Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

GPL Differential Question... (long)

31 posts by 9 people · 20 Nov 1999 - 26 Nov 1999

Notable threadGPL differential ramp angle and preload settings

Chris Cavin asked about differential ramp angles and clutch counts in GPL. Ricardo Nunnini and Thomas Brown quoted Carroll Smith's advice to use about 85 degrees on the coast side and 45 on the power side. The discussion covered trail braking, brake balance, trailing-throttle oversteer and whether engine braking can shorten stopping distances.

setup/driving techniquephysics/realism debateGrand Prix Legends

Automated summary.

Chris Cavin 20 Nov 1999#504356
Got a question about the differential settings in GPL. Hopefully some of you who have actually raced a real race car can provide some input. I started racing GPL, like many others, using 85/30 ramp angles in the differential. I was a little bit different, though, in that I used six clutches because of the stabilizing effect they had on my tendencies to trail brake. Well, after reading several things stating that ramp angles of 45/85 would be much closer to those that are actually used (or had been used), I started trying to make some setups using the 45/85 angles. Needless to say I had (and am still having to some extent) trouble adapting. I still use six clutches and I have become accustomed to the throttle sensitivity required in mid-corner situations. Just keeps my concentration levels up. :) My main trouble is adapting to the coast side angle of 85. I simply cannot come to grips with the lack of corner entry grip provided by the rear end with this ramp angle, even still using six clutches. I've backed off a bit and now use a 60 angle with six clutches, but even with this, I find myself countersteering ALL THE WAY INTO THE CORNER from the moment I turn in to the moment I hit the apex. My question is this: Is this effect in any way realistic? I'll concede that some of this effect may be my setup, but it isn't entirely that. If these cars are SO apt to spinning on corner entry with these settings, like GPL appears to be, I have a MUCH larger respect for the ability it takes to be a quick race driver. I've been using the 45/60 ramp angles now for at least two months and still find myself spinning out on corner entry about 5-10% of the time. I know one suggestion will be to move my brake bias back to 58% or 59% from 56%, but that compromizes my straight line braking to the point that I can't outbrake anybody anymore. I've had some luck using Nunnini's 40%/60% spring and 60%/40% ARB theories, but it's still a bit of a handfull. Well, I've rambled on long enough. Discussions or suggestions on setups would be appreciated. Thanks, -Chris- Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ Before you buy.
I have been driving with 45/85 settings for the past few months and I have found it to be quite fast and indeed comfortable once you get used to the tendency for trailing throttle oversteer. In fact once you get used to it you'll find that you can steer the car with your feet more than with the wheel. I use only 1 clutch as the transition from power on and power off is much smoother and more consistent and to qoute Carrol Smith "the most common misconception with these units is that the amount of preload (clutches) is a primary determining factor of the amount of lockup. It can be, but things are a lot better if it is not. The spreading force of the bevel gears in an order of magnitude greater than any conceivable preload". What seems to work pretty well for me is to make smooth transitions from trailing throttle to heavy braking...for instance going down the front straight at Kyalami as I approach my braking point I begin to roll off the throttle smoothly as I equally apply heavy but smooth pressure to the brake (I have the bias set to 51%). Having the coast side set to 85 means that there will be lest likelyhood of locking up the rear wheels under braking not to mention that it does not cause a lot of mid corner understeer as you might get with a lower coast side ramp angle. Let me know if you'd like to talk shop, I'd be glad to exchange thoughts and experiences with anyone that's been using this kind of setup perhaps we could all learn something. Also, I'd be happy to swap setups/replays etc. Also, I'd strongly recommend buying yourself a copy of "Drive to Win" by Carrol Smith as there is plenty of info on differentials. Thomas JS Brown.
Quoted text (52 lines)> Got a question about the differential settings in > GPL. Hopefully some of you who have actually raced > a real race car can provide some input. > I started racing GPL, like many others, using 85/30 > ramp angles in the differential. I was a little > bit different, though, in that I used six clutches > because of the stabilizing effect they had on my > tendencies to trail brake. Well, after reading > several things stating that ramp angles of 45/85 > would be much closer to those that are actually > used (or had been used), I started trying to make > some setups using the 45/85 angles. Needless to > say I had (and am still having to some extent) > trouble adapting. I still use six clutches and I > have become accustomed to the throttle sensitivity > required in mid-corner situations. Just keeps my > concentration levels up. :) My main trouble is > adapting to the coast side angle of 85. I simply > cannot come to grips with the lack of corner entry > grip provided by the rear end with this ramp angle, > even still using six clutches. I've backed off a > bit and now use a 60 angle with six clutches, but > even with this, I find myself countersteering ALL > THE WAY INTO THE CORNER from the moment I turn in > to the moment I hit the apex. > My question is this: Is this effect in any way > realistic? I'll concede that some of this effect > may be my setup, but it isn't entirely that. If > these cars are SO apt to spinning on corner entry > with these settings, like GPL appears to be, I have > a MUCH larger respect for the ability it takes to > be a quick race driver. I've been using the 45/60 > ramp angles now for at least two months and still > find myself spinning out on corner entry about 5-10% > of the time. I know one suggestion will be to move > my brake bias back to 58% or 59% from 56%, but that > compromizes my straight line braking to the point > that I can't outbrake anybody anymore. I've had some > luck using Nunnini's 40%/60% spring and 60%/40% ARB > theories, but it's still a bit of a handfull. > Well, I've rambled on long enough. Discussions > or suggestions on setups would be appreciated. > Thanks, > -Chris- > Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ > Before you buy.
Chris Cavin 20 Nov 1999#504358
I'm much more comfortable with it now than previously, but most tracks I'm still slower than my 85/30 times. I have, however, used it to good effect at Monza, where I can now take the Eagle or the Lotus to middle or high 1:27's after the tires are good and warm. Not consistent at anything but low 1:28's though. I agree. I've found myself becoming smoother at my throttle/brake transitions. Especially the point at whick I let off the gas. I'm also now very careful not to turn in abruptly (such as Curva Grande) while still on the brakes, or I'll swap ends. Here's where I'm gonna say <huh?> If I'm correct, the numerically larger the ramp angle is and the fewer clutches that are present, the less lock-up force is supplied. This all leads me to believe that the inside rear wheel is *MORE* likely to lock up, rather than less, thus, the trailing throttle oversteer since most of the engine drag torque is given to the inside rear. Also, if the inside rear is locked because of the brakes, there's less diff pressure to split the ground dragging torque present on the inside rear. Yes. I like the mid-corner charactarisics much better. Um, too late. I think I just did. :) I may just do that. It would go nicely on the shelf next to the Millikin's "Race Car Vehicle Dynamics" that I got on a whim back when I was in school. Engineering text book store and all, I just couldn't help myself. :) > > Got a question about the differential settings in > > GPL. Hopefully some of you who have actually raced > > a real race car can provide some input. [snip] Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ Before you buy.
The Great Man's words are: "Since we want minimum lock up under braking, especially trail braking, typically we use an 80 or 85 degree ramp on the coast side with a 45 degree ramp on the power or drive side." "The original 90 degree cost ramps tended to chip and have largely been replaced by 85 degree units. For faster corners with more download some teams use 60/30 ramps. I have never been happy with 45/45 (too much corner entry and mid-phase understeer), but I know some very successful people who are - in the UK. I don't know anyone who likes them in slow corners or on bumpy courses. Personally, I cannot conceive of using any ramp of less than 80 degrees on the coast side. Currently many successful teams are using 80/80 ramps with little or no preload, depending on the spreading forces of the bevel gears to limit the slip. This is a very benign setup if there are no really slow hairpins (or not much available torque)." -- Richard 'Ricardo' Nunnini http://website.lineone.net/~richardn - mirror in case the ISP chokes - http://nunnini.homepage.com/
Chris Cavin 20 Nov 1999#504360
I must confess ignorance in the face of a great, dazzling flow of illumination into which my own pale spark is engulfed as one among thousands. Borne upon a benign current which struggles to carry me from the warm, liquid fire of knowledge which nourishes the willing among this dark and fetid nighttime of mediocrity. Who might be this great man of whom you speak? -Chris- PS: I hope you'll forgive me. I've been indulging too much in the fine drink this evening already and seem to have waxed poetic. A rare occasion for me, to be sure. Pray I don't drink further or you all will be smitten with verbiage the likes of which none have known before. :) -C- PPS: <VVBG> * hic * - Me, who else? -
Quoted text (27 lines)> The Great Man's words are: > "Since we want minimum lock up under braking, especially > trail braking, typically we use an 80 or 85 degree ramp > on the coast side with a 45 degree ramp on the power or > drive side." > "The original 90 degree cost ramps tended to chip and have > largely been replaced by 85 degree units. For faster corners > with more download some teams use 60/30 ramps. I have never > been happy with 45/45 (too much corner entry and mid-phase > understeer), but I know some very successful people who are > - in the UK. I don't know anyone who likes them in slow > corners or on bumpy courses. Personally, I cannot conceive > of using any ramp of less than 80 degrees on the coast > side. > Currently many successful teams are using 80/80 ramps with > little or no preload, depending on the spreading forces of > the bevel gears to limit the slip. This is a very benign setup > if there are no really slow hairpins (or not much available > torque)." > -- > Richard 'Ricardo' Nunnini > http://website.lineone.net/~richardn > - mirror in case the ISP chokes - > http://nunnini.homepage.com/
Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ Before you buy.
Once again, from "Drive to Win": "To my mind, minimum preload should be used only to ensure that the diff's transitional characteristics from power off to power on remain consistent and that the unit will limit slip when one wheel is completely unloaded. One of the problems with the clutch packs - especially on road cars and with sedans - is that, when a driving tire is completely unloaded, the diff functions on preload only - the ramps don't come into it." - Carrol Smith Like I mentioned in my previous post, I have my brake balance set to 51% and the front tires are the only ones that lock up under heavy braking ( the least loaded one), the trailing throttle oversteer seems not to be due to a rear wheel locking up but rather weight shifting forward to the front tires (I pretty much run around 3.5 to 4 inches ride height) which is easily corrected by squeezing on a bit more power and/or maintaining constant throttle and locking up the front tires if you've really stuffed it up. This of course will ruin a good lap, but it will keep you heading in the right direction and more often than not on the track rather than the grass or the kitty litter. Thomas
Aubrey 20 Nov 1999#504362
I wonder how important "engine braking" is. Some cars have more engine friction than others, and I would imagine this would have a big effect on trailing throttle oversteer, or mid-corner understeer. Maybe it's just my imagination, but in GPL I think the V8's have less engine braking than the V12's, and you would think the BRM H16 would have the most of all, with all those cylinders and moving parts. One thing I'm certain of is that you get more trailing throttle oversteer in the lower gears, especially first gear. I was watching Matteo Calestani (damn fast driver) at Spa one time, and I noticed he was downshifting mid-corner, and then upshifting again on exit. Trying to get rid of some mid-corner understeer I guess. In a nutshell, I wonder if a 1967 grand prix car differential would be setup radically differently from say, a heavier sports car with much more momentum to overcome the engine braking, or an F2 car with a smaller engine and therefore less engine braking. Basically, I'm thinking it would take more force to get the inside rear wheel to lock up on a heavier or less powerful car. Might explain why 85/45 feels neutral in GPL, even though it defies conventional wisdom. -Aub
Quoted text (34 lines)>> > Having the coast side set to 85 means that there will be less >> > likelyhood of locking up the rear wheels under braking >> Here's where I'm gonna say <huh?> If I'm correct, the numerically >> larger the ramp angle is and the fewer clutches that are present, >> the less lock-up force is supplied. This all leads me to believe >> that the inside rear wheel is *MORE* likely to lock up, rather than >> less, thus, the trailing throttle oversteer since most of the engine >> drag torque is given to the inside rear. Also, if the inside rear is >> locked because of the brakes, there's less diff pressure to split >> the ground dragging torque present on the inside rear. >Once again, from "Drive to Win": >"To my mind, minimum preload should be used only to ensure that the >diff's transitional characteristics from power off to power on remain >consistent and that the unit will limit slip when one wheel is completely >unloaded. One of the problems with the clutch packs - especially on road >cars and with sedans - is that, when a driving tire is completely >unloaded, the diff functions on preload only - the ramps don't come into >it." - Carrol Smith >Like I mentioned in my previous post, I have my brake balance set to 51% >and the front tires are the only ones that lock up under heavy braking ( >the least loaded one), the trailing throttle oversteer seems not to be >due to a rear wheel locking up but rather weight shifting forward to the >front tires (I pretty much run around 3.5 to 4 inches ride height) which >is easily corrected by squeezing on a bit more power and/or maintaining >constant throttle and locking up the front tires if you've really stuffed >it up. This of course will ruin a good lap, but it will keep you heading >in the right direction and more often than not on the track rather than >the grass or the kitty litter. >Thomas
David Erb 20 Nov 1999#504363
The Great Man of whom the most illuminating and explicating Nunnini doth speak is none other than the dazzling ( and some say benign, occasionally) guru Caroll Smith. The liquid fire of knowledge of things automotively rapid is liberally dispensed in several nourishing tomes titled variously "Engineer to Win"," Prepare to Win" and" Tune to Win". To qoute a Road & Track review " It's probably the best thing for race car mechanics since Duct Tape" . No higher accolade can be made. May your poetic verbiage wax well David :) buy.
Chris Cavin 21 Nov 1999#504522
Color me stumped. My intuition says that if the coast ramp is set at 85 (i.e. nearly no lock up) that the inside rear wheel will lock up due to severe braking. I see several things happening when a driver brakes for a corner: 1) When the brakes are applied, the rears unload evenly and the fronts load evenly proportional to the amount the rears unload. 2) When the driver begins turning in, the inside rear unloads further and that load is correspondingly transferred to the outside front tire. 3) Now, the inside rear tire has the least amount of grip availabe because it is supporting the smallest amount of static weight of the car of any of the four tires. 4) We shall assume that the coast angle (85) and the clutch preload (1) are both set to minimum for the following theories. It is assumed that these settings on the differential will make it behave almost as if it was coasting as an open differential. 5) In the following theories, I'm lumping the mechanical braking torque in with the engine drag torque, so that the case of rear wheel lock-up can be considered a bit more simply. These thing I belive are correct. Following, I have several theories, but I'm not sure which is correct. Theory 1: Under these conditions, as the inside rear wheel approaches the threshhold of locking up, it will receive 94.5% of the engine drag torque because it has the least amount of grip available to it. (Similar to the way an open differenial will transmit 100% of the drive torque to the spinning wheel when it slips, but modifed for the 85 degree ramp angle.) When this happens, the outside rear won't receive enough engine drag torque to lock up, and the car is prevented from spinning, since the outside rear wheel is responsible for (probably) about 80% of the total grip of the rear wheels. Theory 2: Same as Theory 1, except that the outside rear WILL lock up because it now receives a disproportionatly large share of the engine drag torque. The car will then spin because the inside rear locks, robbing the car of about (probably) 15-20%) of the grip at the rear, thus unbalancing the car from the position in which the driver has placed it. Keep in mind that I've lumped mechanical braking torque and engine drag torque in together, since the rear wheels don't differentiate between the two. I don't know which theory is correct, but I do know that the car will display an increase in it's tendency to oversteer under trailing- throttle and trail-braking situations. I hate to question a prophet, but the above quoted section from Carol Shelby goes against what my intuition tells me, which is that the locking of the inside rear wheel, due to minimal differential locking pressure caused by 85 degree ramp angles, causes the trailing throttle oversteer. I'm certainly open to opposing view points and would love to hear discussions on this topic in further detail. -Chris- Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ Before you buy.
Not in my experience. The least loaded front tire is the only one that even begins to lock (both fronts if I've gone too deep).I don't know which theory is correct, but I do know that the car Carrol Smith, not to be confused with Carrol Shelby of Cobra fame. No offense, but if I have to make a choice between your intuition and Mr. Smith's experience as an engineer with the likes of, Adamowicz, Amon, Andretti, Bond, Cobb, Foyt, Gurney, Hulme, Ickx, Matich, McLaren, Millen (S.), Moffat, Ongais, Posey, Rahal, Redman, Ruby, Revson and Vasser.....well the choice seems pretty cut and dried.
drbo.. 23 Nov 1999#504943
I yield to no one in admiration of Carroll. Note, for example, I actually know how to spell his name. :-) However, this discussion often assumes Papyrus has done a brilliant job of modeling the real thing, bevel gear spreading and all. I don't think so. So observations about how the game responds may have validity even tho they disagree with the Great Man. bob
Could you be more specific? In what way does the differential not correspond to the real thing in your opinion? It wasn't an observation per se but rather a hunch that Mr. Cavin had about how the rear wheels may lock up under heavy braking due to the diff being more open on the coast side. My personal observations/experiences within the game tell me otherwise. Thomas
Chris Cavin 23 Nov 1999#504945
My original hunch went something like this: Things I'm assuming are fact (please correct me if I'm wrong): --A 30 coast ramp provides maximum locking force while an 85 coast ramp provides minimum locking force. --Six clutches provide maximum locking force (for a given ramp angle) while one clutch provides minimum locking force. --With the above two assumptions, a 30 coast ramp with six clutches would provide the most locking force available, while an 85 coast ramp with one clutch would provide the least locking force available. --The greater the coast locking force, the less likely the inside rear wheel will be to lock since the two rear wheels are kept rotating (by the high differential locking force) at close to the same speed. --The lesser the coast locking force, the more likely the inside rear will be to lock since the the two rear wheels are allowed (by the low differential locking force) to rotate at very different speeds. My own personal observations: --I originally used a 30 coast ramp with six clutches. This combination gave me stability under trail-braking and trailing throttle situations. The car exhibits little to no trailing- throttle oversteer with this combination. --I have since tried an 85 coast ramp with one clutch. This combination gives me much less stability under trail-braking and trailing-throttle conditions. The car exhibits much trailing- throttle oversteer with this combination. The combination of the things I'm assuming as fact with my personal observations: --I observed the greatest amount of trailing-throttle oversteer when the differential was set with the minimum amount of coast locking force. --I observed the least amount of trailing-throttle oversteer when the differential was set with the maximum amount of coast locking force. Combination of observation, assumption of fact and theory: --Since I observed the greatest amount of trailing-throttle oversteer when the differential was set with the minimum amount of coast locking force, this oversteer condition is caused by the inside rear wheel locking due to a lack of differential locking force. --Since I observed the least amount of trailing-throttle oversteer when the differential was set with the maximum amount of coast locking force, this stable condition is casued by the inside rear wheel not being allowed to lock due to the differential locking force. These are only my observations and theories based on how GPL behaves. I have no experience with a rear-wheel drive car, road or racing. So far, I can't see any flaws in my logic, but I invite others to do so. Cheers, -Chris- Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ Before you buy.
Thats correct Again, correct....however keep in mind that the more preload, the less the ramps come into play. The diff will lock on preload only. And therefore creating a lot of mid corner understeer since the unit acts more like a spool then an open diff. Only if your brake bias is set too far rearward, otherwise under heavy braking the least loaded front wheel will lock while the rear wheels are free to turn. But bags of mid corner understeer.... Right? <snip> The only way your argument makes any sense is if you've got your brake bias set too far rearward. Think about it for a second, you're claiming that less locking is more likely to lock a wheel.... However try setting the brake bias more rearward and you'll find that BOTH rear wheels will lock due to the fact that the diff acts more like a spool. In my experience with GPL the trailing throttle oversteer you describe is not a product of a locked rear wheel but wieght transfer. Ask any race driver what happens if you suddenly lift off the throttle (even while going dead straight). Driving with a 45/85 is much more demanding due to the fact that you must balance the car on the throttle and brake (and how smoothly they are used in conjunction), the transition from power on and power off is much more volitile and less forgiving but with practice allows more control (in my opinion) through the various phases of cornering. <snipped from Ricardo's post> This is what allows me to set the brake bias at 51% and not lock a rear wheel, if you question the validity of my assertion I will gladly provide you with a copy of my setup and a replay. Thomas
Chris Cavin 23 Nov 1999#504947
[snip] I didn't know that. That would explain why I don't feel a drastic difference between an 85-6 power side combo and a 45-6 power side combo. [snip] Yes. :) Didn't bother me too much, though, since I'm more of a "pitch- it-in-and-ride-the-throttoe-out" driver. Probably goes part way towards explaining why I'm having difficulty adapting to the more open coast angles. Nope. I drive with the bias set at 56-57%. I tried your 51% once and I couldn't even keep the car from spinning while I was still braking in a straight line. You must be very good on the brakes. :) Yes. Here's why: Discount the brakes for the moment. It simplifies the conversation a bit. Let's say I'm coming up on a turn. I let off the gas which unloads the rear. Since I'm coasting, the rear wheels are driving the engine and supplying force to keep the engine spinning against its compression. While I'm in a straight line, both wheels supply the same amount of torque back to the engine (more or less) since they're evenly weighted. When I begin my turn in, however, the inside rear unloads further and becomes the least loaded of the two rear wheels. This unloading reduces the available traction at the inside rear and limits the torque it can supply the engine for engine braking. The engine back-torque will remain split evenly between the two rear wheels unless more torque is required than the available traction can supply (if I've downshifted to aggressively, for instance). The wheel that will loose traction will be the inside rear under these circumstances, and once that happens, the nearly open coast differential will send the majority of the torque to the wheel with the least amount of grip (the inside rear). This will make the inside rear lock since the engine back- torque has already overcome the available traction. Adding brakes into the whole equation will cause the inside rear to lock even sooner since there will now be mechanical braking as well as engine braking trying to slow the wheel's rotation. I'll agree with you to a certain extent. Too abrupt a turn-in can certainly cause the car to spin and, no doubt, contributes a bit to my dilema. It's not the only component, though, and what I've discribed above remains valid under transient weight transfer conditions. Eagerly awaiting your reply... :) -Chris- Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ Before you buy.
Aubrey 24 Nov 1999#505198
My own observations match yours exactly. Every last one. Seems too much of a coincidence for us both to be wrong. Although it could all come down to flaws in the physics model of course. -A
Quoted text (93 lines)>[snip] >> > --Six clutches provide maximum locking force (for a given ramp >> > angle) while one clutch provides minimum locking force. >> > --With the above two assumptions, a 30 coast ramp with six >> > clutches would provide the most locking force available, while >> > an 85 coast ramp with one clutch would provide the least >> > locking force available. >> Again, correct....however keep in mind that the more preload, the >> less the ramps come into play. The diff will lock on preload only. >I didn't know that. That would explain why I don't feel a drastic >difference between an 85-6 power side combo and a 45-6 power side combo. >[snip] >> > My own personal observations: >> > --I originally used a 30 coast ramp with six clutches. This >> > combination gave me stability under trail-braking and trailing >> > throttle situations. The car exhibits little to no trailing- >> > throttle oversteer with this combination. >> But bags of mid corner understeer.... Right? >Yes. :) Didn't bother me too much, though, since I'm more of a "pitch- >it-in-and-ride-the-throttoe-out" driver. Probably goes part way >towards explaining why I'm having difficulty adapting to the more open >coast angles. >> <snip> >> > Combination of observation, assumption of fact and theory: >> > --Since I observed the greatest amount of trailing-throttle >> > oversteer when the differential was set with the minimum amount >> > of coast locking force, this oversteer condition is caused by >> > the inside rear wheel locking due to a lack of differential >> > locking force. >> The only way your argument makes any sense is if you've got your >> brake bias set too far rearward. >Nope. I drive with the bias set at 56-57%. I tried your 51% once >and I couldn't even keep the car from spinning while I was still >braking in a straight line. You must be very good on the brakes. :) >> Think about it for a second, you're claiming that less locking >> is more likely to lock a wheel.... >Yes. Here's why: >Discount the brakes for the moment. It simplifies the conversation a >bit. Let's say I'm coming up on a turn. I let off the gas which >unloads the rear. Since I'm coasting, the rear wheels are driving the >engine and supplying force to keep the engine spinning against its >compression. While I'm in a straight line, both wheels supply the same >amount of torque back to the engine (more or less) since they're evenly >weighted. When I begin my turn in, however, the inside rear unloads >further and becomes the least loaded of the two rear wheels. This >unloading reduces the available traction at the inside rear and limits >the torque it can supply the engine for engine braking. The engine >back-torque will remain split evenly between the two rear wheels unless >more torque is required than the available traction can supply (if I've >downshifted to aggressively, for instance). The wheel that will loose >traction will be the inside rear under these circumstances, and once >that happens, the nearly open coast differential will send the majority >of the torque to the wheel with the least amount of grip (the inside >rear). This will make the inside rear lock since the engine back- >torque has already overcome the available traction. >Adding brakes into the whole equation will cause the inside rear to >lock even sooner since there will now be mechanical braking as well as >engine braking trying to slow the wheel's rotation. >> In my experience with GPL the trailing throttle oversteer you >> describe is not a product of a locked rear wheel but wieght >> transfer. Ask any race driver what happens if you suddenly lift >> off the throttle (even while going dead straight). >I'll agree with you to a certain extent. Too abrupt a turn-in can >certainly cause the car to spin and, no doubt, contributes a bit to my >dilema. It's not the only component, though, and what I've discribed >above remains valid under transient weight transfer conditions. >Eagerly awaiting your reply... :) >-Chris- >Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ >Before you buy.
Okay now that tells me a lot. I'd be willing to bet you prefer to allow the higher drag of a lower coast angle to provide you with a certain amount of cornering stability. Which has led you to the mistaken belief that you're getting some use out of engine braking. <snipped from Ricardo's site> "Since engine braking doesn't increase the size of the 'friction circle', it can't slow you down faster." You've lifted off the accelerator entirely at this point right?? Its not just the brakes, its brake and throttle together....to quote the late Denny Hulme "its all a question of balance" or... <snipped from Ricardo's site> Ricardo Nunnini: "As your left foot comes up, your right foot goes down you can even start getting your right foot down before your left has finished coming up." See above qoute from Ricardo Okay, this is where you're getting hung up....when you're using a smaller ramp angle on the coast side (or more clutches on a higher ramp angle) the wheels will be more closely locked together which as stated before will create a certain amount of drag (or understeer) since the wheels are trying to rotate at the same speed. With a more open coast side angle the wheels are allowed to spin more independantly of one another allowing the car to rotate more freely through its directional axis (greater tendency for trailing throttle oversteer) which has nothing whatsoever to do with a wheel locking. Since (what it sounds like from your description) you're trying to coast your way to the apex, you've done 2 things: 1: By lifting off the throttle you've allowed the weight to transfer forward, add brakes to the equation and you get more, (dependant to a certain extent on ride height) which gives the front end even more bite. 2: if you're using an a higher coast side ramp angle, the rear wheels will be less closely locked together, which means they will be able to rotate more independantly of one another, which will make the rear end feel much more loose (even in a straight line). You see, the clutch pack differential functions on torque, its hard to explain without a diagram, but I'll give you another qoute from "Drive to Win": "On the over-run and under neutral throttle conditions the unit is an open differential - there is no differential caused understeer at the apex of slow corners or during the transition from power off to power on." "As soon as significant power is applied the spreading force of the spyder and side gears applies a clamping force on the friction plates which is proportional to the amount of torque being applied and the unit becomes a very effective limited slip differential. Under full power the unit is locked." Do you see now? you can't lock a wheel if the ramp angle is set to 85 with one clutch and you've got your foot off the throttle, the tendency for trailing throttle oversteer is greater due to the fact that it will act like an open diff. Its a matter of making the transition from power on to power off and the smooth application of braking force all at the same time. Once the car settles through your apex, (and you should be gently trailing off the brake at this point) you smoothly apply the throttle through the exit and send the diff back to full lock. Smoothness is the key Thomas
: <snipped from Ricardo's site> : "Since engine braking doesn't increase the size of the 'friction circle', it : can't slow you down faster." Actually this is erroneous - or rather it's true only in a "static" case. Engine braking _could_ slow you down faster if you had a reason to want more braking at the rear at any point. The weight distribution of the car is bound to change from front to rear under braking. A very precise driver might be able to get more "stopping force" by using engine braking to put extra braking force on the rears when the weight shifts more "rearward" (I imagine this would be as you start to turn). So engine braking could help you brake by acting as a "dynamic" brake balance. I doubt anyone's actually good enough to make use of this in practice - but I've been wrong before and I plan to be wrong again. -- Richard G. Clegg Only the mind is waving Networks and Non-Linear Dynamics Group Dept. of Mathematics, Uni. of York www: http://manor.york.ac.uk/top.html
>: <snipped from Ricardo's site> >: "Since engine braking doesn't increase the size of the 'friction >: circle', it can't slow you down faster." > Actually this is erroneous - or rather it's true only in a "static" > case. The sentence is correct in that you probably cannot increase the SIZE of the friction circle with engine braking, but! it can make you slow down faster :) The explanation is like you say below, and in 'friction circle terms' the explanation is that engine braking can get you closer to the edge of the friction circle, instead of staying way inside it. Bingo! :) I use it and I've observed many other drivers using it too. And yes, dynamic brake balance is what we're after. The place were I've noticed I'm using it most is when braking into T1 at Brands Hatch. This braking zone is so weird that even with 52% braking balance the fronts always lock before the rears. This place actually makes you feel like you have infinite rear wheel traction. Atleast in the Lotus. The problem is that using anything like 52% balance or below is going to make you go tail first into all the other corners on that track. So the solution is to use 53-54% balance, and shift down like you're shooting aliens with that downshifting button when coming into T1. Regards, Casper
:>: <snipped from Ricardo's site> :> :>: "Since engine braking doesn't increase the size of the 'friction :>: circle', it can't slow you down faster." :> Actually this is erroneous - or rather it's true only in a "static" :> case. : The sentence is correct in that you probably cannot increase the : SIZE of the friction circle with engine braking, but! it can : make you slow down faster :) The explanation is like you say below, : and in 'friction circle terms' the explanation is that engine : braking can get you closer to the edge of the friction circle, : instead of staying way inside it. Well - I meant the "it can't slow you down faster" bit is erroneous. :> So engine braking could help you brake by acting as a "dynamic" brake :>balance. I doubt anyone's actually good enough to make use of this in :>practice - but I've been wrong before and I plan to be wrong again. : Bingo! :) I use it and I've observed many other drivers using it : too. And yes, dynamic brake balance is what we're after. The place : were I've noticed I'm using it most is when braking into T1 at : Brands Hatch. This braking zone is so weird that even with 52% : braking balance the fronts always lock before the rears. This : place actually makes you feel like you have infinite rear wheel : traction. OK - colour me impressed. I really thought this was of "academic interest only" (as an academic I hate that phrase - I mean the implication that academic == irrelevant)... Is there anywhere apart from Brands where this trick is helpful? It could be some quirk of the coding of Brands which may not be done to the same standard as the other tracks (for example with sharp graduations in grip levels). I can believe this kind of thing could really make a difference if (say) brands was coded in such a way as to have sharp and sudden grip transitions and you found yourself in a situation where for a car's length the rear of the car had plenty more grip than the front. Incidentally, does anyone know how GPL codes friction on surface. It would explain some of the peculiarities of the physics model if it were coded as having a particular value exactly specified for different parts of the track (as opposed to some kind of distribution specification on different parts of the track). : Atleast in the Lotus. The problem is that using anything : like 52% balance or below is going to make you go tail first : into all the other corners on that track. So the solution is to : use 53-54% balance, and shift down like you're shooting aliens : with that downshifting button when coming into T1. (Grin) Gaining the extra braking from the engine in places where the rears have more grip.... I have to say tho that this seems a funny way for things to work and may be a peculiarity of the brands coding. By the way, I would have thought that it would be the most effective way to brake by waiting until after the car has settled from it's initial "dive" when you first press the brakes before using the engine braking. (Because there's more weight on the rears then). Am I right or is the effect too subtle to notice? -- Richard G. Clegg Only the mind is waving Networks and Non-Linear Dynamics Group Dept. of Mathematics, Uni. of York www: http://manor.york.ac.uk/top.html
Chris Cavin 24 Nov 1999#505203
The previous times I've written about engine braking were used for illustrative purposes and don't necessarily apply to my driving style. Some of the comments do and some of the comments don't. Sure, but it can bring you closer to the edge of the friction circle if your setup and driving style weren't allowing you to get there previously. Yes. Completely. And fully on the brakes in a straight line way before the turn-in point has been reached. True, but I was referring to complete, straight-line, full honk braking for the parabolica. After turn-in, well that's another matter, but during completely straight-line braking 51% is just too far rearward for my tastes and abilities. I don't see where Ricardo's quote is valid while under steady-state straight-line braking. I think we're gonna just have to agree to disagree. I see what you're saying and don't disagree with that, but I also still believe that what I've been saying is applicable in addition to the things you're saying. -Chris- Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ Before you buy.
Aubrey 24 Nov 1999#505204
Hmm, now you're making a lot of sense. I'll have to respectfully withdraw my agreement with Chris. ;o) Been using 45 coast side, and 5 or 6 clutches usually, but I'm gonna experiment with a more open diff and more rearward brake balance next chance I get. I imagine some sway bar adjustments will be neccessary to reduce the oversteer. Or would that just defeat the purpose? -A
Quoted text (8 lines) > > My own personal observations: > > > > --I originally used a 30 coast ramp with six clutches. This > > combination gave me stability under trail-braking and trailing > > throttle situations. The car exhibits little to no trailing- > > throttle oversteer with this combination. > > But bags of mid corner understeer.... Right?
Yes. :) Didn't bother me too much, though, since I'm more of a "pitch- it-in-and-ride-the-throttoe-out" driver. Probably goes part way towards explaining why I'm having difficulty adapting to the more open coast angles. Okay now that tells me a lot. I'd be willing to bet you prefer to allow the higher drag of a lower coast angle to provide you with a certain amount of cornering stability. Which has led you to the mistaken belief that you're getting some use out of engine braking. <snipped from Ricardo's site> "Since engine braking doesn't increase the size of the 'friction circle', it can't slow you down faster." > The only way your argument makes any sense is if you've got your > brake bias set too far rearward. Nope. I drive with the bias set at 56-57%. I tried your 51% once and I couldn't even keep the car from spinning while I was still braking in a straight line. You must be very good on the brakes. :) You've lifted off the accelerator entirely at this point right?? Its not just the brakes, its brake and throttle together....to quote the late Denny Hulme "its all a question of balance" or... <snipped from Ricardo's site> Ricardo Nunnini: "As your left foot comes up, your right foot goes down you can even start getting your right foot down before your left has finished coming up." > Think about it for a second, you're claiming that less locking > is more likely to lock a wheel.... Yes. Here's why: Discount the brakes for the moment. It simplifies the conversation a bit. Let's say I'm coming up on a turn. I let off the gas which unloads the rear. Since I'm coasting, the rear wheels are driving the engine and supplying force to keep the engine spinning against its compression. See above qoute from Ricardo While I'm in a straight line, both wheels supply the same amount of torque back to the engine (more or less) since they're evenly weighted. When I begin my turn in, however, the inside rear unloads further and becomes the least loaded of the two rear wheels. This unloading reduces the available traction at the inside rear and limits the torque it can supply the engine for engine braking. The engine back-torque will remain split evenly between the two rear wheels unless more torque is required than the available traction can supply (if I've downshifted to aggressively, for instance). The wheel that will loose traction will be the inside rear under these circumstances, and once that happens, the nearly open coast differential will send the majority of the torque to the wheel with the least amount of grip (the inside rear). This will make the inside rear lock since the engine back- torque has already overcome the available traction. Okay, this is where you're getting hung up....when you're using a smaller ramp angle on the coast side (or more clutches on a higher ramp angle) the wheels will be more closely locked together which as stated before will create a certain amount of drag (or understeer) since the wheels are trying to rotate at the same speed. With a more open coast side angle the wheels are allowed to spin more independantly of one another allowing the car to rotate more freely through its directional axis (greater tendency for trailing throttle oversteer) which has nothing whatsoever to do with a wheel locking. Since (what it sounds like from your description) you're trying to coast your way to the apex, you've done 2 things: 1: By lifting off the throttle you've allowed the weight to transfer forward, add brakes to the equation and you get more, (dependant to a certain extent on ride height) which gives the front end even more bite. 2: if you're using an a higher coast side ramp angle, the rear wheels will be less closely locked together, which means they will be able to rotate more independantly of one another, which will make the rear end feel much more loose (even in a straight line). You see, the clutch pack differential functions on torque, its hard to explain without a diagram, but I'll give you another qoute from "Drive to Win": "On the over-run and under neutral throttle conditions the unit is an open differential - there is no differential caused understeer at the apex of slow corners or during the transition from power off to power on." "As soon as significant power is applied the spreading force of the spyder and side gears applies a clamping force on the friction plates which is proportional to the amount of torque being applied and the unit becomes a very effective limited slip differential. Under full power the unit is locked." Do you see now? you can't lock a wheel if the ramp angle is set to 85 with one clutch and you've got your foot off the throttle, the tendency for trailing throttle oversteer is greater due to the fact that it will act like an open diff. Its a matter of making the transition from power on to power off and the smooth application of braking force all at the same time. Once the car settles through your apex, (and you should be gently trailing off the brake at this point) you smoothly apply the throttle through the exit and send the diff back to full lock. Smoothness is the key Thomas
Well I'm sure that there's more than one way to approach it but thats precisely what I did when I started seriously trying to drive with this type of diff setting. Stiff front ARB and a much softer rear bar. As you get faster your sense of balance changes and then you can run with a stiffer rear ARB. Thomas
Quoted text (9 lines)> Hmm, now you're making a lot of sense. I'll have to respectfully withdraw > my agreement with Chris. ;o) > Been using 45 coast side, and 5 or 6 clutches usually, but I'm gonna > experiment with a more open diff and more rearward brake balance next chance > I get. > I imagine some sway bar adjustments will be neccessary to reduce the > oversteer. Or would that just defeat the purpose?
Aubrey 24 Nov 1999#505206
I don't know if this helps, but the misconception I had was that straight line braking instability is caused by a diff that is too open. Actually, it's caused by the brake balance being too far rearward. The car wants to swap ends when *both* rear wheels lock under braking. I'm not talking about the diff locking, I'm talking about both rear brakes locking simultaneously. 51% brake balance seems excessive to me too, but you might be able to manage the more open diff if you try a more normal brake balance like 55 or 56%. The more open diff does require a more rearward brake balance, but if you go just a tiny bit too far rearward -you're in deep doodoo. (how's that for a euphamism) You can indeed make straight line braking more stable by using more clutches or lower ramp angles, but it just might be better to do it by adjusting the brake balance. Unfortunately, I have no idea how Thomas is getting away with 51%. -A
Quoted text (8 lines)>I think we're gonna just have to agree to disagree. I see what you're >saying and don't disagree with that, but I also still believe that what >I've been saying is applicable in addition to the things you're saying. >-Chris- >Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ >Before you buy.
Well, I never said it was easy using a 51% bias, and I didn't just arbitrarily start using such a rearward setting, it took time and practice. As I've gotten used to the tendency for trailing throttle oversteer, and how to compensate for it (mainly by smoothing out my throttle and brake application....and using the steering less) I've found that I can brake later (not by much but just a wee bit) enough for me to squeeze through the apex at the very limit of adhesion. The thing is, that it requires an enormous amount of concentration (at least for me) and a thorough knowlege of the track and what your personal limits are and even then its quite a handful. Having said that, even if you don't plan to use this kind of setup in competition its an excellent way to improve your sensitivity and also learn something about the operation of the limited slip differential. Chances are that people will still stick to the 85/30 (on a low slung chassis....but thats a whole 'nuther can 'o worms) due to the fact that it's more tolerant of throttle and brake transitions, although I wouldn't be surprised if a Lake or Woeger type could brake some records with 45/85. Thomas PS I'd be glad to send you some replays/setups if you're interested...drop me a note.
Quoted text (30 lines)> I don't know if this helps, but the misconception I had was that straight > line braking instability is caused by a diff that is too open. Actually, > it's caused by the brake balance being too far rearward. The car wants to > swap ends when *both* rear wheels lock under braking. I'm not talking about > the diff locking, I'm talking about both rear brakes locking simultaneously. > 51% brake balance seems excessive to me too, but you might be able to manage > the more open diff if you try a more normal brake balance like 55 or 56%. > The more open diff does require a more rearward brake balance, but if you go > just a tiny bit too far rearward -you're in deep doodoo. (how's that for a > euphamism) > You can indeed make straight line braking more stable by using more clutches > or lower ramp angles, but it just might be better to do it by adjusting the > brake balance. > Unfortunately, I have no idea how Thomas is getting away with 51%. > -A > >I think we're gonna just have to agree to disagree. I see what you're > >saying and don't disagree with that, but I also still believe that what > >I've been saying is applicable in addition to the things you're saying. > >-Chris- > >Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ > >Before you buy.
Well it depends very much on driving style and preference. I'd say its used in varying degrees on different tracks. At Monza for example where all the braking zones are similar to each other (no elevation change and pretty straight braking), I use a braking balance of 53% (if I remember correctly). With this balance its strictly forbidden to use engine braking, since it immidiately throws the car around. This is a kind of counter-example to engine braking, but I just wanted to point out that how rapidly you downshift when braking does have an effect on car stability and stopping power. I could use 55% balance at Monza, but I'd have to downshift like mad at every corner, and I'd still not get the same stopping power as with 53%. No, I don't think this is the case. The braking zone for T1 at Brands is just plain evil. First it's an uphill jump over the finish line, which obviously reduces your grip to close to zero, then as you come down from your short flight the springs compress and you gain additional grip from the car settling back onto the track, and then finally the road dips away from underneath the car going downhill and turning to the right at the same time. Now, you don't need no sharp graduations in grip level coded into the track. You get those sharp changes in grip level just because of the roller coaster ride provided by the natural elevation changes of the track. Well if I'd have to guess I'd guess the grip level is coded as an overall grip level for a particular track. With no section specific levels. This isn't a rallycross sim after all ;) But I might be wrong... As I said above I think this is just as it is supposed to work. It might seem strange at first, but if you think how the car is being thrown around the grip levels of individual wheels is bound to change just because of the physics involved, not because of anything coded into the track. You're right. And hitting the brakes to soon and too hard locks up everything. But you can begin downshifting quite early still (about the same time as you start to apply the brakes), since it takes a little bit of time for the computer guy in the car to get his hand on the stick, press the clutch (?), blip the throttle, and move the stick down a gear. You can check out my Brands lap at Schubi's if your interested in how its done :) I STILL manage to lock up a front wheel though... Regards, Casper
Prefect Bei 25 Nov 1999#505416
<much snippage> Ok, let's hear it from the professionals: http://www.itv-f1.com/pitpass/4604.2html In that transcript, Damon Hill and his engineer seem to be curing oversteer by increasing diff loading. This is more to do with traction, but it might offer some insight. -joe-
Prefect Bei 25 Nov 1999#505417
I always presumed that if you let the wheels rotate more as they wish they won't scrub as much and so more grip is obtained, hence less diff locking gives more drive-wheel grip. I have another question here, somewhat theoretical as I'm interested in the ideas rather than the practice (I don't have GPL as I'm without a system to run it on). When diff locking is increased, the drive wheels cannot turn as indepentantly through a corner. When cornering, weight shifts to the outside wheel and so it has more grip. The natural tendency of the outside wheel is to turn faster than the inside, but with more locking it must turn at a more similar speed to the inside. Does the outside wheel drag the inside wheel up to its speed, or does the inside slow the outside wheel down to its speed? I'm guessing the former as the outside has more grip. -joe-
Aubrey 25 Nov 1999#505418
Well, the GPL manual doesn't explain it in terms of grip. It explains how a more closed diff acts as a kind of primitive ABS system which helps keep the rear brakes from locking. What I was trying to get accross was, you don't really need ABS as long as your brake balance is forward enough. I don't know if you're right about grip, but moving the brake balance rearward would help take advantage of the extra grip if there is any. The catch is, that if you go too far rearward, the rears will lock up because you don't have any "ABS". I've been experimenting with a more open diff, and moving the brake balance just one or two clicks back, and it seems to work pretty well. It does seem like I can brake a tiny bit harder now. I chalked this up to less friction from the diff, but it could be more grip just like you say. -A >I always presumed that if you let the wheels rotate more as they wish >they won't scrub as much and so more grip is obtained, hence less diff >locking gives more drive-wheel grip. >-joe-
: Well, the GPL manual doesn't explain it in terms of grip. It explains how a : more closed diff acts as a kind of primitive ABS system which helps keep the : rear brakes from locking. What I was trying to get accross was, you don't : really need ABS as long as your brake balance is forward enough. Well, I did some playing about on GPL last night and what I found was the following for the power-on diff: 1) If you have the rear wheels very tightly locked then you get understeer in long corners through which you have the power on. Take the first long right hander in Monza - if you have the rears tightly bound then the power will tend to push you to the outside. This is because the rears "want" to move together but what you, the driver, wants is the inside wheel to turn less than the outside wheel (think about it, when going round a corner the last thing you want is the two wheels turning at the same speed because then one or other of them must be slipping). If you set the diff to tightly lock the two wheels when the power is on then you will get dreadful understeer through power on corners. 2) However, if you have the wheels extremely loosely locked then the inside wheel can break away. The inner wheel when you're cornering is the unloaded one. If your diff is set loose then when you put the power on hard, the inner wheel will break free and spin. This will mean that your car is being accelerated more by the outer wheel. This will, in turn, mean that you will spin towards the inside of the corner. In my case, a typical symptom of this is spinning off into the barrier on the right hand side of parabolica. (And, occasionally, if the diff is very open then powering off the road on the right hand side of the first right hander - the name of which I forget). I'm not sure quite what the equivalent bits of this for "power off" diff would be. It seems it would only make a difference on corner entry as you began to turn with the power off. Perhaps something with the diff could stop my habit of having the rear end of the car overtake me as I head into parabolica. Again, I think there may be a compromise between having the wheels tightly bound (which would, as the manual says, provide a rear wheel only ABS) and having the wheels loosely bound (which would allow you to actually turn the corner without the tyres slipping). Apologies if this is obvious to everyone but me - I'd been regarding diff settings as dangerous heavy magic and actually understanding them really seemed to help my lap times. (Also, driving with a very open diff improved my sensitivity on the throttle). -- Richard G. Clegg Only the mind is waving Networks and Non-Linear Dynamics Group Dept. of Mathematics, Uni. of York www: http://manor.york.ac.uk/

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy