Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

GPL track database, Game/Wheel/vid vendors should step up to the plate

8 posts by 5 people · 20 Nov 2003 16:42 UTC - 21 Nov 2003 11:53 UTC

mcewena 20 Nov 2003 16:42 UTC#49089
Hands up if you bought a wheel just to play GPL? Hands up if you wore it out and bought a new wheel just to play GPL? Hands up if you bought a video board just to play GPL? Well chances are Microsoft, Logitec, Actlabs or Thrustmaster etc.. wouldn't have got your money without the hard work and development (and ISP fees) provided by the likes of Alison Hine, Magnus (what is his last name?), Larry Holbert and countless others whose names deserve mention but escape me at the moment. It's people like that who are responsible for taking a good tittle and making it great. Without them you'd probably never have bought your wheel in the first place. You could probably argue that without the GPL community Papy, EA etc.. wouldn't have invested the development effort in what grew to be NR2003, F12002 etc... It's understandable that these people move on eventually and nobody should hold them to a life time commitment for our enjoyment once it starts to feel like a chore to them. But there's got to be some way to take what's been built now, such as the track database and all the add-on tracks and graphics, and inevitably GPLrank and save it before it's lost. That's where the manufacturers come in. The webspace that would be required to maintain the existing track data base and other resources that are slowly fading away would cost them nothing in the corporate grand scheme of things and it would keep us enjoying the game until we wear out our current wheels. I know if brand X stepped up to the plate they'd be the first wheel I'd consider when my current Thrustmaster turns it's last corner. I originally thought that's the sort of thing FILSCA was going to do for the community but they got so bogged down in governance structures and they seemed to think that for profit companies had no place in internet gaming that it came to nothing.
mcewena wrote in news:[email hidden]:
Quoted text (40 lines)> Hands up if you bought a wheel just to play GPL? > > Hands up if you wore it out and bought a new wheel just to play > GPL? > > Hands up if you bought a video board just to play GPL? > > > Well chances are Microsoft, Logitec, Actlabs or Thrustmaster etc.. > wouldn't have got your money without the hard work and development > (and ISP fees) provided by the likes of Alison Hine, Magnus (what > is his last name?), Larry Holbert and countless others whose names > deserve mention but escape me at the moment. It's people like > that who are responsible for taking a good tittle and making it > great. Without them you'd probably never have bought your wheel in > the first place. You could probably argue that without the GPL > community Papy, EA etc.. wouldn't have invested the development > effort in what grew to be NR2003, F12002 etc... > > It's understandable that these people move on eventually and > nobody should hold them to a life time commitment for our > enjoyment once it starts to feel like a chore to them. > > But there's got to be some way to take what's been built now, such > as the track database and all the add-on tracks and graphics, and > inevitably GPLrank and save it before it's lost. That's where the > manufacturers come in. The webspace that would be required to > maintain the existing track data base and other resources that are > slowly fading away would cost them nothing in the corporate grand > scheme of things and it would keep us enjoying the game until we > wear out our current wheels. > > I know if brand X stepped up to the plate they'd be the first > wheel I'd consider when my current Thrustmaster turns it's last > corner. > > I originally thought that's the sort of thing FILSCA was going to > do for the community but they got so bogged down in governance > structures and they seemed to think that for profit companies had > no place in internet gaming that it came to nothing.
In an ideal world, I'd like to think that what you seem to be asking for would be forthcoming. Unfortunately, this is not an ideal world. Until someone with marketing skills puts on a suit and calls on the executives at some of the companies you mention, it isn't going to happen. (And it might not happen even if this mythical marketing wiz were to go calling.) And if it did happen -- especially if it were Microsoft that stepped in -- there'd be so much complaining about it that I suspect they'd soon step back out again. My take -- for what little it's worth -- is that if you want to save some of the online resources, then you're going to have to do it yourself. (Where "doing it yourself" may involve getting some friends together to help you raise money and whatever else it takes.) Despite the cynical tone of my reply, I'd like to join you in saying that I also would hate to see these resources disappear. If you do manage to think of some way to save them, please let the rest of us know. If nothing else, you'll have lots of moral support! All the best, -- Darryl
"mcewena" wrote... > Hands up if you bought a wheel just to play GPL? Check. > Hands up if you wore it out and bought a new wheel just to play GPL? Check. And another. And another. > Hands up if you bought a video board just to play GPL? Yup. > Well chances are Microsoft, Logitec, Actlabs or > Thrustmaster etc.. wouldn't have got your money > without the hard work and development (and ISP > fees) provided by the likes of Alison Hine, > Magnus (what is his last name?), Thome
Quoted text (10 lines)> Larry Holbert and countless others whose names > deserve mention but escape me at the moment. > It's people like that who are responsible for > taking a good tittle and making it great. > Without them you'd probably never have bought > your wheel in the first place. You could > probably argue that without the GPL community > Papy, EA etc.. wouldn't have invested the > development effort in what grew to be NR2003, > F12002 etc...
Exactly... and that's the reward one gets for putting one's time/money in. > It's understandable that these people move on > eventually and nobody should hold them to a > life time commitment for our enjoyment once it > starts to feel like a chore to them. Equally true, but I think we are entitled to an explanation as to why they're pulling out, even if it is "it's become a chore". This situation smells like a tantrum to me, but even that is unconfirmed. And don't go RaceSimCentral on me and tell me I can't be annoyed at that. If your local library took out a commercial on regional television urging people to visit the library and borrow books and you went there two days later to find an empty building with a notice saying "we're taking a break from being librarians and can't be contacted.", wouldn't that annoy you?
Quoted text (15 lines)> But there's got to be some way to take what's been > built now, such as the track database and all the > add-on tracks and graphics, and inevitably GPLrank > and save it before it's lost. That's where the > manufacturers come in. > The webspace that would be required to maintain the > existing track data base and other resources that are > slowly fading away would cost them nothing in the > corporate grand scheme of things and it would keep us > enjoying the game until we wear out our current > wheels. > > I know if brand X stepped up to the plate they'd be > the first wheel I'd consider when my current > Thrustmaster turns it's last corner.
I don't think this one's a matter of lack of hosting opportunities, but you have a point. Unfortunately I think it's very unlikely any sort of major player is going to step up to safeguard the GPL heritage, but on the other hand the community has been doing a good job in keeping major sites alive, provided the original owner was willing to pass on the torch. > I originally thought that's the sort of thing FILSCA > was going to do for the community but they got so > bogged down in governance structures and they seemed > to think that for profit companies had no place in > internet gaming that it came to nothing. I think it's hard to develop something like that from the top down. Jan. =---
> If > your local library took out a commercial on regional television urging > people to visit the library and borrow books and you went there two days > later to find an empty building with a notice saying "we're taking a break > from being librarians and can't be contacted.", wouldn't that annoy you? > Especially if your taxes supported said library. > I don't think this one's a matter of lack of hosting opportunities, butyou > have a point. Yes the database is more then hosting but how many add-ons are gone too so it would be a start. I don't know how to do it but limping along from one overworked volunteer to another can't be the answer either.
Jan Verschueren wrote: ...
Quoted text (10 lines)> Equally true, but I think we are entitled to an explanation as to why > they're pulling out, even if it is "it's become a chore". > > This situation smells like a tantrum to me, but even that is unconfirmed. > > And don't go RaceSimCentral on me and tell me I can't be annoyed at that. If > your local library took out a commercial on regional television urging > people to visit the library and borrow books and you went there two days > later to find an empty building with a notice saying "we're taking a break > from being librarians and can't be contacted.", wouldn't that annoy you?
I don't think we're entitled to anything. What should that be based on? Magnus has provided a wonderful service to the community for free (AAMOF he probably even invested some money), but did the community ever give anything back to him that would constitute a basis for a claim to receive an explanation when Magnus ceases to provide that service? And we have no right to be annoyed either. For years when we saw that ad and went to the library, there was great stuff there. Now one single time, two days after an ad, the building was empty. Considering the relative percentages of having found great stuff, and finding an empty building, we better be quiet and thank Magnus for what he's done for us :) Achim
"Joachim Trensz" wrote...
Quoted text (9 lines)> Jan Verschueren wrote: > > <snip> > I don't think we're entitled to anything. What should > that be based on? Magnus has provided a wonderful > service to the community for free (AAMOF he probably > even invested some money), but did the community ever give > anything back to him that would constitute a basis for a > claim to receive an explanation when Magnus ceases to > provide that service?
Because it's just plain rude not to. I admin a fairly obscure GPL league. If I'm ever in a position where I have to give up on it or don't enjoy doing it anymore I will have the decency to let my members know how things stand. I also realise that having the league is more than just a set of tasks I have to perform. It's a force that binds my members together. I would therefore allow them to build from where I left off. What I wouldn't do is pull the site and put an "I hate the world" message on RSC. Because that's what bothers me... if Magnus, for whatever reason, wants to give up on the Track Database and not allow others to build on his work, that's fine. No problem, if he'd just own up to it. I'm sure there's a couple guys on RSC who know exactly where he's coming from and who sympathise, but 99.999% of the visitors to his site are now thinking "WTF did I ever do to this guy?" and that _ANNOYS_ me. Then again, what was I thinking expecting rational behavior from someone heavily involved with the GPLRally concept... <vbg>
Quoted text (7 lines)> And we have no right to be annoyed either. For years > when we saw that ad and went to the library, there was > great stuff there. Now one single time, two days after > an ad, the building was empty. Considering the relative > percentages of having found great stuff, and finding an > empty building, we better be quiet and thank Magnus for > what he's done for us :)
Magnus saw a job that needed doing and he did it... what did he expect? -A statue? I do stuff for the simracing community too (so do Art, Asgeir, Mark, Fulvio, Pascal, Darius, Tim, Stefan, Helmut, Benoit, Alain, Sebastien, Mitch, Dave, Eldred and many more...). I invest time, money and expertise to advance simracing as a hobby/sport. Do I expect something in return? -No. Would I willingly let my efforts go to waste? -No, regardless of who or what pissed me off. I'll tell you what I got out of it so far (apart from personal satisfaction): I got a corner on a fictional GPL Track named after me. An uphill, off camber, decreasing radius left which you can't break in a straight line for. The ultimate combination of corner characteristics I'm not comfortable with. Woooo-freaking-hoo! Does that bother me? -No. Like I said, I don't like being told who or what I can or can't be annoyed with. If Magnus has a problem with what I say, he knows where to find me. As far as I'm concerned, in the simracing community, you either do nothing, do something yourself and keep doing it or help someone else doing it in your place. And now, if you'll excuse me, I'll get back to doing more important stuff (I wouldn't even have missed the Track DB until March next year at the earliest). I don't see why I should be the one explaning myself over this. Jan. =---
Bravo, Achim! I salute Magnus. I loved his database, used it all the time, and *probably* would have made a monetary donation if I didn't have a squinty-eyed suspicion of PayPal (since proven all too true). If the site is gone, I mourn its passing. It was great while it lasted. Thanks, Magnus! "Joachim Trensz" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:bpjlhv$1q39vd$[email hidden]... > Jan Verschueren wrote: > ... > > Equally true, but I think we are entitled to an explanation as to why > > they're pulling out, even if it is "it's become a chore". > > > > This situation smells like a tantrum to me, but even that isunconfirmed. > > > > And don't go RaceSimCentral on me and tell me I can't be annoyed atthat. If > > your local library took out a commercial on regional television urging > > people to visit the library and borrow books and you went there two days > > later to find an empty building with a notice saying "we're taking abreak
Quoted text (16 lines)> > from being librarians and can't be contacted.", wouldn't that annoy you? > > I don't think we're entitled to anything. What should that be based on? > Magnus has provided a wonderful service to the community for free (AAMOF > he probably even invested some money), but did the community ever give > anything back to him that would constitute a basis for a claim to > receive an explanation when Magnus ceases to provide that service? > > And we have no right to be annoyed either. For years when we saw that ad > and went to the library, there was great stuff there. Now one single > time, two days after an ad, the building was empty. Considering the > relative percentages of having found great stuff, and finding an empty > building, we better be quiet and thank Magnus for what he's done for us :) > > Achim >
Hi Jan > Because it's just plain rude not to It perhaps looks rude at first sight, but we all don't know what happened. IMO we should give Magnus some leeway for all the great work he's done for us. > I admin a fairly obscure GPL league. If I'm ever in a position > where I have to give up on it or don't enjoy doing it anymore IMO you can't compare that. Being a league admin is a position you got by accepting a vote, or the job when it was offered to you. Or you started the league attracting people based on the inherent promise you'd do the job. Magnus was offering his site all by himself, no responsibilities offered, and none accepted. > I got a corner on a fictional GPL Track named after me. An > uphill, off camber, decreasing radius left which you can't break in a > straight line for. The ultimate combination of corner characteristics I'm > not comfortable with. Woooo-freaking-hoo! Does that bother me? -No. Tough luck ;) but aren't you a little ungrateful to the guy who named that corner after you? ;) > If Magnus has a problem with what I say, he knows where to find me. As > far as I'm concerned, in the simracing community, you either do nothing, do > something yourself and keep doing it or help someone else doing it in your > place. I wouldn't take that personally? It is difficult to provide public services selectively, most of us probably simply got caught out by a prob we didn't have anything to do with, I'd guess? Maybe Magnus is moving on to N2k3 - Magnus, we need you there! ;) > And now, if you'll excuse me Dismissed ;) Achim

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy