Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

TCG - Proposal for Track Creation Guidelines (N2003)

12 posts by 9 people · 01 Sep 2003 16:26 UTC - 02 Sep 2003 21:29 UTC

Jan Kohl 01 Sep 2003 16:26 UTC#55389
Ok, I've spent all morning whipping this up, and I hope that it is at least a start for creating a set of standards for making tracks. Note that this is a *proposal*, and any input or other ideas are more than welcome. While I'm not going to go as far as Fran�ois, I do agree that the open reverse-ability that Sandbox allows for a virtual quagmire of poor and slightly modified tracks, all named the same thing. What most have failed to realized in the "other" discussion is that with the GPL tools, you couldn't grab someone else's track, open it up, modify the grip and a few graphics, and repost it. With Sandbox you can...thus someone could take Papy's texas, modify the grip to an unrealistic level, repost it without any documentation, and then cause mayhem. Drivers racing online cannot tell if a track is different, they only see a name and if their track is not the same they won't be able to race there. Pure confusion. Plus, most want to know what they're getting before (or at least when) they download. If everyone likes this and chooses this as a starting point, I welcome all further suggestions to make this better, and ask that everyone "spread the news". You can also help by informing authors..."Hey, you posted a track the same name as "texas", and I'm not downloading it unless you follow the TCG!" Well, at any rate, here's the proposal...complete with version number! :) http://www.theuspits.com/sims/nascar_racing/files/n2003_track_creation_v1.zip Included is a proposed naming convention, a template for the included "readme" file, as well as a simple instructions for filling out the readme. Cheers!
In article <drK4b.41203$[email hidden]>, [email hidden] says...
Quoted text (33 lines)> Ok, I've spent all morning whipping this up, and I hope that it is at > least a start for creating a set of standards for making tracks. Note > that this is a *proposal*, and any input or other ideas are more than > welcome. While I'm not going to go as far as Fran�ois, I do agree > that the open reverse-ability that Sandbox allows for a virtual > quagmire of poor and slightly modified tracks, all named the same > thing. > What most have failed to realized in the "other" discussion is that > with the GPL tools, you couldn't grab someone else's track, open it up, > modify the grip and a few graphics, and repost it. With Sandbox you > can...thus someone could take Papy's texas, modify the grip to an > unrealistic level, repost it without any documentation, and then cause > mayhem. Drivers racing online cannot tell if a track is different, > they only see a name and if their track is not the same they won't be > able to race there. Pure confusion. Plus, most want to know what > they're getting before (or at least when) they download. > > If everyone likes this and chooses this as a starting point, I welcome > all further suggestions to make this better, and ask that everyone > "spread the news". You can also help by informing authors..."Hey, you > posted a track the same name as "texas", and I'm not downloading it > unless you follow the TCG!" > > Well, at any rate, here's the proposal...complete with version number! > > :) > > http://www.theuspits.com/sims/nascar_racing/files/n2003_track_creation_v1.zip > > Included is a proposed naming convention, a template for the included > "readme" file, as well as a simple instructions for filling out the > readme.
This subject came up on the Sierra vboards too. Here's what I posted (massaged a bit after some more consideration): What we really need is a single group/ clearinghouse to which all 3rd-party tracks are submitted - kinda like an ANSI committee. This group would be responsible for evaluating each track for the following: 1) Completeness - racing line, track-side graphics, horizons, setups, and any other stuff that goes with a track. 2) Race-ability - we all know that ovals need at least two racing lines to be "fun", and that road courses must have sections of the track that allow/encourage passing, and test the whole car setup as well as the driver's ability, including the necessity to shift at up/down at the right spots. 3) Graphics - quality and appropriateness of the track-side graphics and horizons (and both hi-res and lo-res graphics should be supplied). 4) AI - the AI must be addressed for each track. There are still many people who don't race online and simply need decent AI to keep them interested in the sim. 5) Default setups - each track should come with at least the <easy>, <moderate>, and <fast> setups. These setups should provide the level of performance and durability that is indicative of their intended purpose. 6) Installation - if it doesn't install painlessly, it's a hassle. If it's a hassle, nobody will race on it. This "committee" would test, and evaluate the track with the help of volunteer testers, and would either pass or fail the track. If the track fails, it is not included in the list of tested/approved tracks. The track author can re-submit the track for approval when he feels that all of the cited issues are addressed. Once a track is "approved", it shouldbe made downloadable directly from the track committee web site (to prevent "small improvements" by the author to be made after the track was originally approved). The track would be assigned a unique ID that will be made part of the name of the track. This way, people can have 20 versions of Texas on their system, but they'd be able to identify them all by their unique id tag. If everyone downloaded from an approved list, the quality of every track should/would be generally higher, and everyone would be singing from the same hymnal as far as track files go..
On Mon, 01 Sep 2003 16:26:49 GMT, "Jan Kohl" <[email hidden]> wrote: <snip> Jan that sounds good. One thing I'm wondering, could any of you guys whip up a real track tutorial for things beyond the actual track file? Sandbox is nice, but it would be nicer if the guide it includes actually created a drivable track. Having a decent guide to the track.ini (and the bare minimums needed in the track.ini in order for a track to load) would be really cool, as I haven't been able to find one. Jason
In article <ylM4b.2433$[email hidden]>, [email hidden] says... > "John Simmons" wrote: > > > This "committee"... > > The all new John "Trotsky" Simmons... :) > I was just trying to appease the one-king-rules-them-all conspiracy theorists. :)
"John Simmons" said: > What we really need is a single group/ clearinghouse to which all > 3rd-party tracks are submitted - kinda like an ANSI committee. That will never work I think... Way too much work and too time consuming. I think this will go the same way as with GPL - although in a much wilder degree.. At first you'll see a hole shit load of really crappy stuff. Truly idiotic work and most probably a whole pile of variations of the Papy tracks.. Night, day, summer, winter, etc. etc. But in the end - it's the best ones that will prevail (sp?).... The "kids" will move on to something new and those of us who really love what we do will keep at it. I wish a board or commitee would work - but I don't think it will. Might aswell open that core.ini the day the patch arrive and set the track flag on at once :-/ -- eD_
>"Jan Kohl" <[email hidden]> wrote > While I'm not going to go as far as Fran�ois, I do agree that the > open reverse-ability that Sandbox allows for a virtual quagmire of poorand slightly > modified tracks, all named the same thing. Yeah well my point was perhaps "loud" and dramatic, but often it's a way to make a point :) I really fear the chaotic nature of this situation, people perhaps underestimate the Nascar community versus the structure and seriousness that the GPL community had. Why would I be against people creating masterpiece tracks like there is in GPL??? Unfortunate people... -- -- Fran�ois M�nard <ymenard> -- http://ymenard.cjb.net/ -- This announcement is brought to you by the Shimago-Dominguez Corporation - helping America into the New World...
>"Ed Solheim" <[email hidden]> wrote > That will never work I think... Way too much work and too time consuming. > I think this will go the same way as with GPL - although in a much wilder > degree.. At first you'll see a hole shit load of really crappy stuff.Truly > idiotic work and most probably a whole pile of variations of the Papy > tracks.. Night, day, summer, winter, etc. etc. But in the end - it's the > best ones that will prevail (sp?).... The "kids" will move on tosomething > new and those of us who really love what we do will keep at it. The kids/immature/stupid ratio unfortunately with NR2003 is 100:1 the one found in GPL. That's what many people who didn't get my point, well.. they don't get :) A website like Magnus' GPL track database would be a great thing, to create a good set of standard tracks, tracks that are "secure" as to the quality of it's creation. Once there's a good version of let's say, Watkins Glen with the boot, there's no need to download another one. -- -- Fran�ois M�nard <ymenard> -- http://ymenard.cjb.net/ -- This announcement is brought to you by the Shimago-Dominguez Corporation - helping America into the New World...
elrikk 02 Sep 2003 03:32 UTC↳ reply to ymenard#55348
"ymenard" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:PuT4b.2526$[email hidden]... > >"Ed Solheim" <[email hidden]> wrote > > That will never work I think... Way too much work and too timeconsuming. > > I think this will go the same way as with GPL - although in a muchwilder > > degree.. At first you'll see a hole shit load of really crappy stuff. > Truly > > idiotic work and most probably a whole pile of variations of the Papy > > tracks.. Night, day, summer, winter, etc. etc. But in the end - it'sthe
Quoted text (8 lines)> > best ones that will prevail (sp?).... The "kids" will move on to > something > > new and those of us who really love what we do will keep at it. > > > > The kids/immature/stupid ratio unfortunately with NR2003 is 100:1 the one > found in GPL. That's what many people who didn't get my point, well..
they > don't get :) But it's that one is what makes it all worthwhile. ;o) > A website like Magnus' GPL track database would be a great thing, tocreate > a good set of standard tracks, tracks that are "secure" as to the qualityof > it's creation. Once there's a good version of let's say, Watkins Glenwith > the boot, there's no need to download another one. > Right . . . and now that Henry Ford has created the Model T there is no need to create any more cars; after all what could possibly be improved on this "good version" ? > > -- > -- Fran�ois M�nard <ymenard> Sorry but I couldn't resist. Will try to be stronger next time. ;o) Elrikk
Since when have you ever had a "point"? =) -- Scott B. Husted � http://www.Husted.cc "ymenard" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:KrT4b.2514$[email hidden]... > Yeah well my point was perhaps "loud" and dramatic, but often it's a way to > make a point :)
>"Scott B. Husted" <[email hidden]> wrote > Since when have you ever had a "point"? =) ...since you stopped being in the "comma" ;) -- -- Fran�ois M�nard <ymenard> -- http://ymenard.cjb.net/ -- This announcement is brought to you by the Shimago-Dominguez Corporation - helping America into the New World... (I know, different grammar, but hey it's a pun)
John Simmons <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:<[email hidden]>...
Quoted text (9 lines)> > What we really need is a single group/ clearinghouse to which all > 3rd-party tracks are submitted - kinda like an ANSI committee. > > This group would be responsible for evaluating each track for the > following: > > 1) Completeness - racing line, track-side graphics, horizons, setups, > and any other stuff that goes with a track.
Absolutely imperative that any site devoted to hosting track downloads catalog their files in this manner. I would prefer some kind of searchable, sortable database for this kind of stuff. The track author could go a long way towards making this useful by completing a catalog entry when they submit the file. > 2) Race-ability - we all know that ovals need at least two racing > lines to be "fun", and that road courses must have sections of the > track that allow/encourage passing, and test the whole car setup as > well as the driver's ability, including the necessity to shift at > up/down at the right spots. I don't see a need for a committee to spend a lot of time assessing this before a track becomes available. Good tracks will spread by word of mouth just fine. Perhaps some kind of community popularity rankings might be in order? > 3) Graphics - quality and appropriateness of the track-side graphics > and horizons (and both hi-res and lo-res graphics should be > supplied). Again, I think we can all make up our own minds... and word will get around about the good stuff. Personally, if a track has awesome racing, the graphics become less important. > 4) AI - the AI must be addressed for each track. There are still many > people who don't race online and simply need decent AI to keep them > interested in the sim. The availability of AI should be part of the cataloging in #1. > 5) Default setups - each track should come with at least the <easy>, > <moderate>, and <fast> setups. These setups should provide the level > of performance and durability that is indicative of their intended > purpose. Again, this should be basic cataloging info. > 6) Installation - if it doesn't install painlessly, it's a hassle. If > it's a hassle, nobody will race on it. Agreed. Somebody needs to come up with a set of best practices for distribution + install.
Quoted text (13 lines)> This "committee" would test, and evaluate the track with the help of > volunteer testers, and would either pass or fail the track. If the > track fails, it is not included in the list of tested/approved > tracks. The track author can re-submit the track for approval when he > feels that all of the cited issues are addressed. > > Once a track is "approved", it shouldbe made downloadable directly > from the track committee web site (to prevent "small improvements" by > the author to be made after the track was originally approved). The > track would be assigned a unique ID that will be made part of the > name of the track. This way, people can have 20 versions of Texas on > their system, but they'd be able to identify them all by their unique > id tag.
I don't necessarily agree with the committee approval part, but yes, any hosting site must make it a big priority that the tracks have unique names. And of course, as the communinity it is our job to make sure that we load only these well-documented tracks on our servers. I wish there was a way to include a comments area in the Sierra connection screens where you could list something like "download our tracks from this url" > If everyone downloaded from an approved list, the quality of every > track should/would be generally higher, and everyone would be singing > from the same hymnal as far as track files go.. Again, I think we can sift out the bad stuff as a community effort, especially if track download sites and authors subscribe to some kind of cataloging scheme. Imagine a track, basically complete with good racing lines is made, but for whatever reason, the author has to move on before he can make the AI or do much in the graphics department, etc. If that track is never made available it will never have the opportunity to be finished by someone else. Agree 100% with the need to keep the names unique to ensure cataloging is not a waste of time.

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy