Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

Let the AI race like we do!!!

18 posts by 12 people · 10 Jun 1999 - 16 Jun 1999

I have an idea that shouldn't be too hard to implement in racing sims. Add a feature where the sim "records" how the driver drives a track. Then you can choose to drive against the AI, where the AI drives like you do. Your driving line, braking points, acceleration, braking distance, etc... Imagine racing against 10 to 20 such AI cars. It should make for some really close racing, and you will think the AI are acting very realistic. While you race yourself, you will of course improve, and the "record driver" feature could be on during these races, so you can later choose to race the better version of yourself. You could also save your AI data, so another driver could race against your AI, or race against a lot of other drivers AI at the same time. It would probably be great practice to prepare you for online racing. Watch a race at Mexico (GPL) from one of the fastest guys on the net and then watch the AI in GPL. You realize the AI have no clue on which racing line is the fastest :o). The AI in GPL doesn't drive like Jim Clark did either, but the fastest drivers on the net do :o). /Christer -- http://home.swipnet.se/~w-41236/ (Read all about the "Global online racing"-proposal under "For developers". Read it a couple of times, cause noone has understood it the first time they've read it yet :o)).
CarpeTu 10 Jun 1999#473033
You're exactly right on all points of your post! A great idea! Perhaps a tiny plus and minus spread of these clone drivers so you'll always have someone to chase. One of my most satisfying encounters in single-player GPL was at Silverstone in a Coventry tarted up as a McLaren. I was attempting to pass a Ferrari whose AI driver's performance just happened to equal mine in that moment in *** time. Four laps I struggled, catching up, balked at overtaking by lack of talent and AI wiles. Gears and speed dead even when a tiny error would drop me back a half-second. Finally after pulling off a series of absolutely perfect lines through three corners I was able to position myself for an overtake on the inside of my favorite corner, Woodcote. The point? By measuring myself against an equal foe, I was able to apply desire and learning to improve my performance, something that is more difficult against Arbitrary Intelligence that drives 2-3 seconds a lap better than me. BTW, isn't there a line of code in GPL titled "Magic Traction"? Must be the AI using it because I'm looking _any traction_!
Joe McGinn 10 Jun 1999#473034
>While you race yourself, you will of course improve, and the "record >driver" feature could be on during these races, so you can later >choose to race the better version of yourself. Several arcade racers have done something similar where you race a "ghost car" of your best lap. Joe McGinn ========================================== Staff Writer for the Sports *** Network [link lost in import: /***.com/] ==========================================
I think that there is a focus on the "four wheel drift" way of driving on the net. And the ones who started it was Papy itself. I have seen some footage of the races of the era, and I must say I was astounded how neutrally they drove! They did errors, yes, and then they sometimes had to use opposite lock and the rear end out, but when they drove the curves perfectly, their cars had no oversteer, no understeer, and it went from one state to another perfectly smooth and with gigantic suspension movement. We're all intrigued by the way they races back in -67, but I suspect the picture of the GP driver going at 100 mph sliding on all fours was the exception rather than the rule. And finally, that is why I don't think the fastest drivers on the net don't drive like Jim Clark, he hadn't his car's rear*** out all the time... In GPL we can do four wheel slides all over the place, and this isn't right, we really shouldn't be able to do that without the kind of input the real thing has, to do high speed sliding manouvres like this you really need all the input you can get, and IMHO, this should be very difficult using your eyes and ears only. That must be down to the fact that a F1 car of -67 was terrifyingly difficult to drive, and that Papy has done all kinds of adjustment to the physics in order for us to race them with any consistency at all. And, that is why I find the F3 class better suited to online racing. Otherwise, the learning AI is a good idea, Christer. The next step must be to simulate the neural network of the racing brain that decides how a driver approach racing decisions. Sometimes they judge it right, sometimes they don't... ---Asgeir--- > Watch a race at Mexico (GPL) from one of the fastest guys on the net > and then watch the AI in GPL. You realize the AI have no clue on which > racing line is the fastest :o). The AI in GPL doesn't drive like Jim > Clark did either, but the fastest drivers on the net do :o).
:> That must be down to the fact that a F1 car of -67 was terrifyingly :> difficult to drive, and that Papy has done all kinds of adjustment to the :> physics in order for us to race them with any consistency at all. : I don't know about you, but I find it incredibly difficult to get a : consistent 4-wheel drift on all corners, and I suspect that getting a : noticeable amount of slide isn't the fastest way round the corner : anyway. Well, I suspect it isn't in real life - but it seems that it _is_ in GPL. : On the other hand you do need to use the throttle and brake to get the : weight on the correct wheels when making the turn, which results in a : very small 4-wheel drift - I suspect that this is actually very : realistic (I don't know as I've never driven a '67 GP car), but you : probably can't see this happening when watching a race anyway. Surely you'd be able to spot a 4 wheel drift unless it was incredibly miniscule in which case it wouldn't have much significance. : I can't see how the real cars could have been any harder to drive than : the sim - otherwise even less of the drivers would have made it through : the season alive. I would strongly suspect that the real cars were easier to drive than the sim. -- Richard G. Clegg Only the mind is waving Dept. of Mathematics (Network Control group) Uni. of York. www: http://manor.york.ac.uk/top.html
Believe me - it would be surprising how much more cautiously and correctly you would drive in GPL if the threat of "Shift-R" were replaced by the threat of death or crippling injury. Cheers! John
Neil Raine 12 Jun 1999#473474
Quoted text (27 lines)> I think that there is a focus on the "four wheel drift" way of driving on > the net. And the ones who started it was Papy itself. > I have seen some footage of the races of the era, and I must say I was > astounded how neutrally they drove! They did errors, yes, and then they > sometimes had to use opposite lock and the rear end out, but when they > drove the curves perfectly, their cars had no oversteer, no understeer, > and it went from one state to another perfectly smooth and with gigantic > suspension movement. > We're all intrigued by the way they races back in -67, but I suspect the > picture of the GP driver going at 100 mph sliding on all fours was the > exception rather than the rule. > And finally, that is why I don't think the fastest drivers on the net > don't drive like Jim Clark, he hadn't his car's rear*** out all the > time... > In GPL we can do four wheel slides all over the place, and this isn't > right, we really shouldn't be able to do that without the kind of input > the real thing has, to do high speed sliding manouvres like this you > really need all the input you can get, and IMHO, this should be very > difficult using your eyes and ears only. > That must be down to the fact that a F1 car of -67 was terrifyingly > difficult to drive, and that Papy has done all kinds of adjustment to the > physics in order for us to race them with any consistency at all.
I don't know about you, but I find it incredibly difficult to get a consistent 4-wheel drift on all corners, and I suspect that getting a noticeable amount of slide isn't the fastest way round the corner anyway. Considering that driving the real cars can result in a serious case of death, I'm not surprised the drivers didn't go in for a lot of 4-wheel slides! On the other hand you do need to use the throttle and brake to get the weight on the correct wheels when making the turn, which results in a very small 4-wheel drift - I suspect that this is actually very realistic (I don't know as I've never driven a '67 GP car), but you probably can't see this happening when watching a race anyway. I can't see how the real cars could have been any harder to drive than the sim - otherwise even less of the drivers would have made it through the season alive.
Neil Raine 12 Jun 1999#473475
Quoted text (7 lines)> >I can't see how the real cars could have been any harder to drive than > >the sim - otherwise even less of the drivers would have made it through > >the season alive. > Believe me - it would be surprising how much more cautiously and > correctly you would drive in GPL if the threat of "Shift-R" were > replaced by the threat of death or crippling injury.
I'd never have made it out of the pits! Since then I've "died" several hundred times, so on balance I'll take Shift-R please!
That's just a replay of your lap that you can race against. I'm talking about you doing a couple of starts and a couple of laps and by that the sim gets a hint on how you drive. If the puter put all your best corners together in one lap, you wouldn't have a chance against it, until you improved :o). If it on the other hand put together a lap of all your badest corners, then you should be able to overtake that AI :o). /Christer
Quoted text (12 lines)> >While you race yourself, you will of course improve, and the "record > >driver" feature could be on during these races, so you can later > >choose to race the better version of yourself. > Several arcade racers have done something similar where you race a > "ghost car" of your best lap. > Joe McGinn > ========================================== > Staff Writer for the Sports *** Network > [link lost in import: /***.com/] > ==========================================
-- http://home.swipnet.se/~w-41236/ (Read all about the "Global online racing"-proposal under "For developers". Read it a couple of times, cause noone has understood it the first time they've read it yet :o)).
You're not mistaking it for just racing a ghost lap, are you :o)? I have Viper Racing and to my recollection I cant remember there being a function where I can race several AI that behave like I do. My idea is that you race the AI as you normally do in an offline race, but the AI will drive like you do. Your racing line, your braking points, your braking distance, your turn-in points, your corner speeds, your apexes, your acceleration, your top speeds. You should also be able to download other drivers behaviour from the net and race against them. Imagine racing AI driving like Ian Lake, Wolfgang W?ger, etc.. It could even be fun to do some offline racing leagues where all the drivers share their behaviour just before the race day, then you race against the other drivers in your offline race. /Christer > I know Viper Racing has that. > Racer X > Veteran Sim Racer > Victory Lane- > http://www.geocities.com/MotorCity/Speedway/1423/ -- http://home.swipnet.se/~w-41236/ (Read all about the "Global online racing"-proposal under "For developers". Read it a couple of times, cause noone has understood it the first time they've read it yet :o)).
Quoted text (8 lines)>snipped< > : I don't know about you, but I find it incredibly difficult to get a > : consistent 4-wheel drift on all corners, and I suspect that getting a > : noticeable amount of slide isn't the fastest way round the corner > : anyway. > Well, I suspect it isn't in real life - but it seems that it _is_ > in GPL.
That was my point exactly. In GPL you can do the four wheel drifts lap after lap without loosing it, and I really find it hard to beleive that this should be possible wihout getting any information from your balance center and spine... Right, you can see they did sideways turning, but I think that was when they didn't get the entry speed 100 % right... They certainly did NOT use it as the fastest way to turn... I think that the fact that we don't have to face the fear of dying means a lot, but I'm not sure this single fact make out the difference in driving style you can see between the GPL hot-hotlappers and the F1 of 1967... ;-) ---Asgeir---
Or how about 3 different AIs being used by the computer at the same time based on a drivers style. Drivers who drive an aggressive line in real life would use an AI that is programed to drive the track aggressively. Another would drive a normal line and another would drive a conservative line. Each driver would use the one that best suits their style and situation in the race.
Quoted text (27 lines)> I have an idea that shouldn't be too hard to implement in racing sims. > Add a feature where the sim "records" how the driver drives a track. > Then you can choose to drive against the AI, where the AI drives like > you do. Your driving line, braking points, acceleration, braking > distance, etc... Imagine racing against 10 to 20 such AI cars. It > should make for some really close racing, and you will think the AI > are acting very realistic. > While you race yourself, you will of course improve, and the "record > driver" feature could be on during these races, so you can later > choose to race the better version of yourself. > You could also save your AI data, so another driver could race against > your AI, or race against a lot of other drivers AI at the same time. > It would probably be great practice to prepare you for online racing. > Watch a race at Mexico (GPL) from one of the fastest guys on the net > and then watch the AI in GPL. You realize the AI have no clue on which > racing line is the fastest :o). The AI in GPL doesn't drive like Jim > Clark did either, but the fastest drivers on the net do :o). > /Christer > -- > http://home.swipnet.se/~w-41236/ (Read all about the "Global online > racing"-proposal under "For developers". Read it a couple of times, > cause noone has understood it the first time they've read it yet :o)).
No... I liked my idea more ;o). /Christer
Quoted text (37 lines)> Or how about 3 different AIs being used by the computer at the same time > based on a drivers style. Drivers who drive an aggressive line in real > life would use an AI that is programed to drive the track aggressively. > Another would drive a normal line and another would drive a conservative > line. Each driver would use the one that best suits their style and > situation in the race. > > I have an idea that shouldn't be too hard to implement in racing sims. > > Add a feature where the sim "records" how the driver drives a track. > > Then you can choose to drive against the AI, where the AI drives like > > you do. Your driving line, braking points, acceleration, braking > > distance, etc... Imagine racing against 10 to 20 such AI cars. It > > should make for some really close racing, and you will think the AI > > are acting very realistic. > > While you race yourself, you will of course improve, and the "record > > driver" feature could be on during these races, so you can later > > choose to race the better version of yourself. > > You could also save your AI data, so another driver could race against > > your AI, or race against a lot of other drivers AI at the same time. > > It would probably be great practice to prepare you for online racing. > > Watch a race at Mexico (GPL) from one of the fastest guys on the net > > and then watch the AI in GPL. You realize the AI have no clue on which > > racing line is the fastest :o). The AI in GPL doesn't drive like Jim > > Clark did either, but the fastest drivers on the net do :o). > > /Christer > > -- > > http://home.swipnet.se/~w-41236/ (Read all about the "Global online > > racing"-proposal under "For developers". Read it a couple of times, > > cause noone has understood it the first time they've read it yet :o)).
-- http://home.swipnet.se/~w-41236/ (Read all about the "Global online racing"-proposal under "For developers". Read it a couple of times, cause noone has understood it the first time they've read it yet :o)).
Ditto. The types of techniques developed by simmers will never be seen on a real track because no one could possibly be insane enough to drive a car that way, that often, to perfect it :)
Quoted text (10 lines)> >I can't see how the real cars could have been any harder to drive than > >the sim - otherwise even less of the drivers would have made it through > >the season alive. > Believe me - it would be surprising how much more cautiously and > correctly you would drive in GPL if the threat of "Shift-R" were > replaced by the threat of death or crippling injury. > Cheers! > John
Peter Ives 14 Jun 1999#473811
Yeah! Sounds like a great idea and, as you say, one that at first glance would seem reasonably easy to implement. What info about your driving would the computer require? As far as I can see the most important parts are the driving line, when you start braking, how much you tend to lock up under braking and relative speed through the corners. Then all that needs to be done is get a mean average for these 4 elements, add a little variation to the AI drivers so that some might be slightly better whilst others are slightly worse and you've got some pretty similar driving styles out there. Whether this info could be updated whilst actually racing against other cars I'm not too sure, what with frame rates being at a premium as they are in GPL, but it sure would make a nice feature:-) -- Peter Ives
Spot on, Byron :o). This might not be the case for all racing sims, but it's probably spot on regarding GPL. /Christer
Quoted text (21 lines)> Ditto. The types of techniques developed by simmers will never be seen > on a real track because no one could possibly be insane enough to drive > a car that way, that often, to perfect it :) > > >I can't see how the real cars could have been any harder to drive than > > >the sim - otherwise even less of the drivers would have made it through > > >the season alive. > > Believe me - it would be surprising how much more cautiously and > > correctly you would drive in GPL if the threat of "Shift-R" were > > replaced by the threat of death or crippling injury. > > Cheers! > > John
-- http://home.swipnet.se/~w-41236/ (Read all about the "Global online racing"-proposal under "For developers". Read it a couple of times, cause noone has understood it the first time they've read it yet :o)).
It would be nice to drive against yourself as you were a couple of month ago, to see where you have improved. It's always nice to see oneself improve :o). I would love to race against other drivers AI :o). /Christer
Quoted text (41 lines)>>I have an idea that shouldn't be too hard to implement in racing sims. >>Add a feature where the sim "records" how the driver drives a track. >>Then you can choose to drive against the AI, where the AI drives like >>you do. Your driving line, braking points, acceleration, braking >>distance, etc... Imagine racing against 10 to 20 such AI cars. It >>should make for some really close racing, and you will think the AI >>are acting very realistic. >>While you race yourself, you will of course improve, and the "record >>driver" feature could be on during these races, so you can later >>choose to race the better version of yourself. >>You could also save your AI data, so another driver could race against >>your AI, or race against a lot of other drivers AI at the same time. >>It would probably be great practice to prepare you for online racing. >>Watch a race at Mexico (GPL) from one of the fastest guys on the net >>and then watch the AI in GPL. You realize the AI have no clue on which >>racing line is the fastest :o). The AI in GPL doesn't drive like Jim >>Clark did either, but the fastest drivers on the net do :o). >>/Christer >Yeah! Sounds like a great idea and, as you say, one that at first glance >would seem reasonably easy to implement. What info about your driving >would the computer require? >As far as I can see the most important parts are the driving line, when >you start braking, how much you tend to lock up under braking and >relative speed through the corners. Then all that needs to be done is >get a mean average for these 4 elements, add a little variation to the >AI drivers so that some might be slightly better whilst others are >slightly worse and you've got some pretty similar driving styles out >there. >Whether this info could be updated whilst actually racing against other >cars I'm not too sure, what with frame rates being at a premium as they >are in GPL, but it sure would make a nice feature:-) >-- >Peter Ives

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy