Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

NFS: HS fatal flaws

8 posts by 5 people · 02 Jul 1999 - 03 Jul 1999

Two ridiculous aspects to this game that perhaps someone can enlighten me about... But first, a quick summary. Definitely a lot better than NFS 3, and, of course, better than NFS2--the low point for the whole series. The realism level is still below that of the original NFS, though. Sounds and graphics are phenomenal. Lots of good gameplay options. Still no tracks to match the originals (which are the best yet)--in fact there is not a single spot on any of the tracks (including all bonus ones) where you could even begin to get any of the cars close to their top speed. I have a need for speed, not just a need to fake powerslide through little twisty bits of track. The two inexcusable design flaws in this for me are the steering and the gear shifting. The handling is ridiculous at best, but this an arcade racer, so.... Auto shifting is the usual mess, and the manual shifting "throttle blip and gear change" has been dramatically improved over that in the previous versions (not counting the original which was fine). However, if you drop below 2000 rpm in 4th gear, the game will automatically shift you into 3rd gear. That's it--no other automated shifts!?!?!?!?! I would be happy to have a dummy mode (that could be toggled) where it downshifted if you were too busy or "dumb" to notice that you were lugging the engine. But only this one gear combination?? It just makes no sense. The steering is the fatal flaw. Again, the floating in air and spinning on the centre axis feeling, I guess, are part and parcel of an arcader. But the non-linearity and speed sensitivity are so over blown and jarring that you literally cannot hope to control the car in any normal manner. Some of us have complained about GPL's built-in speed sensitivity that cannot be turned off (until 1.1, that is). Multiply that effect by about 100, so the car literally spins like a top when you are at launch and then it suddenly drops back to "normal" steering with a lurch. The "normal" steering is hopelessly tuned for keyboard users...it may be OK for joysticks too, I don't know, but it is WAY too non-linear for a wheel. There are 9000 adjustments to every small aspect of the game and controllers and sound and graphics and individual cars (good)...but no linear/non-linear adjustment and no speed sensitivity adjustment (very bad). I loved the original NFS and NFS:HS is the closest yet they have come to something remotely realistic. I don't mind if you can smash walls and do head-ons without your car flying apart and starting over. That's what arcade racers are all about. But why can't we have a bit realism--even to the level that was achieved years ago in the original NFS? If the two steering problems were fixed, NFS:HS would exceed the original's steering (which was it weakest point). What can we do about those tracks?...I don't know. Marc. -- **************************************************************************** Marc Collins Before you criticise someone, walk a mile in his shoes. Then, when you do criticise that person, you'll be a mile away and have his shoes. ****************************************************************************
Terry Welch 02 Jul 1999#477397
It appears that EA is learning the lesson well - the more you can make it look real and the more you can make it play like PlayStation the more you can sell. Unfortunately, except for Papy and a very few others, the American racing sim market is aimed at 10 year olds using gamepads. There are (relatively) so few of us who use decent wheel/pedal controllers and who really demand more realistic physical modeling (handling, damage, road/track construction) that the companies making the most money simply ignore us or just dangle a few "setup screens" in front of us to get our money before we discover that we have been had again. It ain't worth waiting for NFS5 (or the inevitable NFS4 SE). Buy GPL. Buy SCGT. Buy GP2. Pray for honest marketing in Rally Championship. Wait patiently for the next real innovation from Papy. Upgrade your *** PC. Don't give the hucksters your hard-earned money. Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ Share what you know. Learn what you don't.
Joe McGinn 02 Jul 1999#477399
Quoted text (7 lines)>But first, a quick summary. Definitely a lot better than NFS 3, and, of >course, better than NFS2--the low point for the whole series. The realism >level is still below that of the original NFS, though. Sounds and graphics >are phenomenal. Lots of good gameplay options. Still no tracks to match >the originals (which are the best yet)--in fact there is not a single spot >on any of the tracks (including all bonus ones) where you could even begin >to get any of the cars close to their top speed.
I agree completely with your conclusions, as you'll see in my review when it's posted (should be up on Monday or Tuesday). That is the worst aspect of the game, the poor track design. They used the damage mode plus narrow twisty tracks to implement difficulty (i.e., instead of doing decent AI). You sort of can, if you practice a lot - but any novice will just bounce off the walls. My suspicion is that the rights to the code in the original game was shared by EA and Road and Track, who were co-developers of the game. EA went solo on NFS2 so that they could make more money. I think that great driving model code and accident/collision physics from HVS 1 is sitting in a vault somewhere, untouchable. That's why NFS2 was such utterly hopeless ***in every department (user interface, graphics, driving model, track design) - the EA team had to start from scratch. I predict we won't see good NFS tracks until either A) there is a track editor (unlikely) or B) EA develops AI-driver code that can compete in racing and doesn't have to depend on cheap tricks like narrow, twisty tracks. Given EA's reputation in AI programming (typically as abysmal as their graphics programming is superb) I don't expect that anytime soon either. Joe McGinn ========================================== Staff Writer for the Sports *** Network [link lost in import: /***.com/] ==========================================
I already use CTFJ...what settings are you recommending? Marc.
Quoted text (18 lines)> On Fri, 02 Jul 1999 17:32:32 GMT, > >but it is WAY too non-linear for a wheel. > Marc, I agree, but, get CTFJ, and use it to improve the steering > curve in NFS4. I did, and it is REAL nice on my TSW2 > http://home.att.net/~stickworks/ctfjv310.zip > Loads-a-fun, IMO.... > -- > * rrevved at mindspring dot com > * unit.26 - s.p.u.t.u.m. > * http://www.cabal.net > * http://www.sputum.com
I am afraid I have to agree with you. I already own all the titles you suggest but keep getting hoodwinked into the NFS series out of some sort of misguided sentimental loyalty towards the original. Marc.
Quoted text (101 lines)> It appears that EA is learning the lesson well - the more you can make > it look real and the more you can make it play like PlayStation the > more you can sell. Unfortunately, except for Papy and a very few > others, the American racing sim market is aimed at 10 year olds using > gamepads. > There are (relatively) so few of us who use decent wheel/pedal > controllers and who really demand more realistic physical modeling > (handling, damage, road/track construction) that the companies making > the most money simply ignore us or just dangle a few "setup screens" in > front of us to get our money before we discover that we have been had > again. > It ain't worth waiting for NFS5 (or the inevitable NFS4 SE). Buy GPL. > Buy SCGT. Buy GP2. Pray for honest marketing in Rally Championship. > Wait patiently for the next real innovation from Papy. Upgrade your > *** PC. Don't give the hucksters your hard-earned money. > > Two ridiculous aspects to this game that perhaps someone can > enlighten me > > about... > > But first, a quick summary. Definitely a lot better than NFS 3, and, > of > > course, better than NFS2--the low point for the whole series. The > realism > > level is still below that of the original NFS, though. Sounds and > graphics > > are phenomenal. Lots of good gameplay options. Still no tracks to > match > > the originals (which are the best yet)--in fact there is not a single > spot > > on any of the tracks (including all bonus ones) where you could even > begin > > to get any of the cars close to their top speed. I have a need for > speed, > > not just a need to fake powerslide through little twisty bits of > track. > > The two inexcusable design flaws in this for me are the steering and > the > > gear shifting. The handling is ridiculous at best, but this an arcade > > racer, so.... Auto shifting is the usual mess, and the manual > shifting > > "throttle blip and gear change" has been dramatically improved over > that in > > the previous versions (not counting the original which was fine). > However, > > if you drop below 2000 rpm in 4th gear, the game will automatically > shift > > you into 3rd gear. That's it--no other automated shifts!?!?!?!?! I > would > > be happy to have a dummy mode (that could be toggled) where it > downshifted > > if you were too busy or "dumb" to notice that you were lugging the > engine. > > But only this one gear combination?? It just makes no sense. > > The steering is the fatal flaw. Again, the floating in air and > spinning on > > the centre axis feeling, I guess, are part and parcel of an arcader. > But > > the non-linearity and speed sensitivity are so over blown and jarring > that > > you literally cannot hope to control the car in any normal manner. > Some of > > us have complained about GPL's built-in speed sensitivity that cannot > be > > turned off (until 1.1, that is). Multiply that effect by about 100, > so the > > car literally spins like a top when you are at launch and then it > suddenly > > drops back to "normal" steering with a lurch. The "normal" steering is > > hopelessly tuned for keyboard users...it may be OK for joysticks too, > I > > don't know, but it is WAY too non-linear for a wheel. There are 9000 > > adjustments to every small aspect of the game and controllers and > sound and > > graphics and individual cars (good)...but no linear/non-linear > adjustment > > and no speed sensitivity adjustment (very bad). > > I loved the original NFS and NFS:HS is the closest yet they have come > to > > something remotely realistic. I don't mind if you can smash walls > and do > > head-ons without your car flying apart and starting over. That's what > > arcade racers are all about. But why can't we have a bit realism-- > even to > > the level that was achieved years ago in the original NFS? If the two > > steering problems were fixed, NFS:HS would exceed the original's > steering > > (which was it weakest point). What can we do about those tracks?...I > don't > > know. > Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ > Share what you know. Learn what you don't.
Ed Ba 03 Jul 1999#477594
On Sat, 03 Jul 1999 03:41:02 GMT, As it is shipped, the center (initial travel of the wheel from center) is *slow* and sloppy and then suddenly increases at the limits of your wheel. In CTFJ, I click the + -curve- of the X-Axis 2 or 3 times. It will give you an increased steering effect at the center of the wheel travel, and a lessened one as you reach the extreme limits. Experiment with that.. (I also use a minimum deadzone.)
Quoted text (18 lines)>> On Fri, 02 Jul 1999 17:32:32 GMT, >> >but it is WAY too non-linear for a wheel. >> Marc, I agree, but, get CTFJ, and use it to improve the steering >> curve in NFS4. I did, and it is REAL nice on my TSW2 >> http://home.att.net/~stickworks/ctfjv310.zip >> Loads-a-fun, IMO.... >> -- >> * rrevved at mindspring dot com >> * unit.26 - s.p.u.t.u.m. >> * http://www.cabal.net >> * http://www.sputum.com
-- * rrevved at mindspring dot com * unit.26 - s.p.u.t.u.m. * http://www.cabal.net * http://www.sputum.com
On Sat, 03 Jul 1999 03:42:29 GMT, "Marc Collins" >I am afraid I have to agree with you. I already own all the titles you >suggest but keep getting hoodwinked into the NFS series out of some sort of >misguided sentimental loyalty towards the original. I know exactly how you feel. Every time I have received a postcard from EA promising a discounted sequel I have taken the bait. So far the only worthwhile upgrade has been from NFS1 to NFSSE. True, the graphics just keep getting better (though, oddly enough, not the engine sounds), but unless the thrill of driving a Carrera or Viper on Coastal or Alpine is matched I will continue to be disappointed. Maybe it's been said before, but I'd be willing to pay the game's original price for an NFS1 with full Win98 compatibility and even the barest of 3d support. Martin Nigel Mansell RIP!

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy