Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

The one thing i dislike about GPL

24 posts by 17 people · 24 Feb 1999 - 26 Feb 1999

Does countersteering work properly in GPL

A poster complained that opposite lock seemed to make spins worse in GPL. Others with real driving experience explained that rear-engined cars on period tyres behave differently, that too much opposite lock or a low-speed slide can cause this, and that throttle control matters more; most felt GPL's behaviour was realistic.

physics/realism debatesetup/driving techniqueGrand Prix Legends

Automated summary.

Wosco 24 Feb 1999#452343
When you start to spin or slid, you turn away from the spin (which is normally what you do) and it spins more but if you turn into the spin (which normally makes you spin down low) it stops spinning and you go about your business. Just ticks me off cause it is completely opposite in real racing. Jesse
Schlomo4 24 Feb 1999#452344
Try either getting completly out or totally flooring it when this happens. Hitting the brales hard quickly works well too if your bias is set toward the front. Chris
DAVID 24 Feb 1999#452345
No it is not. It is not the fast way to save a spin by turning more when car starts to slide. In really bad cases you will just careen off the track due to the whole car slides. What is happening is you are making the whole car slide and are bleeding speed when you do this. The lower speed makes the car more handlable. If you are able to catch the rear end sliding you can use it to make the car rotate thru the corner and you will not lose any time. the operative word here is IF -- David Robinson Egan's Law The Pace car will always go 2 MPH slower then your race car idles in first gear.
Wosco 24 Feb 1999#452346
but think about it, the whole car gets loose, you crank in more steering to make it turn more unless it goes to a 90 degree angles, if you are really sliding in real life with the back end halfway out and crank in more steering, isnt it going to catch and continue to spin? Only answer if you have real life experience. Jesse
Quoted text (23 lines)>> When you start to spin or slid, you turn away from the spin (which is >> normally what you do) and it spins more but if you turn into the spin >(which >> normally makes you spin down low) it stops spinning and you go about your >> business. Just ticks me off cause it is completely opposite in real >racing. >> Jesse >No it is not. It is not the fast way to save a spin by turning more when >car starts to slide. In really bad cases you will just careen off the >track due to the whole car slides. What is happening is you are making the >whole car slide and are bleeding speed when you do this. The lower speed >makes the car more handlable. If you are able to catch the rear end >sliding you can use it to make the car rotate thru the corner and you will >not lose any time. the operative word here is IF >-- >David Robinson >Egan's Law >The Pace car will always go 2 MPH slower then your race car idles in first >gear.
Wosco 24 Feb 1999#452347
Im not TRYING to find a way to stop spinning, i found that brakes help a lot when you have some good front bias. What I am saying is that is something I dont like about it is how when you go to correct a spin, it spins you, and i dont mean overcorrecting. Jesse >>>When you start to spin or slid, you turn away from the spin (which is >>>normally what you do) and it spins more but if you turn into the spin (which >>>normally makes you spin down low) it stops spinning and you go about your >>>business. Just ticks me off cause it is completely opposite in real racing. >>>Jesse >Try either getting completly out or totally flooring it when this happens. >Hitting the brales hard quickly works well too if your bias is set toward the >front. >Chris
Daisy Du 24 Feb 1999#452348
On Wed, 24 Feb 1999 16:46:50 -0500, "Wosco" >When you start to spin or slid, you turn away from the spin (which is >normally what you do) and it spins more but if you turn into the spin (which >normally makes you spin down low) it stops spinning and you go about your >business. Just ticks me off cause it is completely opposite in real racing. >Jesse Yeah, I know that it's frustrating but, it's not as unrealistic as it seems. IMO the trick to GPL is to use tiny amounts of wheel imput to set your turn-ins and the use your right foot to steer and make corrections and keep the car balanced. In my Toyota the old "steer in to the slide" thing works (I try it every once in a while on my qualifying lap to work <g>) You CAN do those Steve Kinser style World of Outlaws turns in GPL . The car just has to be "neutral" and you have to use very subtle input to make it behave.
Thad Failor 24 Feb 1999#452349
Okay, This one has me quite perplexed. I guess I am confused by how you where talking about correcting for the spin. Driving GPL reminds me of driving in snow/ice. Now, I have never driven a rear-engine vehical in the snow, but I have driven plenty on rear-wheel drive cars in the snow. Last winter, I was driving a long on a icy road, and all of the sudden, The back-end of the car wanted to lead. I am sliding! What do I do? Point the wheels in the direction I want to go. Well, I over corrected and the backend wanted to come around the other side. So, I turn the wheel again to get the front tires headed in the direction that I want to head. Well to make a few sec. even shorter, I kept over correcting (fishtailing) and got to a point (with on coming traffic) I had to get stopped and or off the road. Thus, my mind in a split sec. decided to induce a complete spin. Thus I turned the wheel away from the direction I wanted to head and now I am spinning. To finish the story, I ended up in a ditch, which was much better the hitting an oncoming car. GPL, you got one big problem sitting right behind you (and I asume it is worse on ther different cars). When that engine wants to lead, you are going to have your hands full. IF (like stated in another post) your quick enough to catch it, you can use it to your advantage. IF NOT then you have a lot of thinks to think about. I am not a expert in slid/spin recovery. All, I can tell you, is that if you don't do it right, that engine is going to lead the dance. If, I am totally wrong just ignore me. Thad
Jason Monds 24 Feb 1999#452350
Hi Thad, To reduce this fish-tailing action in GPL put some toe-in on the rears (positive numbers). The Ferrari is the fish-tail king of GPL ;-) One thing I *like* about GPL -- the fish-tailing upon hard accelleration :-) Jason.
Quoted text (33 lines)> Okay, This one has me quite perplexed. I guess I am confused by how you > where talking about correcting for the spin. Driving GPL reminds me of > driving in snow/ice. Now, I have never driven a rear-engine vehical in the > snow, but I have driven plenty on rear-wheel drive cars in the snow. Last > winter, I was driving a long on a icy road, and all of the sudden, The > back-end of the car wanted to lead. I am sliding! What do I do? Point the > wheels in the direction I want to go. Well, I over corrected and the > backend wanted to come around the other side. So, I turn the wheel again to > get the front tires headed in the direction that I want to head. Well to > make a few sec. even shorter, I kept over correcting (fishtailing) and got > to a point (with on coming traffic) I had to get stopped and or off the > road. Thus, my mind in a split sec. decided to induce a complete spin. > Thus I turned the wheel away from the direction I wanted to head and now I > am spinning. To finish the story, I ended up in a ditch, which was much > better the hitting an oncoming car. GPL, you got one big problem sitting > right behind you (and I asume it is worse on ther different cars). When > that engine wants to lead, you are going to have your hands full. IF (like > stated in another post) your quick enough to catch it, you can use it to > your advantage. IF NOT then you have a lot of thinks to think about. I am > not a expert in slid/spin recovery. All, I can tell you, is that if you > don't do it right, that engine is going to lead the dance. If, I am totally > wrong just ignore me. > Thad > >When you start to spin or slid, you turn away from the spin (which is > >normally what you do) and it spins more but if you turn into the spin > (which > >normally makes you spin down low) it stops spinning and you go about your > >business. Just ticks me off cause it is completely opposite in real > racing. > >Jesse
-- -------- Jason Monds "My other car is a Ferrari" http://members.home.net/gpl.mondsj/gpl - For my combined gas/brake setups (Please remove 'no extra spork' when replying)
Wosco 24 Feb 1999#452351
so you are saying that when in a turn in a real life racing car, and it starts to get loose and start to spin, dont use opposite lock cause it helps the spin?
Quoted text (33 lines)>> but think about it, the whole car gets loose, you crank in more steering >to >> make it turn more unless it goes to a 90 degree angles, if you are really >> sliding in real life with the back end halfway out and crank in more >> steering, isnt it going to catch and continue to spin? Only answer if >you >> have real life experience. >> Jesse >The tires are not addressing the road properly and with this the front >tires are still sliding till you bleed off speed. Trust me I know this >since I spent far too long with a car that understeers and cranking in more >steering just made the understeer worse, till I slowed down enough for >tires to get back some grip. It is very similar in GPL the car is >understeering cranking in more steering only makes car slow down, by >letting off some steering lock you will help front hook up better and roll >thru corner. Additionally if the rear end is sliding, by cranking in more >steering you will make front tries loose grip and whole car will slide. >This slide will bleed off speed, and if you have left track surface you >will be able to continue on. If you work on it for a while you will be >able to catch the car at start fo slide and then control it and make use of >it. In fact I have my Lotus and Eagle setup for monza to oversteer at the >corner entry off throttle and have a slight understeer on the throttle at >the exit. This helps me balance the car thru the turn and also has taken 2 >tenths of my best time. 1:27s are jsut a few thousandths away. >-- >David Robinson >Egan's Law >The Pace car will always go 2 MPH slower then your race car idles in first >gear.
You are not totally wrong...we won't ignore you. In fact, you're dead-on. You can imagine the difference between a front-engined, rear-wheel drive car (which many people have driven, and some of us in snowy climates) and a rear-engined, rear-wheel drive cart...they don't react the same way when at the limit. Your "IF you can catch it" sums things up perfectly for me. Marc >Okay, This one has me quite perplexed. I guess I am confused by how you >where talking about correcting for the spin. Driving GPL reminds me of >driving in snow/ice. Now, I have never driven a rear-engine vehical in the >snow, but I have driven plenty on rear-wheel drive cars in the snow. Last >winter, I was driving a long on a icy road, and all of the sudden, The >back-end of the car wanted to lead. I am sliding! What do I do? Point the >wheels in the direction I want to go. Well, I over corrected and the >backend wanted to come around the other side. So, I turn the wheel again to
Quoted text (13 lines)>get the front tires headed in the direction that I want to head. Well to >make a few sec. even shorter, I kept over correcting (fishtailing) and got >to a point (with on coming traffic) I had to get stopped and or off the >road. Thus, my mind in a split sec. decided to induce a complete spin. >Thus I turned the wheel away from the direction I wanted to head and now I >am spinning. To finish the story, I ended up in a ditch, which was much >better the hitting an oncoming car. GPL, you got one big problem sitting >right behind you (and I asume it is worse on ther different cars). When >that engine wants to lead, you are going to have your hands full. IF (like >stated in another post) your quick enough to catch it, you can use it to >your advantage. IF NOT then you have a lot of thinks to think about. I am >not a expert in slid/spin recovery. All, I can tell you, is that if you >don't do it right, that engine is going to lead the dance. If, I am
totally
Quoted text (12 lines)>wrong just ignore me. >Thad >>When you start to spin or slid, you turn away from the spin (which is >>normally what you do) and it spins more but if you turn into the spin >(which >>normally makes you spin down low) it stops spinning and you go about your >>business. Just ticks me off cause it is completely opposite in real >racing. >>Jesse
Wosco 24 Feb 1999#452353
Yeah i run at 18 normally and I can notice it a lot at silverstone and at turn 1 at monza. In turn 1 at Mza, on teh exit, if it is a little loose coming out and i start to turn to the left a little to correct, it will continue the spin but if I turn RIGHT or hold it to where i was steering, it just keeps going. Same thing happened at silver today. I was driving around and I started spinning in turn 1, so i just held it at that amount of steering and added just a little bit more, but then the next time it did the same thing, it got real loose but this time i corrected it using what should work and it spun out right away. Happens all the time. Dont know why but it is very unrealistic. It should help correct or straighten it out when you use opposite lock. If I get a good replay showing the 2 then ill post it. Wosco >On Wed, 24 Feb 1999 16:46:50 -0500, >>When you start to spin or slid, you turn away from the spin (which is >>normally what you do) and it spins more but if you turn into the spin (which >>normally makes you spin down low) it stops spinning and you go about your >>business. Just ticks me off cause it is completely opposite in real racing. >>Jesse >It doesn't do that for me. I would strongly suggest increasing your steering >ratio (less sensitive), or taking it a little more easy! >-- >// rrevved posts from mindspring dot com
> but think about it, the whole car gets loose, you crank in more steering to > make it turn more unless it goes to a 90 degree angles, if you are really > sliding in real life with the back end halfway out and crank in more > steering, isnt it going to catch and continue to spin? Only answer if you > have real life experience. > Jesse Am I correct when I think you're saying that counter-steering doesn't work? That's odd, because it's not how I feel it.... I think it is very similair to my real-life experiences. The major difference from standard road cars is, that you have so much more (and hotter) *** on the road. A real racecar, with sticky tires (not that sticky in GPL <g>) is quite tricky; You can catch it up to a certain point, but the rear end of a rwd racecar tends to steer a lot, with the LSD and all. In short, if it goes sideways, the rears decide a lot more than in a road car. I dunno if I'm clear here. One serious case I saw of this I remember a long time ago, when there was an asphalt hillclimb race locally. A guy who had never run on slicks before, raced his Opel Rally car. On his run up to the finish, he got it sideways, and doing as he was used to on road-tyres, he tried to counter-steer with full throttle. The rears were so grippy, they pushed the slide along, and he ended up in a tree full throttle. Matt -- ----------------------------------------- Matthew Knutsen "The Art of Legends" - GPL add-ons [link lost in import: /~kareknut/simrace1.htm] -----------------------------------------
Tilus 25 Feb 1999#452572
Hey Jesse ! That anomaly only happens if your car slowed VERY much down in a huge slide ! But opposite lock also vorks very, very nice in GPL ( i have a replay, had a huge slide at mosort, applying op. lock soon enough, and i was sliding trought the whole turn, whit opposite lock, on, and i coud carry on, and i still had a good time !) >Try either getting completly out or totally flooring it when this happens. >Hitting the brales hard quickly works well too if your bias is set toward the >front. Yeah ! thats a problem ! That will never work on any ractrack, any car ! And you can make this a lot of times, whitout loosing the car, i use the same thing, to get the car back in straight line at Nuring if i have problems... Tilus sorry for the bad english !
DAVID 25 Feb 1999#452573
The tires are not addressing the road properly and with this the front tires are still sliding till you bleed off speed. Trust me I know this since I spent far too long with a car that understeers and cranking in more steering just made the understeer worse, till I slowed down enough for tires to get back some grip. It is very similar in GPL the car is understeering cranking in more steering only makes car slow down, by letting off some steering lock you will help front hook up better and roll thru corner. Additionally if the rear end is sliding, by cranking in more steering you will make front tries loose grip and whole car will slide. This slide will bleed off speed, and if you have left track surface you will be able to continue on. If you work on it for a while you will be able to catch the car at start fo slide and then control it and make use of it. In fact I have my Lotus and Eagle setup for monza to oversteer at the corner entry off throttle and have a slight understeer on the throttle at the exit. This helps me balance the car thru the turn and also has taken 2 tenths of my best time. 1:27s are jsut a few thousandths away. -- David Robinson Egan's Law The Pace car will always go 2 MPH slower then your race car idles in first gear.
DAVID 25 Feb 1999#452574
Racing a car with racing slicks is a completely different matter. They have great response but the limit of adhesion is very knife edged, where a street tire will loose its grip much slower then a proper racing tire. -- David Robinson Egan's Law The Pace car will always go 2 MPH slower then your race car idles in first gear.
Phil Hobb 25 Feb 1999#452575
I must try that. -- #33 Spa...not yet. >When you start to spin or slid, you turn away from the spin (which is >normally what you do) and it spins more but if you turn into the spin (which >normally makes you spin down low) it stops spinning and you go about your >business. Just ticks me off cause it is completely opposite in real racing. >Jesse
T.Galvin 25 Feb 1999#452576
Well actually Wasco that is exactly what happens in real racing. Opposite lock is what you use to control the slide until your rear gets past the point of no return . When this happens the momentum of the car has now changed and opposite lock is now forcing the car to spin even more. By reversing the lock like you say, you are allowing the front to re-catch the rear so to speak and regain control. This is the first lesson I learnt racing dirt track speedway and was amazed how well it was modelled in GPL. Once you have learned to use it to save your ass you can then use it to push the car to the limit. Todd. >When you start to spin or slid, you turn away from the spin (which is >normally what you do) and it spins more but if you turn into the spin (which >normally makes you spin down low) it stops spinning and you go about your >business. Just ticks me off cause it is completely opposite in real racing. >Jesse
Quoted text (12 lines)> Yeah i run at 18 normally and I can notice it a lot at silverstone and at > turn 1 at monza. In turn 1 at Mza, on teh exit, if it is a little loose > coming out and i start to turn to the left a little to correct, it will > continue the spin but if I turn RIGHT or hold it to where i was steering, it > just keeps going. Same thing happened at silver today. I was driving > around and I started spinning in turn 1, so i just held it at that amount of > steering and added just a little bit more, but then the next time it did the > same thing, it got real loose but this time i corrected it using what should > work and it spun out right away. Happens all the time. Dont know why but > it is very unrealistic. It should help correct or straighten it out when > you use opposite lock. If I get a good replay showing the 2 then ill post > it.
Don't post it but put it up on a web page. I would totally like to see it. In these cars you can do so much with throttle inputs that the alignment of the front wheels may make little difference. -- Anssi Lehtinen
David Ewing 25 Feb 1999#452578
> but think about it, the whole car gets loose, you crank in more steering to > make it turn more unless it goes to a 90 degree angles, if you are really > sliding in real life with the back end halfway out and crank in more > steering, isnt it going to catch and continue to spin? Only answer if you > have real life experience. Doug Milliken (a well known authority on the subject) posted a detailed explanation of why this is realistic. See if you can find it with dejanews. Dave Ewing
schwab 25 Feb 1999#452579
Just my 2 cents... I think GPL does it ok. At Silver, tho, beware of the crown! That can do some wierd things if each end of the car is on opposite sides of the crown. AND... maybe your throttle/brake work was not EXACTLY the same in each instance. Adding more (or less) of one than the other at the wrong time can change things a lot too... as I'm sure you know. --Dave
Quoted text (32 lines)> Yeah i run at 18 normally and I can notice it a lot at silverstone and at > turn 1 at monza. In turn 1 at Mza, on teh exit, if it is a little loose > coming out and i start to turn to the left a little to correct, it will > continue the spin but if I turn RIGHT or hold it to where i was steering, it > just keeps going. Same thing happened at silver today. I was driving > around and I started spinning in turn 1, so i just held it at that amount of > steering and added just a little bit more, but then the next time it did the > same thing, it got real loose but this time i corrected it using what should > work and it spun out right away. Happens all the time. Dont know why but > it is very unrealistic. It should help correct or straighten it out when > you use opposite lock. If I get a good replay showing the 2 then ill post > it. > Wosco > >On Wed, 24 Feb 1999 16:46:50 -0500, > >>When you start to spin or slid, you turn away from the spin (which is > >>normally what you do) and it spins more but if you turn into the spin > (which > >>normally makes you spin down low) it stops spinning and you go about your > >>business. Just ticks me off cause it is completely opposite in real > racing. > >>Jesse > >It doesn't do that for me. I would strongly suggest increasing your > steering > >ratio (less sensitive), or taking it a little more easy! > >-- > >// rrevved posts from mindspring dot com
-- Dave Schwabe The Aussie Toad -- Grand Prix Legends & Brabham site http://users.wi.net/~schwabe
Grant Reeve 25 Feb 1999#452580
> Driving GPL reminds me of driving in snow/ice. Now, I have never > driven a rear-engine vehical in the snow I very definitely have to agree with your comment of driving in snow reminding me of GPL :) A couple of times since I bought a Toyota MR2 a month ago I've experimented with snow driving in the supermarket parking lot accross the road because I had never driven in snow conditions before and needed the experience. An MR2 is a Mid-engine, Rear-wheel drive, 2 seater (hence the MR2 designation) sports car. The model I have does have LSD, I should mention, and I've also got proper snow tires on it. The first time I was skid-pad testing in the snow and*** the tail out I discovered that counter-steering works perfectly for controlling and correcting when the rear starts to head off in it's own direction. To me it feels pretty much exactly like GPL but at lower speeds and in slow motion. But with a 58% weight bias on the rear snow tires the rear wheels do get a lot of good traction compared to front engine rear wheel drive cars which end up fish- tailing, and the LSD makes certain that the inside rear doesn't just light up and spin uselessly. Not sure if this post helped the discussion at all... Grant.
Wosco 25 Feb 1999#452581
well the rears havnt gone completely past the point of no return, just when i get a slight looseness and i try to correct it will spin more.
Quoted text (7 lines)> Well actually Wasco that is exactly what happens in real racing. Opposite >lock is what you use to control the slide until your rear gets past the >point of no return . When this happens the momentum of the car has now >changed and opposite lock is now forcing the car to spin even more. By >reversing the lock like you say, you are allowing the front to re-catch the >rear so to speak and regain control. > This is the first lesson I learnt racing dirt track speedway and was
amazed
Quoted text (14 lines)>how well it was modelled in GPL. Once you have learned to use it to save >your ass you can then use it to push the car to the limit. > Todd. >>When you start to spin or slid, you turn away from the spin (which is >>normally what you do) and it spins more but if you turn into the spin >(which >>normally makes you spin down low) it stops spinning and you go about your >>business. Just ticks me off cause it is completely opposite in real >racing. >>Jesse
KCDC 26 Feb 1999#452798
Wosco, I'm not necessarily an expert on this, but I do have 30+ years of experience driving *** ice and gravel, which GPL feels a lot like. It could be, that by steering into the slide, you are causing the fronts to have more traction, agravating the start of the spin. By counter steering, you are reducing the tire slip angle. If you had a lot of lock on, or at least a large slip angle at the front, reducing the slip angle will give you more grip at the front. All tires have a peak in the grip vs. slip angle, and once you go past the peak it declines fairly rapidly. If the counter steering brings the front tires back up the "back side" of the traction curve, they will grip more, and make the spin worse. On the other hand, turning in more, will further reduce the front's grip. This may be enough to re-balance the car with the rears starting to slide, catching the spin. I have never had GPL do anything that didn't feel completely right (besides the occasional computer crash, and of course that damn internet warping!). I've driven on, and perhaps too frequently past, the edge on ice and snow, and while I have limited experience with a rear engine car (anyone remember the Fiat 750 Spyder?), GPL feels exactly right to me. Kevin Caldwell Calgary, Canada >well the rears havnt gone completely past the point of no return, just when >i get a slight looseness and i try to correct it will spin more.
Wozmon 26 Feb 1999#452799
I thought this was a joke at first..guess not. You turn your wheels INTO a slide to correct, not away. Turning into a slide allows the front end to "catch up" to the rear of the car. In case your wondering, other than drag racing I do not have any experience. But my Father and Uncles raced stocks in the chicago area in the 50's and 60's and I was raised in the pits. If in doubt, watch a World of Outlaws Sprint car. Its easy to see as they have to correct in a much more exagerated way.

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy