Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

If you dont like GTR you wont like GTL

28 posts by 15 people · 17 Aug 2005 18:10 UTC - 25 Aug 2005 13:21 UTC

GT Legends demo impressions: too much like GTR?

The thread opened with the claim that the GT Legends demo was barely different from GTR. Some found its physics more convincing, especially the heavy Corvette, while others disliked the controller lag, the mirrors and locked cars. mcewena wrote a well-received explanation of why GPL still held such affection, citing first love, balance and community.

review/impressionsgame comparisonGT LegendsGTRGrand Prix Legends

Automated summary.

Saltheart_Foamfollower 17 Aug 2005 18:10 UTC#19103
They are nearly identical based on what they gave us in this demo. Ive seen free mods with more changes than this. Where is gmotor2?
Saltheart_Foamfollower wrote: > They are nearly identical based on what they gave us in this demo. Ive seen > free mods with more changes than this. Where is gmotor2? Rfactor? And do you really think gmotor2 is going to be that big of an improvement? I think Simbin's replacement of cars that porpoise constantly with cars that dumptruck all over the place is a pretty big change. Not necessarily a good one...
On 17 Aug 2005 11:49:01 -0700, "jason moyer" <[email hidden]> wrote:
Quoted text (11 lines)>Saltheart_Foamfollower wrote: > >> They are nearly identical based on what they gave us in this demo. Ive seen >> free mods with more changes than this. Where is gmotor2? > >Rfactor? And do you really think gmotor2 is going to be that big of an >improvement? > >I think Simbin's replacement of cars that porpoise constantly with cars >that dumptruck all over the place is a pretty big change. Not >necessarily a good one...
Well, I tried the demo, and noticed the old ISI controller lag is still there...the mirrors aren't very helpfull either, being out of view for the largest part. I do like the sound, though. But still...it's no GPL..... :-P Cheers! Remco
On Wed, 17 Aug 2005 18:10:32 GMT, "Saltheart_Foamfollower" <[email hidden]> wrote: >They are nearly identical based on what they gave us in this demo. Ive seen >free mods with more changes than this. Where is gmotor2? >At least we agree on something.
I guess it follows that if I like GTR, then I'll like GTL... Cool! I like GTR... A lot! (I play offline only, so the multi-player issues of GTR are not an issue for me).
Based on the Rfactor demo yes, I expected more than GTL supplies. I dont follow this "porpoising" stuff in GTR. I dont know exactly what youre describing. I dont have it though ;) The vette is the only one ive tried and it is a fn truck... "jason moyer" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > Rfactor? And do you really think gmotor2 is going to be that big of an > improvement? > > I think Simbin's replacement of cars that porpoise constantly with cars > that dumptruck all over the place is a pretty big change. Not > necessarily a good one... >
Dan Leach wrote: > How do you get split axis to work on this demo? (Logi momo) Have you tried clicking on "throttle" and pressing your throttle, then clicking "brake" and pressing your brake?
"Saltheart_Foamfollower" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:q2OMe.309$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (8 lines)> Based on the Rfactor demo yes, I expected more than GTL supplies. > > I dont follow this "porpoising" stuff in GTR. I dont know exactly what > youre describing. I dont have it though ;) > > The vette is the only one ive tried and it is a fn truck... > >
I've driven one of these Corvettes, and they do drive like trucks. At least the one I drove was extremely heavy and moved almost as one, very heavily. Either my memory has failed me, but don't these older cars drive like this? I have never tried rFactor so I don't know what comparisons to make between the GTL Demo. I know that I did like the demo, and thought, at least considering the interface, that it was much better. I didn't run into any lag problems except when I tried the high-resolution livery on the AI cars. When I did that, as soon as a car came near me, my frames dropped to near zero. I also had to set the shaders to direct-x8. Using direct-x9 caused excruciatingly low frames. I was pleased with the demo, for the most part. As you all know, I'm no expert on these simulators, but it felt pretty decent. How many of us here have actually driven one of these types of cars? I mean, if you haven't, how do you know how they should handle? Though I might wait to hear the final verdict on GTL before I purchase, I saw no real problems with the demo. Is it simply that some are so stuck on GPL, that there's no room for anything else? (Responses to this query will give me the answer.) Alanb
Alan Bernardo wrote: > I've driven one of these Corvettes, and they do drive like trucks. At least > the one I drove was extremely heavy and moved almost as one, very heavily. > Either my memory has failed me, but don't these older cars drive like this? I would expect more wheel spin with a locked power side than you get in the game (I've been running with 80% power, 20% coast) but overall I think the physics in the GTL demo feel "more real" to me than GTR. I made a joke about trading in cars that porpoise for cars that dumptruck, but in my experience old stingrays push like hell without the throttle down.
jason moyer wrote: > Remco Moedt wrote: > > > But still...it's no GPL..... :-P > > GPL is no GTP or RBR. :) or LFS. :P
Well, after having bought and played GTR I ended up "not liking" it after several weeks. I don't know why...things that I can't really put my finger on but as a complete package I couldn't get into it. The GTL demo has been downloaded and run for an hour or so and, like it's cousin, it doesn't grab me. Enjoyable as it is to throw a Corvette around, or a Lotus Elan, I am being influenced against buying the full package by the gameplay aspect, where there are the arcade-like features such as unlocking additional cars. In addition, I was hoping that this would be a retro-type game, along the lines of GPL, where we would be taken back to not only the cars of the 1960's/1970's, but also the circuits of that era. To discover that the complete package is only centred on the FIA's European historical retrospective is disappointing for me. Oh well....back to GPL and GP3 with the 1970's add-ons! :) BK
[email hidden] wrote:
Quoted text (10 lines)> jason moyer wrote: > >>Remco Moedt wrote: >> >>>But still...it's no GPL..... :-P >> >>GPL is no GTP or RBR. :) > > or LFS. :P >
Thank God and Praise Allah. Mr. S.
Ditto here. I am not too fond of the car unlocking and old-cars-on-modern-tracks stuff either. Also the default handling of these cars isn't that fun, IMHO. Tuning them for more oversteer improves things a bit. But not to the level of the Escort Mod. I didn't expect too much from the Corvette, but the Elan is a disappointement. Now, I never sat in a Lotus Elan or a Corvette, but I own a 1967 MGB and have been a passenger in a Type E. While I love a relaxing drive in my MG, I don't think that even with a stiffer suspension it would be really fun on a circuit. Maybe the real test for GTL will come when we can drive something like the AC Cobra. If Simbin releases GTL with the old Spa and Nurburgring tracks, then I am sold. If it goes along the lines of the Demo, then I'll wait for the game to appear in the bargain bin. Meanwhile, I still have RBR, GPL and the Escort Mod :) Regards, Mr. Sylvestre
"jason moyer" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > > Dan Leach wrote: >> How do you get split axis to work on this demo? (Logi momo) > > Have you tried clicking on "throttle" and pressing your throttle, then > clicking "brake" and pressing your brake? Fixed it, it was forgetting my settings when i moved screens. Its ok now
On Wed, 17 Aug 2005 23:07:48 -0400, "Alan Bernardo" <[email hidden]> wrote: >Is it simply that some are so stuck on GPL, that there's no room for >anything else? (Responses to this query will give me the answer.) Probably, but I wouldn't expect anyone to admit it...<g> Eldred
On Thu, 18 Aug 2005 17:47:56 +1000, "Bruce Kennewell" <[email hidden]> wrote: >Enjoyable as it is to throw a Corvette around, or a Lotus Elan, I am being >influenced against buying the full package by the gameplay aspect, where >there are the arcade-like features such as unlocking additional cars. Unlocking?!? Gads, I *hate* that 'feature'... That means that some people may have to cheat to get all the cars they've paid for. I certainly HOPE there are cheat codes available... Eldred
Larry 24 Aug 2005 16:28 UTC↳ reply to EldredP#18528
I hate it too. Give me all of what I paid for! This only make sense in games where you graduate from one series to the next. -Larry "Eldred Pickett" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]...
Quoted text (12 lines)> On Thu, 18 Aug 2005 17:47:56 +1000, "Bruce Kennewell" > <[email hidden]> wrote: > >>Enjoyable as it is to throw a Corvette around, or a Lotus Elan, I am being >>influenced against buying the full package by the gameplay aspect, where >>there are the arcade-like features such as unlocking additional cars. > > Unlocking?!? Gads, I *hate* that 'feature'... That means that some > people may have to cheat to get all the cars they've paid for. I > certainly HOPE there are cheat codes available... > > Eldred
>Is it simply that some are so stuck on GPL, that there's no room for >anything else? (Responses to this query will give me the answer.) It's probably a combination of things: 1) First love. Nobody forgets who popped their cherry. For most of us who've been here long enough, GPL was the first sim that actual made us feel a little like Jim Clark, Mario Andretti, Giles Villeneuve (whom ever your hero was). 2) Balance. GPL's not correct in how it models things but I personally think some of the sims that have gone for more technical correctness in the modeling have lost something in the driveability when you try and transmit that onto a 2d 17" screen with very little sensory inputs to drivers who AREN'T Clark, Andretti, Villenueve etc.. Plus I think the more modern the car being modeled the higher the driver requirement and the narrower the performance band you have to drive in, drive a GPL car at 8/10ths you'll still likely finish on the lead lap, drive a GTP or other modern car at 8/10th you won't even bring the tires into their performance envelop and you'll be lapped in no time. 3) Online experience. To this day I have more fun dicing with my GPL buddies in piddly FV cars then any other sim, maybe it's the mix of talent, maybe it's the flow of the tracks (little chicane blight), maybe it's luck of the draw, who knows. But that overall experience seems to add a certain warm glow by association to GPL that hasn't happened in other sims (dispite the odd good experience). 4) Missed opportunities. There are many things that NR2003, LFS, GTR and others clearly do better then GPL, but it seems they've each got some fatal or near fatal flaw that prevents them from going the final yard. 5) Critical mass. When GPL came out it was the ONLY game in town, now there are half a dozen alternatives, each with half a dozen mods/varients meaning that no one of them is likely to be king of the heap (or likely to be reading the current tea leaves). Diversity is great, but it does also lead to fragmentation of the community. Just my 2 cents.
EldredP 24 Aug 2005 17:45 UTC↳ reply to mcewena#18534
On 24 Aug 2005 10:27:59 -0700, "mcewena" <[email hidden]> wrote: >>Is it simply that some are so stuck on GPL, that there's no room for >>anything else? (Responses to this query will give me the answer.) > >It's probably a combination of things: <snip> Wow, a well thought out, well-stated opinion. Maybe there's hope for r.a.s.yet...<g> How's it going, Art? Eldred
ymenard 24 Aug 2005 19:14 UTC↳ reply to EldredP#18542
Quoted text (9 lines)>"Eldred Pickett" <[email hidden]> wrote > On 24 Aug 2005 10:27:59 -0700, "mcewena" <[email hidden]> > wrote: > >>It's probably a combination of things: > <snip> > Wow, a well thought out, well-stated opinion. Maybe there's hope for > r.a.s.yet...<g> > How's it going, Art?
"That sim is our last hope." "No, there is another..." -- -- Fran�ois M�nard <ymenard> -- This announcement is brought to you by the Shimago-Dominguez Corporation - helping America into the New World...
ymenard wrote: > "That sim is our last hope." > > > "No, there is another..." But RFactor was the chosen one! It was supposed to defeat shitty sims, not spawn more of them!
mcewena 25 Aug 2005 01:16 UTC↳ reply to EldredP#18462
>How's it going, Art? >Eldred I thought you were dead? ;) I'm good you? I'm almost over my annual summer time sick of sim blahs and keen to get back to GPL for the fall. I was keen to race GTP endurance in this Saturday's WOSEC 6 hours of Road Atlanta but my enthusium is out reaching my talent... ;) And has been blunted some by the choice of the Tunlanta version. When can I expect to see you on track again?
>> Unlocking?!? Gads, I *hate* that 'feature'... That means that some >> people may have to cheat to get all the cars they've paid for. I >> certainly HOPE there are cheat codes available... Relax. Every game of this type has a cheat code to unlock all cars available within days of release. RBR, one of the finest sims ever, is a classic example. Nobody seemed to mind having locked cars in that game. I'd have to say, some of you people are incrediby picky when it comes to sims. And not necessarily picky in terms of quality - just in terms of how you think a sim should be or what it should include. -Mulligatawny
Well, it shouldn't include mulligatawny for starters. YECCHHH! :) But Steve, I don't think that we are equating "sim" with"locked"; we just don't like "locked" features, sim or not. Well, that's how I feel about locked features in any game, anyway. Bruce "Steve Simpson" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > I'd have to say, some of you people are incrediby picky when it comes to > sims. And not necessarily picky in terms of quality - just in terms of > how you think a sim should be or what it should include. > > -Mulligatawny
>Well, that's how I feel about locked features in any game, anyway. If it keeps even one more idiot from immediately jumping online in the most powerfull car available *before* he learns the basics, I'm all for locks.

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy