A touch off topic I know, but look out for this program on ITV at
10.55pm tomorrow night!. There looks to be some prime footage of
Jim Clark et al (The preview showed colour footage of a Lotus 49 in
action!).
I'm taking bets that it's a toss up between Stirling Moss or Jim
Clark!
Murray Walker's all-time top ten F1 drivers debated
A UK TV alert for Murray Walker's top ten drivers programme, which included 1960s footage, led to a debate over his list headed by Fangio, Prost and Senna. Posters disputed Mansell's inclusion and the omissions of Gilles Villeneuve, Graham Hill and Nuvolari, compared win ratios, and recalled the impact of Jim Clark's death.
real motorsportoff-topic
Automated summary.
>I'm taking bets that it's a toss up between Stirling Moss or Jim
>Clark!
If it's anyone other than Senna, Schumacher or Clark I'll be
gobsmacked, Nuvolari as an outsider.
Those are the drivers Murray has lauded in that past, although I bet
Il Leone sneaks in there somewhere....!
Cheers!
John
>>I'm taking bets that it's a toss up between Stirling Moss or Jim
>>Clark!
>If it's anyone other than Senna, Schumacher or Clark I'll be
>gobsmacked, Nuvolari as an outsider.
Moss would not surprise me either, but godforib Schumahcer ends up higher than
Clark, Senna, Prost, Fangio.
Oh he's bound too. I've always thought "Il Leone" somewhat a curious
description.
Perhaps "Bastardo grasso dalle Midlands" is better?
Z
Please remove NOSPAM from my email address when replying.
I reckon he'll go for Fangio, Clark, Senna - but now with 50 years of
World Championship GP history it's getting quite tricky to cut it down
to 10. You have to leave out some good'uns :O)
Andy
Quoted text (11 lines)
> >I'm taking bets that it's a toss up between Stirling Moss or Jim > >Clark! > If it's anyone other than Senna, Schumacher or Clark I'll be > gobsmacked, Nuvolari as an outsider. > Those are the drivers Murray has lauded in that past, although I bet > Il Leone sneaks in there somewhere....! > Cheers! > JohnI've just watched it - a great programme and I don't think I'd argue much
with his chosen top 10 !
Mike.
>I reckon he'll go for Fangio, Clark, Senna - but now with 50 years of
>World Championship GP history it's getting quite tricky to cut it down
>to 10. You have to leave out some good'uns :O)
Dammit I want to hear Murray! I'm stuck with the mopes on
SpeedVision every Sunday morning. Grrr.
Quoted text (7 lines)
> A touch off topic I know, but look out for this program on ITV at > 10.55pm tomorrow night!. There looks to be some prime footage of > Jim Clark et al (The preview showed colour footage of a Lotus 49 in > action!). > I'm taking bets that it's a toss up between Stirling Moss or Jim > Clark!Well... give it up...who made the list?
-don
I'd be disappointed if Moss rated up alongside Senna, Fangio et al.
Murray's top ten "what" would be the question. Drivers? Possibly, but
racers, no. Part of being a racer is the political shenanigans to get
your ***into the best car, and at that both Senna and Fangio
excelled. Moss was a good driver, but a classic example of nice guys
finish last.
Cheers!
John
Moss was a fantastic driver, he was unbelievably quick in any type of
car and he won loads of races. The only thing he wasn't that bothered
about was winning championships. He even sacrificed one that he could
have won for the sake of sportsmanship (defended the eventual champion
from disqualification for receiving outside assistance). I would have put
him top of the list.
- Michael
On Thu, 4 Mar 1999 00:19:37 -0000, "Mike Laskey"
>I've just watched it - a great programme and I don't think I'd argue much
>with his chosen top 10 !
Christ, I would. How can Mansell be in there ahead of Piquet, Graham
Hill, Nuvolari etc? How can the man considered as the best driver of
all-time be rated so low (Clark)? How can Senna be marked down purely
for admitting to ramming Prost, when Prost did the same thing the year
before? The only failing then is in admitting to it. How can
Schumacher, for my money a far more complete driver than Prost, be
ranked so far below?
Okay, it's a subjective rating, but I was disappointed to see Mansell
sneaked in there at the expense of Piquet and Nuvolari, for what can
only be sentimental reasons. Having seen that I was half expecting
Damon to crop up.
Cheers!
John
PS - Nice game last night, although Beckham really does need to grow
up. All that nonsense with Simeone at the start then having another
kick at him during the game. The way Simeone was booed you'd think he
had kicked Beckham - it's not like Beckham didn't have a choice over
whether to kick him or not, he dug his own grave. Strange reaction
from the crowd.
> Okay, it's a subjective rating, but I was disappointed to see Mansell
> sneaked in there at the expense of Piquet and Nuvolari, for what can
> only be sentimental reasons. Having seen that I was half expecting
> Damon to crop up.
Hi John. Could you (or anyone else out there) please post Murray's Top
10. Thanks.
A curious American,
Dave Ewing
I agree - I really don't think the Manx Whinger should have made it in at
all. Great determiniation, some outstanding passing manoevers (sp?), but top
10 great driver of all time, I think not.
Also surprised that Nuvo didn't make it in there - Murray has always champed
on about how great he was - I've even seen him say that he thought he was
the greatest.
I thought Damon might sneak in there too :-)
not sure I agree with your assesment of Schumi and Prost, but hey - that's
why Murray didn't pick the same as us either!
Stay on the black bit
cheers
-Lindsay
work like you don't need the money
love like you've never been hurt
dance like no one is looking
Quoted text (28 lines)
>On Thu, 4 Mar 1999 00:19:37 -0000, "Mike Laskey" >>I've just watched it - a great programme and I don't think I'd argue much >>with his chosen top 10 ! >Christ, I would. How can Mansell be in there ahead of Piquet, Graham >Hill, Nuvolari etc? How can the man considered as the best driver of >all-time be rated so low (Clark)? How can Senna be marked down purely >for admitting to ramming Prost, when Prost did the same thing the year >before? The only failing then is in admitting to it. How can >Schumacher, for my money a far more complete driver than Prost, be >ranked so far below? >Okay, it's a subjective rating, but I was disappointed to see Mansell >sneaked in there at the expense of Piquet and Nuvolari, for what can >only be sentimental reasons. Having seen that I was half expecting >Damon to crop up. >Cheers! >John >PS - Nice game last night, although Beckham really does need to grow >up. All that nonsense with Simeone at the start then having another >kick at him during the game. The way Simeone was booed you'd think he >had kicked Beckham - it's not like Beckham didn't have a choice over >whether to kick him or not, he dug his own grave. Strange reaction >from the crowd.>Moss was a fantastic driver, he was unbelievably quick in any type of
>car and he won loads of races.
Yes he was, yes he was, and yes he did.
Bollocks, not to put too fine a point on it. "Wasn't bothered about"?
He was certainly a sportsman, but to imply that he wasn't bothered
about winning the championship that year or indeed any other is plain
wrong. He lost through his sportsmanship and because sporting
behaviour was totally different in those days, but he most assuredly
wanted it very badly.
You're entitled to your opinion, but I'd love to see you justify how
Moss could be placed higher than Fangio when Fangio was equally
sporting, a perfect gentleman but somehow managed to win 5
championships in seven years versus none for Moss.
Nice guys finished last, even in those days.
Cheers!
John
% I'd be disappointed if Moss rated up alongside Senna, Fangio et al.
% Murray's top ten "what" would be the question. Drivers? Possibly, but
% racers, no. Part of being a racer is the political shenanigans to get
% your ***into the best car, and at that both Senna and Fangio
% excelled. Moss was a good driver, but a classic example of nice guys
% finish last.
Nope not a nice guy finishing last, but a Brit that so dearly wanted to
win the Championship in a British car. He wanted that so much he
squandered golden opportunities to be on a winning team. Besides, had
Fangio not been racing at the same time, Moss would have won at least a
couple of championships. Finishing second to Fangio a good deal of the
time is/was no easy feat. ;-) But you are right, he was a heck of a
nice guy playing in a game that was just beginning to become the F1 we
now know and ....
The following is a quote from
[link lost in import]
"In 1955 driving for Mercedes alongside Fangio, he tasted his first
victory at Aintree. In 1956 he drove a Maserati and won twice more. The
following year although again pursued by Ferrari he chose to drive for
the British Vandervell team. This decision to drive for British teams
whenever possible may have cost him future World Championships."
----- and here is a tidbit from the same site:
'Moss still keeps track of the current Grand Prix scene and is not
hesitant to voice his opinion on current circuit design and their vast
run-off areas and ubiquitous chicanes. "To race a car through a turn at
maximum speed, is difficult", he said, "but to race a car at maximum
speed through that same turn when there is a brick wall on one side and
a precipice on the other - Ah, that's an achievement."'
--
**************************** Michael E. Carver *************************
Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town.
=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
As far as I remember it went:
1: Fangio
2: Prost
3: Senna
4: Moss
5: Clark
6: Schumacher
7: Stewart
8: Lauda
9: Ascari
10: Mansell
I don't have too much problem with the first nine, although I would have put
Clark first, Fangio second, Moss third, Senna fourth and Prost fifth, but I
would have included Alan Jones, Nelson Piquet, Keke Rosberg, Graham Hill,
Chris Amon, and several others before Mansell. i doubt whether he would make
my top 20.
Tim
Quoted text (11 lines)
>> Okay, it's a subjective rating, but I was disappointed to see Mansell >> sneaked in there at the expense of Piquet and Nuvolari, for what can >> only be sentimental reasons. Having seen that I was half expecting >> Damon to crop up. >Hi John. Could you (or anyone else out there) please post Murray's Top >10. Thanks. >A curious American, >Dave Ewing: Hi John. Could you (or anyone else out there) please post Murray's Top
: 10. Thanks.
1. fangio
2. prost
3. senna
moss
5. clark
schumaker
lauda
stewart
ascari
10. mansell
numbered where i've remembered. moss and schi could have been transposed.
not sure of the ordering of the 3 above mansell.
martin.
--
Tim Leighton wrote
Mansell but no Nuvolari or GVilleneuve ?
Was Murray talking about the best drivers or best racers here ? Im still
happy to see Ascari here, a great under-esteemed person who was as important
as Fangio, just a little less "idolistic" to the people of that time. Funny
how Lauda, Prost and Stewart in a video I have on GVilleneuve all rated him
as the best driver they ever raced against, far better than themselves (and
I was surprised, normally drivers never say they are worse than the others)
-= Fran?ois Mnard <ymenard/Nas-Frank>
-= NROS Nascar sanctioned Guide http://www.nros.com/
-= SimRacing Online http://www.simracing.com/
-= Official mentally retarded guy of r.a.s.
-= May the Downforce be with you...
"People think it must be fun to be a super genius, but they don't realise
how hard it is to put up with all the idiots in the world."
>The way Simeone was booed you'd think he
>had kicked Beckham - it's not like Beckham didn't have a choice over
>whether to kick him or not, he dug his own grave. Strange reaction
>from the crowd.
I guess not if you are a Man Utd fan (which I am not) - In their opinion I
am sure they are convinced it was Simeone's reaction that got Beckham sent
off in the first place - it was hardly more than a tap which sent him to the
floor pointing at Beckham's outstretched leg. Most football crowds are
intensely biased towards their heroes ('till they move to a rival team) so I
wouldn't have described it as strange.
Obviously the ref agreed.
I actually think Beckham has done remarkably well to get through this & is
playing some excellent football - when his UK career could have been in
tatters if he had folded under pressure. I wouldn't say this to any Man Utd
fans mind - doh!
Cheers
Tony
Murray Walker's top 10 of all time
1 Juan Manuel Fangio
2 Alain Prost
3 Ayrton Senna
4 Stirling Moss
5 Jim Clark
6 Michael Schumacher
7 Jackie Stewart
8 Niki Lauda
9 Alberto Ascari
10 Nigel Mansell
I think he deserves a mention, after all how many other people have
simultaniously been the F1 and Indycar champion (for a short overlap
time).
--
Suck The Goat
On Thu, 04 Mar 1999 09:44:45 -0700, David Ewing
>Hi John. Could you (or anyone else out there) please post Murray's Top
>10. Thanks.
As far as I can remember it was as below. I'm sure of 10, 6, 3, 2 & 1
- others I'm not 100% on the order of (although the drivers are
correct, just maybe in the wrong order for those ones!).
10. Mansell
9. Ascari
8. Lauda
7. Moss
6. Schumacher
5. Clark
4. ????
3. Senna
2. Prost
1. Fangio
Any corrections?
Cheers!
John
On Thu, 4 Mar 1999 22:02:19 -0000, "Tony Rickard"
>I guess not if you are a Man Utd fan (which I am not) - In their opinion I
>am sure they are convinced it was Simeone's reaction that got Beckham sent
>off in the first place - it was hardly more than a tap which sent him to the
>floor pointing at Beckham's outstretched leg.
Nevertheless, Beckham chose to kick him, and being a professional
footballer he must have known what the likely reaction of any
top-class player would be these days.
I actually have a lot of time for Man Utd. Many players came up
through the ranks and they haven't gone out and spent massive fortunes
on foreign "name" players like certain London (and Glasgow!) teams I
could mention. I think much of the dislike for them comes from the way
commentators gush over them, which is very offputting, but for me they
are by far the most complete team (as opposed to a group of highly
talented individuals).
They couldn't have done it without a Scottish manager though..... :-)
Cheers!
John
It's fairly normal to wax lyrical about the dead - I bet if you spoke
to Prost one-to-one there's no way he'd consider Villeneuve a better
driver than him (as he wasn't).
Villeneuve was too rash, too idealistic and lacked the political guile
to be a truly top rated driver, and his record will attest to that.
Cheers!
John
On Thu, 04 Mar 1999 17:05:35 GMT, "Michael E. Carver"
>Nope not a nice guy finishing last, but a Brit that so dearly wanted to
>win the Championship in a British car.
Yes, but that in itself is a weakness. Rated purely on results, how
many championships and wins do you think Schumacher would have had if
he didn't waste the last years at Ferrari and had gone after a move to
Williams or McLaren? I'm not sure that Bernie would allow it, but
that's certainly what Prost and Fangio did.
What that misses is that even Moss has the strongest suspicion that
Fangio allowed him to win (however Fangio manufactured it in such a
way that even Moss is to this day unsure - unlike Mansell giving a
victory to Patrese in the most obvious manner possible to demonstrate
that he really could have won if he wanted).
Cheers!
John
On what oocassion raced Stewart (who retired in 1973) raced against
Gilleneuve?
--
_____
/_______\ .\\ a t t h e a d
I XT /~~~~
I 500\_____ 1977' Yamaha XT.Rex 500 Enduro
\____/\__I_I http://matthead.home.pages.de/
Quoted text (12 lines)
> Murray Walker's top 10 of all time > 1 Juan Manuel Fangio > 2 Alain Prost > 3 Ayrton Senna > 4 Stirling Moss > 5 Jim Clark > 6 Michael Schumacher > 7 Jackie Stewart > 8 Niki Lauda > 9 Alberto Ascari > 10 Nigel MansellJohn Wallace wrote
Thus being the difference between a racer and a driver ;-)
But something really good was posted on rasf1 when they were trying to
imagine themselves GVilleneuve as a racer, in the same team as Schumacher
instead of Jody. The political and racing battles between both drivers at
that time was incredible, it would had been incredible now also, even if
Jody "won".
You can't compare his record still to others. People will know that he was
for two years in an incredible poor Ferrari, and as for the rest he was at
the top, he crashed or he had some car problems. The best example to see
how he was superior to the drivers of this era is when you see the practice
times of then. When all the other drivers were doing normal laptimes
without really pushing the car, Gilles was always at the limit, race or
not, and almost always getting the best laptimes.
But if we do a list of the top 10 driver, I do hope he's at the top with
Nuvolari :)
-= Fran?ois Mnard <ymenard/Nas-Frank>
-= NROS Nascar sanctioned Guide http://www.nros.com/
-= SimRacing Online http://www.simracing.com/
-= Official mentally retarded guy of r.a.s.
-= May the Downforce be with you...
"People think it must be fun to be a super genius, but they don't realise
how hard it is to put up with all the idiots in the world."
Regarding Moss, if all of the races other than Grand Prix events were
taken into consideration, I think there would be no doubt that he
belongs in the list.
--
**************************** Michael E. Carver *************************
Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town.
=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
Absolutely! His Mille Miglia drives were particularly magnificent.
Tim
Quoted text (9 lines)
>Regarding Moss, if all of the races other than Grand Prix events were >taken into consideration, I think there would be no doubt that he >belongs in the list. >-- >**************************** Michael E. Carver ************************* > Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town. >=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=No, thus being the difference between flamboyance and a winner.
Vileneuve had what, 6 victories, no championships and precious few
pole positions. Yes, he is martyred by the Ferrari fans and yes he was
great to watch, but that is no kind of qualification for "greatest of
all time". Chris Amon has more right to that title than Villeneuve -
heck his son Jacques has, having won a championship.
Like Senna in the Lotus? That car was horribly unreliable but you can
see the talent in what he could achieve - the pole positions. I don't
recall any such from Villeneuve.
My point exactly - in practice you don't NEED a great laptime, you
gain NOTHING by a great laptime, in fact you stree your carm show your
hand and risk damaging youself and your equipment. It's flamboyance.
Cheers!
John
On Fri, 05 Mar 1999 20:03:51 GMT, "Michael E. Carver"
>Regarding Moss, if all of the races other than Grand Prix events were
>taken into consideration, I think there would be no doubt that he
>belongs in the list.
Like Prost's, Senna's, Clark's etc? I'm not sure he would make it even
then. In that case people like Mansell etc would have more of a claim,
as would Jacques Villeneuve. Not too many people have combined Indy.
F1 and Indianapolis.
Cheers!
John
On Fri, 05 Mar 1999 12:10:59 -0700, David Ewing
>champion in less *** equipment over Nigel. The Senna fans probably
>would like to see Ayrton ahead of Prost. Senna was probably the
>quickest driver over a single lap of all (he certainly was the greatest
>qualifier of all time), but Prost was more successful come raceday
>(judging by wins, championships, and fastest race laps), so you could
>argue this either way.
Remember Alain was in a competitive (nay, ***) car for almost his
entire career, not too mention his career being longer. It's
extraordinarily to compare drivers over different timeframes.
Cheers!
John
John Wallace wrote
Qualifying saw the most incredible talents of Gilles. You may not like it,
but for our people he's a cultural icon and I need to defend him. I don't
care much about Jacques. He's nothing compared to the pure racing talents
that Gilles had.
Remember this is the driver who got a qualifying lap at Watkins Glens under
the rain 11 (yes eleven!) seconds ahead of the second place. It was the
first day of qualifying, and here is a quote from Jacque Laffite when this
happened :
"Why do we bother ? He's different from the rest of us, on another level
..."
This is the driver who got into the incredible battle with Ren Arnoux at
the 1979 French GP. Enzo Ferrari always considered him as on the same level
as Tazio Nuvolari. He remembers Gilles continuing his Montreal F1 race with
a totally bent front of the car, finishing third, or racing with a blown
tyre at Zandy in 79, and qualifying a full second almost ahead of everybody
at Imola in 81. His best races were never his wins.
He should had won the 1979 World Championship. He had to let the win to Jody
and finish second, who was in a superior car at that time (Ferrari always
gave a better car to Jody), and against the ground-effect Lotus also.
Im probably biased by seeing him in other types of racing. He was one of
the best snowmobile drivers ever. When he first started his Formula
Atlantic season, he had to race with an incredible poor team (even had to
skip some races because the team had no money), but still managed to win the
championship over drivers like Jody Scheckter and other F1 drivers. He was
an incredibly airplane and helicopter pilot also, flying without a license
(of course heh).
If you want more info about him, check those websites :
http://www.ddavid.com/formula1/vill_bio.htm
http://www.forix.com/asp/pi.asp?k=0&l=2&r=7710040&c=0
http://www.bath.ac.uk/~bspahh/gilles/gilles1.html
-= Fran?ois Mnard <ymenard/Nas-Frank>
-= NROS Nascar sanctioned Guide http://www.nros.com/
-= SimRacing Online http://www.simracing.com/
-= Official mentally retarded guy of r.a.s.
-= May the Downforce be with you...
"People think it must be fun to be a super genius, but they don't realise
how hard it is to put up with all the idiots in the world."
Quoted text (9 lines)
> John Wallace wrote > >Like Senna in the Lotus? That car was horribly unreliable but you can > >see the talent in what he could achieve - the pole positions. I don't > >recall any such from Villeneuve. > Qualifying saw the most incredible talents of Gilles. You may not like it, > but for our people he's a cultural icon and I need to defend him. I don't > care much about Jacques. He's nothing compared to the pure racing talents > that Gilles had.I understand that, but I think there is a case of rose-tinted glasses.
Finnish people would say the same about Keke Rosberg, he was a similar
type of driver, a hero, even a world champion - he has more claim to
being one of the Top 10 than Gilles,
Like Barrichello taking pole at Spa? Many things can happen in the
wet/drying track - we don't think Rubens is better than Schumi do we?
Show is good, flamboyance is good, but results are everything. It does
you no good to qualify a second ahead if you fall off the track at the
first turn, if you don't bring the car home, if you don't win the race
or the championship. Ask _why_ Gilles had to drive with the nose of
his car all bent up? If he hadn't hit something he wouldn't have been
so slow and wouldn't have had to make that run, heroic though it was.
Cheers!
John
I have to agree too. I was only 6 months old when Gilles died but he's
still a racing hero of mine. The way he always drove on the limit no
matter what the circumstances was great.
Clive James sums it up best on the 1982 F1 review video when he talks
about Piquet, Lauda and Villeneuve - "One of them was a new World
Champion. One of them was an old World Champion back from the fiery
furnace. And one of them deserved to be World champion, but didn't yet
know that he never would be. It probably wouldn't have stopped him even
if he did......"
He was an incredible racer and an incredible SPIRIT, which I see as
being just as big a factor. I can't ever picture Magny Cours being
renamed the Circuit Alain Prost, for example :-)
He'd definitely be in my top 10.
--
Cheers!
Graeme Nash
http://www.karisma1.demon.co.uk
ICQ# 11257824
1998 Xoom GP2 League Champion
<<Remember this is the driver who got a qualifying lap at Watkins Glens
under
<<the rain 11 (yes eleven!) seconds ahead of the second place. It was the
<<first day of qualifying, and here is a quote from Jacque Laffite when this
<<happened :
<<"Why do we bother ? He's different from the rest of us, on another level
I had the privilage of being at Watkens Glen, in the grand stands in front
of the pits, when Gilles was doing his "out of this world drive".
At one time, it seems as if he was the only one EVERYONE was watching go by.
Everyone near me in the stands, Americans, Europeans, were chearing for him,
'cause he was giving what we all had come and paid to see ; a great F1
drive.
For this and many more reasons, he deserves to be in the top 10.
=;-D
Robert
Hull, Qubec
For the record the wins to starts ratio of these drivers is:
Fangio 47.06%
Ascari 40.63%
Clark 34.72%
Schumacher 28.21%
Stewart 27.27%
Prost 25.63%
Senna 25.47%
Moss 24.24%
J Villeneuve 22.45%
D Hill 22.22%
Mansell 16.58%
Farina 15.15%
Lauda 14.62%
Piquet 11.27%
Brabham 11.11%
Hunt 10.87%
Jones 10.34%
Rindt 10.00%
E Fittipaldi 9.72%
M Andretti 9.38%
G Villeneuve 8.96%
Scheckter 8.93%
Reutemann 8.22%
Peterson 8.13%
M Hakkinen 8.04%
G Hill 7.95%
Hulme 7.14%
Ickx 7.02%
Hawthorn 6.67%
Surtees 5.41%
Coulthard 5.41%
Gurney 4.65%
K Rosberg 4.39%
Laffite 3.41%
Cheers,
Paul
Quoted text (34 lines)
> >I have to agree. I was only a kid when Gilles died, but I can remember how > >unbelievable he was. That race in Montreal with the bent nose is an image > >I'll never forget. I like Jacques as a driver, but he still whines. I doubt > >you'd have ever heard Gilles whine - as long as the engine was running and he > >had fuel you knew he'd be out there driving his a** off. You can't help but > >love that. > I have to agree too. I was only 6 months old when Gilles died but he's > still a racing hero of mine. The way he always drove on the limit no > matter what the circumstances was great. > Clive James sums it up best on the 1982 F1 review video when he talks > about Piquet, Lauda and Villeneuve - "One of them was a new World > Champion. One of them was an old World Champion back from the fiery > furnace. And one of them deserved to be World champion, but didn't yet > know that he never would be. It probably wouldn't have stopped him even > if he did......" > He was an incredible racer and an incredible SPIRIT, which I see as > being just as big a factor. I can't ever picture Magny Cours being > renamed the Circuit Alain Prost, for example :-) > He'd definitely be in my top 10. > -- > Cheers! > Graeme Nash > http://www.karisma1.demon.co.uk > ICQ# 11257824 > 1998 Xoom GP2 League Champion> Clive James sums it up best on the 1982 F1 review video when he talks
> about Piquet, Lauda and Villeneuve
Hmm. Lauda - perhaps he would deserve a mention as well. I'm surprised that no
Aussies have piped up with Jack Brabham - I had just such a discussion with my
Australian brother-in-law and he was all in favour of putting Sir Jack up there
with the greats. He won 3 World Championships after all.
But can we compare? Nuvolari, Fangio, Lauda, Schumacher etc were all *** for
a while but few ever raced eachother at the peak of their careers. That makes
Senna and Prost different. They were both superb drivers and there was little to
choose between them.
Cheers,
Paul
> How can the man considered as the best driver of
> all-time be rated so low (Clark)?
I was 10 when Clark died. I remember him racing - I understood far less than
the limited amount I understand now but I remember his ***. The effect
his death made was extraordinary. It was impossible to believe that someone so
great could die. No one believed that it had happened. Then there was that
long dawning period when you realise that the unthinkable had actually
happened. The only other times that I have witnessed this is when John Lennon
and Elvis Presley died. My emotional reaction to Clark maybe because I am
British and may be further influenced by the fact that Clark was such a
playboy. He drove all sorts of cars competively during the same seasons, and
won on them all. He has the third best wins to starts in F1 history (only
bettered by Fangio and Ascari) and had he not died so young would surely have
acheived so much more than he did - perhaps he would have won as many
championships as Fangio. Murray's decision to put him down at 5th (below Moss)
is baffling (still who would trust Murray to get anything right).
Cheers,
Paul
I always used to keep a (suspicious) eye on Gilles because he and my
girlfriend used to hang out together whenever he would come to Road Atlanta.
She used to do some promotional work for the track, and I recall her coming
back one day and telling me about this adorable, little French Canadian
Formula Atlantic driver she met, only to later find out that it was Gilles
Villeneuve. She couldn't stop talking about what a nice fellow he was.
After one or two more days at the track with Gilles, I always made a point
of accompanying her to the track! <g>
Paul...
I always enjoy your intelligent, informative contributions, so I have to
ask.
I'm intrigued. You admired him, in part, because he was a playboy? Like in
the sense that he played with women or perhaps in the sense that he played
with lots of different kinds of racing automobiles? Maybe its a British
expression with which I am not familiar <g>
Quoted text (12 lines)
> Paul... > I always enjoy your intelligent, informative contributions, so I have to > ask. > >My emotional reaction to Clark...may be further influenced by the fact that > >Clark was such a playboy. > I'm intrigued. You admired him, in part, because he was a playboy? Like in > the sense that he played with women or perhaps in the sense that he played > with lots of different kinds of racing automobiles? Maybe its a British > expression with which I am not familiar <g>A tribute to Jim Clark can be found at:
http://www2.eis.net.au/~bramwell/welcome.htm
Cheers,
Paul
Quoted text (24 lines)
> > Paul... > > I always enjoy your intelligent, informative contributions, so I have to > > ask. > > >My emotional reaction to Clark...may be further influenced by the fact that > > >Clark was such a playboy. > > I'm intrigued. You admired him, in part, because he was a playboy? Like in > > the sense that he played with women or perhaps in the sense that he played > > with lots of different kinds of racing automobiles? Maybe its a British > > expression with which I am not familiar <g> > I didn't mean so much that he played with women more that he was a fashion icon > of the time - something that a 10-year old would readily pick up on. Clark used > to hang around with the Carnaby Street set and his girlfriend was the > super-model and actress, Jean Shrimpton. I remember quite a few pictures of them > together - one car advertising picture with them both in a wood with a sporty > looking but affordable car (I forget the model). Remember this was the swinging > sixties and Jim Clark was one of the superstars of the time. Obviously the > emotional reactions of a 10-year old are rather immature - I don't want to imbue > Clark with qualities that the press may have heaped on him. > Cheers, > PaulQuoted text (8 lines)
> >Regarding Moss, if all of the races other than Grand Prix events were > >taken into consideration, I think there would be no doubt that he > >belongs in the list. > Like Prost's, Senna's, Clark's etc? I'm not sure he would make it even > then. In that case people like Mansell etc would have more of a claim, > as would Jacques Villeneuve. Not too many people have combined Indy. > F1 and Indianapolis.I was 13 at the time. I *know* I would have been impressed at the time if I
knew he dated Jean Shrimpton. <g>
Thanks, Paul.
And what about Graham Hill? He still is the only driver who became World
Champion, won the Indy 500 and the Le Mans 24 hours!
Graham Hill should have been in this list instead of Nigel Mansell.
danny
Quoted text (14 lines)
> On Fri, 05 Mar 1999 20:03:51 GMT, "Michael E. Carver" > >Regarding Moss, if all of the races other than Grand Prix events were > >taken into consideration, I think there would be no doubt that he > >belongs in the list. > Like Prost's, Senna's, Clark's etc? I'm not sure he would make it even > then. In that case people like Mansell etc would have more of a claim, > as would Jacques Villeneuve. Not too many people have combined Indy. > F1 and Indianapolis. > Cheers! > JohnI was 10 too...small world eh :o)
I too was deeply effected by his death. I can clearly remember the
sense of shock and disbelief of losing a personal 'hero'. It was the
first time that I, as a child, began to fully understand meaning of
death.
It saddens me further to know that he was hounded by the taxman even
after he died !...... but that's another story....
% Yes, Clark and Fangio, in particular.
% Clark drove anything and won in it. He would switch from one car to the
% next a few days later and win in it. He won F1, F2, Indy, Touring
% Cars...he even raced Nascars.
Too bad his car crapped out on him at Rockingham (I believe), it would
have been interesting to see how he fared.
--
**************************** Michael E. Carver *************************
Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town.
=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
I agree, G. Hill also won the Indy 500 on his first attempt.


































