Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

Re: Just lost interest in Codemasters Indycar

33 posts by 18 people · 17 May 2003 22:00 UTC - 26 May 2003 20:48 UTC

Early screenshots sour interest in Codemasters' IndyCar game

Screenshots of Codemasters' IRL game, showing no gauges, poor graphics and no multiplayer or road tracks, drew disappointment. John Bodin noted that the IRL had pressed him over his IRL Heat mod, and the thread again rehashed CART versus IRL politics and joked about how RAS would critique a future Papyrus Champ Car sim.

review/impressionsreal motorsportIndyCar Series

Automated summary.

Jan Verschueren 17 May 2003 22:01 UTC#68138
"Kronos" wrote... > And here's why. > <snip> What's the problem? Jan. =---
Yeah, it's not even out yet, and disappointment abounds. I'm actually just baffled that Codemasters has NEVER responded to my queries about beta testing or assisting with the pre- and post-release promotion for this game. They were threatened enough with my IRL Heat mod for NASCAR Heat that they had the IRL deliver me a "cease and desist" message, which forced me to pull the IRL Heat mod from circulation (I have the distinction of having the first "banned" mod, I think): http://irlheat.bhmotorsports.com/new-indyNOTICE.htm :-( If Codemasters really does drop the ball on IndyCar Series, you can always check out my NEW "All-American Open Wheel Racing" mod for NASCAR Heat, though: http;//irlheat.bhmotorsports.com/ Decent physics, PLUS a reasonable cockpit view -- what more could you ask for? ;-) -- JCB "Mike Beauchamp" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:<9tyxa.6261$[email hidden]>...
Quoted text (17 lines)> I saw both of those today actually, and I couldn't get over how bad the > graphics looked. I'm not sure if that's what you are referring to though. > But at least there's a cockpit view :) > > Mike > http://mikebeauchamp.com > > "Kronos" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:[email hidden]... > > And here's why. > > > > http://www.bhmotorsports.com/IRL/screenshot/6577 > > > > http://www.bhmotorsports.com/IRL/screenshot/6576 > > > > -- > > Not For Email
jbodin wrote:
Quoted text (8 lines)> They were threatened enough with my IRL Heat mod for > NASCAR Heat that they had the IRL deliver me a "cease and desist" > message, which forced me to pull the IRL Heat mod from circulation (I > have the distinction of having the first "banned" mod, I think): > > http://irlheat.bhmotorsports.com/new-indyNOTICE.htm > > :-(
This is, IMO, a whole lot of BS. Personally, and I'm not saying the law agrees with me on this, I believe that as long as you're not making one penny from the project and you're not projecting anything negative about the track, then it should be allowed for download. "Well, another company is making a game with our track." My reply, in the land of fantasy, would've been "boo ****ing hoo". You paid for the software (NASCAR Heat), so you should be allowed to modify it however you like. That, in my opinion, is fair use. Charging for it or any kind of defamation isn't. If I were to go make a Firebird in zmodeler and toss it into a sim, I doubt GM would throw a fit over it. If anyone wanted to push the matter, I'd say it was art (which it is) and only give it to friends. Nothing wrong with that. Then again, there is a Indianapolis track for a certain freeware sim. Why aren't they throwing a tantrum over that? -Will
> Then again, there is a Indianapolis track for a certain freeware sim. > Why aren't they throwing a tantrum over that? > > -Will > > I think the legal types at Codemasters were attempting to prevent the dilution of an upcomming product. If there is a freely available IRL mod, then the early birds who usually make up a big portion of software sales, might not be so interested in a commercial version. Or...they don't want to look bad compared to John's effort, which would have had at least one feature not available in the Codemaster's release, and that would be multiplayer...MP that can handle about 20 or so drivers to boot. dave henrie
Dave Henrie wrote:
Quoted text (16 lines)>>Then again, there is a Indianapolis track for a certain freeware sim. >>Why aren't they throwing a tantrum over that? >> >>-Will >> >> > > I think the legal types at Codemasters were attempting to prevent the > dilution of an upcomming product. If there is a freely available IRL mod, > then the early birds who usually make up a big portion of software sales, > might not be so interested in a commercial version. Or...they don't want > to look bad compared to John's effort, which would have had at least one > feature not available in the Codemaster's release, and that would be > multiplayer...MP that can handle about 20 or so drivers to boot. > dave henrie >
That's true, but on the other hand, you'd think they would try to churn out a piece of software better than "the other guys". Could be that you nailed the real reason, as you stated about not to look bad compared to something offered freely or by a competitor. It still doesn't explain, though, why they're not sending a cease and desist order to "that other sims" Indy track creator. Technically, the person is using their intellectual property illegally as well. I'd love to see Mr. Bodin's story hit all the major PC mag rags. It would possibly, and if so, seriously undermine their ability to perform well in the PC market. The bad press is warranted, I believe. These game companies want to keep a tight reign on their software. And, truthfully, I can't blame 'em. Yet the best part of being in the racing sim community is seeing the great work people put out in regards to mod's. Fer chrissakes, take a look at what folks have done with GPL. This little niggle reminds me of the Daytona track that was being designed for NASCAR Racing 2, before ISC got into the mix and nixed it. It's no wonder I throw my support behind people and companies who want customers to use their software creatively. It seems to me that the best purchase I ever made was of the Need For Speed series. Plenty of user created vehicles and tracks amounted to days of fun. -Will
"Kronos" wrote... > > <snip> > Um, no gauges at all in the cockpit? It smacks of arcade > game when they do that. Not to mention the cockpit looks > real bad graphically too. Codemasters haven't made anything resembling a sim in the last 6 years, so nobody's getting their hopes up. Absense of cockpit gauges should not, however, suggest arcade. LFS had no cockpit gauges in the early versions. Real Carsim didn't even have cockpit view. I wouldn't class either as arcade, though. Also, graphics don't enter the equation. They are a nice extra, not a requirement. Jan. =---
"Freak" wrote... > > <snip> > They are if you want to compete in the market. The > cars look great from the outside view so it just > looks odd that they paid so little attention to the > cockpit view. Unless someone took those screen shots > using a low res texture option for slower machines. You have a point, I should have been more clear. If we start from the premise of the game being a simulation, graphics don't enter into the picture as I think we've established that combining simulation with mass market appeal is a futile excercise. For an arcade inspired game, you are right. It's got to have the visuals to wow the public. I haven't seen the release version, but the cockpit graphics in the Race Driver beta-demo (another Codemasters release) were butt ugly too, so they might improve (or not). Jan. =---
"Larry" <[email hidden]> wrote in news:syVxa.31158$[email hidden]: > Does the Indy League run any road courses ? > > Larry > > Not yet, but it is only a matter of time. They have left the usa because Honda paid for the league to run that track(Twin Ring Motegi, Japan), they will race roadies when they find a manufacturer who will grease the rails. ONe of the reasons Mario Andretti pushed so hard to get Road America back on the Cart schedule was the perception that the IRL would love to steal RA and Mid Ohio. dave henrie
> Not yet, but it is only a matter of time. Hopefully not. Well, maybe one or two, just to mix things up but those races won't be nearly as exciting as the IRL oval races. It's another thread I suppose but road courses can't duplicate the races they run on the ovals in IRL. The Texas races being a prime example of that. Wheel to wheel for 25 laps and a photo finish. Beautiful.
Dave Henrie <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:<[email hidden]>...
Quoted text (15 lines)> "Larry" <[email hidden]> wrote in > news:syVxa.31158$[email hidden]: > > > Does the Indy League run any road courses ? > > > > Larry > > > > > Not yet, but it is only a matter of time. They have left the usa > because Honda paid for the league to run that track(Twin Ring Motegi, > Japan), they will race roadies when they find a manufacturer who will > grease the rails. ONe of the reasons Mario Andretti pushed so hard to get > Road America back on the Cart schedule was the perception that the IRL > would love to steal RA and Mid Ohio. > dave henrie
Jeez, can you imagine those guys on a roadie? Turning left seems to be a problem for most of them...
Dave Henrie <[email hidden]> wrote in news:[email hidden]: > grease the rails. ONe of the reasons Mario Andretti pushed so hard to > get Road America back on the Cart schedule was the perception that the > IRL would love to steal RA and Mid Ohio. > dave henrie This is off the topic, but man, how can ChampCar allow IRL to get a sim to market before them? A missed opportunity.
Worse, CART allowed a whole 'nother series to poach their eggs (teams, engines, sponsors, drivers, tracks, TV). "Ped Xing" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]...
Quoted text (10 lines)> Dave Henrie <[email hidden]> wrote in > news:[email hidden]: > > > grease the rails. ONe of the reasons Mario Andretti pushed so hard to > > get Road America back on the Cart schedule was the perception that the > > IRL would love to steal RA and Mid Ohio. > > dave henrie > > This is off the topic, but man, how can ChampCar allow IRL to get a sim to > market before them? A missed opportunity.
"Steve Smith" <[email hidden]> wrote in news:a5qya.176145$[email hidden]: > Worse, CART allowed a whole 'nother series to poach their eggs (teams, > engines, sponsors, drivers, tracks, TV). But now the series for the 'common' man. The low bucks series designed to save American openwheel racing is such a high cost endeavor that many long time particpants can no longer compete. I am especially embarrased for Chevy...nearly a decade of R&D and they are miles behind the first year efforts of Toyota and Honda. How many chassis did the 'man whose name I will never utter' subsidize for this year's field? dave(thinking of Franchitti vs Bordais at a street circuit)henrie
Dave Henrie wrote: > I am especially embarrased > for Chevy...nearly a decade of R&D and they are miles behind the first year > efforts of Toyota and Honda. Until this year, GM had little reason to sink gobs of money into further development, as they had a near monopoly on the field. They had strength in numbers over the Infiniti, and once the Infiniti started showing definite promise, they pulled the plug to focus on the IPS. More a case of caught with their pants down. -jde
"J.D. Ellis"
Quoted text (9 lines)> Until this year, GM had little reason to sink gobs of money into > further development, as they had a near monopoly on the field. They > had strength in numbers over the Infiniti, and once the Infiniti > started showing definite promise, they pulled the plug to focus on the > IPS. > > More a case of caught with their pants down. > > -jde
Leaving the ONE true American Star with little chance of winning. Poor Sam Hornish...hopefully he'll either get a new engine package next year or he will bolt to Nascar. DEI is casting the net. dave henrie
gddd 23 May 2003 22:18 UTC↳ reply to Nick#67646
You mean like all those CART drivers? wait, all those CART drivers now race in the IRL! pffffft You make a statement like that when CART was/is worst than anything the IRL did. lol At least the IRL has a future, unlike CART. Shame about CART, but they did it to themselves. "Nick" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > Dave Henrie <[email hidden]> wrote in messagenews:<[email hidden]>...
Quoted text (12 lines)> > "Larry" <[email hidden]> wrote in > > news:syVxa.31158$[email hidden]: > > > > > Does the Indy League run any road courses ? > > > > > > Larry > > > > > > > > Not yet, but it is only a matter of time. They have left the usa > > because Honda paid for the league to run that track(Twin Ring Motegi, > > Japan), they will race roadies when they find a manufacturer who will > > grease the rails. ONe of the reasons Mario Andretti pushed so hard to
get > > Road America back on the Cart schedule was the perception that the IRL > > would love to steal RA and Mid Ohio. > > dave henrie > > Jeez, can you imagine those guys on a roadie? Turning left seems to be > a problem for most of them...
"gddd" <[email hidden]> wrote in news:H6xza.1361$[email hidden]:
Quoted text (7 lines)> You mean like all those CART drivers? wait, all those CART drivers > now race in the IRL! pffffft You make a statement like that when > CART was/is worst than anything the IRL did. lol At least the IRL > has a future, unlike CART. Shame about CART, but they did it to > themselves. > >
So it was CART that removed the single biggest race in the USA with the largest advertising campaigns from the CART budgets? It was CART that made NO attempt at reconciation? It was CART that said it was an American series for American Drivers on American Ovals???? The single biggest crime of the irl is the splitting of sponsorship $$. Whatever faults each league has, they are maginified by the deminishing sponsorship pool. Ask the two time defending IRL champ how much of a budget he has. And why he's stuck on the 7th row with the fastest Chevy block. Ask Penkse why Marlboro was mad their red & white cars didn't have any logos on them back when Helio first won. Ask any sponsor which series they prefer. Most will probably say...."Series? We just want 'The Race.'" Indy towers over all the CART and irl events. Indy is a club that has been weilded, not by CART, but by that heinous slimeball who sprang up from the loins of the very Devil himself. Yes I am well aware of CART's mis-steps. I am well aware of the mistakes that help push Toyota and Honda over to the 'dark side.' But I also am quite clear on who pushed who first. A childish little man with his step Daddy's toy. Maybe we can get lucky and Nascar will bail out the sorry mess of open wheel racing and put those butt-ugly Daytona Prototypes in the IRL as well. and on another note...one of the stick and ball magazines quoted a statistic that in the USA, ONE SINGLE Nascar race, a nightime event at Richmond, drew more viewers than all the F1, CART and irl races so far this season. Sad. dave henrie
Jeff Green is just warming the seat. I GUARANTEE you that Sam will be driving the number 1 next year. "Dave Henrie" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]...
Quoted text (13 lines)> "J.D. Ellis" > > > Until this year, GM had little reason to sink gobs of money into > > further development, as they had a near monopoly on the field. They > > had strength in numbers over the Infiniti, and once the Infiniti > > started showing definite promise, they pulled the plug to focus on the > > IPS. > > > > More a case of caught with their pants down. > > > > -jde > > Leaving the ONE true American Star with little chance of winning.
Poor > Sam Hornish...hopefully he'll either get a new engine package next year or > he will bolt to Nascar. DEI is casting the net. > > dave henrie > >
"Ped Xing" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... >> This is off the topic, but man, how can ChampCar allow IRL to get a simto > market before them? A missed opportunity. Actually that's kinda a funny thing: Playstation: Launch title: SECA's Champ Car World Series ( Good start but never built on) Dreamcast : Launch title : Flag to Flag (OK in a SEGA arcade kinda way) Playstation 2 : One of the first titles CART Fury (Worst ... game ... ever.) Gamecube: One of the first racing titles: Driven (Worst ... movie ... ever.) (Really bad game too.) PC : One of the first Direct X games Microsoft's : CPR ('nuff said) So actually CART has almost always beaten every one (NASCAR and F1 included) to the punch. Unfortunately, they have almost universally stunk. Getting to market first isn't the trick it's having something worthwhile once you're there. And the writing on the wall for Codemaster's IRL doesn't look good. I realize I see the world through the prism of an RAS guy but I always thought a good litmus test of Chris Pook would be if he could get a licensed game out there that was popular and good. Rudeboy
Quoted text (7 lines)> I realize I see the world through the prism of an RAS guy but I always > thought a good litmus test of Chris Pook would be if he could get a > licensed game out there that was popular and good. > > Rudeboy > >
"Bridgestone Presents the Champcar World Series Powered by Ford, coded by Papyrus and critqued by RAS." or BPCWSFCPCR for short. :) can't wait for BPCWSFCPCR Championship edition and BPCWSFCPCR 2004 and BPCWSFCPCR:2. BPCWSFCPCR:The Turbo Years. I've got more.... :) dave henrie
Dave Henrie wrote:
Quoted text (10 lines)> "Bridgestone Presents the Champcar World Series Powered by Ford, coded > by Papyrus and critqued by RAS." or BPCWSFCPCR for short. :) > > can't wait for BPCWSFCPCR Championship edition and BPCWSFCPCR 2004 and > BPCWSFCPCR:2. BPCWSFCPCR:The Turbo Years. > I've got more.... > :) > > dave henrie >
I can see the critiquing now: Person1: "Man, this tire model sucks. Might I recommend..." Person2: "You're wrong. Shut up, idiot." Person3: "Yeah, tard. It's perfect!" Person4: "Be lucky there's even a Champcar sim to begin with!" Person5: "You don't know what you're talking about." ;) -Will
William Bradshaw wrote:
Quoted text (10 lines)> I can see the critiquing now: > > Person1: "Man, this tire model sucks. Might I recommend..." > Person2: "You're wrong. Shut up, idiot." > Person3: "Yeah, tard. It's perfect!" > Person4: "Be lucky there's even a Champcar sim to begin with!" > Person5: "You don't know what you're talking about." > > ;) > -Will
Person 6: "It's no GPL" -- Ian P <email invalid due to spammers>
Ian P wrote: > Person 6: "It's no GPL" > > -- > > Ian P > <email invalid due to spammers> *laughs* Doh! How could I have forgotten that one? Shame on me. ;) Maybe I should've added a line about Aussie V8's, too? :D -Will

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy