Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

Re: Is there any 3D physics racing sim with "save game" option ?

30 posts by 18 people · 27 Aug 2000 - 20 Sep 2000 20:49 UTC

Notable threadWhy sims with 3D physics lack mid-race saves

Posters asked whether any sim with full 3D physics had offered a mid-race save. Some argued saving a six-degree-of-freedom state was hard, while programmers said it should be straightforward. Papyrus's Charlie Heath explained that complexity lies less in the physics than in AI states, pacing lines and other subsystems, recalled that N2's save took considerable work and had a tyre-temperature bug, and noted N1 restarted saved races under caution.

With Charlie Heath (Papyrus)

community/metaphysics/realism debateNASCAR HeatNASCAR Racing 2

Automated summary.

Yup thats why I posted the question, I think there really is a complexity issue with "save game" in racing sims with 3D physics, not simply a matter of laziness or lack of technical ability on MGIs part. There are clearly some very technical issues with save game. PS: people debate about Heats validity as a sim, but let me tell ya, when your racing Atlanta and come off of Turn 4 you get hella loose. Pitting was always the easy thing with N3, with Heat its a whole new ballgame and I love it. now I see why the real drivers have problems pitting some times. especially at Darlington, you really have to pay attention. On Sun, 27 Aug 2000 18:48:43 +0300, Toni Lassila <[email hidden]> wrote:
Quoted text (7 lines)>On Sun, 27 Aug 2000 10:58:10 -0300, "Alemira" <[email hidden]> wrote: >>And what is the relation between 3D physics and save game option ? I can't >>understand. > >Apparently it's too difficult to save all the variables involved in a 6DOF >simulation to prevent weird and wonderful things happening when you reload the >saved game.
smoothly continuing the race, is no problem (I beleive) because there is now a pause key where all is freezed. Also, how much memory (when pause is active) is for all data that you are saying? I'm continue unsure about the difficulty of this, because if MGI develovers could do such simulator (for me, no doubt), they could implement this important feature. Anyway, could be like ICR1 (I think), where if you save during the race, when you load, all were under yellow flag, then, only would be necessary the racers position. I would prefer it. Alejandro. Sorry by my english. "Joe Marques" <Joe"NO_SPAM"[email hidden]> escribi� en el mensaje news:4Kaq5.27953$[email hidden]... > To save a game with 6DOF physics, not only must you capture the data for > speed/gear/rpm, physical location on the track, car damage/condition/fuel > level/tire wear, car set up including in-race tweaks, AND race positionbut > you must also capture the exact physical position of the car in its "3D > space" based on ALL 6 axes of movement (up/down-front/back-side/side - wax > on/wax off ;-)). Imagine doing this for 43 cars in NH, loading this data, > and smoothly continuing the race. Quite a bit more complicated thansimple
Quoted text (11 lines)> physics models and not surprising that no SOLID 6DOF sim has done it yet. > BTW, Nascar 2000 is not a sim so it certainly doesn't count. > > -- > Joe Marques > > Please remove "NO SPAM" to e-mail me. > > "Alemira" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:8ob6re$agbfi$[email hidden]... > > And what is the relation between 3D physics and save game option ? I
can't
Quoted text (15 lines)> > understand. > > > > <[email hidden]> escribi� en el mensaje > > news:[email hidden]... > > > All this talk about no "save game" feature in Heat, has there ever > > > been a "save game" option in any racing title that has 3D physics. I > > > can't think of one. > > > > > > anyone ???? > > > > > > > > > >
And what is the relation between 3D physics and save game option ? I can't understand. <[email hidden]> escribi� en el mensaje news:[email hidden]... > All this talk about no "save game" feature in Heat, has there ever > been a "save game" option in any racing title that has 3D physics. I > can't think of one. > > anyone ????
Um yes, NASCAR 2000, um yes... um..... -- Tim, [email hidden]|[email hidden] http://legends.sports-gaming.com/forums.shtml FREE forums for your league... http://legends.sports-gaming.com Sim racing website loosely based on gpl... Alan Orton <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > Didn't NASCAR 2000 have one? > > [email hidden] wrote: > > > > All this talk about no "save game" feature in Heat, has there ever > > been a "save game" option in any racing title that has 3D physics. I > > can't think of one. > > > > anyone ????
3D physics models are more difficult to implement than a 2D model, and that means more complexity overall -- which also makes for a more complex save game routine should a developer decide to implement it. -- JB In article <8ob6re$agbfi$[email hidden]>, "Alemira" <[email hidden]> wrote: > And what is the relation between 3D physics and save game option ? Ican't
Quoted text (11 lines)> understand. > > <[email hidden]> escribi� en el mensaje > news:[email hidden]... > > All this talk about no "save game" feature in Heat, has there ever > > been a "save game" option in any racing title that has 3D physics. I > > can't think of one. > > > > anyone ???? > >
Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ Before you buy.
Rich#8 27 Aug 2000 04:40 UTC#236699
All this talk about no "save game" feature in Heat, has there ever been a "save game" option in any racing title that has 3D physics. I can't think of one. anyone ????
Let's see it before we believe it. -- Joe Marques Please remove "NO SPAM" to e-mail me. "Chas39cop" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > Nascar 4
Has Eric Busch officially said that N4 will have "save game" ? If so I aint' seen it. Besides N4 is "terra-simcognito" at the moment, so it doesn't count. Anyone else !!!!!!! On 27 Aug 2000 04:44:20 GMT, [email hidden] (Chas39cop) wrote: >Nascar 4
ICR2 (CART Racing) did have a "save game" feature, but it didn't feature a full 3D physics model. The save game feature was VERY glitchy on my system, and would often cause the game to crash, though. -- JB In article <[email hidden]>, [email hidden] wrote: > All this talk about no "save game" feature in Heat, has there ever > been a "save game" option in any racing title that has 3D physics. I > can't think of one. > > anyone ???? > Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ Before you buy.
<[email hidden]> wrote in message news:8oa9t4$d6m$[email hidden]... > ICR2 (CART Racing) did have a "save game" feature, but it didn't > feature a full 3D physics model. The save game feature was VERY > glitchy on my system, and would often cause the game to crash, though. > > -- JB > Remember, ICR2 wasn't even what we would call a 3d program. At least a non-accelerated 3d program. Only until the Rendition patch was available did it receive the 3d look. dave henrie
Didn't NASCAR 2000 have one? [email hidden] wrote: > > All this talk about no "save game" feature in Heat, has there ever > been a "save game" option in any racing title that has 3D physics. I > can't think of one. > > anyone ????
To save a game with 6DOF physics, not only must you capture the data for speed/gear/rpm, physical location on the track, car damage/condition/fuel level/tire wear, car set up including in-race tweaks, AND race position but you must also capture the exact physical position of the car in its "3D space" based on ALL 6 axes of movement (up/down-front/back-side/side - wax on/wax off ;-)). Imagine doing this for 43 cars in NH, loading this data, and smoothly continuing the race. Quite a bit more complicated than simple physics models and not surprising that no SOLID 6DOF sim has done it yet. BTW, Nascar 2000 is not a sim so it certainly doesn't count. -- Joe Marques Please remove "NO SPAM" to e-mail me. "Alemira" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:8ob6re$agbfi$[email hidden]... > And what is the relation between 3D physics and save game option ? I can't > understand. > > <[email hidden]> escribi� en el mensaje > news:[email hidden]... > > All this talk about no "save game" feature in Heat, has there ever > > been a "save game" option in any racing title that has 3D physics. I > > can't think of one. > > > > anyone ???? > > > >
On Sun, 27 Aug 2000 10:58:10 -0300, "Alemira" <[email hidden]> wrote: >And what is the relation between 3D physics and save game option ? I can't >understand. Apparently it's too difficult to save all the variables involved in a 6DOF simulation to prevent weird and wonderful things happening when you reload the saved game.
My first pit with worn tires was a near disaster :-). I came sliding down the bank and almost spun the damn car. This is a great sim, tons of fun to race. -- Joe Marques Please remove "NO SPAM" to e-mail me. <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > Yup thats why I posted the question, I think there really is a > complexity issue with "save game" in racing sims with 3D physics, not > simply a matter of laziness or lack of technical ability on MGIs > part. > > There are clearly some very technical issues with save game. > > PS: people debate about Heats validity as a sim, but let me tell ya, > when your racing Atlanta and come off of Turn 4 you get hella loose. > Pitting was always the easy thing with N3, with Heat its a whole new > ballgame and I love it. > > now I see why the real drivers have problems pitting some times. > especially at Darlington, you really have to pay attention. > > > > > > > > > > On Sun, 27 Aug 2000 18:48:43 +0300, Toni Lassila > <[email hidden]> wrote: > > >On Sun, 27 Aug 2000 10:58:10 -0300, "Alemira" <[email hidden]> wrote: > >>And what is the relation between 3D physics and save game option ? I can't > >>understand. > > > >Apparently it's too difficult to save all the variables involved in a 6DOF > >simulation to prevent weird and wonderful things happening when you reload the > >saved game. >
I'm sure all that data would fit in a 10k file. Loading would take the same amount of time as loading a normal race start, and re-starts could be acheived with a simple on-screen countdown before the action resumed. I don't agree in general with the principle of having saves during races, but I don't see any reason for not putting them in, for the people who *do* want them. It's not like they could be used for cheating, apart from cheating the AI cars, which is futile anyway. "Joe Marques" <Joe"NO_SPAM"[email hidden]> wrote in message news:4Kaq5.27953$[email hidden]... > To save a game with 6DOF physics, not only must you capture the data for > speed/gear/rpm, physical location on the track, car damage/condition/fuel > level/tire wear, car set up including in-race tweaks, AND race positionbut > you must also capture the exact physical position of the car in its "3D > space" based on ALL 6 axes of movement (up/down-front/back-side/side - wax > on/wax off ;-)). Imagine doing this for 43 cars in NH, loading this data, > and smoothly continuing the race. Quite a bit more complicated thansimple
Quoted text (8 lines)> physics models and not surprising that no SOLID 6DOF sim has done it yet. > BTW, Nascar 2000 is not a sim so it certainly doesn't count. > > -- > Joe Marques > > Please remove "NO SPAM" to e-mail me. >
Bendito wrote: > Let's say you have paused GPL, mid-race. Now, you go away for 2 hours to > the beach or something. You come back, you unpause and continue the race. > How were you able to do that? Well, obviously, the relevant data is kept in > memory. Now, I'm a programmer myself, and I've never had an intractable > problem in moving data from memory to the hard-drive and vice versa - in > fact, it's so simple I don't give it much extra thought. Bendito is right. I'm a software engineer as well (although not a game or graphics programmer). I would imagine that all the relevant state data is stored in objects representing each car on the track. All that is needed is to make these objects persistent (adding methods to write this info out to disk and then read it back in). I don't see why the complexity of the physics model would make this any more difficult - just have to keep track of more info (which is already being done) and add a few extra lines of code for reading and writing these variables. Dave Ewing -- ***************************************************** David A. Ewing Xilinx Boulder [email hidden] *****************************************************
Simon, you sound so sure of this are you a programmer? I'm not flaming here but when the developer says it's not easy and when no real 6dof physics game has done it I think I'll stick with the word of the actual experts. -- Joe Marques Please remove "NO SPAM" to e-mail me. "Simon Brown" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:AnPq5.8290$[email hidden]... > I'm sure all that data would fit in a 10k file. Loading would take the same > amount of time as loading a normal race start, and re-starts could be > acheived with a simple on-screen countdown before the action resumed. > > I don't agree in general with the principle of having saves during races, > but I don't see any reason for not putting them in, for the people who *do* > want them. It's not like they could be used for cheating, apart from > cheating the AI cars, which is futile anyway. >
Joe Marques wrote in message ... >Simon, you sound so sure of this are you a programmer? I'm not flaminghere >but when the developer says it's not easy and when no real 6dof physicsgame >has done it I think I'll stick with the word of the actual experts. Let's say you have paused GPL, mid-race. Now, you go away for 2 hours to the beach or something. You come back, you unpause and continue the race. How were you able to do that? Well, obviously, the relevant data is kept in memory. Now, I'm a programmer myself, and I've never had an intractable problem in moving data from memory to the hard-drive and vice versa - in fact, it's so simple I don't give it much extra thought. It's just a matter of coding it, and coding takes time, and time is money, etc etc. Also, it's harder to implement a feature (say, as a patch) after you've released the game. Some programs don't take too kindly to being augmented. I will say that for GP3, GPL, and other 3d racing games, I'd imagine that the save file would be significantly larger than 10k. But it's definitely doable. Replay files are very similar to save files - they both save similar data to the hard drive. In fact, now that I think about it, replays would much harder to implement than a "save" feature, and yet most 3d racing games have implemented replays. Bendito;
There really wouldn't be much difference in complexity of save game for 6 degrees of freedom physics compared with three. The complexity is elsewhere, in things like AI states, pacing lines, and hooking into various sim subsystems that nobody thought about needing to hook into ahead of time. N2's save game took about 3 days to implement, once I had a few days without any other assignment free to do it. That was working from the save-game stuff from the legacy N1 code, but a lot of internal things changed drastically from N1 to N2, so that wasn't much of a starting point. I'd guess Broske could get save game working in Heat in a couple weeks or less, if he's allowed to do it. It would require fairly extensive QA time, though, to make sure it works in a variety of conditions. Chas <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]...
Quoted text (27 lines)> Yup thats why I posted the question, I think there really is a > complexity issue with "save game" in racing sims with 3D physics, not > simply a matter of laziness or lack of technical ability on MGIs > part. > > There are clearly some very technical issues with save game. > > PS: people debate about Heats validity as a sim, but let me tell ya, > when your racing Atlanta and come off of Turn 4 you get hella loose. > Pitting was always the easy thing with N3, with Heat its a whole new > ballgame and I love it. > > now I see why the real drivers have problems pitting some times. > especially at Darlington, you really have to pay attention. > > > > > > > > > > On Sun, 27 Aug 2000 18:48:43 +0300, Toni Lassila > <[email hidden]> wrote: > > >On Sun, 27 Aug 2000 10:58:10 -0300, "Alemira" <[email hidden]>
wrote: > >>And what is the relation between 3D physics and save game option ? Ican't > >>understand. > > > >Apparently it's too difficult to save all the variables involved in a6DOF > >simulation to prevent weird and wonderful things happening when youreload the > >saved game. >
Hi Charlie....glad to hear from you. I'm getting the feeling that many developers are being limited as to what they can work on by the publishers and their budgets. Is it a matter of TIME or money that prevents code-monkeys from working on new features? dave henrie "Charlie Heath" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:mgmr5.58599$[email hidden]... > There really wouldn't be much difference in complexity of save game for 6 > degrees of freedom physics compared with three. The complexity is > elsewhere, in things like AI states, pacing lines, and hooking intovarious > sim subsystems that nobody thought about needing to hook into ahead oftime. > > N2's save game took about 3 days to implement, once I had a few dayswithout > any other assignment free to do it. That was working from the save-game > stuff from the legacy N1 code, but a lot of internal things changed > drastically from N1 to N2, so that wasn't much of a starting point. > > I'd guess Broske could get save game working in Heat in a couple weeks or > less, if he's allowed to do it. It would require fairly extensive QAtime,
Quoted text (34 lines)> though, to make sure it works in a variety of conditions. > > Chas > > > <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:[email hidden]... > > Yup thats why I posted the question, I think there really is a > > complexity issue with "save game" in racing sims with 3D physics, not > > simply a matter of laziness or lack of technical ability on MGIs > > part. > > > > There are clearly some very technical issues with save game. > > > > PS: people debate about Heats validity as a sim, but let me tell ya, > > when your racing Atlanta and come off of Turn 4 you get hella loose. > > Pitting was always the easy thing with N3, with Heat its a whole new > > ballgame and I love it. > > > > now I see why the real drivers have problems pitting some times. > > especially at Darlington, you really have to pay attention. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > On Sun, 27 Aug 2000 18:48:43 +0300, Toni Lassila > > <[email hidden]> wrote: > > > > >On Sun, 27 Aug 2000 10:58:10 -0300, "Alemira"
<[email hidden]>
Quoted text (13 lines)> wrote: > > >>And what is the relation between 3D physics and save game option ? I > can't > > >>understand. > > > > > >Apparently it's too difficult to save all the variables involved in a > 6DOF > > >simulation to prevent weird and wonderful things happening when you > reload the > > >saved game. > > > >
That's always the case, but the trick is knowing what you can and can't do with a given level of resources, making the best choices, and then following through on the delivery. "Dave Henrie" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:W6or5.40733$[email hidden]... > Hi Charlie....glad to hear from you. > I'm getting the feeling that many developers are being limited as to > what they can work on by the publishers and their budgets. Is it amatter > of > TIME or money that prevents code-monkeys from working on new features? > dave henrie
When you are talking about AI this is not quite as easy. The code tends to be linear and not holographic. In other words if you take a slice of time from the sim and record it in history, you are losing the before and after. If (and this is a big IF), NH actually uses some code that builds on how the AI reacts in a certain situation, then saving this information for a save-game could pose some large hurdles. If this is the case, then we get down to trade-offs..... what does make it to the game and what doesn't. On Wed, 30 Aug 2000 10:30:52 -0600 David Ewing <[email hidden]> wrote: % Bendito is right. I'm a software engineer as well (although not a game or % graphics programmer). I would imagine that all the relevant state data is % stored in objects representing each car on the track. All that is needed is to % make these objects persistent (adding methods to write this info out to disk % and then read it back in). I don't see why the complexity of the physics model % would make this any more difficult - just have to keep track of more info % (which is already being done) and add a few extra lines of code for reading and % writing these variables. % Dave Ewing % -- % ***************************************************** % David A. Ewing % Xilinx Boulder [email hidden] % ***************************************************** -- **************************** Michael E. Carver ************************* Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town. [email hidden] http://www.teleport.com/~mcarver =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
On Thu, 31 Aug 2000 05:43:46 GMT Charlie Heath <[email hidden]> wrote: % There really wouldn't be much difference in complexity of save game for 6 % degrees of freedom physics compared with three. The complexity is % elsewhere, in things like AI states, pacing lines, and hooking into various % sim subsystems that nobody thought about needing to hook into ahead of time. % N2's save game took about 3 days to implement, once I had a few days without % any other assignment free to do it. That was working from the save-game % stuff from the legacy N1 code, but a lot of internal things changed % drastically from N1 to N2, so that wasn't much of a starting point. % I'd guess Broske could get save game working in Heat in a couple weeks or % less, if he's allowed to do it. It would require fairly extensive QA time, % though, to make sure it works in a variety of conditions. And you did a good job of it too. But I also recall some major things got left out with the first release of the save-game (like fuel load, tire temps, gear selection, etc. if I remember correctly <G>). It was appreciated highly by many though. -- **************************** Michael E. Carver ************************* Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town. [email hidden] http://www.teleport.com/~mcarver =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
Michael E. Carver wrote in message ... >When you are talking about AI this is not quite as easy. The code tends >to be linear and not holographic. Good point. Bendito;
LOL, I'd forgotten about that. I'd switched from N1's save / restore technique, which did restarts by lining cars up in a pace lap (or something like that) to saving the exact track conditions. I think the middle tire temps were restored on the wrong tire, or something like that. I think there was something else that was in the "must fix" category that didn't make it into N2P1 that justified a second patch, and allowed the remaining details for save game to be fixed. "Michael E. Carver" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:FUPr5.6623$[email hidden]... > On Thu, 31 Aug 2000 05:43:46 GMT Charlie Heath <[email hidden]>wrote:
Quoted text (9 lines)> And you did a good job of it too. But I also recall some major things > got left out with the first release of the save-game (like fuel load, > tire temps, gear selection, etc. if I remember correctly <G>). It was > appreciated highly by many though. > -- > **************************** Michael E. Carver ************************* > Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town. > [email hidden] http://www.teleport.com/~mcarver > =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
I remember that from N1, anywhere in the race that you exited and saved, it returned you to a caution flag lap for the restart, I always thought that was pretty neat. You could exit a race and return days later and not worry about where exactly on the track and at what speed it was going to drop you. -- Don Burnette Dburn in N3 and Legends ICQ# 74084566 "Charlie Heath" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:Uc%r5.64148$[email hidden]... > LOL, I'd forgotten about that. I'd switched from N1's save / restore > technique, which did restarts by lining cars up in a pace lap (or something > like that) to saving the exact track conditions. I think the middle tire > temps were restored on the wrong tire, or something like that. > > I think there was something else that was in the "must fix" category that > didn't make it into N2P1 that justified a second patch, and allowed the > remaining details for save game to be fixed. > > "Michael E. Carver" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:FUPr5.6623$[email hidden]... > > On Thu, 31 Aug 2000 05:43:46 GMT Charlie Heath <[email hidden]> > wrote: > > And you did a good job of it too. But I also recall some major things > > got left out with the first release of the save-game (like fuel load, > > tire temps, gear selection, etc. if I remember correctly <G>). It was > > appreciated highly by many though. > > -- > > **************************** Michael E. Carver ************************* > > Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town. > > [email hidden] http://www.teleport.com/~mcarver > > =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-= > >
clone 20 Sep 2000 18:25 UTC↳ reply to Rich#8#230564
GP1, GP2, GP3 On Sun, 27 Aug 2000 04:40:49 GMT, [email hidden] wrote: >All this talk about no "save game" feature in Heat, has there ever >been a "save game" option in any racing title that has 3D physics. I >can't think of one. > >anyone ????
GP1, GP2 and GP3 don't have a real physics engine, it's a driving engine. Much like in WSC's video. "clone" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]...
Quoted text (11 lines)> GP1, GP2, GP3 > > > On Sun, 27 Aug 2000 04:40:49 GMT, [email hidden] wrote: > > >All this talk about no "save game" feature in Heat, has there ever > >been a "save game" option in any racing title that has 3D physics. I > >can't think of one. > > > >anyone ???? >

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy