Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

No save race part2-READ!!

24 posts by 10 people · 09 Dec 1996 - 13 Dec 1996

Is saving a race cheating? NASCAR 2 save debate continues

Posters debated whether a save-race feature undermines realism and offline league integrity or is simply a practical necessity. Many suggested a 'save race weekend' option between sessions as a compromise, and some proposed that saved races be flagged for league use.

online racing/leaguesreview/impressionsNASCAR Racing 2

Automated summary.

chaspa.. 09 Dec 1996#347133
I also suspected that time constraints were probably the culprits behind this..I'm sure that big-daddy Sierra wanted the game out by Christmas....but if I were on the team I would have fought for this critical feature. I love all the new features of the game also but would have given some up (the spotter for example) for the monumental importance of the save race option. I bought Indycar 1 when it first came out and it didn't have a save race feature,when Indycar2 was in the works I was informed it would have that option, and I bought that game SOLELY because it now included it. All the other improvements to ICR2 were just a bonus to me. I hate to be so critical as I have loved all your sims..but please reconsider a possible patch for this. I honestly believe that as the initial release "high" begins to fade and all your customers get down to RACING Nas2...your company is going to be swamped by complaints and/or requests for this. Perhaps you can include it in a future track pack (Daytona when the Sega contract is up?) Please mention this to your team and thanks for your reply and honesty....you guys are still great!!! I'm a Nascar freak and this is my dream game!!! Chuck Brennan
I personally don't think there should be a save race feature because what is the point of running a full length race if someone is going break it up into pieces. You don't see real drivers stopping dead in the middle of the track to take a coffee brake, so why should sim racers be allowed to do it? I feel that part of the reason that makes some real drivers so good, such as Senna, is because they can concentrate for the whole duration of the race, not just for a few laps. If we are allowed to save the race, then this aspect of racing would not come into play, which to me is not real racing. Lawrence Lo
Greg Berge 09 Dec 1996#347135
Only problem with that, Larry, is that not all of us have 4 consecutive hours to kill in front of the computer. With that kind of thinking, should flight sim games be more realistic by including the eight hour or more flight to get to where the mission is? And of course, no save game feature, 'cause pilots don't have that option. ~G
>I also suspected that time constraints were probably the culprits behind >this..I'm sure that big-daddy Sierra wanted the game out by >Christmas....but if I were on the team I would have fought for this >critical feature. I love all the new features of the game also but would >have given some up (the spotter for example) for the monumental importance what? give up the spotter for save race option? are you crazy?? ;) You're kidding right? that's like buying a flight sim SOLEY because you could save your flight in progress. If that's all that's important to you, stick with Nascar 1, none of the features in Nascar 2 would be worth anything to you anyways. personally, I am GLAD there isn't a save race feature. Nascar 1 has a way of letting you save the game and start under yellow and avoid going a lap down. sooo, glad it's gone! one less way for the cheaters!
I agree with you! Even having to pause the game (due to the other half not understanding the meaning of 110% concentration) will drop my lap speeds off dramatically for a few laps until I can "get back into the rhythm." I hate to pause the game (But that's necessary due to phone calls, etc) and I REALLY hate to save the game off. however, in the old version, I have run 200+ lap races at, say, N.Wilkes, and had it crash halfway thru it. run again, 100+ laps later, crash. then I would run to the first caution, SAVE GAME, and run until the next crash. very frustrating. hopefully N2 won't do that to me.
Quoted text (32 lines)> I personally don't think there should be a save race feature because what > is the point of running a full length race if someone is going break it up > into pieces. You don't see real drivers stopping dead in the middle of > the track to take a coffee brake, so why should sim racers be allowed to > do it? I feel that part of the reason that makes some real drivers so > good, such as Senna, is because they can concentrate for the whole > duration of the race, not just for a few laps. If we are allowed to save > the race, then this aspect of racing would not come into play, > which to me is not real racing. > Lawrence Lo > > I also suspected that time constraints were probably the culprits behind > > this..I'm sure that big-daddy Sierra wanted the game out by > > Christmas....but if I were on the team I would have fought for this > > critical feature. I love all the new features of the game also but would > > have given some up (the spotter for example) for the monumental importance > > of the save race option. I bought Indycar 1 when it first came out and it > > didn't have a save race feature,when Indycar2 was in the works I was > > informed it would have that option, and I bought that game SOLELY because > > it now included it. All the other improvements to ICR2 were just a bonus > > to me. I hate to be so critical as I have loved all your sims..but please > > reconsider a possible patch for this. I honestly believe that as the > > initial release "high" begins to fade and all your customers get down to > > RACING Nas2...your company is going to be swamped by complaints and/or > > requests for this. Perhaps you can include it in a future track pack > > (Daytona when the Sega contract is up?) Please mention this to your team > > and thanks for your reply and honesty....you guys are still great!!! I'm a > > Nascar freak and this is my dream game!!! Chuck Brennan
If you want to run a full game without saving then you wont have to use the feature ,but for us WE WANT A SAVE GAME FEATURE!!!If I feel like making the game truly realistic I will set aside the four hours to run a full race nonstop just like the pros do.All I am saying is that It would be great to have this feature in the game.Almost all games have a way to save them in progress.It cant hurt to have it . Steve T
Robert 10 Dec 1996#347392
Sorry to seem crude, but last I heard Senna is dead, killed in a crash. When was the last time you were killed in a Nascar crash? Real racing? Good grief Charlie Brown!! This is not real racing. Real simulated racing, not real racing. Don't make me give up living in the real world just so I can escape into the virtual one once in awhile. If you don't want to save your game, fine, don't. But don't you dare press that Pause key either. Gotta go pee? Just do it in your seat. You are a real racer, right? Can't go to the john at 190+ mph, now can you? Race em' all at 100% strength and 100% length, or not at all. Got your fire retardant suit on? Is your house tempature set to 130 degrees? Want to be real, don't we? Perhaps it's time we did. Get real, I mean. Don't hold us to that ' real racers can't, so you can't ' ideal. Life, outside of being a real Nascar driver, is just a little more complicated for the rest of us. Their job is behind that wheel, in the heat and the noise, and they can't afford to ' take a coffee break ' in the middle of the race. I, on the other hand, can afford to get out of my computer chair and go to the fridge and the restroom every so often. And maybe even go into the office every once in a while to see if I was missed.
Robert 10 Dec 1996#347393
Ok, yes, Papy screwed up the origional save game option. Instead of grouping the cars together again, then restarting, they should have just remembered where you were, and made you start from there. Cheating, if it can be called that, was possible. But how did my restarting a game from a previous, unfinished race affect you? It didn't. IF the option were there, it would only be for the single player modes, not multi. What business is it of yours if I save then restart a game? None at all. Guess you want to take all the cheat codes out of the shootem' up games too, huh? Fix them damn cheaters for sure!!
Quoted text (9 lines)>> personally, I am GLAD there isn't a save race feature. Nascar 1 has a >> way of letting you save the game and start under yellow and avoid >> going a lap down. sooo, glad it's gone! one less way for the >> cheaters! >Ok, yes, Papy screwed up the origional save game option. Instead of >grouping the cars together again, then restarting, they should have just >remembered where you were, and made you start from there. Cheating, if it >can be called that, was possible.
yep, that's a problem. However, if they could do the saved game feature where everything was "the way it was", I might add, throw in the last 3-4 laps in realtime replay with the***pit view (so you get the feel again) it would be perfect. Otherwise, you've lost your rhythm. If you were racing in an offline series, it's a big deal. I was, dunno about yourself. so yes, it affected me bigtime. Personally, I don't play shootem' up games. If it isn't a simulation, I don't bother with it (not a doom fan either!) hey, these are just *my* opinions, not the stone hard facts or anything.
Robert 11 Dec 1996#347649
I don't, and won't race in an offline series. How do I know how clever you are with your hex editor? So what you are saying is, unless they beat you in real time, they cheated( saved their games )? If someone can figure out how to set rear stagger with a hex editor, surely there are people out there who can monkey with the... well whatever it is you guys use to validate your races.
Dave Kayl 11 Dec 1996#347650
Quoted text (30 lines)>>> personally, I am GLAD there isn't a save race feature. Nascar 1 has a >>> way of letting you save the game and start under yellow and avoid >>> going a lap down. sooo, glad it's gone! one less way for the >>> cheaters! >>Ok, yes, Papy screwed up the origional save game option. Instead of >>grouping the cars together again, then restarting, they should have just >>remembered where you were, and made you start from there. Cheating, if it >>can be called that, was possible. >yep, that's a problem. However, if they could do the saved game >feature where everything was "the way it was", I might add, throw in >the last 3-4 laps in realtime replay with the***pit view (so you get >the feel again) it would be perfect. Otherwise, you've lost your >rhythm. >>But how did my restarting a game from a previous, unfinished race affect >>you? It didn't. IF the option were there, it would only be for the single >>player modes, not multi. What business is it of yours if I save then >>restart a game? None at all. >If you were racing in an offline series, it's a big deal. I was, >dunno about yourself. so yes, it affected me bigtime. >>Guess you want to take all the cheat codes out of the shootem' up games >>too, huh? Fix them damn cheaters for sure!! >Personally, I don't play shootem' up games. If it isn't a >simulation, I don't bother with it (not a doom fan either!) hey, >these are just *my* opinions, not the stone hard facts or anything.
Well i personally miss the saved game feature very much. If the reason they did it was because of the offline series why not put something in the file that shows it had been saved. Then the people on the series would know who cheated and the rest of us could enjoy the game we like ourselves. Just my 2 cents. Dave K.
>I don't, and won't race in an offline series. How do I know how clever you >are with your hex editor? So what you are saying is, unless they beat you >in real time, they cheated( saved their games )? If someone can figure out >how to set rear stagger with a hex editor, surely there are people out >there who can monkey with the... well whatever it is you guys use to >validate your races. well, to be honest with you, you have a good point there. That's one reason why the IVGA exists. When the top 15 drivers in the standings finish 100% of ALL laps and have ZERO dnf's it starts to sound fishy. especially when they "win" their races 90-95% of the time. (not an overall win... if you don't "win" you can forget getting even a top-15 most weeks)
>Well i personally miss the saved game feature very much. If the reason >they did it was because of the offline series why not put something in >the file that shows it had been saved. Then the people on the series >would know who cheated and the rest of us could enjoy the game we like >ourselves. Just my 2 cents. Dave K. hey, you got a good point there. I know Don Wilshe pushed for it, and a lot of other Nascar Racing offline series directors did as well. I believe they are checking it on Hawaii and probably the NRO as well (basically the same thing IVGA does, only "sanctioned" by Sierra of course :) my only beef with the save game feature is the way it worked in Nascar 1. If they could improve that, it'd be worth it. Obviously, from the word from Adam, it appears to get it to the point would take more than just a few lines of code, else it would have been there...
<snip> : personally, I am GLAD there isn't a save race feature. Nascar 1 has a : way of letting you save the game and start under yellow and avoid : going a lap down. sooo, glad it's gone! one less way for the : cheaters! : I for the life of me can not figure out what everyone means by saying it is "cheating" to save a race in progress. Just who the hell is someone cheating if they do that. I certainly ain't cheating you or any other driver out there. If I opt to save a game that is between me and myself. Sometimes I would let myself and other times I would forbid it. Get off your high horses and quit telling the rest of us that it is cheating to save a race in progress. If the option is there and you consider it cheating then don't use it. But don't deny others who wish this option the chance to save a race just because you lack the will to not use it. -- **************************** Michael E. Carver ************************* Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town. =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
Quoted text (9 lines)>> If you were racing in an offline series, it's a big deal. I was, >> dunno about yourself. so yes, it affected me bigtime. >I don't, and won't race in an offline series. How do I know how clever you >are with your hex editor? So what you are saying is, unless they beat you >in real time, they cheated( saved their games )? If someone can figure out >how to set rear stagger with a hex editor, surely there are people out >there who can monkey with the... well whatever it is you guys use to >validate your races.
If you ran an offline series race at Martinsville and someone's results reported that they had encountered four yellow flags for a total of four laps, would you be suspicious of "cheating"? Obviously, since a typical yellow at Martinsville lasts far more than one lap. Something funny is going on here. This problem cropped up on the NASCAR Racing League series on the Papyrus BBS (running most of 1995). We were running with yellow flags on and using the average race speed to determine places. Avoiding yellows was important, and minimizing the length of them also helped. Unfortunately, this isn't the sort of "cheating" that requires a hex editor and a hacker's mind. That was *how the game save feature was implemented* in NASCAR1 (and ICR2). If you saved at the beginning of a caution, you only ran one lap of caution per yellow flag. Hardly fair to those who ran the full 2-4 laps at reduced speeds. The problem was that, while you might *suspect* that laps under the yellow may have been "shaved", there was no way to *verify* the degree or amount. It was a loophole in the game, one that has been closed now. ;) Pick one or more: Model Rockets (competition-NERCB) / PCs (even Atari!) / Papyrus ICR-ICR2-NCR / Who needs a life when you have multiple non-lives?
Robert 12 Dec 1996#347909
And I thought the IVGA was just established so that <name deleted> could steal all the best setups? :-) I joined it so I could get a number to run the HotLap program with. Ran it a few times, and even uploaded one. Never saw it posted, and while it was not the fastest by any means, it was faster than some of the slowest ones. Didn't get any sort of response, so I said***it, and deleted the thing off my computer. And then all the ***about Papy banning the IVGA members ( please, please, don't save me $500 a year ) and the email started...... Oh, kinda lost track there for a sec... ANYWAY...... give me back my save game please. The only person I could possibly cheat is myself, and I don't rightly give a hoot.
Robert 12 Dec 1996#347910
Again, you are assuming that I want to ' Race by E-mail '. I don't, and won't. Ok, so because the minority of the Nascar racers race in off-line series, the majority of racers just have to suck it up? You work for the affirmative action council or something? Does this mean that because Pres. Clinton got more votes, he lost? If you are so scared that they are cheating, just quit. I don't want the old save feature, but I would take it over the current offering. The rat bastards cheated, and should be killed. But please, let those of us who don't play by e-mail keep some sort of save game.
It seems obvious that NASCAR2 should only contain what *you* want it to contain, because everyone else's wishes are subordinate to yours. I wasn't trying to change your mind, just explain the problems of a race save. But you chose to ignore it and go off on a rant since it doesn't apply to you. So long as we know where we stand... ;) Pick one or more: Model Rockets (competition-NERCB) / PCs (even Atari!) / Papyrus ICR-ICR2-NCR / Who needs a life when you have multiple non-lives?
Everyone's got a right to an opinion, Michael. You, me, and everyone else. With yours stated and mine as well, I won't repeat it. However, I *wouldn't* mind a save weekend feature so you can qualify, save it, come back next day "like in real life"
>And I thought the IVGA was just established so that <name deleted> could >steal all the best setups? :-) hehehe, I never joined IVGA... hey, how about a "Save Race Weekend" option? now that sounds useful. qualify, save it and come back the next day. (like, qualify on Friday, race on Saturday or Sunday)
Robert 13 Dec 1996#348157
> It seems obvious that NASCAR2 should only contain what *you* want > it to contain, because everyone else's wishes are subordinate to > yours. Look around B.H. I am not the only one who wants it there, not by a long shot. And those that don't want it to be there can mostly be put in to two catagories: 1: Parinoid e-mail racers who are scared someone is going to cheat them out of a win. 2: Racing purists who don't think it belongs in a SIM ( but advocate the use of the Pause key... duh!! ) 3: ( He said two!! ) Those who would rather have some other feature instead. And the ones who want it are mainly in one large group. 1: Want to have a regular life and still race the longer races. Ranting is highly over rated, but it does helps to vent steam when dealing with certain people. But then again, there's you! :-) You're right, it doesn't apply to me. And I still can't imagine why you feel like you should be able to force the majority of Nascar racers to do without this feature, simply because the e-mail racers are a bunch of cheaters. ( Your impression, not mine ) So long as we know where we stand... ;) Yep, you got what you want, just not for the reasons you wanted it. Time vs cheaters . The rest of us will just have to wait and see, and hope...
Robert 13 Dec 1996#348158
At this point, I would take that. ( Then ask for more, of course :-) )
Luca Varan 13 Dec 1996#348159
Hello, I am reading all these posts about the save game feature, and I must say I am quite interested. I never played against any other human players, I have neither the money nor the time to do it, and I will never do that (at least in the foreseeable future). I like the feeling of having a 100% distance race rather than a "sprint race", but I haven't got the time to do it in just one session. Leaving the computer in pause and "on" for a few days is obviously not a choice. What is my point? I will not buy Nascar 2 if there is not such a feature. My hope is that by saying so the save game option will be implemented sooner or later. I might understand that cheating can occurr in on/offline races due to this feature, so I would like to know: how many people are involved in these races compared to how many people buy the game? Assuming that all the people who do not race on the net wants the save option (sounds reasonable), then I would say that having 1000 die hard fans of the sim (which will buy it in any case since that's their everyday bread) against 300000 people who just buy the game and play on their own, implementing the save game option as soon as possible seems to be a reasonable thing to do. Of course I have no clue about the numbers above, and an inversed ratio would mean that the save game is not such an urgent affair. Thanks for reading, Luca
>At this point, I would take that. ( Then ask for more, of course :-) ) hehehehe

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy