Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

More GPL purist ramblings

21 posts by 15 people · 21 Jan 2000 - 27 Jan 2000

Follow-up debate on speedometers and feel in GPL

Jcharm clarified that he wanted tools such as a speedometer to compensate for what a PC cannot convey. Most replies insisted GPL is driven by feel, sound and revs rather than numbers, while Obiwan and EldredP defended the request as a way to add immersion for people with limited feedback.

physics/realism debateGrand Prix Legends

Automated summary.

Jcharm 21 Jan 2000#515468
People seem to be missing the point of my original post. There is nothing real about driving a computer in your living room, but there are tools you can use to better compensate for this fact like force feedback wheels and speedometers. But consider this - if GPL had an average crappy physics system would we all be playing it? Would we all know the nuances of the 1967 season and be complaining about inaccuracies? What if Papyrus had chosen to do a Cart sim with that amazing physics engine? We'd all be CART-heads. Let's be thankful they didn't, but really, whatever sim gives me the best racing experience I'll be playing. It's not about historical inaccuracies it's about the racing. Thanks JH
David Karr 21 Jan 2000#515469
Indeed, that is well put, and well-taken. --DK
Quoted text (7 lines)> What is the point of this examination into the pros, cons, rights, wrongs, > goods, bads etcetera ad infinitum of the game anyway? Why the big attempt > at navel-gazing and pondering whether it should be this, could be that or > may be something else alltogether? > The whole aspect of like or dislike, good or bad, game or simulation, is > subjective anyway and what appeals to one may be completely out-of-whack
to > another. > Surely it is blatantly obvious that we are not all going to be satisfied > 100% of the time simply because we are individuals. We simply need to stop > trying to be missionary-like in forcing personal messages of dissatisfaction > down other's throats and respect the fact that our likes and dislikes may be
Quoted text (12 lines)> vastly different. > -- > Regards, > Bruce Kennewell, > Canberra, Australia. > --------------------------- > > People seem to be missing the point of my original post. There is
nothing > > real about driving a computer in your living room, but there are tools you > > can use to better compensate for this fact like force feedback wheels and
Quoted text (17 lines)> > speedometers. > > But consider this - if GPL had an average crappy physics system would we > all > > be playing it? Would we all know the nuances of the 1967 season and be > > complaining about inaccuracies? What if Papyrus had chosen to do a Cart > sim > > with that amazing physics engine? We'd all be CART-heads. Let's be > > thankful they didn't, but really, whatever sim gives me the best racing > > experience I'll be playing. It's not about historical inaccuracies it's > > about the racing. > > Thanks > > JH > -----------== Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News
==---------- > http://www.newsfeeds.com The Largest Usenet Servers in the World! > ------== Over 73,000 Newsgroups - Including Dedicated Binaries Servers ==-----
ymenard 22 Jan 2000#515683
No, look at Spirit of speed 1937. Yes, since a car is a car is a car. Many of us know how a vintage car races from experience. Some even raced some of those cars (far or close to their actual 67 specs). Vintage racing touch a sensible chord to many of us. It brings back memories. It's important to a human being you know ? Plus, the tracks were different in those days. The racing was different in those days. The danger was really there. Would you really hop in one of those cars and go full throttle at the Masta Kink at Spa ? I would not, Im not that crazy. I would fear too much. That is something that is praised alot in GPL. Of course, we would all be. Why ? We are all awaiting for it. 8 out of 9 titles Papyrus has been/will be released are Nascar simulators. They will someday -do- a non stockcar title no ? Let's hope it will be a CART one. Actually, I would not mind anything else than stockcar. It's getting old. The thing is.. the vintage Formula 1 of the year 1967 give us incredible racing experiences. That's why it is that praised. It was probably the best year for Papyrus to do, in terms of R&D for the new game engine, and also to please the *** simracer. Who's average age is much higher than many people think. The average *** simracer was probably living when those cars hit the tracks. Give us anything with the GPL game engine and we will praise it. Everything else will be compared to it. It is -years- ahead of anything else. For some reason, Papyrus decided to not push it into any of their new software yet. It looks like the next Nascar stockcar title will have it, but who actually knows. We will know more during the Daytona weekend I guess. Probably some press release by Sierra Sports about their 2000 line of product. -- -- Fran?ois Mnard <ymenard> -- May the Downforce be with you... "People think it must be fun to be a super genius, but they don't realise how hard it is to put up with all the idiots in the world."
For me It's the period and quality that's counting for the sim. I'm a bit sick of all those F1 sims (maybe except GP3) All looking a bit too much the same. Give me more Legends stuff (F1, F2, F3, Nascar, Indy, 1937 but with GPL quality, Le Mans, etc. Those where the days when driving was real driving instead of doing figures)
Quoted text (16 lines)> People seem to be missing the point of my original post. There is nothing > real about driving a computer in your living room, but there are tools you > can use to better compensate for this fact like force feedback wheels and > speedometers. > But consider this - if GPL had an average crappy physics system would we all > be playing it? Would we all know the nuances of the 1967 season and be > complaining about inaccuracies? What if Papyrus had chosen to do a Cart sim > with that amazing physics engine? We'd all be CART-heads. Let's be > thankful they didn't, but really, whatever sim gives me the best racing > experience I'll be playing. It's not about historical inaccuracies it's > about the racing. > Thanks > JH
Jalo 22 Jan 2000#515685
If you need a speedometer to race GPL, your going about it all wrong, it's not about numbers, it's about feeling. Being able to tell if your going to fast into a corner, with just the feel of the car. Besides, why would you want to look away from the road when you need to look at it the most?
What is the point of this examination into the pros, cons, rights, wrongs, goods, bads etcetera ad infinitum of the game anyway? Why the big attempt at navel-gazing and pondering whether it should be this, could be that or may be something else alltogether? The whole aspect of like or dislike, good or bad, game or simulation, is subjective anyway and what appeals to one may be completely out-of-whack to another. Surely it is blatantly obvious that we are not all going to be satisfied 100% of the time simply because we are individuals. We simply need to stop trying to be missionary-like in forcing personal messages of dissatisfaction down other's throats and respect the fact that our likes and dislikes may be vastly different. -- Regards, Bruce Kennewell, Canberra, Australia. --------------------------- -----------== Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News ==---------- http://www.newsfeeds.com The Largest Usenet Servers in the World! ------== Over 73,000 Newsgroups - Including Dedicated Binaries Servers ==-----
True, Jalo. For me, when racing, I only check the tacho for gear ratios, to ensure that I am optimizing the power/torque of the engine, or not over-revving. Maybe max speeds at straights. But it's all a business of hearing. After a few laps in a car, you know about where you are RPM-wise. And unless you're saving fuel or the car, you just go as fast as you can, and look at the pitboard. "Speed isn't the issue" :-) (ref here is not racing on the PC, but in a racecar) Best Matt
Aubrey 22 Jan 2000#515688
Ummm, that's what this newgroup is for. Or did I accidentally wander into alt.parenting.***feeding again? We discuss racing sims, and occasionally, their pros & cons. Wow, imagine that. Call it navel gazing if you wish, but you don't have to read it if you don't like it, bigshot.
Quoted text (12 lines)>What is the point of this examination into the pros, cons, rights, wrongs, >goods, bads etcetera ad infinitum of the game anyway? Why the big attempt >at navel-gazing and pondering whether it should be this, could be that or >may be something else alltogether? >The whole aspect of like or dislike, good or bad, game or simulation, is >subjective anyway and what appeals to one may be completely out-of-whack to >another. >Surely it is blatantly obvious that we are not all going to be satisfied >100% of the time simply because we are individuals. We simply need to stop >trying to be missionary-like in forcing personal messages of
dissatisfaction >down other's throats and respect the fact that our likes and dislikes may be
Quoted text (12 lines)>vastly different. >-- >Regards, >Bruce Kennewell, >Canberra, Australia. >--------------------------- >> People seem to be missing the point of my original post. There is
nothing >> real about driving a computer in your living room, but there are tools you
Quoted text (18 lines)>> can use to better compensate for this fact like force feedback wheels and >> speedometers. >> But consider this - if GPL had an average crappy physics system would we >all >> be playing it? Would we all know the nuances of the 1967 season and be >> complaining about inaccuracies? What if Papyrus had chosen to do a Cart >sim >> with that amazing physics engine? We'd all be CART-heads. Let's be >> thankful they didn't, but really, whatever sim gives me the best racing >> experience I'll be playing. It's not about historical inaccuracies it's >> about the racing. >> Thanks >> JH > -----------== Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News
==---------- > http://www.newsfeeds.com The Largest Usenet Servers in the World! >------== Over 73,000 Newsgroups - Including Dedicated Binaries Servers ==-----
I'll second those comments, Matt. After a year with GPL, I can drive it on sound alone. Turn the sound off, and I'm stuffed!!! But I only use the tacho to check for over-rev and wouldn't need a speedo in a month of Sundays. -- Regards, Bruce Kennewell, Canberra, Australia. --------------------------- > >If you need a speedometer to race GPL, your going about it all wrong, it's > >not about numbers, it's about feeling. Being able to tell if your going to > >fast into a corner, with just the feel of the car. Besides, why would you > >want to look away from the road when you need to look at it the most? > True, Jalo. For me, when racing, I only check the tacho for gear ratios, to > ensure that I am optimizing the power/torque of the engine, or not > over-revving. Maybe max speeds at straights. But it's all a business of > hearing. After a few laps in a car, you know about where you are RPM-wise. > And unless you're saving fuel or the car, you just go as fast as you can, > and look at the pitboard. "Speed isn't the issue" :-) > (ref here is not racing on the PC, but in a racecar) > Best > Matt -----------== Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News ==---------- http://www.newsfeeds.com The Largest Usenet Servers in the World! ------== Over 73,000 Newsgroups - Including Dedicated Binaries Servers ==-----
Whoosh! Through to the 'keeper. -- Regards, Bruce Kennewell, Canberra, Australia. --------------------------- > Ummm, that's what this newgroup is for. Or did I accidentally wander into > alt.parenting.***feeding again? We discuss racing sims, and > occasionally, their pros & cons. Wow, imagine that. Call it navel gazing > if you wish, but you don't have to read it if you don't like it, bigshot. > >What is the point of this examination into the pros, cons, rights, wrongs, > >goods, bads etcetera ad infinitum of the game anyway? Why the big attempt > >at navel-gazing and pondering whether it should be this, could be that or > >may be something else alltogether? > >The whole aspect of like or dislike, good or bad, game or simulation, is > >subjective anyway and what appeals to one may be completely out-of-whack to > >another. > >Surely it is blatantly obvious that we are not all going to be satisfied > >100% of the time simply because we are individuals. We simply need to stop > >trying to be missionary-like in forcing personal messages of > dissatisfaction > >down other's throats and respect the fact that our likes and dislikes may > be > >vastly different. > >-- > >Regards, > >Bruce Kennewell, > >Canberra, Australia. > >--------------------------- > >> People seem to be missing the point of my original post. There is > nothing > >> real about driving a computer in your living room, but there are tools > you > >> can use to better compensate for this fact like force feedback wheels and > >> speedometers. > >> But consider this - if GPL had an average crappy physics system would we > >all > >> be playing it? Would we all know the nuances of the 1967 season and be > >> complaining about inaccuracies? What if Papyrus had chosen to do a Cart > >sim > >> with that amazing physics engine? We'd all be CART-heads. Let's be > >> thankful they didn't, but really, whatever sim gives me the best racing > >> experience I'll be playing. It's not about historical inaccuracies it's > >> about the racing. > >> Thanks > >> JH > > -----------== Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News > ==---------- > > http://www.newsfeeds.com The Largest Usenet Servers in the World! > >------== Over 73,000 Newsgroups - Including Dedicated Binaries Servers > ==----- -----------== Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News ==---------- http://www.newsfeeds.com The Largest Usenet Servers in the World! ------== Over 73,000 Newsgroups - Including Dedicated Binaries Servers ==-----
EldredP 23 Jan 2000#515875
>If you need a speedometer to race GPL, your going about it all wrong, it's >not about numbers, it's about feeling. Being able to tell if your going to >fast into a corner, with just the feel of the car. Besides, why would you >want to look away from the road when you need to look at it the most? Ok, Jalo - How do you GET that feeling, while staring at a 15" monitor, and using a non-ff wheel? And you can *usually* read a speedo with peripheral vision(a digital one, anyway). Eldred -- Tiger Stadium R.I.P. 1912-1999 Own Grand Prix Legends? Goto http://gpl.gamestats.com/vroc Never argue with an idiot. He brings you down to his level, then beats you with experience... Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
Mike Laskey 23 Jan 2000#515876
Other forms of feedback are usually exaggerated for the computer game, eg tyre feedback - a good physics engine coupled with a high framerate gives sufficient feedback for most the time to understand what the virtual car is doing. As for digital readouts, I've got a large digital speed readout and an analogue tacho on my motorbike and the only time I really get to look at those are on the straight bits - if I've got time to look at them in a corner then I'm obviously nowhere near the limit :) Mike.
Jalo 23 Jan 2000#515877
Well, let me ask you this, if you change your set up, and if you had based your driving on actual car speed, how are you going to be able to tell if the changes you made help, or hinder you? You will not be able to, it's all about being able to "feel" the car. If you can't "feel" the car, you will not enjoy GPL, thats all there is to it, in my opinion.
Obiwan 24 Jan 2000#516075
Exactly where did he say that he was going to base his driving on ONLY the speed readout ??? It's not about getting a DIFFERENT way of racing,but rather to make a RICHER and more immersive (with more sensory input) SIMULATION experience. He has only explained that misinterpretation of his original post about 10 times or so,so one would think that people would start to get it by now,,,,,,,then of course it is up to them to decide wether or not they consciously want to narrow their sensory input to a more limited set than what's available in reality. and how are you going to "feel" the car if you cant se which way it is aligned and how it is moving in relation to to it's surroundings....... yeah,yeah,by the "subtle cues" provided on the screen by papyrus..... Personally,I would prefer some not-so-subtle clues that are available to real-life drivers,such as knowing and seeing which way your car are headed. -- Robert S?derberg If replying by mail,remove the word INGENSPAM from the adress.
EldredP 24 Jan 2000#516076
writes: I don't. I don't have ANY skill in modifying setups. I have to rely on other peoples' setups, because the changes I make don't help me any.... Eldred -- Tiger Stadium R.I.P. 1912-1999 Own Grand Prix Legends? Goto http://gpl.gamestats.com/vroc Never argue with an idiot. He brings you down to his level, then beats you with experience... Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
:>If you need a speedometer to race GPL, your going about it all wrong, it's :>not about numbers, it's about feeling. Being able to tell if your going to :>fast into a corner, with just the feel of the car. Besides, why would you :>want to look away from the road when you need to look at it the most? :> : Ok, Jalo - : How do you GET that feeling, while staring at a 15" monitor, and using a non-ff : wheel? And you can *usually* read a speedo with peripheral vision(a digital : one, anyway). I have to say, if I had a speedo, I bet I'd be able to judge when I'd got a good corner exit a lot better. I mean "hmm 105 mph as a I pass that bush" is a little more accurate than "hmm seems kinda fast as I pass that bush" - I KNOW you can do it on the replay but it'd be nice when you were driving too. -- Richard G. Clegg Only the mind is waving Networks and Non-Linear Dynamics Group Dept. of Mathematics, Uni. of York www: http://manor.york.ac.uk/top.html
Alan Orton 24 Jan 2000#516078
I just look at my tach when going past the bush. ;) If it's one tick higher then I got a good run out of a corner.
Try this.. Take a setup and adjust your rear roll bar all the way up and do a lap. Then adjust it all the way down and do another lap. Now tell us what the effects are. If you couldn't tell the difference, then you are over driving the car and nothing you do will help you. Do the same with the other settings, all the way up, do a lap, all the way down, do a lap. ect..ect.. If you do end up feeling a difference, you'll start to understand what does what as well as start to "feel" the car. If you don't "feel" any difference, then again, you're over driving it and that would be why you can't "feel" the car. Change only one thing at a time and make that change as drastic as you can.:) -- ========================================= Mike Barlow of Barlow Racing? ========================================= http://members.xoom.com/BarlowRacing/ Racing online with the help of...... Race Communications Association Holodyne Engineering Mystic Music (have Your !!Name/Address!! placed here)
Hmmm... I judge it by "gear change points" along the track. Always rev to the same readout and see where on the track I am. For example, can I get into 5:th gear _before_ the finish line at Monza. /petern
Quoted text (14 lines)>I just look at my tach when going past the bush. ;) >If it's one tick higher then I got a good run out of a corner. >> I have to say, if I had a speedo, I bet I'd be able to judge when I'd >> got a good corner exit a lot better. I mean "hmm 105 mph as a I pass >> that bush" is a little more accurate than "hmm seems kinda fast as I pass >> that bush" - I KNOW you can do it on the replay but it'd be nice when >> you were driving too. >> -- >> Richard G. Clegg Only the mind is waving >> Networks and Non-Linear Dynamics Group >> Dept. of Mathematics, Uni. of York >> www: http://manor.york.ac.uk/top.html
Alan Orton 25 Jan 2000#516279
That too. :)
Quoted text (24 lines)> Hmmm... I judge it by "gear change points" along the track. Always rev > to the same readout and see where on the track I am. > For example, can I get into 5:th gear _before_ the finish line at > Monza. > /petern > >I just look at my tach when going past the bush. ;) > >If it's one tick higher then I got a good run out of a corner. > >> I have to say, if I had a speedo, I bet I'd be able to judge when I'd > >> got a good corner exit a lot better. I mean "hmm 105 mph as a I pass > >> that bush" is a little more accurate than "hmm seems kinda fast as I pass > >> that bush" - I KNOW you can do it on the replay but it'd be nice when > >> you were driving too. > >> -- > >> Richard G. Clegg Only the mind is waving > >> Networks and Non-Linear Dynamics Group > >> Dept. of Mathematics, Uni. of York > >> www: http://manor.york.ac.uk/top.html
EldredP 27 Jan 2000#516711
Quoted text (13 lines)> Try this.. Take a setup and adjust your rear roll bar all the way up >and do a lap. Then adjust it all the way down and do another lap. Now >tell us what the effects are. If you couldn't tell the difference, then >you are over driving the car and nothing you do will help you. > Do the same with the other settings, all the way up, do a lap, all the >way down, do a lap. ect..ect.. If you do end up feeling a difference, >you'll start to understand what does what as well as start to "feel" the >car. If you don't "feel" any difference, then again, you're over >driving it and that would be why you can't "feel" the car. > Change only one thing at a time and make that change as drastic as you >can.:)
I'll get back to you...<g> Eldred -- Tiger Stadium R.I.P. 1912-1999 Own Grand Prix Legends? Goto http://gpl.gamestats.com/vroc Never argue with an idiot. He brings you down to his level, then beats you with experience... Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy