RaceSimCentral LFS S1 review and car unlocking
A link to RaceSimCentral's review of Live for Speed S1 prompted discussion of its points system for unlocking faster cars. EldredP objected to having to earn content he had paid for, while others said it took about an hour, recommended short pro races, and argued it kept inexperienced drivers out of the fastest cars online.
review/impressionsLive for Speed
Automated summary.
WOW. Those screenshots... wow.
Okay, I"m convinced.. where do I pay?
Mike
http://mikebeauchamp.com
"Four furry fiends" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:bfjec4$79m$[email hidden]...
> http://www.racesimcentral.com/articles/reviews/pc/lfs/index.shtml
>
> Sean
>
>
"Mike Beauchamp" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
lfs.racesimcentral.com I believe
Doug
Quoted text (7 lines)
> WOW. Those screenshots... wow. > > Okay, I"m convinced.. where do I pay? > > Mike > http://mikebeauchamp.com >In article <bfjec4$79m$[email hidden]>, "Four furry fiends"
<[email hidden]> writes:
>http://www.racesimcentral.com/articles/reviews/pc/lfs/index.shtml
>
>Sean
"The cars become available on a point system, as you race. Under both online
and single player, you accumulate points for finishing in the top 3. These
points are used to unlock the more advanced cars, but don't be too disheartened
by this, bear in mind this is an Online Racing Simulator, the points system
ensures that new or inexperienced racers don't get the hands on something too
quick, too early. It's also a crafty way of maintaining a progressive learning
curve for drivers. Experienced sim racers will have their hands on all the cars
within a relatively short time frame."
I hate games that make you 'unlock' the cars. If I paid for the game, give me
ALL the cars, dammit...
Eldred
--
Help find missing child: Tatianna Ashley Chillcutt from Michigan(info on my
homepage)
Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett
Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
In article <[email hidden]>,
[email hidden] (EldredP) wrote:
> I hate games that make you 'unlock' the cars. If I paid for the game,
> give me ALL the cars, dammit...
Agreed. If I hadn't forked out real money for the S1 release I'd not
have bothered building up the points. The basic cars aren't very
entertaining IMO. They demonstrate the working code well, and they were
interesting enough for a while in the initial demo, but that was
*forever* ago.
Andrew McP
Heheh, "patience, for the Jedi it is time to eat as well" or something like
that. - Yoda.
I thought driving was part of the fun... ;)
Sean
>
> I hate games that make you 'unlock' the cars. If I paid for the game,give me
> ALL the cars, dammit...
>
> Eldred
> --
Yeah, any cheats in LFS to get to the better cars? This FWD crap is
annoying!
Larry
"Four furry fiends" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:bfrvju$n8b$[email hidden]...
> Heheh, "patience, for the Jedi it is time to eat as well" or somethinglike
Quoted text (14 lines)
> that. - Yoda. > I thought driving was part of the fun... ;) > > Sean > > > > > I hate games that make you 'unlock' the cars. If I paid for the game, > give me > > ALL the cars, dammit... > > > > Eldred > > -- > >"Larry" <[email hidden]> wrote in news:8igUa.3888$5b7.1473@lakeread01:
> Yeah, any cheats in LFS to get to the better cars? This FWD crap is
> annoying!
If I were in charge of design, I wouldn't have you unlock cars, but it's
not a big deal. I unlocked the RB4 and FX0 within an hour of playing,
IIRC.
"Larry" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:8igUa.3888$5b7.1473@lakeread01...
> Yeah, any cheats in LFS to get to the better cars? This FWD crap is
> annoying!
Drive really fast.
Malc.
In article <[email hidden]>, Ped Xing
<[email hidden]> writes:
Sure, not a big deal for you. I also watched you lap Silverstone 10 seconds
per lap faster than me. Imagine if you had to break the 8:30 mark at the Ring
in the Eagle in order to unlock the Ferrari and Lotus. Some of us STILL
wouldn't be able to access those two cars.
Eldred
--
Help find missing child: Tatianna Ashley Chillcutt from Michigan(info on my
homepage)
Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett
Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
Quoted text (8 lines)
>"Larry" <[email hidden]> wrote in news:8igUa.3888$5b7.1473@lakeread01: > >> Yeah, any cheats in LFS to get to the better cars? This FWD crap is >> annoying! > >If I were in charge of design, I wouldn't have you unlock cars, but it's >not a big deal. I unlocked the RB4 and FX0 within an hour of playing, >IIRC.In article <bfrvju$n8b$[email hidden]>, "Four furry fiends"
<[email hidden]> writes:
Maybe, but if you can't access all the cars, you're not getting all the game
you've PAID for. I have Gran Tourismo for the PS1. I can't win the races at
the "b" level(whatever the highest is). Therefore, there are 3 or 4 cars that
I can't use. That's bull, IMO.
You should be able to race every car in the game on every track in the game.
Whether or not you could control said combo isn't relevant...
Eldred
--
Help find missing child: Tatianna Ashley Chillcutt from Michigan(info on my
homepage)
Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett
Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
Quoted text (10 lines)
>Heheh, "patience, for the Jedi it is time to eat as well" or something like >that. - Yoda. >I thought driving was part of the fun... ;) > >Sean > >> >> I hate games that make you 'unlock' the cars. If I paid for the game, >give me >> ALL the cars, dammit...EldredP wrote:
Sigh, you'd never make it in the racing game industry.
I bet you even believe that the game should be about racing,
rather than stuffing in more "Gameplay".
;)
- Matt
Quoted text (26 lines)
> In article <bfrvju$n8b$[email hidden]>, "Four furry fiends" > <[email hidden]> writes: > > >>Heheh, "patience, for the Jedi it is time to eat as well" or something like >>that. - Yoda. >>I thought driving was part of the fun... ;) >> >>Sean >> >> >>>I hate games that make you 'unlock' the cars. If I paid for the game, >> >>give me >> >>>ALL the cars, dammit... >> > > Maybe, but if you can't access all the cars, you're not getting all the game > you've PAID for. I have Gran Tourismo for the PS1. I can't win the races at > the "b" level(whatever the highest is). Therefore, there are 3 or 4 cars that > I can't use. That's bull, IMO. > You should be able to race every car in the game on every track in the game. > Whether or not you could control said combo isn't relevant... > > Eldred"EldredP" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
> Imagine if you had to break the 8:30 mark at the Ring
> in the Eagle in order to unlock the Ferrari and Lotus. Some of us STILL
> wouldn't be able to access those two cars.
You don't have specific goals to achieve to unlock the cars, you just
accumulate points. The better your results the more points you get, but you
can get them in on-line races too, so as long as you finish 3rd or higher,
you'll get the points sooner or later.
Considering your reputation for finishing races, I would think you should be
able to get the points as quickly as the next chap on-line, and the AI
really aren't that hard to beat as long as you don't crash.
Malc.
"EldredP" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
> Maybe, but if you can't access all the cars, you're not getting all thegame
> you've PAID for. I have Gran Tourismo for the PS1. I can't win the racesat
> the "b" level(whatever the highest is). Therefore, there are 3 or 4 carsthat
> I can't use. That's bull, IMO.
> You should be able to race every car in the game on every track in thegame.
> Whether or not you could control said combo isn't relevant...
If it's as rigid as LFS, I think it's a bad idea, but if it's as fluid as
GT, I think it's brilliant, because you can tune up a car you do own to race
better cars in the same category. The rules aren't so rigid.
It's the same with story based FPS games. If you get stuck on Half-Life,
you're stuck completely because it's 100% linear, but if you get stuck on
Deus Ex, you can take care of a secondary objective and find a way around
the problem.
It's all about the implementation, not the concept.
It takes 1 hour to get all the cars unlocked... and thats one hour of seat
time some kidz need VERY badly before they can select the LX6 in an online
race :)
You won't find the LX6 any fun before you have had a few hours in the other
cars anyway.
The developers actually wanted a lower credit level needed, while a lot of
the betatesters voted for a much highter threshold, in the end I think we
found a good compromise.
Pick a 3 lap race at the shortest track, place in the top 3 to accumulate
credits and after a few repeats you will be able to select the RB4... after
that you will have no difficulty getting the rest of the points needed to
unlock the LX6. Please try it and I'm sure you will agree it was not any
problem at all ;)
Mikkel
EldredP <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
online
> and single player, you accumulate points for finishing in the top 3. These
> points are used to unlock the more advanced cars, but don't be toodisheartened
> by this, bear in mind this is an Online Racing Simulator, the pointssystem
> ensures that new or inexperienced racers don't get the hands on somethingtoo
> quick, too early. It's also a crafty way of maintaining a progressivelearning
> curve for drivers. Experienced sim racers will have their hands on all thecars
> within a relatively short time frame."
>
> I hate games that make you 'unlock' the cars. If I paid for the game,give me
> ALL the cars, dammit...
>
> Eldred
> --
> Help find missing child: Tatianna Ashley Chillcutt from Michigan(info onmy
> homepage)
> Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett
>
> Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
Quoted text (8 lines)
> In article <bfjec4$79m$[email hidden]>, "Four furry fiends" > <[email hidden]> writes: > > >http://www.racesimcentral.com/articles/reviews/pc/lfs/index.shtml > > > >Sean > > "The cars become available on a point system, as you race. Under bothIn article <[email hidden]>, Matt Jessick <[email hidden]>
writes:
Hehe...guilty as charged...<g>
Eldred
--
Help find missing child: Tatianna Ashley Chillcutt from Michigan(info on my
homepage)
Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett
Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
Quoted text (16 lines)
>> Maybe, but if you can't access all the cars, you're not getting all the >game >> you've PAID for. I have Gran Tourismo for the PS1. I can't win the races >at >> the "b" level(whatever the highest is). Therefore, there are 3 or 4 cars >that >> I can't use. That's bull, IMO. >> You should be able to race every car in the game on every track in the >game. >> Whether or not you could control said combo isn't relevant... >> >> Eldred > >Sigh, you'd never make it in the racing game industry. >I bet you even believe that the game should be about racing, >rather than stuffing in more "Gameplay".In article <bftm14$iauha$[email hidden]>, "Nick"
<[email hidden]> writes:
>If it's as rigid as LFS, I think it's a bad idea, but if it's as fluid as
>GT, I think it's brilliant, because you can tune up a car you do own to race
>better cars in the same category. The rules aren't so rigid.
I got so frustrated with GT that I haven't played it in several months. In a
solid weekend(friday - sunday) of playing, I was not able to win the
championship that would allow me to access the best cars. We're talking
several hours each day. Couldn't do it, got pissed off, it's collecting dust
now.
Eldred
--
Help find missing child: Tatianna Ashley Chillcutt from Michigan(info on my
homepage)
Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett
Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
In article <dhoUa.50037$[email hidden]>, "Malc"
<[email hidden]> writes:
Ah, so it's like collecting experience points in Diablo 2? Ok, well that's a
*little* better. I still disagree with that in principle, though.
Eldred
--
Help find missing child: Tatianna Ashley Chillcutt from Michigan(info on my
homepage)
Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett
Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
Quoted text (11 lines)
>"EldredP" <[email hidden]> wrote in message >news:[email hidden]... > >> Imagine if you had to break the 8:30 mark at the Ring >> in the Eagle in order to unlock the Ferrari and Lotus. Some of us STILL >> wouldn't be able to access those two cars. > >You don't have specific goals to achieve to unlock the cars, you just >accumulate points. The better your results the more points you get, but you >can get them in on-line races too, so as long as you finish 3rd or higher, >you'll get the points sooner or later.writes:
Hehe...guilty as charged...<g>
Eldred
--
Help find missing child: Tatianna Ashley Chillcutt from Michigan(info on my
homepage)
Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett
Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
[email hidden] (EldredP) wrote in
news:[email hidden]:
> Sure, not a big deal for you. I also watched you lap Silverstone 10
> seconds per lap faster than me. Imagine if you had to break the 8:30
> mark at the Ring in the Eagle in order to unlock the Ferrari and
> Lotus. Some of us STILL wouldn't be able to access those two cars.
No Eldred, it's not even close to being that hard! Really.. just try it
and you'll see. The AI is kind of a pushover. At least on the settings I
used - 'Quick', which I believe is one step below 'Pro'.
I do agree with you. I've never liked the "unlock" concept; a carry-over
from console games. I'm just saying that it's not so bad as it might seem.
In message <3f22847b$0$32518$[email hidden]>, Mikkel
Gram-Hansen <[email hidden]> writes
Why a 3 lapper, I went for a 1 lapper worked much quicker. Now I have
got into the 200 pts i'm more relaxed about hitting the 2 top cars.
Miles
--
Miles Osborne Items for Sale http://members.ebay.co.uk/aboutme/talsworthy/
Southampton http://www.spampal.org.uk/
UK ICQ: 1 23270583 MSN: Miles_Osborne at hotmail.com
Quoted text (15 lines)
>It takes 1 hour to get all the cars unlocked... and thats one hour of seat >time some kidz need VERY badly before they can select the LX6 in an online >race :) >You won't find the LX6 any fun before you have had a few hours in the other >cars anyway. >The developers actually wanted a lower credit level needed, while a lot of >the betatesters voted for a much highter threshold, in the end I think we >found a good compromise. > >Pick a 3 lap race at the shortest track, place in the top 3 to accumulate >credits and after a few repeats you will be able to select the RB4... after >that you will have no difficulty getting the rest of the points needed to >unlock the LX6. Please try it and I'm sure you will agree it was not any >problem at all ;) >"Miles Osborne" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:4dobUVByosI$[email hidden]...
> In message <3f22847b$0$32518$[email hidden]>, Mikkel
> Gram-Hansen <[email hidden]> writes
> >Pick a 3 lap race at the shortest track, place in the top 3 to accumulate
> >credits and after a few repeats you will be able to select the RB4...after
Winning a 3-lap pro race is the shortest race that gets you the 'full' 48
points. 1 or 2 lap races will get you the points very nearly as quickly, but
if you just want to get the points to unlock the cars (and who can blame you
;-)) there isn't any advantage to doing longer races.
I started out with some 10 lap races thinking I was getting 12 points per
lap for a win, but quickly realised that it wasn't the quickest way to get
the points, although it probably is the best way to learn the track /and/
earn points at the same time.
I think you get 1 point for winning a drag race too. I tried a couple to see
if it was an easier way to get points (it only takes a few seconds to do a
run) but it didn't seem like it, and 600 drag races would have been a pretty
boring way to get the points ;-)
Malc.
Quoted text (7 lines)
> >that you will have no difficulty getting the rest of the points needed to > >unlock the LX6. Please try it and I'm sure you will agree it was not any > >problem at all ;) > > > > Why a 3 lapper, I went for a 1 lapper worked much quicker. Now I have > got into the 200 pts i'm more relaxed about hitting the 2 top cars.In article <3f22847b$0$32518$[email hidden]>,
[email hidden] (Mikkel Gram-Hansen) wrote:
> It takes 1 hour to get all the cars unlocked... and thats one hour of
> seat time some kidz need VERY badly
That's a very good point actually. Mind you, it didn't help the kid I
met this morning who kept causing no end of trouble in a car he clearly
couldn't handle.
ME: "You might want to learn to drive that LX m8"
Muppet: "Can you drive the LX Andrew?"
ME: "Not well."
Muppet: "Then shut up!"
Well, that's me told then! I love a reasoned debate, it's why I enjoy
the flight-sim group so much :-)
To be fair though, what did I expect racing on a Saturday morning?
Hardly prime time for old gits like me.
Andrew McP


































