Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

TOCA2 vs GPL

8 posts by 5 people · 30 Jan 1999 - 31 Jan 1999

t.. 30 Jan 1999#447888
I have tried both demo's and TOCA2 really kicks GPL's ass. I am not sure why there is so much acclaim for GPL. TOCA2 is really impressive. Does GPL support 10x7 in the demo. I think I am only getting 6x4.......
Paul E 31 Jan 1999#448008
>I have tried both demo's and TOCA2 really kicks GPL's ass. I am not sure >why there is so much acclaim for GPL. TOCA2 is really impressive. Does >GPL support 10x7 in the demo. I think I am only getting 6x4....... Depends what you want from a game, if you have raced real cars you REALLY enjoy the physics of GPL but TOCA2 is a quick thrill type game... both have there strong points
Cant you be more specific :o)? I mean there are those of us that say graphics is more important than physics and AI. Then there are those of us that say physics is more important than graphics and AI. There are even those who think AI is the most important, but they play strategy and tactical games, not racing games. Then there are opinions and taste which even more garbels the issue :o). The most important for me is physics, then comes AI and then comes graphics. With that in mind I think GPL takes the longer straw, cause it seems the physics is better in GPL. I even think the graphics are better, but that is more taste than science. The TOCA2 is more cartoonish, IMO, very much like F1RS. The reality isn't that colorful, is it :o)? The AI in GPL has it's own chapter. I think Papy wanted too much and didn't have time to finish it. In short they made it too complex. They took a too big step in one go and fell. To succed in any project, my tip is to keep it simple and take one step at the time. That's how we got to the moon, so why not learn from that :o)? The best way to change AI strength is to modulate the same things as what makes the difference in human strength. That is you modulate the braking point, the braking efficiency, the turn in point and the start accelerating point. I might have forgotten a parameter, but what you dont do is what Papy did - modulate the accelerating. As an example the really fast AI at Monza reach their top speed, 312 kph, already at the start/finish line. I dont find this very realistic. /Christer > I have tried both demo's and TOCA2 really kicks GPL's ass. I am not sure > why there is so much acclaim for GPL. TOCA2 is really impressive. Does > GPL support 10x7 in the demo. I think I am only getting 6x4....... -- http://home.swipnet.se/~w-41236/ (Read all about the "Global online racing"-proposal under "For developers". Read it a couple of times, cause noone has understood it the first time they've read it yet :o)). http://home.swipnet.se/~w-41236/GplLadder/SOGL/index.html (Join one of the online GPL ladders)
Remco Moedt 31 Jan 1999#448010
Well Tony, I admit, you're a brave soul. Are you aware of the fact that GPL support resolutions up to 1600x1200? Next... Remco >I have tried both demo's and TOCA2 really kicks GPL's ass. I am not sure >why there is so much acclaim for GPL. TOCA2 is really impressive. Does >GPL support 10x7 in the demo. I think I am only getting 6x4.......
t.. 31 Jan 1999#448011
I will say that the spinout of TOCA2 is a real pain. I am not sure that a car really spins out everytime it touches grass. On the other hane. GPL really looks bad. I cant get over the fact that the wheels snap to the left and the right. That really looks bad. The cars are really ugly. I guess the car drives ok, but how many people have ever driven a Grand Prix car to know if it is a true sim or not. The sky in GPL really looks funky, like a bunch of squares. Maybe I can adjust this, but I only have the demo. That is just my opinion...
Quoted text (41 lines)> Cant you be more specific :o)? I mean there are those of us that say graphics is > more important than physics and AI. Then there are those of us that say physics > is more important than graphics and AI. There are even those who think AI is the > most important, but they play strategy and tactical games, not racing games. > Then there are opinions and taste which even more garbels the issue :o). > The most important for me is physics, then comes AI and then comes graphics. > With that in mind I think GPL takes the longer straw, cause it seems the physics > is better in GPL. I even think the graphics are better, but that is more taste > than science. The TOCA2 is more cartoonish, IMO, very much like F1RS. The > reality isn't that colorful, is it :o)? > The AI in GPL has it's own chapter. I think Papy wanted too much and didn't have > time to finish it. In short they made it too complex. They took a too big step > in one go and fell. To succed in any project, my tip is to keep it simple and > take one step at the time. That's how we got to the moon, so why not learn from > that :o)? > The best way to change AI strength is to modulate the same things as what makes > the difference in human strength. That is you modulate the braking point, the > braking efficiency, the turn in point and the start accelerating point. I might > have forgotten a parameter, but what you dont do is what Papy did - modulate the > accelerating. As an example the really fast AI at Monza reach their top speed, > 312 kph, already at the start/finish line. I dont find this very realistic. > /Christer > > I have tried both demo's and TOCA2 really kicks GPL's ass. I am not sure > > why there is so much acclaim for GPL. TOCA2 is really impressive. Does > > GPL support 10x7 in the demo. I think I am only getting 6x4....... > -- > http://home.swipnet.se/~w-41236/ (Read all about the "Global online > racing"-proposal under "For developers". Read it a couple of times, cause noone > has understood it the first time they've read it yet :o)). > http://home.swipnet.se/~w-41236/GplLadder/SOGL/index.html (Join one of the > online GPL ladders)
t.. 31 Jan 1999#448012
Can I change it in the demo? I also am note sure if I want it after the problems I have had with other Sierra games...
Quoted text (15 lines)> Well Tony, > I admit, you're a brave soul. Are you aware of the fact that GPL > support resolutions up to 1600x1200? > Next... > Remco > >I have tried both demo's and TOCA2 really kicks GPL's ass. I am not sure > >why there is so much acclaim for GPL. TOCA2 is really impressive. Does > >GPL support 10x7 in the demo. I think I am only getting 6x4.......
Jack 31 Jan 1999#448013
You're apparently not using a 3Dfx or Rendition board. They make a BIG difference in graphics quality, frame rate, and driveability. Without the right hardware you can't really enjoy or appreciate GPL.
Remco Moedt 31 Jan 1999#448014
Hi Tony, >Can I change it in the demo? I believe you can, but I suspect that you don't have eighter a Rendition or an 3DFX card. Right? So you use the software renderer I suppose. If that is the case, you're right, GPL sucks. However, if your video card supports OpenGL, then you could download the OpenGL patch at www.papy.com. This will work with the latest demo, too. GPL is written by Papyrus, did you've any problems with a previous Papyrus title? If you've driven the GPL demo with the right settings, then not even 10 horses could drag you away from the store. 11 maybe, but 10 is out of the question. If you like real racing, GPL is the game for you. If you like arcade, then you should buy TOCA2. Personaly, I don't like TOCA2 very much. It's nice for 2 hours, but then I got bored. Remco Please don't flame me about the huge amounts of if's....

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy