Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

What does 'fun' have to do with it?

15 posts by 7 people · 15 Feb 1999 - 25 Feb 1999

jalo 15 Feb 1999#450235
You have got to be kidding, right? I don't have GPL working right at this moment, I'm going to have to check, and see for myself, as soon as I get another wheel.
Ian Wright 16 Feb 1999#450437
If you get an adrenaline rush, then you're having fun IMO. Example: I had an online race at Watkins Glen tonight - I was in a bunch of four close, high speed racers, coming out of the big bend at full throttle, the car in front suddenly swerved left - I saw why, a backmarker appeared out of nowhere, stationary in the middle of the track. I missed him by the narrowest of margins... it was pretty exciting I tell you what, and it's not something you can experience when using the "Nintendo view" or Shift-R races. Also has anyone noticed that if you stop at the side of the road, a car speeding past makes your car rock gently... that's great physics. Ian
Paul Jone 16 Feb 1999#450438
Yeah, VROC is amazing fun. Two great races hosted by G.Wilson tonight - thanks GW. One at Monza, one at Kyalami. Full grids, very little warp. Went through my Kyalami PB 3 times. I caught the tail-ender though :-( Cheers, Paul
Quoted text (13 lines)> If you get an adrenaline rush, then you're having fun IMO. > Example: I had an online race at Watkins Glen tonight - I was in a bunch of four > close, high speed racers, coming out of the big bend at full throttle, the car in > front suddenly swerved left - I saw why, a backmarker appeared out of nowhere, > stationary in the middle of the track. I missed him by the narrowest of > margins... it was pretty exciting I tell you what, and it's not something you > can experience when using the "Nintendo view" or Shift-R races. > Also has anyone noticed that if you stop at the side of the road, a car speeding > past makes your car rock gently... that's great physics. > Ian
> Racing is a tense and even rather grim business, isnt it? I know Jackie >Stewart talking about banishing all pleasant and light hearted thoughts from >his mind well before a race started. In any case, if the competition is good >and you are actually trying to *BEAT* them, there dosent (off the top of my >head) seem to be much call for 'fun' to be an issue in a sim ..at least if >the objective is to mimic real life action. But do we want a little fun?? Racing _is_ fun. Period, full stop, end of story. It can be many other things, dangerous, grim, downright ***, but at the bottom of everything, the reason why Jacke Stewart was even there in the first place, was because he enjoyed driving cars and driving them as fast as he could. Any race-driver will tell you that. I believe at some point the danger, pressure and competitive atmosphere *could* overshadow the fun, but I certainly never found it. A story I've told here before but which always brings a smile to my face is about precisely that aspect. An interviewer was touring the Adelaide pitlane prior to the '94 Hill/Schumacher showdown, interviewing all the drivers on what they thought about racing, F1, the competition, the danger. All gave "the Coulthard answer", professional, PR-friendly, nice soundbites about responsibility to team, sponsors, the need to race safely, environmentally conscious etc. The interviewer then came to Alesi, who sat and contemplated for a few seconds before a massive grin split his face - "I do F1 because it is such a HUGE fun". That's the answer I think the others would give if they were being honest. Sims are an extension of this, and while you can still have a small measure of the pressure you can have none on the danger and much of the fun. If I'm not getting paid and I'm not having fun then I'm not going to spend my spare time doing it! :-) Even (especially) GPL is "fun" for me, outweighing by far all other considerations. Cheers! John
David Ewing 16 Feb 1999#450440
> Yeah, VROC is amazing fun. Two great races hosted by G.Wilson tonight - thanks GW. > One at Monza, one at Kyalami. Full grids, very little warp. Went through my Kyalami > PB 3 times. I caught the tail-ender though :-( Paul, and the race before you got there was an intermediate long race with a full field of 20 drivers at Monza - and 15 guys made it to the finish! Great stuff (and a big thank you to G. Wilson). Dave Ewing (To paraphrase Jean Alesi, "I do GPL because it is such a HUGE fun")
Spot on (as ever) John. Without AI or on-line human opposition, the sheer joy of running countless laps on my own around Watkins Glen during the 'demo months' is hard to understand - it just conveys the feeling of driving on & over the edge. Once you add the racing factor of other drivers it IS great fun. I guess the fun factor can lessen if it becomes an obsession to better other drivers hotlaps - which is a problem created by the internet. I was blissfully unaware I wasn't the greatest F1GP driver - cos I won at the highest level. Once I got on the Net I found all these add-ons to boost the F1GP AI to make it a challenge for the quick drivers. Most sports we are involved in are at a local level, so many can be top of their field. Net racing is world wide, so whilst we can be relatively good the competition is on a world wide level - this can be disheartening seeing that my low 1:05s (which seemed impossible a few months ago) at the Glen just don't cut it with the quick guys. I just have to be philosophical about it or the fun element goes away - to be replaced by obsessive practicing. I do wonder about some computer games. Clearly I am biased cos I love motor racing, but I question whether platform games for instance are fun - or whether the only motivation to play is to finish the level & move on. I find single player Quake can suffer from the same desire to complete it rather than enjoy it. Deathmatch is totally different - I don't do it very often so I get stuffed by the good guys - but it is total fun. Perhaps GPL seems too much like hard work for some, but thats hobbies for you - some people push themselves to physical & mental limits within their hobbies - were all different & our perception of fun likewise. For the party animals spending an evening racing on the internet is perceived as sad. Definitions of fun are extremely personal. Cheers Tony Cheers Tony
Quoted text (28 lines)>Racing _is_ fun. Period, full stop, end of story. It can be many other >things, dangerous, grim, downright ***, but at the bottom of >everything, the reason why Jacke Stewart was even there in the first >place, was because he enjoyed driving cars and driving them as fast as >he could. Any race-driver will tell you that. I believe at some point >the danger, pressure and competitive atmosphere *could* overshadow the >fun, but I certainly never found it. >A story I've told here before but which always brings a smile to my >face is about precisely that aspect. An interviewer was touring the >Adelaide pitlane prior to the '94 Hill/Schumacher showdown, >interviewing all the drivers on what they thought about racing, F1, >the competition, the danger. All gave "the Coulthard answer", >professional, PR-friendly, nice soundbites about responsibility to >team, sponsors, the need to race safely, environmentally conscious >etc. The interviewer then came to Alesi, who sat and contemplated for >a few seconds before a massive grin split his face - "I do F1 because >it is such a HUGE fun". That's the answer I think the others would >give if they were being honest. >Sims are an extension of this, and while you can still have a small >measure of the pressure you can have none on the danger and much of >the fun. If I'm not getting paid and I'm not having fun then I'm not >going to spend my spare time doing it! :-) Even (especially) GPL is >"fun" for me, outweighing by far all other considerations. >Cheers! >John
Paul Jone 16 Feb 1999#450442
I seldom win an online race in GPL - perhaps I have won 4 or 5 out of 100. But it's still amazing fun and there are always people around your pace to compete with and pretty soon you recognise all their names and can see what sort of race it's going to be. Thank heaven all those other middling racers find it worth racing online because if only the real ***s raced then I would find it rather dull. If you forget the thought of beating Tadej Krev, Ian Lake, Roos, Rick Prydden, Barry Stoch, Ian Parker etc then you set yourself reasonable targets and have a ball. Racing the AI is dull as dishwater by comparison. I'd rather be thrashed online (as usual) than beat Clark and Hill at Grand Prix level. There's no adreneline involved with the AI, no pressure - ther's no "shoot, I'm in the lead - my God - can I hold it? - just 4 laps left - don't overrev, idiot, you'll blow her - you've got 4 seconds on him - oh Christ! a backmarker - hell I hope he's seen or heard me - why's he racing me? - YOU *&"&^"% - oh, well 2nd is great" :-) Cheers, Paul
Quoted text (36 lines)> Spot on (as ever) John. > Without AI or on-line human opposition, the sheer joy of running countless > laps on my own around Watkins Glen during the 'demo months' is hard to > understand - it just conveys the feeling of driving on & over the edge. Once > you add the racing factor of other drivers it IS great fun. > I guess the fun factor can lessen if it becomes an obsession to better other > drivers hotlaps - which is a problem created by the internet. I was > blissfully unaware I wasn't the greatest F1GP driver - cos I won at the > highest level. Once I got on the Net I found all these add-ons to boost the > F1GP AI to make it a challenge for the quick drivers. > Most sports we are involved in are at a local level, so many can be top of > their field. Net racing is world wide, so whilst we can be relatively good > the competition is on a world wide level - this can be disheartening seeing > that my low 1:05s (which seemed impossible a few months ago) at the Glen > just don't cut it with the quick guys. I just have to be philosophical about > it or the fun element goes away - to be replaced by obsessive practicing. > I do wonder about some computer games. Clearly I am biased cos I love motor > racing, but I question whether platform games for instance are fun - or > whether the only motivation to play is to finish the level & move on. I find > single player Quake can suffer from the same desire to complete it rather > than enjoy it. Deathmatch is totally different - I don't do it very often so > I get stuffed by the good guys - but it is total fun. > Perhaps GPL seems too much like hard work for some, but thats hobbies for > you - some people push themselves to physical & mental limits within their > hobbies - were all different & our perception of fun likewise. For the party > animals spending an evening racing on the internet is perceived as sad. > Definitions of fun are extremely personal. > Cheers > Tony
> I'd call that an adrenaline rush, but I sure wouldnt want to feel that way >'all the time' ..if you get my meaning. (and all of you guys who regularly sit >at home and lean back in a chair too far for 'fun' while nobody else is home, >you are SICK!) :-) Many times I have sat with my legs*** out of an aeroplane door at 12,000ft ready to hurl myself out into space, and apart from feeling much colder the adrenalin rush is much the same - as is the sick and giddy feeling of falling and disorientation. It just lasts much longer! And yes, it is fun - a HELL of a lot of fun :-) Cheers! John PS - Wear a parachute, it helps....
Paul Jone 17 Feb 1999#450691
> Laughing. Hmmm, mabey *you* should take a page from Johns book and wear a > parachute. On the plus side, the low hardware requirements for what you are > doing is a big advantage :) For this kind of activity I think soft wear (sic) is better :-) Cheers, Paul
On Tue, 16 Feb 1999 22:56:00 -0000, "Tony Rickard" >I guess the fun factor can lessen if it becomes an obsession to better other >drivers hotlaps - which is a problem created by the internet. Hotlapping is a totally false comparison, and one which I dislike as a means of comparison. "Who is the fastest" in real life comes from the driver who, in a given number of laps, can best marshall his developed talents of setup, driving and opportunism, with a bit of luck thrown in, to get as close to their perception of the limit as they possibly can. In sims drivers have all the time in the world to try setups, cut corners, exceed the limit and gradually pind down precisely what is and isn't possible in any given car. Whichever driver is prepared to put the most time in will have an advantage, regardless of the talent, setup skill or whatever. It's a comparison and competition of sorts, but nothing akin to real life. Agreed. I played Half Life all the way through to the end and haven't touched it since. OTOH I _still_ play Quake and Quake2 deathmatch but have never played it through to the end. Recently I'm heavily into "Tribes" which doesn't even HAVE a single-player mode! I got a mate to send it to me from the U.S., since as ever it's not out in the UK so far. Defining others by your own beliefs and perceptions is sad, that's about it. Cheers! John
Quoted text (15 lines)>Hotlapping is a totally false comparison, and one which I dislike as a >means of comparison. >"Who is the fastest" in real life comes from the driver who, in a >given number of laps, can best marshall his developed talents of >setup, driving and opportunism, with a bit of luck thrown in, to get >as close to their perception of the limit as they possibly can. In >sims drivers have all the time in the world to try setups, cut >corners, exceed the limit and gradually pind down precisely what is >and isn't possible in any given car. Whichever driver is prepared to >put the most time in will have an advantage, regardless of the talent, >setup skill or whatever. >It's a comparison and competition of sorts, but nothing akin to real >life.
Agree with everything except "regardless of talent". Talent does play its part. Sure take 2 drivers of equal talent & the one who gets the most time will have the advantage. I know from my own experience how surprised I have been to keep on reducing times at tracks. Clearly if I could have condensed several months playing into several days, then I would have had an advantage over my competitors, and on the assumption I would continue to improve (albeit at a slower rate) be significantly faster than I am now. Some of the quickest GPL drivers have spent an enormous amount of time improving their times, but even if I was to devote the rest of my life to GPL I accept they will still be ahead of me :-( Tony
Jack 24 Feb 1999#452318
Tony. Your wife and son have asked me to ask you not to do this. I'm sorry.
On Wed, 24 Feb 1999 17:12:24 -0000, "Tony Rickard" >Agree with everything except "regardless of talent". Talent does play its >part. Sure take 2 drivers of equal talent & the one who gets the most time >will have the advantage. Read it again - "will have _an_ advantage". He will not necessarily have THE advantage (i.e. be expected to triumph) but the time invested will be an advantage he can call upon which is not afforded in real life, at least not to that extent. I thought I'd worded that quite carefully to avoid misinterpretation, but I'll work on it more in future - sorry :-) Cheers! John
>I thought I'd worded that quite carefully to avoid misinterpretation, >but I'll work on it more in future - sorry :-) Thanks John We're only simple folk down in the West Country. Now Randy - 'bout that ploughing race sim.... Cheers Tony
>>...if I was to devote the rest of my life to GPL... >Tony. Your wife and son have asked me to ask you not to do this. I'm sorry. The former has made it clear to me... Also she keeps arranging things to the extent that Zandvoort is going to be very realistic in terms of no pre event practice!!! Cheers Tony

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy