Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

OT: Unreal Tournament - that's the way to do it

5 posts by 5 people · 12 Jan 2000 - 12 Jan 2000

It's nothing to do with motor sport, it isn't a simulation, but boy oh boy there's loads that race sim developers could learn from Unreal Tournament, namely: - - Taking an existing game engine and tweaking it until it hurts, rather than putting a fancy frock over it and hoping nobody notices. - Recognising that oceanic depth of gameplay is the most critical element in computer entertainment. - Providing an awesome range of options that allow you to play a game almost any which way you like. - Offering superb compatibility with a wide range of video cards e.g. totally effective D3D implementation. - Creating what is arguably the most daring approach ever to changing the perceptions of a genre, in this case redefining the scope and potential of the first-person shooter. - Delaying the release of the game until its polished to an extent worthy of dipping into your pocket. Of course UT is not trying to replicate a real-life experience in the way a racing sim has to. But is this a sufficient excuse for the disappointments we've all suffered in the past couple of years with sequels that have often failed to deliver what we might reasonably have expected? "Help me GP3 - you're my only hope" - Much rests on how this game leaps forward from its illustrious predecessor. Unreal Tournament shows what can be achieved with dedication and the willingness to delay a game's release until it has been tweaked to the max. Knowing Mr Crammond's work ethic, we still have very good cause to be optimistic - let's hope we don't all have to buy P3 1000's to make it run well.
On Wed, 12 Jan 2000 14:41:18 -0000, "Chris Wright" >It's nothing to do with motor sport, it isn't a simulation, but boy oh boy >there's loads that race sim developers could learn from Unreal Tournament, >namely: - >- Taking an existing game engine and tweaking it until it hurts, rather than >putting a fancy frock over it and hoping nobody notices. Or building a new engine. GPL - check. That's GPL, in spades. GPL out of the box loses points here (particularly regarding novices), but independent add-ons (AITweak) have eased that. Another sore point for GPL. OTOH, the Papyrus-heads with Rendition cards were happy, and the serious gamers with Voodoos were happy. And, when the sim was released 15+ months ago (and developed that much further back) D3D wasn't such a panacea. GPL is such a quantum leap that it got me seriously interested in racing sims again, much like the original ICR did in '93. Check. While we might have wanted more (weather, for instance), GPL 1.0 out of the box was a pretty darn good (and bug-free) product. And we didn't even get around to free online racing, VROC, and the many other independent add-ons... So, Chris, how did you like GPL? :) Based on past history, performance optimization, meeting deadlines, and after-sale support may well be problems. We'll just have to wait and see. It certainly will be good to have a top-notch, modern F1 sim. "But in a way, fear is a big part of racing, because if there was nothing to be frightened of, and no limit, any fool could get into a motor car and racing would not exist as a sport." -- Jim Clark
Vintook 12 Jan 2000#513867
I have to differ with you on this, I tried it out and the online play was laggy as hell, and I have a cable modem and connected to the fastest server so I know it's not that! Id software still has the best online play through Quake and only half-life team fortress has come close to it. Unreal still looked great but not good enough online play to suit me, hell even GPL blows it away for connection smoothness. Just my thoughts. Vintook
BClay 12 Jan 2000#513868
I've played UT online many times and have no problems with lag when connecting to a fast host. The fastest connection I can get is 28.8. The game rocks online and offline for me. BClay I have to differ with you on this, I tried it out and the online play was laggy as hell, and I have a cable modem and connected to the fastest server so I know it's not that! Id software still has the best online play through Quake and only half-life team fortress has come close to it. Unreal still looked great but not good enough online play to suit me, hell even GPL blows it away for connection smoothness. Just my thoughts. Vintook > It's nothing to do with motor sport, it isn't a simulation, but boy oh boy > there's loads that race sim developers could learn from Unreal Tournament, > namely: - > > - Taking an existing game engine and tweaking it until it hurts, rather than > putting a fancy frock over it and hoping nobody notices. > > - Recognising that oceanic depth of gameplay is the most critical element in
Quoted text (13 lines) > computer entertainment. > > - Providing an awesome range of options that allow you to play a game > almost any which way you like. > > - Offering superb compatibility with a wide range of video cards e.g. > totally effective D3D implementation. > > - Creating what is arguably the most daring approach ever to changing the > perceptions of a genre, in this case redefining the scope and potential of > the first-person shooter. > > - Delaying the release of the game until its polished to an extent worthy
of > dipping into your pocket. > > Of course UT is not trying to replicate a real-life experience in the way a > racing sim has to. But is this a sufficient excuse for the disappointments > we've all suffered in the past couple of years with sequels that have often
Quoted text (16 lines) > failed > to deliver what we might reasonably have expected? > > "Help me GP3 - you're my only hope" - Much rests on how this game leaps > forward from its illustrious predecessor. Unreal Tournament shows what can > be achieved with dedication and the willingness to delay a game's release > until it has been tweaked to the max. Knowing Mr Crammond's work ethic, we > still have very good cause to be optimistic - let's hope we don't all have > to buy P3 1000's to make it run well. > > > > > > >
ymenard 12 Jan 2000#513869
The needs of each community is different. As seen with the work being presently done on the NASCAR Racing 3 beta patch, we have started to understand that on the N3 newsgroup. It is simply too different to say "look at X's game multiplayer to see how good it can be". I say that today multiplayer racing isn't even enough. A company has to create online community tools. That's a much better term. Taking an existing game engine and tweaking it is what Papyrus did to some extent with N3. The new game engine for N4 will be incredible, some people are forgetting that ;) It's a FPS, not a racing game. How can you add gameplay to a race ? Different mode ? Catch the flag on a racetrack? ;-D Racing is racing is racing. NASCAR Racing 3, and Grand Prix Legends offer incredible ammount of customisation. Especially the beta (and soon real N3 patch), you can do soo many thing. About any parameter can be changed. You want to create a dirt league ? Modify N3 with graphics and the tyre grip parameters. Want to create a road-course only N3 league ? Create something like TPTCC, with everybody using fixed setup AND a restrictor plate, etc.. N3 has that. Irrelevant to racing simulations. GPL already did that Just a different production philosophy. Some companies work like that, others not. On both side you have great products. So all those things have already been implemented in the racing community. -- -- Fran?ois Mnard <ymenard> -- May the Downforce be with you... "People think it must be fun to be a super genius, but they don't realise how hard it is to put up with all the idiots in the world."

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy