Agreed in most cases. You can apply the triangle of forces to this
situation.
MS
or should I say the designers and people who signed off on such a design are to
blame. in the moment it takes to sense the horror it was plain to see that by
angling the walls for emergency vehicle access ( ironic ) it would clearly lead
to highly inflated impact values. at their present angle the walls it looked
like almost a straight on hit for Greg. surely a reduction of the 20 degrees
that the walls are set on would make a difference, perhaps even here where the
tragedy of speed once again reminds me to live my life fully every day.
jm
To be more specific to the cause of Greg's passing i have noticed to be
the emergency vehicle road from the infield. If you are able to see the
replay again, though i'm against any airing of it except the live shot,
you will see that there is a considerable elevation change from grass to
asphalt to grass, i predict it to be three inches. G's car was
sliding perpendicular on to that road. He was going across the first
part of grass okay, hit the asphalt okay, but the grass rising the three
inches caught the right side tires causing the roll which lead to the
upside-down impact on to an average wall that was just there. A tire
wall along that wall could have been just as fatal how he hit. The tires
could have caused the damage to his neck/spine by pressing him just as
much as the roll bar. Leave it at this, i live on vancouver island which
is close to Maple Ridge, when i saw the accident the first time i was
sick to my stomach, i still am but his accident was caused by turbulence
from the car infront, lost air to his back end, spun, caught the grass
and flipped to a critical angle and hit a cement wall.
Rest in piece. He was going to be the best...
Quoted text (8 lines)
> or should I say the designers and people who signed off on such a design are to > blame. in the moment it takes to sense the horror it was plain to see that by > angling the walls for emergency vehicle access ( ironic ) it would clearly lead > to highly inflated impact values. at their present angle the walls it looked > like almost a straight on hit for Greg. surely a reduction of the 20 degrees > that the walls are set on would make a difference, perhaps even here where the > tragedy of speed once again reminds me to live my life fully every day. > jmI am just kinda wondering why everyone is sitting around casting blame.
After seeing accident I cannot see why someone can say this is why or that
is why or he or she is to blame. Greg Moore died doing something he loved
doing, and he was good enough at it to make a very good living at it. In a
way I envy him since he was able to do something he loved dearly in the
last moments of his life.
Dave
Quoted text (7 lines)
>or should I say the designers and people who signed off on such a design are to >blame. in the moment it takes to sense the horror it was plain to see that by >angling the walls for emergency vehicle access ( ironic ) it would clearly lead >to highly inflated impact values. at their present angle the walls it looked >like almost a straight on hit for Greg. surely a reduction of the 20 degrees >that the walls are set on would make a difference, perhaps even here where the >tragedy of speed once again reminds me to live my life fully every day.Gimme a break! You're telling me that regardless of whether I skip off
a wall and lose 10% of my velocity or if I head-on the wall and lose
100% of my velocity the forces imparted on the car are the same --
they are just "distributed" differently. LOL
Randy
Quoted text (10 lines)
> While all of us are concerned with track safety, you're assumptions are >completely wrong. Force is determined by mass and velocity. Nothing >more. The angle of a wall has nothing to do with the impact forces a car >will sustain. The only thing it effects is how the force gets distributed >into the mass of the vehicle. >-- > | "Instead of letting the moon be the >Bill Mette | gateway to our future, we have let >Enteract, Chicago | it become a brief chapter in ourI hate to break it to you, but most oval track accidents, even the ones
that are "200 MPH" are really only 40-80 MPH accidents with the wall.
This has been confirmed via telemtry from actual CART crashes. The
*ONLY* thing that matters relative to the whole vehicle is your speed
relative to the wall. If you glance off a wall, only a portion of your
velocity is lateral. This is called the normal force in physics. Pick up
any physics text book and you'll see what I'm talking about. If you don't
believe me, ask some others who remember their phisics.
--
| "Instead of letting the moon be the
Bill Mette | gateway to our future, we have let
Enteract, Chicago | it become a brief chapter in our
Quoted text (15 lines)
>Gimme a break! You're telling me that regardless of whether I skip off a >wall and lose 10% of my velocity or if I head-on the wall and >lose 100% of my velocity the forces imparted on the car are the same -- >they are just "distributed" differently. LOL >Randy >> While all of us are concerned with track safety, you're assumptions >>are completely wrong. Force is determined by mass and velocity. >>Nothing more. The angle of a wall has nothing to do with the impact >>forces a car will sustain. The only thing it effects is how the force >>gets distributed into the mass of the vehicle.Quoted text (18 lines)
> > or should I say the designers and people who signed off on > > such a design are to blame. in the moment it takes to sense > > the horror it was plain to see that by angling the walls for > > emergency vehicle access ( ironic ) it would clearly lead to > > highly inflated impact values. at their present angle the > > walls it looked like almost a straight on hit for Greg. surely > > a reduction of the 20 degrees that the walls are set on would > > make a difference, perhaps even here where the tragedy of > > speed once again reminds me to live my life fully every day. > While all of us are concerned with track safety, you're > assumptions are completely wrong. Force is determined by mass > and velocity. Nothing more. The angle of a wall has nothing > to do with the impact forces a car will sustain. The only > thing it effects is how the force gets distributed into the > mass of the vehicle. > Bill Mette>Agreed in most cases. You can apply the triangle of forces to this
>situation.
>MS
Of course, the only thing that truely matters is the deceleration of the
brain and internal organs. This is the part that's insanely complex.
Things like which part of the car hit first, what the seat belts are
contructed of, the weight of the driver's helmet, etc... all play roles.
It's a morbid but very important field of study.
--
| "Instead of letting the moon be the
Bill Mette | gateway to our future, we have let
Enteract, Chicago | it become a brief chapter in our
I believe it was the turbocharger which killed him. He was off the turn and
headed straight, about where the turbo will really kick in, and the thing
looped on him. Same thing happened to another driver several laps before.
I have always hated turbo's. CART is the only series left that still uses
the damn things...
From what I hear, Greg had brushed the wall heading into turn 1 that lap and it
damaged the suspension or deflated a tire or something of that sort. That
caused him to spin out.
Dan Belcher
Team Racing Unlimited
http://members.xoom.com/simcrash1/simcrash
I think predicting what angle a car is going to hit a wall at is a big
problem. Ultimately, I'd bet it was the grass that killed him. The tires
dug into the turf and got him airborne and tipped him over. If the grass
were more smooth or paved over, maybe he would have slid into the wall
instead of flying into it, and would have lost some speed in the process.
And maybe he wouldn't have hit that wall sideways and head first. Although
since this is all in retrospect, I can't see blaming anyone for it. I'm
sure race track safety is an extremely complex topic and there's about a
million things we aren't taking into consideration here.
-A
>or should I say the designers and people who signed off on such a design are to
>blame. in the moment it takes to sense the horror it was plain to see that by
>angling the walls for emergency vehicle access ( ironic ) it would clearly lead
>to highly inflated impact values. at their present angle the walls it looked
>like almost a straight on hit for Greg. surely a reduction of the 20 degrees
>that the walls are set on would make a difference, perhaps even here where the
>tragedy of speed once again reminds me to live my life fully every day.
>jm
You originally said:
"The angle of a wall has nothing to do with the impact forces a car
will sustain. The only thing it effects is how the force gets
distributed into the mass of the vehicle."
It sounds like we are now saying the same thing... If you head-on a
wall it's completely different than skipping off. If the wall doesn't
absorb all the car's energy -- regardless of the relative velocity --
the the forces on the car will not be the same. How fast is the car
moving (retained energy) after the contact, this will matter.
Randy
Quoted text (28 lines)
> I hate to break it to you, but most oval track accidents, even the ones >that are "200 MPH" are really only 40-80 MPH accidents with the wall. >This has been confirmed via telemtry from actual CART crashes. The >*ONLY* thing that matters relative to the whole vehicle is your speed >relative to the wall. If you glance off a wall, only a portion of your >velocity is lateral. This is called the normal force in physics. Pick up >any physics text book and you'll see what I'm talking about. If you don't >believe me, ask some others who remember their phisics. >>Gimme a break! You're telling me that regardless of whether I skip off a >>wall and lose 10% of my velocity or if I head-on the wall and >>lose 100% of my velocity the forces imparted on the car are the same -- >>they are just "distributed" differently. LOL >>Randy >>> While all of us are concerned with track safety, you're assumptions >>>are completely wrong. Force is determined by mass and velocity. >>>Nothing more. The angle of a wall has nothing to do with the impact >>>forces a car will sustain. The only thing it effects is how the force >>>gets distributed into the mass of the vehicle. >-- > | "Instead of letting the moon be the >Bill Mette | gateway to our future, we have let >Enteract, Chicago | it become a brief chapter in ourWe've only been able to see the one replay of Moore's crash - whereas on
Hearne's incident a few laps earlier, there were multiple-camera replays. If
you watch the Hearne's incident from the in-car camera, you will see that
the car loses control as soon as Hearne's car enters the airflow directly
behind the car in front of him. Many drivers have been complaining for a
while now about the lack of grip, and more importantly the side-effects of
the Hanford device ("dirty air", where there is turbulence and reduced
downforce).
The following diagram (crudely) shows what I saw on the replay:
}{ <car in front of Hearne
}{ < Hearne (no problems yet)
---------
}{ <car in front of Hearne
}{ <Hearne (problems now!!)
Moore was reported to be in traffic (close to 4 cars?) at the time of his
incident. Another report suggested his tire hit the wall in Turn 1, and may
possibly have deflated. Still, I believe due to the uncanny similarity
between Moore's incident and Hearne's - that until/if any further evidence
is brought forward, I must conclude that whatever caused Hearne's similarly
caused Moore's loss of control (skid marks were almost identical.. only a
couple of metres separated them).
R. Hashana
Well if you want to get technical, the velocity must be split up into
components perpendicular and parallel to the wall and the perpendicular
component is the only one used in the calculation of force.
JB
> >or should I say the designers and people who signed off on such a design are to
> >blame. in the moment it takes to sense the horror it was plain to see that by
> >angling the walls for emergency vehicle access ( ironic ) it would clearly lead
> >to highly inflated impact values. at their present angle the walls it looked
> >like almost a straight on hit for Greg. surely a reduction of the 20 degrees
> >that the walls are set on would make a difference, perhaps even here where the
Quoted text (12 lines)
> >tragedy of speed once again reminds me to live my life fully every day. > While all of us are concerned with track safety, you're assumptions are > completely wrong. Force is determined by mass and velocity. Nothing > more. The angle of a wall has nothing to do with the impact forces a car > will sustain. The only thing it effects is how the force gets distributed > into the mass of the vehicle. > -- > | "Instead of letting the moon be the > Bill Mette | gateway to our future, we have let > Enteract, Chicago | it become a brief chapter in ourIn reality it was not the wall that did Moore in, it was the access
road.
Both Hearn's car and Moore's cars became airborne as they bounced over
the raised access road. Hearn's stayed upright, but Moore's flipped when
it hit the access road. Without the road he would have hit at a shallow
angle still upright and the accident might not have been fatal!
buzard
Quoted text (35 lines)
> Well if you want to get technical, the velocity must be split up into > components perpendicular and parallel to the wall and the perpendicular > component is the only one used in the calculation of force. > JB > > >or should I say the designers and people who signed off on such a design > are to > > >blame. in the moment it takes to sense the horror it was plain to see > that by > > >angling the walls for emergency vehicle access ( ironic ) it would > clearly lead > > >to highly inflated impact values. at their present angle the walls it > looked > > >like almost a straight on hit for Greg. surely a reduction of the 20 > degrees > > >that the walls are set on would make a difference, perhaps even here > where the > > >tragedy of speed once again reminds me to live my life fully every day. > > While all of us are concerned with track safety, you're assumptions are > > completely wrong. Force is determined by mass and velocity. Nothing > > more. The angle of a wall has nothing to do with the impact forces a car > > will sustain. The only thing it effects is how the force gets distributed > > into the mass of the vehicle. > > -- > > | "Instead of letting the moon be the > > Bill Mette | gateway to our future, we have let > > Enteract, Chicago | it become a brief chapter in our> >or should I say the designers and people who signed off on such a design are to
> >blame. in the moment it takes to sense the horror it was plain to see that by
> >angling the walls for emergency vehicle access ( ironic ) it would clearly lead
> >to highly inflated impact values. at their present angle the walls it looked
> >like almost a straight on hit for Greg. surely a reduction of the 20 degrees
> >that the walls are set on would make a difference, perhaps even here where the
> >tragedy of speed once again reminds me to live my life fully every day.
> While all of us are concerned with track safety, you're assumptions are
> completely wrong. Force is determined by mass and velocity. Nothing
That's not correct. It's determined by mass and difference of velocity
(more accurately, difference between vectors of velocity) before
and after impact.
When the car hits the wall while the angle between the velocity vector
and the surface of the wall is 90 degree, its velocity after impact will be
0 or rather small value with the opposite direction. If the car hits the
wall
while that angle is 20 degrees, it will continue to move after impact
slightly
slower, and the direction of the movement will turn at 20-40 degrees,
so the force of the impact will be approximately the same as if it has hit
the wall
at 90 degrees while moving with the velocity x times smaller
(x = 1/sin( 20 degrees) = approx 3). Three times slower speed makes a big
difference.
Sorry for my english.
Richie Hearn's accident was at virtually the same speed and angle of
impact but he walked away. As you say elsewhere in the message, it was
being launched and hitting the wall while in the air that killed Moore.
- Michael


































