Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

FF wheels vs non FF wheels?

10 posts by 10 people · 18 Apr 1999 - 19 Apr 1999

Tim Mavers 18 Apr 1999#462694
I am considering getting a force-feedback enabled wheel but am not sure which one to buy. I read an article the other day (maybe on Gamecenter?) that discussed the pros and cons of force-feedback wheels. One of the "cons" was that if you are using an FF wheel with a non-FF enabled game, the wheel is probably going to feel very loose and sloppy? Is this true, and if so, is it real bad? I don't know all the sims I will use with a wheel (F1 and GPL for sure), but I would hate to have to use a joystick because my FF wheel doesn't work "too well" with a future sim. Also, can anyone make any recommendations as to what wheel I should get? I was thinking about the MS wheel, but it only has a game-port interface (I prefer serial or USB). Gamecenter said the FF effects were lame too. Especially for $200. Any comment (FF or non-FF wheels) are appreciated. I really don't want to spend more than $150 tops. Thanks..
Mike King 18 Apr 1999#462695
I believe it is mainly a matter of personal choice but would point you to: http://www.anandtech.com/html/review_display.cfm?document=933&pagenum=1 for a reasonable review of the MS, Logitech and Actlabs wheels. Some wheels allow you to set them to 'return to center' even in non FF software. The MS definitely in GPL and all other sims/racers I have tried with the exception of N2 (which no FF wheel works with as far as I am aware) - I don't know about other wheels. I would not recommend the TM Force GT under any circumstances as I only managed to live with it for approx. 1/2 hour - others may not agree but again personal choice plays a part. The current version of the MS wheel only connects via a gameport but I understand that a USB version will be out later in the year (no idea when). I have an SBLive soundcard and the results I have with the MS wheel connected to this are better than the Force GT was via USB. I would also suggest that once you have an idea from which wheels you will eventually choose you do a power search via Dejanews on this newsgroup - I am sure you will dig up all sorts of comments on just about every wheel out there. Best of luck. >I am considering getting a force-feedback enabled wheel but am not sure >which one to buy. I read an article the other day (maybe on Gamecenter?) >that discussed the pros and cons of force-feedback wheels. One of the >"cons" was that if you are using an FF wheel with a non-FF enabled game, the >wheel is probably going to feel very loose and sloppy? Is this true, and >if so, is it real bad? >I don't know all the sims I will use with a wheel (F1 and GPL for sure), but >I would hate to have to use a joystick because my FF wheel doesn't work "too
Quoted text (11 lines)>well" with a future sim. >Also, can anyone make any recommendations as to what wheel I should get? I >was thinking about the MS wheel, but it only has a game-port interface (I >prefer serial or USB). Gamecenter said the FF effects were lame too. >Especially for $200. >Any comment (FF or non-FF wheels) are appreciated. I really don't want to >spend more than $150 tops. >Thanks..
STev 18 Apr 1999#462696
I was thinking of buying the ActLabs FF wheel recently but decided not to when I realised that it was digital. N2 & NROS won't work with a digital wheel. Shame as it seams to be the best bet from the reviews I've seen. Steve-S +-----------------------------------+-------------------------------------+ | And quickly he's subdued | Split_S3 on IRC | | Thru constant pained disgrace | Steve-S on TEN | | The young boy learns their rules | Unforgiven (-unfg-) on Warbirds | | Metallica | Dweebs of Death | +-----------------------------------+-------------------------------------+ | Dale Earnhardt | Dale Earnhardt Jr | +-------------------------------------------------------------------------+
The Logitech wheel feels great to me with non FF sims--not loose and sloppy at all. In fact, I've actually improved times in GPL with it over the TM GP1/CH pedals setup I was using. The Logitech pedals that come with the wheel take some getting used to, but I've actually come to like them, after initially considering returning the setup just because of them. I surely do like the button placement and programmability of the Logitech stuff, too, and recommend it. (I've always thought that the MS wheel would feel OK, too, but that's just based on dry runs in the stores and no actual experience.) Jerry Morelock
Ryan 18 Apr 1999#462698
Tim, I am a proud owner of a Logitech Force Feedback wheel and would highly recommend it to anyone. Pros: -Great customer support (Tom the driver guy is awesome!!!) -Good for any game (Force or non-Force) -Excellent Force effects (smooth and informative) -Looks good (Love the red!) -Is highly configurable (Profiles, Force strength, and Centering Force) -Works on serial and USB Cons: -Some people can't stand the pedals, but it is very easy to replace the springs if you don't like them -Costs $180 at retail stores (way less online) I haven't tried any other wheels, so I guess that this is a biased opinion, but my experience has been painless and highly ***ive. I takes a couple hours to get used to it, but after that it all seems natural. Best wishes, Ryan >I am considering getting a force-feedback enabled wheel but am not sure >which one to buy. I read an article the other day (maybe on Gamecenter?) >that discussed the pros and cons of force-feedback wheels. One of the >"cons" was that if you are using an FF wheel with a non-FF enabled game, the >wheel is probably going to feel very loose and sloppy? Is this true, and >if so, is it real bad? >I don't know all the sims I will use with a wheel (F1 and GPL for sure), but >I would hate to have to use a joystick because my FF wheel doesn't work "too
Quoted text (11 lines)>well" with a future sim. >Also, can anyone make any recommendations as to what wheel I should get? I >was thinking about the MS wheel, but it only has a game-port interface (I >prefer serial or USB). Gamecenter said the FF effects were lame too. >Especially for $200. >Any comment (FF or non-FF wheels) are appreciated. I really don't want to >spend more than $150 tops. >Thanks..
John Bodin 19 Apr 1999#462856
All in all, the pedals may be more critical than the actual Force Feedback versus non-Force Feedback issue. Many people find pedals with short travel (like the Saitek R4 pedals, for example) to be a big limiting factor in ultra-realistic sims like GPL. If you really want a new wheel for sims like Viper Racing or games like NFSIII, then you should be considering a FF wheel. If GPL is more your speed, then a high-quality non-FF wheel is something you should consider. Consider: The MS Sidewinder FF wheel typically sells for $199. If you want to use it for Force Feedback-equipped games like NFSIII and Viper Racing, then it may be a great value at that price point. If you want to get the most out of games like GPL, though, it's definitely worth the cost to spend an extra $20 to get a TSW2. Nothing made of plastic can compare to the TSW2 pedals -- and you have to step up to the ECCI wheel to find anything that's really *better* than the TSW pedals. The price of the basic TSW2 is $220; upgrades will drive the price up, but for $220, you can have the best wheel for GPL short of . . . a pricier, upgraded TSW2. I know you've said your price point is $150, but since you can't get a MS Sidewinder wheel in that price range, that pretty much leaves the InterAct V4 FF wheel (currently retailing for $99), the ACT Labs RS Force wheel ($139, I believe?), or a refurbished Saitek wheel ($99, but most people wouldn't recommend it highly for GPL because of what many consider to be short pedal travel). Given all this, you might be better off overall going with a non-FF wheel (the non-FF ACT Labs RS has gotten rave reviews, for example), or saving a bit more so you can move beyond the $150 price range. If you'd like to read some of my past reviews, including the Thrustmaster NASCAR Pro, the TSW2, the Saitek R4 Force, and the PDPI digital game port, check out The IRL Insider Sim site: http://irlinsider.adnetweb.com/sims/ Enjoy! -- John Bodin Publisher, The IRL Insider Magazine http://irlinsider.adnetweb.com/
Brett Resch 19 Apr 1999#462857
Hi Tim, Whether it was Gamecenter or whoever, the source of the info you mentioned above is 0 for 2. Most (?) of the FF wheels support some type of auto centering now. With the Logitech, I have adjustable centering force in games that have FF implemented, and in games that don't. This is the kicker over a non-FF wheel for me, I love adjusting the centering force to suit my taste. (or mood :) Also, I would say that the MS wheel has the best FF effects of all that I tried - which are the Logitech, MS, Saitek, and InterAct V4. I have never have tried the Actlabs RS wheel, but I've heard mostly good things about it. The MS wheel had easily the strongest FF effects of all, plus it had some jolts in Viper Racing that I noticed I don't get with the Logitech. If there's anything that the MS wheel is lacking, it's neither quality of FF nor strength of FF. After trying all of these, the Logitech was the clear winner overall, for me. I am extremely pleased with this wheel, and I would recommend it. You should be able to get it in your price range. There's also a nonFF version of the Logitech that seems to be decent, although I've never touched one. I suggest you do a search at Dejanews for this topic in RAS, as many others and I have posted plenty of opinions about most of the FF wheels in the past. --Or if you have any other specific questions, fire away. Also, if you happen to remember the site you referred to above, I'd love to take a look at it. Good luck! Brett And for you automated email spammers out there, here's the email addresses of the current board of the Federal Communications Commission: And let's help you send some spam to the USPS, too:
btw. Best pedals I've tested are Microsoft FF wheels pedals with moving range of 5.5cm TM F1RW(also known as Nascar Pro) has for example 2.4cm(brake) and 3.6cm(throttle) and not even close as good as MS FF pedals. Does anyone know if it is possible to buy MS pedals separately without the wheel? or can they be combined? TM wheel with MS pedals? What costs the cheapest TSW _with_ split axis?(all others are next to useless... I know that cheapest models don't have split axis...)
Meiji 19 Apr 1999#462859
What would work for me would be the Logitech FF wheel and the MS pedals. I love the Logitech wheel but the pedals are terrible. It's like they ran out of metal and decided shoddy plastic would be fine. Incidentally, isn't it about time we had FF pedals too. I'd like to be able to feel my brakes. M
Joe McGinn 19 Apr 1999#462860
>that discussed the pros and cons of force-feedback wheels. One of the >"cons" was that if you are using an FF wheel with a non-FF enabled game, the >wheel is probably going to feel very loose and sloppy? Is this true, and >if so, is it real bad? It may be true with some of them, but not my Logitech WFF wheel. It feels great in all games (including GPL). The gameport is kind of lame, thouygh it's not as much of a problem with digital-optical devices like Microsoft's (i.e., they have no stutter anyway). But the USB connection on the Logitech is nice, and it's a very high quality wheel overall (the best wheel I've owned actually). Joe

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy