Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

Daytona, N2, and Ebonics

38 posts by 27 people · 25 Feb 1997 - 22 Mar 1997

Notable threadWhy NASCAR 2 has no Daytona: copyright and add-on tracks

Eric Busch posted a joke 'translation' of Jim Sokoloff's repeated explanation of why Daytona is not in NASCAR Racing 2, sparking a long debate on track licensing and fan-made tracks. Sokoloff explained that distributing modified Papyrus track files infringes Papyrus's copyright, which it must defend, while a fully original track only raises issues with the real track's owner; tools that modify files already on the user's disk were acceptable. Most posters defended Sokoloff, though the thread ended with a user posting a hacked Daytona track as a binary.

With Jim Sokoloff (Papyrus)

mods/tracks/carsindustry/businessNASCAR Racing 2

Automated summary.

Eric Busch 25 Feb 1997#357348
The question of why there is no Daytona in N2 continually comes up despite the numerous answers (both official and otherwise). Perhaps it's just a language barrier of some sort? Anyway for the benifit of all, here is Jim Sokoloff's position once again (translated of course). Enjoy: "It's not Papyrus who be preventin' ya' fum racin' at Daytona. Sheeeiit... Sega gots'ta an 'slusive license t'use da damn dojigger and likesness uh Daytona fo' all fum Internashunal Speedway Co'p (owners uh de Daytona Internashunal Speedway). Daytona USA holds some license fum ISC t'use da damn Daytona track dojigger and likesness in deir 'eshibit, which Papyrus indeed dun did develop fo' dem. 'S coo', bro. Daytona USA's use apparently duzn't conflict wid de Sega license. What it is, Mama! Papyrus would love t'gots' Daytona available in our game, fo' our users t'play and enjoy; we'd love t'gots' Indy in our game, fo' our users t'play and enjoy. Slap mah fro! Unfo'tunately, Papyrus gots'ta been unable, by wo'kin' wid de co'po'ashuns controllin' de rights t'license dose propuh'ties, t'secure da damn rights t'use dose propuh'ties in our game. What it is, Mama! Given de above facts, how 'esactly do ya' arrive at da damn conclusion dat Papyrus be preventin' ya' fum havin' Daytona fo' N2?" ---Jim Sokoloff, Papyrus. ah' believe I'm speakin' 100 de trud here, but I'm not speakin' as Papyrus licensin' spokessucka' -- The IWCCCARS Project: Q & A Representative http://www.theuspits.com/iwcccars/index.html http://userwww.service.emory.edu/~ebusch/
Wade Tschi 25 Feb 1997#357349
Eric, I hope some hardware manufacturer releases some new stuff soon, " 'cuz yous gots way too much time on yo' hans, and yo brain is pumpin dawg ;-}. Happy Lappin' Wade Tschida
Quoted text (31 lines)>The question of why there is no Daytona in N2 continually comes up >despite the numerous answers (both official and otherwise). Perhaps >it's just a language barrier of some sort? Anyway for the benifit of >all, here is Jim Sokoloff's position once again (translated of course). > Enjoy: >"It's not Papyrus who be preventin' ya' fum racin' at Daytona. >Sheeeiit... >Sega gots'ta an 'slusive license t'use da damn dojigger and likesness >uh Daytona fo' all fum Internashunal Speedway Co'p (owners uh de >Daytona Internashunal Speedway). >Daytona USA holds some license fum ISC t'use da damn Daytona track >dojigger and likesness in deir 'eshibit, which Papyrus indeed dun did >develop fo' dem. 'S coo', bro. Daytona USA's use apparently duzn't >conflict wid de Sega license. What it is, Mama! >Papyrus would love t'gots' Daytona available in our game, fo' our users >t'play and enjoy; we'd love t'gots' Indy in our game, fo' our users >t'play and enjoy. Slap mah fro! Unfo'tunately, Papyrus gots'ta been >unable, by wo'kin' wid de co'po'ashuns controllin' de rights t'license >dose propuh'ties, t'secure da damn rights t'use dose propuh'ties in our >game. What it is, Mama! >Given de above facts, how 'esactly do ya' arrive at da damn conclusion >dat Papyrus be preventin' ya' fum havin' Daytona fo' N2?" >---Jim Sokoloff, Papyrus. ah' believe I'm speakin' 100 de trud here, >but I'm not speakin' as Papyrus licensin' spokessucka' >-- >The IWCCCARS Project: Q & A Representative >http://www.theuspits.com/iwcccars/index.html >http://userwww.service.emory.edu/~ebusch/
WELL EXCUSE US BUT .....If someone posted a Datona track or any others, INDY etc. who is the first to cry, and demand (advise) that the tracks be removed from their web sites?????? Jim Sokoloff, Nothing against Jim but facts are facts. Tell it like it is...... And if we can't get them from PAPY we should be able to get them from those who can make them. Papy still doesn't lose. We need their sim to run the tracks. Stop the mumbo jumbo!!!!!!
Jim Sokolo 26 Feb 1997#357464
[My original post filtered through 'jive' snipped...] I'm not doing it for my health... I'm merely advising folks as to what my perception of the law is. (Many people don't understand what constitutes infringement in intellectual property law, and I'm merely trying to save them potentially thousands of dollars in legal fees, civil and possibly criminal penalties.) With that in mind, I can tell you that posting or e-mailing one of our tracks, or a derivative of our tracks is infringing on copyright grounds. (Which is what I calmly advise people who ask for the "Indy" or other track in a public forum that I see.) Posting or e-mailing even a completely original Daytona track (which is not in ANY way derived from a Papyrus track, otherwise also see above paragraph) infringes on International Speedway Corp's trademark on the appearance, name and tradedress of the Daytona International Speedway. Papyrus will defend its intellectual property. (We'd prefer to never have to do it, but just as any company will defend its property, we will defend ours...) You can be DAMN sure that ISC will also defend its intellectual property. (And you can be pretty darn sure that Papyrus will co-operate if asked, since most infringements against ISC will probably involve derived tracks...) For the record, I've never demanded that anyone who was infringing do anything at all. I will take credit for advising them of my take on the legal issues involved, as I think that's the neighborly thing to do (assume that people aren't intending to break the law, and thus advise them that what they are doing is breaking the law)... So far, I've never had any reason to notify management at Papyrus that someone was infringing; it's always stopped at my e-mail to them. Everyone is their own person, and I am powerless to stop you from engaging in behavior which is infringing. However, if you knowingly infringe on Papyrus (or ISC or other licensor) property, I will support our lawyers' actions to uphold the law by stopping and/or penalizing you. Believe me, I can sympathize with the frustrations people feel about not having (and having no reasonable expectation of having in the short term) two of the Cup tracks for our simulation... But that doesn't mean I can advocate or condone lawlessness to "solve" the problem. After all, I'm not rich, but there's a bank nearby with PILES of money; why don't I just break into the bank and "solve" my problem? ---Jim Sokoloff, Papyrus, speaking as myself, for myself.
Quoted text (8 lines)> The question of why there is no Daytona in N2 continually comes up > despite the numerous answers (both official and otherwise). Perhaps > it's just a language barrier of some sort? Anyway for the benifit of > all, here is Jim Sokoloff's position once again (translated of course). > Enjoy: > "It's not Papyrus who be preventin' ya' fum racin' at Daytona. > Sheeeiit...
snip ROFLMAO!! hawaii: ingenious nro: pending
Mike White 26 Feb 1997#357466
<SNIP>
Quoted text (7 lines)> Posting or e-mailing even a completely original Daytona track (which > is not in ANY way derived from a Papyrus track, otherwise also see > above paragraph) infringes on International Speedway Corp's trademark > on the appearance, name and tradedress of the Daytona International > Speedway. > ---Jim Sokoloff, Papyrus, speaking as myself, for myself.
How about defunct race tracks? Ontario Motor Speedway. Ontario, CA. Any idea how long someone owns the rights to a non-existant entity? I believe I heard that before Nascar drivers "invaded" Indy the only testing on a simular track was Ontario. P.S. I was at the track the day Tom Sneva was the first (Indy Car) to run a 200 mph lap. -- MyKey
Richard Sco 27 Feb 1997#357577
Much cut and edited, but the gist is intact
Quoted text (22 lines)>[My original post filtered through 'jive' snipped...] >> Papy still doesn't lose. We need their sim to run the tracks. > Jim's Post: >With that in mind, I can tell you that posting or e-mailing one of our >tracks, or a derivative of our tracks is infringing on copyright >grounds. (Which is what I calmly advise people who ask for the "Indy" >or other track in a public forum that I see.) >Ifyou knowingly >infringe on Papyrus (or ISC or other licensor) property, I will >support our lawyers' actions to uphold the law by stopping and/or >penalizing you. >Believe me, I can sympathize with the frustrations people feel about >not having (and having no reasonable expectation of having in the >short term) two of the Cup tracks for our simulation... But that >doesn't mean I can advocate or condone lawlessness to "solve" the >problem. After all, I'm not rich, but there's a bank nearby with PILES >of money; why don't I just break into the bank and "solve" my problem? >---Jim Sokoloff, Papyrus, speaking as myself, for myself.
So, you're saying someone writing a track addition for use with your Sim is not right because it may stop you guys from making money in the future. Obviously these 'add-ons' aren't permitted for a reason. But if the tracks are a modification of one of yours, and posted for enjoyment <not profit> and enhance the popularity of the game, why would their be a problem? If Quake, Warcraft 2, and other games promote editors, why not Nascar Racing? And I seriously doubt you sympathize with frustrations, if in your own opinion you compare people on their own time for no profit creating tracks to make your sim better, with lawless sorts. Get real. You guys make a hell of a Sim, but everything interrelated to that makes you seem like businessmen first. That's what will stop you from ever crossing over into the top tier of *** companies, like Blizzard and ID. They're there for the *** community. You guys are there first as a business. Get a clue. I appreciate you guys shooting from the hip, but I wish you'd for once put the gamers first. Wishful thinking I guess, coupled by all the Offline league features you torpedoed in Nascar 2. But you feel our frustrations.... Right. Richard Scott
TOlson94 27 Feb 1997#357578
It's not only Papyrus, but also the track owners would get mad. There are editors for Warcraft 2 and Quake because you can make all the levels you want, and not violate any licenses .None of the monsters in Quake own a license to any of the levels you could create, and the Orcs aren't going to get mad at you for making your own version of Azeroth ;). ID and Blizzard would still be as great as they are now, even if they didn't include any editors.
CPDRKITEKT 27 Feb 1997#357579
Hey Jim, For your own sanity, give it up. You're never going to get these people to quit ***in'. As I am fond of saying, "You can please some of the people some of the time,***the rest." Some of us know it's not in your power to produce Daytona and Indy at this time, and those that can't understand it, even though it has been discussed to DEATH, obviously have little real world experience with business. Thanks for you input in this newsgroup. ChrisP
R. Beutnage 27 Feb 1997#357580
Eric: Please give Mr. Sokoloff a break here.....he has helped many of us with problems and has been a gentleman in all respects. This man is only trying to help and often helping involves explaining. His explainations with regard to intellectual property law and trademark law (likeness to Daytona Speedways "touch and feel"). He has been very calm and civil as far as I've seen. He is right, and he is kind enough to explain things in a way which might keep a legally nieve person from being forced to climb courthouse steps. I know a little about intellectual property law, trademark and copyright law. What people must realize is that the law "requires" property owners to persue those who infringe. If owners do not persue infringers the owner could "lose" his ownership of those properties. In other words.....if the owner is aware of infringements but choses to ignore the infringing ( because he doesn't want to appear as a bad guy, or because he doesn't like lawyers or judges or legal fees...or whatever ) he could lose his rights later on. The owner "must" persue all infringers even if he would rather not. It is the way the law works. By not aggressively persueing infringers it appears as though the owner "abandons" his property and it could become public domain as a result. There is currently a lot of controversy regarding Paramounts notification of Star Trek related websites. Paramount ( I hear ) has required such sites to remove trademarked material to the dismay of us all, but they must do this or lose their rights. I don't know if Paramount is doing this reluctantly or out of a sense of power but it matters not they "must" persue infringer whether they want to or not. Did I explain this right Mr. S.? ***********************************************************************
Quoted text (17 lines)> The question of why there is no Daytona in N2 continually comes up > despite the numerous answers (both official and otherwise). Perhaps > it's just a language barrier of some sort? Anyway for the benifit of > all, here is Jim Sokoloff's position once again (translated of course). > Enjoy: > <<<<<<snip snip >>>>>>>>>>>> > Given de above facts, how 'esactly do ya' arrive at da damn conclusion > dat Papyrus be preventin' ya' fum havin' Daytona fo' N2?" > ---Jim Sokoloff, Papyrus. ah' believe I'm speakin' 100 de trud here, > but I'm not speakin' as Papyrus licensin' spokessucka' > -- > The IWCCCARS Project: Q & A Representative > http://www.theuspits.com/iwcccars/index.html > http://userwww.service.emory.edu/~ebusch/
-- +----------------------------------------------------+ _ | - | / )| - | / / | - Name : Rick Beutnagel | (\\\\ \_/ / | \ /--------------------------------------------------+ \ _/ / / / / =========
RWF0 27 Feb 1997#357581
Just my two cents worth-- I fthose guys who make the tracks are smart enough and dedicated enough to do what they have done then I say GREAT! And I appreciate them for adding to and helping us all out, allbeit technically illegal as it has been stated in original message. So if editing tracks is illegal then I suppose any and every change or "patch" not made by Papy/Sierra is also wrong... i.e. the mirror patch, changing driver settings, editing calendar files -- you get the picture. Get real--Papy/Sierra. Better yet read the manual on customer satisfaction/support. Don't blaze the guys who are doing something when your companies do so little once the product hits the street. I do love the sim, don't take me wrong. I'd just like to have some support for the things the customer wants, needs or dreams for! After we-- we pay the bills, right? My thanks go out to ALL the guys/gals who do a little editing to make a great game better, more playable, ect. Papy/Sierra-- cut those guys a check for doing your job ;) Xducer aka-- Roger F.
racet.. 27 Feb 1997#357582
[snip] [snip] The problem is not with Papyrus, Richard... The problem is with the *tracks* and the *owners* of the tracks... If they could, don't you think Papyrus would LOVE to put out Daytona and Indy? Write to IMS and Daytona and tell them what a huge marketing opportunity they are missing... tell them not to renew their exclusive agreements with lousy arcade game producers... tell them the real fans who will buy tickets want to run a SIMULATION, not play a game.... - Mike. ================================================================ = R.I.P. Scott Brayton: February 20, 1959 - May 17, 1996 = R.I.P. Jeff Krosnoff: September 24, 1964 - July 14, 1996 = R.I.P. Jim Chapman: January 24, 1916 - October 10, 1996 ================================================================
Jim Sokolo 27 Feb 1997#357583
The problem with technically illegal is it can cause you near endless hassles... And for a lot of the things that people are doing, there are ways to do it which are not illegal. (Some of the things people are doing, I can think of a way to make legal... :-) ) That's not true at all. First of all, editting tracks is not (in and of itself) illegal, and we've never maintained that it was. Distributing derivative works without the copyright holders permission is illegal, and we're forced to take steps to maintain our copyrights. In addition, several types of third-party patch programs are completely legal. (Basically, anything that doesn't involve bundling of copyrighted material.) So, if someone were to (to pick a wild example) write a converter that took Indy and converted it to ICR2 and N1, and distributed only the converter program (and not the Indy track), there'd be no problem with Papyrus copyrights. Same with the guy who wrote the Taladega->Daytona program, since he didn't include the Talladega track with it, Papyrus doesn't have any legal ground to stop him from distributing it. (NB: I don't know what ISC's position on this is, and I don't have a law degree, so I can't really say this guy is "in the clear", but at least he's not violating Papyrus copyrights... :-) ) If someone wrote a patch program to make the dates appear to be 1997 dates, and distributed it as a patch, we couldn't stop them. (But distributing a pre-patched executable wouldn't be OK under copyright law...) We are working on a patch, to address several shortfalls in the 1.00 release of N2. And yes, you and all the other customers do pay the bills (and thus, my salary) and for that I thank you. ---Jim Sokoloff, Papyrus
Jim Sokolo 27 Feb 1997#357584
Did I say that? Where? "Because it would stop us from making money in the future" is not the reason. "Because it violates our copyrights, which we are forced by law to defend or risk losing." is the reason. The notion that non-profit items are somehow "less infringing" is a fallacy. (It might make a judge more sympathetic to you when awarding damages, but it doesn't make it legal...) That was an analogy, purposely chosen to be a little extreme. (You could read Rich Stallman's stuff, and come up with a bunch of reasons why my analogy is imperfect. But you don't need to bother with that, since I'll admit that an intellectual property theft is not *AS* damaging as a physical property theft, but it's still damaging...) As far as I can tell, the real difference is that our types of games brush all too closely with lawyers, and the law and the *** community are most comfortable when they are separated by a distance... You can be sure that Id is agressively pursuing the folks who "liberated" the source code to Quake (oh no, wait, that wasn't done for profit, I guess it's OK... :-) ) The first patch addresses some of the off-line gamers concerns. (No doubt it doesn't address all of them, but it will demonstrate to some rational people (perhaps not to the *** theorists) that off-line leagues are not being sabatoged by Papyrus.) ---Jim Sokoloff, Papyrus
Mike Radl 27 Feb 1997#357585
<Level headed response to a previous post snipped> Ok Jim, that's it! Your not a programmer for Papy!!! You are obviously a cleverly disguised PR guy for Sierra. Either that, or you have an endless amount of patience ;-)
Richard Sco 27 Feb 1997#357586
If we want to simulate small, local tracks, or larger tracks and not put any copyright infringement, where would there be a problem. I'm not saying rebuilding Daytona and putting it on the web. That would obviously by wrong. But our own creations with no copyright infringements. I can understand the fine line Papyrus is walking with the legalese, but what can and can't we do? I understand Intellectual Property and it is important. However, modifying tracks to me is borderline. It would only enhance the game and raise Papy's popularity. The game is great, but I guess there are always other tracks people would love to see :) After all, whats a Nascar Season without 3 of the major tracks?? Richard Scott says...
If someone made "Jim Bob's 1/2 mile oval, I doubt Papy would mind as long as they made it totally by scratch. Not a modified Bristol or Martinsville. ANd if you'd been around for a while, you'd know if Papy released their track editor, 99.95% of the prople couldn't use it without four years of training. Mike
Tom Hansen 27 Feb 1997#357588
Jim's statement here is being misinterpreted by the follow on posts here. The statement here is not that producing a home made track that is not using Papyrus' bits is infringing - but rather that producing a home built track for Daytona, Indy or any other actual speedway may infringe on the track's copyrights. I believe that producing a Thompson Speedway for N2 would cause no problems - unless Thompson Speedway complained - which I doubt they would. Producing a high profile track like Daytona would of course cause problems. Papyrus MUST play be the rules or there existing license with drivers/tracks etc. would be at risk. This is an untenable situation for Papy - since no one would buy racing sims without real drivers or tracks - now would they ? Papy MUST thereby support a track in their action against someone producing an unlicensed replica of the track. In summary - producing low profile tracks for N2 will likely cause no problems at all. Heck - its just free advertising for the track. I suspect an author of such a track could even contact the speedway and get clearance to distribute it. Daytona could never give this clearance due to their contract with Sega. /THansen
Jim Sokolo 27 Feb 1997#357589
Yes, that's a good clarification of a point which I glossed over. A completely original track, using no Papyrus intellectual property, doesn't infringe on us, and at that point, you must only concern yourself with the owner(s) of the real track you are modelling (if applicable). Thanks, Tom. (for pointing out the source of (some of) the confusion) ---Jim, Papyrus
I really hate to even get in on this because I am tired of hearing about the lack of certain tracks in the game. From all the posts I have seen here, there are basically two problems that I see that prevents us from having these tracks. #1) By distributing, Papyrus included, sim tracks with the likeness of <insert track name> (I won't say the D word) you are infringing on the copyright of the track's. #2) By distributing sim tracks that are derivatives of the originals you are infringing upon papyrus copyrights. Solution: As Jim S. has already said "editting tracks is not (in and of itself) illegal". Therefore, Papyrus should develop and release a track editor. It is in everybodys best interest, Papyrus included, in my opinion. I don't buy the argument that it would be too difficult for people to use. I just downloaded an editor for another racing game (MTM). Either that or they could release specifications for the track files to enable somebody else to develop one. This would solve both problems. With a track editor, users could create their own tracks in whatever likeness they choose as long as they did not distribute them. If somebody did distribute one, they would be at risk of copyright violations. What I would like to know is, what is Papyrus's "real" hangup with creating one. Brad
ccorpor 27 Feb 1997#357591
> If we want to simulate small, local tracks, or larger tracks and not put any > copyright infringement, where would there be a problem. I'm not saying > rebuilding Daytona and putting it on the web. That would obviously by wrong. > But our own creations with no copyright infringements. > I can understand the fine line Papyrus is walking with the legalese, but what > can and can't we do? REPLY: Since I'm bored.... Can't somebody build a track with similarities of Daytuna, without any props saying it is as such. Somebody else build billboards and logos with Daytuna on it. I doubt anybody has the rights to the word Daytuna, if so have it where we can type anything we like on the darn thing and I'll type Daytuna Somebody else the buildings and stands, who cares it there missing the last 10 rows or a few office cubicals. Then the user can put them together if they choose in the privacy of their own house and come up with a poor man's unofficial Daytuna? I mean I'm sure the tracks we have from papy aren't exact duplicates on how the track actually feels, please don't take offense but IMO to make it just like the track is impossible. So where already playing on tracks that are ideas in our heads of what the actual track may be like and that's all I ask anyways. Altered Reality. Sorta like a bomb. You can buy all the ingredients and it's up to you what you want to do with them. Or more in the line of this business a NBA game with Jordan in it. Most don't have him in it because of licensing. But they have this unknown guy out there that is awesome who just so happens to play shooting gaurd for the Bulls who doesn't follow suit with the other players in terms of matching on the roster. They also included this thing called an editor where you can change the name and the number of that shooting gaurd. Guess what everybody in America does? I refuse to answer (under oath), but you know!! The funny thing is at the end this guy who was basically nameless at the start even looks like MJ himself. You see those companies aren't allowed to put MJ in the game but they have all the bits and pieces in place so the person at home can do whatever they like. It's called creative planning. Q.B.M.
Robert 27 Feb 1997#357592
Give Jim a break? Good grief, Charlie Brown! Did you miss the intent of his post? Eric just tried to put Jim's reasons into a language that some of the readers here could understand. Since Jim, and others, have tried to explain it in English, to little or no avail, Eric put it into the latest craze, " Ebonics ". He was in no was being discourteous to Jim, but making fun of the dullards who just don't get it. While you obviously have a fine grasp on the laws involved, your grasp of humor is severely lacking. His post was, I believe, his way of calling those who still can't grasp the idea of copyright laws, well, less than intelligent. But then again , I could be mistaken.
Eric Busch 27 Feb 1997#357593
Jim has stated that modifying tracks is fine, as long as you only distribute something like an automated utility that uses the files from the existing tracks on the users HD to make the changes (this has been done in the past). If you start distributing parts of the existing Papyrus created (hence copyrighted) tracks, that's where the trouble begins. -- The IWCCCARS Project: Q & A Representative http://www.theuspits.com/iwcccars/index.html http://userwww.service.emory.edu/~ebusch/
Kel 27 Feb 1997#357595
Quoted text (9 lines)> >Obviously these 'add-ons' aren't permitted for a reason. But > >if the tracks are a modification of one of yours, and posted for > >enjoyment <not profit> and enhance the popularity of the game, why > >would their be a problem? If Quake, Warcraft 2, and other games > >promote editors, why not Nascar Racing? > "Because it would stop us from making money in the future" is not the > reason. "Because it violates our copyrights, which we are forced by > law to defend or risk losing." is the reason.
Hi Jim. Ok, then why not the same "laws" for creating and distributing cars and carsets? I think it's because the car owners see a good thing coming in terms of advertising themselves :) Obviously Datona see's it differently. And how does it violate "your" copyright laws if "someone else" puts out a fictious track that may drive just like Datona but looks nothing at all like it? Again I keep going back to the cars that are being made all the time and handed out freely. Just a curious question Jim. I have no real probs with N2 that can't be fixed with a little text editing here and there. You guys DO make a hell of a Sim and I'm not complaining about it at all :-) Kel Calgary, Alberta CANADA
Jim Sokolo 28 Feb 1997#357702
[snipped for brevity; it's still on dejanews if anyone really cares] There are the same laws; the teams choose not to enforce those laws. (Probably because no one else if offering them multiple millions of dollars for the license to use their car *exclusively* over three years... :-) ) If the fictitious track is "derivative work" from a Papyrus track, you would need our permission (as the copyright holder on the original work) to distribute it. If it is a completely original work, you don't need that permission... (Every non-Papyrus track effort I've ever seen has been based on a Papyrus track [presumably for technical reasons], but it doesn't mean that every one in the future will be...) ---Jim Sokoloff, Papyrus
Greg Cisko 28 Feb 1997#357703
Jim, Thanks for explaining this. I was quietly sitting back and wondering what you guys thought about the converters & such. It is now clear that things can be done in a reasonable way. Greg
David Spark 28 Feb 1997#357704
Quoted text (7 lines)>So, you're saying someone writing a track addition for use with your >Sim is not right because it may stop you guys from making money in the >future. Obviously these 'add-ons' aren't permitted for a reason. But >if the tracks are a modification of one of yours, and posted for >enjoyment <not profit> and enhance the popularity of the game, why >would their be a problem? If Quake, Warcraft 2, and other games >promote editors, why not Nascar Racing?
You need a grounding in intellectual property law to understand the issue here, but I'll try to explain it. If Papyrus knows of an infringement, and they fail to take action against the infringing party, then they can lose the rights to that property and anyone can do what they want with it. This is the logical extension to "squatter's rights" to intellectual property. It gets even more complicated when it's a licensed property, such as the name and likeness of a track. Now both the licenser and licensee may have contractual obligations to defend the property against infringement. So its possible that if Papyrus doesn't take action against infringers who use the Talladega track to create a likeness of Daytona, they could conceivably lose the rights to use Talladega as well. Dave Sparks IWCCCARS Project: http://www.theuspits.com/iwcccars Late Night League: http://www.sequoia-dev.com/Hawaii/latenite.html Hawaii Handle: davids
Don Mullin 28 Feb 1997#357705
snip snip snip Hmmmm. A track editor perhaps? :) -- Todo Es Justo En Amor Y Carreras. The Rusty Wallace Miller Lite stock car, awsome when opened up! GO#2! Mullins Motorsports Inc. http://www.***tron.com/~ddmj
Quoted text (12 lines)> Hey Jim, > For your own sanity, give it up. You're never going to get these people > to quit ***in'. As I am fond of saying, "You can please some of the > people some of the time,***the rest." Some of us know it's not in > your power to produce Daytona and Indy at this time, and those that can't > understand it, even though it has been discussed to DEATH, obviously have > little real world experience with business. > Thanks for you input in this newsgroup. > ChrisP
I think most have little real world experience period. The majority of the whiners sound like ten year old kids whose internet time should be monitored by their wayward parents. And now I must add the obligatory 'Sentence of Filler Crap' in order for my little post to leave my system. Seems that I must have more NEW text that what I am replying to. Maybe this is enough now... Jim
ymenard 08 Mar 1997#358512
Quoted text (7 lines)> It's not only Papyrus, but also the track owners would get mad. There are > editors for Warcraft 2 and Quake because you can make all the levels you > want, and not violate any licenses .None of the monsters in Quake own a > license to any of the levels you could create, and the Orcs aren't going > to get mad at you for making your own version of Azeroth ;). ID and > Blizzard would still be as great as they are now, even if they didn't > include any editors.
Yeah but if you make the Daytona track for Quake... (like in Duke3d) :) Good race at the Brickyard, (Old'Indytrack guy) [===] Go Rubens Barrichello, Jacques Villeneuve, | ! | And all you that thinks that Jacques Villeneuve is |!| from Canada, your right!! He's from St-Jean sur le |o| Richelieu, 30 minutes from Montreal, Quebec, Canada. [--I--] v Fran?ois Mnard "Wasupe LeGrand" Nien Numb in the National Star Wars League(X-Wing vs Tie-Fighter league) http://www.theuspits.com/iwcccars/index.html http://userwww.service.emory.edu/~ebusch/ Star Wars Trilogy Special Edition,N2,Gp2,Icr2.How can my life be better? May the force be with you, always!! Que la force soit avec toi, jamais!(for you French people) Excuse me for my poor English(I'm French speaking)
ymenard 08 Mar 1997#358513
I think Jim is playing with his words. It's not the first time that Jim is writting this kind of things. He has a talent of showing between two lines the futures projects of Papyrus. The F1 historic sim was subtilly inserted in one of his post. So it's probably true. But here's another question. If it's real that the second patch of Papyrus will come with a track editor, new tracks, etc... how will it be free?? Everyone here thinks that it could be inserted in less then 10 meg!! I think it will be in a Cd-rom. thanks a lot, Good race at the Brickyard, (Old'Indytrack guy) [===] Go Rubens Barrichello, Jacques Villeneuve, | ! | And all you that thinks that Jacques Villeneuve is |!| from Canada, your right!! He's from St-Jean sur le |o| Richelieu, 30 minutes from Montreal, Quebec, Canada. [--I--] v Fran?ois Mnard "Wasupe LeGrand" Nien Numb in the National Star Wars League(X-Wing vs Tie-Fighter league) http://www.dakotacom.net/~strange/ http://www.starwars.com/ Star Wars Trilogy Special Edition,N2,Gp2,Icr2.How can my life be better? May the force be with you, always!! Que la force soit avec toi, jamais!(for you French people) Excuse me for my poor English(I'm French speaking)
PPut 22 Mar 1997#360331
so make the editor so u cant over write any of the old tracks #2 and make it to where its like the paint kit ? #3 Jim is this that big of a prob to do ?
PPut 22 Mar 1997#360332
also EVERYONE hear this i am almost done with a Daytona track 4 nascar2 along with a calender file so u have Daytona as the first race of the year i will post it in a mint so get it while its there the owner of this group will take it off when papy tell them to :) spread this track around!
<snip> : i will post it in a mint so get it while its there the owner of this group : will take it off when papy tell them to :) Just a minor point. No one person owns this group. If you are talking about "large binaries" getting removed, this is done because this is a discussion group, not a binaries group. If you want to post "legitimate" sim related binaries, use alt.binaries.simulators.autos If you are planning on posting files which violate international copyright laws or licensing agreements, please find a "warez" binaries group. As it stands now, alot of folks don't have ISP's that carry alt.binaries.simulators.autos (though if they request it, their ISP may start). However, if a.b.s.a. becomes a haven for binaries which violate copyright or licensing agreements, many ISP's that do carry it will drop it like a hot potato(e) [sorry D. Quayle]. We own this group and "we" control it. -- **************************** Michael E. Carver ************************* Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town. =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
Quoted text (7 lines)> also EVERYONE hear this i am almost done with a Daytona track 4 nascar2 > along with a calender file so u have Daytona as the first race of the year > i will post it in a mint so get it while its there the owner of this group > will take it off when papy tell them to :) > spread this track around!
WHERE....?????? WHAT'S THE URL????? YOU FORGOT TO TELL US WHEEERRRREEEEE ???????????!!!!!!!!!
Joel 22 Mar 1997#360335
guys take that datona track and put it uin a dir called daytonab than take and copy your taladega dat file and go into it as text rename all taladega names to daytonab than place that in your daytonab dir that i posted and u have daytonab i will xplain better later have fun gota go
Joel 22 Mar 1997#360336
This is a multi-part message in MIME format. --------------6DB33DA7126C Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit here it is il try again --------------6DB33DA7126C Content-Type: application/x-zip-compressed; name="Daytona.zip" Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64 Content-Disposition: inline; filename="Daytona.zip" <encoded_portion_removed> TjJCUEsFBgAAAAAbABsA3QUAAEaZAQAAAA== --------------6DB33DA7126C--

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy