Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

Resting on their laurels?

28 posts by 16 people · 06 Sep 1999 - 17 Sep 1999

Are the big sim makers resting on their laurels?

John Bodin argued that with GP3 and NASCAR Racing 3 both built on older engines, the established developers were coasting, and that newcomers such as Ratbag with Dirt Track Racing and Motorsims with AMA Superbike could take over. Others added MGI, makers of Viper Racing, while Tracey Miller feared it was the beginning of the end for high-quality sims as consoles grew stronger. Posters also discussed the demise of the Can-Am series and Motorsims' planned Can-Am title, and corrected the history of Papyrus's engines.

industry/businessrumour/speculation

Automated summary.

John Bodin 06 Sep 1999#490551
With Hasbro's GP3 looking more and more like an update of GP2 (reports indicate that it's going to be based on the GP2 engine with 3D graphics support) and Papyrus' NASCAR3 being based on the N2 engine (which was based on ICR2, essentially), it looks more and more like the big guns are really resting on their laurels. When this happens in any industry, it usually means that the big guns are ready to be knocked off their pedestals. There are at least two companies waiting in the wings that may be poised to unseat the current leaders: Ratbag and Motorsims. Ratbag's Dirt Track Racing should have a wide range of appeal (oval tracks with late-model stock cars) and a broad audience (it will feature an arcade mode, but the default mode will reportely be pure sim) -- AND it should be the first race sim ever (I believe) to offer a "spectator mode" for non-participants. Ratbag's first virtual racing title, Powerslide, was a very solid entry into the arcade racer with a physics model that's better than many titles that claim to be "sims." These guys could set the industry on its ear. Motorsims is also a strong contender, with their AMA Superbikes and Can-Am titles on the horizon. Motorsims has a strong background in online ***, so the AMA and Can-Am titles may distract quite a few people from places like TEN and VROC. Any NASCAR title will always have a dedicated following, but if Motorsims does it right, N3's online capabilities may pale in comparison. Plus, Motorsims is also plugged-into the concept of a "spectator mode" for non-participants, so this is also going to be a big draw for their titles. There are othe developers and other titles brewing right now, but Ratbag and Motorsims may be the first to show the current leaders that it's not safe to just rest on your laurels when you're on top. No matter what the outcome of all this, it looks like we're going to be the winners -- based on the diversity and sophistication that we're beginning to see in race sims, we may one day look back and refer to this time the golden age of sim racing. I know I'm e***d! -- John Bodin Publisher, The IRL Insider Magazine http://irlinsider.adnetweb.com/
don hodgdon 06 Sep 1999#490552
<snip> Now that the SCCA has killed off the USRRC and the Can-Am once again, I wonder if there will be a Can-Am sim, or will Motorsims line up a license agreement with either Bill France and his new Grand American series or Don Panozs' ALMS. don [|]-(_)-[|]
Tom Pabst 07 Sep 1999#490858
Thank you John for some insightful thoughts on the current state of affairs in the motor racing simulation software industry. I couldn't agree more.......there's going to be a new "king" of motorsims. I would only add to your list of contenders those "Viper" guys over at MGI. They have a new "deep pockets" publisher and have been quietly but diligently working away almost since the "close" of the Viper Racing project on their new "baby." Promising to be a motor racing simulation "blockbuster," look for a beta ready to go in Q1 to Q2 time period next year. Remember, these are the same guys who quietly produced the #2 physics model simulation.....Viper Racing.....to Dave Kaemmer's "king of the hill" GPL p-model. No one else has come as close to GPL as MGI......and frankly, its my opinion there isn't even a #3 p-model (at this time) on the market. This all sort of reminds me of the television industry in 1955. Color TV won't even be out for a couple more years. And Sierra is acting much like the guy who 44 years ago said, "Huh? Color TV? No way, people will never want color on their television sets.....its just a passing fad at best.....the "market" just isn't big enough to justify it!" Wouldn't it be cool if Sierra could do all of sim racing a huge favor and actually fire Dave Kaemmer.....and give him, as his "parting gift"......give him the "rights" to his p-model to do with as he pleases! Heck, they don't seem to value it anyway, nor do I think they intend to use it at any time in the near future (don't look for it on the N2000 or N4 release......they'll surely come up with another excuse why they couldn't put it on that sim too). Thanks John, keep that good stuff coming! Tom Pabst
> No matter what the outcome of all this, it looks like we're going to be the > winners -- based on the diversity and sophistication that we're beginning to > see in race sims, we may one day look back and refer to this time the golden > age of sim racing. I know I'm e***d! Very nice. I agree with everything except for your conclusion. I think we may look back upon this as the beginning of the end, rather than the "golden age" of sim racing. We may have seen our last "3 years in development" GPL type of quality sim. I don't believe it's coincidence that both Hasbro and Sierra dumbed down these latest offerings to rush them out the door. The real bad news is these games are going to sell. They will sell partially because of the reputation of the GPx and NASCAR x series, but also since they are by default the best simulators of the motor sport they are simulating.The two companies will come to the conclusion that dumbing down was a great idea, and dumb down their next releases even more. The future of sim racing depends not on good sale for these two offerings, but on the sales of newcomers like Dirt Track Racing and AMA Superbike. If arcade gamers shy away from the "sim" platform, or sim enthusiasts shy away from the lack of a big name racing series being simulated, then another wrong message will be send to game publishers: the sim market is dead. Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ Share what you know. Learn what you don't.
>Ratbag's Dirt Track Racing should have a wide range of appeal (oval tracks >with late-model stock cars) and a broad audience (it will feature an arcade >mode, but the default mode will reportely be pure sim) -- AND it should be Hmm ... I can't see oval track dirt racing appealing to too many simmers outside US. Or maybe it's just me :) Hena
John Bodin 07 Sep 1999#490861
Tom, Geez, I forgot all about the MGI guys -- I would KILL to know what they are working on! I also agree with you about their efforts on Viper Racing -- VERY excellent physics engine. I'm still playing with Viper Racing quite a bit -- I ran a 20-lap race against 15 AI cars last night at Rock Island for the CompuServe Viper Club, and MAN was that an experience! GPL isn't the only sim out there with a lock on 4-wheel drift; I can tell you that because there was plenty of that going on last night at Rock Island! <G> -- JB >Thank you John for some insightful thoughts on the current state of affairs in >the motor racing simulation software industry. I couldn't agree >more.......there's going to be a new "king" of motorsims. >I would only add to your list of contenders those "Viper" guys over at MGI. >They have a new "deep pockets" publisher and have been quietly but diligently >working away almost since the "close" of the Viper Racing project on their new >"baby." Promising to be a motor racing simulation "blockbuster," look for a >beta ready to go in Q1 to Q2 time period next year. Remember, these are the >same guys who quietly produced the #2 physics model simulation.....Viper >Racing.....to Dave Kaemmer's "king of the hill" GPL p-model. No one else has >come as close to GPL as MGI......and frankly, its my opinion there isn't even a >#3 p-model (at this time) on the market. >This all sort of reminds me of the television industry in 1955. Color TV won't >even be out for a couple more years. And Sierra is acting much like the guy who >44 years ago said, "Huh? Color TV? No way, people will never want color on >their television sets.....its just a passing fad at best.....the "market" just >isn't big enough to justify it!" Wouldn't it be cool if Sierra could do all of >sim racing a huge favor and actually fire Dave Kaemmer.....and give him, as his >"parting gift"......give him the "rights" to his p-model to do with as he >pleases! Heck, they don't seem to value it anyway, nor do I think they intend >to use it at any time in the near future (don't look for it on the N2000 or N4 >release......they'll surely come up with another excuse why they couldn't put it >on that sim too). >Thanks John, keep that good stuff coming! >Tom Pabst
John Bodin 07 Sep 1999#490862
Tracey, There's a definite attraction to games that have a major-league tie-in, to be sure; F1 and NASCAR sims will always have their markets, but given licensing problems, etc., that come with major-league affiliation, I think we're going to see more and more "brown bag" racing titles. Flight sims don't have licensing problems: ANYBODY can be "the official flight sim of WWII," but only a chosen few can obtain the NASCAR or F1 license. Still, when sims like Viper Racing can bring us a variety of tracks, good AI, great physics, and awesome racing all with a single license, there's no reason to believe that it couldn't be done sans license altogether. I believe that DTR will feature "generic" street stocks, but from the screen shots I've seen, they sure look close enough to old Chevelles, Buicks, etc., to be satisfying to me. If the racing is good and the sim aspects are top-notch, I don't think it needs the "NASCAR" label to be a success. Part of the secret lies in finding something that appeals to the masses, and something that is more accessible to Joe Average than GPL (both from the appeal and the difficulty standpoint) -- and a GOOD sim with a scalable difficulty level plus a built-in "arcade" mode definitely could be accessible across the board, regardless of your skill level. I think you're right, though -- we may never see another GPL. And that may not be all bad -- if they can manage to produce things that are GPL-caliber with a broader range of appeal, then then sim racing might finally begin to really prosper. -- JB
Quoted text (32 lines)>> No matter what the outcome of all this, it looks like we're going to >be the >> winners -- based on the diversity and sophistication that we're >beginning to >> see in race sims, we may one day look back and refer to this time the >golden >> age of sim racing. I know I'm e***d! >Very nice. I agree with everything except for your conclusion. I think >we may look back upon this as the beginning of the end, rather than the >"golden age" of sim racing. >We may have seen our last "3 years in development" GPL type of quality >sim. I don't believe it's coincidence that both Hasbro and Sierra >dumbed down these latest offerings to rush them out the door. The real >bad news is these games are going to sell. >They will sell partially because of the reputation of the GPx and >NASCAR x series, but also since they are by default the best simulators >of the motor sport they are simulating.The two companies will come to >the conclusion that dumbing down was a great idea, and dumb down their >next releases even more. >The future of sim racing depends not on good sale for these two >offerings, but on the sales of newcomers like Dirt Track Racing and AMA >Superbike. If arcade gamers shy away from the "sim" platform, or sim >enthusiasts shy away from the lack of a big name racing series being >simulated, then another wrong message will be send to game publishers: >the sim market is dead. >Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ >Share what you know. Learn what you don't.
Whilst I agree with much of what you say, I'm not quite so negative about the longer term outlook. In fact a short term reduction in interest in cutting edge sims from the major publishers could easily prove very beneficial in the longer term.... Cheers, Richard
The Mocke 07 Sep 1999#490864
I know I am looking forward to DTR. (But we have already established that I am the consumate ugly American) And I think it will have a wide appeal. If the competition is good people will play. I remember a great game for the Amiga (and PC I think) Stunt Track Racer. Totally unrealistic, but a great game, excellent to play in a null-modem race. If games have that level of fun AND have some real-world physics it seems likes it's a can't miss, regardless if you are lucky enough to have real dirt oval racing in your area. Personally I don't think a game like AMA will have such a broad appeal. I haven't been to any bike races, but they suffer from the same problems that all road racing suffers from, low attendance. (At least here in the states.) Goodyear publishes some figures for some racing series, they don't cover the AMA however, I guess Goodyear tires are not used that much in the AMA. Here is the link to that information. http://www.goodyear.com/us/racing/98attend.html I would also like to know if anyone knows the web site that has a list of upcoming racing/auto-sim games. I seem to remember seeing this, but I have lost the link. I heard that Infogrames has some type of demolition derby game on it's schedule, and would like to find out more about this. I also had heard about a Legend car sim. I thought from MGI, but I could be wrong. -- The Mocker *****LEGAL NOTICE TO ALL BULK E-MAILERS***** NOTICE TO BULK EMAILERS: Pursuant to US Code, Title 47, Chapter 5, Subchapter II, 227, any and all nonsolicited commercial E-mail sent to this address is subject to a download and archival fee in the amount of $500 US. E-mailing denotes acceptance of these terms.
John 07 Sep 1999#490865
They are working on a Nascar simulation if I remember. There is a case study about them using a 3D scanning tool to model a Nascar for an upcoming game. Thanks, John
Gee, that last statement reminds me of rick from the TEN newsgroup with all his Y2K doom prophecy! I doubt it. Maybe not from Sierra or Papyrus, but there are still others out there willing to do such a thing. Not to mention, developers come and go all the time. I think thats being a bit drastic.
> Gee, that last statement reminds me of rick from the TEN newsgroup with all > his Y2K doom prophecy! I'm not talking about the end of civilization, or even the end of racing games, there will always be a niche for fill-in-the-blank Madness, or the NFS type of games, but realistic simulators may disappear. With the new consoles coming out that rival the capabilities of PC's, it make not be too long before the entire PC *** market dries up, but that's another discussion. Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ Share what you know. Learn what you don't.
I hope to god not. The market is already saturated with Nascar games. > They are working on a Nascar simulation if I remember. There is a case study > about them using a 3D scanning tool to model a Nascar for an upcoming game.
Quoted text (11 lines)> Thanks, > John > > Tom, > > Geez, I forgot all about the MGI guys -- I would KILL to know what they > are > > working on! I also agree with you about their efforts on Viper
Racing -- > > VERY excellent physics engine. I'm still playing with Viper Racing quite > a > > bit -- I ran a 20-lap race against 15 AI cars last night at Rock Island > for > > the CompuServe Viper Club, and MAN was that an experience! GPL isn't the > > only sim out there with a lock on 4-wheel drift; I can tell you that > because > > there was plenty of that going on last night at Rock Island! <G> > > -- JB
How is "the market" saturated with NASCAR games? There are less then 5 sims out there, that is not saturated. -Stuart Becktell Racing guy at www.gamewire.org ICQ # 18183832
Quoted text (19 lines)> I hope to god not. The market is already saturated with Nascar games. > > They are working on a Nascar simulation if I remember. There is a case > study > > about them using a 3D scanning tool to model a Nascar for an upcoming > game. > > Thanks, > > John > > > Tom, > > > Geez, I forgot all about the MGI guys -- I would KILL to know what
they
Quoted text (7 lines)> > are > > > working on! I also agree with you about their efforts on Viper > Racing -- > > > VERY excellent physics engine. I'm still playing with Viper Racing > quite > > a > > > bit -- I ran a 20-lap race against 15 AI cars last night at Rock
Island
Quoted text (8 lines)> > for > > > the CompuServe Viper Club, and MAN was that an experience! GPL isn't > the > > > only sim out there with a lock on 4-wheel drift; I can tell you that > > because > > > there was plenty of that going on last night at Rock Island! <G> > > > -- JB
John Bodin 07 Sep 1999#490870
I'd heard of the demise of the USRRC and Can-Am, but I was kind of hoping that the CanAm title would still be a "go." I mean, if the series is now defunct, doesn't that simply qualify it as a "retro" sim candidate now? <G> I'm kidding, of course, but if the series is gone and Motorsims still holds the rights to a game, couldn't they STILL produce the sim (as a "retro" sim, perhaps)? Actually, they could just s***the "modern" Can-Am version they were working on and just go straight to the REAL retro ('70s) Can-Am sim that was supposed to be a follow-on. Just a thought (hope). -- JB ><snip> >>Motorsims is also a strong contender, with their AMA Superbikes and Can-Am >>titles on the horizon. Motorsims has a strong background in online ***,
Quoted text (19 lines)>>so the AMA and Can-Am titles may distract quite a few people from places >>like TEN and VROC. Any NASCAR title will always have a dedicated >following, >>but if Motorsims does it right, N3's online capabilities may pale in >>comparison. Plus, Motorsims is also plugged-into the concept of a >>"spectator mode" for non-participants, so this is also going to be a big >>draw for their titles. >>-- John Bodin >> Publisher, The IRL Insider Magazine >> http://irlinsider.adnetweb.com/ >Now that the SCCA has killed off the USRRC and the Can-Am once again, I >wonder if there will be a Can-Am sim, or will Motorsims line up a license >agreement with either Bill France and his new Grand American series or Don >Panozs' ALMS. >don >[|]-(_)-[|]
don hodgdon 07 Sep 1999#490871
I would think that if Motorsims is still interested in a Can Am sim, it's all up to the SCCA at this point. The SCCA still owns the Can Am name and they are notoriously difficult to deal with. I too hope we get a retro Can Am sim someday, there is nothing I would rather try than a Chaparral up through the esses at Riverside! don [|]-(_)-[|] >I'd heard of the demise of the USRRC and Can-Am, but I was kind of hoping >that the CanAm title would still be a "go." I mean, if the series is now >defunct, doesn't that simply qualify it as a "retro" sim candidate now? <G> >I'm kidding, of course, but if the series is gone and Motorsims still holds >the rights to a game, couldn't they STILL produce the sim (as a "retro" sim, >perhaps)? Actually, they could just s***the "modern" Can-Am version they >were working on and just go straight to the REAL retro ('70s) Can-Am sim >that was supposed to be a follow-on. Just a thought (hope). >-- JB
> >Ratbag's Dirt Track Racing should have a wide range of appeal (oval tracks > >with late-model stock cars) and a broad audience (it will feature an arcade > >mode, but the default mode will reportely be pure sim) -- AND it should be > Hmm ... I can't see oval track dirt racing appealing to too many simmers > outside US. Or maybe it's just me :) Well as a brit (scot), I'm ashamed to admit that some of the best AI racing I ever did, in terms of adrenalin and excitment, was in papy's original ICR at New Hampshire. 32 cars doing 180mph on a 1 mile oval certainly gave some good overtaking opportunities. Couple that with a damage model that meant almost any touch would see you with at least a puncture and you have tense, tense stuff. -- Suck The Goat
Kirk Lane 07 Sep 1999#490873
Frankly, I haven't noticed a huge difference between any of Papy's sims (GPL excluded of course) from ICR1 to N1999. GP3 there looks a LOT like GP2. More than I'd like it to. The only pseudo-advantage would be that it in theory shouldn't be hard to port the GP2 stuff to GP3... I never thought I'd say this, but I hope that Papy dies (or manages to break free of Sierra's corporate mindset). 'Holding off on GPL-Based NASCAR sims because PC's can't run it'??? Heck, I ran ICR1 on a P90 with 8MB of RAM (pretty good for '94) with no graphics on!!! I don't give a rat's behind if Joe Shmoe's P166 won't run it!!! If it supports D3d or Rendition, I can run it fast. I betcha that if Papy hadn't been bought we'd be begging for N4, ICR5, and Indy Car Legends (GPL, NL, so of course ICL :) You know, on a side note, I think Sierra/Papy could stand to make a LOT of money if they took the GPL-engine and added in provisions for it to be 'adjusted' to different carmodels. You buy the 'base set' which includes the engine and say the NASCAR addon. Then, the addons include all of the physics data for the cars, and the engine models them. You could even then include a 'dumbed down' version for the non-simmers out there. When it comes to racing sims, bigger ain't better. Go Ratbag and Motorsims. I've always wanted a dirt track racing game. I'm buyin this one. Yes, online is definitely a big draw these days. And if it turns out to be even better than GPL's or N3's, all the better. Isn't that what we've been screaming about since we heard N3 was using N2 physics? :) Heck yeah!!! -- Kirk Lane ICQ: 28171652 BRT #187 "I read dead Russian authors volumes at a time I write everything down except what's on my mind 'Cause my greatest fear is the sucking sound And then I know I'll never get back out" -'Narcolepsy', Third Eye Blind
This is NOT the end of realistic simulators, racing or otherwise. And yeah, consoles are getting better, but they still are very limited in what they can and can't do.
Quoted text (9 lines)>> Hmm ... I can't see oval track dirt racing appealing to too many simmers >> outside US. Or maybe it's just me :) >Well as a brit (scot), I'm ashamed to admit that some of the best AI >racing I ever did, in terms of adrenalin and excitment, was in papy's >original ICR at New Hampshire. 32 cars doing 180mph on a 1 mile oval >certainly gave some good overtaking opportunities. Couple that with a >damage model that meant almost any touch would see you with at least a >puncture and you have tense, tense stuff.
No shame in that! I remember doing a 200-lapper at Loudon with both ICR and ICR2. That was intense and fun! In general, I enjoy watching CART races on an oval. But watching (or playing) stock cars on a dirt track going circles ... couldn't care less :) But like I said, maybe it's just me ... Hena
EldredP 10 Sep 1999#491615
>> Very nice. I agree with everything except for your conclusion. I think >> we may look back upon this as the beginning of the end, rather than the >> "golden age" of sim racing. >Gee, that last statement reminds me of rick from the TEN newsgroup with all >his Y2K doom prophecy! He was on TEN, too? I remember him from alt.games.starcraft. <g> __ Own Grand Prix Legends? Goto http://gpl.gamestats.com/vroc If all the world's a stage, where is the audience sitting? remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
EldredP 10 Sep 1999#491616
Quoted text (10 lines)>How is "the market" saturated with NASCAR games? There are less then 5 sims >out there, that is not saturated. >-Stuart Becktell >Racing guy at www.gamewire.org >ICQ # 18183832 >> I hope to god not. The market is already saturated with Nascar games.
Ok, there are more nascar titles than any OTHER series. How's that? <g> Don't get me wrong, I'll probably by THEIRS too, but I'd really like a CART sim right now... Eldred __ Own Grand Prix Legends? Goto http://gpl.gamestats.com/vroc If all the world's a stage, where is the audience sitting? remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
> Don't get me wrong, I'll probably by THEIRS too, but I'd really like > a CART sim right now... Don't say that too loud, Electronic Arts might be listening. <G> A QUALITY CART sim would be long over due. Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ Share what you know. Learn what you don't.
EldredP 11 Sep 1999#491799
>> Don't get me wrong, I'll probably by THEIRS too, but I'd really like >> a CART sim right now... >Don't say that too loud, Electronic Arts might be listening. <G> The sad part is, I'd STILL probably buy it. Isn't that the same company that did SBK, SCGT, and Andretti Racing? I have all three...<g> Hear, hear! __ Own Grand Prix Legends? Goto http://gpl.gamestats.com/vroc If all the world's a stage, where is the audience sitting? remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
On Wed, 8 Sep 1999 05:16:21 -0700, "John O. Twitchell"
Quoted text (7 lines)>> With Hasbro's GP3 looking more and more like an update of GP2 (reports >> indicate that it's going to be based on the GP2 engine with 3D graphics >> support) and Papyrus' NASCAR3 being based on the N2 engine (which was >based >> on ICR2, essentially), >I believe Nascar Racing (1) was based on the ICR2 engine.
Kinda sorta, but not exactly. The progression was: 1993 - IndyCar Racing 1994 - NASCAR Racing 1995 - IndyCar Racing 2 1996 - NASCAR Racing 2... The NASCAR1 sim engine was supposed to be a substantial change from the ICR1 engine (if still based on it, just like ICR1 was a far-flung relative of Indy 500:The Sim). For John B., of course any sensible code slinger is going to base a new product on existing code. There's a thing called "re-inventing the wheel". They try to avoid that. :) "But in a way, fear is a big part of racing, because if there was nothing to be frightened of, and no limit, any fool could get into a motor car and racing would not exist as a sport." -- Jim Clark
Mapson 17 Sep 1999#493267
I would have been jealous of you, with my 486-SX-33...

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy