Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

Bob Mandel at AVAULT shits on another racing sim.

43 posts by 17 people · 04 Jan 2000 - 06 Jan 2000

Flame warAvault's 2.5-star Dirt Track Racing review divides readers

A poster attacked Avault reviewer Bob Mandel for giving Dirt Track Racing 2.5 stars. Several regulars agreed with the review, finding the tracks samey and the graphics and physics weak, while DTR supporters, notably Pete, cited Dale Earnhardt Jr.'s endorsement and real racers in the beta group. Exchanges between Pete and Ron Ayton became openly insulting.

review/impressionsDirt Track Racing

Automated summary.

Huh 04 Jan 2000#512147
http://avault.com/reviews/review_temp.asp?game=dirttr Bob Mandel at AVAULT shits on yet another racing sim. DTR = 2 1/2 stars. Heres some snippets: "This is the only offering so far to replicate a popular, yet not widely known, form of racing in the U.S., with over 700 tracks across the country .." Bob-ster, uhhh.. how in the hell can real-life dirt racing be 'popular', yet 'not widely known'. Huh? Help us out with this.. "Unfortunately, the courses seem all too similar as you drive on them; I am sorely tempted to say, "If you've seen one looped dirt track, you've seen 'em all."" So I guess it really comes as a shock to this weenie that the most popular forms of racing in the US of F***ING A are done on OVALS!! Is this guy fer real? "Additionally, the vehicle models are all fictional--there are no licensed brands--and they show none of the creative inspiration demonstrated in other computer-created automobiles, such as those in Ubi Soft's Speed Busters." Well, now there's something to ponder. Bob 'The Intimidator' Mandel sez that DTR would be better if it used SPEED BUSTERS style cars!! I'm gasping for breath here, folks .. "From an aesthetic standpoint, the visuals are downright unsightly." YAH, Bobby, I give the graphics maybe 9 out of 10 stars. They suck so bad. Too damned realistic. I want chrome, baby!! And some of those pink Speed Busters cars would ROOL!! sp33d bust3rs ownz j00.. "The play screen is quite easy to read and nicely laid out. I especially appreciate the presence of a standard rear view mirror, which is often oddly missing in racing titles." BWAHAHAHA... PLAY SCREEN.. ??? I'm losing control here. "One of the main problems is boredom; driving around an oval track 12 times with nothing outside worth looking at can get mighty tedious, especially if you are far in the lead or way behind." And we can guess which end of the line you were on, Bob. Yah, the scenery suX0rs, dud3. Maybe they coulda, shoulda had these babies at that Monaco track. There's lotsa scenery there, whooo boy. And those french babes make my pecker stiff I GA-RON-TEE.. Hey, they coulda had a Monaco.Mudslide and then it woulda worked. Lousy Aussie developer missed a big chance here. "The speed of the racing is considerably slower than I am used to, due in large part to the unpaved road surface;" Yah, since you have never driven a real CAR from a real PLAY SCREEN, I think we can understand what you're saying here. "While racing, the sounds of the engine and the occasional collision are pretty much all you hear." SHIT! I wanted Alyssa Milano dripping those honey-drop words of love on.. in my err.. ear.. while I was whuppin' up on the wimpy AI. Those lamers at Ratbag, WTF were they thinking.. Whew.. Hey y'all, just go read it for yourself. This clueless reviewer has done this before with several other sims. He is a detriment to our hobby, in my opinion. Time for a few ***-grams (again). I'm outta here.
Actually, I agree with Bob.... It's popular in the US, but not in the rest of the world. That makes it popular, yet not widely known. The ovals in Nascar 3 are very different from each other. Very different types of corners on each track. The corners thus the tracks in DTR are allmost all the same. In N3, I can tell which track I'm on after a drove one lap on it. If you give me ten tracks from DTR, I can't tell you which tracks I drove on, because they do look the same to me. He is. I think he means that the cars in DTR look very dull. And they do. The cars from Speedbusters look beautifull, they paid very much attention to car details. He isn't talking about car behaviour here! The graphics in DTR look dull, which very little scenery. You know what he means. Indeed, I find DTR a very boring game too. Dull graphics, dull gameplay, dull tracks. A lot of people seem to have fun with DTR, great, but I find driving circle after circle on a dirtrack plain boring. And I love Nascar 3, so it isn't because I find ovals boring. It's the oval tracks in DTR that are boring. (Whew, another 22-second lap!) Indeed. No feeling of racing, no feeling of gaining speed, due to the really crappy engine sounds. I think Bob is just being honest. He doesn't like DTR for a couple of good reasons. You can agree or disagree with him, or with me, but there's no need to trash his review like this. IMHO it's a good and honest review. Andre
Ron Ayton 04 Jan 2000#512149
I do too Andre... I personally think DTR is dull, and very samey from track to track, with poor graphics and even poorer physics.. The sense of speed is non-existant and it never feels as though i have a direct controllable link to the steering input. The revs, verses the engine sound to gear change times, relay nothing to the user at all. The cars handle like speedboats/hovercrafts and sound like malfunctioning sewing machines on steroids. This is my opinion only and if others like it, well and good, but for me, i cannot see what all the hype is about with this game. Cheers, Ron
Pete 04 Jan 2000#512150
Here is this whiz bang reviewers bio! Look at his favourite racing games! :-) What a joke! Obviously, his ego matches his reviewing skills! Howie Mandel's brother, what a couple of clowns! Pete CT Staff Writer Daily tasks: Playing Games, Evaluating Games, Being a Gamester Age: 3 Acts: 0 Location: Portland, Oregon First game: My own version of Tic-Tac-Toe, which could beat or tie any human using 10 lines of code Likes: arcade shooters, pinball, arcade racing, and puzzle games (both action-puzzle and adventure-puzzle varieties) Current Faves: Dethkarz, Motorhead, Recoil, Descent 3, Slave Zero, Nerf ArenaBlast Interested to see: MDK2 Fondest *** Memories: Writing over 20 of my own computer games Spare Time: Enjoying my family Other: Chairing a college department, teaching, having five books published Cool: I love undersea and pirate adventure. Hates: Gratuitous sex and *** System Specs: a 400 megahertz Pentium II with 128 megs of RAM, a 16.8 gigabyte hard drive, a DVD drive, a 21-inch Sony Trinitron monitor, a Xitel Platinum Storm sound card, a Riva TNT 2D/3D video card, and a Voodoo2 accelerator card. Pseudo .plan: An endless stream of *** articles Copyright 1995-2000 [ NewWorld.com, Inc ] All Rights Reserved
He enjoys arcade racing games, so what? That doesn't mean that he doesn't know what a real sim should be like. Andre
Quoted text (153 lines)> Here is this whiz bang reviewers bio! Look at his favourite >racing games! :-) What a joke! Obviously, his ego matches his >reviewing skills! Howie Mandel's brother, what a couple of clowns! > Pete >CT >Staff Writer >Daily tasks: >Playing Games, Evaluating Games, Being a Gamester >Age: >3 >Acts: >0 >Location: >Portland, Oregon >First game: >My own version of Tic-Tac-Toe, which could beat or tie any human using 10 >lines of code >Likes: >arcade shooters, pinball, arcade racing, and puzzle games (both >action-puzzle and adventure-puzzle varieties) >Current Faves: >Dethkarz, Motorhead, Recoil, Descent 3, Slave Zero, Nerf ArenaBlast >Interested to see: >MDK2 >Fondest *** Memories: >Writing over 20 of my own computer games >Spare Time: >Enjoying my family >Other: >Chairing a college department, teaching, having five books published >Cool: >I love undersea and pirate adventure. >Hates: >Gratuitous sex and *** >System Specs: >a 400 megahertz Pentium II with 128 megs of RAM, a 16.8 gigabyte hard drive, >a DVD drive, a 21-inch Sony Trinitron monitor, a Xitel Platinum Storm sound >card, a Riva TNT 2D/3D video card, and a Voodoo2 accelerator card. >Pseudo .plan: >An endless stream of *** articles >Copyright 1995-2000 [ NewWorld.com, Inc ] All Rights Reserved >> http://avault.com/reviews/review_temp.asp?game=dirttr >> Bob Mandel at AVAULT shits on yet another racing sim. >> DTR = 2 1/2 stars. >> Heres some snippets: >> "This is the only offering so far to replicate a popular, yet >> not widely known, form of racing in the U.S., with over 700 tracks >> across the country .." >> Bob-ster, uhhh.. how in the hell can real-life dirt racing be >> 'popular', yet 'not widely known'. >> Huh? Help us out with this.. >> "Unfortunately, the courses seem all too similar as you drive on >> them; I am sorely tempted to say, "If you've seen one looped dirt >> track, you've seen 'em all."" >> So I guess it really comes as a shock to this weenie that the most >> popular forms of racing in the US of F***ING A are done on >> OVALS!! >> Is this guy fer real? >> "Additionally, the vehicle models are all fictional--there are no >> licensed brands--and they show none of the creative inspiration >> demonstrated in other computer-created automobiles, such as >> those in Ubi Soft's Speed Busters." >> Well, now there's something to ponder. Bob 'The Intimidator' >> Mandel sez that DTR would be better if it used SPEED BUSTERS >> style cars!! >> I'm gasping for breath here, folks .. >> "From an aesthetic standpoint, the visuals are downright unsightly." >> YAH, Bobby, I give the graphics maybe 9 out of 10 stars. >> They suck so bad. Too damned realistic. I want chrome, baby!! >> And some of those pink Speed Busters cars would ROOL!! >> sp33d bust3rs ownz j00.. >> "The play screen is quite easy to read and nicely laid out. I >> especially appreciate the presence of a standard rear view mirror, >> which is often oddly missing in racing titles." >> BWAHAHAHA... PLAY SCREEN.. ??? >> I'm losing control here. >> "One of the main problems is boredom; driving around an oval track >> 12 times with nothing outside worth looking at can get mighty >> tedious, especially if you are far in the lead or way behind." >> And we can guess which end of the line you were on, Bob. >> Yah, the scenery suX0rs, dud3. Maybe they coulda, shoulda had >> these babies at that Monaco track. There's lotsa scenery there, >> whooo boy. And those french babes make my pecker stiff >> I GA-RON-TEE.. >> Hey, they coulda had a Monaco.Mudslide and then it woulda >> worked. Lousy Aussie developer missed a big chance here. >> "The speed of the racing is considerably slower than I am used to, >> due in large part to the unpaved road surface;" >> Yah, since you have never driven a real CAR from a real PLAY SCREEN, >> I think we can understand what you're saying here. >> "While racing, the sounds of the engine and the occasional collision >> are pretty much all you hear." >> SHIT! I wanted Alyssa Milano dripping those honey-drop words of >> love on.. in my err.. ear.. while I was whuppin' up on the wimpy AI. >> Those lamers at Ratbag, WTF were they thinking.. >> Whew.. >> Hey y'all, just go read it for yourself. This clueless reviewer >> has done this before with several other sims. He is a detriment >> to our hobby, in my opinion. Time for a few ***-grams (again). >> I'm outta here.
Pete 04 Jan 2000#512152
Its obvious in reading his reviews he knows little or nothing about real life racing or what physics are involved in Dirt Track Racing. After reading Dale Earnhardts interview on the game and talking with dozens of real life racers it seems that he is using an arcade mentality in his viewpoint. Does, this mean that because you agree with him that this is your source of reference as well? Or perhaps, you and Howie Mandrel are much more versed in whats real and what isn't! As far as graphics go its no NFS4, Dethkarz or Motorhead! But we are talking about racing in dirt! Cars aren't spit and polish show cars but maybe that has escaped you! He says the courses are all similiar! Gee, he must have tried just 1 of them then. Setups are different for me at every track and you can use crossovers with flat tracks, medium banking and high banked but even then they are different. He keeps comparing the game to arcade games ie. Speed Busters what would this imply on his and your points of view? The only sounds you hear are the engine and the ocassional banging of cars. Hilarious! All the racers I know have Opera playing on their entertainment centers in their race cars! What crap! And you endorse this review? Pretty sad bud! I could go on but I think you get the point. I don't dislike arcade games and have all the ones mentioned above but I certainly don't use them to reference sims. To use his frame of reference Speed Busters beats out GPL for the best sim! You may not like a game because of personal choice but to endorse a poorly reviewed piece of work is sad. Pete
Quoted text (13 lines)> He enjoys arcade racing games, so what? That doesn't mean that he > doesn't know what a real sim should be like. > Andre > > Here is this whiz bang reviewers bio! Look at his favourite > >racing games! :-) What a joke! Obviously, his ego matches his > >reviewing skills! Howie Mandel's brother, what a couple of clowns! > > Pete
Mike Grandy 04 Jan 2000#512153
Everyone is entitled to their opinion, but when writing reviews you should use facts and be unbiased. I personally find it very good and exiting in the multiplayer mode. I never was one for racing AI, it's much more fun racing real people.
Pete 04 Jan 2000#512154
Don, I'm not sure of this endor***t. I would rather take Ron, Andre and Howies(Bob) point of view into consideration first. After all they are in agreement on the piece and what would Dale know. Pete I have just one response to this. If NASCAR 3 and DTR is good enough for Dale Jr., Its good enough for me. He states it like the real thing and hardly different. Now for those reviewers that dont know Dale Jr. Earnhardt. He drives in NASCAR. But we are gonna make it better. Don Wilshe PCSD: What is your favorite game right now? Dale Earnhardt Jr: I would say it is a toss up between Nascar 3 and Dirt Track Racing. The makers of each game have done a fantastic job on reality. Very close to the real thing for me. What Papyrus and Sierra has done with their Nascar based games is incredible. I know that some of you were looking for more improvements from game to game. The thing is, I feel fortunate to play them each time I do. The add-ons found on the internet such as cars, tracks, and other utilities continue to make a great game even better. Myself and my fellow racers in Busch and Winston Cup become more fascinated each game. To drive the real thing and then play the computer game is hardly different. The only thing I believe we need is a force feedback seat! -- Donald Wilshe, Tampa, Florida 813 641-2572 Automotive Services: Marketing, Sales, ***, Support, E-Commerce Games-Advertising www.games-advertising.com Pro-Beta www.proapproved.com DASCAR Dirt Racing www.ivga.com WHRA Drag Racing www.whra.com Martel Brothers Performance www.martelbros.com You Can Sell Performance Parts Howtofofast www.howtogofast.com
Jalo 04 Jan 2000#512155
All of the courses are similiar compared to GPL, SCGT, and MGPRS2. He should have compared it to Nascar 3 (or even Nascar Revolution for that matter), at least the frame of reference would have been somewhat correct (American oval racing). I'm not sure why he compared it to Speed Busters.
I agree with Bob's review too. DTR bored me to tears after a mere thousand laps or so. The only exciting thing in single player was when new sponsors popped up. :-) A pity, considering Powerslide was so much fun and would have lasted much longer had it only had more tracks. I can't imagine anyone screaming for more tracks for DTR? /petern >Actually, I agree with Bob.... >>http://avault.com/reviews/review_temp.asp?game=dirttr >>Bob Mandel at AVAULT shits on yet another racing sim. SNIP
Ron Ayton 04 Jan 2000#512158
Don, I'm not sure of this endor***t. I would rather take Ron, Andre and Howies(Bob) point of view into consideration first. After all they are in agreement on the piece and what would Dale know. Pete ------------------------------- Point of view/consideration, being the key words here Pete... We are also entitled to our opinion, and that is all it is, "our opinion" Just because Dale reckons he likes it, does that make it accurate. ? Off hand, i can think of racing drivers giving similiar endorcements to every racing sim that has come on the market, does that make them feel real too ?? Just because we are not named, "Dale" does that mean we automatically do not know how a car handles and feels on a dirt track or a saloon car on a NASCAR oval, for that matter.? There are a lot of people in this news group, that DO have real life experience in DTR, NASCAR, Formula V, Formula Ford etc etc, so just because we don't all brag about it on this news group, don't think we are all as ignorant of a car's handling and physics as you obviously are. I stated my opinion on DTR, and i DO know how a DTR car feels... If you think the feeling and controllability of DTR is even close to a saloon car on a dirt oval surface, then you have never driven a car on a dirt surface, or driven a car full stop... The steering input is floaty and totally detached from what the car is actually doing on the screen. Mind you, i think DTR does do an admirable job of replicating a Hovercraft.. Cheers, Ron
Pete 04 Jan 2000#512159
And its obvious you don't know how to configure a pc to run a game properly if you compare this to a Hovercraft because I spent a fair bit of time in a Hovercraft and it handles nothing like this game. We have a huge number of real life racers included in our beta group and they don't have the same opinion as you do either but then again with all the Dirt Track racing you have done and your running of the Nascar Circuit does give you a huge advantage over Dale. Its nice see you can comment on my driving experience and you don't even know me. Could it be that your psychic ability exceeds your driving knowledge. If so it is limited on both counts! As far being ignorant you are an expert in that field so I will let you comment on your obvious talents. Good job arcade breath! Pete
Quoted text (37 lines)> Don, I'm not sure of this endor***t. I would rather take Ron, > Andre > and Howies(Bob) point of view into consideration first. After all they > are in > agreement on the piece and what would Dale know. > Pete > ------------------------------- > Point of view/consideration, being the key words here Pete... > We are also entitled to our opinion, and that is all it is, "our > opinion" > Just because Dale reckons he likes it, does that make it accurate. ? > Off hand, i can think of racing drivers giving similiar endorcements to > every racing sim that has come on the market, does that make them feel > real too ?? > Just because we are not named, "Dale" does that mean we automatically > do not know how a car handles and feels on a dirt track or a saloon car > on a NASCAR oval, for that matter.? > There are a lot of people in this news group, that DO have real life > experience in DTR, NASCAR, Formula V, Formula Ford etc etc, so just > because we don't all brag about it on this news group, don't think we > are all as ignorant of a car's handling and physics as you obviously > are. > I stated my opinion on DTR, and i DO know how a DTR car feels... > If you think the feeling and controllability of DTR is even close to a > saloon car on a dirt oval surface, then you have never driven a car on > a dirt surface, or driven a car full stop... > The steering input is floaty and totally detached from what the car is > actually doing on the screen. > Mind you, i think DTR does do an admirable job of replicating a > Hovercraft.. > Cheers, > Ron
Ron Ayton 04 Jan 2000#512160
As usual, it seems your lack of maturity and real world driving ability rules your mind... I didn't flame you, but it is obvious who is the little child here, Petey.. It's little boys like you that need to be told by their real world heros, how a car should drive etc.. Stick to your tiddlywink set Petey, it suits your skills more. Ron
Joe62 04 Jan 2000#512161
>The ovals in Nascar 3 are very different from each other. Same in DTR, IMO. Different driving techniques are needed to excel at most of them. Like the tracks, they look realistic. If someone has a personal preference for fantasy cars/tracks then fine, say so, but it's not a fair comment as written. Joe McGinn _________________________ GA-Sports Writer http://www.ga-sports.com/
Pete 04 Jan 2000#512162
Ah, the sim god has spoken! Let us all bow to your talents and knowledge oh great one! If calling me ignorant isn't flaming than I guess I need to come down to your level of maturity, but your lack of vocabulary makes it so hard. I guess all those years of racing around in saloons has made you drunk with power! Your diction is intoxicating but you know what happens when you get too drunk, you regurgitate it up for the rest of us to see. Your my hero by the way, I like to cheer for the misguided and uninformed lost souls that wonder the net professing to be an experts! I like tiddly winks by the way, reminds me of saloon cars! Bottoms Up Actually, I like tiddle winks!
I thought it was the first sensible rating of this much overrated game.
Did you create this game? A little sensitive maybe?
Quoted text (48 lines)> Its obvious in reading his reviews he knows little or nothing > about real life racing or what physics are involved in Dirt Track > Racing. After reading Dale Earnhardts interview on the game and > talking with dozens of real life racers it seems that he is using an > arcade mentality in his viewpoint. Does, this mean that because > you agree with him that this is your source of reference as well? > Or perhaps, you and Howie Mandrel are much more versed in > whats real and what isn't! > As far as graphics go its no NFS4, Dethkarz or Motorhead! > But we are talking about racing in dirt! Cars aren't spit and polish > show cars but maybe that has escaped you! > He says the courses are all similiar! Gee, he must have tried > just 1 of them then. Setups are different for me at every track > and you can use crossovers with flat tracks, medium banking and > high banked but even then they are different. > He keeps comparing the game to arcade games ie. Speed Busters > what would this imply on his and your points of view? > The only sounds you hear are the engine and the ocassional banging > of cars. Hilarious! All the racers I know have Opera playing on their > entertainment centers in their race cars! What crap! And you endorse > this review? Pretty sad bud! > I could go on but I think you get the point. I don't dislike arcade > games > and have all the ones mentioned above but I certainly don't use them > to reference sims. > To use his frame of reference Speed Busters beats out GPL for the > best sim! > You may not like a game because of personal choice but to endorse a > poorly reviewed piece of work is sad. > Pete > > He enjoys arcade racing games, so what? That doesn't mean that he > > doesn't know what a real sim should be like. > > Andre > > > Here is this whiz bang reviewers bio! Look at his favourite > > >racing games! :-) What a joke! Obviously, his ego matches his > > >reviewing skills! Howie Mandel's brother, what a couple of clowns! > > > Pete
Youre pretty stupid Ron.
Quoted text (30 lines)> As usual, it seems your lack of maturity and real world driving ability > rules your mind... > I didn't flame you, but it is obvious who is the little child here, > Petey.. > It's little boys like you that need to be told by their real world > heros, how a car should drive etc.. > Stick to your tiddlywink set Petey, it suits your skills more. > Ron > > And its obvious you don't know how to configure a pc > > to run a game properly if you compare this to a Hovercraft > > because I spent a fair bit of time in a Hovercraft and it handles > > nothing like this game. > > We have a huge number of real life racers included in > > our beta group and they don't have the same opinion as > > you do either but then again with all the Dirt Track racing > > you have done and your running of the Nascar Circuit does > > give you a huge advantage over Dale. Its nice see you can > > comment on my driving experience and you don't even know me. > > Could it be that your psychic ability exceeds your driving > > knowledge. If so it is limited on both counts! > > As far being ignorant you are an expert in that field so I will > > let you comment on your obvious talents. > > Good job arcade breath! > > Pete
Ron Ayton 04 Jan 2000#512166
Your right Ronnie, Having a personal opinion about something i like or dislike is totally stupid, how foolish of me..!! Cheers, Ron
Ron Ayton 04 Jan 2000#512167
Little Petey, I should never have replied to your childish ramblings in the first place, as it has only brought me down to your weener level.. Have a nice day... Ron
Quoted text (10 lines)> Ah, the sim god has spoken! Let us all bow to your talents > and knowledge oh great one! > If calling me ignorant isn't flaming than I guess I need to come > down to your level of maturity, but your lack of vocabulary makes > it so hard. I guess all those years of racing around in saloons has > made you drunk with power! Your diction is intoxicating but you > know what happens when you get too drunk, you regurgitate it up > for the rest of us to see. > Your my hero by the way, I like to cheer for the misguided and > uninformed lost souls that wonder the net professing to be an
experts!
Quoted text (8 lines)> I like tiddly winks by the way, reminds me of saloon cars! > Bottoms Up > Actually, I like tiddle winks! > > As usual, it seems your lack of maturity and real world driving
ability
Quoted text (8 lines)> > rules your mind... > > I didn't flame you, but it is obvious who is the little child here, > > Petey.. > > It's little boys like you that need to be told by their real world > > heros, how a car should drive etc.. > > Stick to your tiddlywink set Petey, it suits your skills more. > > Ron
Seems to me you were already there. Michael K. Grandy Sr Proud Member of Precision Racing Professional Internet Race Team Officially sponsored by ECCI "ECCI - A proud sponsor of the 1998 NROS finals" The CDS4000 was designed for stock car racing... and it delivers Member of OSCAR Freedom Cup Series Member of Nass99 Pro Online Series Nas99 Pro is sponsored by 4CDs.com Member of the National Invitational Series The NIS is sponsored by Thomas Enterprises Little Petey, I should never have replied to your childish ramblings in the first place, as it has only brought me down to your weener level.. Have a nice day... Ron
Quoted text (10 lines) > Ah, the sim god has spoken! Let us all bow to your talents > and knowledge oh great one! > If calling me ignorant isn't flaming than I guess I need to come > down to your level of maturity, but your lack of vocabulary makes > it so hard. I guess all those years of racing around in saloons has > made you drunk with power! Your diction is intoxicating but you > know what happens when you get too drunk, you regurgitate it up > for the rest of us to see. > Your my hero by the way, I like to cheer for the misguided and > uninformed lost souls that wonder the net professing to be an
experts!
Quoted text (8 lines) > I like tiddly winks by the way, reminds me of saloon cars! > > Bottoms Up > > Actually, I like tiddle winks! > > As usual, it seems your lack of maturity and real world driving
ability
Quoted text (13 lines) > > rules your mind... > > I didn't flame you, but it is obvious who is the little child here, > > Petey.. > > It's little boys like you that need to be told by their real world > > heros, how a car should drive etc.. > > Stick to your tiddlywink set Petey, it suits your skills more. > > > > Ron > > > > > >
Mitch_A 04 Jan 2000#512169
I guess I'm stupid also Ron A! While DTR was kinda fun the first day or two the fun quickly vanished. Almost as fast as this thread degenerated into a flame fest :0). This game can hardly be called a Sim! But as you have said numerous times this is only my opinion (like ***s, we all have one, and it don't stink!). BTW I still can't stand F2 or F3 :-) Couldn't agree with ya completely could I? Mitch Alatorre
Quoted text (8 lines)> > Youre pretty stupid Ron. > Your right Ronnie, > Having a personal opinion about something i like or dislike is totally > stupid, how foolish of me..!! > Cheers, > Ron
Huh 04 Jan 2000#512170
>> http://avault.com/reviews/review_temp.asp?game=dirttr >> Bob Mandel at AVAULT shits on yet another racing sim. >> DTR = 2 1/2 stars. >I thought it was the first sensible rating of this much overrated game. Here are a few other 2 1/2 star titles from AVAULT. Do you REALLY think it belongs in this crowd? http://avault.com/reviews/index.asp?index=reviews_2hstars Deer Hunter II - WizardWorks Dragon Dice - Interplay Flesh Feast - SegaSoft Fox Sports Soccer '99 Gooch Grundy's X-Decathlon Power F1 - Eidos Interactive Robo Rumble - Interactive Magic Tennis Elbow - GOTO Software Nitro Racers - 3DO
Donny Nelms 04 Jan 2000#512171
-- Unfortunately, the courses seem all too similar as you drive on them; I am sorely tempted to say, "If you've seen one looped dirt track, you've seen 'em all."" Well even thought Bristol Motor speedway isnt in DTR the World of Outlaws and Have a Tampa Late models are gonna be there when the Worlds greatest dirt races will be at the WORLD FASTEST HALFMILE! Now that is one track ya havent seen yet and it will be the Greatest Show on Earth for Dirt races! BULLBAG on WON Member of Milenio Motorsports--"Warpin to the Future,Not Crying about the Past" Member of International Brotherhood Of Electrical Workers LU#934 Union Electricians Do "IT" Without Shorts!
Pete 05 Jan 2000#512395
How thoughtful of you! Your timing and insight are truly remarkable. It has been a pleasure communicating with you at such a profound level. Hopefully, you can still find time to hover around those saloons and share your fanciful repartee afterwards! Have a nice day as well playing with your little "Petey"! Pete
Pete 05 Jan 2000#512396
Todd, gosh I didn't think people would notice! I'm such a warm, compassionate kind of guy! :-) Pete
Ron Ayton 05 Jan 2000#512397
Where does that leave you then Mike ? I tried to hold a sensible discussion with you Mike, in relation to DTR but all you can say in response is "Seems to me you were already there." Seems to me i have company then....!! Seems to me you were already there.
Ron Ayton 05 Jan 2000#512398
LOL, we could never have that Mitch.. :)) Cheers, Ron PS.. about time you showed fo for a league bash again, i need to kick some RedNeck ***in Roundy Roundy racin' :)) > I guess I'm stupid also Ron A! While DTR was kinda fun the first day or two > the fun quickly vanished. Almost as fast as this thread degenerated into a > flame fest :0). This game can hardly be called a Sim! But as you have said > numerous times this is only my opinion (like ***s, we all have one, and > it don't stink!). BTW I still can't stand F2 or F3 :-) Couldn't agree with
Quoted text (13 lines)> ya completely could I? > Mitch Alatorre > > > Youre pretty stupid Ron. > > Your right Ronnie, > > Having a personal opinion about something i like or dislike is
totally > > stupid, how foolish of me..!! > > Cheers, > > Ron
Pat Dotson 05 Jan 2000#512399
None of you guys are criticizing the game/sim. You are criticizing the form of racing, which is kind of lame. DTR deserves more than 2.5 stars. -- Pat Dotson > > Bob Mandel at AVAULT shits on yet another racing sim. > > DTR = 2 1/2 stars. > -- > Unfortunately, the courses seem all too similar as you drive on > them; I am sorely tempted to say, "If you've seen one looped dirt > track, you've seen 'em all."" > Well even thought Bristol Motor speedway isnt in DTR the World of Outlaws > and Have a Tampa Late models are gonna be there when the Worlds greatest > dirt races will be at the WORLD FASTEST HALFMILE! > Now that is one track ya havent seen yet and it will be the Greatest Show on > Earth for Dirt races! > BULLBAG on WON > Member of Milenio Motorsports--"Warpin to the Future,Not Crying about the > Past" > Member of International Brotherhood Of Electrical Workers LU#934 > Union Electricians Do "IT" Without Shorts!
<SNIP> IMHO the graphics of DTR look dull. No nice textures, no scenery. But this is all personal taste, and graphics are not the most important thing in a race sim. I'm glad you like it Pete, really. But for me, and my name is not Dale so I must know nothing about racing sims, the tracks are very similar. There are little differences, but all in all, the tracks are very short ovals. Some have high bankings, some have medium bankings, but after I drove on a couple of tracks, the game became boring to me. I still play GPL every single day for more than a year now, and DTR became boring after a couple of hours. Just to be clear: If you like DTR, that's great, keep on playing and have fun, that's all what computer games are about! But the topic here was Bob's review. Reviews are nothing more than opinions. How you find the graphics, the sound and the gameplay, it's all personal taste. Bob's review got trashed. I know how cars handle, I know the difference between a good sim and a good arcade racer, and even if Bob's knowledge of car physics is very limited, his opinion about DTR is exactly the same as mine. Read his review again. He only compares the look of the cars with Speedbusters. The cars in DTR look very dull, with very little texturing. The cars in Speedbusters look beautiful, with great attention paid to car details. He isn't saying that DTR plays like Speedbusters, nor that DTR should have the same cars like Speedbusters. He was just talking about graphic quality, taking Speedbusters as an example of how well computer graphics can be done these days. You're right Pete, all I need to hear are engine sounds and the banging of cars. But what do you think of the quality of the engine sounds? When you floor the throttle, does the engine noise sound real to you? Great, finally we can agree on something here :) (if not, please listen to a real engine to know how an engine should sound.) You're right ofcourse, sims shouldn't be compared to arcade games when it concerns physics. But you can compare graphic quality. And that's all Bob did in his review. I hope you will have realised in the meantime that this statement is nonsence. If you don't agree with a review, and call the review poorly because of that.... that's poor. Andre
Quoted text (18 lines)> Pete >> He enjoys arcade racing games, so what? That doesn't mean that he >> doesn't know what a real sim should be like. >> Andre >> > Here is this whiz bang reviewers bio! Look at his favourite >> >racing games! :-) What a joke! Obviously, his ego matches his >> >reviewing skills! Howie Mandel's brother, what a couple of clowns! >> > Pete
Now that's exactly what i thought when I read the review. I thought I was the only one who didn't like DTR. Andre
This is no fair comparison ofcourse. Time of release is very important for a game. If DTR came out five years ago, it would have got 5 starts immediately, because for that time it would have been the best racing game ever. Comparing it with the scores of games from a completely different genre doesn't make sense. I hate those boring hunting games, but Deer Hunter 2 is one of the best hunting games for people who like these games. In the hunting games genre. 2.5 stars is very fair for Deer Hunter 2. Of the games you mention, only Power F1 is in the racing genre. It's a stupid racing game, but when it was released, the graphics were quite spectaculair, and for an arcade racer, it was not that bad. If PowerF1 would have been released at the same time as DTR, PowerF1 wouldn't have got 2.5 stars, maybe 1. Andre
Sensible conversation with me? I thought you were conversing with a guy named Pete. Lost me pal, maybe you better have another one. Michael K. Grandy Sr Proud Member of Precision Racing Professional Internet Race Team Officially sponsored by ECCI "ECCI - A proud sponsor of the 1998 NROS finals" The CDS4000 was designed for stock car racing... and it delivers Member of OSCAR Freedom Cup Series Member of Nass99 Pro Online Series Nas99 Pro is sponsored by 4CDs.com Member of the National Invitational Series The NIS is sponsored by Thomas Enterprises Where does that leave you then Mike ? I tried to hold a sensible discussion with you Mike, in relation to DTR but all you can say in response is "Seems to me you were already there." Seems to me i have company then....!! Seems to me you were already there.
Andre, The problem isn't that the guy likes Dethkarz. It's the fact that he has "spare time" to spend "enjoying his family" and has "published 5 books". No simmer worth the name has time for such frivolities. :) Regards, Gordon
Quoted text (60 lines)> He enjoys arcade racing games, so what? That doesn't mean that he > doesn't know what a real sim should be like. > Andre > > Here is this whiz bang reviewers bio! Look at his favourite > >racing games! :-) What a joke! Obviously, his ego matches his > >reviewing skills! Howie Mandel's brother, what a couple of clowns! > > Pete > >CT > >Staff Writer > >Daily tasks: > >Playing Games, Evaluating Games, Being a Gamester > >Age: > >3 > >Acts: > >0 > >Location: > >Portland, Oregon > >First game: > >My own version of Tic-Tac-Toe, which could beat or tie any human using 10 > >lines of code > >Likes: > >arcade shooters, pinball, arcade racing, and puzzle games (both > >action-puzzle and adventure-puzzle varieties) > >Current Faves: > >Dethkarz, Motorhead, Recoil, Descent 3, Slave Zero, Nerf ArenaBlast > >Interested to see: > >MDK2 > >Fondest *** Memories: > >Writing over 20 of my own computer games > >Spare Time: > >Enjoying my family > >Other: > >Chairing a college department, teaching, having five books published > >Cool: > >I love undersea and pirate adventure. > >Hates: > >Gratuitous sex and *** > >System Specs: > >a 400 megahertz Pentium II with 128 megs of RAM, a 16.8 gigabyte hard
drive, > >a DVD drive, a 21-inch Sony Trinitron monitor, a Xitel Platinum Storm sound
Quoted text (100 lines)> >card, a Riva TNT 2D/3D video card, and a Voodoo2 accelerator card. > >Pseudo .plan: > >An endless stream of *** articles > >Copyright 1995-2000 [ NewWorld.com, Inc ] All Rights Reserved > >> http://avault.com/reviews/review_temp.asp?game=dirttr > >> Bob Mandel at AVAULT shits on yet another racing sim. > >> DTR = 2 1/2 stars. > >> Heres some snippets: > >> "This is the only offering so far to replicate a popular, yet > >> not widely known, form of racing in the U.S., with over 700 tracks > >> across the country .." > >> Bob-ster, uhhh.. how in the hell can real-life dirt racing be > >> 'popular', yet 'not widely known'. > >> Huh? Help us out with this.. > >> "Unfortunately, the courses seem all too similar as you drive on > >> them; I am sorely tempted to say, "If you've seen one looped dirt > >> track, you've seen 'em all."" > >> So I guess it really comes as a shock to this weenie that the most > >> popular forms of racing in the US of F***ING A are done on > >> OVALS!! > >> Is this guy fer real? > >> "Additionally, the vehicle models are all fictional--there are no > >> licensed brands--and they show none of the creative inspiration > >> demonstrated in other computer-created automobiles, such as > >> those in Ubi Soft's Speed Busters." > >> Well, now there's something to ponder. Bob 'The Intimidator' > >> Mandel sez that DTR would be better if it used SPEED BUSTERS > >> style cars!! > >> I'm gasping for breath here, folks .. > >> "From an aesthetic standpoint, the visuals are downright unsightly." > >> YAH, Bobby, I give the graphics maybe 9 out of 10 stars. > >> They suck so bad. Too damned realistic. I want chrome, baby!! > >> And some of those pink Speed Busters cars would ROOL!! > >> sp33d bust3rs ownz j00.. > >> "The play screen is quite easy to read and nicely laid out. I > >> especially appreciate the presence of a standard rear view mirror, > >> which is often oddly missing in racing titles." > >> BWAHAHAHA... PLAY SCREEN.. ??? > >> I'm losing control here. > >> "One of the main problems is boredom; driving around an oval track > >> 12 times with nothing outside worth looking at can get mighty > >> tedious, especially if you are far in the lead or way behind." > >> And we can guess which end of the line you were on, Bob. > >> Yah, the scenery suX0rs, dud3. Maybe they coulda, shoulda had > >> these babies at that Monaco track. There's lotsa scenery there, > >> whooo boy. And those french babes make my pecker stiff > >> I GA-RON-TEE.. > >> Hey, they coulda had a Monaco.Mudslide and then it woulda > >> worked. Lousy Aussie developer missed a big chance here. > >> "The speed of the racing is considerably slower than I am used to, > >> due in large part to the unpaved road surface;" > >> Yah, since you have never driven a real CAR from a real PLAY SCREEN, > >> I think we can understand what you're saying here. > >> "While racing, the sounds of the engine and the occasional collision > >> are pretty much all you hear." > >> SHIT! I wanted Alyssa Milano dripping those honey-drop words of > >> love on.. in my err.. ear.. while I was whuppin' up on the wimpy AI. > >> Those lamers at Ratbag, WTF were they thinking.. > >> Whew.. > >> Hey y'all, just go read it for yourself. This clueless reviewer > >> has done this before with several other sims. He is a detriment > >> to our hobby, in my opinion. Time for a few ***-grams (again). > >> I'm outta here.
> I have just one response to this. If NASCAR 3 and DTR is good > enough for Dale Jr., Its good enough for me. He states it like the > real thing and hardly different. Now for those reviewers that dont > know > Dale Jr. Earnhardt. He drives in NASCAR. But we are gonna make > it better. We had a few F1 drivers recommend F1 "games". That doesn't mean anything, just that some money changed hands for the endorsment, maybe... l8er ronny
LOL :))) Andre
Quoted text (16 lines)>Andre, >The problem isn't that the guy likes Dethkarz. It's the fact that he has >"spare time" to spend "enjoying his family" and has "published 5 books". No >simmer worth the name has time for such frivolities. :) >Regards, >Gordon >> He enjoys arcade racing games, so what? That doesn't mean that he >> doesn't know what a real sim should be like. >> Andre
Pete 05 Jan 2000#512407
Andre, I agree on all counts and in my personal reply to Bob Mandel I have expressed this very opinion. But he indicated that it was one of his most important criteria in evaluating a game. We also have to remember that in order to create the ambiance of dirt racing everything at the track is covered in dirt and dust. We also have to take frame rates and online play into account for playability reasons. We have a dozen people in our group that race these cars besides Dale and they have had very positive feelings as to the handling and feel of the game. So maybe having one person say that they like it doesn't mean much but taken in context with many of the racers in our group, yes it does mean something. But then again thats their choice. The tracks make look similiar to you and others but they certainly don't drive the same. I have had to do entirely different setups for almost every track in order to run the best numbers and I have found that each track does have a personality of its own. As far as comparing to GPL I don't. It has a feel and look of its own which make both products unique. As far as Bob's review, I would value your opinion more than his because of his preference for arcade type games. Not that its bad but having a bias towards something other than what you are evaluating may not let the reviewer give the most objective view. Again, two different genres with emphasis on different aspects of game play. His choice should have been within the same area, then it would be more applicable. If you go for pretty graphics, physics, AI and frame rate will suffer. I would rather have graphics be downplayed. Again, as I'm sure you know, at a dirt race there is dirt and dust everywhere so everything is muted and drab looking. There are two points to the quality of sounds, one of which I have addressed before but maybe you missed. First in the Alpha and Beta of this game the sounds were nothing like the final release. The sounds you hear where taken from a real race car! But do to compression and encryption routines that were put into the gold copy it dramatically altered the sounds. That is why Barry Clay went to work with myself trying to alter the sounds in the game to compensate for the changes. It proved to be very time consuming in finding ways to compensate. Eventually, Barrys hard work paid off and the sound patch turned out reasonably well on most systems. RatBag lended much assistance in order to try and correct things. But something that was recently discovered by David Harrison may explain why even the sound patch didn't sound correct on some systems and hopefully I will have more to report on that in a few days. As far as knowing what a real engine sounds like I have one in my garage that I can listen to any time I want. It managed to get 600hp on the dyno out of a 400 cubic inch small block, 9 to 1 single 4 barrel engine. Oh, and I must mention its an AMC. Well, I think he should be comparing them first to the genre they represent and then to other sims. Maybe, not! He indicated to me the only sim he likes is EA's SBK. That may be correct but having an Apple grower here in Ontario reviewing this years Florida Orange crop isn't correct either! Pete
Pete 05 Jan 2000#512408
There is a difference in the group that we are associated with! They are playing the games they endorse and are every bit as hard core a sim racer as anyone on here. And are providing their expertice to the final product. Pete
Quoted text (13 lines)> > I have just one response to this. If NASCAR 3 and DTR is good > > enough for Dale Jr., Its good enough for me. He states it like the > > real thing and hardly different. Now for those reviewers that dont > > know > > Dale Jr. Earnhardt. He drives in NASCAR. But we are gonna make > > it better. > We had a few F1 drivers recommend F1 "games". That doesn't mean > anything, > just that some money changed hands for the endorsment, maybe... > l8er > ronny
Pat Dotson 05 Jan 2000#512409
Hmm, I mean that the criticism is lame, not the form of racing :) I go to sprint car races almost exclusively. -- PD > None of you guys are criticizing the game/sim. You > are criticizing the form of racing, which is kind of > lame. > DTR deserves more than 2.5 stars. > -- > Pat Dotson
: Andre, : The problem isn't that the guy likes Dethkarz. It's the fact that he has : "spare time" to spend "enjoying his family" and has "published 5 books". No : simmer worth the name has time for such frivolities. :) : Regards, : Gordon That's the dilemma I face. I wonder sometimes how others find the time to get proficient at, for example, GPL. People are clamouring for new tracks to run in their Ferraris, yet I don't have the time to master the original ones which shipped with the game. As it is, I only run the 'Ring (awesome), Spa and Mosport (my old "home" track) seriously. I can't imagine finding the time to dabble with ovals, converted ICR2 tracks etc. In the final push towards finishing my thesis, GP2 disappeared from my HD, which was the first time since I bought it in '96. Every other game also disappeared. As I contemplate the post-doc I wil start next month, I wonder when I will find time to maintain my GPL skills (such that they are). One secret wish is that the S3 mobile chip has a decent OpenGL ICD - I could rationalise the purchase of a new notebook to replace my current one and make use of my train ride. This reviewer obviously manages to fit in time for ***. How do others do it? Do you have other hobbies, or is GPL your focus? I try to maintain a fairly serious level of training for my skiing and cycling racing, but must sheepishly admit that there are many days I would rather spend my free hour lapping Spa than heading out for a 40km training ride in the pissing rain. Damn you Papyrus. Stephen
I agree that framerate is more important than graphics. But it would have been nice if DTR had better graphics and textures, with the option of turning them off if a pc can't handle it, just like every single graphic option in GPL can be turned on or off. I agree that DTR is the best dirt track racing sim. But driving the car just doesn't feel real to me, also due to the bad engine sound. Most reviews I read were praising DTR as being a superb racing game. I felt otherwise, and was pleased to read a review that stated my opinion about DTR. The main problem I have with the driving model is lack of feeling the ground. Someone said the cars drive like hovercrafts. I never drove a hovercraft, but I think it's a nice description for the driving model, the cars seem to float above the ground. I admit that I didn't spent too much time on DTR to be able to tell the differences between all the tracks. I'm sure if you spend enough time driving on them, subtle differences can be noticed. Even in GPL, which I play now for more than a year, I still notice slight elevations on tracks which I drove hundreds of times before! To be able to judge if he can write a good review of a real sim, I'm curious if he ever wrote a review of GPL. If he wrote that GPL is impossible to drive, too hard etc., I fully agree with you. As I said, it would have been nice if better textures were available, and there would have been an option to turn them off if it would affect physics on a slower pc. Great that patches for the sound are coming out, i didn't expect otherwise, but I think it was a very bad think that the original dire engine sound was put in the gold version of DTR. A good engine sound is VERY important for a driving sim. You said he compared DTR with Speedbusters, that was not correct, he was only talking about graphic quality. Well, I think we have argued enough about Bob's review now. Back to racing! You DTR, me GPL, and we're both happy :) Andre
I spend allmost 2-3 hours a day on GPL, but only one or two hours a day I'm really racing. The rest of the time I spend on RAS, all other GPL newsgroups and websites. I never sleep more than 4-5 hours a night so I got some spare time over :) Since GPL there have been few games that drew my attention away, and if they did, it was only for a short time. Some games that I really liked are RC2000, Swat3, Baldur's gate, Outcast and The Nomad Soul. Spent quite some time on these games as well. Sometimes it really is a problem to combine my social life with my hobby :) Andre
Quoted text (32 lines)>: Andre, >: The problem isn't that the guy likes Dethkarz. It's the fact that he has >: "spare time" to spend "enjoying his family" and has "published 5 books". No >: simmer worth the name has time for such frivolities. :) >: Regards, >: Gordon >That's the dilemma I face. I wonder sometimes how others find the time to >get proficient at, for example, GPL. People are clamouring for new tracks >to run in their Ferraris, yet I don't have the time to master the original >ones which shipped with the game. As it is, I only run the 'Ring >(awesome), Spa and Mosport (my old "home" track) seriously. I can't >imagine finding the time to dabble with ovals, converted ICR2 tracks etc. >In the final push towards finishing my thesis, GP2 disappeared from my HD, >which was the first time since I bought it in '96. Every other game also >disappeared. As I contemplate the post-doc I wil start next month, I >wonder when I will find time to maintain my GPL skills (such that they >are). One secret wish is that the S3 mobile chip has a decent OpenGL >ICD - I could rationalise the purchase of a new notebook to replace my >current one and make use of my train ride. >This reviewer obviously manages to fit in time for ***. How do others >do it? Do you have other hobbies, or is GPL your focus? I try to >maintain a fairly serious level of training for my skiing and cycling >racing, but must sheepishly admit that there are many days I would rather >spend my free hour lapping Spa than heading out for a 40km training ride >in the pissing rain. Damn you Papyrus. >Stephen

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy