Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

Best F1 sim? <duck>

14 posts by 10 people · 29 Aug 2003 01:49 UTC - 31 Aug 2003 15:09 UTC

I've played GPL, F1GP,GP2,GP3 and EA F1 1999(first one). I wasn't impressed with GP3 and F1'99. Of course GPL is the best (or was when I played it) Aside from GPL, what's the best modern day F1 sim?
F1 Challenge 99-02 from Electronic Arts. Developed by ISI, the same guys who did Sports Car GT. Same guys who did the other EA F1 games too, but F1C is the last and by far the best of them. <etwqeggqjqd324234> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > I've played GPL, F1GP,GP2,GP3 and EA F1 1999(first one). I wasn't > impressed with GP3 and F1'99. > > Of course GPL is the best (or was when I played it) > > Aside from GPL, what's the best modern day F1 sim?
("[email hidden]" <etwqeggqjqd324234>) wrote... > I've played GPL, F1GP,GP2,GP3 and EA F1 1999(first one). I wasn't > impressed with GP3 and F1'99. > > Of course GPL is the best (or was when I played it) > > Aside from GPL, what's the best modern day F1 sim? GPL of course. You just need to set your system clock to 1967. ;-) Ian -- Ian Riches Bedford, UK
<etwqeggqjqd324234> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > I've played GPL, F1GP,GP2,GP3 and EA F1 1999(first one). I wasn't > impressed with GP3 and F1'99. > > Of course GPL is the best (or was when I played it) > > Aside from GPL, what's the best modern day F1 sim? Mestill likes F1C. :) J.R.
> Aside from GPL, what's the best modern day F1 sim? " F1 Challange '99-'02 " - Hands down. The multiplayer *still* isn't as good as GPL which is a bit frustrating but the good news is that it wallops GPL in every other department.
Damien Smith wrote: > " F1 Challange '99-'02 " - Hands down. The multiplayer *still* isn't as > good as GPL which is a bit frustrating but the good news is that it wallops > GPL in every other department. Except for the modelled era, replay and user interface departments, maybe ? ;) Seriously, F1C '99-'02 is very very good and quite addictive. And the question was about modern F1 anyway. Mr. Sylvestre (Nixon's voice : I am not a GPL zealot)
"Damien Smith" <[email hidden]> kirjoitti viestiss� news:bin5np$b312d$[email hidden]... > > Aside from GPL, what's the best modern day F1 sim? > > " F1 Challange '99-'02 " - Hands down. The multiplayer *still* isn't as > good as GPL which is a bit frustrating but the good news is that itwallops > GPL in every other department. For me the F1C was a disappointment. I guess I just can't find the fun in driving without sliding ;) The physics engine is most likely better than in GPL, but it's still no GPL. I think I'll wait for the F1C mods... - Igor -
> For me the F1C was a disappointment. I guess I just can't find the fun in > driving without sliding ;) The physics engine is most likely better thanin > GPL, but it's still no GPL. I think I'll wait for the F1C mods... I'm not sure how you can say F1C was a disappointment....What were you hoping for? - a quasi-F1 with sliding cars? If I want sliding, I'll race sprint cars. Tarmac racing is about being 'on the edge' of grip - at least for me - probably why GPL has never really floated my boat (even though I raced in a GPL league for 2 years!)
On Fri, 29 Aug 2003 19:17:42 +1000, "Damien Smith" <[email hidden]> wrote: >> Aside from GPL, what's the best modern day F1 sim? > >" F1 Challange '99-'02 " - Hands down. The multiplayer *still* isn't as >good as GPL which is a bit frustrating but the good news is that it wallops >GPL in every other department. I dunno, GPL still has a better tire model, or at least I should say, at least it's possible to overheat the tires (you can't really wear them out in either sim). F1C is a vast improvement over f1 2002, but considering the importance of tire selection, tire pressure, and camber in real life and the complete lack of importance they hold in the sim I really can't go overboard praising it anymore. If the tire model were fixed I'd give it another go for sure. I have to be wary about any sim where I can push 100% for an entire GP with full negative camber on one set of soft tires. Jason
Quoted text (9 lines)> I dunno, GPL still has a better tire model, or at least I should say, > at least it's possible to overheat the tires (you can't really wear > them out in either sim). F1C is a vast improvement over f1 2002, but > considering the importance of tire selection, tire pressure, and > camber in real life and the complete lack of importance they hold in > the sim I really can't go overboard praising it anymore. If the tire > model were fixed I'd give it another go for sure. I have to be wary > about any sim where I can push 100% for an entire GP with full > negative camber on one set of soft tires.
GPL doesn't even model tyre wear.
I should add that you're right though and the beta testers should have their asses kicked for allowing such an obvious blunder. Luckily it doesn't really affect gameplay - it just means that tyres don't wear out. GP1 modelled tyre wear better.
Damien Smith wrote: >>I dunno, GPL still has a better tire model, or at least I should say, >>at least it's possible to overheat the tires (you can't really wear > GPL doesn't even model tyre wear. Yep, but due to the overheating the effect is nearly the same - I noticed I definitely was having trouble keeping up the same cornering speeds after ten laps on the Glen, when I was trying to push it. It may be a bit primitive (heck, it doesn't even model rubber debris next to the racing line, sheesh ;) but at least it definitely does penalize pushing too hard for too long. Regards, Rudy (GPLRank -7.8)
> Yep, but due to the overheating the effect is nearly the same - I > noticed I definitely was having trouble keeping up the same cornering > speeds after ten laps on the Glen, when I was trying to push it. It may > be a bit primitive (heck, it doesn't even model rubber debris next to > the racing line, sheesh ;) but at least it definitely does penalize > pushing too hard for too long. That's true. I think GTR2002 probably has the king of tyre models at the moment.
IMHO F1C is probably the best Sim that I have used so far. It is different to GPL obviously, but as a modern day Sim, I feel it is the best so far. Tyres are a big issue. I find that cold tyres seem to have pretty much the same grip as warm ones, and they do not seem to wear out. The other problem that I have found is that tampering with the setup doesn't seem to have much effect on the cars handling or your lap times. You can pretty much jump in the standard car, adjust the high end gearing, and rip off a scorcher. I have never seen this happen on any other sim. Usually it takes ages of adjusting your setup before you get anywhere near scorching times. Other than that, it just needs more work on the online code ( steal Papy's Code ) and it would be a ripper. Darf "jason moyer" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]...
Quoted text (13 lines)> > > I dunno, GPL still has a better tire model, or at least I should say, > at least it's possible to overheat the tires (you can't really wear > them out in either sim). F1C is a vast improvement over f1 2002, but > considering the importance of tire selection, tire pressure, and > camber in real life and the complete lack of importance they hold in > the sim I really can't go overboard praising it anymore. If the tire > model were fixed I'd give it another go for sure. I have to be wary > about any sim where I can push 100% for an entire GP with full > negative camber on one set of soft tires. > > Jason

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy