Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

GP3-Why it 'SHOULD' be harder than gpl to drive

20 posts by 14 people · 17 Jan 2000 - 19 Jan 2000

Should GP3 be harder to drive than GPL?

After watching a modern F1 car struggle up the Goodwood hill climb, Dave Henrie argued GP3 should be harder to drive than GPL. Others said grooved tyres and aero dependence make modern F1 cars twitchy at low speed, while some noted the Goodwood car was on cold tyres and a hard setup, and that real racing cars are easy to drive slowly.

physics/realism debatereal motorsportGrand Prix 3Grand Prix Legends

Automated summary.

Dave Henrie 17 Jan 2000#514752
I just watched a Speedvision show on the Goodwood Festival of Speed from Jolly ol England. It was taped during the summer and featured many many different cars, especially 60's & 70's Le Mans cars. The 917, and 962 looked awesome. Some Can Am cars, and even Richard Burns Rally winning Subaru. They all ran this one way course that took just under a minute for most of the cars to complete. The fastest car was a year old McClaren Formula One with Nick Heidfield driving. now my point: Most of the old cars ran up the course fairly well behaved, looking quite smooth. But the Mclaren was twitching and jumpy and in general looking more like a crash waiting to happen than a sophisticated world class racing car. Now granted, the course was not of F1 caliber and the Le Man cars probably never made it past 2nd gear, but the F1 racer was waaaay more twitchy than anything else shown during the program. Even Derek Bell sliding the Porche 962 into the hay bales looked genteel compared to the Mclaren run. So...for everybody whose claimed GPL is too hard to drive because it models skinny tired wingless wonders, I have to ask...what would a modern F1 sim be like? Shouldn't it too be extremely difficult to handle? I'm not saying they won't turn-in or anything, but if that Mac was representative of current F1 roadhugging, then GP3 should be EXTREMELY difficult to drive even in a straight line. And finally...with all this world class hardware on display, what were the British film crews going gaw-gaw over? Behind Bell during an interview, a '70 Dodge Daytona R/T (the winged cars of Nascar Legends)was on display and the TV guy was slightly giddy standing next to it... dave henrie
Aubrey 17 Jan 2000#514753
Yup, I'm sure modern F1 cars are a pain in the ass. The grooved tires put all the emphasis on aerodynamic grip, so as soon as the car starts to get sideways the aero gets spoiled, and you suddenly lose a lot of grip. Plus, with the tiny engines, fuel loads, and gearboxes they have these days, I bet the cars have a tiny polar moment of inertia which should make them even twitchier. Then there's also the relatively stiff suspension, which exaggerates the effects of bumps. Harder than GPL though? I don't know. Let's not assume GPL is perfectly realistic. -A
Quoted text (27 lines)> I just watched a Speedvision show on the Goodwood Festival of Speed >from Jolly ol England. It was taped during the summer and featured many >many different cars, especially 60's & 70's Le Mans cars. The 917, and >962 looked awesome. Some Can Am cars, and even Richard Burns Rally >winning Subaru. They all ran this one way course that took just under a >minute for most of the cars to complete. The fastest car was a year old >McClaren Formula One with Nick Heidfield driving. now my point: > Most of the old cars ran up the course fairly well behaved, looking >quite smooth. But the Mclaren was twitching and jumpy and in general >looking more like a crash waiting to happen than a sophisticated world >class racing car. Now granted, the course was not of F1 caliber and >the Le Man cars probably never made it past 2nd gear, but the F1 racer >was waaaay more twitchy than anything else shown during the program. >Even Derek Bell sliding the Porche 962 into the hay bales looked genteel >compared to the Mclaren run. > So...for everybody whose claimed GPL is too hard to drive because it >models skinny tired wingless wonders, I have to ask...what would a >modern F1 sim be like? Shouldn't it too be extremely difficult to >handle? I'm not saying they won't turn-in or anything, but if that Mac >was representative of current F1 roadhugging, then GP3 should be >EXTREMELY difficult to drive even in a straight line. > And finally...with all this world class hardware on display, what were >the British film crews going gaw-gaw over? Behind Bell during an >interview, a '70 Dodge Daytona R/T (the winged cars of Nascar >Legends)was on display and the TV guy was slightly giddy standing next >to it... >dave henrie
You figure at slow speeds aero is nonexistent. So trying to handle 800 hp on a several hundred kilo car, with grooves or with out?, would have to be near impossible. Of course every two weeks during the season 22 lucky bastards show us how its done, at sufficient speeds though.
Quoted text (27 lines)> I just watched a Speedvision show on the Goodwood Festival of Speed > from Jolly ol England. It was taped during the summer and featured many > many different cars, especially 60's & 70's Le Mans cars. The 917, and > 962 looked awesome. Some Can Am cars, and even Richard Burns Rally > winning Subaru. They all ran this one way course that took just under a > minute for most of the cars to complete. The fastest car was a year old > McClaren Formula One with Nick Heidfield driving. now my point: > Most of the old cars ran up the course fairly well behaved, looking > quite smooth. But the Mclaren was twitching and jumpy and in general > looking more like a crash waiting to happen than a sophisticated world > class racing car. Now granted, the course was not of F1 caliber and > the Le Man cars probably never made it past 2nd gear, but the F1 racer > was waaaay more twitchy than anything else shown during the program. > Even Derek Bell sliding the Porche 962 into the hay bales looked genteel > compared to the Mclaren run. > So...for everybody whose claimed GPL is too hard to drive because it > models skinny tired wingless wonders, I have to ask...what would a > modern F1 sim be like? Shouldn't it too be extremely difficult to > handle? I'm not saying they won't turn-in or anything, but if that Mac > was representative of current F1 roadhugging, then GP3 should be > EXTREMELY difficult to drive even in a straight line. > And finally...with all this world class hardware on display, what were > the British film crews going gaw-gaw over? Behind Bell during an > interview, a '70 Dodge Daytona R/T (the winged cars of Nascar > Legends)was on display and the TV guy was slightly giddy standing next > to it... > dave henrie
Well they do say that modern F1 cars are a *** to drive becasue of the grooves on the tyres.. So I agree GP3 should be a *** to drive !! As for the comment about the guys being giddy over the winged dodge !! Us Brits find anything americans make or do funny !! :) P.S. You should check out the Goodwood revival meets from 99 and 98 !! Circuit racing as it used to be !! No flaming please its a joke !!!!
Cossie 18 Jan 2000#514918
Easy? Looking at the training F1 drivers go through. We don't see anyone that shape like Jimmy Spencer in F1 now do we.... Modeern F1 car should pull a lot more Gs than the old one, thank god we don't have to do that in sims.. >Yup, I'm sure modern F1 cars are a pain in the ass. The grooved tires put >all the emphasis on aerodynamic grip, so as soon as the car starts to get >sideways the aero gets spoiled, and you suddenly lose a lot of grip. Plus, >with the tiny engines, fuel loads, and gearboxes they have these days, I bet
Quoted text (38 lines)>the cars have a tiny polar moment of inertia which should make them even >twitchier. Then there's also the relatively stiff suspension, which >exaggerates the effects of bumps. >Harder than GPL though? I don't know. Let's not assume GPL is perfectly >realistic. >-A >> I just watched a Speedvision show on the Goodwood Festival of Speed >>from Jolly ol England. It was taped during the summer and featured many >>many different cars, especially 60's & 70's Le Mans cars. The 917, and >>962 looked awesome. Some Can Am cars, and even Richard Burns Rally >>winning Subaru. They all ran this one way course that took just under a >>minute for most of the cars to complete. The fastest car was a year old >>McClaren Formula One with Nick Heidfield driving. now my point: >> Most of the old cars ran up the course fairly well behaved, looking >>quite smooth. But the Mclaren was twitching and jumpy and in general >>looking more like a crash waiting to happen than a sophisticated world >>class racing car. Now granted, the course was not of F1 caliber and >>the Le Man cars probably never made it past 2nd gear, but the F1 racer >>was waaaay more twitchy than anything else shown during the program. >>Even Derek Bell sliding the Porche 962 into the hay bales looked genteel >>compared to the Mclaren run. >> So...for everybody whose claimed GPL is too hard to drive because it >>models skinny tired wingless wonders, I have to ask...what would a >>modern F1 sim be like? Shouldn't it too be extremely difficult to >>handle? I'm not saying they won't turn-in or anything, but if that Mac >>was representative of current F1 roadhugging, then GP3 should be >>EXTREMELY difficult to drive even in a straight line. >> And finally...with all this world class hardware on display, what were >>the British film crews going gaw-gaw over? Behind Bell during an >>interview, a '70 Dodge Daytona R/T (the winged cars of Nascar >>Legends)was on display and the TV guy was slightly giddy standing next >>to it... >>dave henrie
The fastest car was a year old Hehe, I was there (again). Highly recommended! The reason Nick was all over the place was that it was an official hillclimb record attempt! Jonathan Palmer put one of Senna's McLarens into a stone wall trying to do the same the day before..:) Sadly, most of the others were just cruising, especially the 60s F1s. in 98 Mark Hales made me jump sky high going all out with Dale Jarrett's T-bird..all over the place, and he was fast too. Really great to see such a variety of cars competing against each other. Derek Bell in Donohue's Can-Am 917 had wheelspin in *all* gears up the hill...lol! Ooh, would somebody take a wild guess how much faster the F1s were up that backyard grimy road than Kankkunen, McRae et all in modern rally cars trying to do the same? Really shows the speed of F1.... Matt
The softest possible suspension is still far too hard for the course at Goodwood, so that's one of the reasons why the car was moving that much. The other reason is that it's impossible to get some decent heat into the tires at that course. Modern F1 cars aren't easy to drive, but the difference is that the fastest way to drive them is without real sliding. So the difficult is to drive on the outright limit without it overdoing a single bit. And you've got to be that precise while accelerating like a rocket and braking like driving into a soft wall.
GraDee 18 Jan 2000#514921
Sorry but I must just ***in .... as usual:-) To be honest this is quite a load of codswallop. N/A GP3 should be very hard to drive so was GP2 to an extent. But like you said if I GT car can't even go past 2nd gear its undrivable for an F1 car which is why it was twichy. I was just at the Motrosport international show in the RDS lately and they made a rally sprint stage in the car park!?!?! Well layed out but almost all cars had tremendous difficulty, extremly narrow and the car was begging to be pushed hard but the driver would end up in IT for a while. Because of the speed and mainly the power curve of F1 they have to be able to flow into a corner, all F1 tracks allot this, even Monaco to an extent, there are exceptions but nothing drastic that I can think of off hand. I would imagine it would be easier to drvie a slower car on the type of circuit you described since the power curve is not so great meaning less wheels spin and tight movement which I think is the cause for the twitchyness. Still though, I don't know the circuit but if tyou think a modern day F1 caris more diffcult to drive than a 1960's car then forget it. A chicane was not heard of in 1960 for 2 reasons..... 1. It slows you down, who wants that.......? 2. Just try imagine drving GPL in Monza in its current state....loads of fun, but it just can't be done as well as in 1960's spec. But look at 1999 cars, they just flick through with no bother (except Mika but thats another rant on RASF1.....hehe) Anyway thats my idea of things -- GraDee (...who awaits reasons why his responce is totally outragious...... go on ymenard, I know your out there.....hehe, just joking.) ------------------------------------------------------------- Karting "3.65" www.esatclear.ie/~karting ------------------------------------------------------------- "The dozens and dozens........."
GraDee 18 Jan 2000#514922
I might just add that with the groves in F1 cars now I would be expecting cars to slide more like we've seen on TV and probably that its a *** to set-up for grip. The only problem I see with this is that compared to other modern F1 sims is that it would be more "slidy" which would probably get it some stick for not being realistic from non-simming and probably some sim drivers. -- GraDee ------------------------------------------------------------- Karting "3.65" www.esatclear.ie/~karting ------------------------------------------------------------- "The dozens and dozens........." > Sorry but I must just ***in .... as usual:-) > To be honest this is quite a load of codswallop. > N/A GP3 should be very hard to drive so was GP2 to an extent. > But like you said if I GT car can't even go past 2nd gear its undrivable for > an F1 car which is why it was twichy. > I was just at the Motrosport international show in the RDS lately and they > made a rally sprint stage in the car park!?!?! > Well layed out but almost all cars had tremendous difficulty, extremly > narrow and the car was begging to be pushed hard but the driver would end up > in IT for a while. Because of the speed and mainly the power curve of F1 > they have to be able to flow into a corner, all F1 tracks allot this, even > Monaco to an extent, there are exceptions but nothing drastic that I can > think of off hand. > I would imagine it would be easier to drvie a slower car on the type of > circuit you described since the power curve is not so great meaning less > wheels spin and tight movement which I think is the cause for the > twitchyness. > Still though, I don't know the circuit but if tyou think a modern day F1 > caris more diffcult to drive than a 1960's car then forget it. A chicane was > not heard of in 1960 for 2 reasons..... > 1. It slows you down, who wants that.......? > 2. Just try imagine drving GPL in Monza in its current state....loads of > fun, but it just can't be done as well as in 1960's spec. But look at 1999 > cars, they just flick through with no bother (except Mika but thats another > rant on RASF1.....hehe) > Anyway thats my idea of things > -- > GraDee (...who awaits reasons why his responce is totally outragious...... > go on ymenard, I know your out there.....hehe, just joking.) > ------------------------------------------------------------- > Karting "3.65" > www.esatclear.ie/~karting > ------------------------------------------------------------- > "The dozens and dozens........." > > I just watched a Speedvision show on the Goodwood Festival of Speed > > from Jolly ol England. It was taped during the summer and featured many > > many different cars, especially 60's & 70's Le Mans cars. The 917, and > > 962 looked awesome. Some Can Am cars, and even Richard Burns Rally > > winning Subaru. They all ran this one way course that took just under a > > minute for most of the cars to complete. The fastest car was a year old > > McClaren Formula One with Nick Heidfield driving. now my point: > > Most of the old cars ran up the course fairly well behaved, looking > > quite smooth. But the Mclaren was twitching and jumpy and in general > > looking more like a crash waiting to happen than a sophisticated world > > class racing car. Now granted, the course was not of F1 caliber and > > the Le Man cars probably never made it past 2nd gear, but the F1 racer > > was waaaay more twitchy than anything else shown during the program. > > Even Derek Bell sliding the Porche 962 into the hay bales looked genteel > > compared to the Mclaren run. > > So...for everybody whose claimed GPL is too hard to drive because it > > models skinny tired wingless wonders, I have to ask...what would a > > modern F1 sim be like? Shouldn't it too be extremely difficult to > > handle? I'm not saying they won't turn-in or anything, but if that Mac > > was representative of current F1 roadhugging, then GP3 should be > > EXTREMELY difficult to drive even in a straight line. > > And finally...with all this world class hardware on display, what were > > the British film crews going gaw-gaw over? Behind Bell during an > > interview, a '70 Dodge Daytona R/T (the winged cars of Nascar > > Legends)was on display and the TV guy was slightly giddy standing next > > to it... > > dave henrie
pez 18 Jan 2000#514923
its quite easy to drive racing cars slowly around circuits, the biggest problem people tend to have is misjudging how slowly they need to be going around corners, thats why so many people slide off in gpl and in gp2 etc. Real racing cars go faster when drifting slightly, how much slip angle depends on a lot of things, but its generally 5degrees for the front tires i think, and this is where modern f1 cars get ***, they dont have a progressive slip curve, so they snap quickly if you go a bit too far. Racing gp2 (hotlapping expecially) on the edge was quite difficult, but as eddie irvine said in his documentary, you dont go down the straights and then scream in the corners, its really quite relaxed, you build up rhythm, and pace. Ive played gp3, and i did find it a bit more difficult to drive, but only because i had 4 laps and drove like a maniac on the streets of monaco. You learn how much you can slip the cars, how much speed you can carry, and you go quickly. It just takes a little practice.
ymenard 18 Jan 2000#514924
> N/A GP3 should be very hard to drive so was GP2 to an extent. Your right. GP2 was actually tough. Anybody remember your first experience ? Going to the software store a day during Spring ? Trying to steer the car using AZ/<>, gamepad or joystick. It was difficult, even with most of the help on. I do expect a BIG learning curve with Gp3, but of course, it should also have the great gameplay depth and customisation so that every type of gamer can enjoy it. Like every previous software by Geoff Crammond. Of course, we can't say that about GPL (even if it had such customisation it wouldn't had sold, it's the "vintage racing" thing. Look at NLegends). Yes that is what I love about Monaco. It is so tight, yet the F1 cars are able to flow the car into the corners, more than anything I have ever seen. It just takes the corner flawlesly like a Matchbox car around the carpet roads when you were young. Hey that was a nice reference ;) <sarcasm but true> FIA suits so that you can see better the advertising on the cars and surrounding. It is the only reason now that they are killing even more 2 tracks in F1 (Monza and Hocken). outrageous? from me? naw, Im not that type. Im a black sheep, but they aren't always evil, aren't they? ;) -- -- Fran?ois Mnard <ymenard> -- May the Downforce be with you... "People think it must be fun to be a super genius, but they don't realise how hard it is to put up with all the idiots in the world."
Kirk Lane 18 Jan 2000#514925
I couldn't agree MORE!!!! Even the Subaru WRC and Ford Focus that zipped around before it, dropping 2 wheels off the road at reckless abandon were more composed than the McLaren. Oh, and that '67 RA300....droool.... They did mention that the car was a '98 on '99 spec tires (4 groove fronts) but I wouldn't think it would make much of a difference...if it did, maybe for '99 they put more front downforce into the car? -- Kirk Lane ICQ: 28171652 BRT #187 "Yeah you won't find me I'm going MIA Tonight I'm leaving Going MIA Getting lost in you again Is better than being known" -Foo Fighters, "MIA"
Cossie 19 Jan 2000#515118
Didn't Makinen or McRae tested for Williams, end up they were spinning all over the place?
:-) Speed is the diff. The Rrally cars looked like mopeds in comparison...<g> They were running max downforce, extremly short gear ratios, and used tire warmers. They meant business.... Can't wait for the FOS this year! Matt
: Didn't Makinen or McRae tested for Williams, end up they were spinning all : over the place? My poor memory says that both Makinen and Mick Doohan (500cc bikes) put it into the wall. However, I'm sure someone has a much better memory and will prove me wrong, and if I am really unlucky, it wasn't Doohan and I will end up with a bunch of rabid Australians and New Zealanders threatening to rip my skin off for insulting Mick :) Stephen
: Your right. GP2 was actually tough. Anybody remember your first experience : ? Going to the software store a day during Spring ? Trying to steer the car : using AZ/<>, gamepad or joystick. It was difficult, even with most of the : help on. Actually, I found my first experience with GP1 was the eye-opener, partly because I chose Monaco to start at, and the sterile graphics didn't really give me a clue of where to go. all I remember was a full day of going "biff, biff, biff" of every single wall. Somehow I had missed the original "Indy500" game, so my experience with driving games was the Test Drive series (TD3 was the highest at the time). GP1 was a whole different level of game, and the first one that I hung the "sim" label on. Gp2, comparitively, was a cake walk to get up and running with. Stephen
ymenard 19 Jan 2000#515122
Not playing the Devil's advocate, but any of you remember Ayrton Senna driving a Rally car ? ouch! ;) -- -- Fran?ois Mnard <ymenard> -- May the Downforce be with you... "People think it must be fun to be a super genius, but they don't realise how hard it is to put up with all the idiots in the world."
µartijn 19 Jan 2000#515123
No, I don't. But from your remark, I cannot conclude whether he was very good or very bad. Please enlighten me/us.
Surely you mean GP2...
Quoted text (16 lines)>its quite easy to drive racing cars slowly around circuits, the biggest >problem people tend to have is misjudging how slowly they need to be going >around corners, thats why so many people slide off in gpl and in gp2 etc. >Real racing cars go faster when drifting slightly, how much slip angle >depends on a lot of things, but its generally 5degrees for the front tires i >think, and this is where modern f1 cars get ***, they dont have a >progressive slip curve, so they snap quickly if you go a bit too far. >Racing gp2 (hotlapping expecially) on the edge was quite difficult, but as >eddie irvine said in his documentary, you dont go down the straights and >then scream in the corners, its really quite relaxed, you build up rhythm, >and pace. Ive played gp3, and i did find it a bit more difficult to drive, >but only because i had 4 laps and drove like a maniac on the streets of >monaco. You learn how much you can slip the cars, how much speed you can >carry, and you go quickly. It just takes a little practice.

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy