I have run the demo for some time,and haven't been able to
understand if there's a speedometer in any of the cars,and
in the cars which it is.,and if there is one at all?
The only time I seem to have found any legible info about
speed is when pressing F10......
The dials on the dashboard are too blurry to read even at 1024X768,
and the readme file didn't say anything about it ,as far as I could see.
The big thing in the middle ought to be the RPM.meter,as far as I have
understood,and there's oil pressure and something else...but speed?
Thanks,
Robert S?derberg
If replying by mail,remove the word INGENSPAM from the adress.
Gauges, field of view and sense of speed in GPL
A demo player asked how to read speed in GPL. Others explained that 1967 F1 cars had no speedometer and that drivers rely on the rev counter, and pointed to replacement gauge and cockpit add-ons. The discussion turned to whether GPL's field of view and perspective make speed hard to judge.
Automated summary.
Since i can't seem to find the url directly to the gauge site you can get it
at
http://simracing.com/alison/gpl/
Go to the GPL help section and there is a gauge page. While your'e there
read everything.
John Moore
Quoted text (14 lines)
> I have run the demo for some time,and haven't been able to > understand if there's a speedometer in any of the cars,and > in the cars which it is.,and if there is one at all? > The only time I seem to have found any legible info about > speed is when pressing F10...... > The dials on the dashboard are too blurry to read even at 1024X768, > and the readme file didn't say anything about it ,as far as I could see. > The big thing in the middle ought to be the RPM.meter,as far as I have > understood,and there's oil pressure and something else...but speed? > Thanks, > Robert S?derberg > If replying by mail,remove the word INGENSPAM from the adress.Formula One cars in 1967 didn't have speedometers. The big one is the rev
counter. There used to be an explanation of the gauges on Alison Hines
'Eagle Woman site; maybe somebody knows where its gone. For better gauges
and***pits go to
[link lost in import] . With these you get a proper red line which
helps stop over-revving the engine, and the***pits look great.
Steve
Quoted text (14 lines)
>I have run the demo for some time,and haven't been able to >understand if there's a speedometer in any of the cars,and >in the cars which it is.,and if there is one at all? >The only time I seem to have found any legible info about >speed is when pressing F10...... >The dials on the dashboard are too blurry to read even at 1024X768, >and the readme file didn't say anything about it ,as far as I could see. >The big thing in the middle ought to be the RPM.meter,as far as I have >understood,and there's oil pressure and something else...but speed? >Thanks, >Robert S?derberg >If replying by mail,remove the word INGENSPAM from the adress.Most racing cars did not (and maybe still don't) have speedometers. RPM was
certainly more important to observe but a driver would know how fast he was
travelling in top for the particular gear ratio used on a partivular circuit
(x mph per 1000rpm at drive shaft).
I use this method in a pre-metric car I drive....I've marked the tacho at
points corresponding to 60, 80, 100 and 110 kph in top gear. With the tacho
checked for accuracy this is an extremely effective method of not being
picked up by the laser speed camera.
-----------== Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News ==----------
http://www.newsfeeds.com The Largest Usenet Servers in the World!
------== Over 73,000 Newsgroups - Including Dedicated Binaries Servers ==-----
Quoted text (14 lines)
> I have run the demo for some time,and haven't been able to > understand if there's a speedometer in any of the cars,and > in the cars which it is.,and if there is one at all? > The only time I seem to have found any legible info about > speed is when pressing F10...... > The dials on the dashboard are too blurry to read even at 1024X768, > and the readme file didn't say anything about it ,as far as I could see. > The big thing in the middle ought to be the RPM.meter,as far as I have > understood,and there's oil pressure and something else...but speed? > Thanks, > Robert S?derberg > If replying by mail,remove the word INGENSPAM from the adress.On 8 Dec 1999 02:50:12 GMT, "Obiwan Benkenobi"
<snip>
There is no speedometer, because it is not needed. In a racing car it
is laptime that is important, not vehicle speed at any particular
point on the track. Just about all racing cars have a revcounter and
not a speedometer.
Plus you can always tell if your going faster/slower by looking at
what revs you're pulling in a particular gear at a particular point on
a circuit.
Andy
_____________________________________________
Andy Cunningham
Stockholm, Sweden
ICQ: 11355339
: Plus you can always tell if your going faster/slower by looking at
: what revs you're pulling in a particular gear at a particular point on
: a circuit.
Which works really well with the original GPL gauges. "Lessee, I'm taking
Masta at about 3 blobby, blurry whatsits below vertical...". I find I
treat the rev counter as just another warning gauge. It gives me shift
points, and nothing else. For cornering speed, I rely on other sensory
inputs, such as engine note and the peripheral vision of scenery flying
past. I'm too busy concentrating on the driving on corner entry to
actually study the crappy little rev counter, and fine my ears can pick up
fairly subtle differences in revs strictly from the sound frequency.
As for examining replays from the chase view to see exactly what revs I'm
pulling, well... that would be like cheating! No telemetry in the good
ol' days. For me it's strictly seat of the pants together with overall
laptimes.
Stephen
Right--you won't find any speedo's (or speedometers) in the cars.
Inauthentic. You can find superb new***pits (courtesy of Andrew Olley),
however, here:
[link lost in import]
DK
Quoted text (14 lines)
> I have run the demo for some time,and haven't been able to > understand if there's a speedometer in any of the cars,and > in the cars which it is.,and if there is one at all? > The only time I seem to have found any legible info about > speed is when pressing F10...... > The dials on the dashboard are too blurry to read even at 1024X768, > and the readme file didn't say anything about it ,as far as I could see. > The big thing in the middle ought to be the RPM.meter,as far as I have > understood,and there's oil pressure and something else...but speed? > Thanks, > Robert S?derberg > If replying by mail,remove the word INGENSPAM from the adress.If it weren't for speedlimits, there would be no need for speedometers
whatsoever. I take them off all my motorcycles... I hate them.
speedracer
Quoted text (19 lines)
> : Plus you can always tell if your going faster/slower by looking at > : what revs you're pulling in a particular gear at a particular point on > : a circuit. > Which works really well with the original GPL gauges. "Lessee, I'm taking > Masta at about 3 blobby, blurry whatsits below vertical...". I find I > treat the rev counter as just another warning gauge. It gives me shift > points, and nothing else. For cornering speed, I rely on other sensory > inputs, such as engine note and the peripheral vision of scenery flying > past. I'm too busy concentrating on the driving on corner entry to > actually study the crappy little rev counter, and fine my ears can pick up > fairly subtle differences in revs strictly from the sound frequency. > As for examining replays from the chase view to see exactly what revs I'm > pulling, well... that would be like cheating! No telemetry in the good > ol' days. For me it's strictly seat of the pants together with overall > laptimes. > StephenIf your in***pit view and have a close look, there are little dials that
move, the biggest one should habve a white and red marker, the white is the
speed and the red is revs or something, I'm not suer what the otehrs are,
maybe fuel or something, watch closely to se them move.
The problem is that, like you said, they are too blurry toread, they do tell
you stuff, but they are too blurry to know what they actally read!!??!
Quoted text (14 lines)
> I have run the demo for some time,and haven't been able to > understand if there's a speedometer in any of the cars,and > in the cars which it is.,and if there is one at all? > The only time I seem to have found any legible info about > speed is when pressing F10...... > The dials on the dashboard are too blurry to read even at 1024X768, > and the readme file didn't say anything about it ,as far as I could see. > The big thing in the middle ought to be the RPM.meter,as far as I have > understood,and there's oil pressure and something else...but speed? > Thanks, > Robert S?derberg > If replying by mail,remove the word INGENSPAM from the adress.<snip>
</snip>
Ok, well this is where I gotta ***in, another fault I find in GPL (I seem
to be the only one finding them for some reason) is that you simply cannot
tell your speed, the feel of speed is dreadful, you can only tell at high
speeds and thats because your car goes mad, not becasue of what you can see
on screen.
From low to mid speed and revs you can see or feel no difference because of
the totally ***sounds and no clue from the surroundings as they moev in a
similar fasion at any lowish to high speed.
> Ok, well this is where I gotta ***in, another fault I find in GPL (I seem
> to be the only one finding them for some reason) is that you simply cannot
> tell your speed, the feel of speed is dreadful, you can only tell at high
> speeds and thats because your car goes mad, not becasue of what you can see
> on screen.
GPL has quite a narrow field of view, which makes it harder to judge
speed. The problem is that if they had used a wider field of view (as
in many other games on the arcade end of the scale) all objects would
appear smaller on screen, so what you win in speed perception you
lose in image detail.
Still, I would love an option to GPL letting you adjust the field of
view. Since all drawn objects are 3D, it should be quite easy to add,
and with a graphics card allowing a really high resolution, the loss
of detail is no big problem.
Think about GPL in 1900x1400 pixels on a 24" monitor with the field
of view set to something close to 180 degrees and your nose not to
far away... That would give enough of speed perception making a seat
belt mandatory :-)
_
Mats Lofkvist
...ah - like the FOV thing in Quake - brilliant idea. Lobby
your local Papyrus...
Drive a RX-7, one of the few cars on the road that actually have the tach in the middle as the
main gauges. The useless gauge like the speedo is the small one on the side....
As shania put it, "If you wanna win it, there is no speed limit. You just go faster faster, rev it
up till the god darn engine goes...."
> GPL has quite a narrow field of view, which makes it harder to judge
> speed.
On the contrary, GPL has a WIDER field of view than the natural
perspective! This makes objects look smaller and corners farther away
than they really are. I guess it's done for practical reasons. It allows
you to look deeper into corners, as you would in real life. The
trade-off is it distorts the sense of speed.
I too would like a field-of-view button, but only to narrow it to a
natural perspective.
--
Bye,
Leo
> Formula One cars in 1967 didn't have speedometers. The big one is the rev
[snip]
Racing cars don't have speedos, full stop. How fast are you going?
7500 rpm in third is all you need to know...
The big one in the middle should *always* be the rev counter.
Jonny
Some race cars may have one actually. I saw in an incar shot of a BTCC car
that it had a small digital one, probably because of the pitlane speed
limit.
-Bj?rn
2
03...
> > Formula One cars in 1967 didn't have speedometers. The big one is the rev
Quoted text (8 lines)
> [snip] > Racing cars don't have speedos, full stop. How fast are you going? > 7500 rpm in third is all you need to know... > The big one in the middle should *always* be the rev counter. > JonnyYou might want to check these gauges(screenshots also in pages), if
accuracy/readability is your priority. :)
http://www.kolumbus.fi/ken.lie/gplpages/gauges.html
I was recently watching some Handi-cam in car video a friend did while driving
his car along a twisty mountain road. It was interesting to see that whenever
he used the zoom function there was a cooresponding loss in the sense of speed
as well as a loss in the ability to sense where you where laterally on the
road. When zoomed it reminded me a lot of the incar gpl view. I find the f12
rollbar view far superior to the default***pit view, but I hate not having my
analog tack and shift lever. I agree that being able to "tune" your driving
perspective would be great, and not unrealistic, as it's a bit unrealistic as
it is now.
--
Don Scurlock
Vancouver,B.C.
Err.. excuse me but I think you may need to review your research material,
if you have any.
Steve
Quoted text (9 lines)
>> Formula One cars in 1967 didn't have speedometers. The big one is the rev >[snip] >Racing cars don't have speedos, full stop. How fast are you going? >7500 rpm in third is all you need to know... >The big one in the middle should *always* be the rev counter. >JonnyIn the initial post I said that in 1967 Formula One cars did not have
speedometers. So what the hell is wrong with that. I did not say that ALL
formula cars of any period did not have speedometers, simply because I did
not want to be so pedantic. I have not gone into it, but I would hazard a
guess that some eccentric manufacturer somewhere since 1950 has used an
analogue speedo. Not to mention that the modern F1 car has telemetry that
CAN tell you the speed. But to say that racing cars do not have speedos is
clearly absurd. I am willing to bet that in the last six weeks somewhere in
the world a car has won a race with a working speedometer. The Jaguar 'C'
Type had one, the Ferrari 250 SWB had one, the McLaren F1 has one, the
Volkswagen Golf has one. I does not mean that the driver looks at it.
Get real
Steve
Jonny Hodgson wrote in message ...
>On Thu, 9 Dec 1999, Stephen Barnett wrote:
>
>> Err.. excuse me but I think you may need to review your researchmaterial,
rev
Quoted text (9 lines)
>> if you have any. > >Are you going to qualify that statement, not having actually >disagreed? > >> Jonny Hodgson wrote in message ... >> >On Wed, 8 Dec 1999, Stephen Barnett wrote: >> > >> >> Formula One cars in 1967 didn't have speedometers. The big one is theQuoted text (10 lines)
>> >[snip] >> > >> >Racing cars don't have speedos, full stop. How fast are you going? >> >7500 rpm in third is all you need to know... >> > >> >The big one in the middle should *always* be the rev counter. > >Jonny >Ringmeister-to-be: current best lap 9m21s >Quoted text (11 lines)
> > GPL has quite a narrow field of view, which makes it harder to judge > > speed. > On the contrary, GPL has a WIDER field of view than the natural > perspective! This makes objects look smaller and corners farther away > than they really are. I guess it's done for practical reasons. It allows > you to look deeper into corners, as you would in real life. The > trade-off is it distorts the sense of speed. > I too would like a field-of-view button, but only to narrow it to a > natural perspective.> What fov is natural depends on how far your eyes are from the screen.
Ofcourse, ultimately the field of view is limited by the size of the
screen. You can't put it close to your eyes, you can't move it very far
either. But it's the perspective that throws you off, not the f.o.v.
Compare a wide angle fish-eye lens and and a narrow angle tele. Same
size picture, different perspective. GPL has slightly fish eye view.
This is immediately obvious when you drive in real life on one of the
GPL tracks. I've done that on Zandvoort, Spa and the Ring. Things are
always a lot nearer than they appear to be on the GPL screen.
--
Bye,
Leo
On Thu, 9 Dec 1999, Stephen Barnett wrote:
> Err.. excuse me but I think you may need to review your research material,
> if you have any.
Are you going to qualify that statement, not having actually
disagreed?
Jonny
Ringmeister-to-be: current best lap 9m21s
Quoted text (10 lines)
> Jonny Hodgson wrote in message ... > >On Wed, 8 Dec 1999, Stephen Barnett wrote: > > > >> Formula One cars in 1967 didn't have speedometers. The big one is the rev > >[snip] > > > >Racing cars don't have speedos, full stop. How fast are you going? > >7500 rpm in third is all you need to know... > > > >The big one in the middle should *always* be the rev counter.
Stephen Barnett <[email hidden]> skrev i inl�gg
<82l52o$9pp$[email hidden]>...
> Formula One cars in 1967 didn't have speedometers.
Ok,thanks...I was afraid of that :-)
--
Robert S�derberg
[email hidden]
If replying by mail,remove the word INGENSPAM from the adress.
In article <82m8hd$1no$[email hidden]>, "GraDee" <[email hidden]>
writes:
>From low to mid speed and revs you can see or feel no difference because of
>the totally crap sounds and no clue from the surroundings as they moev in a
>similar fasion at any lowish to high speed.
>
That's probably one reason that so many pile-ups occur in the first turn after
a short run from the start. People can't judge their speed as well, and often
hit the corner too fast. Either that, or they hit the brakes WAY too early -
surprising following drivers.
Eldred
--
Tiger Stadium R.I.P. 1912-1999
Own Grand Prix Legends? Goto http://gpl.gamestats.com/vroc
Never argue with an idiot. He brings you down to his level, then beats you
with experience...
Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.


































