Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

OF1R - why such few posts?

20 posts by 9 people · 01 Jun 1999 - 09 Jun 1999

Why so few posts about Official F1 Racing?

Iain Mackenzie asked why Eidos's Official F1 Racing got so little discussion. Most replied that it was an arcade game with poor physics and installation problems, unworthy of a sim group, while Mackenzie defended its driving model as more realistic than Monaco Grand Prix Racing Simulation 2 on kerbs. A critical online review was cited as summing it up.

review/impressionsgame comparisonOfficial Formula 1 Racing

Automated summary.

Why are there so few posts relating to this flawed but fun title? Is nobody playing it? Iain
Te 01 Jun 1999#471355
On Tue, 1 Jun 1999 07:47:25 +0100, "Iain Mackenzie" >Why are there so few posts relating to this flawed but fun title? Is nobody >playing it? Maybe because it is not exactly 'on topic'? :) After all you won't hear much about Psygnosis F1 here either... --Tel
=rez 01 Jun 1999#471356
I RECOMMEND that nobody play it.. There are serious install Video and controller setup problems with this demo. eg: If you have more than one video card installed, it may detect the wrong one and ZAP.. your desktop is suddenly reset to an incorrect resolution and/or crashed which can be restored only after a safe-mode re-start. Controller setup is difficult if not impossible, and controll of the car has extreemly coarse resolution, and is not satisfying at all; the car feel is numb to nonexistant.. Some graphics and screen shots look pretty, and camera angles abound, but the graphics in the game are cartoon like, blocky, and just plain yuchy. In short, this game is a waste of your time, no to mention the FIA F1 license.
Driver 01 Jun 1999#471357
It is on topic, it is a simulator. Just not a very good one, and thats why no one talks about it.
Te 01 Jun 1999#471358
>It is on topic, it is a simulator. Just not a very good one, and thats why >no one talks about it. Is every simple arcade racer hiding behind an official F1 sticker a simulator? That's the question here - I don't think so. ;) --Tel
Ruud 02 Jun 1999#471493
Quoted text (10 lines)> On Tue, 1 Jun 1999 07:47:25 +0100, "Iain Mackenzie" > >Why are there so few posts relating to this flawed but fun title? Is nobody > >playing it? > Maybe because it is not exactly 'on topic'? :) After all you won't > hear much about Psygnosis F1 here either... > --Tel
This is a ng about sims,...not about arcade games like this piece of shit!!! -- Greetings :)Ruud +------------------------------+
Pretty silly reply actually. OF1R is nothing like F1. F1 is pure arcade nonsense - nothing more. You should really check your facts before mouthing off! Iain > On Tue, 1 Jun 1999 07:47:25 +0100, "Iain Mackenzie" > >Why are there so few posts relating to this flawed but fun title? Is nobody > >playing it? > Maybe because it is not exactly 'on topic'? :) After all you won't > hear much about Psygnosis F1 here either... > --Tel
Te 03 Jun 1999#471644
On Wed, 2 Jun 1999 21:24:00 +0100, "Iain Mackenzie" >Pretty silly reply actually. OF1R is nothing like F1. F1 is pure arcade >nonsense - nothing more. You should really check your facts before mouthing >off! So is OF1R. In what way exactly does it differ? Besides, you ever heard about such thing as 'sarcasm'? ;) --Tel
I take it you haven't played the 'sim' otherwise you wouldn't be asking the question! Iain
Phil Robbi 03 Jun 1999#471646
I downloaded the demo last night and looked at it for no more than, say, 10 minutes before putting it down in disgust. Maybe I was over-hasty? Maybe it does grow on you? Maybe the real thing is better than the demo? Would be interested in hearing other people's opinions. Phil
Te 03 Jun 1999#471647
On Thu, 3 Jun 1999 07:26:53 +0100, "Iain Mackenzie" >I take it you haven't played the 'sim' otherwise you wouldn't be asking the >question! >Iain Oh please, what 'sim'? Are we still talking about 'Official F1 Racing' by Eidos? I've played both, this one and Psygnosis efforts and apart from more camera settings & replay OF1R clearly belongs in the same category. Driving model & physics are ridiculous, setup options are marginal, in fact it is even worse than F1'97 - implementation of rules is even worse, track layout and graphics are just ugly not to mention awfully wrong. Drives fine with a gamepad though, and together with those funny arrows which indicate the steering direction it's a fast & funny arcade racer - nothing else. --Tel
I presume you're winding me up here, as your comments are just plain silly! Sure, OF1R is not in the same league as GPL, but it is better than MGPRS in some respects, and the driving model grows on you. It does have significant drawbacks in the reality stakes in terms of the overall package, but nevertheless, there are a lot of redeeming features - unlike F1'97. Iain > On Thu, 3 Jun 1999 07:26:53 +0100, "Iain Mackenzie" > >I take it you haven't played the 'sim' otherwise you wouldn't be asking the
Quoted text (14 lines)> >question! > >Iain > Oh please, what 'sim'? Are we still talking about 'Official F1 Racing' > by Eidos? I've played both, this one and Psygnosis efforts and apart > from more camera settings & replay OF1R clearly belongs in the same > category. Driving model & physics are ridiculous, setup options are > marginal, in fact it is even worse than F1'97 - implementation of > rules is even worse, track layout and graphics are just ugly not to > mention awfully wrong. Drives fine with a gamepad though, and together > with those funny arrows which indicate the steering direction it's a > fast & funny arcade racer - nothing else. > --Tel
Te 03 Jun 1999#471649
On Thu, 3 Jun 1999 21:06:20 +0100, "Iain Mackenzie" >I presume you're winding me up here, as your comments are just plain silly! >Sure, OF1R is not in the same league as GPL, but it is better than MGPRS in >some respects, and the driving model grows on you. It does have significant >drawbacks in the reality stakes in terms of the overall package, but >nevertheless, there are a lot of redeeming features - unlike F1'97. <shrug> well sure, if cruising around a weird looking Interlagos track in less than a minute is okay for you, who am I (or apparently every reviewer on this planet) to change your opinion... besides, in what way exactly does it come close or is even better than MGPRS? As I mentioned earlier it does not even reach the level of F197 in some aspects. --Tel
Interlagos is poor, I agree. But, 'cruising around in under a minute' - I don't think so. It is better than MGPRS only in the respect that the driving model is more realistic IN SOME WAYS. It is too easy (and unrealistic) to lose the back end in MGPRS. Watch in-car shots for real and you soon realise that MGPRS is very poor in this respect - it's just too easy to lose control of the car. The way that the kerbs are modelled in MGPRS is also pretty bad - OF1R is better here as the differing degrees of kerb are better modelled, i.e. usable at Interlagos, but not at say Imola. MGPRS doesn't do this well - one touch and you're off! Iain > On Thu, 3 Jun 1999 21:06:20 +0100, "Iain Mackenzie" > >I presume you're winding me up here, as your comments are just plain silly! > >Sure, OF1R is not in the same league as GPL, but it is better than MGPRS in > >some respects, and the driving model grows on you. It does have significant
Quoted text (11 lines)> >drawbacks in the reality stakes in terms of the overall package, but > >nevertheless, there are a lot of redeeming features - unlike F1'97. > <shrug> well sure, if cruising around a weird looking Interlagos track > in less than a minute is okay for you, who am I (or apparently every > reviewer on this planet) to change your opinion... > besides, in what way exactly does it come close or is even better than > MGPRS? As I mentioned earlier it does not even reach the level of F197 > in some aspects. > --Tel
Te 05 Jun 1999#471904
On Thu, 3 Jun 1999 22:51:15 +0100, "Iain Mackenzie"
Quoted text (10 lines)>Interlagos is poor, I agree. But, 'cruising around in under a minute' - I >don't think so. >It is better than MGPRS only in the respect that the driving model is more >realistic IN SOME WAYS. It is too easy (and unrealistic) to lose the back >end in MGPRS. Watch in-car shots for real and you soon realise that MGPRS is >very poor in this respect - it's just too easy to lose control of the car. >The way that the kerbs are modelled in MGPRS is also pretty bad - OF1R is >better here as the differing degrees of kerb are better modelled, i.e. >usable at Interlagos, but not at say Imola. MGPRS doesn't do this well - one >touch and you're off!
You know, F1 racing isn't supposed to be 'easy' ;) but that's exactly why such games as OF1R exist... btw, I guess you may want to check out this superb review at [link lost in import: /,6,0-2854,00.html?st.gc.tc.mo] Pretty much sums it up. --Tel
Yep, I agree, the review is pretty accurate. Although, the guy did recommend F1RS in place of MGPRS so he's not completely with it! I wasn't suggesting that F1 should or is easy, I was merely stating how UNREALISTIC MGPRS is at modelling the cars performance on kerbs and stability in general. MGPRS is undoubtedly my favourite modern F1 racer, but it is not perfect by any means. Iain
Driver 07 Jun 1999#472283
You can get on the kerbs (on some tracks), and not loose control, it just takes practice. The kerbs at Imola are probably the worst in the game.
Mrv 08 Jun 1999#472499
Not very good? It is the best racing sim out there by far.
Quoted text (9 lines)> >>Why are there so few posts relating to this flawed but fun title? Is > nobody > >>playing it? > >Maybe because it is not exactly 'on topic'? :) After all you won't > >hear much about Psygnosis F1 here either... > It is on topic, it is a simulator. Just not a very good one, and thats why > no one talks about it.
Whats the best sim out there by far? Must be talking about GPL then? If not , you're wrong :o),<VBG> adn I aint the only one that'll TELL you that, it's not just an opinion :o) Ross
Quoted text (8 lines)>Not very good? It is the best racing sim out there by far. >> >>Why are there so few posts relating to this flawed but fun title? Is >> nobody >> >>playing it?
P Gagg 09 Jun 1999#472765
> Article: 166996 of rec.autos.simulators > Newsgroups: rec.autos.simulators > Subject: Re: OF1R - why such few posts? Cos its cack? *Peter* 8-)

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy