Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

OT dsl vs cable

17 posts by 10 people · 25 Sep 2002 04:54 UTC - 27 Sep 2002 14:28 UTC

Bamadano 25 Sep 2002 04:54 UTC#96674
I'm currently using Bellsouth ADSL but the cable company (Charter communications) made me an offer I couldnt refuse. (or at least think hard about) My DSL 95% of the time only connects around 600mbs anyway and cable promises 1.3. To those with cable...how is it? Any horror stories? Had both?? Which is better? All opinions appreciated. Thanks, Dan
Having used both Pacbell DSL and Charter Pipeline there isn't really any comparison. DSL is a better product for online gaming. Pipeline is better for downloading porn ;-) Mitch Bamadano wrote:
Quoted text (7 lines)> I'm currently using Bellsouth ADSL but the cable company (Charter > communications) made me an offer I couldnt refuse. (or at least think hard > about) My DSL 95% of the time only connects around 600mbs anyway and cable > promises 1.3. To those with cable...how is it? Any horror stories? Had both?? > Which is better? All opinions appreciated. > Thanks, > Dan
"Bamadano" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > I'm currently using Bellsouth ADSL but the cable company (Charter > communications) made me an offer I couldnt refuse. (or at least think hard > about) My DSL 95% of the time only connects around 600mbs anyway and cable > promises 1.3. To those with cable...how is it? Any horror stories? Hadboth?? > Which is better? All opinions appreciated. > Thanks, > Dan You might want to check here: http://www.dslreports.com/ to see if there is any information about Charter Communications. It may not help but I have had AT&T cable for about 18 months. There have been some ups and downs with the service but the last 6 months have been relatively trouble free (raps self on head smartly several times ;-) ). Depending on the download location I usually max out at 1.5 Mbps and that includes going through a router with a hardware firewall. As far as Bellouth is concerned: Yikes! I am planning to move in about a month to a residence that has both AT&T cable and Bellsouth FastAccess available. I decided to check my options so I went to Bellsouth's website to learn what I could about their ADSL service. After reading through most of their requirements and disclaimers I decided to stay with AT&T cable. AT&T wants to charge $25 to transfer service so I think I'll just cancel their service, wait about a month (Internet withdrawal...aaagh!), and then sign up as a new customer to get the free installation and intro offer with NO contractual requirements. Price wise, in my area, cable internet access is about 10-15% cheaper per month than most of Bellsouth's internet access only plans. HTH. -- callsignviper The truth is out there. You just have to look in the right places and ask the right questions.
>Having used both Pacbell DSL and Charter Pipeline there isn't really any >comparison. DSL is a better product for online gaming. Pipeline is >better for downloading porn ;-) > >Mitch That last sentence may have decided it Mitch <G>
Quoted text (23 lines)>You might want to check here: http://www.dslreports.com/ to see if there is >any information about Charter Communications. > >It may not help but I have had AT&T cable for about 18 months. There have >been some ups and downs with the service but the last 6 months have been >relatively trouble free (raps self on head smartly several times ;-) ). >Depending on the download location I usually max out at 1.5 Mbps and that >includes going through a router with a hardware firewall. > >As far as Bellouth is concerned: Yikes! I am planning to move in about a >month to a residence that has both AT&T cable and Bellsouth FastAccess >available. I decided to check my options so I went to Bellsouth's website to >learn what I could about their ADSL service. After reading through most of >their requirements and disclaimers I decided to stay with AT&T cable. AT&T >wants to charge $25 to transfer service so I think I'll just cancel their >service, wait about a month (Internet withdrawal...aaagh!), and then sign up >as a new customer to get the free installation and intro offer with NO >contractual requirements. > >Price wise, in my area, cable internet access is about 10-15% cheaper per >month than most of Bellsouth's internet access only plans. > >HTH.
Thanks for the great information HTH. In all fairness I do live just outside the 3 mile circle from a Bellsouth central office that they say is required for optimal performance. It's more their customer support or lack thereof and lower cable prices that will prompt my change. No internet for a month !! Yikes is right :) You could always pick up an AOL 300 hrs free disk and go dial up at the risk of going insane after cable :) Thanks for your help, Dan
"Bamadano" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... (snip) > > Thanks for the great information HTH. In all fairness I do live justoutside > the 3 mile circle from a Bellsouth central office that they say isrequired for > optimal performance. It's more their customer support or lack thereof andlower > cable prices that will prompt my change. No internet for a month !! Yikesis > right :) You could always pick up an AOL 300 hrs free disk and go dial upat > the risk of going insane after cable :) > Thanks for your help, > Dan > You're welcome. Glad to help when I can. As far as AOHell is concerned I'd rather sleep on a bed of hot coals than install their junk software on my system. WinBlows has enough inherent problems without further sabotage/subterfuge from the AOHell software. -- callsignviper The truth is out there. You just have to look in the right places and ask the right questions.
Just do NetZero for the interim. It's not the best, but a hell of a lot better then AOL. :) "callsignviper" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:Fndk9.535483$me6.74754@sccrnsc01...
Quoted text (12 lines)> > "Bamadano" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:[email hidden]... > > (snip) > > > > > Thanks for the great information HTH. In all fairness I do live just > outside > > the 3 mile circle from a Bellsouth central office that they say is > required for > > optimal performance. It's more their customer support or lack thereof
and > lower > > cable prices that will prompt my change. No internet for a month !!Yikes > is > > right :) You could always pick up an AOL 300 hrs free disk and go dialup
Quoted text (21 lines)> at > > the risk of going insane after cable :) > > Thanks for your help, > > Dan > > > > You're welcome. Glad to help when I can. > > As far as AOHell is concerned I'd rather sleep on a bed of hot coals than > install their junk software on my system. WinBlows has enough inherent > problems without further sabotage/subterfuge from the AOHell software. > > > -- > callsignviper > > > The truth is out there. You just have to look in the right places and ask > the right questions. > >
"Bamadano" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > I'm currently using Bellsouth ADSL but the cable company (Charter > communications) made me an offer I couldnt refuse. (or at least think hard > about) My DSL 95% of the time only connects around 600mbs anyway and cable > promises 1.3. To those with cable...how is it? Any horror stories? Hadboth?? > Which is better? All opinions appreciated. > Thanks, > Dan Dan, I've used Verizon DSL and Charter Pipeline. I generally had a bit more downtime with DSL, but I was an early adopter in my area. The best thing about Charter is combining it with digital cable service - I currently get all the regular cable channels (including SPEED), all the digital cable channels, all the HBO, Cinemax, Movie Channel, and Showtime channels, and my cable internet for about $105/month. Granted, even with all those channels, it's still a case of "500 channels and nothing to watch", but it's nice having the choice for not much more than basic cable (about $40 most places) and broadband internet (another $40). Rick
Doug D 25 Sep 2002 15:34 UTC↳ reply to Bamadano#96609
I've been on cable(at home w/ optonline) for about 1 yr and its been great. I use sprint verizon DSL at work and the connection is solid also but not as fast. Optonline has been rated #1 and I for one could not be happer. I dont think you can really say DSL is better then cable or cable is better then DSL. It would depend on your provider, location ect. ect. There are to many variables to say one is better then the other. If you can get optonline, go for it and see what you think. BTW the porn is much faster on optonline :) Doug D
I agree. I keep NZ installed on my ghetto laptop for trips...thing is, the max time per month is either 10 or 20 hours on any given account... Make lots of free NZ accounts. ;) Milhouse "Lannie Schafroth" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]...
Quoted text (33 lines)> Just do NetZero for the interim. It's not the best, but a hell of a lot > better then AOL. :) > > "callsignviper" <[email hidden]> wrote in > message news:Fndk9.535483$me6.74754@sccrnsc01... > > > > "Bamadano" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > news:[email hidden]... > > > > (snip) > > > > > > > > Thanks for the great information HTH. In all fairness I do live just > > outside > > > the 3 mile circle from a Bellsouth central office that they say is > > required for > > > optimal performance. It's more their customer support or lack thereof > and > > lower > > > cable prices that will prompt my change. No internet for a month !! > Yikes > > is > > > right :) You could always pick up an AOL 300 hrs free disk and go dial > up > > at > > > the risk of going insane after cable :) > > > Thanks for your help, > > > Dan > > > > > > > You're welcome. Glad to help when I can. > > > > As far as AOHell is concerned I'd rather sleep on a bed of hot coals
than
Quoted text (9 lines)> > install their junk software on my system. WinBlows has enough inherent > > problems without further sabotage/subterfuge from the AOHell software. > > > > > > -- > > callsignviper > > > > > > The truth is out there. You just have to look in the right places and
ask > > the right questions. > > > > > >
Larry 25 Sep 2002 20:59 UTC↳ reply to Bamadano#96561
In most cases, I think Cable is better IF the cable company runs and provisions it correctly. The predicted horror stories of 'shared bandwidth' never really did materialize. I sure don't notice it. That doesn't mean I haven't had trouble. It's been a real battle with Cox and their conversion from RoadRunner. A nightmare is more accurate. But that's because of Cox, not the cable itself. If it's run right, it's fine. -Larry "Bamadano" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > I'm currently using Bellsouth ADSL but the cable company (Charter > communications) made me an offer I couldnt refuse. (or at least think hard > about) My DSL 95% of the time only connects around 600mbs anyway and cable > promises 1.3. To those with cable...how is it? Any horror stories? Hadboth?? > Which is better? All opinions appreciated. > Thanks, > Dan
Mitch_A 25 Sep 2002 22:22 UTC↳ reply to Larry#96570
I would say just the opposite Larry. DSL seems to be solid as a rock whereas cable is iffy at best. I decided that bandwidth isnt the key issue for me and my family. Low/consistent latency is worth the extra $15/mo. Bear in mind though I live <3k/ft from the CO so I get exceptionally good lats. As always in this stuff, your mileage may vary... Too many variables. "Larry" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:8tpk9.28434$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (18 lines)> In most cases, I think Cable is better IF the cable company runs and > provisions it correctly. > > The predicted horror stories of 'shared bandwidth' never really did > materialize. I sure don't notice it. > > That doesn't mean I haven't had trouble. It's been a real battle with Cox > and their conversion from RoadRunner. A nightmare is more accurate. But > that's because of Cox, not the cable itself. > > If it's run right, it's fine. > > -Larry > > "Bamadano" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:[email hidden]... > > I'm currently using Bellsouth ADSL but the cable company (Charter > > communications) made me an offer I couldnt refuse. (or at least think
hard > > about) My DSL 95% of the time only connects around 600mbs anyway andcable
Quoted text (7 lines)> > promises 1.3. To those with cable...how is it? Any horror stories? Had > both?? > > Which is better? All opinions appreciated. > > Thanks, > > Dan > >
Quoted text (13 lines)>Dan, > >I've used Verizon DSL and Charter Pipeline. I generally had a bit more >downtime with DSL, but I was an early adopter in my area. The best thing >about Charter is combining it with digital cable service - I currently get >all the regular cable channels (including SPEED), all the digital cable >channels, all the HBO, Cinemax, Movie Channel, and Showtime channels, and my >cable internet for about $105/month. Granted, even with all those channels, >it's still a case of "500 channels and nothing to watch", but it's nice >having the choice for not much more than basic cable (about $40 most places) >and broadband internet (another $40). > >Rick
That is the exact package that I am getting Rick. I had the digital cable channels but they just went up to 72.95 so I'm taking the package for 99.99 + tax. This allows me to drop the 49.95 DSL bill. Thanks for the input, Dan
what pings were you getting on the cable? TIA Achim "callsignviper" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:BPbk9.534431$me6.74680@sccrnsc01... ... > It may not help but I have had AT&T cable for about 18 months...
"Bamadano" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > >Dan, > > > >I've used Verizon DSL and Charter Pipeline. I generally had a bit more > >downtime with DSL, but I was an early adopter in my area. The best thing > >about Charter is combining it with digital cable service - I currentlyget > >all the regular cable channels (including SPEED), all the digital cable > >channels, all the HBO, Cinemax, Movie Channel, and Showtime channels, andmy > >cable internet for about $105/month. Granted, even with all thosechannels, > >it's still a case of "500 channels and nothing to watch", but it's nice > >having the choice for not much more than basic cable (about $40 mostplaces) > >and broadband internet (another $40). > > > >Rick > > That is the exact package that I am getting Rick. I had the digital cable > channels but they just went up to 72.95 so I'm taking the package for99.99 + > tax. This allows me to drop the 49.95 DSL bill. Thanks for the input, > Dan Thought that might be the case :^) Anyways, I don't do any online gaming, so I can't comment on how well Pipeline works for that, but as far as typical broadband stuff goes, once you get past a certain threshold on download speed there's little to quibble about. My cable modem seems about as fast as my old DSL setup, but not as fast as my girlfriend's newer SBC DSL connection in CT. Rick
I've used both and found cable to be faster. Bamadano wrote:
Quoted text (7 lines)> I'm currently using Bellsouth ADSL but the cable company (Charter > communications) made me an offer I couldnt refuse. (or at least think hard > about) My DSL 95% of the time only connects around 600mbs anyway and cable > promises 1.3. To those with cable...how is it? Any horror stories? Had both?? > Which is better? All opinions appreciated. > Thanks, > Dan
Larry 27 Sep 2002 14:28 UTC↳ reply to Mitch_A#96299
Well, all I can say is that folks in my area are not fond of the DSL service at all. -Larry "Mitch_A" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:gGqk9.3514$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (21 lines)> I would say just the opposite Larry. DSL seems to be solid as a rock > whereas cable is iffy at best. > > I decided that bandwidth isnt the key issue for me and my family. > Low/consistent latency is worth the extra $15/mo. Bear in mind though I > live <3k/ft from the CO so I get exceptionally good lats. > > As always in this stuff, your mileage may vary... Too many variables. > > > > > "Larry" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:8tpk9.28434$[email hidden]... > > In most cases, I think Cable is better IF the cable company runs and > > provisions it correctly. > > > > The predicted horror stories of 'shared bandwidth' never really did > > materialize. I sure don't notice it. > > > > That doesn't mean I haven't had trouble. It's been a real battle with
Cox > > and their conversion from RoadRunner. A nightmare is more accurate.But
Quoted text (22 lines)> > that's because of Cox, not the cable itself. > > > > If it's run right, it's fine. > > > > -Larry > > > > "Bamadano" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > news:[email hidden]... > > > I'm currently using Bellsouth ADSL but the cable company (Charter > > > communications) made me an offer I couldnt refuse. (or at least think > hard > > > about) My DSL 95% of the time only connects around 600mbs anyway and > cable > > > promises 1.3. To those with cable...how is it? Any horror stories? Had > > both?? > > > Which is better? All opinions appreciated. > > > Thanks, > > > Dan > > > > > >

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy