We want a late 70's G.P. game. The time when turbo's took over F-1. And we
want it with the GPL engine! Just think of getting side ways with Gilles
Villeneuve in turn one at Watkin's Glen. The racing then was magnificent. So
put this first in line on your to do list, we don't need another Nascar game
right now!
Calls for Papyrus to make sims beyond NASCAR
A poster urged Papyrus to make a late-1970s turbo-era F1 sim on the GPL engine instead of another NASCAR title. Many agreed and suggested separating tracks from cars so any car could run on any track, while NASCAR fans defended stock car racing and others noted Sierra's business case favours NASCAR in the US. The thread became a long and sometimes snide oval versus road racing argument.
Automated summary.
Actually - just listen to this Papy.
NO MORE NASCAR...
Diverge a little, will you??
There's SO many forms of motorsport, and you focus on one that has already
been done plenty well enough (Nascar's 1 & 2)
So play with wierd stuff.
How's about a Mid 70's F1 sim, and a good sim of 1992, when car's were at
their best.
Doug
>We want a late 70's G.P. game. The time when turbo's took over F-1. And we
>want it with the GPL engine! Just think of getting side ways with Gilles
>Villeneuve in turn one at Watkin's Glen. The racing then was magnificent. So
>put this first in line on your to do list, we don't need another Nascar game
>right now!
<dream mode on>
I'd love to see that also. 'Turbo era' F1, contemporary F1... , why not just
a platform with GPL quality physics, where you get different add-ons for
carsets, tracks, etc. for different eras of F1... or other racing series
(drool... :-)
<dream mode off>
I think there is the big problem, that you have to simulate aerodynamics
(wings, drag, ground effect...) to do this. If papy would make a 'winged' F1
sim using the GPL engine, they'd also want to model aerodynamics as good as
possible.
...and we all know, how much CPU power the GPL physics without aerodynamics
needs... :-(
Peter
Vienna, Austria
we
> >want it with the GPL engine! Just think of getting side ways with Gilles
> >Villeneuve in turn one at Watkin's Glen. The racing then was magnificent.
> So
> >put this first in line on your to do list, we don't need another Nascar
> game
> >right now!
Quoted text (19 lines)
> Actually - just listen to this Papy. > NO MORE NASCAR... > Diverge a little, will you?? > There's SO many forms of motorsport, and you focus on one that has already > been done plenty well enough (Nascar's 1 & 2) > So play with wierd stuff. > How's about a Mid 70's F1 sim, and a good sim of 1992, when car's were at > their best. > Doug > >We want a late 70's G.P. game. The time when turbo's took over F-1. AndBring on SODA 2 :-)
After they read your pleasant request I'm sure that Messrs. Papyrus will
just leap into action, eager to do your bidding.
-----------== Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News ==----------
http://www.newsfeeds.com The Largest Usenet Servers in the World!
------== Over 73,000 Newsgroups - Including Dedicated Binaries Servers ==-----
Agreed!
(also dreaming)
I can't wait till they start separating the cars and track. Build the
tracks as a regular over the shelf product and have cars that you have
to download. This way, if we wanted, we could drive NASCAR on the
tracks that we want to, and/or the Motorcycles on those tracks, and/or
F1's (1967), and/or F1's (1975), and/or the combination of all of these,
plus.
Hmm, racing a dragster on Nurburgring against a 500 cc honda
motorcycle, and against a Monster truck? This combination probably would
only happen in off line racing. But online, sure would be great to race
in a amateur SCCA even where different classes run together. Closest
thing to that right now is SCGT where you can run GTq, GT1 and GT2
together.
--
=========================================
Mike Barlow of Barlow Racing?
=========================================
Racing online with the help of......
Race Communications Association
http://members.xoom.com/RCA/toc.html
Holodyne Engineering
Mystic Music
(have Your !!Name/Address!! placed here)
Quoted text (45 lines)
> <dream mode on> > I'd love to see that also. 'Turbo era' F1, contemporary F1... , why not just > a platform with GPL quality physics, where you get different add-ons for > carsets, tracks, etc. for different eras of F1... or other racing series > (drool... :-) > <dream mode off> > I think there is the big problem, that you have to simulate aerodynamics > (wings, drag, ground effect...) to do this. If papy would make a 'winged' F1 > sim using the GPL engine, they'd also want to model aerodynamics as good as > possible. > ...and we all know, how much CPU power the GPL physics without aerodynamics > needs... :-( > Peter > Vienna, Austria > > Actually - just listen to this Papy. > > NO MORE NASCAR... > > Diverge a little, will you?? > > There's SO many forms of motorsport, and you focus on one that has already > > been done plenty well enough (Nascar's 1 & 2) > > So play with wierd stuff. > > How's about a Mid 70's F1 sim, and a good sim of 1992, when car's were at > > their best. > > Doug > > >We want a late 70's G.P. game. The time when turbo's took over F-1. And > we > > >want it with the GPL engine! Just think of getting side ways with Gilles > > >Villeneuve in turn one at Watkin's Glen. The racing then was magnificent. > > So > > >put this first in line on your to do list, we don't need another Nascar > > game > > >right now!I say bring out NASCAR with the GPL engine. I bet if you take all systems
into account, there are more Indy type games on the market than NASCAR. So
enough of the pretty fragile cars, bring on more NASCAR games where its more
skill than setup. One more thing before you start flaming, when is the last
time you saw 43 indy cars bunched up about 6 inches apart doing around 200
for three hours? If you want to go fast that's fine,drive the indy cars, if
you want to RACE, you'll race NASCAR.
Sondog
> Agreed!
> >We want a late 70's G.P. game. The time when turbo's took over F-1. And we
> >want it with the GPL engine! Just think of getting side ways with Gilles
> >Villeneuve in turn one at Watkin's Glen. The racing then was magnificent. So
> >put this first in line on your to do list, we don't need another Nascar game
> >right now!
Yes, and we want engines that stall as well please.
That would be so easy to code, yet make it much more realistic.
>We want a late 70's G.P. game. The time when turbo's took over F-1. And we
>want it with the GPL engine! Just think of getting side ways with Gilles
>Villeneuve in turn one at Watkin's Glen. The racing then was magnificent. So
>put this first in line on your to do list, we don't need another Nascar game
>right now!
We need more GPL-engine based simulations, full stop.
Jan.
----
Don't even bother Son... they just don't get it and they never will. They
don't look past the going round in circles bit.
Jan.
----
Screw all this motorsports crap!!! I want bicycles at a velodrome!!! or how
about baby buggies down Lombard St. in San Francisco, or those damned ***
duck races!!!
we
> >want it with the GPL engine! Just think of getting side ways with Gilles
> >Villeneuve in turn one at Watkin's Glen. The racing then was magnificent.
> So
> >put this first in line on your to do list, we don't need another Nascar
> game
> >right now!
Quoted text (19 lines)
> Actually - just listen to this Papy. > NO MORE NASCAR... > Diverge a little, will you?? > There's SO many forms of motorsport, and you focus on one that has already > been done plenty well enough (Nascar's 1 & 2) > So play with wierd stuff. > How's about a Mid 70's F1 sim, and a good sim of 1992, when car's were at > their best. > Doug > >We want a late 70's G.P. game. The time when turbo's took over F-1. And>***all this motorsports crap!!! I want bicycles at a velodrome!!! or how
> about baby buggies down Lombard St. in San Francisco, or those damned ***
> duck races!!!
I remember when I lived in Australia down in Melbourne there was a
festival every year when people had to run a contraption that carried a
person down a gigantic takeoff ramp into a river. Whoever's creation
went the farthest won.
About 20 people/companies took it seriously and built these
glider/speeder things but there were always dozens more who would build
just the most insane devices out of old beds or just guys flapping their
arms with cardboard wings, etc.
I really miss watching that every year...
I think that's what nintedo is for. ;-)
--
Sean Higgins
"HigPup"
"Hollywood" for R6 "Hollywood__NWO" for ZONE
http://home.sprintmail.com/~higgy/hsts2/ HSTS, Powered by ATI Rage 128
http://home.sprintmail.com/~higgy/
http://www.colormation.com Colormation (sponsor of H.O. Motorsports)
http://www.atitech.ca ATI Technologies
> Hmm, racing a dragster on Nurburgring against a 500 cc honda
>motorcycle, and against a Monster truck? This combination probably would
>only happen in off line racing. But online, sure would be great to race
>in a amateur SCCA even where different classes run together. Closest
>thing to that right now is SCGT where you can run GTq, GT1 and GT2
>together.
On Sat, 28 Aug 1999 09:33:52 -0400, Michael Barlow
snip
snipo
long straight, 300 MPH+, last hill....... we could compete for
airtime
To email me remove the "u"s
The concept of separating the cars and the track is an EXCELLENT idea --
Papy already does this, to some extent with the Craftsman Truck add-ons and
such. It's also a capability that is somewhat built-in to SCGT; you're
stuck with all the original tracks (so far), but new cars can be added in.
This is an idea whose time has DEFINITELY come. Is ANYBODY paying
attention???
-- JB
just
>> a platform with GPL quality physics, where you get different add-ons for
>> carsets, tracks, etc. for different eras of F1... or other racing series
>> (drool... :-)
>> <dream mode off>
>> I think there is the big problem, that you have to simulate aerodynamics
>> (wings, drag, ground effect...) to do this. If papy would make a 'winged' F1
>> sim using the GPL engine, they'd also want to model aerodynamics as good as
>> possible.
>> ...and we all know, how much CPU power the GPL physics without aerodynamics
already
>> > been done plenty well enough (Nascar's 1 & 2)
>> > So play with wierd stuff.
>> > How's about a Mid 70's F1 sim, and a good sim of 1992, when car's were at
And
>> we
>> > >want it with the GPL engine! Just think of getting side ways with Gilles
>> > >Villeneuve in turn one at Watkin's Glen. The racing then was magnificent.
>> > So
>> > >put this first in line on your to do list, we don't need another Nascar
Quoted text (20 lines)
> (also dreaming) > I can't wait till they start separating the cars and track. Build the >tracks as a regular over the shelf product and have cars that you have >to download. This way, if we wanted, we could drive NASCAR on the >tracks that we want to, and/or the Motorcycles on those tracks, and/or >F1's (1967), and/or F1's (1975), and/or the combination of all of these, >plus. > Hmm, racing a dragster on Nurburgring against a 500 cc honda >motorcycle, and against a Monster truck? This combination probably would >only happen in off line racing. But online, sure would be great to race >in a amateur SCCA even where different classes run together. Closest >thing to that right now is SCGT where you can run GTq, GT1 and GT2 >together. >> <dream mode on> >> I'd love to see that also. 'Turbo era' F1, contemporary F1... , why notQuoted text (15 lines)
>> needs... :-( >> Peter >> Vienna, Austria >> > Actually - just listen to this Papy. >> > NO MORE NASCAR... >> > Diverge a little, will you?? >> > There's SO many forms of motorsport, and you focus on one that hasQuoted text (7 lines)
>> > their best. >> > Doug >> > >We want a late 70's G.P. game. The time when turbo's took over F-1.Quoted text (16 lines)
>> > game >> > >right now! >-- >========================================= >Mike Barlow of Barlow Racing? >========================================= >Racing online with the help of...... >Race Communications Association >http://members.xoom.com/RCA/toc.html >Holodyne Engineering >Mystic Music >(have Your !!Name/Address!! placed here)When was the last time you saw any of those 43 NASCAR cars do anything else
besides roll around in a traffic-jam drafting train, playing
follow-the-leader lap after lap with little or no passing? Bring on the
Indy cars; BRING ON CART AND BRING ON THE IRL!
-- JB
>I say bring out NASCAR with the GPL engine. I bet if you take all systems
>into account, there are more Indy type games on the market than NASCAR. So
>enough of the pretty fragile cars, bring on more NASCAR games where its more
>skill than setup. One more thing before you start flaming, when is the last
>time you saw 43 indy cars bunched up about 6 inches apart doing around 200
>for three hours? If you want to go fast that's fine,drive the indy cars, if
magnificent.
>So
>> >put this first in line on your to do list, we don't need another Nascar
>game
>> >right now!
Quoted text (15 lines)
>you want to RACE, you'll race NASCAR. >Sondog >> Agreed! >> >We want a late 70's G.P. game. The time when turbo's took over F-1. And >we >> >want it with the GPL engine! Just think of getting side ways with Gilles >> >Villeneuve in turn one at Watkin's Glen. The racing then wasHow about a modern CART sim, based on GPL engine of course. All this
nascar bandwagon ***makes me sick.
Folks, I am going to tell you a sad truth. It is one that everyone else
in the *** industry has known for a long time...
SIERRA AND PAPYRUS PRODUCE GAMES BECAUSE THEY WANT TO MAKE MONEY.
They have to make a relatively large profit on the games/sims they sell
or else they lose their shirt, just like every other business
establishment in the world. And because of this simple fact, they know
NASCAR, a sport with an incredible fan base in the United States and a
much smaller, but sizable, fanbase in Europe, will sell far more copies
than some obscure F1 sim.
Maybe this explanation will put it better:
Joe Gamer is perusing the game aisles at CompUSA when he comes to the
racing section. Assuming he hasn't read any read any reviews about
them, What is his reaction to these two titles?
NASCAR Racing 3: "Whoa cool! NASCAR! I love to watch NASCAR and I'd
love to play it! I'm gonna pick this one up!
Formula 1 1975: "Huh? What kind of thing is this? 1975? I wasn't even
born then. And what's Formula 1 anyway?"
Good day. Feel free to flame away.
Sam
> How about a modern CART sim, based on GPL engine of course. All this
> nascar bandwagon ***makes me sick.
Bristol was indeed something to see, but have you ever watched the IRL race
at Texas, Atlanta, or C***te? The IRL open-wheelers put on a show at
NASCAR's 1.5 mile ovals that the NASCAR boys are hard-pressed to beat.
Ditto CART at places like Michigan and Gateway. A show like Bristol seems
to be the exception, not the rule in NASCAR.
Now, just to keep this from becoming TOO off-topic (this IS
rec.autos.SIMULATORS, after all), I do admit that open-wheel sims can be
very annoying in that it's difficult to have such delicate cars in a
simulated environment, where you are deprived of many important sensory
inputs and left with only a vague awareness of where the four corners (and
open wheels) are with respect to you.
In a sim environment, it's much easier to get by in a simulated environment
that's somewhat forgiving of bumping and rubbing -- which is where sims like
NASCAR and SCGT really shine. No matter how rewarding a good lap is in GPL,
I still find that it brings me very little relaxation -- just stress. Given
the opportunity to do a little strategic rubbing and bumping, I find I can
blow off a lot of stress -- which is VERY relaxing. AND rewarding. <G>
I'm just glad we have such a diversity of games to choose from. Despite the
availability of titles like GPL and the myriad of F1 sims on the market now,
there IS a distinct lack of open-wheel sims that are NOT F1-related. CART
and IRL fans are pretty much left out in the cold, so while the average
NASCAR fan may felt lost in a sea of F1 wheels and wings, the IRL and CART
fans are just simply lost AND forgotten.
Keep bringing the NASCAR sims on -- AND the F1 sims, and Le Mans, etc., but
let's all pray that they DON'T forget about the IRL and CART fans along the
way.
-- JB
>gotta keep nascar....if you saw bristol...you cant even question nascars
>existence
CART Sim Features Sheet
Important ones denoted with *
All tracks*
Good but easy to use Track Editor
All cars (none fictional)*
Fantasy Tracks 8^)
GPL Physics or N3 if not GPL*
All teams (tobacco and *** if possible)*
native RENDITION support***
drafting*
3d***pits*
3d Physics engine that simulates true CART handling*
Resolutions like 800x600 and 1024x768*
Excellent car damage model so that no two crashes look alike*
Realistic flip effects,like GPL and not Andretti Racing (boo)
Comprehensive car setups, including springs, shocks, camber, weight jacker on
ovals, static ride height, dampers, rebounds, bump stops, etc. *
Realistic effects like bottoming out*
Realistic debris that you can run over and damage your car on
Random tire blowouts*
Oil and other fluids from engine failures*
Fire (highly unlikely this will be allowed by CART)*
Realistic wall types and wall effects (Armco barriers do more damage than
concrete, tire walls do less damage than concrete, tire walls
cause car to get airborne and flip more than concrete and armcos, etc.)*
Realistic gravel trap effects (Come on, you know you wanna do an Andretti at
Mid-Ohio, admit it...)*
Improved Paintkit*
realistic sounds actually digitally recorded*
animated pit stops*
area in pit road that can be drivin off into the infield to get to
victory lane..or garage*
realistic***pit that has hand on wheel like GPL*
better frame rates/3d acceleration/1024x768 resolution*
better engine, way more realistic damage to the car, the way the damage is
spread across the track in real life...fliping catchin air on other
tires*
better smoke,skid marks and racing groove*,
possible damage of the catch fencing*
RED FLAGS*
animated workers on the track after a wreck...and if possible
ambulances or REAL tow-trucks*
marks on the walls after a hit, animated flagmen*
more options to change on the car in garage
full field of cars*
all the current tracks ( if possible...Indianapolis, since it rightfully is
CART's) *
realistic lookin part-time road courses like with the closed off streets and
stuff*
fire,fuel and oil leaks, (causin slippery race track)*
possible damage to the pit wall..*
animated OPPONENT pit stops*
more realistic AI cars*
weather changes like durin the race, rain, wind, etc*
possible use of rain tires, and racing in the rain (regardless of if there was
rain that season or not*)
The problem is that this stuff works the other way too you see....
Imagine Bob Gamer who lives in London or Franz Gamer in Munich or Pierre
Gamer in Paris, walking up to the racing section in at the computer shop....
Do you think they'll pick NASCAR 3 ??
I'll give 100:1 that 95% or more will pick a Formula 1 sim or a CART sim.
Why? Both Formula One and CART get good exposure over here...
NASCAR we (sadly) see way too little of.... like in pretty close to nill!
--
All the best,
Edwin Solheim *remove SPAM-GUARD in address to reply*
The Paddock - a legendary site....
<http://home.c2i.net/thepaddock>
gotta keep nascar....if you saw bristol...you cant even question nascars
existence
Ok, no arguing with your basic point, but I think every serious simmer,
currently playing GPL, will buy the next GPL-engine based product,
regardless of which form of motorsport it portrays. The sadder truth is,
unless those guys at Ratbag pull off a stunning coup there won't be anything
to rival GPL for at least a year.
Bring on ANY racing sim, if it's as good or better than GPL.
Jan.
----
..........so, using the GPL engine, you'd like Papyrus to do a sim of that
for you?
-----------== Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News ==----------
http://www.newsfeeds.com The Largest Usenet Servers in the World!
------== Over 73,000 Newsgroups - Including Dedicated Binaries Servers ==-----
Quoted text (22 lines)
>> Joe Gamer is perusing the game aisles at CompUSA when he comes to the >> racing section. Assuming he hasn't read any read any reviews about >> them, What is his reaction to these two titles? >> NASCAR Racing 3: "Whoa cool! NASCAR! I love to watch NASCAR and I'd >> love to play it! I'm gonna pick this one up! >> Formula 1 1975: "Huh? What kind of thing is this? 1975? I wasn't >> even born then. And what's Formula 1 anyway?" >The problem is that this stuff works the other way too you see.... >Imagine Bob Gamer who lives in London or Franz Gamer in Munich or Pierre >Gamer in Paris, walking up to the racing section in at the computer >shop.... >Do you think they'll pick NASCAR 3 ?? >I'll give 100:1 that 95% or more will pick a Formula 1 sim or a CART >sim. Why? Both Formula One and CART get good exposure over here... >NASCAR we (sadly) see way too little of.... like in pretty close >to nill!But another time.. who knows ? You got information, statistics about that ?
We are just all arguing about assumptions we think are true. I still think
that the Non-American *** market is almost as big as the US one. Did you
know that at the end of 1999 that Americans won't dominate anymore the # of
users on the Internet ? :)
--
-- Fran?ois Mnard <ymenard>
-- May the Downforce be with you...
"People think it must be fun to be a super genius, but they don't realise
how hard it is to put up with all the idiots in the world."
Let's remember that Ratbag is not the only competitor to Papyrus <vbg>
There is Motorsims with AMA Superbike, Europress with Rally Championship,
and Geoff Crammond with GrandPrix3. Those titles are to be took seriously,
the thing about nothing will touch GPL for at least year is probably not
true, even if one of those titles comes up as bad, or arcade-style, there
will be probably one of them superior to GPL.
--
-- Fran?ois Mnard <ymenard>
-- May the Downforce be with you...
"People think it must be fun to be a super genius, but they don't realise
how hard it is to put up with all the idiots in the world."
>Ok, no arguing with your basic point, but I think every serious simmer,
>currently playing GPL, will buy the next GPL-engine based product,
>regardless of which form of motorsport it portrays. The sadder truth is,
>unless those guys at Ratbag pull off a stunning coup there won't be anything
>to rival GPL for at least a year.
However, based on figures thrown around here, that's only about 40,000 people.
Can *any* publisher afford to sell so few copies?
Eldred
__
Put your message in a modem, and throw it in the ***-sea...
remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
Sadly? I only wish I lived somewhere where I didn't have to hear about NASCAR.
I don't get this sport at all. Oval tracks and 1960's technology DO NOT make an
exciting sport. Where's the skill? In the pits if it's anywhere. NASCAR
drivers make an *** amount of money for what they do, I can only hope the
guys in the pits are bringing home their fair share for they are the true
driving force behind the sport. All this goes for the IRL too. Indy 500, god
lord man, what a tremendous non event.
-Andrew
Gp3 within the space of year?? -Wanna put some money on that? ;-)
However good a bike game AMA (and GP500) turn out to be, they're never going
to be as immersive as racing car simulations. Also, I had some serious
questions about the sim content (and scripted damage) of Europress's
previous 2 Rally games, so I wouldn't hold my breath for that one either.
So what's left?? N3: less detailed physics for the sake of frame rate. And
dark horse Dirt Track Racing: looks and sounds promising, but will it
deliver?
Jan.
----
> > <snip>
> Let's remember that Ratbag is not the only competitor to Papyrus <vbg>
> There is Motorsims with AMA Superbike, Europress with Rally Championship,
> and Geoff Crammond with GrandPrix3. Those titles are to be took seriously,
> the thing about nothing will touch GPL for at least year is probably not
> true, even if one of those titles comes up as bad, or arcade-style, there
> will be probably one of them superior to GPL.
> <snip>
I don't understand your POV. For you, Europress can't make a sim because of
the two Rally sim/game they made in the past, but Ratbag can do it because
of an arcade-style game named Powerslide ? I would say that Europress has
much bigger chances to be successful.
Your opinion is that bike sims can't be as immersive, but in my opinion I
say they can both be as immersive as possible. I say GP3 within a space of
year, probably spring of 2000.
--
-- Fran?ois Mnard <ymenard>
-- May the Downforce be with you...
"People think it must be fun to be a super genius, but they don't realise
how hard it is to put up with all the idiots in the world."
Bump up the price... we know it's going to be good. Might save us some
whines about how hard the thing is on here.
GPL is way under the 1cent/hour mark as far as entertainment value goes for
me. I, for one, would be prepared to pay substantially more for a pure sim
title.
Jan.
----
<Snip>
> However, based on figures thrown around here, that's only about 40,000 people.
> Can *any* publisher afford to sell so few copies?
> Eldred
>---------
> Put your message in a modem, and throw it in the ***-sea...
> remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
How much would they have to pay YOU to do something as crazy and dangerous
as driving Nascar?? You just don't understand, do you?
IRL is a nice, patriotic idea, but doomed.
Jan.
----
<snip>
I don't understand yours and the presses'... until the game ships it's going
to be the best and the most realistic sim yet, but when it does it's usually
halfway at best: e.g. TOCA2, SCGT, CMR, Nascar Revolution, the list goes on.
With a history of disappointments like that I'm adopting a "seeing is
believing" additude. The sad fact is no racing "sim" in the past year has
even come close to GPL and I see no change in the foreseeable future. Even
Papy themselves are having trouble going one up on the masterpiece.
I'm not saying Europress can't do it, only that they've got a lot to make up
for. I'm also trying not to get my hopes up for Dirt Track Racing. Yes,
Powerslide was a graphically stunning, wholy enjoyable racing game with
passable physics and I'll surely give Dirt track Racing some serious
attention when it arrives. But you can hardly say Ratbag have got a
simracing pedigree. I'm just hoping the "Powerslide was just a test, we're
ready for the serious stuff now" -line is more than just that, a line.
As for bike sims... to me driving a motorbike is just too physical to be
able to really simulate. I'm not saying GP500 and AMA won't be enjoyable
games, just not as gripping as.... well..... GPL.
Jan./ the cynic??
----
PS.: Gp3 in spring 2000?? -No way!! $10 says it doesn't even make X-mas 2000
;-)
Ditto downunder.
shop....
-----------== Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News ==----------
http://www.newsfeeds.com The Largest Usenet Servers in the World!
------== Over 73,000 Newsgroups - Including Dedicated Binaries Servers ==-----
Quoted text (14 lines)
> > Joe Gamer is perusing the game aisles at CompUSA when he comes to the > > racing section. Assuming he hasn't read any read any reviews about > > them, What is his reaction to these two titles? > > NASCAR Racing 3: "Whoa cool! NASCAR! I love to watch NASCAR and I'd > > love to play it! I'm gonna pick this one up! > > Formula 1 1975: "Huh? What kind of thing is this? 1975? I wasn't even > > born then. And what's Formula 1 anyway?" > The problem is that this stuff works the other way too you see.... > Imagine Bob Gamer who lives in London or Franz Gamer in Munich or Pierre > Gamer in Paris, walking up to the racing section in at the computerQuoted text (11 lines)
> Do you think they'll pick NASCAR 3 ?? > I'll give 100:1 that 95% or more will pick a Formula 1 sim or a CART sim. > Why? Both Formula One and CART get good exposure over here... > NASCAR we (sadly) see way too little of.... like in pretty close to nill! > -- > All the best, > Edwin Solheim *remove SPAM-GUARD in address to reply* > The Paddock - a legendary site.... > <http://home.c2i.net/thepaddock>Well, in the shelves here we've got "NASCAR ROAD RACING".
Any guesses? Yup, N.Revultion in another cardboard box with some real
Andretti-racing-like tracks....(mmmmphh!!)
Matt
--
---------------------------------
Matthew Birger Knutsen
The Art of Legends;
http://www.gpl.electra.no
Cheek Racing Cars;
http://www.cheekracing.electra.no
Quoted text (38 lines)
> Ditto downunder. > > > Joe Gamer is perusing the game aisles at CompUSA when he comes to the > > > racing section. Assuming he hasn't read any read any reviews about > > > them, What is his reaction to these two titles? > > > NASCAR Racing 3: "Whoa cool! NASCAR! I love to watch NASCAR and I'd > > > love to play it! I'm gonna pick this one up! > > > Formula 1 1975: "Huh? What kind of thing is this? 1975? I wasn't even > > > born then. And what's Formula 1 anyway?" > > The problem is that this stuff works the other way too you see.... > > Imagine Bob Gamer who lives in London or Franz Gamer in Munich or Pierre > > Gamer in Paris, walking up to the racing section in at the computer > shop.... > > Do you think they'll pick NASCAR 3 ?? > > I'll give 100:1 that 95% or more will pick a Formula 1 sim or a CART sim. > > Why? Both Formula One and CART get good exposure over here... > > NASCAR we (sadly) see way too little of.... like in pretty close to nill! > > -- > > All the best, > > Edwin Solheim *remove SPAM-GUARD in address to reply* > > The Paddock - a legendary site.... > > <http://home.c2i.net/thepaddock> > -----------== Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News ==---------- > http://www.newsfeeds.com The Largest Usenet Servers in the World! > ------== Over 73,000 Newsgroups - Including Dedicated Binaries Servers ==-----Yeah....it's also available here, Matt.
(We also get the chaff with the wheat!)
the
even
> > > > born then. And what's Formula 1 anyway?"
> > > The problem is that this stuff works the other way too you see....
> > > Imagine Bob Gamer who lives in London or Franz Gamer in Munich or Pierre
> > > Gamer in Paris, walking up to the racing section in at the computer
> > shop....
> > > Do you think they'll pick NASCAR 3 ??
> > > I'll give 100:1 that 95% or more will pick a Formula 1 sim or a CART sim.
> > > Why? Both Formula One and CART get good exposure over here...
> > > NASCAR we (sadly) see way too little of.... like in pretty close to nill!
==----------
> > http://www.newsfeeds.com The Largest Usenet Servers in the World!
> > ------== Over 73,000 Newsgroups - Including Dedicated Binaries Servers ==-----
-----------== Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News ==----------
http://www.newsfeeds.com The Largest Usenet Servers in the World!
------== Over 73,000 Newsgroups - Including Dedicated Binaries Servers ==-----
Quoted text (19 lines)
> Well, in the shelves here we've got "NASCAR ROAD RACING". > Any guesses? Yup, N.Revultion in another cardboard box with some real > Andretti-racing-like tracks....(mmmmphh!!) > Matt > > Ditto downunder. > > > The Johnson Family (well not the whole family, but one of them!) > > > > Joe Gamer is perusing the game aisles at CompUSA when he comes toQuoted text (7 lines)
> > > > racing section. Assuming he hasn't read any read any reviews about > > > > them, What is his reaction to these two titles? > > > > NASCAR Racing 3: "Whoa cool! NASCAR! I love to watch NASCAR and I'd > > > > love to play it! I'm gonna pick this one up! > > > > Formula 1 1975: "Huh? What kind of thing is this? 1975? I wasn'tQuoted text (7 lines)
> > > -- > > > All the best, > > > Edwin Solheim *remove SPAM-GUARD in address to reply* > > > The Paddock - a legendary site.... > > > <http://home.c2i.net/thepaddock> > > -----------== Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet NewsQuoted text (9 lines)
> -- > --------------------------------- > Matthew Birger Knutsen > The Art of Legends; > http://www.gpl.electra.no > Cheek Racing Cars; > http://www.cheekracing.electra.no>When was the last time you saw any of those 43 NASCAR cars do anything else
>besides roll around in a traffic-jam drafting train, playing
>follow-the-leader lap after lap with little or no passing? Bring on the
>Indy cars; BRING ON CART AND BRING ON THE IRL!
>-- JB
Ummm, just about every race involves a lot of passing.
I assume you just don't watch any.
The "traffic jam drafting train" could only refer to Talledaga(sp).
Even that race involves huge scrambles for position.
Skill? NASCAR? Hahaha. Nascar has a lot more to do about SETUP, teamwork
and then driving skill than just skill alone.
And FYI, just because you can line up 43 cars and do nearly 200mph does NOT
mean its good racing. Or exciting racing, or that its better. Personally I
prefer 28 cars doing over 200mph and dodging, weaving, attacking the
corners, etc than just a draft-a-thon that NASCAR superspeedway with
restrictor plates is.
> I say bring out NASCAR with the GPL engine. I bet if you take all systems
> into account, there are more Indy type games on the market than NASCAR. So
> enough of the pretty fragile cars, bring on more NASCAR games where its more
> skill than setup. One more thing before you start flaming, when is the last
> time you saw 43 indy cars bunched up about 6 inches apart doing around 200
> for three hours? If you want to go fast that's fine,drive the indy cars, if
Gilles
> > >Villeneuve in turn one at Watkin's Glen. The racing then was magnificent.
> So
> > >put this first in line on your to do list, we don't need another Nascar
> game
> > >right now!
Quoted text (14 lines)
> you want to RACE, you'll race NASCAR. > Sondog > > Agreed! > > >We want a late 70's G.P. game. The time when turbo's took over F-1. And > we > > >want it with the GPL engine! Just think of getting side ways withYup, this is very true. Its why I think for a good openwheel sim to really
succeed, while its physics needs to be very good or better than GPL, it
needs to also relax some of the collisions and amount of damage absorped
slightly so that a minor bump or scrape caused by latency, warp, etc,
doesn't adversely damage the racing.
Mms, perhaps you are working at it too hard. Relax, go with the flow and
you might find yourself able to get better laps w/o as much work?
Why? I'd rather make an absolutely CLEAN pass, make the move, hound someone
into making a mistake, etc. rather than going by the because I rubbed or
bumped them out of my way.
Gotta agree with you there, even if the IRL fans are lost and looney period.
:)
Yeah, especially the CART fans. :)
hehehe. Like the first part of "BRING ON CART ....", rest we could do
without. ;)
> When was the last time you saw any of those 43 NASCAR cars do anything else
systems
> >into account, there are more Indy type games on the market than NASCAR. So
> >enough of the pretty fragile cars, bring on more NASCAR games where its
> more
> >skill than setup. One more thing before you start flaming, when is the
> last
> >time you saw 43 indy cars bunched up about 6 inches apart doing around 200
And
> >we
> >> >want it with the GPL engine! Just think of getting side ways with Gilles
> >> >Villeneuve in turn one at Watkin's Glen. The racing then was
> magnificent.
> >So
> >> >put this first in line on your to do list, we don't need another Nascar
> >game
> >> >right now!
Quoted text (9 lines)
> besides roll around in a traffic-jam drafting train, playing > follow-the-leader lap after lap with little or no passing? Bring on the > Indy cars; BRING ON CART AND BRING ON THE IRL! > -- JB > >I say bring out NASCAR with the GPL engine. I bet if you take allQuoted text (14 lines)
> >for three hours? If you want to go fast that's fine,drive the indy cars, > if > >you want to RACE, you'll race NASCAR. > >Sondog > >> Agreed! > >> >We want a late 70's G.P. game. The time when turbo's took over F-1.This has been argued too much already. And I do believe the basic
conclusion was that it was NOT the gpl physics, but it was the late 60s
grand prix racing theme that may have "doomed" GPL to only 40,000 copies
[which is still quite a lot of copies] being sold. Slap on a Nascar
pictures on the box, slap on 1960/70s American muscle cars, etc on the box
and it would have sold even more [especially considering MOST people buy
games at places that won't take the game back if opened]. :)
> >Ok, no arguing with your basic point, but I think every serious simmer,
> >currently playing GPL, will buy the next GPL-engine based product,
> >regardless of which form of motorsport it portrays. The sadder truth is,
> >unless those guys at Ratbag pull off a stunning coup there won't be anything
> >to rival GPL for at least a year.
> However, based on figures thrown around here, that's only about 40,000 people.
Quoted text (8 lines)
> Can *any* publisher afford to sell so few copies? > Eldred > __ > Put your message in a modem, and throw it in the ***-sea... > remove SPAM-OFF to reply.Hi Chris,
Now the really fun is to put 43 cars on a short track. :-D You get your
dodging, weaving, attacking and a few bumps don't put you out of the race.
Jason.
--------
Jason Monds
"My other car is a Ferrari"
http://members.home.net/gpl.mondsj/gpl - For my combined gas/brake setups
(Please remove 'no extra spork' when replying)
Quoted text (8 lines)
> Skill? NASCAR? Hahaha. Nascar has a lot more to do about SETUP, teamwork > and then driving skill than just skill alone. > And FYI, just because you can line up 43 cars and do nearly 200mph does NOT > mean its good racing. Or exciting racing, or that its better. Personally I > prefer 28 cars doing over 200mph and dodging, weaving, attacking the > corners, etc than just a draft-a-thon that NASCAR superspeedway with > restrictor plates is.>Hi Chris,
>Now the really fun is to put 43 cars on a short track. :-D You get your
>dodging, weaving, attacking and a few bumps don't put you out of the race.
>Jason.
Which is why I used to LOVE running Bristol in N2. Great fun!
__
Put your message in a modem, and throw it in the ***-sea...
remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
Speak for yourself please.
Quoted text (25 lines)
>Actually - just listen to this Papy. >NO MORE NASCAR... >Diverge a little, will you?? >There's SO many forms of motorsport, and you focus on one that has already >been done plenty well enough (Nascar's 1 & 2) >So play with wierd stuff. >How's about a Mid 70's F1 sim, and a good sim of 1992, when car's were at >their best. >Doug >>We want a late 70's G.P. game. The time when turbo's took over F-1. And we >>want it with the GPL engine! Just think of getting side ways with Gilles >>Villeneuve in turn one at Watkin's Glen. The racing then was magnificent. >So >>put this first in line on your to do list, we don't need another Nascar >game >>right now!Quoted text (15 lines)
>Actually - just listen to this Papy. >NO MORE NASCAR... >Diverge a little, will you?? >There's SO many forms of motorsport, and you focus on one that has already >been done plenty well enough (Nascar's 1 & 2) >So play with wierd stuff. >How's about a Mid 70's F1 sim, and a good sim of 1992, when car's were at >their best. >DougQuoted text (7 lines)
>> but let's face it, that user base is much smaller. (And I'm not talking >> worldwide TV audence, I'm talking about euro fans with PC's that can run >> a modern racing sim.) >But another time.. who knows ? You got information, statistics about that ? >We are just all arguing about assumptions we think are true. I still think >that the Non-American *** market is almost as big as the US one. Didanybody forgotten that they love their games more than everybody else???
pez
Huh?
Andre
Wow, I guess America is the only place in the world where people know whats
going on then huh?
I really hate when Amercians claim that America is so huge, and we are
better than everything.....etc. I am from California, and its so funny to
hear people that have absolutely no idea what another country is like making
statements like I have read here.
Auto Racing sims are MORE Popular in Europe than in the US, all except for
Nascar Racing. The rest of the world hates Nascar, and we love it, so if you
are talking Nascar games, then yes the US is the biggest market. Rally?
hardly ever see a rally game in the US. Is rally more difficult and more
dangerous than Nascar in real life?? Hell yes!!. Cant see them cars fer long
enough to have a beer and holler alot though!
Lets not ruin the reputation of American Sim Racing Enthusiasts by making
bogus claims.
ML
>>> but let's face it, that user base is much smaller. (And I'm not talking
>>> worldwide TV audence, I'm talking about euro fans with PC's that can run
>>> a modern racing sim.)
>>But another time.. who knows ? You got information, statistics about that ?
>>We are just all arguing about assumptions we think are true. I still think
>>that the Non-American *** market is almost as big as the US one. Did
>you
>>know that at the end of 1999 that Americans won't dominate anymore the # of
>>users on the Internet ? :)
>You must be joking??? Which country is going to dominate???? If you're
>saying that the rest of the world combined will dominate - maybe, but that
>doesn't stop the fact that success in America is winning half the battle (in
>one hit!!!) and that goes for virtually every industry.
Bring out COLA 4 :-0
| Bring on SODA 2 :-)
|
|
Quoted text (17 lines)
>>On Sat, 28 Aug 1999 08:18:59 +0100, "Douglas Ellison" >>>Actually - just listen to this Papy. >>>NO MORE NASCAR... >>Here here! No more NasCrap! I'm sick of rednecks with names like*** >>Trickle (is that a name or an affliction? What pissed his parents off >>that much?) and Gordan. Get into real racing for a change! >>____________________ >>Hydrogen and Stupidity.. The two most universal elements >NasCrap? >Real racing?... Is that what those F1 cars do with margins of minutes >in between each car? *yawn*On Sat, 28 Aug 1999 08:18:59 +0100, "Douglas Ellison"
>Actually - just listen to this Papy.
>NO MORE NASCAR...
Here here! No more NasCrap! I'm sick of rednecks with names like***
Trickle (is that a name or an affliction? What pissed his parents off
that much?) and Gordan. Get into real racing for a change!
____________________
Hydrogen and Stupidity.. The two most universal elements
On Wed, 15 Sep 1999 09:07:32 GMT,
*plonk*
--
* rrevved at mindspring dot com
* unit.26 s.p.u.t.u.m.
* http://www.cabal.net
Quoted text (10 lines)
>On Sat, 28 Aug 1999 08:18:59 +0100, "Douglas Ellison" >>Actually - just listen to this Papy. >>NO MORE NASCAR... >Here here! No more NasCrap! I'm sick of rednecks with names like*** >Trickle (is that a name or an affliction? What pissed his parents off >that much?) and Gordan. Get into real racing for a change!Quoted text (13 lines)
>On Sat, 28 Aug 1999 08:18:59 +0100, "Douglas Ellison" >>Actually - just listen to this Papy. >>NO MORE NASCAR... >Here here! No more NasCrap! I'm sick of rednecks with names like*** >Trickle (is that a name or an affliction? What pissed his parents off >that much?) and Gordan. Get into real racing for a change! >____________________ >Hydrogen and Stupidity.. The two most universal elementsYeah... why don't those F1 blokes throw more of those goshdarnnit-great
full-course-yellows to bunch the field up... sure would make it a bunch
easier fer them rednecks to pay attention once them there car-thingies
are all in the same screenshot again. ;-)
--
Paul G
Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/
Share what you know. Learn what you don't.
:> NasCrap?
:> Real racing?... Is that what those F1 cars do with margins of minutes
:> in between each car? *yawn*
:> :)
: Yeah... why don't those F1 blokes throw more of those goshdarnnit-great
: full-course-yellows to bunch the field up... sure would make it a bunch
: easier fer them rednecks to pay attention once them there car-thingies
: are all in the same screenshot again. ;-)
Why stop there - F1 could have the full Nascar "real racing" where
the rules dynamically adjust to penalise faster cars. Admittedly
McLaren would have to run without front wings because otherwise they
wouldn't have interesting on track battles with Minardi. But, hell,
it's "real racing".
--
Richard G. Clegg Only the mind is waving
Dept. of Mathematics (Network Control group) Uni. of York.
www: http://manor.york.ac.uk/top.html
Ed,
Absolutely and utterly stay out of my newsreader [and I'm assuming that most
people would prefer that too] with your silly killfile remarks.
Quoted text (21 lines)
> On Wed, 15 Sep 1999 09:07:32 GMT, > >On Sat, 28 Aug 1999 08:18:59 +0100, "Douglas Ellison" > >>Actually - just listen to this Papy. > >>NO MORE NASCAR... > >Here here! No more NasCrap! I'm sick of rednecks with names like*** > >Trickle (is that a name or an affliction? What pissed his parents off > >that much?) and Gordan. Get into real racing for a change! > *plonk* > -- > * rrevved at mindspring dot com > * unit.26 s.p.u.t.u.m. > * http://www.cabal.netQuoted text (10 lines)
>More like Super Touring, WRC/Can-Am, etc. F1 is pretty much a >fast-forward parade series give or take the odd shunt. Nas***is >pretty much a few of the same good old boys going in circles with >nearly pre-determined winnners. Yawn's-ville on a good day. The ONLY >interesting time to watch Nas***is when you see them out on a nice >winding road course where they suddenly discover that the suspensions >suck and they have to turn the steering wheel two directions and deal >with a brake pedal. Ever notice that people you have never heard of do >quite well on these venue's? Heck, I'd rather have a sim based on >SCCA Regional Runoffs and autocrosses than one more Nas***sim.> :> NasCrap?
> :> Real racing?... Is that what those F1 cars do with margins of minutes
> :> in between each car? *yawn*
> :> :)
> : Yeah... why don't those F1 blokes throw more of those goshdarnnit-great
> : full-course-yellows to bunch the field up... sure would make it a bunch
> : easier fer them rednecks to pay attention once them there car-thingies
uhhmmm... I was KIDDING about the yellow flags... I hope you were
kidding about "penalizing faster cars" (I think you were :) ...
I always get a kick out of the way NASCAR fans promote the fact that the
racing is so "close". It is that way for many reasons, none of which I
consider to encourage "pure racing":
1. Frequently thrown full course yellows, which bunch up the field;
2. lack of motivation to pull out a big lead, due to the fact that the
inevitable full course yellow will render it meaningless, hence "why
would I want to use up my tires and fuel building up a 30sec lead if it
is going to be taken away from me every 20 minutes"; sure, this
promotes close racing, but I prefer to see a faster car rewarded
consistently for it's pace throughout the race, not just in the last 1/5
of the race;
3. Constant rule changes to penalize the fastest cars. Again, IMHO, I
prefer to see excellence in driving skill, engineering and design
rewarded, rather than penalized.
4. Stringent restrictions on racecar design and materials. This is an
approach that has been taken to keep costs down; a respectable reason,
and a fine approach. We can't fool ourselves into thinking that we are
seeing "state of the art" machinery out there when they are using some
chassis that are 8-10 years old, but I don't necessarily see that as a
negative, just a fact.
I realize NASCAR has it's merits, and I don't wish to rehash another
"battle of series" - we are comparing apples and oranges, and neither is
"better" than the other, just very different. I prefer F1, others
prefer NASCAR, and each of us "feels" that the other is a little
misguided in their opinion, but we are all entitled to our own
preferences. However, the reasons for the close racing in NASCAR not to
be overlooked, and those reasons are (IMHO) not in the interest of
"pure" racing as I see it.
--
Paul G
Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/
Share what you know. Learn what you don't.
Quoted text (13 lines)
> : are all in the same screenshot again. ;-) > Why stop there - F1 could have the full Nascar "real racing" where > the rules dynamically adjust to penalise faster cars. Admittedly > McLaren would have to run without front wings because otherwise they > wouldn't have interesting on track battles with Minardi. But, hell, > it's "real racing". > -- > Richard G. Clegg Only the mind is waving > Dept. of Mathematics (Network Control group) Uni. of York. > www: http://manor.york.ac.uk/top.html> Ed,
> Absolutely and utterly stay out of my newsreader [and I'm assuming that most
> people would prefer that too] with your silly killfile remarks.
Don't bother, he's an old geek letting everybody know, who's oppinion he
doesn't want to read anymore...
l8er
ronny
--
"I heard if you play the NT-4.0-CD backwards, you get a satanic
message."
"That's nothing, if you play it forward, it installs NT-4.0"
nascar is racing, it's more competitive than f1 anyday.


































