Here are the results from the poll, sorted in places:
A total of 273 people voted
1) Grand Prix Legends - 205 Votes
2) Live For Speed Demo - 77 Votes
3) NASCAR Racing Series - 52 Votes
4) Gran Turismo Series - 49 Votes
=4) Viper Racing - 49 Votes
6) F1 2001/2 (and mods) - 46 Votes
7) Colin McRae Rally Series - 41 Votes
8) Sports Car GT (and mods) - 37 Votes
9) Indycar Racing Series - 32 Votes
10) Grand Prix Series (Crammond) - 31 Votes
11) Need For Speed Series - 30 Votes
=11) Rally Trophy - 30 Votes
13) Indy 500: The Simulation - 24 Votes
14) Mobil 1 Rally - 22 Votes
15) TOCA Series - 21 Votes
=15) Stunts - 21 Votes
17) Ferrari F355 Challenge - 20 Votes
18) Racer - 15 Votes
=18) Mercedes Benz Truck Racing - 15 Votes
20) GP 500 - 14 Votes
21) Carmageddon Series - 11 Votes
=21) Superbike Series (EA) - 11 Votes
23) Slicks 'n' Slide -10 Votes
24) Test Drive Series - 9 Votes
=24) Street Rod Series - 9 Votes
26) Dirt Track Racing Series - 8 Votes
=26) S.O.D.A Racing Series - 8 Votes
28) NetKar - 7 Votes
=28) ReVolt - 7 Votes
=28) Outrun - 7 Votes
31) Motocross Madness Series - 6 Votes
=31) Ironman 4x4 - 6 Votes
33) Network Q Rally - 4 Votes
=33) Burnout/NIRA Drag Series - 4 Votes
=33) Micro Machines Series - 4 Votes
=33) Sega Rally Series - 4 Votes
37) NASCAR Legends - 3 Votes
38) Car & Driver - 2 Votes
=38) Daytona USA Series - 2 Votes
40) Monster Truck Madness Series - 1 Vote
=40) Leadfoot - 1 Vote
=40) Bill Elliots NASCAR Challenge - 1 Vote
43) Spirit Of Speed 1937 - None!!
44) Mario Andretti Racing - None!!
Heres what i think:
Suprises (higher placed than i thought):
Viper Racing
Colin McRae
Slicks 'n' Slide (its a classic tho!)
Suprises (lower placed than i thought):
Leadfoot
Spirit Of Speed 1937
Monster Truck Madness
Mercedes Benz Truck Racing
Obvious ones:
Grand Prix Legends (duh!)
What people might find controversial:
Live For Speed
The Golden Goose award for a game that had big hopes on the developer and
player side but flopped in a big way:
A Tie between:
Spirit Of Speed 1937 & NASCAR Legends
Alltime classic award:
Indy 500: The Simulation
Runner ups:
Grand Prix Legends
Stunts
--
Luke
-=87=-
Thanx for a job well done, Luke !
Yep, good work Luke....
The original poll and peoples comments can be found here:
http://forum.racesimcentral.com/showthread.php?s=&threadid=44470
We hope Luke will instigate a similar poll in a few months, then we'll
announce it on the front of RSC and here in RAS to hopefully make even more
people vote. We should also change the format so people could give points to
e.g. 5 sims (10, 6, 4, 2 & 1 point)
That should give a better picture of people favourite sims.
Mikkel
Trick Dacy <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:P%Do9.152325$[email hidden]...
> Thanx for a job well done, Luke !
>
>
>
>"Luke Phillips" <(NOSPM)[email hidden]> wrote
> 3) NASCAR Racing Series - 52 Votes
Shouldn't Nascar Legends kinda be incorporated into that? ;)
> Suprises (higher placed than i thought):
Gran Turismo.
> Suprises (lower placed than i thought):
> Leadfoot
Bad support by the company.
> Spirit Of Speed 1937
Again.
> Monster Truck Madness
It was fun a couple of year ago, yeah.
> Mercedes Benz Truck Racing
I don't know why it's not as popular as it should be. It's a solid title.
Perhaps it's not enough customiseable. Perhaps it lacks in multiplayer.
> The Golden Goose award for a game that had big hopes on the developer and
> player side but flopped in a big way:
> A Tie between:
> Spirit Of Speed 1937 & NASCAR Legends
NASCAR Legends is one of the most solid title ever. It was just badly
marketed, and released at the same time as another Papyrus title. :(
--
-- Fran�ois M�nard <ymenard>
-- http://ymenard.cjb.net/
-- This announcement is brought to you by the Shimago-Dominguez
Corporation - helping America into the New World...
It's sad when a DEMO takes second spot :)
-Larry
"Luke Phillips" <(NOSPM)[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:hABo9.19151$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (87 lines)
> > Here are the results from the poll, sorted in places: > A total of 273 people voted > > 1) Grand Prix Legends - 205 Votes > 2) Live For Speed Demo - 77 Votes > 3) NASCAR Racing Series - 52 Votes > 4) Gran Turismo Series - 49 Votes > =4) Viper Racing - 49 Votes > 6) F1 2001/2 (and mods) - 46 Votes > 7) Colin McRae Rally Series - 41 Votes > 8) Sports Car GT (and mods) - 37 Votes > 9) Indycar Racing Series - 32 Votes > 10) Grand Prix Series (Crammond) - 31 Votes > 11) Need For Speed Series - 30 Votes > =11) Rally Trophy - 30 Votes > 13) Indy 500: The Simulation - 24 Votes > 14) Mobil 1 Rally - 22 Votes > 15) TOCA Series - 21 Votes > =15) Stunts - 21 Votes > 17) Ferrari F355 Challenge - 20 Votes > 18) Racer - 15 Votes > =18) Mercedes Benz Truck Racing - 15 Votes > 20) GP 500 - 14 Votes > 21) Carmageddon Series - 11 Votes > =21) Superbike Series (EA) - 11 Votes > 23) Slicks 'n' Slide -10 Votes > 24) Test Drive Series - 9 Votes > =24) Street Rod Series - 9 Votes > 26) Dirt Track Racing Series - 8 Votes > =26) S.O.D.A Racing Series - 8 Votes > 28) NetKar - 7 Votes > =28) ReVolt - 7 Votes > =28) Outrun - 7 Votes > 31) Motocross Madness Series - 6 Votes > =31) Ironman 4x4 - 6 Votes > 33) Network Q Rally - 4 Votes > =33) Burnout/NIRA Drag Series - 4 Votes > =33) Micro Machines Series - 4 Votes > =33) Sega Rally Series - 4 Votes > 37) NASCAR Legends - 3 Votes > 38) Car & Driver - 2 Votes > =38) Daytona USA Series - 2 Votes > 40) Monster Truck Madness Series - 1 Vote > =40) Leadfoot - 1 Vote > =40) Bill Elliots NASCAR Challenge - 1 Vote > 43) Spirit Of Speed 1937 - None!! > 44) Mario Andretti Racing - None!! > > Heres what i think: > > Suprises (higher placed than i thought): > Viper Racing > Colin McRae > Slicks 'n' Slide (its a classic tho!) > > Suprises (lower placed than i thought): > Leadfoot > Spirit Of Speed 1937 > Monster Truck Madness > Mercedes Benz Truck Racing > > Obvious ones: > Grand Prix Legends (duh!) > > What people might find controversial: > Live For Speed > > The Golden Goose award for a game that had big hopes on the developer and > player side but flopped in a big way: > A Tie between: > Spirit Of Speed 1937 & NASCAR Legends > > Alltime classic award: > Indy 500: The Simulation > Runner ups: > Grand Prix Legends > Stunts > > > > -- > Luke > -=87=- > > >Larry wrote:
> It's sad when a DEMO takes second spot :)
Think about it, that's what we want to see really.
Gerry
In article <dGFo9.6343$[email hidden]>, "ymenard"
<[email hidden]> writes:
>> Mercedes Benz Truck Racing
>
>I don't know why it's not as popular as it should be. It's a solid title.
>Perhaps it's not enough customiseable. Perhaps it lacks in multiplayer.
>
If I had the same success configuring the retail version as I did the demo, I'd
love the thing. However, I've NEVER been able to get it to use my TSW2
correctly. So, it sits on my shelf, collecting dust... :-(
Eldred
--
Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett
GPLRank:+8.03
N2002 Rank:+20.124
Never argue with an idiot. He brings you down to his level, then beats you
with experience...
Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
On Tue, 08 Oct 2002 14:02:53 GMT, "Luke Phillips"
<(NOSPM)[email hidden]> wrote:
>
>Here are the results from the poll, sorted in places:
>A total of 273 people voted
>...and nothing about Rally Masters...:(
Every night there is 30+ people online, having fun racing...
We race and don't read newsgroups :)
--
Med venlig hilsen / Best regards
Thore Sorensen - DK-2700 Bronshoj
(Z = spamfilter)
well, i guess it depends a bit on which forum/site this poll took place. of
course i like gpl, but this must be a gpl-fan-crowded site obviously.
then, seeing that LFS "Demo" (good game!) is 2nd here makes me think that a
sim-racer must be some kind of disappointed nature, disappointed by the
sim-racing gaming industry.
viper is quite a cool/relaxing game, i wasn't surprised seeing it on 4th
place.
uhm....place 6 and 10 (which i supposed to be on top) counted together have
as many votes as LFS and only a third of gpl, now is that representative ?
oh, and sorry for the critics, i did not put on my flame-suite before
entering gpl.autos.simulators ;)
"Luke Phillips" <(NOSPM)[email hidden]> schrieb im Newsbeitrag
news:hABo9.19151$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (14 lines)
> > Here are the results from the poll, sorted in places: > A total of 273 people voted > > 1) Grand Prix Legends - 205 Votes > 2) Live For Speed Demo - 77 Votes > 3) NASCAR Racing Series - 52 Votes > 4) Gran Turismo Series - 49 Votes > =4) Viper Racing - 49 Votes > 6) F1 2001/2 (and mods) - 46 Votes > 7) Colin McRae Rally Series - 41 Votes > 8) Sports Car GT (and mods) - 37 Votes > 9) Indycar Racing Series - 32 Votes > 10) Grand Prix Series (Crammond) - 31 VotesYou are right... RSC is/was very much centered around the world of GPL, and
of course that shows in the result.
I think a lot would look different though if people had had the chance to
distribute their votes a bit more instead of picking just one game.
LFS in second place is in my view a good thing as it shows that we have
somethning really good to hope for in the future.
The thing I wonder most about is why Racer is not places higher despite
being "our" own simulation.... guess the lack of multiplayer and AI really
kills it ?
Anyways hope Luke will instigate a polling in a few months again....
Mikkel
Stefan Roth <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:1034159632.389634@nbgm66x...
> well, i guess it depends a bit on which forum/site this poll took place.of
> course i like gpl, but this must be a gpl-fan-crowded site obviously.
> then, seeing that LFS "Demo" (good game!) is 2nd here makes me think thata
> sim-racer must be some kind of disappointed nature, disappointed by the
> sim-racing gaming industry.
> viper is quite a cool/relaxing game, i wasn't surprised seeing it on 4th
> place.
> uhm....place 6 and 10 (which i supposed to be on top) counted togetherhave
Quoted text (25 lines)
> as many votes as LFS and only a third of gpl, now is that representative ? > > oh, and sorry for the critics, i did not put on my flame-suite before > entering gpl.autos.simulators ;) > > > "Luke Phillips" <(NOSPM)[email hidden]> schrieb im Newsbeitrag > news:hABo9.19151$[email hidden]... > > > > Here are the results from the poll, sorted in places: > > A total of 273 people voted > > > > 1) Grand Prix Legends - 205 Votes > > 2) Live For Speed Demo - 77 Votes > > 3) NASCAR Racing Series - 52 Votes > > 4) Gran Turismo Series - 49 Votes > > =4) Viper Racing - 49 Votes > > 6) F1 2001/2 (and mods) - 46 Votes > > 7) Colin McRae Rally Series - 41 Votes > > 8) Sports Car GT (and mods) - 37 Votes > > 9) Indycar Racing Series - 32 Votes > > 10) Grand Prix Series (Crammond) - 31 Votes > > >Multiple selections were available, i choose the racing games that i
remember having the most fun with, not just what im having fun with today or
last year, or for the last 4 years.... how can you go past stunts??? :)
Cool Hand Luke
-=87=-
"Mikkel Gram-Hansen" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:3da41807$0$18534$[email hidden]...
> You are right... RSC is/was very much centered around the world of GPL,and
that
?
Quoted text (20 lines)
> of course that shows in the result. > I think a lot would look different though if people had had the chance to > distribute their votes a bit more instead of picking just one game. > > LFS in second place is in my view a good thing as it shows that we have > somethning really good to hope for in the future. > The thing I wonder most about is why Racer is not places higher despite > being "our" own simulation.... guess the lack of multiplayer and AI really > kills it ? > > Anyways hope Luke will instigate a polling in a few months again.... > > Mikkel > > Stefan Roth <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:1034159632.389634@nbgm66x... > > well, i guess it depends a bit on which forum/site this poll took place. > of > > course i like gpl, but this must be a gpl-fan-crowded site obviously. > > then, seeing that LFS "Demo" (good game!) is 2nd here makes me thinkQuoted text (8 lines)
> a > > sim-racer must be some kind of disappointed nature, disappointed by the > > sim-racing gaming industry. > > viper is quite a cool/relaxing game, i wasn't surprised seeing it on 4th > > place. > > uhm....place 6 and 10 (which i supposed to be on top) counted together > have > > as many votes as LFS and only a third of gpl, now is that representativeQuoted text (26 lines)
> > > > oh, and sorry for the critics, i did not put on my flame-suite before > > entering gpl.autos.simulators ;) > > > > > > "Luke Phillips" <(NOSPM)[email hidden]> schrieb im Newsbeitrag > > news:hABo9.19151$[email hidden]... > > > > > > Here are the results from the poll, sorted in places: > > > A total of 273 people voted > > > > > > 1) Grand Prix Legends - 205 Votes > > > 2) Live For Speed Demo - 77 Votes > > > 3) NASCAR Racing Series - 52 Votes > > > 4) Gran Turismo Series - 49 Votes > > > =4) Viper Racing - 49 Votes > > > 6) F1 2001/2 (and mods) - 46 Votes > > > 7) Colin McRae Rally Series - 41 Votes > > > 8) Sports Car GT (and mods) - 37 Votes > > > 9) Indycar Racing Series - 32 Votes > > > 10) Grand Prix Series (Crammond) - 31 Votes > > > > > > > >In article <3da41807$0$18534$[email hidden]>, "Mikkel
Gram-Hansen" <[email hidden]> writes:
>You are right... RSC is/was very much centered around the world of GPL, and
>of course that shows in the result.
>I think a lot would look different though if people had had the chance to
>distribute their votes a bit more instead of picking just one game.
I picked about 6 or 7 out of my previous top 10 list. Obviously *you* didn't
choose more than one...? :-)
Eldred
--
Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett
GPLRank:+8.03
N2002 Rank:+20.124
Never argue with an idiot. He brings you down to his level, then beats you
with experience...
Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
LOL.. Yep I did, but as far as I can see "behind the scenes" of the poll,
most people voted only for one game.
Mikkel
EldredP <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
> In article <3da41807$0$18534$[email hidden]>, "Mikkel
> Gram-Hansen" <[email hidden]> writes:
>
> >You are right... RSC is/was very much centered around the world of GPL,and
> >of course that shows in the result.
> >I think a lot would look different though if people had had the chance to
> >distribute their votes a bit more instead of picking just one game.
>
> I picked about 6 or 7 out of my previous top 10 list. Obviously *you*didn't
you
> with experience...
> Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
Quoted text (9 lines)
> choose more than one...? :-) > > Eldred > -- > Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett > GPLRank:+8.03 > N2002 Rank:+20.124 > > Never argue with an idiot. He brings you down to his level, then beatsOn Tue, 08 Oct 2002 14:02:53 GMT, "Luke Phillips"
<(NOSPM)[email hidden]> wrote:
>3) NASCAR Racing Series - 52 Votes
I assume that means Sierra/Papyrus releases. What about NASCAR
Heat? I thought with some of the mods that would get *some* votes.
And how about 1NSANE?, that's a lot of fun.
Otherwise, interesting poll, thanks for posting.
"But in a way, fear is a big part of racing, because if there was
nothing to be frightened of, and no limit, any fool could get into
a motor car and racing would not exist as a sport." -- Jim Clark


































