Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

MS X-box will KILL Computer games

26 posts by 17 people · 10 Mar 2000 - 14 Mar 2000 21:56 UTC

Debate over whether Microsoft's X-Box will kill PC gaming

A poster predicted that Microsoft's X-Box would freeze PC games development if it succeeded. Most replies disagreed, saying PCs offered upgradeability, better displays, and suitability for racing and flight sims and other uses. Participants also traded specification details for the announced console.

industry/businesshardware: PC/graphicsoff-topic

Automated summary.

Kai Fuller 10 Mar 2000#522340
If it isn't forever upgradeable then it won't replace computers, id it is, then it's just a computer with a fancy name... ZERO titles, I can't see *** turn based ware games playing on it? They're all turning back to small developers distributing over the net.
Quoted text (25 lines)> > If the Xbox suceeds. I predict there will be ZERO development of new > >computer technologies aimed at ***. I predict ZERO new products by > >the end of 2002. I predict "if" the Xbox is a sucess, computer *** > >as we know it will vanish. > > The reason is money, every developer and thier publishers will be able > >to code for the Box and not have to spend big bucks designing, coding, > >testing, for all the different hardware and software combo's out there. > > If the Xbox produces, we will all become console buyers or face a > >future of no ***.(of course, we will always have gpl) > >dave henrie > Anyone have specs on this X-Box? I cannot comment on the above until i > know more :) > Computer *** will never vanish tho. I cant see my TSW2 hooking up > to a console. :) > ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ > Skotty Flynn > skotty20 on Won > Nascar-Racing-Sims.Com: > http://www.nascar-racing-sims.com > The Ultimate Sim Racing Directory: > http://www.nascar-racing-sims.com/directory/
Mitch_A 10 Mar 2000#522341
I disagree. All the Xbox does is narrow the focus of a standard PC. It is still a PC though! The specs I saw mentioned a P3/600, Geforce video, 64MB ram, 8GB HD. Windows2k, DX8. Internet access, game port blah blah blah. This will likely change by fall 2001. If anything this will get more developers coding PC games due to a larger market share of PC's (including XBox) than the proprietary consoles. Yes this will eliminate the myriad of API choices available currently. GPL is a perfect example of this, written for Glide and had to be ported to OpenGL for any non 3DFX cards. Remember the Rendition cards? Same situation. In fact Im still waitin for the SODA Glide patch :-) Less time the devs have spend to make different ports of the same s/w the more time they can spend on the graphics/physics/AI etc. This shouldnt make less hardware available to PC's it should make hardware mfg's more conscience of compatability while still improving performance. Just my 2cents Mitch
Dave Henrie 11 Mar 2000#522600
If the Xbox suceeds. I predict there will be ZERO development of new computer technologies aimed at ***. I predict ZERO new products by the end of 2002. I predict "if" the Xbox is a sucess, computer *** as we know it will vanish. The reason is money, every developer and thier publishers will be able to code for the Box and not have to spend big bucks designing, coding, testing, for all the different hardware and software combo's out there. If the Xbox produces, we will all become console buyers or face a future of no ***.(of course, we will always have gpl) dave henrie
Quoted text (10 lines)> If the Xbox suceeds. I predict there will be ZERO development of new >computer technologies aimed at ***. I predict ZERO new products by >the end of 2002. I predict "if" the Xbox is a sucess, computer *** >as we know it will vanish. > The reason is money, every developer and thier publishers will be able >to code for the Box and not have to spend big bucks designing, coding, >testing, for all the different hardware and software combo's out there. > If the Xbox produces, we will all become console buyers or face a >future of no ***.(of course, we will always have gpl) >dave henrie
Anyone have specs on this X-Box? I cannot comment on the above until i know more :) Computer *** will never vanish tho. I cant see my TSW2 hooking up to a console. :) ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Skotty Flynn skotty20 on Won Nascar-Racing-Sims.Com: http://www.nascar-racing-sims.com The Ultimate Sim Racing Directory: http://www.nascar-racing-sims.com/directory/
Mitch_A 11 Mar 2000#522602
Coupla corrections The graphics processor is the NVidia NV25 not the Geforce. Also just to be clear, it wont use Win2K as the OS but the Win2k Kernel and DX libraries. They had better not strip it to much though as then compatability with true PC games will become the issue. It will also have DVD and 10/100 Ethernet. Mitch > I disagree. > All the Xbox does is narrow the focus of a standard PC. It is still a PC > though! The specs I saw mentioned a P3/600, Geforce video, 64MB ram, 8GB > HD. Windows2k, DX8. Internet access, game port blah blah blah. This will > likely change by fall 2001. If anything this will get more developers > coding PC games due to a larger market share of PC's (including XBox) than > the proprietary consoles. Yes this will eliminate the myriad of API choices > available currently. GPL is a perfect example of this, written for Glide > and had to be ported to OpenGL for any non 3DFX cards. Remember the > Rendition cards? Same situation. In fact Im still waitin for the SODA > Glide patch :-) > Less time the devs have spend to make different ports of the same s/w the > more time they can spend on the graphics/physics/AI etc. This shouldnt make
Quoted text (20 lines)> less hardware available to PC's it should make hardware mfg's more > conscience of compatability while still improving performance. > Just my 2cents > Mitch > > If the Xbox suceeds. I predict there will be ZERO development of new > > computer technologies aimed at ***. I predict ZERO new products by > > the end of 2002. I predict "if" the Xbox is a sucess, computer *** > > as we know it will vanish. > > The reason is money, every developer and thier publishers will be able > > to code for the Box and not have to spend big bucks designing, coding, > > testing, for all the different hardware and software combo's out there. > > If the Xbox produces, we will all become console buyers or face a > > future of no ***.(of course, we will always have gpl) > > dave henrie
Another thing I have noticed too with the current console's is that even though the graphics have come a long way, you just cant get a TV to look as crisp as a computer monitor. Even though the console specs get better and better, will they ever really be able to develop a racing game with decent physics in the near future? All the current racing games for console's blow. :) I do find that the sports games run better on console's such as football and hockey games tho. "The first release for X-Box is from the famed Pokemon series!" LOL On Sat, 11 Mar 2000 01:19:00 -0800, "Mitch Alatorre"
Quoted text (49 lines)>Coupla corrections >The graphics processor is the NVidia NV25 not the Geforce. Also just to be >clear, it wont use Win2K as the OS but the Win2k Kernel and DX libraries. >They had better not strip it to much though as then compatability with true >PC games will become the issue. It will also have DVD and 10/100 Ethernet. >Mitch >> I disagree. >> All the Xbox does is narrow the focus of a standard PC. It is still a PC >> though! The specs I saw mentioned a P3/600, Geforce video, 64MB ram, 8GB >> HD. Windows2k, DX8. Internet access, game port blah blah blah. This >will >> likely change by fall 2001. If anything this will get more developers >> coding PC games due to a larger market share of PC's (including XBox) than >> the proprietary consoles. Yes this will eliminate the myriad of API >choices >> available currently. GPL is a perfect example of this, written for Glide >> and had to be ported to OpenGL for any non 3DFX cards. Remember the >> Rendition cards? Same situation. In fact Im still waitin for the SODA >> Glide patch :-) >> Less time the devs have spend to make different ports of the same s/w the >> more time they can spend on the graphics/physics/AI etc. This shouldnt >make >> less hardware available to PC's it should make hardware mfg's more >> conscience of compatability while still improving performance. >> Just my 2cents >> Mitch >> > If the Xbox suceeds. I predict there will be ZERO development of new >> > computer technologies aimed at ***. I predict ZERO new products by >> > the end of 2002. I predict "if" the Xbox is a sucess, computer *** >> > as we know it will vanish. >> > The reason is money, every developer and thier publishers will be able >> > to code for the Box and not have to spend big bucks designing, coding, >> > testing, for all the different hardware and software combo's out there. >> > If the Xbox produces, we will all become console buyers or face a >> > future of no ***.(of course, we will always have gpl) >> > dave henrie
I predict that you are blowing this way out of proportion and computer *** the way we have it today is a result of what Microsoft has done. I am eternally graeful to Microsoft and I can assure you we take what Windows can do for granted. Don't blame Microsoft, blame game producers for making Microsoft a monopoly. Hey, they could port the games to other os's like Linux but do they? Be glad for what you got, could be a lot worse Phillip
Utter rubbish, I'm afraid. Can you do word-processing, spreadsheets, *proper* Internet (ie with newsgroups, ftp, IRC etc), Ultima Online- type games, CAD, video editing, easy h/w upgrades or on an X-Box? I think not. So there will always be a huge number of PCs around. Any game publisher that ignores a market of that size is a fool. -- David. "The lawyers are destroying inspiration." (Michael Turner, motorsport artist)
> If the Xbox suceeds. I predict there will be ZERO development of new >computer technologies aimed at ***. I disagree. Why should I buy a separate *** system when I can play games on a computer just as well if not better. This is just typical anything-you-can-do-I-can-do-better Bill Gates stuff.
Cliff Roman 11 Mar 2000#522608
I do not agree with this statement of yours. This is just Bill Gates trying to once again revolutionlize the way something is done. There is NOTHING wrong with that. I am by far a MS supporter, but if it was not for Bill Gates trying to revolutionize the way we do things on a computer, we would not be nearly where we are today. Bill Gates has some awesome ideas for the future with technology. Have you ever listened to what he really had to say? Let him try this, who knows, it may turn out to be the greatest thing that ever happened to ***. If not, then no one will support and it and no one is worse off than we are now. We have nothing to lose, we can only gain from this effort. (same thing goes when any company tries a new idea/technology.. we can only gain from the effort) > games on a computer just as well if not better. This is just typical > anything-you-can-do-I-can-do-better Bill Gates stuff.
Victor Chan 11 Mar 2000#522609
Nah. PC hardware will advance further and games will become more break-through. For the X-Box, console users, for the first time, will get the same PC performance and quality as of today, in Fall 2001. Besides, who knows if it will be ready by then. Remember that it is still a console. The screen resolution is restricted to 600x400 where as on a PC monitor the resolution can go as high as the monitor and video card can support. Of course, if the X-Box can support PC monitor, that would be something good for a change.
Victor Chan 11 Mar 2000#522610
The only way I know why anyone would make such a claim about the X-Box replacing computer is either this person only plays games on his PC or his PC is so under-powered than the X-Box. <G>
Quoted text (14 lines)> > If the Xbox suceeds. I predict there will be ZERO development of > > new computer technologies aimed at ***. I predict ZERO new > > products by the end of 2002. > Utter rubbish, I'm afraid. Can you do word-processing, spreadsheets, > *proper* Internet (ie with newsgroups, ftp, IRC etc), Ultima Online- > type games, CAD, video editing, easy h/w upgrades or on an X-Box? I > think not. So there will always be a huge number of PCs around. Any > game publisher that ignores a market of that size is a fool. > -- > David. > "The lawyers are destroying inspiration." > (Michael Turner, motorsport artist)
Kai Fuller 11 Mar 2000#522611
HDTV I'm sure the next Gen consoles will be HDTV compatible, that will be the next Gen console... right now the new stuff coming out just seems like a better playstatiom, not like the jump to 3D from the Genesis.
Quoted text (16 lines)> Another thing I have noticed too with the current console's is that > even though the graphics have come a long way, you just cant get a TV > to look as crisp as a computer monitor. > Even though the console specs get better and better, will they ever > really be able to develop a racing game with decent physics in the > near future? All the current racing games for console's blow. :) > I do find that the sports games run better on console's such as > football and hockey games tho. > "The first release for X-Box is from the famed Pokemon series!" LOL > On Sat, 11 Mar 2000 01:19:00 -0800, "Mitch Alatorre" > >Coupla corrections > >The graphics processor is the NVidia NV25 not the Geforce. Also just to
be > >clear, it wont use Win2K as the OS but the Win2k Kernel and DX libraries. > >They had better not strip it to much though as then compatability with true > >PC games will become the issue. It will also have DVD and 10/100 Ethernet.
Quoted text (8 lines)> >Mitch > >> I disagree. > >> All the Xbox does is narrow the focus of a standard PC. It is still a
PC > >> though! The specs I saw mentioned a P3/600, Geforce video, 64MB ram, 8GB > >> HD. Windows2k, DX8. Internet access, game port blah blah blah. This > >will > >> likely change by fall 2001. If anything this will get more developers > >> coding PC games due to a larger market share of PC's (including XBox) than > >> the proprietary consoles. Yes this will eliminate the myriad of API > >choices > >> available currently. GPL is a perfect example of this, written for Glide > >> and had to be ported to OpenGL for any non 3DFX cards. Remember the > >> Rendition cards? Same situation. In fact Im still waitin for the SODA > >> Glide patch :-) > >> Less time the devs have spend to make different ports of the same s/w the
Quoted text (13 lines)> >> more time they can spend on the graphics/physics/AI etc. This shouldnt > >make > >> less hardware available to PC's it should make hardware mfg's more > >> conscience of compatability while still improving performance. > >> Just my 2cents > >> Mitch > >> > If the Xbox suceeds. I predict there will be ZERO development of
new > >> > computer technologies aimed at ***. I predict ZERO new products by > >> > the end of 2002. I predict "if" the Xbox is a sucess, computer *** > >> > as we know it will vanish. > >> > The reason is money, every developer and thier publishers will be able > >> > to code for the Box and not have to spend big bucks designing, coding, > >> > testing, for all the different hardware and software combo's out there. > >> > If the Xbox produces, we will all become console buyers or face a > >> > future of no ***.(of course, we will always have gpl) > >> > dave henrie
> If the Xbox suceeds. I predict there will be ZERO development of new >computer technologies aimed at ***. I predict ZERO new products by >the end of 2002. I predict "if" the Xbox is a sucess, computer *** >as we know it will vanish. According to similarly alarmist posts in other newsgroups, the Playstation 2 will kill computer games. By the time the X-Box comes out, there should therefore be nothing left to kill. Right? Would you like to make a wager on that "ZERO new products" prediction? Martin Long Live Nigel Mansell!
On the following date: Sun, 12 Mar 2000 09:14:38 -0700, said person(s) "Kirk Lane" <[email hidden]> stated: >Well, let's see the specs...from what I know, the Xbox is going to be, when >it finally comes out, a below-entry-level computer (given that a Ghz chip >will prolly be entry level by then) for playing games. What planet are you on? I'm running ALL of today's games on a Celeron P2 466. So your telling me in less than year that 1000 is going be standard? Bull hockey. That's what Marketing wants you to believe. Hell I ran most games on a P133 when most people were claiming a P2 200MX was the "standard" Maybe for you folks that make over $100,000 a year you can afford to raise the "standard" but don't try to make everyone else think they have to throw out a fortune. I'm sure MS has studied the competition and knows what they need to make it work. I have yet to see a MS product that didn't make gobs of money.
Dave Henrie wrote:
Quoted text (11 lines)> > Ok let me rephrase that slightly....ZERO new products that don't match > exactly the Xbox specs. The thing the Xbox "could" do is FREEZE > development. Developers will love that. Hardware producers will hate > it. All inovation 'could' stop. but remember, all this hinges on > whether the Xbox is a sucess or not. My statement was prefaced by > a disclaimer. "IF" the Xbox is a sucess, the pc as a gaming platform > will die and we will be forced to type or scan or worse yet crunch > numbers on them. > dave henrie > prediction?
I still don't agree. Most people use a PC as a "work"station, while also playing on them. Dedicated gamers COULD switch to the XBox, but most of them would miss the flexibility and configurability of a generic PC, so they won't buy a closed system (they esp. don't have a lot of problems with getting a PC configured). -- l8er ronny Your mouse has moved. Windows must be restarted for the change to take effect. Reboot now? |\ _,,,---,,_ I want to die like my Grandfather, ZZZzz /,`.-'`' -. ;-;;,_ in his sleep. |,4- ) )-,_. ,\ ( `'-' Not like the people in his car, '---''(_/--' `-'\_) screaming their heads off!
Dave Henrie 12 Mar 2000 02:49 UTC#287611
No I don't think so. "IF" your system matches up with the Xbox then you will be fine, but if your vid card, soundcard, memory, bios, motherboard...if ANY of those(or more!) are not 100% Xbox compatible, you will be on the outside looking in. dave henrie "Morgan VW�" wrote:
Quoted text (9 lines)> > HA! That's like Rick the Y2K nut last December! Ridiculous. > > -- > ----------------------------------- > Morgan Vincent Wooten > mailto:[email hidden] > http://members.tripod.com/~morganv/ >
Dave Henrie 12 Mar 2000 02:56 UTC#287612
Ok let me rephrase that slightly....ZERO new products that don't match exactly the Xbox specs. The thing the Xbox "could" do is FREEZE development. Developers will love that. Hardware producers will hate it. All inovation 'could' stop. but remember, all this hinges on whether the Xbox is a sucess or not. My statement was prefaced by a disclaimer. "IF" the Xbox is a sucess, the pc as a gaming platform will die and we will be forced to type or scan or worse yet crunch numbers on them. dave henrie prediction? > > Martin > Long Live Nigel Mansell! ps, why do Brits like the Number 5? Nige was known as Red5 and Richards Burns the fast Subaru Rally driver also uses the #5. Further proof comes from Monty Python...."one, two, FIVE!" Need I say more? deh
Kirk Lane 12 Mar 2000 16:10 UTC#287448
> > If the Xbox suceeds. I predict there will be ZERO development of new > > computer technologies aimed at gaming. I predict ZERO new products by > > the end of 2002. I predict "if" the Xbox is a sucess, computer gaming > > as we know it will vanish. Well, let's see the specs...from what I know, the Xbox is going to be, when it finally comes out, a below-entry-level computer (given that a Ghz chip will prolly be entry level by then) for playing games. Weak ones. Besides, there are some games that are just so much better suited to a computer - racing, flying, Command & Conquer type games, anything where you need to use more than 4 buttons at a time... Not to mention a TV isn't hi-res enough... You can try to throw the Xbox at me all you want but you'll have to pry my COMPUTER out of my cold dead hands!!! -- Kirk Lane [email hidden] [email hidden] ICQ: 28171652 BRT #187 "Yeah you won't find me I'm going MIA Tonight I'm leaving Going MIA Getting lost in you again Is better than being known" -Foo Fighters, "MIA" > >
Dave Henrie 12 Mar 2000 16:33 UTC#287457
Quoted text (10 lines)> > I still don't agree. Most people use a PC as a "work"station, while also > playing on them. Dedicated gamers COULD switch to the XBox, but most of > them would miss the flexibility and configurability of a generic PC, so > they won't buy a closed system (they esp. don't have a lot of problems > with getting a PC configured). > > -- > l8er > ronny
I'm not saying you or I will stop using a computer. What I'm saying is the money-grubbing-suits in most publishing firms won't release development funds for testing and rewriting code to match the hundreds of possible computer setups. If you have an A3d card but the Xbox uses only D3d, then eventually the programs will not include A3d support. If you have a 3dfx Vid card, but the Xbox only supports D3d, then eventually there will be no native ports.(think about all the trouble users of Matrox, Nvidia, and 3dfx have in running generic D3d code. Each program has to be rewritten several times to adapt to the different implementations of the same API. Factor in that the Sega Dreamcast is already running winCE, and you may find increasing pressure from the money-end of the programming effort, to limit the compatiblity to only that which matches the Xbox. (but now my standard disclaimer. The Xbox could be a total and complete flop, in which case we will all need to make sure our computers can speak Playstation 2.) Remember 3d0 and Trip Hawkins? His idea was to create a video standard, like Creative's soundblaster standard, that would eliminate the need to spends buckets and bushels of cash trying to get code to work with dozens of different vid-cards. That is the same kind of pressure the Xbox "could" exert except the entire subsystem would then be locked in, not just the video. Don't have an Intel motherboard? Using Via bios chips? I'd be worried. dave henrie
BH 12 Mar 2000 18:30 UTC#287488
X-Box will have a keyboard and mouse available and be able to use a monitor. Just for the record. BH Kirk Lane <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:8agfh8$esd$[email hidden]... > > > > If the Xbox suceeds. I predict there will be ZERO development ofnew > > > computer technologies aimed at gaming. I predict ZERO new products by > > > the end of 2002. I predict "if" the Xbox is a sucess, computer gaming > > > as we know it will vanish. > > Well, let's see the specs...from what I know, the Xbox is going to be,when > it finally comes out, a below-entry-level computer (given that a Ghz chip > will prolly be entry level by then) for playing games. Weak ones.Besides, > there are some games that are just so much better suited to a computer - > racing, flying, Command & Conquer type games, anything where you need touse > more than 4 buttons at a time... Not to mention a TV isn't hi-resenough...
Quoted text (23 lines)> > You can try to throw the Xbox at me all you want but you'll have to pry my > COMPUTER out of my cold dead hands!!! > > -- > Kirk Lane > [email hidden] > [email hidden] > ICQ: 28171652 > BRT #187 > > "Yeah you won't find me > I'm going MIA > Tonight I'm leaving > Going MIA > Getting lost in you again > Is better than being known" > -Foo Fighters, "MIA" > > > > > > >
Dave Henrie 13 Mar 2000#522878
>(snippers!) > I'm sure MS has studied the competition > and knows what they need to make it work. I have yet to see a MS > product that didn't make gobs of money. Hmmmm Microsoft BOB comes to mind....;) dave henrie
Joe McGinn 13 Mar 2000#522879
On Sat, 11 Mar 2000 09:29:16 GMT, Skotty Flynn >Even though the console specs get better and better, will they ever >really be able to develop a racing game with decent physics in the >near future? It's too soon to say. The DC/PS2 are the first consoles with enough processing power to make it feasible.
Kirk Lane 14 Mar 2000 21:56 UTC#287286
I did say that it will be below entry level... Why? Guess what...both Intel and AMD have GHz chips out...Xbox is what, a year away? How long does it take for the average chip to filter down from top-end to entry level? Given that chip speeds more or less double every year (look at the numbers...it's a fact), and an entry level system is in the 450-550 MHz range (about half of a top-end)...in one year, GHz chips will be entry level. I never said that the Xbox is going to be slow...but I have (begin Y2J ripoff :) NEVER, EEEEEEEVER (end Y2J :) seen a console that could beat a computer, especially of late. PSX: Hideous lookin!!! N64: Not much better!! Dreamcast: Still not as good as my Celeron 300a @ 450 with a G200 and a V2, but (graphically) better than my PII350 @ 466 with a Rendition. Screenshots from PS2: I REALLY, REALLY hope that Gran Turismo looks a LOT better than that before it gets here...it looks worse than Dreamcast when it should have an extra year's worth of horsepower behind it!!! Neither Dreamcast or PS2 can come close to what my Celeron 450a with a V2 or G200 can do!! Haven't seen any Xbox screenshots yet, but I doubt it will be much better. Besides, Dreamcast has a few problems - nasty habit of frying to death if it isn't ventilated enough, cuts your fingers in the cd tray, controllers fall apart... By the way, before I got these computers a year ago, guess what I had? A PENTIUM 90! So don't go whining how you ran your stuff on a P133 until you've really experienced how slow even Windows goes with 8MB of RAM!!! Xbox is going to be fast...but PCs will just be faster. -- Kirk Lane [email hidden] [email hidden] ICQ: 28171652 BRT #187 "Yeah you won't find me I'm going MIA Tonight I'm leaving Going MIA Getting lost in you again Is better than being known" -Foo Fighters, "MIA"

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy