speeds overall. That is essentially what Papy did from >NR2002 to NR2003, and it did improve things, but it appears they didn't go >quite far enough. I know they were working with one of the teams but it is >likely that team didn't want to show the other teams how good they thought >they were, so they probably dumbed down the data they gave Papy.
I dunno if it's downforce, but I've had the impression since N2003 came out that there wasn't enough drag or grip. The BR tracks with the CTS physics (I prefer the 88 mod) are pretty nice, altho it feels really odd if you run the low line and drift up and suddenly the car snaps into place because of the extra grip. Or you do a really hot qualifying lap without coming anywhere near the apex of the corners (more of a problem at MichiganBR than say, CaliBR or TheRock). Jason
On Mon, 21 Jun 2004 04:48:16 GMT, "Mitch_A" <[email hidden]> wrote: >Dont kid yourself. There is only one way to go fast. If you set the car up fairly loose for a long fuel run, it's a lot faster and easier to run the high line until the tires start to come in about 1/3 of the way in before attacking the low line. Without dynamic grip you'll never get truly realistic lines, but you can run multiple lines with some success if your setup can handle it. I'm also pretty sure passing on the outside would be easier if each car had did different performance characterstics. Jeff Gordon is someone who tends to set his car up really loose while running the high line early in fuel runs and he can power past people because he has the power and the aero to do it. And then of course there's the constantly changing grip on a real track as the surface temperature changes, cars lay down rubber, kick marbles out of the way, leave debris/oil on the track, etc. If Papy modelled every detail that affected the grip available on the surface of the track I think multi-line racing would be easier to do. The BR tracks aren't particularly realistic in the way grip is distributed across the track surface but it's a decent compromise if you want multiple static grooves. Jason
Umm, they were running on it all weekend. Pez <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:KSEBc.18265$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (8 lines)> but then they wouldve been running on it all weekend long. > > track grip varies depending on many things. > > papyrus tracks have uniform grip, which creates ONE distinct 'best line' > around any track. > > hardware speed and time to implement are the reasons for not having
dynamic
Quoted text (10 lines)> track grip. > > pez > > "JP" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:gPoBc.382$%[email hidden]... > > Not reall > > Mitch_A <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > news:tioBc.6292$[email hidden]... > > > You may be on to something Pez. A dynamic groove/grooves may have
been > > the > > > main contributor. The key is, we as drivers need to be able toidentify > > the > > > change and till this point we haven't had the level of detail neededto
Quoted text (7 lines)> > > identify the change. Very well could be hardware related then, no? > > > > > > Mitch > > > > > > Not really. Take Michigan, Rock, whatever. Real race, they can run the > > same as they do later in the race. iow, they're not waiting for a
groove > to > > be laid down. > > > > > >
JP 21 Jun 2004 21:49 UTC↳ reply to Mitch_A#35609
Ah, k. Mitch_A <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:2LtBc.2767$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (8 lines)> I was thinking more along the lines of a larger static groove which has > dynamic elements on the edges. > > "JP" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:gPoBc.382$%[email hidden]... > > > > Not really. Take Michigan, Rock, whatever. Real race, they can run the > > same as they do later in the race. iow, they're not waiting for a
groove > to > > be laid down. > > > > > >
JP 21 Jun 2004 21:49 UTC↳ reply to Haqsau#35610
True enough. Haqsau <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > Perhaps, but the crew chief involved made the statement that he did notgive
Quoted text (14 lines)> Papy the exact data. > > > "JP" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:jOoBc.381$%[email hidden]... > > I don't think the team, Jasper Motorsports, had anything to hide from > any > > of the others.......they're a backmarkers backmarker, always have been. > > > > Its safe to say, not many other teams are concerned with how good they > > are. > > > >
JP 21 Jun 2004 21:54 UTC↳ reply to jason moyer#35612
Jason Moyer <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > On Sun, 20 Jun 2004 18:43:08 -0400, "Haqsau" > <[email hidden]> wrote: > > >I think more downforce would allow people to run the outside groove. > >Downforce is proportional to speed squared, so the more you have, themore > >important it becomes to keep your speed up, thus making the outside line > >preferable. Then increase the drag so that the increased downforcedoesn't > >allow unrealistic speeds overall. That is essentially what Papy did from > >NR2002 to NR2003, and it did improve things, but it appears they didn'tgo > >quite far enough. I know they were working with one of the teams but itis > >likely that team didn't want to show the other teams how good theythought
Quoted text (13 lines)> >they were, so they probably dumbed down the data they gave Papy. > > I dunno if it's downforce, but I've had the impression since N2003 > came out that there wasn't enough drag or grip. > > The BR tracks with the CTS physics (I prefer the 88 mod) are pretty > nice, altho it feels really odd if you run the low line and drift up > and suddenly the car snaps into place because of the extra grip. Or > you do a really hot qualifying lap without coming anywhere near the > apex of the corners (more of a problem at MichiganBR than say, CaliBR > or TheRock). > > Jason
Try using the cts physics with the cup cars, and that can make that snap disappear usually. That snap is really bad at Dover imo. But since the cts mod is supposedly what the cup "mod" should be like, give it a go.
I definitely think setup is a big contributing factor, and even more to the point, fixed setups are a big part of it. Arguably there is only one best line for a given setup, and therefore if everybody is using the same setup there is only one best line. In the real races most drivers start out trying to keep the car on the bottom, and only go up high if the car isn't working on the bottom. You have to adapt the line to the car if you want to get the most out of it. If everybody used different setups there would be different optimal lines for everybody. "Jason Moyer" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]...
Quoted text (21 lines)> > If you set the car up fairly loose for a long fuel run, it's a lot > faster and easier to run the high line until the tires start to come > in about 1/3 of the way in before attacking the low line. Without > dynamic grip you'll never get truly realistic lines, but you can run > multiple lines with some success if your setup can handle it. I'm > also pretty sure passing on the outside would be easier if each car > had did different performance characterstics. Jeff Gordon is someone > who tends to set his car up really loose while running the high line > early in fuel runs and he can power past people because he has the > power and the aero to do it. And then of course there's the > constantly changing grip on a real track as the surface temperature > changes, cars lay down rubber, kick marbles out of the way, leave > debris/oil on the track, etc. If Papy modelled every detail that > affected the grip available on the surface of the track I think > multi-line racing would be easier to do. The BR tracks aren't > particularly realistic in the way grip is distributed across the track > surface but it's a decent compromise if you want multiple static > grooves. > > Jason
JP 22 Jun 2004 00:35 UTC↳ reply to Haqsau#35621
Actually, it's the same in open setup leagues too. Haqsau <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > I definitely think setup is a big contributing factor, and even more tothe > point, fixed setups are a big part of it. Arguably there is only one best > line for a given setup, and therefore if everybody is using the same setup > there is only one best line. In the real races most drivers start out > trying to keep the car on the bottom, and only go up high if the car isn't > working on the bottom. You have to adapt the line to the car if you wantto
Quoted text (28 lines)> get the most out of it. If everybody used different setups there would be > different optimal lines for everybody. > > "Jason Moyer" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:[email hidden]... > > > > If you set the car up fairly loose for a long fuel run, it's a lot > > faster and easier to run the high line until the tires start to come > > in about 1/3 of the way in before attacking the low line. Without > > dynamic grip you'll never get truly realistic lines, but you can run > > multiple lines with some success if your setup can handle it. I'm > > also pretty sure passing on the outside would be easier if each car > > had did different performance characterstics. Jeff Gordon is someone > > who tends to set his car up really loose while running the high line > > early in fuel runs and he can power past people because he has the > > power and the aero to do it. And then of course there's the > > constantly changing grip on a real track as the surface temperature > > changes, cars lay down rubber, kick marbles out of the way, leave > > debris/oil on the track, etc. If Papy modelled every detail that > > affected the grip available on the surface of the track I think > > multi-line racing would be easier to do. The BR tracks aren't > > particularly realistic in the way grip is distributed across the track > > surface but it's a decent compromise if you want multiple static > > grooves. > > > > Jason > >
Haqsau 22 Jun 2004 02:11 UTC↳ reply to JP#35623
But... does anybody really try to set the car up for the high line? I would think most sim racers would set it up to run the bottom. "JP" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:88LBc.444$%[email hidden]... > Actually, it's the same in open setup leagues too. >
JP 22 Jun 2004 02:35 UTC↳ reply to Haqsau#35625
I would bet you're right, but then the chicken/egg argument comes in; i.e., are the setups made that way, because everyone knows there is no high line in the game ? One thing for sure; been this way since N1, so you'd think someone must have tried it by now. Haqsau <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > But... does anybody really try to set the car up for the high line? Iwould
Quoted text (9 lines)> think most sim racers would set it up to run the bottom. > > > "JP" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:88LBc.444$%[email hidden]... > > Actually, it's the same in open setup leagues too. > > > >
jason moyer 22 Jun 2004 06:37 UTC↳ reply to JP#35630
On Mon, 21 Jun 2004 16:54:00 -0500, "JP" <[email hidden]> wrote: > Try using the cts physics with the cup cars You mean cup cars with the BR tracks? Just want to make sure I understand what you're saying. =)
yeah, and altering its grip charactaristics all weekend too. pez "JP" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:XHIBc.431$%[email hidden]...
Quoted text (37 lines)> Umm, they were running on it all weekend. > > > Pez <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:KSEBc.18265$[email hidden]... > > but then they wouldve been running on it all weekend long. > > > > track grip varies depending on many things. > > > > papyrus tracks have uniform grip, which creates ONE distinct 'best line' > > around any track. > > > > hardware speed and time to implement are the reasons for not having > dynamic > > track grip. > > > > pez > > > > "JP" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > news:gPoBc.382$%[email hidden]... > > > Not reall > > > Mitch_A <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > > news:tioBc.6292$[email hidden]... > > > > You may be on to something Pez. A dynamic groove/grooves may have > been > > > the > > > > main contributor. The key is, we as drivers need to be able to > identify > > > the > > > > change and till this point we haven't had the level of detail needed > to > > > > identify the change. Very well could be hardware related then, no? > > > > > > > > Mitch > > > > > > > > > Not really. Take Michigan, Rock, whatever. Real race, they can run
the
Quoted text (10 lines)> > > same as they do later in the race. iow, they're not waiting for a > groove > > to > > > be laid down. > > > > > > > > > > > >
its more to do with track grip, its uniform in the game, its NOT in real life, and in real life it alters as the cars run on it. also, tyres arent as consistent in real life as they are in the game. in real life the drivers sometimes alter their lines to drive around understeer oversteer problems, whereas we, whove put in so many laps, tend to just work on sets to combat that. in real life they dont get so much time, and so they find that the cars tend to be a little more inconsistent. at the end of the day, its a grip issue. pez "JP" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:LUMBc.458$%[email hidden]... > I would bet you're right, but then the chicken/egg argument comes in; > i.e., are the setups made that way, because everyone knows there is nohigh
Quoted text (22 lines)> line in the game ? > > One thing for sure; been this way since N1, so you'd think someone must > have tried it by now. > > > > Haqsau <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:[email hidden]... > > But... does anybody really try to set the car up for the high line? I > would > > think most sim racers would set it up to run the bottom. > > > > > > "JP" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > news:88LBc.444$%[email hidden]... > > > Actually, it's the same in open setup leagues too. > > > > > > > > >
Pez <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:AlTBc.18753$[email hidden]... > yeah, and altering its grip charactaristics all weekend too. > > pez ? Don't recall saying they weren't. You were saying they would have been running it all weekend, i.e, implying they weren't. All I said was they were running it all weekend, just as they have since, what, 1965 I think ?
JP 22 Jun 2004 21:48 UTC↳ reply to jason moyer#35579
Jason Moyer <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]...
Quoted text (7 lines)> On Mon, 21 Jun 2004 16:54:00 -0500, "JP" <[email hidden]> wrote: > > > Try using the cts physics with the cup cars > > You mean cup cars with the BR tracks? > > Just want to make sure I understand what you're saying. =)
Well, that too, but what I really meant was using cts info with the cup cars, and then run the BR tracks. Since the BR tracks are made for the cts mod, it seems the cup cars work better(no snap) then. Link on how to do it, http://www.tptcc.com/board/viewtopic.php?t=4192&highlight=cts+cup Oh, and forgot this; the BR tracks also have some updates, which can help the feel with the cup cars left as is. But the updates are usually only found in the BR forum. Kind of a pita, but they do change things.
No, we're fighting with fixed setups that, shall we say, were not optimal for this track. -Larry "EL" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:ERoBc.25958$[email hidden]... > Did a race yesterday at Michigan and was 2 and 3 wide all race. Must beyour
Quoted text (9 lines)> drivers. > > EL > > > "Mitch_A" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:wNlBc.2598$[email hidden]... > > First off this isn't a Papy bashing post. That company did more for > > Simracing than any other period, and I for one do appreciate what
they've > > done that has given me many many thousands of hours of enjoyment (allthe > > way back to Indy 500 and every single title since). > > > > That being said I wonder why or what prevented Papy from giving us amore > > accurate experience. As I sit and watch the Michigan race I clearly see > > that Papy's efforts have a weakness that they NEVER over came. Each > > successive title improved (or hid) the weakness but it has always been > their > > since N1. The BR tracks again seem to just "hide" the issue notovercome > > it. > > > > My question (more for fun than anything) is what do you all think this > > inherent weakness is and why do you think Papy was never able to solveit? > > > > Mitch > > > > > >
Actually, I am willing to bet there are a lot more online racers than offline. At least for players that play the game regularly. Aren't WE all online racers? Gil
I'd bet yer wrong.....nothing interests me less than online racing. Well, I guess tennis, golf, hockey, basketball are less interesting. I race just about everyday. Phil "Gil Violette" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > Actually, I am willing to bet there are a lot more online racers than > offline. At least for players that play the game regularly. Aren't WE > all online racers? > > Gil
Tell you what. Give it a try - on your best track. Bet you find a good number of those online racers will leave you in the dust. There are some talented drivers out there. And, some wreckers, too! Just to keep it interesting. Gil

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy